11th National Health Meeting at the National University of Rosario

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

23 November 2024 · 11th National Health Meeting · National University of Rosario, Rosario, Argentina

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed health workers at the 11th National Health Meeting at the National University of Rosario on November 23, 2024, reviewing past health achievements.
Main themes
Argentine public health system achievements, primary health care expansion, hospital construction, health equity and territorial access, mandatory medical program reforms, assisted fertilization coverage, mental health crisis, state role in healthcare, dismantling of health programs under current government, health as a political and social fact, integrated health system vision
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,288
63rd percentile
Sentences
117
70th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 52%49%
  • Ceremonial 28%26%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

117 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Thank you very much. Thank you very much, comrades. Thank you very much. Well, good day to everyone. We are very happy to be here in Rosario. I just heard Nico and couldn't help but remember the third meeting we held at the University of Lanús back in December 2016, but also the initial kick-off that was the first meeting on health sovereignty in 2014, which took place at the former ESMA. A whole symbol as well, and that place.

And the truth is that I want to remember some things today because we come to speak here in front of workers of the Argentine health system with the authority of facts and what has been done. Because in this liquid and instant world where what happened the day before yesterday is forgotten, it is good to remember that there was a moment and a country that built a health system from 2003 to 2015 that improved the quality of life and health care for all Argentines. Without distinctions. Without distinctions.

Nico just spoke about strengthening the primary health care system, and we built more than 25 hospitals by 2015 and 71 hospitals that we left underway. We take pride in the fact that the hospital we inaugurated at the intersection in Florencio Varela is today a Latin American model of a health system. Néstor started it, and I inaugurated it, and it serves millions of Argentines. Of the more than 7,500 CAPS (Primary Health Care Centers) when we launched and reformulated the community doctors program, which they are now dismantling, and which helped prepare human resources. We even reached having up to 800 bilingual indigenous compatriots who allowed us to enter the deepest communities of our country to provide health care.

But we did not stay inside the buildings of hospitals or ministries; we also went out to provide health systems of territorial equity, where one of the most beautiful programs we created was “Argentina Smiles” with 30 health trucks that returned beautiful smiles to thousands of Argentines. Because we must go out to seek out Argentines who cannot reach the urban centers in deep Argentina. Or that health train that also delivered more than one hundred thousand glasses to Argentines.

And I say that we did not limit ourselves only to the discourse and the action of vulnerable sectors because we also expanded the mandatory medical program by introducing, for example, assisted fertilization, which no one wanted to cover. No one wanted to cover it. I never tire of hearing, when I travel the country from end to end, a couple or a family approach me to say, “because you included assisted fertilization in the PMO, we were able to have a child because it didn’t fit into any program.” But we also passed the law so that the prepaid health plans that serve the middle and upper-middle sectors of Argentina could not unilaterally set the fees as they do now. To those who say and curse us, to those who say and curse us because they say that we only care about the poor, we remind all the boys and girls from the prepaid health plans that while we were in power, they paid fair fees, not like now when they rip you off.

And this, comrades, is not that… And this, compatriots, is not that suddenly we had in the health sector… No, no, no, because Carrillo already said it: “Health is not a scientific fact; it is a political and social fact.” And it requires a model of a country where not only hospitals function but also where sewer and drinking water networks are built so that people do not get sick, so that people can access housing. And so that they have salaries that can meet the dignity of life. How many problems do you doctors have with the precarious people who arrive at the emergency rooms and want… Nurses too, of course, how could I forget? How could I forget? They arrive at the emergency room demanding that they be given something quickly because they have to rush to work, or they will lose the bonus of the little bit of money they earn each month. That also undermines health.

And not to mention the mental health created by the fear of losing a job, of not having enough money, having to juggle three or four jobs… By the way, mental health that today, unfortunately, in the Argentine Republic we can see from the highest spheres down to the very bottom. The problem of mental health has penetrated transversally in the Argentine Republic, compatriots. And there are some cases that seem to have no cure either, but well.

And this does not mean that we had the ideal state and that everything was fine, but if we consider from that reality of what we did the need to rebuild a state, the necessary state as I say, and the efficient state as well. Let’s not be afraid of the word efficiency; we also need to build an efficient state. Because the next stage is, as Nico just defined, and you will have heard me say in other opportunities, the integrated health system. But for that, a very organized state is required, a state with a lot of information, a very capable governance to articulate because really the investment between the public and private subsystems in Argentina is among the highest, if not the highest in Latin America. And therefore, it also requires us to rethink the state. A state that cannot be static inside the ministries, a state that has to go out, a close state, a state where people see that every employee, that every state agent is committed to their reality. So that they do not see them as privileged beings, which then these bad governments argue and convince people that they have to destroy the state, not realizing that they are destroying their lives.

That’s why… and it’s also good, with all this that we are seeing, to reflect on both our own and others because many times I heard, while I was president, many times I heard this about “the manners, the finger, the national broadcast.” Yes, because I’m a woman a little bit, but because I govern for everyone even more, that’s more. Yes, because I’m a woman a little bit, the rest… because I know many women who are in government and govern for themselves and a select group only. But for those… I say for our own and others who perhaps reproached forms and went far away for the form, darling, next to this I already told you I am the Countess of Chikoff. Absolutely, really.

But I want to talk a little about this and this narrative that they tell us. I was looking at some of the workshops you have today in discussion, but I stopped at one: “The impact of the crisis on the health of the people and the health system.” I allow myself to suggest a correction. Are you over there? Well, here it goes… I allow myself to suggest just a correction: this was not a crisis, guys. Do you know what crisis we had? With the pandemic, that is a crisis. The pandemic was a crisis, something unpredictable, unmanageable that did not only happen to us but to the whole world. And how well we did and how the inconsistency in the private system was demonstrated in facing the pandemic and the consistency of the public system in facing the pandemic.

I cannot forget, I cannot forget interviews on television with circumspect owners of prepaid health plans. I will not name names, no, no, no, no, because then they get angry and say those horrible things to me. I will not name names, but look for it, you will find it. But recognizing in television audiences that they could not cope in private clinics and that COVID patients were treated in the entire public sector. I do not say it; one of the owners of the most important prepaid health plans in the country said it, and that is what I want to talk about. There are two central issues that expose how deceitful and false the discourse of deregulating the state to help citizens is. There are two fundamental parts: they deregulated the prepaid health plans to the detriment of millions, among whom I also find myself, as a user of prepaid health plans where they set the fee as they please. A lot of people have been forced to abandon their prepaid plans, and today, as Nico said, we can see them queuing in public hospitals. The other day I was looking at the Faculty of Dentistry at UBA; they were part of the 30 trucks with milling equipment that we had bought and distributed among several universities. Surely some may have come here, they went to UBA, they also went to the University of Córdoba, and today they serve for postgraduate courses. All good, but I liked it more when they arrived in the deep neighborhood so that people could have teeth like people. I liked it more. What do you want me to say? I liked it more.

And the other big issue that they do not dare to deregulate, because they deregulate in favor of a few very powerful, is that of medications. Let’s see, Milei, since you are so brave. Deregulate medications so that we can have imported generic medications for the cost of health budgets. Let’s see if you dare. Let’s see if you dare.

Very well. Well, the other day I was chatting about these things with Nico, and I also received the ambassador of India just a few days ago at the Patria. And the truth is that it would be very easy; it would be enough to articulate from ANMAT, from the Ministry of Health those foreign laboratories that have validation from the countries with which we have agreements, which are the United States, the FDA, the United Kingdom, Germany, Japan, which have already inspected the plants of laboratories, for example, in India or China to authorize those medications to come. To give you an idea, what am I going to tell you? When we finished our government, the health budget impact was 15 to 20%, even with the vaccination schedule of 19, I had forgotten, 19 mandatory vaccines along with the delivery of free HIV medications. That only in Argentina was one of the few countries in the world that did it. With 19 mandatory and free vaccines, with the delivery of… in PAMI and in hospitals to retirees of medications. With the delivery of medications to HIV patients, even then it was only 15 or 20% in the budget impact. Today it is 40.

But it didn’t stop there. Argentine laboratories have had extreme profitability amid popular misery. Why? Their sales fell, but they compensated for the drop in sales with the indiscriminate price increases, some of which reach 500%, especially for the most used medications. So from here, from the National University of Rosario, we tell Milei: dare and deregulate medications. Tell the deregulator of the Megacanje to have the courage so that people can access medications. So that it is not a martyrdom for a retiree to have to go to a pharmacy and leave half or three-quarters of the medications they need because they cannot afford it.

How can there be such insensitive and cruel people? Is that capitalism? No, no, let them not make us stand on the opposite sidewalk and stay there… No, capitalism, and I have said it many times, needs consumers, it needs people who can buy. What kind of capitalism is this where there are fewer and fewer consumers? I stick with the capitalism we had, in Peronism, where everyone can consume, not just a few.

Well, comrades, it’s very hot, don’t forget that I’m a penguin, I’m a penguin. Never forget that, and the truth is that in the face of so much despair, one wonders what to do. The other day in Santiago, in Santiago del Estero… The other day in Santiago del Estero, I said: we need to expand the issue of militancy and not only incorporate or challenge the Peronist militant but everyone. And I want to tell you here that you are militants of the health system, but, as I always say, I am not a Peronist lawyer; I am a Peronist who is a lawyer. It seems the same but it is not the same, it is not the same because we prioritize our conception, our perspective, our vision of the world before our corporate belonging. This is key, and so we must rebuild together with other militants who are not from politics but who one often crosses in the neighborhood, in the church, or in the club, calling on all Argentines. And you, especially the health militants, played a fundamental role during the pandemic and have a fundamental role in people’s lives. Because the connection between the patient and the doctor is something that transcends any other connection in other professions, engineering, law, architecture. No, no. Because it is linked to understanding, solidarity, and healing because people, ultimately, go to you to heal. Teach the rest of the Argentines how we can heal from these things that happen to us and make us so unhappy.

Thank you very much. Thank you very much, comrades, thank you very much, Rosario, thank you very much to the National University of Rosario. I love you all very much, and thank you again to all the workers of public health. Thank you very much.