PRESS CONFERENCE – EUROPEAN COUNCIL

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 October 2019 · European Council press conference

Context
Macron held a press conference at the October 2019 European Council summit, reporting on Brexit developments and the EU's five-year strategic agenda.
Main themes
Brexit agreement, European Council summit, future of EU27, European Commission strategic agenda, climate ambition, EU budget negotiations, European sovereignty, EU solidarity, common agricultural policy, migration policy, internal market protection, Ireland stability
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,836
73rd percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 34%33%
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

136 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Hello everyone.

I would like to report on this Council before answering your questions. We held a European Council marked by two main topics.

The first was obviously the question of Brexit.

Boris JOHNSON, Michel BARNIER, and Jean-Claude JUNCKER presented the agreement reached in recent hours. As you know, we had set, at the request of France in particular, a deadline of October 31 to finalize discussions and find an agreement both on the terms of withdrawal and the political declaration on future relations.

This agreement, after several weeks of additional discussions, has been found.

It is a good agreement, respectful of the framework we had set and our principles, which were, for us, both the preservation of the internal market and the stability of Ireland. The political declaration that outlines the main lines of our future relationship also guarantees a clear framework, a free trade agreement that will need to be negotiated in detail, and commitments to fair competition, which will be the condition for access to our market.

From now on, it is necessary to proceed with the vote on this agreement in the British Parliament on Saturday, with readings then taking place on Monday and Tuesday, and in the European Parliament at the beginning of next week, and it is only after these parliamentary expressions that we can consider this agreement as final.

In any case, I hope that we can meet the deadlines we have set for ourselves, and that the date of October 31 will be respected.

I want to commend the work of our negotiator Michel BARNIER and his team, and also acknowledge the commitment of Jean-Claude JUNCKER. They have defended, for many months in unity, both firmly and kindly towards an allied and friendly country, the interests of the European Union. I believe that what we have managed to achieve and the method that has been maintained, including in these last days, was extremely important, which was that of this constant unity.

The second major series of topics we discussed at this Council is, in a way, our future as 27.

This was the meaning of the presence of the elected President of the European Commission Ursula VON DER LEYEN throughout this European Council.

This was the subject of our discussion this morning on the strategic agenda for the next five years in which we fully find ourselves, as I had the opportunity to say, and whose most structuring themes correspond to those we have championed:

the climate ambition first, with carbon neutrality, the definition of a carbon tax at the borders, a climate bank; the definition of an economic and social model that involves defending unemployment insurance within the eurozone, a minimum wage for European countries; but also a more sovereign Europe with a defense, security, asylum, and migration policy, finally renovated, more effective, and responsive to contemporary challenges.

I will not go into detail on this agenda. It has led to an expression from the Council. It was mainly presented by the President during her speech before Parliament, and widely detailed. And it has our full support. In connection with this political project, it was also the meaning of our exchange on the future European budget. On this point, it must be noted that consensus was not reached. This is normal. It was the first discussion, and we were getting into some detail. But on this, France defended, if I may say so, a coherent ambition. First, the one that consists of not opposing new policies, which would be our objectives in terms of migration, defense, space, artificial intelligence where we need to invest, to meet the objectives we have set for ourselves as well as to prepare for the future, with the so-called traditional policies, such as agricultural policy or cohesion policy. It seems to me that we must, on the contrary, combine solidarity and responsibility, and succeed, fundamentally, through this budget and the objectives we will set for ourselves, to be consistent with the ambition we have set for ourselves that Parliament validated with the election of Ursula VON DER LEYEN, which is that of a geopolitical Commission.

What does a geopolitical Commission mean? After a Commission, it must be recognized, political for the next five years. It means that we are not a loose politico-economic space that has little ambition and solidarity. On the contrary, for me, there are two pillars.

You have heard me defend for several years on the one hand a pillar of sovereignty, on the other hand a pillar of solidarity. Defending our sovereignty means being able to choose our future.

And for that, we need to invest in the common agricultural policy, because it is the key to our food sovereignty. Our citizens want to choose their food. They want us to produce in Europe. They want to be sovereign on this point. Investing in our migration policy, in our digital policy, in our environmental policy, these are policies of sovereignty. It is about choosing our future, shaping our future, and deciding that we are neither vassals of China nor of the United States of America. We need to invest for that, just as these two great powers invest. And on our side, we are a space where there are divergences, differences on the economic and social level that need to be helped to catch up. This is the objective of what is classically called convergence policies, that is to say, true solidarity. And I like this term solidarity, because it is not a mechanical convergence. It is the idea of saying "we must help some to catch up but they must also engage in this effort of convergence." These funds should not be used to finance either social dumping, or fiscal dumping, or the unraveling of the rule of law. And that is why I am also attached to the idea of conditionality in this framework.

I have also defended two other things: the end of rebates.

The rebate was British. From the moment the member state that had made it a condition of its participation leaves, the rebate goes away. We need to put an end to this element, which is an element of opacity, of destruction of the European budget. A budget that multiplies rebates is a budget where everyone looks at the share that comes back to them after what they have put in, that is to say, anything but a budget. And then the idea of having more own resources.

Indeed, we need more ambition.

Everyone is also keen to keep some budgetary limits within themselves. And so, we have defended the idea of moving towards new own resources: the carbon tax at the borders, tax on non-recyclable plastic, other elements of taxation that we could put together, such as the digital tax and others. On this point, I believe that we must also show ambition. In any case, we cannot validate an ambitious project, an ambitious Commission, if we do not have behind it a budget that is equally ambitious, and gives us the means to succeed. We wished on this basis that the future President of the European Council, Charles Michel, could continue discussions and carry them out to have, there too, a coherent multiannual budget that can be decided as quickly as possible so as not to lose time and opportunities, because the ability to decide quickly is important.

At dinner last night, we had several discussions on, I would say particularly, two types of subjects. First, on Turkey.

On Turkey, we had a discussion first about our own sovereignty.

We reaffirmed our solidarity towards Cyprus, the respect for the exclusive economic zone of Cyprus, and clearly condemned the incursions and provocations that have been repeatedly made by Turkey. And of course, we also took a common position, condemning the offensive in North East Syria, deciding to suspend our arms exports to Turkey. We will continue to coordinate very closely through our foreign ministers. But we also decided with Prime Minister JOHNSON, Chancellor MERKEL, to be able, in the coming weeks, to see President ERDOGAN, probably in London. We did this in this framework as three Europeans, which is also an element to restore coherence to what NATO can and must be in the moment we are living, since, I remind anyone who may have forgotten, which is not totally illegitimate in the period, Turkey is a member of NATO, which should also normally lead to certain forms of solidarity. And so, we will have this joint initiative while continuing to coordinate on the contacts we will have in the coming days with Presidents ERDOGAN, PUTIN, TRUMP in particular. I could come back to this subject in the context of questions.

We also had a long debate on enlargement last night and I believe that we must, on this important subject, also keep a spirit of seriousness and moderation.

I believe, I have said several times, in a strong Europe, a sovereign Europe. But I also believe in a Europe that is coherent and responsible.

The countries of the Balkans, including North Macedonia and Albania, are making important reforms, sometimes undergoing profound transformations with a lot of courage. I want to commend here the courage, in particular of Zoran ZAEV who made the constitutional changes, and a name change that was extremely difficult to achieve, and which was part of the demands. But very clearly, several countries were reluctant to open negotiations today. France was among these countries very clearly, not to say that efforts have not been made, that progress is not there. But to say first, all the requested progress is not there and we still have problems. There too, I could come back, inconsistencies, situations that are not controlled with some of these countries on the migratory level among others, and on the respect of all the rules. But above all, I would say more deeply, the discussion for me yesterday was extremely instructive on the vision that each and everyone can have of Europe.

First, I do not consider that the only relationship we should have with our neighborhood is a relationship of expansion or enlargement.

We would be the only power in the world that considers that the neighborhood policy is to propose membership. We have collectively subscribed to this spirit, which is strange. It is strange, it does not work very well at 28, it will not work very well at 27. I am not sure it will work much better when we have expanded.

I repeat: before any effective enlargement - here, it is only a matter of starting negotiations, let us be realistic - but before any effective enlargement, let us know how to reform ourselves. And to those who tell me you will simply open the door to a start of negotiation, it will take 10 years, 15 years. First, I tell them it is not a good method because we are told "if you do not open today but next month you will despair those who have made efforts." Do you think that in 5 years, we will not say that we are despairing them by not opening right away? This time, membership and no longer negotiation. But above all, I look today at our pace of progress in Europe. We experienced a crisis in 2008. If I follow, unfortunately, the decisions currently made within the European Union and the eurozone, we will have finalized a true banking union by 2028. There you go, when we have a potentially deadly crisis, it takes 20 years to reform ourselves. That is our functioning today. So, if there is not a moment of collective awakening, we cannot let in, even in five or ten years, other members. We are not at the right pace. And so we must first and foremost question ourselves about that. And I will not yield on this ambition. And I think that if we validate in particular the agenda of the European Commission, then we can question ourselves, there, I am speaking more for future memberships, about this process.

Next, the second element, the nature of the enlargement process no longer seems appropriate to me. First of all, because it is fundamentally very bureaucratic. The political agreement is at the beginning and at the end; it no longer speaks to the peoples. I invite you to look at the situation of the countries that have started discussions on enlargement. The thread is then quickly lost. And those who say that if we do not open negotiations, you will see China, Russia, and Turkey gain influence, I invite them to go to the countries where negotiations have been opened. It is not just the large towers with French, German, and Italian industrialists that are being built. This influence is present in the region. I believe rather that we are not investing enough, we, in a coordinated manner. This is not a process of enlargement; it is a choice of investment in economic, educational, linguistic, and cultural matters in these countries. It is a strategic agenda that we need to have with partners, not necessarily future members. And then, above all, this enlargement agenda is no longer suitable. It is not sufficiently differentiable and differentiated. It is not political enough, and at certain moments in the process, it must be clearly reversible for me. Otherwise, it is not credible.

And so I wish, before we open to new member states, that we carry out this reform that has been requested for years by several member states.

I say this because otherwise, the day we start negotiations with the current procedure, we will be told, "it would not be correct to change the rules of the game, since we have started discussing together." Here are some of the points. I could return to them in the context of your questions, but I believe that if we truly want to be a power, to be consistent with our ambitions, to be respectful also to those who want to turn towards Europe, we need to have a reformed union, a redefined enlargement process, real credibility, and a strategic thought about who we are, our role, and the region. Here are the few points I wanted to make, which led – at one point, we tried to find a consensus – rather to postpone decisions on these points before the Zagreb summit. And finally, two last points that I want to mention here before answering your questions.

This morning, I held a working breakfast with President VON DER LEYEN, Angela MERKEL, and representatives of the three major political families to discuss the establishment of the new Commission.

This strategic agenda and the work of the European Parliament. This agreement in the Council, in the European Parliament, among the political families that have managed to come to an agreement to form the new team for Europe, and who will constitute the majority of action, of implementation of the political program I mentioned, is essential in my eyes. That is why I wanted us to meet in this format. In this same spirit, President VON DER LEYEN will exchange with the leaders of the political groups in the European Parliament at the beginning of next week.

We need to truly build a pact of responsibility, majority, and ambition together.

Finally, the last remark I wanted to make here was to pay tribute to the work, to the European commitment of Jean-Claude JUNCKER.

First, we paid long tribute to him at the end of the morning, and he was a Commission president who advanced it, who made it more political, as I said, but who, on issues of defending strategic interests, defense, and more broadly on the agenda I have returned to several times, advanced Europe, but who, above all, for decades as Minister of Finance, as Prime Minister of his country, was entirely devoted to the European cause. This was his last Council, and I want to pay tribute to him both for the work done in this capacity and for his entire career dedicated to the cause of our Europe.

President Donald TUSK is also completing his term, and we have also paid tribute to him.

I want to say here how, as the second president of this Council, he also played an important role after having held the highest offices in his country. I do not know what the future holds for him and what he will want to do, but I wanted to pay tribute to his spirit of consensus, his willingness to build consensus and agreements in sometimes difficult moments. And I hope that the votes I mentioned on Brexit will be able to complete a work to which he has also largely contributed through his commitment.

I also want to pay tribute to the work of Federica MOGHERINI, who continued, where she was, this work of external policy of Europe over the past few years.

I will now answer your questions.