European Space Strategy: the speech of President Emmanuel Macron from Toulouse.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 February 2022 · European Space Strategy speech · Toulouse, France

Context
Macron addressed European Space Agency representatives and officials in Toulouse on February 16, 2022, outlining France's European space sovereignty strategy during its EU Council presidency.
Main themes
European space sovereignty, French EU Council presidency, space as strategic priority, European Space Agency, industrial space ecosystem, Copernicus and Galileo programs, Ariane launcher, new space and startups, scientific exploration missions, military and strategic sovereignty, technological independence, astronaut recruitment
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,744
90th percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.20
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 36%35%
  • Geopolitical 23%23%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

193 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. Commissioner, dear Thierry,

Ladies and gentlemen representatives of the countries of the European Space Agency,

Ladies and gentlemen members of parliament,

Mr. Senator,

Mr. Member of the European Parliament,

Madam President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Mr. Mayor,

Mr. Director of the European Space Agency,

Mr. Prefect of the region,

Ladies and gentlemen business leaders,

Ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and capacities,

I am very happy to see you here today in this beautiful region that is dear to me and in this beautiful city of Toulouse, whose destiny is linked, among other things, to the space adventure but also to the excellence of all the industries related to it. And you know, we have placed the French presidency under the sign of European sovereignty. To ensure, in a way, that in all areas our union has the means to define its own policy by cooperating with whom it chooses but without depending on the choices of others. That is our ambition. I believe that the world in which we live reinforces this conviction more and more each day - it may have seemed theoretical to some just a few months ago. If we needed demonstrations, we have had them. And if we want to realize this objective of sovereignty, a necessary and essential step, the sovereignty of sovereignties, is indeed space.

Without mastery of space, indeed, there is no technological sovereignty. Access to the Internet, satellite navigation, all of this depends largely on space. Without mastery of space, there is no industrial and economic sovereignty beyond the tens of thousands of jobs, 32,000 direct jobs for France alone that are concerned, thus the sector, space guides an entire ecosystem of research, innovation, and industry. Without mastery of space, there is no scientific advancement nor fine knowledge of the major environmental and climatic challenges. Without mastery of space, there is no strategic and military sovereignty. Mastery of communication networks, data exchanges, observation of the movements of different armies on the planet, space has also become one of the new arenas of contemporary conflicts. Without mastery of space, there is fundamentally no complete power capable of fully controlling its destiny and conquering new frontiers. For all these reasons, space is a priority of the French presidency but also because France is, concurrently, co-President of the Council of the European Space Agency with Portugal.

So, our Europe, in terms of space, has considerable assets that make it a leading space power; many of you in this room are direct actors in this.

Our operational programs are among the most efficient in the world: Copernicus, which ensures the collection and analysis of Earth observation data, Galileo, with 22 satellites used on 2 billion devices, which allows free access to its positioning more accurately than GPS. These are two major successes, to name just two, that have become indispensable to our daily lives. With Ariane, more than 110 successful launches, Vega, we also have autonomy of access to space. Ariane remains the most reliable launcher in the world, and we had new proof with the impeccable launch of the James Webb telescope at the end of last year. We rely more broadly on a solid industrial base, with notably European players in the satellite field - ADS, DAS, OHB - coming from the main industrial nations in the sector and who are global leaders in their markets, and a whole fabric of very dynamic and promising emerging players, whether they are SMEs or mid-sized enterprises that have consolidated over the years or these start-ups, what is now called new space, that are beginning to emerge. And so we, Europeans, truly have an industrial strength, all sizes of companies, all ages, if I may say so, and the necessity also to build cooperations between our established, solid major players and these new space actors throughout our countries. We also continue to embody the vanguard of exploration missions, whether with Philae towards comet Chury, ExoMars, Perseverance on Mars, and I want to thank all the major research centers, whether it be CNES, CNRS, CEA but also DLR, ASI to name Germany and Italy, among others, and all the leading European agencies and universities that are contributing to this European dream. We can also count on globally recognized faces. I think of Samantha Cristoforetti, Matthias Maurer, Thomas Pesquet, and 40 years after Jean-Loup Chrétien's first manned flight, I am pleased to see that ESA's call for young astronauts is meeting with extremely strong success, with more than 22,000 applications and nearly 40% of women selected; that was the goal pursued, and I remember very well the ambition that Thomas Pesquet himself, being one of its ambassadors, wanted to promote, which is a real transformation as well, of these faces and this new generation.

And so all these successes are indeed there, tangible. It is the result of decades of research, investments from our nations, building European cooperation and scientific excellence, fundamental and applied research, industrial excellence that irrigates all our territories. Here, we know how much, but many of the European territories I mentioned through the few industrialists or research organizations live also through these jobs. Nevertheless, these successes should not prevent us from being lucid, which is the condition for embracing the future. Europe has also missed some strategic turning points in recent years, particularly in launchers, underestimating the very rapid emergence of some of our competitors. Competition, indeed, is becoming increasingly fierce among powers: the United States, China, Russia are thus ahead of Europe in terms of the number of launches, while others, such as Japan, India, Iran, South Korea, have engaged with great force in the race. And for some, mentioned just now, are also massively reinvesting. We have undoubtedly underestimated the meteoric emergence of private actors who have managed, in a few years, to mobilize massive resources and make real breakthroughs, including in terms of technological positioning that 5 to 10 years ago, we believed ourselves impossible. SpaceX, Blue Origin are unfortunately not European. And they have made bets and they have managed to combine, which is a model by the way that we must draw inspiration from, significant public resources, agencies and public research organizations and the velocity of emerging private actors. We have fallen behind in the space arms race. Consider that there are spy satellites that can seek to interact, for example, with our own satellites, and other powers are developing technologies that will allow them to approach objects in orbit. All this is not science fiction; it is happening today and there are massive investments being made by some of our competitors. And if Europe is largely absent from this new landscape, if our industry is now competing on our own soil, it is for a simple reason: we did not sufficiently embrace our space adventure a few years ago, and we did not sometimes agree on a common vision fundamentally, because we did not sufficiently believe in ourselves. And I think we must draw the consequences of these years where we have allowed some of our competitors to move faster. They have invested more, they have made bolder technological bets, and above all, they have put in more resources because they have benefited from our divisions.

I am sure of one thing: when Europeans know how to come together, harmonize their views, make bold disruptive technological and industrial research choices, then they are at the forefront. And so what I have just described with much lucidity is not a fatality; it is what we will catch up on through the choices we are making today. Because if our industry is today under attack, contested by new actors who are no longer on European soil, and if we were to remain somewhat inert, we would exit history. But the choice we are making collectively is the opposite: to act urgently, to carry so as not to have solutions imposed on us by others, a European vision of space conquest and thus to make clear, structuring choices, with massive short-term reactions, but also with a sense of the long term, as we have indeed managed to do in recent years in terms of batteries, hydrogen, or even electronics with the recent Chips Act. And I say this here to reinforce us. I still remember, you know, five years ago, almost to the day, our major industrialists in the automotive sector told me: "We do not make batteries in Europe. Do not go too fast on electric. Electric batteries, that is not Europe, it is China and Korea." We have conjured this fatality because we acted as Europeans, we built alliances; for France alone, there are three major projects. We were told just a few months ago that in semiconductors, Europe was falling out of the race. We mobilized, reunited, we invested, and we are building the projects that will allow us to catch up on this delay. I deeply believe that in space, we have a situation that is, first of all, with the strengths I have mentioned, but relative weaknesses, there is the recent situation, we have ample means to compensate for them if we know how to act in the same way. That is the purpose in my eyes of today's meeting, which is based notably on the work of the Union and Commissioner Thierry Breton. And I want to thank him, because in particular, the work released yesterday, which I know led to fruitful discussions this morning among the ministers, was important, as well as the commitment of ESA and its Director General Josef Aschbacher. And so, thank you for this work.

So, the first thing, for me, the first axis we must pursue is to ensure our competitiveness and our scientific and industrial sovereignty. For that, the first condition of competitiveness and space sovereignty is launchers. It is the basis of everything; it is what allows us to access the rank of space power. We, Europeans, must build major launcher projects. We have already done a lot. The ministerial conference in Seville confirmed the Ariane 6 program. There will therefore be an Ariane 6 with real commercial prospects. And the agreement at ESA, signed this summer, as well as the bilateral agreements, have secured this future by ensuring their workload through visibility on planned launches. It is more necessary than ever to apply a European preference for the launch of institutional satellites as our competitors do. And here, I say very clearly: there is no industrial and research policy if Europe is the only naive power, that is to say, the only power that would not involve a principle of preference for itself. The Chinese do it, the Americans do it, let us not do it systematically! All this is what will allow us to give a workload plan that enables us: to make our models profitable, to provide visibility, to continue to innovate. And fundamentally, when we have a workload plan thanks to institutional and commercial launches, first, the more we give ourselves a workload plan with our institutional launches, the more competitive we are on the commercial side, the more we win on the commercial side, the more we can make the product profitable and build our competitiveness for tomorrow, and the more we avoid compensating for our own naivety with public funding which, historically — what we have done too often — is not, however, sufficient. Europe must fully take the turn of mini and micro-reusable launchers. We indeed need to develop our public and private investments in disruptive technologies, as some states have begun to do. We have started to do this in France with France 2030, several projects launching, for example, in Vernon or Reims. In Germany, Italy, Spain, there are also very structuring projects launching on these subjects and with many other European colleagues. We must continue to move forward, not by trying to catch up on our delay, but by thinking about the next step, aiming for the technological frontier. First in a logic of competition between projects and with the ultimate goal of cooperating between member states with the alliance of launchers that Thierry Breton is leading.

The second condition for competitiveness and spatial sovereignty is constellations. This subject is still little known to the general public, but — I recognize several faces — it is well known to many of you. Indeed, constellations are at the heart of the work of many of our industrialists, our research organizations, and they will be at the core of our existences, of our lives tomorrow. Why? Because military networks and objects, connected services, autonomous vehicles, maritime transport, teleconsultation, tele-surgery, the fight against the digital divide, everything that already makes up our daily lives, a good part of our struggles requires these infrastructures and the constellations. Europe must take its share in the constellation revolution. It is a matter of sovereignty and efficiency. Who can imagine that, because we do not have a European constellation, we would effectively decide to delegate control of traffic data or control of health data of Europeans to other powers? In any case, to actors who, being non-European, cannot be regulated by European law. And so, we would be put by the development of connected objects, of all the uses I just mentioned, in situations where, faced with the legitimate demand of our industrialists, of our compatriots, we would be developing these uses but the space infrastructures would be controlled by other actors and therefore regulated by other norms, other spaces. Democratically and not just industrially, we would truly be facing an unacceptable situation. It is also a question of economic prosperity in the sector of building these constellations where actors like Iridium Next, Globalstar, Telesat, OneWeb, O3b, etc. have first-rate expertise. And other powers have already committed to massive developments of constellations, whether they are civilian constellations, OneWeb, Kuiper, to name just two, or military ones in the United States, in particular.

And so, it is up to us, Europeans, to take our destiny into our own hands on this subject of constellations. And there is urgency. Indeed, the number of telecommunications constellations that can be deployed is limited. Fewer than ten, probably. We must therefore, without delay, unite the forces of the member states, bring together the various nascent initiatives to move forward. The European Commission, thanks to the commitment of the Commissioner, has just presented an ambitious proposal to realize a European connectivity constellation. More than a dozen consortia have responded to its call for proposals. We must now turn this into action and mobilize the entire European sector, whether it involves new entrants or established players. By innovating, as everyone senses that technological breakthroughs in this field are within reach, by using direct service purchases to encourage scaling up, to ensure that the new players in the field are European, and by quickly clarifying our needs and priorities for this venture. France, I say very clearly, will be at the forefront of this revolution. First by making available to the Union the precious asset that the priority frequency assignments it holds represent. Then, by launching its own share of investment and in the coming days, as part of France 2030, two calls for projects will specifically mobilize actors to support innovative projects in this area. One on in-orbit services and one on disruptive constellation projects, for example, to support projects like those of LoftOrbital, which completely revolutionizes in-orbit services, a large part of which is carried out right here in Toulouse, or E-Space, which is truly a completely transformative project in terms of disruptive constellations and many others as well. I only mention two. This subject of European constellations is a true revolution, but it is a duty for us for the reasons of sovereignty and the economic reasons I mentioned.

But it is also a geopolitical project for our Europe, because we will offer our compatriots and our industries completely sovereign connectivity solutions with economic developments, and because in doing so, we will also build a North-South alliance in terms of connectivity. And I know that you discussed this this morning, and I thank you for the choices made. But allowing Africa the opportunity to deploy its connectivity in a completely new alliance between Europe and Africa, enabling the deployment of projects for our research and observation poles is a true geopolitical and research revolution that the European constellation project will offer. That is the main focus for our competitiveness, our scientific and industrial sovereignty.

The second major pillar for me of the space action we must undertake is the power and military aspect that exists behind this space issue. Space, indeed, is also the expression of the strategy of powers, and we must face this reality. Indeed, beyond economic and industrial strategies, it is the place for the deployment of military strategy, power, and new conflictuality. France is one of the few major powers to have fully committed to this field. With our space defense strategy, which allocates more than 5 billion euros of investment until 2025, we have added to the classic missions of observation, telecommunications, and listening, a real capacity for action in exo-atmospheric space. The Air Force, now the Space Force, has been equipped with a major space command, based right here in Toulouse, where I was a few months ago, similar to the armies of our major European allies. At the international level, the establishment in Toulouse of the NATO Space Centre of Excellence will enable cooperation among allied member states, and the ongoing work on the strategic compass should allow progress towards a European military space strategy. We must indeed finalize elements of clear doctrine that will allow us to have the framework enabling the best possible responsiveness. Because we saw it again a few months ago, aggressiveness and perhaps issues of conflict or provocations will multiply, and we must therefore define clear doctrinal elements that will allow the greatest responsiveness for those who have to make operational decisions and the appropriate margins of maneuver. Our ambition in this area is, without aggression but without naivety, to equip ourselves with a vision for the protection and resilience of our space infrastructures and on how to respond with all our allies to aggressions against our capabilities. This involves European investments in equipment, innovation, and research. It is precisely about seizing all the opportunities offered by the new space. They will be highlighted during our AsterX 2022 space defense exercise, which will take place right here in a few weeks.

But the challenge, and this is the third pillar for me, of this adventure and this vision in terms of space that we need to have, the challenge is also to make space a place for the protection of a common good by promoting regulatory standards. In this regard, the management of space traffic is among our priorities. In continuity with the EU SST project, which brings together seven European countries, we will define a European model for space traffic management that will be our basis for negotiating an international agreement. We want, as we have done in other areas, for Europe to be able to build a regulatory framework, to think for itself, and to build a regulatory reference that can then be shared by other powers, or even gradually impose itself as we have done, for example, in the digital realm. Thus, we will be able to ensure that attacks no longer hide, as is currently the case, behind pretexts of collisions and malfunctions. Space, indeed, cannot be a lawless zone. We have too many interests at stake in terms of economics, in terms of sovereignty regarding the continuity of the functioning of many of our public services, or in military terms. Space is a common good of humanity that, to continue to be one, must be removed from the sole logics of market and power and be regulated. However, today, that is not the case. We are in a logic of facts where provocations, unilateral acts, in any case, the choices made by some sometimes impose themselves, and in a way, we suffer them and react. We must therefore build this regulatory framework. We will make a European proposal, then try to build it at the international level. And I want to commend the commitment of many academics, non-governmental organizations in this regard, for example, the Net Zero Space initiative, which fits exactly into this logic and dynamic and which we must support and from which we must draw inspiration. There too, in France, with France 2030, we will present in the coming days calls for projects to support space surveillance projects and contribute to this work.

Finally, the fourth and last axis that I wanted to present and share with you here is our space, the space adventure, and by excellence must remain, a fundamental project of research and scientific exploration. Space is a major lever in itself for fundamental and applied research and for the many applications it allows to develop, particularly the climate challenge that I mentioned earlier. Few of our fellow citizens know this, but mastery of space can be a decisive lever for measuring, and thus attempting to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Not only because it allows for a better understanding of the state of the biosphere, by measuring with sensors the state of the oceans, ice, freshwater, and layers of the atmosphere, but also because it allows for tracking the evolution of global warming. The Copernicus program thus provides the world with no less than 420 Petabytes of Earth observation data, which allow for real-time mapping of temperature changes or water resources. Space can also be a verification tool for states to meet their commitments to reduce emissions. It is even one of the safest means to do so. It is thus, thanks to Copernicus, and with the company Kayrros and its partners, that we were able to detect greenhouse gas emissions that other powers did not wish to reveal. And so, through innovation, through space research, we have the possibility to much better track, measure, and have the mechanisms of accountability and control of all our climate change policy, of which you are all aware of the vital importance for our planet. This is the type of project that ESA aims to accelerate, which comes from both public and private actors.

But beyond climate, space also carries a part of dream. What a power projects into space says something about what it is, about its relationship with the world. And I believe that we must also, in these times when we rightly fight against fanaticism, the self-serving attitudes, aspire to dream in a rational, enlightened way with our fellow citizens, and to know how to invest in these dreams that also allow us to improve our understanding of the world as well as the universe. For us, Europeans, the viable space model is that one. The one that embraces its share of dream, but in an open, academic manner, this part of free teaching and free research. And I say this here with great strength, for us, Europeans, the viable space model is not that of exploitation, is not that of increasing the number of space tourists for thousands, even millions of dollars, just as the only horizon is not the mining exploitation of the Moon. We, Europeans, indeed cultivate a certain idea of space as a perspective that shifts our view of the world and the human condition, as a common good that must be useful to all. We, Europeans, believe more in exploration, in knowledge, and therefore in long-term manned flights rather than in the commercialization of space. The end of international cooperation within the framework of the ISS after 2030 must lead us to propose, alongside the United States and China, our own model, and this is also the right moment for us to ask this question. We must continue to fund major programs of fundamental research, applied research, and just as I said that our space, a common good, should be regulated in its uses, we must continue to invest in its research, its understanding, to continue training the best minds, to continue having the greatest Nobel laureates who invest in this field, to have our youth interested in it, for all these forms of research and application, and to develop this model that allows us to be here today. The ESA has already identified avenues in the field of space science and manned flights. And I want to thank you for that. And I propose that we can support this momentum, by working within the framework that the ESA will define by next summer, to formulate proposals on our European ambitions in exploration, in manned flights, to be able to illuminate the strategic decisions we will then have to make. And we must each time, of course, measure the social utility, know how to set our quantified priorities. And in view of the ministerial meeting in November 2022, prepare the choices we will have to make. By asking ourselves questions that are somewhat vertiginous in nature, and which must be informed by the best minds in the field, but also, I believe, be informed by political leaders, researchers in ethics so that we can make the necessary trade-offs. What should be the respective share of manned and robotic flights, particularly for flights to the Moon or Mars? If the heavy launcher option is ambitious but costly, can the development of robotic capabilities be a path to explore, especially since the benefits for sustainable terrestrial activities such as health, digital technology, or energy can also be numerous? Are we aiming for the Moon, where the Chinese will soon return, then Mars, which the Americans are targeting? We must also anticipate a European positioning for a first international human mission to Mars soon at the end of the next decade. Are we aiming for cooperations, in light of the ISS, or strategic autonomy in this area? These are some questions. When I said they are vertiginous, it is not simply by referring to what one can imagine, if it is imaginable, the projects that lie behind, the human and scientific adventures they encompass, but because these are truly fundamental questions that will engage us for decades. Depending on the answers provided, projects can be built. We will then have to give ourselves the means for the ambitions we will define together, with, again, an open approach to technological breakthroughs by mobilizing the entire sector, and also with a logic of service purchasing and iterative development to effectively mobilize all private actors. With a first feedback by mid-year and looking ahead to the upcoming ESA ministerial conference to be held in Paris next autumn, which should allow us to realize this vision, we see how much the space agenda is busy on all these fundamental issues.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, here are some of the reflections, the avenues for work and action that I wanted to share with you today. You see, we are at a decisive moment for our Europe, given the technological and industrial acceleration, also given the fundamental, civilizational choices being made regarding space. And ultimately, deciding to withdraw, deciding not to invest anymore, is to decide to leave great powers, large private multinationals to do it in our place and choose another model. And so we must take on the responsibility to massively support our great universities, our major research organizations, to pursue major programs with our historical industrial partners and new actors, and to build this key European space strategy for our sovereignty.

One of the fathers of our civilization, Plato, said that "astronomy compels the soul to look upward." And by engaging in the space adventure, we defend more than just sovereignty, more than just prosperity. We defend a vision of the world. That is why it was important for me to be present among you in Toulouse today, the heart of aerospace that already hosts the core of the European adventure in the aeronautics field, but especially because I know how crucial the ongoing work of the Commission, the commitment of the ESA, and the work of the ministers of our Europe here these days and in the coming months will be for our future.

I thank you. Thank you all.