PRESS CONFERENCE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC AND THE PRIME MINISTER OF IRELAND

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

26 August 2021 · Press conference of the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister of Ireland · Government Buildings, Dublin, Ireland

Context
Macron held a joint press conference with Irish Taoiseach Micheál Martin during a state visit to Dublin on August 26, 2021.
Main themes
Franco-Irish bilateral relations, European Union cooperation, Afghanistan crisis, COVID-19 recovery, climate change and COP26, Brexit and Northern Ireland protocol, French presidency of the EU, Franco-Irish action plan, cultural and historical ties, economic recovery, digital and climate transformation
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
6,014
94th percentile
Sentences
302
95th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

302 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Micheál MARTIN

First of all, I would like to say that I am truly very happy today to welcome President Emmanuel MACRON to Dublin. His visit and our exchange this afternoon attest to the warm friendship and close cooperation between Ireland and France. It is a great pleasure to welcome you, President MACRON, to this place, Government Buildings, today. A busy day, cultural and economic, awaits us in addition to the meeting we just held and the meeting this morning with President HIGGINS. I hope you will leave Dublin with beautiful memories, and we are very grateful for the lovely weather you have brought us as well. We are truly thankful for that, and allow me also to warmly greet the delegation accompanying the President, Ministers Monsieur LE DRIAN, LE MAIRE, BEAUNE, Senator CONWAY-MOURET, and Deputy HOLROYD. You are all very welcome.

France and Ireland are bound by an ancient and deep friendship. It is a friendship that has existed and evolved for centuries, from the refuge granted by Ireland to the French Huguenots, to that offered to the Wild Geese by France, through the inspiration drawn from the French Revolution by Irish Republicans, or the rich cultural ties, particularly in the field of literature, that we will celebrate today. It is also nearly five decades of close partnership within the European Union. Ireland and France have always stood together. The ties that bind us are deep and have never been stronger. I am proud, Mr. President, to have the opportunity to celebrate them with you today. We just had a very useful and warm meeting. We discussed the excellent relations that exist between our two countries, and we look forward to deepening them further in the months and years to come. We warmly welcome the Franco-Irish action plan signed today by Ministers CONWAY and LE DRIAN, which outlines an ambitious program of cooperation across a wide range of areas. We have much to gain by intensifying our joint work. And I particularly commend the commitment to strengthen cooperation in the fields of education and research, as well as the promotion of the French language here and Irish studies in France.

The President's visit comes at an important time for our two countries, for the European Union, and for the world. We discussed some of the most pressing issues facing the European Union and international challenges during our meeting today. Naturally, the extremely difficult and worrying situation in Afghanistan was very much on our minds. France has been very present alongside us in supporting our efforts to ensure the safe return of Irish citizens and their families by mobilizing, I apologize, our team on the ground at Kabul airport. Mr. President, your assistance has been invaluable to us. Thank you very much.

We also discussed COVID-19, which remains a challenge in both our countries. As we emerge from the pandemic, ensuring a strong and socially just economic recovery will be a priority for the European Union, particularly during the French presidency of the Union in the first half of next year. We discussed the need to make the most of the new and historic European recovery program “Next Generation” to enable the digital and climate transformations on which our future well-being and prosperity depend. The recovery must be robust, inclusive, and above all sustainable. As the recent IPCC report clearly establishes, climate change is already a reality in all regions of the world. But the report also highlights that the capacity to change the course of events through decisive action is now in our hands, and that is the message we will carry to COP 26 in Glasgow in November. The European Union must continue to demonstrate global leadership in the field of climate. We also discussed the European Union's relations with the United Kingdom. It is in everyone's interest to pursue a positive and constructive partnership. But this partnership will only materialize with relationships built on trust and the willingness to respect commitments made. The European Union is demonstrating commitment, patience, and creativity in the work of implementing the withdrawal agreement and the protocol. With the right political will, I am convinced that it is possible to find wise solutions to some of the outstanding issues within the framework of the protocol. The President and I fully support the European Union team and the positive approach it is taking to advance this work.

Clearly, following Brexit, France now represents Ireland's closest neighbor in the European Union. There are new opportunities available to us, to our citizens, and our businesses in this new context. We are already seeing more Irish exports being routed directly to other countries in the European Union via French ports. We look forward to the Celtic Interconnector, which will ensure the first direct electricity transfer connection between Ireland and the continent. And we also eagerly await the return of French tourists and students to Ireland as we return to normal. With a strong common past behind us, we now face the future together. And so, President MACRON, Emmanuel, I would like to thank you again for your visit to Ireland, and I wish you every success for the remainder of your visit as well as for the upcoming French presidency of the European Union. Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Mr. Prime Minister, dear Micheál. Thank you for this warm welcome and for our joint work, not only today but over the past months. I would like to thank you on behalf of my entire delegation. Thank you very much, Mr. Prime Minister, dear Taoiseach, for this welcome and the exchanges we have just had. This morning, I had the pleasure of speaking with President HIGGINS, discussing contemporary Ireland, and also with several intellectuals and academics. I would like to warmly thank him for this welcome.

The Taoiseach has just reported on our exchange and all the topics we covered. The first, perhaps the most pressing of them, the one I would like to start with, is obviously the question of Afghanistan. At this very moment, the situation has profoundly deteriorated around the military airport; I want to once again commend the commitment of our teams who are doing everything possible to carry out the work we have committed to, that of international solidarity, humanitarian law, and the protection of our citizens, the citizens of all friendly countries, but also of all Afghans who must be protected because of who they are or the struggles they are engaged in. For several days, France, along with other allies, has been doing everything possible in this situation. We will continue to do so as long as the conditions are met at the airport site. As I speak to you, we are facing this extremely tense situation which obviously leads us to coordinate with our American allies, but we call on everyone to exercise the utmost caution in a context that we do not control, as we know. Nevertheless, I want to reiterate that it is France's honor, from the beginning, to carry out these evacuations, to protect, and we will continue to do so.

The last hours have been extremely difficult, and I have a thought for our teams, a thought also for all the families and for all those who are trying to protect their lives and leave the country, even as several explosions have occurred near the airport in the last minutes and hours. On the subject of Afghanistan, we obviously have very close coordination, we have humanitarian operations on the ground, and we have been able to carry out operations that have allowed the return of Irish citizens. We have close cooperation to manage the issues that will arise, particularly migration or security issues. And we have close cooperation within the United Nations Security Council, as we will need to define in the coming days and weeks, obviously, the mandate of the United Nations in the new Afghan context, and our two countries in this forum will have close coordination.

Beyond the Afghan question, which will require all Europeans to deeply draw geopolitical conclusions from this situation and to strengthen this strategic autonomy that has become existential for Europe, we discussed several major European files of the moment. The Taoiseach has perfectly summarized them; I will not be longer, but our climate commitment, essential, based on the proposal made by the European Commission last summer, we will work hard to be able to quickly bring forth the first texts, and the French presidency of the European Union must allow us to advance several of the mechanisms included in this strategy.

Next, the continuation of the fight against the pandemic, and on this aspect, we have a common task with the Taoiseach. Europe allows us to vaccinate our populations; I want to commend the remarkable results of your country's vaccination policy, and we continue to move forward together, both to better protect our populations and to carry out a policy of solidarity within the framework of ACT-A, which we care about greatly. Thirdly, the economic recovery. We obviously talked about the macroeconomic context that requires us to continue to support innovation, industrial supply as we do in our countries, to continue to advance in terms of Eurogroup coordination. And I commend here the President of this forum and the presence alongside him of his colleague, dear Pascal; we will have the opportunity, shortly, to meet part of the Irish business and startup community. In this regard, we obviously talked particularly about the digital sector where several projects are underway, and we have a common desire to move things forward. But also the way to shape the future of the Union, as many citizens participate in the Conference on the Future of Europe to enrich this debate. And we naturally discussed the upcoming French presidency of the European Union, which will begin on January 1st.

In this context, we also discussed the situation since the departure of the United Kingdom. And I want to say here something very simple to all our Irish friends. Europe has been united and solidary since the beginning of this British referendum, and it will remain so until the end, do not doubt it. There is no minor issue in this matter. It is an existential question for the solidarity and unity of the European Union. We will ensure that the agreements that have been signed after long negotiations are duly respected in all their components, whether it concerns fishing agreements or the well-known protocols. To put it in more familiar terms, we will never let you down. Our common strength is the single market, the rules, but also the history and what binds our peoples and our countries. And for me, the European Union is first and foremost a political project; it is in this regard that we are being tested, and we will be there by your side.

Our exchanges have been intense and given what I have just said, beyond obviously our relationship and our joint work within the European Union. France has today become Ireland's closest neighbor within the Union, which obviously goes beyond the projects that have existed for several years. This multiplies our willingness to go even further. In order for this friendship and mutual assistance to continue, we are adopting today a joint action plan for the period 2021-2025. I thank our foreign ministers who coordinated this work and who have worked hard, as well as the Secretary of State for European Affairs, and I mentioned our ministers of Economy and Finance. Supporting sustainable growth, increasing trade and connectivity, developing the digital economy, strengthening ties in education and research, promoting the French language and encouraging cultural heritage, all these dimensions have been covered. You spoke of the Celtic interconnector, a flagship project in the context of our energy cooperation, to better guarantee our energy security. We have bilateral projects in the areas of cities, agriculture, and sustainable fishing. In the field of the digital economy, we want to go further and we will have the opportunity to discuss this at the Guinness Enterprise Center shortly. We want to strengthen our cooperation through the partnership between Scale Ireland and Enterprise Ireland, with French Tech and the Public Investment Bank and the joint work on Scale-up Europe. What also binds us, as I mentioned, is culture and language. These are our values that are carried by them: openness to the world, multilingualism, human rights, equality. And we will commit to these major issues for the knowledge-based Europe. France is already Ireland's primary partner within the Erasmus program and many initiatives will continue to develop. I will shortly be at Trinity College to engage with students. But the new framework for bilateral cooperation that we are signing today will allow us to strengthen the mobility of teachers in training, vocational training, partnerships, like the new cooperation agreement between several Breton and Irish universities. I also welcome the choice of the French Lycée in Ireland, which will be inaugurated shortly by the minister. I also acknowledge the presence of our parliamentarians alongside him. The choice of the French Lycée in Ireland to bear the name of Samuel BECKETT, this fabulous writer who also connects our two countries, is something we had the opportunity to discuss earlier. I could also mention architecture, writing, drawing among the scholarships and projects we have on a bilateral level, which show the vitality of this agenda. What binds our two countries is not simply the economies and trade exchanges, but the friendship that exists between our citizens. It is the weight of our history. It is two souls, in essence, that speak to each other. There you go, Mister Taoiseach, that is what I wanted to add here, alongside your remarks, before thanking you. Thank you so much.

Journalist

You are forced to stop evacuations from Afghanistan tomorrow evening, is it too early? How many Afghans in danger will not have been evacuated and what do you plan to do to not abandon them? Will an embassy remain operational, open, and with an ambassador on site? Then there are reports of several explosions near the airport, you mentioned this issue in your opening remarks, there may be casualties, do you have any information? Is this a terrorist attack?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much for all these questions on an extremely serious subject. First of all, I do not have more information than you do about the explosions near the airport. Indeed, we have confirmed these explosions. The circumstances are still extremely unclear. So, I will be very cautious here and I have no human toll to communicate beyond what is shared by your colleagues who are on site. We have had exchanges obviously with our teams, but they do not allow for more information given the degree of confusion. But it is clear that the tension is rising significantly. We all knew this risk from the beginning, given the confusion prevailing in Kabul and the tension that has existed since the beginning at the military airport, and the coming hours will continue to be extremely risky in Kabul and at the airport. As for the ambassador and the teams, the ambassador and all his teams, several other French nationals, police officers, our special forces are on the site of the military airport and they are set to leave Afghan territory on the last flights we will carry out depending precisely on the slots that will be given to us by our American allies and therefore in the very next days. For security reasons, the French ambassador will not remain in Afghanistan for the moment. He will remain ambassador, which means that we will continue to have an ambassador and a team, an embassy, because we do not recognize a regime but we recognize a country and we continue to work with a country. However, for security reasons, he will operate from Paris for as long as we deem necessary to fully ensure his safety and also depending on the guarantees we will obtain from the Taliban.

Regarding the humanitarian situation, what we have been able to do or where we stand and the coming days and weeks. I want to first say that France has been doing its humanitarian work for years in two respects. France, as I reminded our compatriots on August 16, unlike many of our allies, has militarily withdrawn since December 2014 from the Afghan theater. So, we have not been militarily engaged in the conflict since that date after 13 years of involvement. Since that date, we have gradually protected those who helped us as well as their families when they came forward. This has led us to protect about 850 Afghan nationals, what we call "the auxiliaries of the French army" along with their families over the last few years. The second thing we have done in recent years is that we have received Afghan refugees who have come forward, as in all European countries. But France has been one of the most solicited countries and one of the European countries that provides the most significant asylum protection. Over the last three years, we have had about 10,000 Afghan women and men who have arrived on French soil and applied for asylum. We have granted asylum to about 7,000 Afghan women and men on average per year. I mention this at a time when we are having these debates because France has done its duty and did not wait for this crisis in August 2021 to do so. Secondly, after the statements from the United States of America, we were not among those who thought that the situation could improve. We therefore anticipated the evacuation operations of local personnel, of our embassies and their families. This has sometimes been criticized. If you remember at the time, that is to say from April and May, and I am pleased about it, France at that time repatriated for their safety about 630 Afghan women and men to put them in safety on French soil. We were right to do so. Then, since there has been an emergency situation, we have protected about 2,600 Afghan women and men. We have evacuated 2,600 people, among whom 125 French nationals, 40 non-French nationals, and therefore all the other people, more than 2,000 being Afghan women and men who were in a risky situation. We have done everything in our power to reach these people, to help them then go from their place of residence to the airport, and then to take them on the flights we have provided. With also great courage, and I want to acknowledge here our French police and the teams that remained at the French embassy, since we carried out an extremely delicate operation a few days ago, which allowed us to protect several hundred people who were still at the embassy without international protection.

As we speak, we have 20 buses with dual nationals and several Afghan women and men in danger that we wish to repatriate. Several of these buses are in the queue in the area outside the airport. We are facing the disorder, the chaos that I mentioned earlier. We will do our utmost to ensure that all these people we have been able to take care of, but who have not arrived within the military airport, can access it and then be evacuated to the United Arab Emirates and France. This represents several hundred people in danger, still. I cannot today guarantee that we will be able to carry out these operations because the security situation is not under our control. We will continue in connection with our allies, particularly our American allies, in a discussion that has, in any case, been built today on the site of the airport and nearby with the Taliban, we will do everything we can to bring them back. Then, France has provided certificates, titles to the people we have identified as at risk today, who can reach the airport and be taken care of, but we will continue to do so. This means that we will build, in connection with our allies, the ways and means, after August 31, to ensure humanitarian operations that will necessarily have a different nature, that will be more targeted. But to continue to protect judges, lawyers, journalists, intellectuals, and anyone who is threatened because of the fights they are waging and what they are to continue to allow them to leave Afghan soil. This will obviously be a different nature of operation because we will no longer have the military airport and its control, its security, and therefore, we will build this with particularly our allies. This is the discussion we had two days ago at the G7. We will see what options remain possible. It is too early today for me to provide you with a precise answer. As for what is under our control, we have passed these titles, so we have a follow-up. We know where these people are. We will continue to do so for the people who are reported to us. Then, we will be dependent on the solutions that will be built on site.

Journalist

Mr. President, you told President Biden that it is a moral responsibility to evacuate all Afghans. Is this responsibility called into question by this decision not to extend the deadline? Will you put pressure on the Irish government to continue to do so?

Emmanuel Macron

I have had numerous exchanges with President Biden about Afghanistan. And let me tell you, you know, I will not adopt your vocabulary; you spoke of betrayal. But in fact, the situation is no longer under control, and I think no one expected such a rapid deterioration of the situation in Kabul. President Biden confirmed to us during the G7 meeting that he would leave the military airport and end these operations on October 31. I think that de facto, we all find ourselves in a situation where we cannot protect all the Afghans we would like to protect. Now, our responsibility is to devise additional solutions in order, in the weeks and months to come, to protect these people. And I have no doubt about the good intentions given the situation. Now, as for what we want to do with the Americans, we will work as hard as possible until the last moment to carry out as many operations as possible and to ensure and guarantee the situation of our own personnel. Secondly, we will cooperate in terms of humanitarian access, protection, but also in terms of migration and coordination with the new regime. As for your question about corporate tax, it is not for me to exert pressure on our friends. We work very well together. We cooperate. I am aware of the public debate organized notably by your government, and I think it is a very good signal. I fully respect the economic model of Ireland and of recent decades. And I think you have achieved exceptional results. What you have managed to do over these decades is exceptional, is unique, and it is based on a model with a very low corporate tax rate. Now, I believe the situation is different. The post-COVID world is new, and it will require, first, greater involvement from the European Union and governments to help people, to accompany the major changes: climate change, health, education. And secondly, a stronger and united Europe. The situation will therefore undoubtedly require profound changes to our classic economic models, but it is up to you to decide. It is not for France to exert pressure. However, I do believe that the OECD framework makes sense in this context, and I think we will find a good path to have a method, a common framework, and a common rate. And that makes sense for businesses, it makes sense for the European Union. It makes sense in terms of cooperation, not only among OECD members but within an inclusive framework of more than a hundred countries. And I believe that citizens no longer understand why when you are an SME, you pay tax, but when you are a large digital company, you do not pay. Now, our citizens want the system to change, and I think what our technicians, our ministers, and the OECD teams have managed to achieve makes sense. But it is now up to us to find the common path, the change that will suit Ireland and the other member states to find a solution. So again, I exert no pressure. I work with the Irish Prime Minister.

Journalist

I have a question for both of you regarding the Franco-German initiative, the Franco-German desire to establish a distribution mechanism for the reception of refugees within the European Union. First, Mr. Prime Minister, are you in favor of this idea? And what share would you be willing to take in terms of receiving additional refugees compared to what you have already announced? And Mr. President, very concretely, where do we stand on this initiative? Do you hope that it will really come to fruition? And if so, within what timeframe? And then, I would also like to ask you what your reaction is to the criticisms from part of the opposition in France who accuse you of naivety on these issues and who reproach you for sidelining the security of the French people?

Emmanuel Macron

On your second question, I will be straightforward. There is a part of the political class that says we are naive and a part that says we are inhumane. So we must be fair. You know, we must be guided by our principles and speak about reality and speak about what we know with honesty. The urgency is humanitarian. That is what I told the French on August 16, that is what we are talking about. That is what our teams are threatened with. Humanitarian. Are we doing naive humanitarian work? No. The people who return and are protected are identified as being at risk. But they are monitored, followed, identified, and also taken care of by our security services. There is no naivety, but we must do our duty because these are families of women and men who have helped us. These are women and men who take a risk based on who they are in complete chaos.

Then, the second phase will be to manage migration issues. I will return to the European initiative. And then, we also have to draw the geopolitical consequences. There is no naivety. And by the way, I spoke about all this on August 16. I understand that everyone expresses their sensitivities, but I believe that our compatriots want France to hold its rank and moral role and to be up to its duties, especially towards those who have helped it, who have served it in Afghanistan and elsewhere. But I think our compatriots also want to be protected, want us to continue the fight against terrorism that we have been waging vigorously for several years and that, for my part, I have contributed to strengthening and completing over the past four and a half years. And all of this confirms the organization that we have collectively chosen. We do things with, I would say, humanity and firmness. As for immigration, there are several things. We have Afghan women and men in Europe to whom several countries have refused asylum. They can no longer return to Afghanistan. How do we manage them together? The first question we must ask ourselves.

The second question is that we have too great differences in terms of protection, France being a country that protects more than others. We must coordinate to move towards a similar type of asylum protection, a second issue that requires a European approach. The third issue is that we have neighboring countries that are under strong migratory pressure: Iran, Pakistan, or others. What are we ready to do collectively to help the High Commissioner for Refugees and the United Nations to assist these countries, to take care of these refugees in the region, to prevent them from going to other countries but especially to prevent them from being even more destabilized? And then the fourth issue is that sometimes you have Afghan women and men who are evacuated by allies, for example, the United States is evacuating them to neighboring countries of Europe, and they will arrive in Europe. How do we do this? When the United States evacuates Afghan women and men who are then displaced to other countries, what does the European Union do? This is a question we must ask ourselves as Europeans. And I do not want us to suffer migratory pressure; I have never used grandiloquent terms on this subject; we know there will be migratory movements, there will be irregular flows because it is a disorder and because it is a country that is in civil war with a violent regime. It is important that we provide a response to this. All these issues are at the heart of the initiative we have taken with Germany. It is not at all a text where we will distribute people. It is a text that defines common mechanisms to be able to act as Europeans and not to suffer. This text is the subject of an agreement between Germany and France today. We have exchanged it with several partners; it was sent yesterday to the Taoiseach's advisor, we discussed it in spirit today, and we will work together in the coming days to build a solution with several other partners. I also had an exchange with Prime Minister Draghi, Prime Minister Rutte, and we will move forward on this basis. So there is already a Franco-German basis; my wish is that we can expand it to build a European solution that responds very concretely to what I have just mentioned but that is not simply a column with a number and a country. That would not make sense.

Micheál Martin

As for Afghan refugees, we wish to respond to this humanitarian need generously, and we will do so. We also want to ensure that when refugees arrive in our country, there are capacities in place to provide them with a decent life. Furthermore, we want to support the Afghan community already present in Ireland, knowing that sometimes their family members are still in Ireland, in Afghanistan, sorry. And so we will do our best to respond to this humanitarian crisis currently unfolding in Afghanistan. Some have already begun to return to Ireland. It is ongoing. But we realize that the challenge is much broader, and we will act in this context with the broader European partnership to support those who are most at risk in Afghanistan. You have, for example, academics, people who work in the media, and who are very concerned about what may happen to them and what may also happen to women in particular in Afghanistan. Therefore, we must use all possible means to protect these people, ensure respect for fundamental rights, human rights, women's rights, their right to education, for example. But the most effective way to do this is through multilateralism, in the European context but also in the UN context. We must approach the humanitarian challenges that will undoubtedly arise in a very strategic manner and perhaps with more insight, with a longer-term vision than in the past, possibly, to address these migration-related difficulties that will certainly arise. I would also like to say, regarding corporate tax, that we had a good discussion on this matter. Ireland has always been constructive in its multilateral relations, working with organizations like the OECD. We have always had constructive cooperation with the OECD, and we will continue to do so. A consultation is underway regarding the proposals made within the framework of the OECD concerning corporate tax; we have some reservations about certain aspects, but the process continues, and we will continue to engage in this work. The Irish economy has also evolved, and within the framework of the action plan we have adopted, there are very strong commitments regarding research and education. And what will undoubtedly represent a radical change compared to the 1960s is precisely the investment in education. And Ireland is no longer the same country as it was then, in this regard, but there are still significant challenges to overcome for us, and there is no doubt that we will continue to engage in this process, even if there is still a little way to go on this point. Thank you.

Journalist

Mr. President, regarding Sophie Toscan du Plantier, who died 25 years ago, France has condemned the perpetrator, but he will not be extradited by Ireland. What more can be done for her family? Could you perhaps, Mr. President, respond in Irish, and speak about the importance of today's discussion and the importance of this discussion on corporate tax?

Micheál Martin

First, regarding the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, it was a dreadful act, the murder of an innocent woman, and it has profoundly affected the entire community of West Cork, which still suffers from this event, from these atrocities within a peaceful community. And as for Sophie Toscan du Plantier's family, we have conveyed our compassion, our sympathy, and a documentary has been published, but we are well aware of the enormity of the trauma experienced by this family. The investigation is still open within the police. As you know, we do not interfere with judicial processes, but we want justice to be done. It is a terrible burden on a country for such an event. It is a person who loved coming to Cork, as did her family. I love that part of the country myself, and it is incomprehensible what happened that night. It is a story that continues to deeply touch the Irish population. And even at this stage, we strongly encourage anyone with information that could help us shed light on this case to come forward so that justice can be done. Thank you.

Journalist

Would Mr. Macron like to speak to respond to the question about Sophie?

I will first, of course, think of all his loved ones and his family. The Taoiseach mentioned it a moment ago, it is a terrible tragedy and there is still an enormous amount of personal suffering because there is still an ongoing trial and a mourning process that has not been able to take place. I have, first of all, a personal and human word for the entire family. Then, on the procedural level, Sophie TOSCAN du PLANTIER is a French victim. An investigation has been opened in France to determine the cause of her death, and it is in this context that the Paris Assize Court found Ian BAILEY guilty of murder and sentenced him in absentia to a prison term of 25 years. If the individual consents to his extradition to the French judicial authorities, the conviction will then be null and a new trial can be organized in his presence. This has not been possible given that he has not wished to submit to French justice. In this context, the Paris Assize Court issued a European arrest warrant against Mr. BAILEY, which the High Court of Dublin has refused to execute at this stage. The Assize Court will therefore determine the appropriate response to this refusal, and we must allow time for dialogue between the jurisdictions. The Prime Minister just said it, it is in this dialogue between jurisdictions that a solution can be found. And very clearly, mutual trust will be the cornerstone of building a Europe of justice. It is this mutual trust between our jurisdictions that must lead us to find a way forward in this criminal case, but also to build a Europe of justice that alone will ensure full respect for human rights and the guarantee of fair and impartial justice in Europe.