In front of the readers of the EBRA group in Mirecourt.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

28 November 2025 · Meeting with readers of the EBRA group · Robert Flambeau Space, Mirecourt, France

Context
Macron addressed readers of the EBRA regional press group in Mirecourt, Vosges, for a citizen exchange on digital dangers to democracy and youth.
Main themes
Social networks and digital dangers, cyberbullying, misinformation and disinformation, foreign interference, media education, democracy and public debate, regional press and journalism, artificial intelligence, youth and digital addiction, information trust and certification, citizen engagement, territorial representation
Duration
~171 min
99th percentile
Words
20,475
99th percentile
Sentences
1,205
99th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%46%
  • Ceremonial 20%19%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

1,205 sentences in 261 paragraphs

Sophie GOURMELEN

Thank you very much. Mr. President of the Republic, dear readers, ladies and gentlemen, welcome to Mirecourt in the Robert Flambeau Space. Mr. President, allow me to express how much your visit here touches us. Your presence in a small town in the Vosges is not a trivial gesture, even if it required a bit of creativity from our teams, whom I would like to thank here. It is concrete proof that you choose to meet the French people, wherever they live. This matters for our territories, for our readers, and for our newspapers, which tell their daily lives throughout the year. Thank you sincerely for being here.

I also want to warmly greet our readers — I turn here — who have come sometimes from very far away, from all the regions covered by the 9 titles of the EBRA group. We have people who have come from Strasbourg, Lyon, Grenoble, and Dijon. Your presence speaks volumes. Regional press brings together attentive and engaged citizens who want to understand the world and actively participate in public debate. It is a true strength for our democracy.

The topics we are addressing today, cyberbullying, addiction to social networks, misinformation, foreign interference, media education, are at the heart of our readers' concerns. We have selected a dozen witnesses who are directly affected in their daily lives, and this meeting offers you, Mr. President, a direct and frank exchange with those who are experiencing these transformations, sometimes with concern, but often with great clarity. It is also an opportunity for our readers to be heard and to get answers on how to prevent the dangers of social networks when they are neither regulated nor sufficiently understood.

The EBRA group wishes to fully participate in this collective reflection. That is why we are going to create a think tank, which we will call Information and Democracy, an independent place, rooted in the territories, to analyze, understand, and propose. Our ambition is simple: to contribute, in our own way, to a better-informed, calmer, and more confident society. This is for us the natural continuation of our mission, to strengthen the bonds of proximity and trust in our regions. I also want to return to a commitment that makes the EBRA group unique in France. We have renewed the Journalism Trust Initiative certification, JTI. The EBRA group is now the only French press group to hold this label. It is a demanding process that requires us to be exemplary in the treatment of information. It constitutes an international recognition of the professionalism of our journalists and the rigor of our editorial teams. Backed by the seriousness and independence of Reporters Without Borders, this certification sends a clear message to our readers and our advertisers. We do what we say, and we do it transparently. In an environment that is saturated with content, where false information circulates faster than the truth, this requirement is not just a promise, but a democratic duty.

The daily regional press has a unique mission: to connect, explain, and make visible the realities on the ground. What happens in villages, in medium-sized towns, in neighborhoods, must never remain in the shadows. Our role, Mr. President, is also to create the conditions for a sincere dialogue between citizens and those who decide. Thank you, Mr. President, for accepting this exchange. Thank you for your availability, for your listening, and for the attention given to our territories. Thank you all, readers, for your trust. I now propose that we move on to what we are all gathered here for: the exchanges and the debate. Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Thank you, Madam Director General, for your words, and thank you to the Municipality of Mirecourt and the leaders of Flambeau for hosting us. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for being here. As you mentioned, I know that several of you have come from far away to have this exchange. I will not give an opening speech, because I believe that the exchange is what matters most.

I have been doing this for several weeks with several regional daily press titles, because I consider that the moment we are living through, whether it concerns the impact of social networks or artificial intelligence, which we will undoubtedly return to in our discussions, on both our youth and the functioning of our democracies, has reached a point that requires us to, in a way, build consensus on our understanding of it and try to construct collective decisions. In fact, decisions cannot simply be a law, a decree taken from Paris, or changes in European rules, because part of all this also depends on Europe, from Brussels; it can only work if we all agree on the observation, at least a majority of us, because it requires a form of mobilization, a resurgence of the nation. But something is happening in the functioning of our democracies that is going awry, if I had to put it as simply as possible.

I have been a bit surprised, since we started this debate, I must admit, to sometimes read or hear comments in the national press or on television saying that all this is of little interest. It’s strange. As if, in the end, debates on national platforms where two experts on a national stage were purging the debate were what was interesting. I am more interested, on this subject, in listening to the French people everywhere across the national territory. I thank the regional daily press for carrying this fight and doing so, I would say, against all odds, and even if it is not fashionable with some, because it turns out that from Épinal to Saint-Dié, going all the way to Grenoble, and as you said, throughout your area, you have things to say, you are experiencing things, and I am interested in hearing them, and I want us to debate, so I will not be any longer.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President of the Republic. So, we have two hours now to exchange. For this first segment on misinformation, titled "Misinformation and Foreign Interference."

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President, thank you for being here. Hello everyone. As you said, we are starting with foreign interference and misinformation. This is a subject on which you intervene regularly, and you have often alerted us to the democratic risks it implies. The observation is therefore not new, but it is worsening. In the face of this, we are not starting from scratch. You will probably talk about VIGINUM. I specify, it is the public service of vigilance and digital protection against foreign interference. It has existed for 4 years.

Certainly, it exists, but it has not prevented nearly 150 information sites from being created in France alone between January and June. So, in the face of these orchestrated disinformation enterprises from abroad, we, the regional daily press, have long believed ourselves to be somewhat spared. Spared because we are close to the ground, we are close to people, close to local realities, but it is precisely because we are all of this that we have become targets of interference. So to talk about it, I will not first give the floor to one of the readers, and they will be many to speak later. I will give the floor to a journalist from Vosges Matin, who has written a comprehensive investigation on this subject that was published in all our newspapers 48 hours ago.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President, hello everyone. Yes, we conducted an investigation on this subject. As Nathalie said, 150 fake sites that mimic the codes of regional press, it is quite striking, the observation is striking, and this is despite VIGINUM. So my question will be very simple. You set up, 4 years ago, means of action to combat all this, and yet the State seems overwhelmed by the situation and completely powerless. Let's take the example of a more local site called Vosges en ligne, which was created at the beginning of the year, I believe. Today, it has disappeared, since I think it has been reported that it has disappeared since our investigation. It is no longer accessible, but our research has shown that it took only a few hours via ChatGPT and a dozen euros to create it abroad, that it was hosted in a data center in Iceland, and that it had been referenced by a company… a company based in London. We see how easy it is to create a fake news site and circulate false information online. So my question is very simple, in light of this observation, what concrete means could, in your opinion, be put in place to prevent it from re-emerging under another name in a few days, in a few hours even? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. So, this is a huge subject, and we are not necessarily aware of it. But indeed, social networks and artificial intelligence, which now also comes into play, are being used by foreign powers to destabilize our democracies. Now, you cited a case; I do not know who is behind it. In any case, there are elements to show that it comes from abroad and that it is rather to destabilize us. For example, a few months ago, there was a false piece of information. This was not a fake site that circulated, but it was false information claiming that we had sent 1,000 legionnaires to the front in Ukraine. You may have read it, perhaps at one point believed it. All of this was completely false, but it circulated and was seen millions of times.

The best example to see the risk we run is what happened in Romania, where elections were annulled in the first round, with a technique that resembles what you just described and what you denounced. That is to say, in Romania, pro-Russian elements, aided by Russia, systematically set up fake accounts for months. They first identified people who were vulnerable to false information, because it does not work with everyone. There is a form of vulnerability. So, people who were interested in alternative medicine, people who were interested in religions — that does not mean that everyone can believe nonsense when looking at these sites — but it creates predispositions. In any case, they had identified this as possible areas, and then local information.

They methodically created fake accounts, fake pages, thousands and thousands of fake pages for months, but they attracted people. And then, when the campaign was launched, the candidate who was supported and pushed by the pro-Russians began to create networks that referred to these fake accounts. And it created a viral loop that made him have absolutely crazy success and was pushed by all of this, which obviously distorted the democratic functioning.

So all this to say that we are not talking about fictions, about things that are not possible. This happened in a large democracy of the European Union, what I am telling you. And so it is clear that this will happen, at least they will try things during electoral deadlines, as they did there for Russia. So what do we do in the face of this? Indeed, it has been said, we created an agency called VIGINUM, which monitors, relays, conducts investigations, and now we release information. As soon as we have established information, we have a dialogue with the sites. How can we act, and what is our action, and what has probably — I will check because I do not know the exact case you mentioned — but what do we do in the face of these sites? The only thing we can do legally today is to look at all these fake sites and say that they do not comply with the general terms of use, and we ask for their removal. This is indeed what the VIGINUM teams do, and they request the removal of these sites, all this information, when they are identified as interference. Simply, it is extremely long, complicated, and slow. And so we can see that we are in a phase, and this is what we are preparing, where we will have to toughen up.

So what we want to put in place, and we have already done a bit with the first directives, the directive on digital services that was pushed by France in 2022 during our presidency, and then adopted a few months later, is to establish a real system of platform accountability. The only way to be very responsive and avoid suffering, as you said, is for hosts or platforms to have responsibility when they allow false information or fake sites that are the result of interference to thrive, as you are. As a press title, if there were false information being pushed in one of the titles of the EBRA group or an interference, I would ask you to remove it or the VIGINUM, and if that were not done, we would hold you accountable. That is not the case today for those sites.

So, 1) it exists and what you have described shows, 2) we now know how to attribute it, meaning we can still most of the time trace it back to powers. I mentioned Russia, which is the most aggressive, but it is not the only one. We can come back to that. 3) We are able to act, but really, it is a daily battle for the teams. 4) Now, we will have to industrialize, so we are putting in a lot more resources. We are also putting resources to alert everyone to this risk, and then to establish a system of accountability for platforms and networks so that they remove content much faster, and if they do not remove it, for them to hunt it down themselves and to have responsibility when they allow these interferences to thrive.

Speaker

Mr. President, good morning. As explained, I work in communication. So I am aware of social networks on a daily basis and I am primarily of Romanian and French nationality. So exactly one year ago, there was the annulment of the first round of the Romanian elections by the Constitutional Court, which is historic and which created a strong mobilization at the heart of the Romanian diaspora, of which I was a part. We had many concerns given our country's past, which has experienced a very severe communist regime not long ago. Romania is a country close to France, and my question, you have already answered it a bit, but it is to know, as we approach the municipal and presidential elections next year, how we can protect ourselves and not relive the experience that Romania or even Moldova went through?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you. So, I started to answer that. Romania has provided a feedback experience. There is a very comprehensive report that was made by Romania, which it shared with us, which allows me to tell you what I just explained with the methodical work that was done before by, I would say, largely the Russians and pro-Russians. Moldova also had its election with a lot of interference and meddling from Russia that tried to manipulate. The most organized system we have seen is clearly the one that occurred in Romania, because it was based on both false information on networks, but many relay accounts, and so, in a way, they created a nebula and then accelerated.

In Moldova, it was mostly false information that was pushed by accounts. So the way to prepare for it is 1) to strengthen the system, which we are doing with VIGINUM, 2) to make things public. That is to say, in a democracy, we are all antibodies to interference, normally, when we know we are victims of it, when we know we can be exposed to it. That is why their entire strategy relies first on people who are a bit weaker or gullible, whom they identify. But all of us, if we are clear-eyed and we know it, that we know the risk exists, we pay more attention, we are more vigilant. That is very important, and for me, it is also the importance of our debates. It creates vigilance because we become aware. Honestly, a year or two ago, I believe no one would have had the debate in a room like this today, come on, two years ago, no one would have said: it can happen. No one. And I would even say, I would go back to just before 2022, it is not that long ago, before the outbreak of the Russian aggression war in Ukraine, when we had much less interference, much less information wars pushed by Russia. You would have told me: he is crazy or he is paranoid. But today, it is really a reality. So our vigilance is primarily something that protects us.

Then, we will release, at the beginning of next year, a very comprehensive work that has been done on this subject, led by, precisely, VIGINUM and the General Secretariat for Defense and National Security, which has piloted this with the best experts. We will also push all the experts from all think tanks, academics, to explain how this risk exists. Thirdly, we are putting in place systems where we disconnect much faster, as I said, that is to say, we create a responsibility for platforms.

There is another fight related to this. Finally, there are two things that I consider very important in this fight and that must be highlighted here. The first is the issue of fake accounts, what we call bots, trolls. You may have heard about this, but you do not see them. That is to say, when you have a message that is highly connected, you say to yourself: oh dear, there are still 2 million people who supported it. When this message or this information ends up becoming viral, when it then sometimes becomes a form of information, in any case a social fact, which is then taken up by the press legitimately, because they say, there are still 2.5 million people who pushed this. You cannot say today if it is 2 million people, you know it is 2 million accounts, but you cannot say if there are real people behind those accounts. Now, there are people who do this for commercial reasons, sometimes political, but there are many people who use this for geopolitical reasons. Those who meddle, and in the case of Romania, it was very identified, there were massive troll farms, and so you had millions of fake accounts that were mobilized. We must demand from these social networks that they ensure, that they guarantee that behind each account, there is a real person.

Another question, we may come back to it in the debate, is that of anonymity. But at the very least, we need to know if there is someone real or not. And if there is not someone real, we can see that it distorts exchanges, it distorts democracy. It distorts it when we have an issue of interference, but even when we are going to exchange with someone on a certain account, if it is a fake account, it changes everything, if there is not a real person behind it. So that is something we will demand, we will fight for. It is a battle we will have to wage at the European level. And it is absolutely key.

The second is that during election periods, we must no longer allow the purchase of information pages. Here, I may make a small parenthesis, if you allow me just a minute, because when we talk about all this, I think we will come back, I believe, to all the topics that deal with social networks, I think that collectively, we must never forget what we are talking about. I think this little clarification is important for all of us. That is to say, when I want to inform myself, I will look at a newspaper on television. We have people who are paid for that. There is a public contribution, there is an economic model behind it. Or I will buy a press title, regional or national, I pay to be informed. Then, newspapers will supplement this remuneration by what they receive from legal announcements or advertising. But there is an economic model. I pay to be informed, I make a request to professional people.

Social networks, when we inform ourselves on them, are they made to inform you? No. What are social networks made for? They are made to attract you, create excitement in you to sell individualized advertising pages. That is the economic model. That is why the infrastructure that these social networks constitute, and I am not saying it is good or bad, because it allows for many great things, to alert, to exchange, etc., but it is an infrastructure that is, today, created, whose economic model is not non-profit, as we say in good French, it is not charitable. It is an economic model that relies on the sale of individualized advertisements, because in fact, they will collect data on you to be able to tell a certain advertiser: I have someone who likes this type of product or who is oriented, I will be able to push your advertisements to them. It is much better than displaying them or putting them in the press. That is why we have lost a lot of money in our press model because of that. So, it is important to understand that the purpose of these social networks is not for you to have deliberation, for you to be informed. Their purpose is for you to spend as much time as possible on them, to create therefore the maximum excitement to have the maximum information and to be able to push you the maximum number of advertising pages.

Once we understand that, we understand that, in the order of things, argumentation is the least interesting for social networks. Because when I change an argument, it does not create annoyance, excitement. I inform myself, that is very good, then I leave. Emotion is better because it will create more traffic. But negative emotion is even better, because it is the one that will... so rage, anger, etc. Look when we are on a social network, what works is that, or what is addictive and that the algorithms detect.

So let us never forget in our discussions that when we talk about social networks, and I say this, it can be a wonderful thing, social networks too, but we are talking about something that is structured to create rather dependence, excitement, and therefore rather negative emotions, because they earn their money by pushing you individualized advertising. Once we understand this bias, we say, it is probably not where we should primarily inform ourselves, and we can see that this bias is a vulnerability in relation to foreign interference, because if I massively buy pages or accounts or information that I can push, because I can also have sponsored things on these networks, during an election period, well, I can totally penetrate the informational space. And so, beyond what we have said, transparency and the prohibition of trolls and fake accounts, and the prohibition during election periods of any paid advertising, paid pages or pushed content are key.

Speaker

Mr. President, good morning. I have indeed recently published a book called "Foules ressentimentales," you were talking about anger and resentment earlier, sorry. You stated, I believe yesterday, the necessity of reintroducing military service on a voluntary basis for our youth. Indeed, you anticipate a conflict, as the Chief of Staff did last time, a possible conflict with foreign powers, and in that sense, we can commend this initiative. Alongside military armies, there are now armies of trolls. You mentioned it, troll farms, troll factories, that engage in interference. This was the case during the Yellow Vests crisis, you were already President of the Republic. It was certainly also the case regarding our strategic positions in Africa, the Russians and certainly the Chinese have dealt with this. It is quite serious because it aims to harm our national cohesion and sometimes even perhaps to dissolve or destroy it.

You said earlier that it is very long to anticipate this. For example, for attacks, to talk about something very tragic, you have services that anticipate attacks, but you also have intervention troops that, in case of emergency, can intervene. My question is a bit dramatic, if I may say so, but if we propose two catastrophic scenarios that Madame was talking about earlier. The elections in March 2026, the municipal elections, the elections in April-May for the presidential elections in 2027, what can the State do urgently, for example, if there is a wave of massive disinformation and if, as you say, the work of anticipation is extremely long? Do we have the capacity to intervene urgently in the event of massive disinformation and, how should I put it, interference and attack on our national sovereignty?

Speaker

Hello Mr. President. So, precisely, I am 18 years old and that means that this year, I have acquired the right to vote, and so I would like to participate in this democracy and through, in particular, testimonies and especially observations that I have been able to have at university and more generally, on my age group, my peers, etc., I have noticed that there is a certain information that young people have which is completely different from that of other generations, that is to say, today, we only inform ourselves through social networks.

But the problem with social networks is that they are conditioned by algorithms. This means that today, when we have a political viewpoint, an opinion that appears on social networks, it follows this algorithmic path that leads us to be enclosed in this algorithmic bubble, and once we have a certain ideology that the social network, in particular, has detected, it will confine us in this bubble and reinforce our idea.

And so I made these observations because I see that I have peers who are completely trapped, in fact, in the idea that, for example, they have these political viewpoints without having had a contradiction, and therefore without having really experienced the pluralism that we can have in conventional media. My question is quite simple: do you support the idea of imposing on social media platforms a certain algorithmic serendipity, that is to say, a positive randomness for users, mainly for young people who do not necessarily have the habit of informing themselves through anything other than social networks, and therefore impose on these platforms ultimately a counter-algorithmic logic that would force these platforms to a pluralism regarding the ideas presented on these platforms?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, there are two different things we are talking about. I think we need to distinguish them for the clarity of our debates. There is the functioning, fundamentally, of social networks themselves in our democracy, and there is the question of interference, which assumes that there is a foreign power that uses them. Because what you just described touches a bit on what I mentioned earlier; it is the very functioning, fundamentally, of social networks and the state of our democracy with social networks. I do not need the Russians to have the problem you just described, fundamentally.

We can see that we have a form of a bit of degeneration in the functioning of our democracies due to what is happening. Because, as I mentioned, social networks are not designed, and their economic model has nothing to do with informing and leading a democratic debate. They are not made for that. So the problem is that now, we have particularly among young people, more and more young people who go on these networks to inform themselves, and we have more and more of us who spend a lot of time there and who, in fact, inform ourselves there. In any case, we are confronted with content, whether we seek it out or not.

So it does have an impact on democracy, because what is democracy? It is, of course, elections; we choose our mayor, our deputy, our president, but it is also about forging free, rational opinions in order to make that decision. And we are increasingly delegating the forging of these opinions, the manufacturing of these opinions, to our interaction with these social networks. And when you have young people who, in nearly 50% of your age group, will inform themselves on social networks, even if they do not fully trust them, when you have young people under 18 who spend an average of more than 4 hours a day on these networks, you can see that we must still take care of this; we cannot let this jungle thrive like that. And so what happens? As I said earlier, the economic model of these networks is rather to create excitement, dependency. So it is not information.

But if we go a step further regarding what you just said, the networks, mechanically, also confine us in bubbles. That is to say, where in a democracy, to function, we need to create common ground, which is a bit like this room, what you do, what our mayors, our elected officials do when they gather, what daily or weekly press does when it gathers its readers. You can have affinities because you read the same press titles. But it is likely that if I were to conduct a survey today, you are in different professions and you probably think very differently on many subjects. It is a chance, because that is how we create common ground.

But if you only go to inform yourself or exchange on the platforms, on your social networks, very quickly, you are influenced by all the people who follow you. And if what you say does not please them, they will unsubscribe from your account, they will stop following you, or you block them because they insulted you three times. So you will be pushed by the most extreme people who think like you. Then you will also follow the accounts that bring you.

The mechanism we see is a mechanism that totally pushes towards extremes, that confines us with people who think like us about our certainties. That is why we have more and more conspiracy theories in the world we live in, because we have more and more people. I mean, if I am in a bubble where, all day long, I think and am with people who think that the vaccine is a very bad thing, it is likely that after 15 days, we will have convinced each other that the vaccine is really very dangerous. If in my group, there is no virologist, no doctor, no scientist, no specialist, it is not the most enlightened debate on Earth, but we will have really pumped each other up. Then the group will grow, and we will be 200, 500 to really think that it is the worst thing. That is exactly what is happening. So it confines us in cognitive bubbles and pushes us to extremes. And that is dangerous.

So that is another problem we have with the infrastructure of these networks. We can see that first, we need to train our young people and our less young people more and more to inform themselves outside and prepare the democratic debate outside of these networks. I think that is a public health measure to say that we need, for democracy to function, to restore deliberation, exchange, physically, and to do it through the role that our local and national elected officials have, perhaps reinventing forms, using totally sincere platforms, and doing it with our titles. So we need to slow down the democratic functioning a bit, give it back some proximity to the physical. I am convinced of that, because it is the thing that will allow us to cool down the engine a bit; otherwise, it goes in all directions.

The second thing would be, as you mentioned, the question of algorithms. And there, to be clear for everyone, the algorithm is in a way the editor-in-chief of the platform or the network. That is to say, every day in your newspapers, there is an editor or editor-in-chief with the editorial team who will say, we put this on the front page, who will push, prioritize content and push it to you, and who will decide to put this information before that one and perhaps choose not to include certain ones. Well, you have a super editor-in-chief, individualized, when you open your social networks, called the algorithm. It does not exist physically, but it is made precisely for the reasons I mentioned earlier. It is made for you to become more and more dependent because it looks at your reactions every day. So it will push you what you like, it will push you what makes you react the most, because it sees it and measures it, which will create the most excitement for it, because it will push what will allow it to sell much better, because that is its goal, its model.

Before knowing if we can create a counter-algorithm, what we are going to fight for at the European level is to have transparency of algorithms towards everyone, because that will create a public debate, and obviously towards regulatory authorities. Because I cannot say today what the biases of the algorithm are in X or the algorithm that exists on TikTok. But I know there are biases, meaning it works incorrectly. There are researchers today who have shown this very well, for example. They work in a French start-up called Arlequin, but they are academic researchers, Mr. Micheron with his colleagues. They showed that when you create, they did it by sequencing, by putting totally neutral accounts with different characteristics, and they opened different accounts on TikTok. A young person, regardless of their characteristics, who goes on TikTok, after scrolling through 4 to 5 videos, is exposed to a video of Salafist content. Because the platform has detected that it creates excitement, evidently. In any case, that we manage to catch young people through that and push them. It is a huge bias; it is a huge problem. So we are working on resolving this with them. But that, because we tested this subject. But we need to have transparency. What is the bias behind these platforms? What do they push? So that is a very important point that we are going to push for before the elections.

But in parallel to all these measures, and many are calling for them to be made at the European level, the key is what we are saying here. Because what we are saying here, I hope to have touched some of you, you will leave with more distrust or vigilance about social networks. It is this battle that needs to be fought before the elections. And in this context, trolls play an extremely important role. So what can we do before our elections? What I started to say. We are going to raise the posture. So first, we raise it with VIGINUM, but also with the Quai d'Orsay, which, more and more, indeed, pushes information, does what technicians call, sorry for this Anglicism, but pre-bunking, that is to say, they prepare minds for this vigilance. So when we identify things or anticipate them, we ourselves push the information by saying: beware, this is going to happen, so that people are less sensitive to it.

Then, we have put more resources to identify these fake accounts and have them removed and counter them. Finally, we are going to fight, and this needs to change the rules, to ban them, because it is the basis of everything. It is not normal that we have these hidden armies because we allow them on our national territory. And what needs to be understood is that, in fact, it is an informational and cognitive war, because it is a war to push false information, and for example, in the case of Russia, to undermine trust in the effort we are making and the legitimacy of what we are doing alongside the Ukrainians. But behind it, it is a war to divide us, weaken us, and make democracy a bit crazy, if I may say so. Sometimes they succeed. So it is really about emphasizing that. That needs to be banned.

Sophie GOURMELEN

Thank you, Mr. President.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Nathalie, and to our witness, whom we can applaud, please. We have three more sequences, three themes in just over an hour now. And I will invite Georges Bosi, who is next to me, Georges Bosi, who is the deputy editor-in-chief at Dauphiné Libéré. And your sequence, Georges, concerns the fight against cyberbullying.

Moderator

Thank you. Hello, Mr. President. Hello everyone. A few figures very quickly published by INSEE last October, on the 10th precisely. In 2024, online harassment represented 35% of harassment offenses. In middle school, we will talk about it, 21% of students reported having received insults online, compared to 15% in high school. Between 2016 and 2024, the number of victims of digital sexual harassment has multiplied by 6. So, I will have two small sequences in this segment, if you don't mind, Mr. President. First, two witnesses will ask you a question, then we will discuss – you mentioned AI – a form of cyberbullying involving extreme image impersonation.

So, first, I will address Annabelle Guichard. Hello, Annabelle. Hello again, Annabelle. It will be better with the microphone. You come from Côte-d'Or, Annabelle. Your son was a victim of bullying in middle school and in the gaming community. It is important to specify that.

Speaker

Yes.

Moderator

And I add that you created the association "La Voix du Harcèlement" last May. We are listening to you.

Speaker

Absolutely. Mr. President, hello. I am a close caregiver, so I fight daily for the respect of the rights and interests of my children. The triggering event for the creation of my association, "La Voix du Harcèlement," was a question my son asked me when he was bullied in 2023: "Mom, if the adults at school who are supposed to protect me don't do it, what do I do to defend myself?" Indeed, there are the platforms, 3018, 3020, but things do not move fast enough, not far enough. We make a report, and the next day, what do we do? We send our children back into the arena to continue being bullied? That is not possible. It was just something that was not conceivable for me. As a mother, seeing my child suffer is just not possible.

Today, online gaming platforms are also becoming a place of cyberbullying, just like some class WhatsApp groups, where things can quickly escalate. So, my question is simple: what timeline do you set for making these digital platforms safer and thus ensuring the mental health of our children?

Host

Thank you, Annabelle. We will now listen to Mattéo Jacques. Mattéo Jacques, you are 22 years old, you come from Sélestat. You were a victim of bullying in middle school and high school. I specify this because you have attempted to take your own life twice. We are listening to you.

Speaker

Thank you, Georges. Mr. President, every year, 600,000 students suffer in silence: isolation, verbal and physical violence, cyberbullying. School bullying is today the scourge of youth, and it is unacceptable. The blows, the humiliations, the insults. I have experienced them all the way home. My arms, my throat remember those suicide attempts. For me, bullying is yesterday, today, and tomorrow. The scars, they are the story of my life. What I hold in my hand here is a 6-page book. This book was written by my bully when I was in high school. It was written on his school computer and sent to all my classmates. Mr. President, how can we explain this? How can a school tool be used to cause suffering? What can we say to a young person who, like me, is suffering or has suffered?

Sweden has found a good part of the solution; it is one of the pioneers here in Europe. How can we do everything possible to ensure the pHARe plan is respected? We have something in place, but how can we make it automatic? And why not sanction the institutions that do not implement it? And will action and prevention become our watchwords? I have written you a letter; I hope to be able to hand it to you.

Host

Thank you, Mathéo. Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, thank you for your testimonies, sir, and then madam for your son. I think everyone has felt the extreme pain that was present in both cases. Bullying, to put it simply, and once I have said that, we still obviously have far too many cases of bullying, and every time we have a child or a teenager who continues to be bullied in our country, it is something we must not and cannot get used to. There has been a collective awakening in recent years. And what you have experienced, I do not know during which years it was.

Speaker

It was in 6th grade, 5th grade, and in senior year.

Emmanuel MACRON

And I understand that it was in 2023 for your son. And speaking of all this, by the way, I think of young Lucas as well, who took his own life not far from here, and whose mother continues to fight this battle. That was a little over two years ago.

And so we arrive at tragedies, and in any case, we also arrive... even without it leading to tragedy, unfortunately the most terrible being the suicide attempt or suicide, at school dropouts and a suffering that nothing can justify because school must be the place where we learn, where we gain self-confidence, and where we also learn kindness. So the fight against bullying, for me, is key.

Since 2018, we launched the pHAre program, as you mentioned. It takes time, too much time to deploy, because perhaps we were also hiding it a bit. In any case, it was a bit of a hidden continent of our National Education, it must be said. And so, I believe that in recent years, we have made a lot of collective progress, I say this with the utmost humility, with recognition towards the teaching and educational communities. So yes, you still find this or that institution, we have sometimes seen it in recent news, that does not fully engage, that does not do enough. So now, the rectorates have been instructed to be extremely strict, to review. But to be clear for everyone, we have set up these programs that train teachers, but also the rest of the educational community, so the educational advisors, all those who are in contact with our children or teenagers. We are raising awareness among families. So, we have created vigilance to see the weak signals. And we have also empowered children and teenagers with ambassadors at each level, who help to prevent this. Does it create a completely perfect system? No. But we have improved it a lot, we have increased the sensors.

On top of that, in recent years, we have changed several things, we have strengthened controls, and we have created, in the penal code, a definition of what bullying is. And so we can now pursue the perpetrators of bullying, which was not the case before. And we have, regarding bullying and online bullying, changed the game a bit, meaning that now, it is the bullies who are removed. And in relation to what you said, which is absolutely correct, for a long time, in fact, we advised parents who had a bullied child to leave the institution when it was no longer working. Now, we have established in the rules that when we have identified a bully in an institution, the responsibility of the rectorate, of the educational community, is to remove this young person. Once I have said that, they must be removed, but they must also be supported, because often, behind a young person who bullies, we have someone who is not well in their head either. I say this, it is very hard for you to hear what I am saying, but it is not normal to do what you have described. It shocks me as much as it shocks you, but it means that you had someone who was your age, who did something terrible, who hurt you to the worst extent, but it means that it is someone who is probably also suffering greatly. So, our responsibility is also to take and try to treat the family and the young person. But today, we have these policies of removal.

And regarding cyberbullying, we have set up a system that means that when this cyberbullying is identified, we require the account to be closed for X months, and if there are recurrences, to be completely removed from the platform. So, we have improved things. Is it perfect? No. Because the relay, you mentioned it very well by citing two things, madam, it is the messaging loops and video games that are somewhat on the margins of social networks, it is not social networks, but something is also happening there. And so now, we need to toughen up on this. That is what we are preparing, and it has come up a lot in the debates we have had, with things that should not be neglected, including for young people who may be in distress. So, it is on the border of bullying, but other things, it is that today, these messaging loops – which we could say "they are not really social networks, we should not touch them" - they have AI agents in them.

When you go on WhatsApp, to name just them, with a provider that no longer cooperates with us at all, it is the worst. They do not cooperate at all, so when we ask them to remove information, Meta, nothing. They have put their AI agent, meaning you have a conversational agent. Maybe you use it, by the way, when you go on your WhatsApp, you ask it things, information. Young people aged 10 or 11 to whom we have allowed WhatsApp by saying: "I close social networks, but I put WhatsApp," they talk. Look at what they exchange with the agent. Because since these agents are anthropomorphic, they can lead them quite far. And there, we have no oversight. I will close this parenthesis.

But in any case, we have bullying happening on these messaging services and also on video games. And so, what are we going to continue to do? To toughen up, first to catch them by our rules, to apply now. Because we are going to take penal circulars to apply what we have put in place – that is to say this responsibility, the penal qualification – and to hold the platforms accountable when they do not remove content and do not stop, since we have established in the law the removal. And so, we will also apply it to video games and messaging services. It is a fight, once I have said that, you see, in recent years, it is both training, prevention, and repression. But we need to have a society of kindness that establishes itself. I understand that I am being too long.

Host

Thank you, Mr. President. It is a very brief testimony that I propose we listen to. Hello again, Anna.

Speaker

Hello again.

Host

Anna Baracetti, you come from Grenoble, you have traveled a lot, you are 34 years old, you are Italian, that is evident, and you are an assistant to a teacher with a disability, so you are in the school environment. You work at the Stendhal high school in Grenoble, and your story is both incredible and frightening. You were harassed by a colleague who did not accept your refusal.

Speaker

No, he thought he could have a relationship with me, he started sending me a lot of messages, and he was convicted for the first time in September.

Host

He was convicted, but I believe that it did not serve much purpose.

Speaker

No, he created a fake account on Instagram to steal photos from me that he modified with AI.

Host

And how did he modify them?

Speaker

To create pornographic photos and videos.

Host

So, he made a fake account in your name, meaning that these photos and videos were visible everywhere, including potentially by your students.

Speaker

Yes, he had put my name, my profession, and a call to contact me for sexual relations. Everyone could see them, my family, my friends, and yes, maybe my students; I was so afraid they would find these sites.

Host

So, as the worst is never disappointing, he was convicted during the trial, and his attitude completely shocked you.

Speaker

He did not feel guilty; he was not afraid because it was just the Internet, it was not serious.

Host

Very well, please ask your question to the President. Thank you, Anna.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President, thank you for being here. I would like to know what measures could be considered to prevent cyberbullies from hiding behind multiple identities and to ensure they are more severely punished.

Emmanuel MACRON

Was he removed from the institution?

Speaker

Yes, only for a year, but yes, after the conviction, he continued to work since February. And it is only since November 5 that he has stopped working in the school.

Host

Thank you, Anna. Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you. I think everyone is appalled by what you are experiencing and what you are saying. In this case, what you are experiencing is primarily someone who is personally harassing you, and you have responded because you are adults and have used the law; he was removed from the institution. So, I would say that on this aspect, what has been dealt with, what is behind, especially in what you are saying – and which requires a more vigorous and rapid action – is when someone, either by using social networks or by using social networks and artificial intelligence, in your case, spreads false information and information that is harmful to your dignity. That is the issue. And there, we have a problem; today, we are very slow.

And so, just this week, I held a Defense Council on information warfare where I asked for help, precisely, for a work report to be delivered to me by the end of the year, because we have a lot of things that exist. But that exist, for example, in the political domain, we can file a summary for false information when there is false information about someone. Within 48 hours, the judge can order the platform to remove it because it will affect the integrity of the election. We used it once in 2019, once. So, we can see that we are not using this law.

But in everyday life, I fully understand what you are experiencing; I won't elaborate here, but I have been personally, or my wife even more than I, confronted with the same kind of things; we are completely helpless. That is to say, it takes an incredible amount of time, it continues, people see it, there are crazies who think it's true, and then it wears you down. And there, we have no means to bring the judge into play. And so, what we need to do is really set up a system; I don't want to say technical, but it's called a summary proceeding. That is to say, you say, look, you can see that there is something: it's eating away at my life, it's not possible, I'm a teacher, it's in front of my students, I ask you to rule within 48 hours and to force it to shut down and then take it to trial, but to force it to shut down. And so, we must toughen our laws regarding people who do this. And to toughen, and it's always the same thing, the responsibility of the networks, because today, they wash their hands of it. They have no responsibility. And so, they must have editorial-type responsibility, because when they promote on their network, their platform, people who do this, of whom they are aware, if they do not remove them, it must be their fault. So, that's it, the two things. A summary proceeding to act quickly and a system of responsibility for the platforms. But I am wholeheartedly with you.

Speaker

Thank you, thank you very much.

Moderator

Mr. President, I think the next question from them would have been: by when do you think this will be possible?

Emmanuel MACRON

As soon as possible. What I am saying about the summary proceeding is French national law. The responsibility of the platforms is European law. We have a beginning of platform responsibility with this famous directive we call the DSA on digital services. We have several cases that are being pushed. We prioritize them, but we have cases... We are very active, we in France, but we have cases that have been before the Commission for 2 years. So it's too, too slow. But this is a push we will make at the European level by engaging. Because what you are experiencing, we have European citizens everywhere in the world who are experiencing it, sorry, not everywhere in the world, but everywhere on the European continent, in the 27 countries of the European Union. So, we have that.

Simply, this debate is not rising, and we must say it clearly. Many are afraid at the level of the Commission and the Member States to lead it because you have an American offensive at the moment against the application of this directive on services and on digital markets, because it is the big companies that are behind the American administration, and they are even asking for these directives to be removed. So there, we have a real geopolitical battle to fight. This is not Russian interference; it is clearly American, because these platforms do not want us to come and bother them, to put it politely. They want to continue making as much money as possible without any responsibility. And we want to fight on that. So, this is really a European battle. So, the summary proceeding is French, as soon as possible. What I just said about the responsibility of the platforms is European law that needs to be pushed.

Moderator

Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Moderator

And thank you, Georges BOSI. We can also applaud, please, our witnesses. Our third theme will address a subject that has already been mentioned, Mr. President. We will continue to delve into this subject, which is how to protect the youngest. And I will invite Sandrine Chabert, who is the deputy editor-in-chief at Le Progrès, to join me.

Host

Hello Mr. President, hello everyone. So indeed, we will address this question that concerns us all, how to protect our young people, our children from the dangers, from the "jungle," to use your words, of social networks. We know that 45% of children under 13 today use social networks, even though theoretically, access is prohibited for them. We know that 55% of 15-17 year-olds say they have often been confronted with shocking content. These are figures from a recent study by ARCOM.

I would add another figure, and I think it will find consensus, which is that 100% of parents are worried about what is happening on social networks. They know that they cannot really protect their children. They do not really know how much time their children spend on social networks. That is clear. They do not know exactly what they publish there either, and they do not know at all the content to which their children, despite themselves, are exposed. These are the famous opaque algorithms you mentioned. In the face of this, we know that our children are not equipped, that they are vulnerable, and we, the parents, do not really know how to protect them. I think this will resonate with the testimonies of Benoît Leroy that we will hear. Benoît, you are a general practitioner in Épinal, you are 42 years old, and you confided to me that you recently had a very strong shock. Something happened that you did not expect. We are listening to you; tell us.

Speaker

Thank you, Sandrine. Mr. President, hello everyone. Indeed, my stepdaughter, who is currently in middle school, received, as we discussed earlier, a video on her class WhatsApp group, showing one of her classmates engaging in a sexual act. This video was then disseminated to all the WhatsApp groups of the middle school immediately. Fortunately, the middle school reacted extremely well, and the video was removed within hours. But unfortunately, the damage was done, and more than half of the middle school saw this video, and that evening, our stepdaughter came home completely devastated.

While we thought, as responsible parents, that we had banned all social networks for our children, allowing only WhatsApp for class groups and family discussions, we were confronted with something for which we were absolutely unprepared, even though we thought we were being extremely vigilant. You mentioned earlier that I have the impression that at the level of children, prevention is going quite well. And my granddaughter in primary school, from primary school, they have awareness programs in middle school and child ambassadors. However, I have a question regarding parents. I have the impression that prevention at the level of parents is not necessarily going very well and that there is a gap in this area.

And my question is — as a health professional, I believe I have a responsibility in the prevention of parents — but my question is to know what is the role of the State in this prevention, what can parents do regarding the risks of social networks concerning our children, and how to organize this prevention?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, prevention is primarily about information for parents who are citizens. And then, it is about involving them much more in this work with the educational community, and therefore, the institution. It is true that we have left, as you mentioned, parents a bit alone in recent years, because this phenomenon has arrived quite quickly, at least developed. And I would say that since 2015, there has been a form of acceleration. This is roughly the period when all this spreads, democratizes, and when we have social networks entering our lives. It’s about that; it’s been about 10 years. And there is another acceleration, which is the Covid period, where in reality, we were all plunged into a form of solitude, that of confinement, of worry, and where screen time for adults as well as for young people increased significantly. These are the two dates for me, 2015-2020, which are turning points and which mean that things have changed quite a bit. Something has happened in our societies.

And since 2020, it is true that we have gone back as if nothing had happened. That’s partly why I wanted us to launch all this. We can see that we have indeed gone back off track. So, in parallel, we have tried to understand better. We have requested scientific reports and others that have been made public. And I asked for a report in 2022 from Mr. Bronner, who is a specialist in the subject, a very prominent sociologist who produced a report on, precisely, the lights in the digital age to show the impact it had on democratic functioning. And then, I received last year a report made by scientists, rather in different fields, on the impact of screens and social networks on our young people, what we called the Screen Commission, which was an important moment because that’s where there was a scientific convergence. There were many disagreements among specialists about the impact it had. And we have crossed a threshold because in recent months, there have been academics from all countries who have produced work. What can I tell you today to prepare parents and what are we going to launch? But these debates are part of it. These are prevention debates that we are also having.

The first thing is that we know that for a child under 3 years old, screens are harmful. We say that, and we all agree. Take the train tomorrow. Tell me if, in a TGV or a TER, you haven’t seen many parents, sometimes under the pressure of the collective, who do not put a screen in front of a 2-year-old child to calm them down. That is a disaster. We know that we must avoid, as much as possible, if we can, before 6 years old. We are reviewing this, even if France has done less to move it than many countries in Northern Europe; all-screen is pedagogically harmful. And it is clear that before 15-16 years old, social networks are not a good thing. Because both, we have not sufficiently consolidated things on an emotional, cognitive, and affective level. In fact, the brain is not finished, is not mature enough to be exposed to that. And we can document it quite easily; it is that this generation, unfortunately, to which we have given access to almost everything. We have seen a surge in online harassment that has reinforced physical harassment, but we have seen a surge in eating disorders. Many young girls are confronted with the vision of ideal bodies through these networks, etc., a surge in forms of violence or desocialization. We have far too many young people who, through social networks, access pornographic content. And so, we can fight every day to say: gender equality is key for us, respect for women, the fight against violence. We have more and more of our young people compared to our generations whose awakening, if I may say, to emotional and sentimental awareness is happening through networks and online pornography. We have a surge of loneliness and, fundamentally, a mental health problem among our young people. Even if we cannot really establish a cause-and-effect link, we clearly have a correlation link. And so, for me, the key to all this is that we must take these networks. So, 1) we need to have the school and early childhood much more with us. Now, it is done; these are the rules we are putting in place. That’s why we have removed mobile phones from middle schools now in all middle schools at the start of last year, and we will probably extend it to high schools at the start of next year with the minister. He is looking into that. And we are now warning, we are engaging with parents on these issues, in parent-teacher meetings, and we are going to launch a large national communication and prevention campaign aimed at parents. But parents, if we want to engage them, we need to be able to tell them what a scientific consensus is; that is what I am giving you, and we need to tell them, you have a role to play because we also give you a norm. And the last point, we may come back to it, but it is to say that before 15 years old, children should not be exposed to social networks. And so, we will prohibit social networks before 15 years old. For it to really work, parents need to play along. But we will give parents a norm. Until now, there hasn’t really been one because we know more today.

Speaker

It’s the digital majority that you are advocating for, right?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes. But I don’t know if there are any reader questions about that.

Speaker

Not exactly about that.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I can tell you in two words if you want me to elaborate. But I think that Mr.’s question was, in my opinion, also very important, because starting from prevention, everything we say only works if families get on board. Because we can say, we will ban screens before the age of 15, but families need to play along. So I think they will play along. Today, families have no standards. We haven’t told them anything; we’ve left them to fend for themselves. But gradually, it happened a few decades ago, we banned wine for minors. Sixty years ago, we served wine to kids. We banned it. There may still be people who serve beer to infants, but in my opinion, that is not the majority today in the country, because when we give a standard to families, they know it’s not good for their children, they won’t do it. Well, we must say that until now, we haven’t had a discourse that stated it was bad in itself. Now, we know it, we have established it, so we will say and we will enforce this rule. How are we going to implement it in law?

In two ways. First, we have — that’s why it took time after the screen commission — last summer, a few months ago, the European Commission, following our questions and requests, gave us guidelines for this famous directive on digital services, and it said: “yes, you have the option to request age verification.” This is exactly what we used on pornographic sites. To ban pornographic sites for those under 18, we imposed age verification. It was a big battle. Now, it’s done in France and in many European countries. It told us: “you can do it more broadly for social networks.” So we have that. It’s a European competence. Okay. And then it says: “it’s up to each state to define its digital majority.” So that will be a national law that will define the digital majority. We will propose 15 years. And we will be able to activate these technical means that exist to say: 15 years is the digital majority, so we ask your platforms, when people sign up, to verify the age by different techniques and to block access to your network for someone who is under 15. That’s how we will implement it. So that’s it. It’s a national law, to be very precise. So the timelines can be reasonable, because we have obtained what we want to obtain at the European level, which is mandatory verification.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President, hello everyone. I have been a sales teacher for just under 5 years. I work in different institutions to train a little over 50 young people each week. I have noticed in these different institutions that young people are really dependent first on their mobile phones, then on social networks since they use their mobile phones to access social networks. And unfortunately, in sales and commerce, we are obliged to use computers and phones to adapt to the evolution of sales methods in the market. In the school where I currently work, there is a system that has been put in place. It consists of collecting mobile phones to store them in a locked cabinet. But these young people still find a way to circumvent the system. We have young people who have two mobile phones, who use one and keep the second, others who discreetly put their phone case on and keep the phone, and others who make us believe they don’t have their phone, but it is well stored in a backpack. It’s difficult for us to search, since we are somewhat limited. We must respect our students. So, we can see a real dependency. So my question is: what educational and preventive strategy do you plan to implement to combat social media addiction among young people?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. What you describe, I believe many teachers have seen, and we see it, it relates to what I just mentioned. So, it creates an addiction, and we have, at the core, an attention crisis, which is terrible for learning and for living in society and interacting. What is this attention crisis due to? Many of these young people are on social networks, including at home. So they no longer read, they no longer focus on a text, etc. The average for these young people is 4 hours and 20 minutes a day on social networks. 4 hours and 20 minutes a day. And as a result, we have many young people, it happens, I’ve even seen some who explained this to me and what they experienced, well, they have become addicted, they are dependent. It’s like a drug, because of this algorithm phenomenon that I mentioned.

And so, you have young people who arrive exhausted in class and who, afterwards, indeed, need to be on their phones to check, exchange, go on social networks. But it’s really an attention crisis and therefore, of learning, of the possibility of learning. So, first thing, it’s prevention for families, for teachers. And the battle we are currently re-engaging, we have never given up, but moving forward, on reading, which is key, because it’s the absolute antidote. As I tell many of these young people, whether you go on social networks, but even more on AI, it’s a tribute to reading, artificial intelligence, because an artificial intelligence is just a supercomputer that has read a lot of books. So, rather than depending on it, read as many books as you can, it will make you smarter and more autonomous, and it will free you from this thing.

I close this parenthesis, there too. So, it’s prevention, it’s explaining, it’s accompanying them. It’s then making it clear that we are unhappy when we are in a state of dependency. Whatever it is, we are not well. And the third thing is the accompanying prohibition. And so the strategy is the prohibition of social networks before the age of 15. And we will prepare young people much better for this, which means that we will have, this is what we deeply believe, fewer addictive behaviors. Then the second thing is the assumed prohibition of mobile phones. I think your young people are mostly high school students, so mobile phones are not banned. So since it’s just the institution that does it, there is less consensus. We had done it in middle schools experimentally. We generalized it last September. The feedback we have, I speak under the control, if there are teachers here and from the education authorities, is that it works quite well, because since it’s a national prohibition, it’s assumed. So, there are various techniques, some have put lockers, some say it’s prohibited from bell to bell. But in any case, now we are installing it. No more mobile phones in middle school. You will have young people who, however, have been accustomed to something else. And starting next school year, we want to do more mobile phones in high school to really go to the end of this approach and say: this is not the place where you should do that, this is the place where you learn and then, this is the place where you interact. Because otherwise, I challenge you to go to a high school during recess. You can have young people, sometimes adults are not better. Look at public transport or elsewhere where heads are down at 2 meters. There is no more interaction, there is no more humanity. And so, I think it’s both prevention, support, and prohibition. And we will do it at the national level.

Speaker

I would like to respond to your measure that consists of banning social networks for those under 15. I think it might be a radical method that could have long-term consequences regarding what I perceive with young people. It could create frustration. Some might, for example, use circumventing methods to access these social networks. We see it, for example, with alcohol. The restriction has not prevented young people from being alcoholics, from consuming alcohol, minors. So, that means if we implement a radical measure for those under 15, they will certainly team up with young people over 16, 18 years old to access social networks. Is this radical measure effective? Wouldn’t it be a bit risky?

Emmanuel MACRON

But in reality, if I had social networks that cooperate, I could tell them, create content for young people. They do not cooperate. It’s not in their interest, they won’t do it. And it will take us years, and I think we won’t succeed. What you say is absolutely true. But first, the first virtue of the ban is to say: we know it’s bad. My responsibility is first to go all the way. We know it’s bad for a young person under 15. There are even scientists who say under 16. If I know it’s bad, am I well inspired to let it be? No. 2) I give a standard. So all the families who are ready, who say: “I’ve been told it’s bad, scientists say so, the French government, the French legislator says it’s bad, we are going to vote a law,” I can tell you that an overwhelming majority of families will say: “no, we will respect it.” And that’s absolutely true. There are still people who will try to circumvent it. But will that be the majority? No. And they will gradually reflect.

You made a very good comparison with alcohol. Today, how many 14-year-olds are alcoholics or drink? It’s very, very, very minority. It’s very small. Now, it’s young people who, sometimes, are left... Most of the time, young people who are in broken families, young people who are in very tough family situations. But honestly, I don’t know many families that make their children drink. I don’t know any. Before the age, there are some who may deviate, who start at 16 to let them taste this or that alcohol, or at family parties. But we all had it. Fifty years ago, when there was no prohibition that was passed, well, it started under Mendes, I can tell you it was very young. So it works. And I cannot, knowing this, having a consensus, say: we leave families without standards. So will it be 100% overnight? No, because we are not going to put social control behind each one. But finally, since there will be identity verification, an adult or a family member will have to open the account or the platform for the young person to access it. There will be some, you are right. But I still think we will have moved in the right direction and that we will have engaged as many young people as possible. As many. And from what we have done for alcohol as what we have done for tobacco, comparison is not reason, well, we must do it for networks. And it’s the same as what you said about alcohol. There are young people, very young sometimes, who smoke. And it’s prohibited. We make them understand. So, we will not go to zero. But I think it’s the most effective method if we consider, and that’s what scientists are now telling us, that it’s a real risk. And it’s an emotional, cognitive, and affective risk. That’s what we need to understand. That is to say, it changes the way of behaving with others, social networks. It changes the way of evolving in society. And it changes the way of learning and it damages it. So, for all these reasons, I really believe we need to do it.

Speaker

So, we had a final testimony from a teacher, you are 44 years old, you are a history-geography teacher in a rural college in Nord-Isère. You, the impact of screen overexposure that the President was talking about, you see it every day and you conducted an interesting exercise with your students to make them aware of it. Can you explain it to us?

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President of the Republic, and in any case, thank you for this very constructive exchange, where many topics have already been addressed. So I may sometimes revisit certain points that have been mentioned. My students spend an enormous amount of time on social media with the consequences we know, such as sleep disturbances and difficulties in concentration. It is true that with networks like TikTok, where videos scroll continuously, we notice in class that we need to vary activities very frequently. And then there are forms of cyberbullying, as Anna also mentioned. I conducted a small experiment in several classes by asking them to check the "Digital Well-being" setting on their phones and to note the time they spend online on social media. And this approach, as you said, averages 4 hours and 20 minutes, which led them to reflect on their excessive consumption of content, sometimes violent, discriminatory, or defamatory. They also became aware that they often place excessive trust in what they see, particularly in content generated by artificial intelligence, without having the necessary perspective to analyze it critically. In light of these observations, I believe it has become essential to strengthen training in AI, both for teachers and for society as a whole, as I see around us, in order to help our adolescents become informed citizens. At the same time, it would be wise to limit the use of AI in the school context to preserve our students' intellectual effort when everything is accessible with a click. I notice that I have quite a few colleagues, particularly in high school, who no longer assign homework because they feel they are correcting AI. And that indeed poses more and more problems. It calls into question our functioning, our ways of working, and evaluating. Could we consider a logo to signal the use of AI or conversely use AI to detect and limit inappropriate content and finally implement some form of parental control on the use of AI for our children? Thank you very much for your attention and thank you to all the readers present here.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. I think you have perfectly illustrated one of the preventive measures we discussed for young people, which is to show them the consequences and the time, I would say, wasted, stolen by social media when we raise their awareness. I would like to make two remarks regarding what you said. The first is that beyond everything I have said and what we have been discussing, the daily, excessive consumption of videos, whether on social media, on video game sites, or online video games, because it is a related phenomenon, and has massive links, desensitizes individuals to violence and excess. This is one of the problems we have for our democratic collective functioning. I would like to emphasize this point because we have discussed it less so far.

We talked about cognitive bubbles, we talked about interference. But as I told you, it drives a lot of negative emotions, a lot of violent content, it’s the videos you are exposed to on TikTok or elsewhere, and it disinhibits violence, including verbal violence. We can see that the structuring of our informational space by networks among young people, but even among the less young, has shifted our linguistic references towards much more excess or violence. In recent years, it has profoundly deviated. However, democracy only exists if there is respect that goes with it. But it desensitizes, especially the youngest, to violence and to the most brutal acts. I would like to link this to something we collectively experienced in the summer of 2023, the famous riots, after the death of young Nahel. These riots were carried out by very young people, in all the neighborhoods where it happened. Many people tried to explain it, and then the public debate somewhat lost interest in this subject. Some said: "they're all immigrants, so that's the problem, we told you so." Others said: "it's the opposite," and then we stopped there. It's a shame.

They were very young. 90% of them were children from single-parent families, in great difficulty, or children from child welfare services, thus isolated. But they had one characteristic: they were all overexposed. When we look at the testimonies, they organized themselves through social media to go to the sites and did things that were crazy, things we had hardly ever seen. They burned schools, gymnasiums, libraries, sports facilities made for them, because there is a form of derealization of violence that occurs through these networks. I say this just to add, so that we are fully aware of what is happening among the very young with these networks, especially when the family or parental structure is very weakened.

Now, to address your point and add on AI, yes, we need to consider two things regarding AI. First, to regulate its use and access. That’s why I was talking about AI agents. The dialogue we have started is, first of all, that they should be well identified, that they should be less, I don’t want to be technical, but anthropomorphic, meaning that these agents are emotionally too close to us. There are more and more people, and not just young people, who, when they go to their AI, feel like they are talking to a friend and make confidences to friends. That becomes dangerous. In any case, it’s a subject that needs to be better regulated. Then, the content that comes from AI needs to be better identified. This is a battle we are starting to wage at the European level for images as well as written content, to have them identified as AI. It’s a whole process that is beginning, but we are pursuing it at the European level to achieve this identification and separation.

Now, for our children, education and AI, I think of several things. First, we need to continue to maintain learning and sanctify it, and AI does not replace it. That’s why the in-class assignments remain a key element. In this regard, the continuous assessment we have implemented in high school, all these things, are good practices because it is not AI that can replace it. The second thing is that we need to prepare high school students to use AI, but to use it in a healthy way and not to depend on it. The third thing is that we have research programs with INRIA, the Collège de France, and others, on how to use AI for individual support. Because AI can be used for good things, it can help to learn and understand and have, in a way, a form of personalized tutoring. This can only be done under the supervision of the teacher, so to speak, and in symbiosis with the teacher and the parents. Today, we sometimes have abusive uses, but I think we would be wrong to stop assigning homework, and especially to do less in-class assignments, because there, AI cannot do it in place.

Moderator

Thank you. The fourth and final theme we will discuss is media education for all.

Speaker

Hello everyone. Mr. President, dear readers, within the EBRA group, media and information education is a priority. Today, Friday, the "Journalist for a Day" program, a major initiative run for over 30 years by Alsace and DNA, is concluding, involving over 600 high school students in just one week. A few days ago, a cross-border campus in four languages was held in Metz, organized by Le Républicain Lorrain, L'Est Républicain, and Vosges Matin. In both cases, the young participants were able to create journalistic content, through writing, images, and videos, and discover how reliable and verified information is constructed. Throughout the group, media education workshops are held for school audiences, young people, but also for older individuals.

And speaking of older individuals, she is part of that generation which we have documented as spreading fake news seven times more than those aged 18-25. She participated in a media education workshop that our titles offer, and she will share her experience with us. Anna, the floor is yours.

Speaker

I think I am the oldest in this assembly. My only merit is having participated in a training on fake news. It is very important because it was a sensitization aimed at seniors and it was very well received by everyone. Personally, what terrifies me the most is foreign interference and political disinformation. Because, in a way, I feel like the war has begun.

If I can say something that has nothing to do with the topic at hand: I wanted to tell you that the French are very worried and that it is urgent to reassure them and give them hope, as they are terribly lacking in it.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for participating in this training. What you said is very true; when we look at the accounts that spread the most false information, we find that they are mostly accounts of people over 60, who are the most sensitive. This is quite understandable, as it is a generation that was trained to read the press and therefore to believe what they read. It is somewhat unthinkable to think that we are in a jungle where anyone can write anything. It is a reality. As technology has changed very quickly and practices have changed with it, there is a form, if I may say so, of vulnerability to false information. Therefore, I believe that the programs you are leading are very important, and I thank you for that. There is a role for the National Education system, but there is also a role across all forms of education to train people in media literacy. It is a bit of preventive work, as we have discussed. The doctor mentioned it earlier with his scientific hat. But it is democratic prevention to fight against fake news.

The second remark, I do not want to use words that are too anxiety-inducing, but there is an informational war today being waged by foreign powers. I believe we need to be aware of that. Now, it is not just that; there are also dysfunctions in our own society that are at play. As we have been discussing, there are both. But it creates vulnerabilities that lead to this. On your last point, you know, I have been where I am for over eight years now, and I see our society evolving, what we can do, and how we can move forward. I have tried for eight years to do my best to ensure that our country progresses and that our Europe stands firm. We are in a moment that can disturb many people. We must simply try to set the game. I think we cannot reassure our fellow citizens in a somewhat naive or very simple way. I allow myself to say this. Because we are in a moment of great upheaval, and if I may say so, of uncertainty. What we are all experiencing is somewhat the experience that many certainties are collapsing. We need to try to take things one by one, which I am trying to do modestly, and to approach them with maximum will.

We need to maintain a bit of concern because some of it is legitimate. I do not want to reassure in a naive way or by taking the French people lightly, not in a serious manner. I think the concern you describe is primarily linked to the geopolitical situation, which is frightening. In the face of this, I have tried, I can tell you again here, to say: "we do not have to be excessively afraid. But there are risks that are present, geopolitical risks that have awakened. If we are honest, war has returned to European soil, and that is one of the great concerns we can have. I think since 2022, we are right to have that concern. Do I think tomorrow we will be attacked by Russia? No. But I think that first, there is an informational war, hybrid, as we say, but we must prepare ourselves. This risk exists, which can fuel concern, fear, which sometimes, when exaggerated, leads to saying, "the President is a warmonger," the right response is to say no. We must face this risk, we must prepare for it, and therefore be stronger. That is on the military side.

Then, I think we are a country, and that may reassure you, much stronger than we say every day. The message I would have is: let us not underestimate ourselves and let us not divide ourselves. Let us not underestimate ourselves because there are many challenges, many things we need to address. We see the difficulties due to the current political fragmentation. We are much stronger than we believe or than we tell ourselves. France is a great country. We are solid; we have solid infrastructures, solid institutions, a strong energy and economic force. We have some of the most robust public services in Europe. We must also look at this solidity, even if there are many things to improve.

The last message to reassure is to maintain unity. What I did yesterday with the announcement of the national service that we are resuming, what we want to do again with investment in our school, what we are doing now on social networks, which are a very great source of concern for people, because social networks worry people because they feed on them, and for all the reasons I have mentioned earlier, it fuels anxiety. By reclaiming and regaining control of these social networks, we can also help to reassure. My point is, let us prepare and be strong in geopolitical, military, and technological terms. Let us not be afraid, but let us prepare. That is how, by the way, we will overcome the fear that may exist or the anxiety. The second thing is, let us not underestimate ourselves. We have plenty of things to improve, plenty of things to do, but we are a very large country, we can move forward, and I say this for our youth. The third thing is, let us not divide ourselves. Let us continue to build the school, the national service, the reclaiming of the networks to remain a united country. These three messages are, I think, what can allow us to move forward. I hope so, in any case.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. There is an observation, which is that we still represent an older generation that had a desire, a thirst to seek information from newspapers in print. It was almost a need. The current generation, when we ask them in class, none, but really none, go to printed newspapers first. Eventually, when they are on weekends at their grandparents' house, about 20 to 30% of a class says: "Oh yes, we saw them at our grandparents'." Seeing them is not the same as practicing them. But we should not take anything away from them; they are indeed in need of information, they are very much in search of critiques, and they are extremely curious. It is not at all to criticize them. We observe that when we put them into action, when we break the fourth wall of the classroom like in theater, when they go into other situations, such as in the case of "Journalist for a Day," they are full of spirit and initiative.

The theme of this year was "Long Live Diversity." The students I was able to mentor last Tuesday, as part of this operation, produced very high-quality projects and articles. It is very rewarding to see what they are able to produce. I was also able to organize many meetings in situ at the high school with a number of witnesses, whether they are journalists, people from "Cartooning for Peace," or Holocaust survivors like Ginette KOLINKA. That is what remains for them. The program is essential, but it needs that extra step, that additional experience.

So, how can we increase more than what is currently possible, initiatives that will put them in contact with journalists, with the media? Who will show them that nothing is given, that everything comes from a long-term effort, from work that costs money? My second question is also that the brain takes about 25 years to develop. When we intervene in these young formative years in high school with screens, something is lost. Moreover, there is a recent study from MIT that states that the use of AI literally shuts down areas of the brain, and it takes 2 to 4 months of abandoning AI for it to reactivate. That shows the whole issue. My question regarding this brain development is, could we not consider abandoning digital textbooks before university? Could we also consider boosting the cultural pass again? I think of the possibility of subscribing to printed newspapers. When I surveyed the students, the only resources they could find in terms of newspapers were digital newspapers.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, media education, in any case, civic education, since that is also what we are talking about, is done by teachers, and this is where our school plays an essential role, and I thank you and express my gratitude for the enthusiasm you have for the role you play with your students. This extra step, in fact, is very dependent on the teachers. I also want to mention the commitment of our teachers to take students to see these experiences, that is, to see great witnesses of history, to go to a site to understand things, or to take that winding path that is what will remain. You are absolutely right.

So, first, it is to strengthen our school, strengthen our teachers, strengthen teacher training, which is, for me, the major project we must undertake in the time to come. Next, it is to provide the tools to teachers. I am a strong advocate of the cultural pass that allows for this, in connection with our booksellers and others, and it must absolutely be maintained. Third, it is indeed, in connection with what I mentioned, to maintain the culture of writing and written expression. And I think that... Well, I don't just think, it is rather scientifically proven that continuing to write by hand, continuing to read books, with the discursivity that it creates, awakens the mind and helps to maintain cognitive skills that are very important, and that the all-screen approach is not good. In reality, it is a question of balance. And that is the school's responsibility.

So, I noted the point about digital textbooks; I cannot answer you because I have not looked into this point, and I do not know if there is a consensus. I intuitively agree with you, but I do not want to say anything foolish. However, I think it is the right approach. So yes, we need to maintain in our school, if I may say so, a mixed model for as long as possible and therefore protect this relationship with the written word, with the physical. But I would like to make another point that is at least as important, it seems to me, in relation to the media and information, which is to make our young people understand, to encourage them to go towards press titles that are, by the way, physical, paper, because that is the distinction we just made, or digital, but already going to a site of a newspaper or a media outlet with journalists is not the same as going to such and such a site that is not familiar to you, that is not known, that is not recognized as a site of information for getting informed. And I think that is very important.

This connects with what you said at the beginning and which is a very delicate subject, which is that of a label and which is also a way to combat what you showed in your survey. Because you can be deceived, you can create a fake news site. And I believe we must be lucid; when we have a newspaper with an editorial team, there has been, since our 19th-century press laws, a responsibility of that editorial team. That is to say, the information that you are given to read, what you need to know from newspapers, there is someone who is responsible. So if it is false, if it undermines your dignity, if it is false information, we can ask for it to be corrected, we have a right of reply, and we can ask for it to be amended. We can even go to penalize, so go before the judge to punish the editorial team.

This is still the big difference with what we have been talking about all this time. A social network is not at all the case, and a fake news site is not the case. This foundation must be understood because it is a guarantee in itself that the people who work in a press title have an ethics code and must verify this information. This is what makes this information reliable, and therefore it has value. I think this needs to be educated, it needs to be transmitted, it needs to be reminded as well, because we tend to lose sight of it. But that is also why I believe it has a lot of value that the editorial teams themselves, in a way, strengthen this muscle.

What you have done, since you mentioned it earlier with the labeling that you adopted through the methodology that Reporters Without Borders had put in place, is also an important point of quality. Because if we leave the informational space in a completely undifferentiated manner, the reader is a bit lost, because they sometimes feel like they are in a newspaper. There, you guarantee that your journalists have an ethics code, a working methodology, and therefore will verify. I say this, it is important because it is not the state that should verify. If the state has to verify, it is no better than the system we live in today. Because then it becomes a dictatorship. But journalists must guarantee their readers that they have verified with an ethics code, of which they are the guarantors among themselves, and a methodology that is built among them and guaranteed by third parties, peers. That is very important, and I think it is key, and it is also important to distinguish between digital and physical.

Sophie GOURMELEN

Just to extend the question about the cultural pass, it is maintained, of course. The institutions are waiting to know more.

Emmanuel MACRON

You understood where I was coming from. The President of the Republic that I am, who wanted this cultural pass to be promoted, defended, I believe in it wholeheartedly, in its part. There is an individual part and a collective part that is in the hands of the teachers. You have a National Assembly that is fragmented, if I may say so, divided, that is in the process of building consensus. It is not me who is working on this matter. I would love for it to be able to produce a budget that preserves it, because I think it is a very good thing for our youth and for the teachers. There you go.

Moderator

Thank you. So, we will continue with the students from Dolmaire College, a college that is not unknown to you, since you visited it in 2018. It is an institution that places media and information education at the heart of its priorities. The students have been contributing for three years to a newspaper in partnership with our newspapers, but also with the Maison pour la Science de Lorraine and the Fondation La Main à la Patte, whose objective is to highlight scientific fields and initiatives. So, these students are with us, they are also accompanied by one of the teachers, and each has a question to ask you.

Speaker

Mr. President. I will build on the idea of raising the age for social media to 15 years. So my question is, would it be possible to block certain content that may be shocking rather than raising the age to 15 years?

Speaker

So hello Mr. President, how can we find true information on the Internet without being manipulated?

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. The students participated in a very nice activity in a laboratory with four researchers where the objective was to form teams on different but related subjects in order to try to find the truth about a local problem. This problem was a pollution issue, the one we chose. Artificial intelligence consumes energy, consumes electricity, and consumes water. And this artificial intelligence, we use it very often without our knowledge or when we want to. Hence my question. How to reconcile the apparent ease of artificial intelligences and their growing environmental impact in our daily uses?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. So, regarding your first question, it is actually quite difficult and not very effective to remove content because we do not have many means on social networks to do so.

Today, every day, we try to have content removed. We have achieved high struggles to remove terrorist content. And it is applied by some platforms; unfortunately, there are still some that do not comply. Normally, they are not allowed to post content that is racist or anti-Semitic. And we can activate a platform called Pharos to have such content removed when it appears. It is very hard, very slow, and it is not always done because, in fact, the platforms do not moderate, as we say. That is, they do not allocate enough resources to do so. And so, we have tried all these last years; I have been bringing all these social networks, these platforms together at least once a year for eight years to go in the direction of what you were saying. I have never obtained credible results, and they are rather going in the opposite direction today. So, in fact, it is not effective. We will not succeed. It is not efficient to simply remove content. That is the first point.

The second point is that, in fact, the scientific consensus is rather to say that beyond certain content, it is the very fact of spending so much time in front of a screen and on these networks that is not good before the age of 15. It is the dependency that it creates. It is the very mechanism of dependency that is linked to these famous algorithms that I have been talking about for a while, what will be pushed. And even if it were just videos of kittens or whatever, it is not great to spend 4 hours and 20 minutes watching kitten videos. You see? It is not very good for emotional and cognitive development. So it is not just a question of content. In reality, until the age of 15, we should try much more to be in human relationships that create kindness. It is the face of the other, the gaze of the other, the real world. Because I have not consolidated my relationship with reality and I cannot spend too much time in a world that is actually a somewhat unreal world, that of videos or messages. You see, I have somewhat answered the question, but it is better to go in that direction. It may seem like a very important effort, but I do not believe so, because all the generations that lived without it did not live in misery. And so, it will just change things a bit, but I think for the better, and it will also teach them to use it.

Then, in fact, it is what we wrote about how to have true information and not be manipulated. First of all, I would not want you to enter a world of absolute distrust. If I tell you something, normally, I do not do it to lie to you, and you do not do it with me either. So that is super important. We are in a society where we seek to have trust. What is true is that in the jungle, in the vastness of the Internet, you are not always sure. When you do not know people, you do not know. So the best thing is to go to sites dedicated to information to inform yourself and therefore to look for press titles, local or national newspapers, or specialized ones, but which are made by people whose job it is to inform. That is how you have a guarantee, as we said, because you have behind that not people like us, if I may say, except for a few exceptions in this room, that is to say people who will have an opinion or who will give their view of the world, even if perhaps we are right or wrong, or perhaps it is true, but you have the guarantee of having information that is made by journalists. That is to say, people whose job it is, who have been trained for that, and who have an ethics, who have therefore verified this information. So it is about going to true and known information sites.

And then on your question, professor, which is in another field which is artificial intelligence, I would first not want to give the impression that we should be technophobic. Social networks, artificial intelligence, technological innovations, it is a wonderful thing. Simply, I say it, recalling our old masters: "Science without conscience is but the ruin of man." So what we have been saying for a while is simply our old precepts of Renaissance humanism, innovation is great, science and its innovations are great, but we must bring consciousness back to it, so put it at the service of humanity. But it is therefore a very good thing to have AI. AI, we use it everywhere. What is artificial intelligence? It is a learning machine with enormous computing capabilities. And so, we must not be mistaken, we are talking a lot about it because we have a learning machine that does language. This is what we call generative AI. The Chat, ChatGPT, etc.

But you are actually using artificial intelligence all the time. As soon as you navigate a search engine, as soon as you use something that guides you in your car, etc. It is true that it consumes. And so, there are two answers to that, it is to have the models that are the most sober, and that is everything we are trying to develop in our artificial intelligence strategy. If Mistral and its model called Le Chat is better in our eyes than the others, it is primarily because it is European, that is true, and French, but it is also because it is more sober, that is to say it uses fewer computing capabilities to do its work. And so, there is a possibility of doing the same thing without sending nets everywhere. So sobriety.

And two, it is to produce the most decarbonized energy to serve it. And that is what, for once, France has a huge advantage. That is why I think we are made to be a great nation of AI because we have researchers and companies that develop much more sober models than the super large Anglo-Saxon massive computing models, and that we, unlike the United States, produce the most decarbonized and controllable electricity in Europe, because we have nuclear, renewable, and energy sobriety. We have a large installed base of nuclear.

Host

To conclude, I propose that we exchange with three high school students. They are all engaged, elected, within the Student Life Council of the Vuillaume high school, not far from here.

Speaker

Mr. President. My question today is how can we ensure that victims of cyberbullying are better supported, whether legally or psychologically, when we see that there are fewer and fewer resources in public health and that, above all, financially, it poses many problems for many families.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, so first, we must be careful, whatever the debates we hear. There is not less money in public health. There has been massive investment. The budgets, even if there are disagreements, people are debating in the Assembly right now. It is about the nature of the increase. But the health budget is increasing. And by the way, there is no scenario where it can decrease, because we have an aging population. But some want it to increase more, others less, others this or that. But it is increasing. And I had made decisions before Covid, I made some at the exit of Covid with what we called "the Ségur," of even historic increases in remuneration. I say this, we must be careful, because we are not a country that reduces health or education spending. These are items that are increasing. That is one point.

Then, cyberbullying relates to the discussion we had earlier. It is, 1) we must be much stronger on prevention, what we do at school and with families. 2) we have improved things on the response, so the repression, the penal, the distancing of those who harass. 3) we will continue the support. And that is the message that is also sent to the rectorate, with the educational community, and the teachers do a very big job to support families and students who have suffered this, because we want to keep students in the school where they suffered it, but rather distance those who harass. And it is an investment we are making in mental health and support for young people. So we will not lower the flag on that. And I hope that the debates that will follow will allow us to safeguard these resources.

Speaker

So the parents of these victims and these victims can hope to find perhaps a greater diversity of solutions to their problems, to this violence that we find on social networks?

Emmanuel MACRON

So that is a broader question that is a bit what we have been talking about for a while. I think the right answer is to somehow bring back discipline, calm, respect, and kindness in social networks. That is why we must first protect the youngest. We must, at school, put kindness back at the heart of the mission. That is everything we have done in recent years, especially with the youngest. The learning of kindness, which is a key element, and to have a society collectively that calms down, I hope. The answer is not one-sided and it is not solely in my hands.

Speaker

You are currently addressing the issues related to the use of social networks from a perspective of prohibiting access for those under 15. Do you not think it would be more relevant, on the contrary, to educate from a young age about free will and the reasoned and responsible use of digital tools?

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. We are all aware of the importance of algorithms in accessing digital content. How do you plan to legally compel platforms to modify their algorithms in a more virtuous way, but also to establish advanced control over the content circulating on networks?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I was going to say on the first question, in accordance with my usual practice, I would say at the same time. No, I will not oppose them. In reality, we now know that education about free will, etc., is not sufficient. It relates to what I was saying. First, overexposure to networks, to screens, is bad, and not just when you are exposed to bad information. It is bad by the time it takes from you, by the time taken away from sports, reading, social life, if I may say, thank you. And so, it is not just the ability to protect oneself from false information, it is much broader. Then, the brain is not ready for that at that age. There is now an increasingly strong consensus. It awakens disorders earlier, it is bad.

So, it is not just the teaching of free will that can lead me to say that it should be left open. It is a scientific consensus and an experience we have had in recent years that leads me to tell you: until the age of 15, it is not a good thing. It is better to cool down, to be less on screens, technology, but you must be taught to use it. And where you are absolutely right is that at the same time we must do both. It is not because we prohibit it that we should leave you in complete fog, it is that we must teach you to use these instruments, we must awaken you to the wonderful opportunities and the risks that may exist, and equip you with your free will.

After that, simply, we are talking about 15 years, and I want to put things in order, that is to say that I sometimes hear, in the public debate, free will, critical spirit, it is very important, but it is at a certain age. We must first teach and transmit solid knowledge. And in reality, in this world, and this relates to the question about the concern of Madame earlier, the world worries us.

I have tried to provide some answers on a human scale, but it also worries us because we feel that there is nothing certain anymore. Everything is kind of disintegrating. And so, we also need, for the youngest, to say that we must transmit knowledge and certainties, that is to say robust and solid things. And we can navigate the world, we can start to doubt, to have a critical and free spirit, when we have a solid base of knowledge. And that is very important, including for everyone's well-being. Because if we live in permanent doubt and fog, we cannot be happy, we cannot be stable. And so, school is primarily about transmitting knowledge, knowledge. It is the role of society towards the youngest. It is then to learn to doubt intelligently.

The critical spirit, but it requires a certain age. I learned Descartes, but I first knew how to count. He taught me to doubt about two and two, but I had first learned the multiplication tables well. So, I am not in a society where we must doubt everything before having learned the beginning of an idea. So, we must transmit knowledge, free will, critical spirit, and protection against social networks to save you time. Ultimately, time for self-construction until the age of 15, and then to have the right practice.

On algorithms, it is quite difficult to ask them to evolve in the right direction because we do not know how they work today, it is a black box. So, what we must ask these social networks is transparency about their algorithms, and then to be in a dialogue. So either it is absolute transparency, that is to say you make them public to everyone, which is the simplest, or it is at least transparency towards regulators who can look and at that moment give directions saying: you must correct this or that, you have a problem. Today, we can only do tests of proper functioning or malfunctioning of algorithms. What I said earlier about TikTok is an empirical test, but we do not have a view of the algorithm. So I want to fight for us to have algorithm transparency, which is the only thing that will ensure that it is sincere, either public or to the regulators of these platforms.

Host

Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you to our witnesses, our middle school students, our high school students, and our journalists, whom we can also applaud, please. And I will give the floor to Madam President Sophie GOURMELEN to close this face-to-face with the President of the Republic.

Sophie GOURMELEN

Thank you for the quality of the exchanges and thank you for the testimonies that were sometimes extremely moving, very intimate. And I believe that no platform would have been capable of conducting this debate like the one that took place today. So, thank you also to the journalists who prepared this interview and who ensured that what you heard, Mr. President, were statements that are precise, clear, detailed, and that allowed you to have an understanding of the concerns of the French people, at least of our readers.

We see how important newspapers are, and I hope that the people in this room today will continue to read us for a long time, to buy us as well. And it is true that for us, as a press group, the ecosystem in which we operate, with platforms that plunder our content and increasingly use false information, as you yourself mentioned, to attract more and more users, destroys value, and the value of our content today is becoming less and less significant. We can no longer charge, at least among young people, for information. It is very difficult, but we have a lot of creativity, a lot of desire, and we believe in it a lot.

So, with all the titles of the EBRA group, we will strive to ensure that newspapers last for a long time and that we can, like today, continue to hold debates of this quality. In any case, thank you for your presence.

Moderator

Thank you, Madam President, Sophie GOURMELEN, and Mr. President of the Republic. We will let you conclude this morning's session Face aux lecteurs of the EBRA group.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, thank you again to the EBRA group, Madam President, for the welcome, and thank you to the editorial teams that have been mobilized, to the journalists who prepared and facilitated these debates, and to all of you, Ladies and Gentlemen, who took the time to come and exchange. I hope this has shed light on some aspects or at least made you think. I have also taken note of many ideas, comments, questions, or suggestions that have been made.

But fundamentally, what we did this morning, well, the practice, I would say, regardless of the subject or the content, illustrates the importance of deliberation. And it is not the same as exchanging opinions on a platform that quickly turns into invective. And so we can clearly see the importance, fundamentally, for a democracy to function; it needs reliable and clear information, and therefore it needs a free, independent, and professional press. It needs moments of deliberation. They are organized by the press, they are held in our towns and villages, they must be at the national level, and it is a collective effort that is important to manage our agreements and disagreements, but to ensure that we have common ground.

And I would like to just conclude with this point. I think we are in a generational society that has tremendous opportunities. We must not be mistaken. I would not want you to leave with a catastrophic view of the world we live in. It is a moment of technological acceleration that holds unprecedented opportunities, and we want to seize them in health, in energy, etc. And we have a chance to be connected with knowledge, with the ends of the world, and to accelerate, to have absolutely unprecedented scientific breakthroughs. Simply, we need to regain control for our democratic life and for our children. And I believe that is the work we have to do, which is a work of balance and, fundamentally, of collective consciousness. And we must do it to prevent our society from going a bit in all directions. That is to say, to turn inward, which is what worries me most in this moment of tremendous opportunities, is that there is a growing solitude in our society and a decrease in the ability to discuss. And it is somewhat related to the subject we have been discussing for some time.

And so, if we want to restore common ground, we need to find the ways and means to do so and therefore regain control of these technological instruments to ensure that they are at our service, but that they do not mutate, if I may say so, our way of being together and being a strong democracy, and that they do not provide unprecedented opportunities to adversaries or enemies who would want to bring us down. But all this just means regaining control of our democratic life and our lives. It is possible if we have collective consciousness and if we decide to do so. I believe that is the work we must do, and it is important. It is important for the independence of the nation and it is important for the well-being of our democracy and for the well-being of our youth. So, it is a tremendous mission, but we can only meet it together. That is what I believe, and that is a bit of what we did collectively this morning. And so behind that, to give you transparency, I will finish these debates in the regions. There will come a time when I will report at the national level. And then, we will likely draft national legislation, so quite soon, in the first quarter of 2026, we will launch them.

And then, we will launch a series of European initiatives; they always take a bit longer, but at the same time, to try to get the maximum feedback in the year 2026 in particular, because on issues of interference or others, we have some upcoming deadlines where we need to be even better equipped. And there you go, so you understand the progress and to say that everything we discussed this morning will also lead to a decision-making and action agenda. Thank you very much, in any case, to all of you.

Moderator

We thank you, Mr. President of the Republic. Let us once again applaud, please, Ladies and Gentlemen, and who will have to leave us now in a few moments. Mr. President, whom we can thank once again and applaud warmly, please.