Press conference of the President of the Republic following the European Council.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

20 October 2021 · Press conference following the European Council

Context
Macron held a press conference following the October 2021 European Council, summarizing discussions on energy prices, Poland's rule of law, and other EU policy matters.
Main themes
Energy prices, European energy independence, decarbonization and climate transition, nuclear energy, rule of law in Poland, judicial independence, European Council outcomes, electricity market reform, migration challenges, digital issues, European trade policy, Fit for 55 plan
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,569
82nd percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

174 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Hello everyone. This European Council is coming to an end and has allowed us to cover a very large number of topics. We held several discussions and orientations in particular, notably on digital issues, migration challenges, and European trade policy. We started yesterday with two extremely important topics: the price of energy and the rule of law in Poland.

On the price of energy, we reached a common conclusion: the rise in gas and electricity prices, as well as the rise in gasoline prices, is a major social and economic challenge. So, we all provided national emergency and support responses. In France, the measures adopted by the Government will protect our most vulnerable citizens and our businesses, particularly the smallest ones, from this rapid price increase, which is an action taken in many European countries, and is both urgent and fair. In the medium term, obviously, we have a huge task ahead of us with two fundamental objectives. It is essential not to lose sight of them. The first objective is to accelerate decarbonization in the context of a fossil energy crisis, and the second is to strengthen our energy independence. We must face this crisis; it validates the Fit for 55 plan, which is also a plan to exit carbon-based energies, where we see that our problem is an increase in fossil energy prices. It also validates the fact that this transition must be made while keeping in mind the importance of sovereignty. Today, we depend too much on imports of certain energy sources whose prices increase depending on market tensions. In this regard, very pragmatically, we all recognize the necessary diversification of energy sources, and in this context, nuclear energy must obviously be part of the mix. Never before at the European Council has such clear and broad support been expressed for the use of nuclear energy to achieve our objectives in over four years – during which I have attended these councils. In this regard, the Commission has reiterated its commitment to release the delegated act on gas and nuclear by the end of the year. We also decided that a study would be conducted on the functioning of the electricity market to anticipate the necessary adjustments to better protect the future of consumers and businesses against the price shocks we are experiencing today. I do not want to be too technical; we can return to this if you wish in the questions, but because the formation of the electricity price in Europe depends a lot, as you know, particularly regarding prices for our consumers, on the marginal price of the source invoked, and therefore, at the moment, on the price of gas. When the price of gas increases, electricity does too, even if gas represents less than 20% of the sources of electricity produced. The price of electricity is then over-determined by gas. When gas prices rise globally, electricity prices increase far too quickly. It is a question of pricing formula. In this regard, on this subject, we have requested a study to be able to reopen it. So, on energy prices, you can see that the key for us lies beyond national short-term responses. How can we, at the same time, accelerate our environmental transition? How can we do this while considering our needs in terms of sovereignty? And how can we truly have a more efficient market, providing visibility and protecting our citizens and our businesses?

On Poland, we had a frank discussion with Prime Minister Morawiecki about the situation of the rule of law following the ruling of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal. Regarding everything I have read and the debates that may exist, I want to clarify one or two points here. The first is that the fundamental issue of the Polish question is absolutely not the question of the primacy of European law. That is not the subject at hand. European law, its primacy over national law, I want to remind you here, is primarily a guarantee of non-discrimination and respect for the rights of citizens among themselves. This is what we have freely consented to. When contradictions exist between European law and national law, there are solutions that we have always followed, precisely as respect for the dialogue of judges and our hierarchy of norms. No, the question that arises regarding Poland and that concerns us all is that of the independence of the judiciary; this is a different question. It is a very concrete issue: attacks on the independence and impartiality of the judiciary must alert us. Challenging these values, questioning the rule of law, is to challenge the very foundations of the European project. For this, we had a very precise, very detailed, and respectful discussion. I believe that, first of all, there is a common will to say: everyone, all member states, are committed to the rule of law. Then, in respect, there must be an in-depth dialogue and work that allows us to resolve today the problems that arise in the Polish case. We now expect concrete gestures from the Polish government to avoid having to resort to all the pressure instruments at our disposal to enforce the law. Very clearly, the Polish Prime Minister expressed last night his willingness to engage in this work and to respond to the questions raised.

This morning, our discussions focused on other topics; I will mention them briefly. Before that, I also wanted to mention trade, which we discussed last night. On trade, our trade policy is clearly an undeniable economic asset. Yesterday, we reaffirmed its importance, with a few principles that I want to recall here, which I had the opportunity to defend last night and which are also at the heart of the text released last February by the Commission, which we support for our trade strategy. The fact is that the European trade strategy is inseparable today from our climate and social objectives. Therefore, we must absolutely integrate them into this agenda, push for mirror clauses, and obviously have environmental, social, and fair competition requirements, as well as respect for our standards, particularly health standards. For this reason, we all expressed our willingness to relaunch the WTO reform, to acknowledge that our trade policy constitutes a tool for international convergence towards our standards, and to rethink our objectives and instruments, without naivety, as we have begun to do with initial instruments to combat dumping practices. Finally, I particularly emphasized that the euro is an instrument of our trade policy. If we want to protect our businesses from the extraterritoriality of the dollar and sometimes from American standards, we need to further internationalize the euro. This is the link that must govern between these discussions and the discussions we have on the status of the euro in the integration of the European financial market. We were also able to discuss the Indo-Pacific and the European strategy that we have thus validated. A very comprehensive agenda also on other points, and I will perhaps conclude on that.

Today, we had a long discussion on our migration policies, thus preparing the texts that the Commission will soon release to reform Schengen, and you know what we want to push under the French presidency on these issues. We had a long discussion particularly related to the situation created by the Belarusian strategy, truly using the migration weapon to destabilize several countries in the European Union. We reaffirmed our willingness to continue the work begun by the Commission and the European institutions in relations with countries of origin and transit to improve our tools for preventing migration flows, to better equip ourselves to protect our common borders, and to be more effective in returning to the countries of origin those nationals who are not granted asylum or who are not integrated.

I do not want to be too long here; I could respond to that. But all of this obviously prepares for the finalization of the migration package and the reform of Schengen, which is absolutely essential. And we still see today, with the cases I mentioned, but also what is happening in Cyprus or on the southern shore of the European Union, the difficulties we may face.

Finally, we discussed the very comprehensive and ambitious agenda of digital sovereignty, whether in terms of cybersecurity, platform regulation, and artificial intelligence, and we have two texts to advance, DMA and DSA, and I wanted to particularly emphasize that the regulation of platforms, particularly in terms of content, requires us to know how to take a step forward on the largest platforms and perhaps entrust the European Commission with an additional role to avoid the endless debate between countries of origin and destination. And so, on the directive regulating services known as DSA, we defend the idea that the Commission can play a more important role in direct regulation for very large platforms. There you go, I do not want to be longer. I will now answer a few questions. Thank you very much.

Journalist

Hello Mr. President. I have two questions, one on Poland, the other on migration. On Poland, you said that the issue was not the primacy of European law, but that is still how Poland's challenge is expressed. Do you feel that there could be a solution in this standoff? Will they change their law, recognize the primacy of European law knowing that when we see your political opponent, Marine Le Pen, announcing that she has launched an alliance with 14 other European parties to defend the sovereignty of nations, after meeting with the Polish Prime Minister, we can imagine that this attitude becomes a sort of refuge for all those who want a Europe without legal reach?

And my second question, if you will, you spoke about the situation in Belarus, more specifically about a dozen countries building barbed wire walls, notably Poland. Journalists, NGOs cannot access these areas, and some of these countries are even asking for funding from the Commission to help them erect these walls. Does this seem to you a good way to protect external borders? Is it compatible with European values? And in the upcoming French presidency, which is supposed to focus on the protection of external borders, do you plan to address these walls? Thank you.

Emmanuel Macron

Thank you very much. Listen, I said there is an argumentation that tries to make it seem that the Polish problem is indeed about the supremacy of European law. I said it is false. On this debate, I want to remind you here, the European construction is us. The treaties that are ours and that the courts apply, and the role of the Court of Justice of the European Union, as well as that of the European Court of Human Rights, we have sovereignly decided, we negotiated, we signed, we ratified. That is sovereignty.

But sovereignty also means that when we set rules for ourselves, we put ourselves in a position to respect them. Otherwise, we confuse everything. So there is a blatant political lie on the part of those who would like to make us believe that it is not so. So, very clearly, we are for respecting the rules that we have set for ourselves as Europeans because we believe in cooperation, in the dialogue of judges as in political dialogue.

Once we have said that, the Polish problem is a problem of independence of the judiciary that was triggered by the establishment of a mechanism, particularly disciplinary chambers, and the decision of the Supreme Court. The Polish Prime Minister announced that he was ready, on the subject of disciplinary chambers, to abolish them. This is a first step; he must now provide visibility on this agenda, and the legal questions raised by the opinion issued by the Supreme Court must now be clarified technically in a dialogue with the Commission, perhaps with other supreme courts and the CJEU. And so, this is what the coming weeks will allow us to implement; this is really the issue. But no European country can call itself European if its judges are not independent. This is at the heart of our values, of our fundamental texts, whether it is the European Charter of Human Rights, our primary convention, and the block that is ours within the European treaties.

On the subject of walls, you are absolutely right to mention it; each country tries to protect the external borders of Europe and its own in the way it sees fit. There is a part of national sovereignty that I respect. But the President of the European Commission has very clearly reminded us that the Commission would not finance such structures because that is neither its purpose nor its competence today.

Now, I have an approach that is both about efficiency and a response to our values. I think that on the subject of migration, it is always the same line for me that must prevail. It is very clear today that several powers consider that migration has become an instrument of destabilization of Europe, and therefore we must protect ourselves. But we must never do so while forgetting the principles that are ours. Europe was built on, for example, the subject of asylum. We are a continent that has experienced asylum; most of our countries have, and we have done so by protecting the fighters for freedom. We cannot abandon this value. Therefore, we must protect our values and gain in efficiency.

So in this regard, we must have coordinated and common modes of protection for our external borders. I believe I understand that many migrants arrive by air or sea routes. I fear that a wall will not suffice. Therefore, we need to work, as we announced with the Commission, through dialogue with the countries of origin and transit, through policies aimed at prevention and funding - we actually have policies in our European budgets that allow us to do this - to help countries prevent these flows. There must be reasonable and appropriate policies to prevent unwanted arrivals when they are mass, organized, or manipulated, but in a targeted and discussed manner. In any case, for the equipment you mentioned, it is not the Commission's purpose to finance them today. And then, we need to have more cooperation on how to manage the migration issue within our borders, and we must drastically increase the efficiency of our return policies to the countries of origin for those who are not granted either asylum or residence permits.

Journalist

The Belgian Prime Minister stated yesterday, following the meeting on the rule of law, that there was a feeling of not having achieved much. Do you seem more optimistic, particularly regarding the dissolution of the disciplinary chamber? Did you receive better assurances from the Polish Prime Minister, perhaps a more precise program, a date for abolition, or has everything remained very vague and general?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I want to be optimistic because I think there must be a willingness for dialogue and respect. Moreover, that was what emerged from yesterday's discussion, a genuine demand. Alongside that, there is a real willingness to do it in dialogue and respect; otherwise, it systematically leads us, when we have disagreements on such existential issues, to push towards extremes immediately and not to seek out useful facts first.

The discussion I had with the Polish Prime Minister yesterday noon and the long discussion we had last night on this subject first led him to confirm his determination to abolish these disciplinary chambers, and he did not condition it on anything. Very clearly, this is a decision he will implement in the coming weeks or months. He also did not provide a precise date, and that is part of the work he will conduct with the European Commission and what he will clarify in the coming weeks. Then, there is complementary work, very technical and legal, on the consequences of the Supreme Court's ruling. In this regard, it is this work that must be carried out, and he indicated his willingness to do so. Therefore, I consider that we had a respectful discussion yesterday, and fundamentally, there has clearly been no change, but there could not have been. We were at the European Council, but we decided on a procedure, a mechanism, and a willingness to engage from Poland. That is what we will be looking at in the coming months.

Journalist

Mr. President, the European Commission, in its toolbox, has encouraged countries to lower energy taxes to restore purchasing power to Europeans. That is not the choice you made. Why did you choose to provide checks instead? What do you say to some of your opponents who accuse you, in a way, of giving away free money and distributing checks for Christmas six months before a presidential election?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, you will notice that all European countries are facing this situation. I spoke this morning with the Italian Prime Minister, Mario DRAGHI, who also had to issue a very significant check and is in a very different political context. All European countries are facing this. We have our compatriots today, and this is true everywhere in Europe, who are under very strong pressure to heat their homes, travel, and live. We must all support them. The Government has put in place a series of measures. The first energy check and yesterday, an exceptional allowance that was decided and announced by the Prime Minister.

In fact, I would like to draw the attention of all those who propose lowering fuel taxes. The first thing is that manipulating VAT is not possible under European law. The second thing is that regarding fuel taxes, we are about average in Europe, except that it costs much, much more. All those who call for prudence in terms of public finances would do well to look at how much this reduction costs. The third element is that it is absolutely not targeted; that is to say, when you lower taxation on fuels, which does not increase with the price, it is indeterminate; it is VAT that will increase with the price. When you lower it, you lower it for everyone. I believe that what the Government has decided is fairer and better targeted. They are absolutely right. If we want to support our fellow citizens regarding purchasing power, those who are subject to increases in various segments, it is better to have a more targeted instrument than a general one. Furthermore, it is not very coherent with what we want to do in terms of climate. I am actually surprised to see people who tell us, "You should go much faster and harder on climate," the consequence of what they advocate is the increase in fossil fuel prices. And as soon as they rise, they tell us, "You should lower taxes on them." It is the price of carbon. So we can see that what is done through checks, and what several European countries are doing, is exactly what we should do, which we had not done quickly enough, I readily acknowledge. There, it is global prices that are driving them, but we are going towards an increase in fossil fuel prices.

We must support the most modest, particularly our compatriots who work and need to travel. We must support the energy transition with instruments for the most modest, but therefore, targeted instruments. I believe that this is quite coherent with what our neighbors are doing, with what should be done without being too extravagant, and with strategy as well because it is likely that fossil fuel prices, whether gas or gasoline, will remain high in the coming months due to global markets. No one has told me, "It will go down in two or three months." So, we need to support. Secondly, given all the policies we are implementing everywhere, these prices will continue to rise, if not through global markets progressively, then through the carbon prices we have decided on and that our compatriots want. It is important, right now, to react urgently with support mechanisms. In the long term, it is about continuing to think about these support mechanisms for our compatriots who may have purchasing power problems and who have constrained travel. We must support them there, in the short term, because it is a sudden shock, but also support them by helping them to re-equip. That is the strategy the Government has with Ma Prime Renov’ to help you consume less and heat your homes, with the conversion bonus for vehicles, to help you acquire vehicles that consume less and emit less. This is what, in the long term, is very good. Also, the best way to resolve this crisis, beyond the instruments announced yesterday and in recent weeks by the Government, is to intensify the policy we are pursuing to aid the transition. That is the overall strategy. I believe it is clear. It is not, I would say, linked to any political cycle. It is linked to a shock in the markets that is determined by the global recovery and particularly the fact that the Chinese market is buying a lot of reserves today on gas and that there is pressure from the global recovery on the oil market. So this is likely to last. Those are the few elements I could provide in response.