EXCHANGES OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC WITH STUDENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF LAUSANNE.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 November 2023 · Exchanges of the President of the Republic with students of the University of Lausanne · University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

Context
Macron addressed students at the University of Lausanne on November 16, 2023, speaking about Europe's challenges and the case for deeper European unity and sovereignty.
Main themes
European unity and sovereignty, multi-crisis facing Europe, war in Ukraine and Middle East conflict, democratic erosion and disinformation, artificial intelligence and technological disruption, climate change and biodiversity, European political community, rise of extremism and authoritarianism, Switzerland-EU relations, peace and prosperity, nationalism vs. European integration
Duration
~69 min
97th percentile
Words
8,254
97th percentile
Sentences
428
98th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%36%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Social 13%11%
  • Environmental 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Technological 1%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

428 sentences in 111 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. Rector,

Madam President,

Ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and capacities, dear professors, dear students.

So, your President has just demonstrated admirably that Switzerland is inseparable from Europe geographically, historically, philosophically, and therefore, I will not revisit these links, the ongoing discussions, the associations, which I hope will come, and everything that will allow us to continue to move forward together, as I am convinced here that indeed, Switzerland and the European Union have mutually, enormously to offer each other. But I have been asked to speak about Europe.

It is a somewhat strange character in the moment we are living, but nonetheless indispensable. Strange, because Europe - and a little over 5 years ago, I was speaking in front of other students at another university in the Sorbonne - I was trying to express what my vision of Europe was and what we then worked on. I used to remind, which I believe is historically true. The European Union is a project of peace, of prosperity, which means that our continent has not known war for seven decades, which has never happened in our history. Because Europe is the continent of civil wars. That is the history of the previous millennia. And the European Union is a unique construction that has put an end to stories of hegemony and civil wars to build a balance of peace and stability among the different countries. By bringing us together, it is the brilliant intuition of MONNET and SCHUMAN, what we fought over: coal and steel. Then, gradually, establishing a single market on the foundation of common values. However, as I speak to you, the very foundations of our Europe have perhaps never been so shaken.

War is returning to our soil. It is the war of aggression launched by Russia against Ukraine at the beginning of 2022, but it had fundamentally begun as early as 2014. War is returning everywhere to our doors, and I am obviously thinking of the terrorist attack against Israel and now the bombings in Gaza. The principles and the very functioning of our democracies are being shaken by new practices, technological innovations, the rise of disinformation and the use of social networks, and now artificial intelligence; the very foundations of democratic trust, the strength of public opinion, the means by which we inform ourselves, exchange ideas, are being disrupted. Fears are returning and transforming our model of prosperity.

We must continue to build a strong economy that allows for demanding social models and responds to the immense challenges of biodiversity and climate change. And so, you see, the challenges are there and mean that our Europe is, fundamentally, in the midst of a multi-crisis that attacks its very foundations and what had until then made its strength, and that fundamentally, peace is threatened in Europe. Prosperity is shaken by these changes, and the democratic spirit is also deeply shaken. We see it in the rise of extremes, in the sometimes-fascination with authoritarianism that runs through and crosses our entire continent.

So, in this context, why do I think that Europe is an even more essential project? First, because responding to contemporary challenges by reproducing the mistakes of yesterday would be absolutely terrible. Think that in the face of all the challenges I have - and I did not want to be too long in the observation - the response that would be to return to nationalism, to conflicts between one another, and to abandon what has carried us would be a catastrophe. The question is what new ambition and what new challenges are there to respond to everything I have mentioned? I will do this in about ten minutes so that we have time for questions and answers, and I can detail my remarks through your inquiries.

I wanted to emphasize, for me, two things, three things – but I will stick to ten minutes anyway: unity, sovereignty, democracy. And in doing so, I continue the thread of the remarks I made at the Sorbonne. In the context I am referring to, Europe needs more unity. And that is why, as President BERSET said earlier, I proposed in May 2022 that we establish this European political community. Our challenge is that we have the European Union. And if you look at a map, this European Union has lost the British with Brexit, and then it has many gaps. Switzerland is part of it, we have the Western Balkans, and then we have other countries further north, which are not necessarily European but have essential links. I think of our Norwegian friends and several others. And then we now have Eastern Europe, shaken by war. Ukraine, Moldova, under strong pressure, which are also at our doors. And so if we want Europe to respond to the challenges I mentioned, it needs to be more united. And so, this unity first requires us to be aware of this and to have institutional and political audacity to invent new forms.

If we want to respond to climate challenges, to the issue of migration, to the energy question, to our defense and security question, we cannot remain as we are. We cannot do it if we do not have with us, for example, the Western Balkans and the British. It is a migratory route, it is unique. We cannot talk about energy if we only do it among members of the European Union. We have many energy connections with Switzerland. We have a lot - also - with the Western Balkans. We cannot talk about our defense if we do not integrate the Ukrainian question, Moldova as well, which is the subject of cyberattacks; Northern Europe, including when it is outside the European Union.

And so, we have even more, than before the return of war to our soil, a need for unity in the face of all these great challenges. This unity must be woven through concrete projects.

This is, for example, what we have been able to do in recent days on the cryosphere. It is an immense challenge. Our scientists have studied it, and we are addressing it as Europeans. We signed an important agreement on research and investment together yesterday, and we will do it with our major partners on the cryosphere, who were with me the other day: Switzerland, Norway, Monaco. What better demonstration of Europe? It does not stop at the European Union. We need this unity that will go through several levers.

First, fundamentally, a political and project-oriented Europe is the European political community. It must be agile, ambitious, but respond to almost all the challenges I mentioned earlier.

Secondly, an expanding European Union. And it is clear that this perspective that is given, the desire to integrate the European Union of several countries, we must consider it. This requires that the European Union reform itself, because it cannot function at 30, 35, perhaps even more, as it does today at 27, but enlargement is a strategic element of this unity. Otherwise, we will leave within us other powers that will come to weaken us, push their agenda, and we see it in the Western Balkans, where Russia sometimes, Turkey in the past, China increasingly, come to push their interests and divide us, thereby threatening our own security, sometimes our own interests, for sure.

And then, it goes through ambitious association agreements, which also, are made touch by touch. So, you have understood, for me, in the face of all the risks of being torn apart, of a return to nationalism, Europe is the answer to the challenges that are ours. And for that, we need to build new forms of unity.

The second element I wanted to emphasize is sovereignty. Now, sovereignty may have surprised when I first spoke about it for Europe, because we attach it, and rightly so, to popular sovereignty, which exists at the level of nation-states. Nevertheless, we have gradually built - it is still imperfect - a European demos. A European Parliament that has existed since 1979, we have managed to establish debates. I would like us to be able to go further. I have defended the idea of lists that are precisely the same across all countries of the European Union. I think we need to do much more for a European public opinion to be forged; even if I feel that in recent years, thanks to our youth, it is being forged more and more. But I believe very deeply that there is a European sovereignty. It is imperfect, it is incomplete, and it is all the institutional path that remains to be taken, but it is there.

Fundamentally, what is this sovereignty? It is the idea of saying, we, Europeans, want to decide for ourselves what is important for us. It is the basis of what has been called “strategic autonomy” in some discussions or “independence” in others. It is not Europe retreating into itself. It is not autarky, independence, but it is the idea of saying that we cannot talk about Europe and meet all these challenges if we gradually.

Sometimes, even without realizing it, we let Europe depend on other powers and no longer be able to decide for itself. And I think that is one of the greatest responsibilities of my generation towards yours. It is this independence, this European sovereignty. Because if we look at things by taking two steps back, geographically and over time, the great threat hanging over Europeans is to be a continent that learns and innovates less than the Americans and the Chinese, that builds fewer technologies, that builds fewer defense instruments for itself, that builds fewer responses to the climate transition, and that therefore, gradually, has such significant dependencies that it can no longer fully decide its future.

Once I have said that, our history, and I still believe in our presence, is that we are a great scientific, cultural, innovation, economic power. But, when we look at the figures, we invest today in artificial intelligence much less than the Americans and the Chinese. We have gotten into the habit, in recent decades, of buying a lot of American equipment and saying: defense, we will live under their umbrellas. We have recently gotten into the habit of saying: we can depend on China, even when it comes to masks. We saw what that meant in times of pandemic. And in recent years, we have rediscovered the cost of dependencies.

Remember, when the world closed with Covid, we realized that when we depended on certain things that seemed completely banal, we were quite clever, we, leaders, to say: wear masks, do this, do that, when we no longer had any.

We recognized this cost of energy dependence with the beginning of the war in Ukraine. When Europe realized that it was massively dependent - it is not so much the case for France but I speak as Europeans - massively on Russian gas. This means that we Europeans must have a real strategy of autonomy, independence, sovereignty. This means that we must take on the responsibility of investing massively in knowledge, the training of minds, our universities, our researchers, our artists, because it is true of science, as it is of the arts, that they shape minds, that they forge both what constitutes the independence of a country and its public opinions. And from artificial intelligence to quantum, to the ability to train minds that will write scenarios, films, to have actors, the metaverse or artistic creation is absolutely essential to our intellectual and cultural independence.

We, Europeans, must invest massively in our technological independence. We cannot depend on Chinese technological components. We cannot depend on responses in artificial intelligence that would be entirely American. We cannot depend on solutions in cleantech, as we say in good French, and therefore, green industry that would be either Chinese or American when I see the strength that is put into investments, state subsidies, on both sides. We must have our European solutions. And we must also do this for our own defense: to have our equipment, our industries, our military capabilities to protect ourselves. This axis is absolutely essential, otherwise we will have, in 10, 20, or 30 years perhaps, great debates among Europeans; but if we have lost scientific, technological, industrial, or military sovereignty, you will have before you leaders who are not fully in control of their own affairs and you will become leaders who may be commentators on the world, but who will no longer be the decision-makers. This is a decisive axis that requires massive investments.

Europe has made, rather, the right strategic choices, but it must invest much more to do so. We can return to this, I hope, if we talk about climate and biodiversity where we are undoubtedly the continent that is the most ambitious, but where we invest insufficiently to build this sovereignty of green industries.

And the last point is democracy. Europe is the continent where we invented it, and we have, if I may say so in this regard, a responsibility - without making anyone jealous - it would not be entirely false to say that the spirit of the Enlightenment is a Franco-Swiss co-production. You welcomed Voltaire, and it seems that Rousseau had connections. And so, in this respect, we have a huge responsibility. And I believe that today we particularly need to re-establish the relationship between information, the formation of public opinion, and democracy in the age of social networks and artificial intelligence. This is a debate that is technological, but it is also an ethical and democratic debate. A few weeks ago in France, we launched the General States of Information with both scientists, philosophers, hard sciences, and human sciences, as your universities, by the way, allow for dialogue. And we will involve the entire nation in this debate. It is a profoundly European debate.

But I say this because we see the propaganda of authoritarian powers returning, and we see it everywhere in our democracies, the fake accounts that push false information, the artificial intelligence that is capable, today, of creating completely false content, the reality of which is very difficult to verify. And even the models in which we will exchange, whether related to industries or generative and used by citizens, have enormous training biases, which can completely change the way we see the world. Because if we have artificial intelligence models that are entirely based on Anglo-Saxon models, that is a huge bias. If we have platforms, social networks, that are formed on algorithms that are unfair, on which we do not have real visibility, which cannot be the subject of an ethical, democratic dialogue, we can have enormous biases. And even with the best democratic systems in the world, the oldest, the most solid, democracy exists and works well only if minds are well-formed and if the democratic debate is well-prepared. It can be an instrument of massive destruction.

Our Europe has a responsibility to re-establish it, that is to say, to regulate it, to think about it, to allow innovation, to create on our continent, but also to redefine its terms so that it corresponds to our deep values, our philosophy. This has been at the heart of Europe to build democracy and peace.

I had made a commitment not to be too long, so I will stop here. But given the multiple crises we are experiencing, all these challenges, you understand, I think that Europe is the best scale to address them. And I believe that Europe, whatever its institutional forms, needs today unity, independence, and therefore ambition for investments, and to regain democratic vitality, particularly in light of these technological innovations that are shaking it up. Thank you, and now I will respond and engage with you.

Moderator

If Switzerland were to join Horizon Europe, that would be great, wouldn't it?

Emmanuel MACRON

The ministers are discussing it, and we are very much in favor. No, but I think that honestly, and I am very respectful of the debate, the exchanges, and the pace that it should have, we should not put any pressure. I said it yesterday, in fact, Switzerland is already European. We have 11,000 French students who come to study in Switzerland. So, the link is already huge. We have many universities, not just here, that are connected. Our research centers, we have immense researchers who have one foot on both sides. And so, our wish is that we can indeed continue to aggregate all of this, so that would be great.

Moderator

Survey: Does Europe have the power to play a leading role in resolving global crises? We see that there is a lot of confidence in the European Union in the room. I would obviously be interested, President MACRON, President BERSET, to have your comments on this.

Emmanuel MACRON

I completely agree with what the President said. I would just like to add that for this, we need unity. Because, yes, and I salute the confidence that is behind this survey, but our challenge is to have a united response with the same firepower, because the great difficulty is that when the United States or China speak, they are large domestic markets, so to speak, and large powers united by definition. And so, we need to speak with one voice. That is what makes Europe audible in this world. When we talk about climate change, when we talk about geopolitics, we need to be united.

The second challenge, in my view, for us to really weigh in on crises, is that we have a truly European line. And we can see it well since, I find, the Covid crisis, the great risk for Europeans is to be pushed towards the west or towards the north, in the current geopolitical debates. We have these values. We have allies. Our allies are mostly to the west and north, but it would be a huge mistake to say that, for example, democracies only exist in the north or the west. That is false. It would be a huge mistake to think that our agenda is limited to Europe or the transatlantic axis. That is false. We must also be the guarantors of an effective and balanced multilateralism that knows how to speak with the major emerging countries, with the countries of the South, with all continents.

Moderator

Thank you. We will now move on to two questions that have been collected online, through the digital network, here. People in the room have asked the questions, and we have selected two questions on the issue of Europe facing global crises. So, I propose to display them. So, is it possible to reform Europe to make it less opaque and more representative? We saw, in discussions particularly with student representatives earlier, there is a real question: what are the tools, what is the issue of representativeness? You mentioned it, of course, President MACRON, in your speech. How can we do better, quite simply, to make it a more agile democracy?

Emmanuel MACRON

On this point. First of all, we have a very lively, very vibrant European Parliament that is active, that acts, that moves forward. What are the difficulties, the limits we have today? It is that, fundamentally, many subjects are in the hands of the executive and the Commission. It is subject to oversight by the European Parliament, but it is not exactly as strong as it is in our states, in democracies. And that is why I said that we have a European democratic system that has improved a lot in recent times. We have a transparency system that has improved a lot, and we must recognize all the advances that have been made, the work that has been done by the European Commission, by the European Parliament. But it is incomplete, for several reasons.

First of all, in my view, we do not have real European elections. We have European elections at the same time in each country, but with national lists and where the debates remain very national. If we really want to go all the way, for European elections, we should have a list for Europe, and we should really have a European debate, the same in the countries. So that is a subject on which I am pushing a lot for us to move forward. Then, there is the question of the anchoring of European parliamentarians, which is a debate that always comes back, to allow for a return to the territory, and that is part of this reform that we need to engage with colleagues. But I am, in any case, very eager for us to have this reform regarding the issue of representativeness.

Then, I think we need to have more, regarding community competencies. Because you know that you have community competencies, which are held by the Commission. There, I think we need to strengthen democratic oversight, democratic transparency, and dialogue with Parliament. That is what will allow us to answer your question. And alongside that, we must acknowledge that we have a whole series of subjects that remain intergovernmental. I also defend this balance, meaning that there are matters that we have not transferred to a community body, but which fall under a debate among heads of state and government. There, it is democratic because everyone must account to their people, and everyone has democratic legitimacy in their country. And we need to clearly reclarify the dividing line between what is community and what is intergovernmental. Here are some of the key points, in my view.

Participant

What is your country's position on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? The conflict is disastrous, and we have a hard time understanding your positions.

Emmanuel MACRON

On the subject, there has been a European position that was taken at the last European Council, which is quite clear and which is a position of unity, but there are many differences on this subject between countries. Because we have different histories and democratic traditions regarding the region, and because we have a relationship to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the ongoing war that is very different. The reactions, by the way, we can see well, in all our countries, show that it is a subject of international politics, but it is also a domestic issue at the same time. Because this subject is also the matrix of something much deeper, historically, culturally.

So, what is France's position from day one? I will try to express it in the simplest and most sequenced way, and then you can tell me if it is not clear.

First, on October 7, something terrible happened, which is the most massive, most heinous attack against Israel and its people launched by Hamas, a terrorist group, which killed more than 1,200 people, babies, women, elderly people in abominable conditions. We have obviously condemned this terrorist attack with the utmost firmness, expressed our support for Israel, and reaffirmed - because it has always been France's policy - Israel's right to defend itself and the importance of its security in the region.

This is the fruit of history and the necessity to defend the right of this people to live in security in a region that is also hostile to it. It is absolutely essential. There will be no peace if there is no secure Israel and a Jewish people living securely in this region.

At the same time, I said, because Israel is a democracy, this right to defend itself, to protect itself, must, as it does for all of us - we have also, unfortunately, been affected by terrorism - always respect the law of war, international humanitarian law, and the texts we have signed.

This means that the way to defend oneself, to protect oneself cannot be total war, without rules. It means yes to going after and attacking terrorists, but no to harming civilian populations.

That is why, and here, there is not a united position to be honest at the European level, you have seen it, and I am transparent with you, France, very early on, made resolutions with, for example, Brazil, and then with Jordan, which is a proposal that I myself carried last week at the humanitarian conference for Gaza, which was the first we organized, which is to call for an immediate truce leading to a humanitarian ceasefire.

I fully stand by this position because I believe it is coherent: recognizing Israel's right to defend itself does not justify bombing civilians and having children, families who are killed under these bombings. It is our duty as heads of state and government, I believe, given our values, to say that there is no double standard and that we cannot remain indifferent to the pain and atrocities that all these families and Palestinian families are experiencing in Gaza.

That is why we clearly condemn these bombings that are carried out against civilians or against civilian infrastructure or hospitals, and we call for this immediate humanitarian truce leading to a ceasefire, because I consider it compatible with the right to defend oneself, but it is the humanitarian pillar that we are protecting.

And then, the last point, I also reiterated from the beginning, is that we call for an immediate resumption of political dialogue to allow the Palestinian people to have a state, because it is a legitimate cause.

France has never changed its policy in recent years, including when there have been turnarounds, when some others have literally abandoned the Palestinian cause, and have gone to recognize Jerusalem as the sole capital of Israel. We have always refused these changes. I have continued to receive the President of the Palestinian Authority. And if we want to be consistent and say: Hamas is a terrorist attack, it does not represent the Palestinian people, which is true, then we cannot have a response that is only security-based regarding the Palestinian issue. We must have a response that is political.

We must resume this dialogue with the legitimate political authorities of the Palestinian people, with all the countries in the region, with the authorities of the Israeli people, and lead to a solution.

I do not want to preempt the forms here. Some are starting to have ideas, saying: we need a confederal solution, some say: it’s two states. We actually have international texts that have been signed and that have not been respected that went in this direction. But we absolutely must resume this dialogue.

That is our position. We are clear on the condemnation, we are obviously very firm on the fight against terrorism. We have an essential battle for humanitarian issues and we want the resumption of political dialogue.

The very last point, which is the first in this context, is that at the moment I am speaking to you, we have hostages. There are hostages from all over the world, but we, the French, have hostages and dual nationals, and the prerequisite for all this, and I say it as a prerequisite, because it is not even a subject for discussion. It is the release of all hostages, because it is an odious blackmail carried out by a terrorist group, and that is the top priority of our policy in the region.

Intervenor

You spoke earlier about the Western Balkans. Are you afraid that a new conflict will break out there, especially when we see all the tensions around Serbia, Kosovo, or Bosnia and Herzegovina? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for talking about the Western Balkans today because it is a subject that I think is essential for our Europe. We are worried and that is why we are engaged. There has been a rise in tensions, particularly since what happened at the end of summer in northern Kosovo. So, there is a very strong rise in tensions between Serbia and Kosovo. We have proposed a Franco-German roadmap. We have met with the leaders. They were both actually with us in Paris for the Paris Peace Forum, and I was able to see them. I think the tensions have somewhat subsided today. KFOR plays a very important role and I thank Switzerland for its commitment within this NATO force that maintains, as you know, peace and stability at the border. I actually think we should strengthen this commitment to truly maintain stability.

The solution, there too, I would say especially, is political. And so we have a roadmap that essentially consists of reorganizing the elections in the municipalities of the north, recognizing the Serbian municipalities by Kosovo, and allowing for a political path that eases tensions. And so the coming weeks will be key for the leaders on both sides to implement the roadmap we agreed upon. It remains very fragile. We are very committed. I think it is possible to avoid a resurgence of tensions that would go in the same direction because there is still a sense of responsibility, but it remains extremely fragile.

In Bosnia and Herzegovina, the three presidents were there, also in Paris, I saw all three of them. I am also worried about the situation because there is a resurgence of an ethnic approach in this country, and it is its very history, the Dayton-Paris agreements, which constituted Bosnia and Herzegovina by rejecting that. And I think it is very important because the very European model is at stake, that is to say, the fact that political reality and the ability to coexist, regardless of origins, regardless of religions, together, is what characterizes us.

The tensions that are playing out again in Bosnia and Herzegovina, which are being pushed and maintained, to be clear, by Russia, aim to dismantle this model, to weaken this country and to have it recompose into ethnic minorities that would separate and have nothing to do together. I have very clearly expressed France's vision; it would be terrible because it would open the door to war again in our Western Balkans, but more broadly.

This relates to what we were saying about conflicts as they occur everywhere. It is the return, in a way, of the ethnico-religious risk everywhere in the world. That is to say, we have people who say, "We are going to make war because we no longer want to live together. We are different, we do not come from the same people, we are not of the same religion, we will decide to take the state for ourselves alone, we will redraw the borders." Look at what is happening from the Near/Middle East to the Caucasus to the belly of Europe, that is it. It is a historical regression, historical.

The model we believe in, which is our very essence, is to say that with different languages, with sometimes different histories, minorities that can come from different countries, we want to live together, do together, build together, because we create the political forms that allow us to reduce these differences without erasing them. So, I am worried in both cases. I still think we will not see a resurgence of conflicts because we have a very strong political commitment, but it requires being very vigilant.

Moderator

Thank you for that response. We have questions here.

Intervenor

Hello, Mr. President. I had a question regarding climate and the climate emergency that is sweeping across Europe and the world. You spoke about the enlargement of the European Union, the opening to other countries, whether it be Moldova or Ukraine or also Bosnia and Herzegovina, which have made their applications.

How do you plan to act concretely through the European Union on the climate emergency, when currently within the European Union, there are divergences because each country has its needs and takes its actions somewhat in a nationalist manner, without taking into account the climate emergency, each has different degrees, so how do you plan to act concretely at the level of the European Union on this climate emergency?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I will perhaps nuance more, I do not want to be too technical. Europe and the European Union is the only geopolitical plate that has made such strong commitments to reduce its emissions by 2030 and achieve carbon neutrality by 2050. What we call "Fit for 55," our green plan, consists of texts, rules, standards that we have put in place as Europeans, there is no equivalent, and with already existing mechanisms of constraint that are advancing. So, that is really an achievement of the European Union that takes responsibility and has begun to implement in these texts. After that, each country takes the texts in force and indeed, where you are right, is that the energy models are particularly national, it is the fruit of history. It would be almost impossible to have, for once, a European model right away because, for example, I am the President of a country that produces its electricity almost three-quarters from nuclear power. Next to me, I have neighbors who have decided to completely exit nuclear power, who are, if I take the Spaniards now, almost three-quarters with renewables, if I take the Germans who were over 50% with gas, who are now reopening coal plants and increasing renewables. So we have very varied models. But we have a common path, we have set constraints, there will be, if I may say, penalties.

Ultimately, the challenge we face is that the war in Ukraine has greatly disrupted the transition because it has forced us to articulate two things: the reduction of our emissions and energy sovereignty. And we had not anticipated that. So, what do we need to do? We need to go even faster. So, there are choices that have been made that go a bit in the opposite direction in the short term. Other countries need to converge now as quickly as possible.

We have a very clear policy, which is to develop three axes. Energy sobriety, consuming less, that applies to all of Europe. Nuclear production, because it is a non-intermittent decarbonized production, it is good for the transition and sovereignty, because we produce it on our soil. And producing more renewables because it is a decarbonized production, but it is intermittent. We need both. We cannot have 100% nuclear, that would not make sense. We cannot have 100% renewable, that would not make sense because on the networks, it puts enormous pressure because it is totally intermittent. And now, what do we need to do at the European level? Push all the countries that are further behind to make this transition and therefore first completely exit coal, then gas, to move towards a model that is renewable, nuclear, and energy efficiency.

We have a huge effort to make for electrical interconnection because, in fact, Europe can decarbonize while remaining sovereign if it exchanges much better, if I may say, decarbonized electrons. And so it is the free market of green electrons that needs to be organized. And so that is a huge interconnection task. And that is exactly what we need to do with the countries of enlargement, some countries having very different models. Ukraine has a nuclear history, it still has nuclear power plants that we are trying to protect and that are threatened. Other countries are much more dependent on gas, that is the case of Moldova. So here too, the models are very different for these countries. So it is about converging towards energy production models that are good, making our interconnections, primarily electrical, and others, for example, green hydrogen, and implementing the strategy we have decided. Because the texts are in place, it is about implementation. What do we lack the most in my eyes today? It is the level of investment. That is to say, the great risk is that most of the technologies we use to make this transition are produced in China or the United States. And by the way, look, when everywhere in Europe, 15-20 years ago, we massively deployed photovoltaic panels, we had abandoned the sector, we imported photovoltaic panels from China. It was a huge industrial mistake. And so at the same time, we need to reinvest so that the technological solutions are conceived in our research centers and that we produce, that there are all the sectors that allow for this transition. Because that is what will also create jobs and prevent us from being dependent. And that is why we need to go much faster, especially after the Inflation Reduction Act in the United States, which allows for a lot of production there. We need to produce a lot at home. That is the strategy.

Intervenor

We talked about the very strict agenda around climate and Europe, how do we balance market competitiveness around countries like the United States and China that will be much less critical on climate and pass much fewer laws?

Emmanuel MACRON

For me, there is a triangle that needs to be brought together, it is quite simple. The competitiveness of our industries. Why? Because we cannot make a transition if we do not continue to create wealth. And I say this in our countries because we have a very generous social model, it is a strength, but if we say the transition must create less wealth and sacrifice economic competitiveness, it will create enormous crises. Because we will say we can no longer finance health, we can no longer finance education, we can no longer finance research. So, it must be compatible with competitiveness.

The second point of the triangle, the second vertex, is sovereignty. My transition must allow me to have energy sources that I control to avoid experiencing what we went through at the beginning of the war in Ukraine.

The third point, it must reduce CO2 emissions and preserve or even restore biodiversity. I always hold the two together; we must never forget biodiversity with the issue of emissions because it is completely twin. So, our strategy must hold together these three objectives in a very simple way. It is totally feasible, but it requires a lot of public and private investments to change our production models and decarbonize our models. And so, that is what we are currently doing.

For example, all over Europe, when we look at our economic situation, our industry, it is sectors like steel, metallurgy, and cement that used to produce a lot. What do we do? We invest with industrialists and their shareholders, but we put a lot of public money into converting their models, either to reduce emissions, or to change electricity production methods, or even to change manufacturing methods to decarbonize.

Then, alongside that, what do we do? We say we must align our policy and this decarbonization with the wider world. And that is why I wanted to emphasize this point and raise your awareness about it. We are all open economies, we value that, we trade with the whole world. But our trade agenda must be compatible with the climate agenda. And so at the moment we do this, we ask our industrialists to make this effort, but I could have taken the example of our farmers and others, we must ask the same thing of those we trade with, and that is how we maintain competitiveness with the climate.

That is why the European Union has established a carbon adjustment mechanism at its borders to say: if I trade with a country that makes the same efforts as I do in its industry, that’s good, we can enter with the same tariffs. But if it does not make the same efforts as I do and has embedded CO2 because it has not decarbonized, there must be an adjustment mechanism at my borders, there is in a way a carbon and biodiversity tariff to somewhat sanction it for entering.

This is smart because at that moment, not only do we decarbonize, we defensively preserve our competitiveness to avoid being, if I may say, shaken by products that have not made the same efforts and by industrialists who have not made the same efforts, but because the European Union is one of the major global markets.

We encourage other major economies to do as we do in order to continue importing their goods, their products into our market. And that is also why I advocate for what we call "mirror clauses" and to say that when we have industrial or agricultural negotiations, we must ensure that countries make the same efforts as we do with their agriculture, with their industry, if they want to trade with us more favorably.

This is a moment of tension. Not everyone agrees with me in Europe. We have adopted the adjustment mechanism. It is being implemented. On the mirror clauses, we sometimes have discussions. But that is how we can do things, through investment, acceleration, these mechanisms. The risk, you are absolutely right, is that we become the continent that regulates a lot but does not invest enough or is not coherent enough. That is the risk of the moment. So we need to put a lot of energy into it.

I just wanted to make one last remark a bit on the sidelines, but to make it clear for everyone. We have a responsibility: we are major markets. So if we want to succeed in implementing the Paris Agreements, for me, we have two essential things to do. The major rich economies must respect the Agreements. We, since 2018-2019, are on our trajectory in France. We respect the Paris Agreements. We had been condemned for climate inaction during the period before 2018. Since then, we are on our trajectory. Simply, we must make 2.5 times more emission reductions in the coming years, so we cannot sit back and rest on our laurels. All rich countries must make this transition: the United States, the European Union, Japan, South Korea.

The second key element if we want to succeed is to get emerging economies out of coal, if I had to be simple, because there are many other things to do. But the key, if we really want to succeed, at least by 2030, is to ensure that China reaches its peak faster, that India, that the major emerging economies begin to reduce their dependence on coal, even by switching to gas. That is much better than coal. The exit from coal in emerging economies, for you to remember this, is at the heart of the battle. Because if they take the path of growth with coal, it is enormous because it almost annihilates, at least in the short term, the efforts that we are making. That is why, diplomatically, that is where we are putting our efforts to try to do everything we can to get the major emerging economies out of dependence on coal. And we have established what we call just transition contracts that we have started signing with South Africa, that we are currently discussing with India, that we have signed with Senegal, that we are advancing with Indonesia, that we are working with Brazil, to help them make these transitions.

Unidentified speaker

A question about the migration crisis, rather refugees than economic immigration. Europe, historically, has not been very benevolent, nor fair, with the inhabitants from those countries. Do you think that Europe has a responsibility now, to help the people coming from those countries who sometimes see Europe as the only way to save their lives?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I will tell you, the history of our Europe, and particularly contemporary Europe, is inseparable from the question of exiles, stateless persons, and political asylum.

Political asylum is the protection of freedom fighters, of women and men who flee their country because they are threatened due to their position, their choices, or because their country is at war. And that is what is at the heart, by the way, of our texts, even. That is why I have always said, even if we are shaken by migratory phenomena, we must never lose sight of what made us.

As for France, it is even in the preamble of our Constitution. It is not simply conventional, it is constitutional.

Europe, which had not done its part at the beginning of the century or before, and which was shaken between countries on this subject, has done so since 1945. For about ten to fifteen years, because wars have returned to our neighborhood, the war in Syria, wars in Africa, and because there have been many migrations that have come in parallel, which are not just these, I will come back to that, has faced unprecedented migratory pressures in the last 10 years, unprecedented. We have never had so many people arriving.

Has Europe not been up to the task for the women and men fleeing war-torn countries? I would not be as harsh as you. I tell you this sincerely. Because each time, we protect and we have national agencies that protect, that welcome. And when I look compared to other major regions, we are much more generous on this subject than most other G20 countries. After all, when I say countries, major groups.

There is no more generous model on the subject of political asylum than the Europeans. We need to stop flagellating ourselves. It is not true. There is none. And including countries, by the way, that give lessons, including major emerging economies that give lessons. They generally refuse political asylum at home and to neighboring countries. So, Europeans, we need to stop flagellating ourselves. It is not true.

What worries me today is the fact that some countries or political currents in certain countries are saying: the solution to address migration would be to exit political asylum or these conventions. Terrible mistake. Where what you say is true is that we have all been under pressure and therefore we have humanitarian situations in our countries, and that has also been true in France, which have been very hard for women and men fleeing their country and who were therefore in a situation of waiting for status.

What has happened in the last 15 years is that economic migration networks have also formed, which, knowing the rules, have come to Europe and have all come to apply for political asylum. And so today, I speak to you of a country that, in recent years, has had about, on average, 80,000 to 100,000 asylum applications per year. Per year.

For many, when I look at the main countries — coming from Afghanistan, Pakistan, we totally understand — but the main countries where there are these asylum applications are Côte d'Ivoire, Senegal, Guinea, these are countries where there is no war and where we exchange, we have embassies, consulates.

So, you can see what is happening? The political asylum request is today used as a pathway to arrive in our territories and, in fact, is an umbrella for economic migration. And that is our challenge.

Because all our systems are clogged, there are enormous waiting times, we have women and men who all live in a form of precariousness, even if in France, I also tell you, we care for and will continue to care for, to be clear, those who request asylum or who are on our soil. Because it is a humanitarian duty and it is a duty of solidarity, and it is also a duty of public health.

Second point, we provide unconditional housing. Every year, we invest 2 billion euros in France on emergency housing, the majority of which is largely for people who are in an irregular situation on our soil or in asylum requests or in status requests. So, we invest, we continue to do so, but our problem is that there is a confusion of things.

So what must we do if we want to treat more humanely? We must protect the women and men who request asylum much faster, who are exactly those for whom we have a moral and political duty that we will not abandon. And we must much more quickly resolve the cases of women and men who fall under economic migration or others to be able to know if they have a vocation to stay on our territory or if they must return to their country, because it is not a war-torn country, because they came illegally onto our soil, etc., etc.

I make this distinction because it is essential and because the public debate often creates a lot of confusion. And I want to tell you this because it is a subject of the future for our Europe. Europe must continue to respect what it has constituted within itself, that is to say, protect the fighters for freedom, continue to have political asylum. But Europe, if we want to continue to have this model of unconditional human reception, if we want to continue to have very generous social models, cannot fail to regulate economic migration and effectively combat illegal migration. And it would be totally demagogic to tell you otherwise, because at that moment, our models would become totally unsustainable because our citizens would no longer want to continue financing a model where it is enough to come illegally onto our soil to benefit very quickly. And so, as always, the humanist philosophy requires rigor and efficiency in its implementation and distinction in principles. That is what we will continue to do.