SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE OCCASION OF THE LAUNCH OF THE GENERAL STATES OF JUSTICE

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 October 2021 · Launch of the General States of Justice

Context
Macron addressed judges, lawyers, and justice officials at Futuroscope, Chasseneuil-du-Poitou, to launch the 120-day États Généraux de la Justice on October 18, 2021.
Main themes
Justice reform in France, États Généraux de la Justice, criminal sentencing effectiveness, prison conditions and capacity, alternatives to incarceration, judicial organization modernization, victim protection measures, penitentiary administration, anti-terrorism justice, community service and reintegration, fight against sexual violence
Duration
~62 min
96th percentile
Words
7,429
96th percentile
Sentences
316
96th percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 70%66%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

316 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Mr. Minister, Madam Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament,

Madam Prefect,

Madam First President of the Court of Cassation,

Mr. Attorney General, near the Court of Cassation,

Mr. Vice President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen Mayors,

Ladies and Gentlemen Heads of Court, Ladies and Gentlemen Heads of Jurisdiction, Ladies Directors, Gentlemen Directors, Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of Conferences, Mr. President of the National Council of Bars, Ladies and Gentlemen Bâtonniers,

Mr. President of the National Chamber of Bailiffs,

Mr. President of the National Company of Statutory Auditors,

Mr. President of the National Council of Judicial Administrators and Judicial Mandataries,

Madam President of the National Council of Clerks and Commercial Courts,

Mr. President of the Committee of the Estates General of Justice, dear students,

Ladies and Gentlemen, thank you.

First, I would like to thank Mr. Mayor of Chasseneuil-du-Poitou for welcoming us to this emblematic place, in this hall and this site of Futuroscope, and thank all our parliamentarians and local elected officials for being present today.

The subject is vast, as you have outlined in the 45 minutes of testimonies, shared reflections, and through the short film we just watched. It will be the subject of 120 days of work for these Estates General. So first, why now? I know this is the question many are asking.

Why now? The first element of response I have provided is that, as I have always repeated, in all areas, we must act until the last minute. As long as there are possible improvements, we must commit ourselves, and we owe it to the French people. We can see that many issues still need to be modernized, clarified, and reopened. The time is therefore right. This does not mean that we have waited until now to reform and work on justice. Much has been done over the past four years.

We have worked to restore meaning to punishment, as you have very well mentioned just now. I had the opportunity to speak at the National School of Penitentiary Administration in Agen, and texts have followed aimed at achieving a more effective execution of sentences based on the simple principle that every sentence pronounced must be executed. We have toughened penalties, among other things, for sexual crimes or assaults on law enforcement. We have extended several statutes of limitations. And we also propose the end of the automaticity of sentence reductions by conditioning them. These are just a few of the many topics that have been addressed, dealt with, and on which our parliamentarians have had to legislate over the past years and which are now being deployed. To make sentences increasingly effective, we have innovated by implementing fixed fines for certain offenses, primarily where procedures, often too lengthy, did not lead to results. We have also implemented anti-approach bracelets or emergency phones to better protect women victims of violence, with now a whole challenge to fully deploy them across the territory and further prevent assaults. In parallel, we have increased, in accordance with what Carine just told us, alternatives to incarceration when appropriate. We created the Agency for Community Service and Professional Reintegration of Prisoners in 2018, but this comes after many reforms. Jean-Marc SAUVÉ reminded me of the 1983 law on community service. All of this makes us modest and shows us that it is a work that continues ceaselessly.

To begin to address the indignity of the prison situation, we have also, in continuity with the previous five-year term, initiated a program to construct 15,000 prison places. 7,000 are under construction, and 8,000 for which sites have been established. And the mention of these prison places also allows me to take this opportunity to thank the staff of the penitentiary administration. Because it is not just about places; it is about the women and men, you have recalled their importance, all our staff for their exceptional mobilization, especially during the pandemic which made their tasks even more difficult, and to reiterate how the security works for which the Government is investing more than 100 million euros will continue. Following the opinion issued by the European Court of Human Rights, we have opened by law the possibility of appeals in cases of inhumane detention. But a law is not enough, and I know I can count on Madam the General Controller of Places of Deprivation of Liberty to ensure its concrete application.

We have also continued to rethink the judicial organization to make it closer to citizens. The High Courts and the Courts of Instance have thus been merged into judicial courts, and the link with our fellow citizens is maintained by local courts. We have also advanced specialized justice, the anti-terrorism justice with the creation of a dedicated national prosecutor's office and the strengthening of penitentiary intelligence. And I want to thank all those who for so many years have allowed our justice to continue its work on this subject, to improve it, at a time when our country is holding an exceptional trial in every respect, which must also be a source of pride for the entire judicial world and for those who contribute to its task. Juvenile justice has also been modernized with the entry into force on September 30 of a new code, as you mentioned, which allows for quicker judgments of juvenile offenders and faster compensation for victims. We have also launched the major project of digitization, which has also been mentioned several times just now. This will allow us to refocus on their core business; internal security forces, magistrates, lawyers, administrative staff. Starting in 2022, the digital criminal procedure will begin to be deployed throughout the territory.

But I also know the expectations, the impatience. We must be realistic; we have taken too long to modernize our information systems, our digitization. And the legitimate impatience of professionals is there. In accordance with what is our philosophy in all areas of public action, which consists of both investing and transforming, all these reforms have been accompanied by unprecedented investments. Where justice had been a budgetary adjustment variable for decades, it has become a priority: +30% in 5 years. And I want to salute the commitment of Prime Minister Jean CASTEX and Keeper of the Seals Eric DUPOND-MORETTI who, particularly in these last two years, have ensured the passage of a historic increase in resources. This is what has allowed us to surpass the threshold of 9,000 magistrates in our country, 9,090 exactly today, which is 700 more magistrates, 850 more clerks, the doubling of prosecutor delegates, numerous night justice points, ultra-portable distribution to all magistrates, 500 cars distributed, a current vacancy rate of magistrates of 0%, etc. All this to tell you that, of course, we did not wait for these Estates General to act, to carry out numerous projects that have been at the heart of the work of the Keeper of the Seals, of the entire administration, of the Ministry of Justice and of parliamentarians and to invest.

Nevertheless, these are as many projects that have often been taken separately or successively. And we can see that several of the most delicate issues probably require us to revisit, at this moment, with a form of systemic thinking, so many subjects that are interconnected — the organization, the nature of procedures — to untangle some of the Gordian knots that have been mentioned and have contributed to degrading the situation we have known for so many decades.

The second reason that led me to launch these Estates General at this very moment is that, together with the two highest magistrates in the country, we shared the observation of the loss of trust and the regular questioning in public debates of our justice. With attacks sometimes, I must say, whose vehemence is detrimental in every respect to democracy. If you wished, Madam First President, Mr. Attorney General, to meet with me four months ago with the Keeper of the Seals, it is because we shared the common observation that there was, according to you, an urgency to restore the link between justice and those on behalf of whom it is rendered, namely the French people. I then asked you what solutions you recommended, and you suggested the organization of Estates General, despite the democratic moment we are in. I accepted with the desire to initiate, in a way, after the elements of repair I just mentioned, a new phase, that of the modernization of our justice, with two main objectives. The first, to restore the civic pact between the Nation and justice. The second, to guarantee the effectiveness of the public service of justice. And we are here this afternoon, near Poitiers.

For me, there are three conditions for success in the unprecedented approach we are undertaking today. The first condition is that these Estates General must provoke a debate throughout society. Of course, here are gathered the actors and partners of justice: judges, whether professional or elected, prosecutors, clerks, judicial service agents, justice auditors, lawyers, notaries, bailiffs and auctioneers, soon to be united in the same profession of judicial officers, statutory auditors, judicial mandataries, prison guards and directors, probation and reintegration counselors, professionals in youth judicial protection. Everyone has a role to play, their expertise to contribute. And I want to say here how much the civil servants, all the civil servants of the ministry have a key role to play in the context of these Estates General and how much they have all my consideration. Students preparing for access to all the professions I just mentioned; professors, as they may also prepare themselves to teach, have an essential role to play in these Estates General. There are also police officers, gendarmes, customs officers who contribute to the continuum of the penal response. And there are the trade unions and associations that also play such an important role, either on the side of all legal professions or on the side of victims, litigants, our fellow citizens. But we will only succeed if the nation as a whole engages, if the French people who, at some point in their lives, are necessarily litigants, whether as victims, accused, or parties in a civil trial, mobilize. You have indeed said it very well just now, it is a matter for citizens, active citizens who have learned to better know their justice and to help us collectively improve it.

That is why I wish that in the coming weeks, the places of justice, but also the offices and amphitheaters, the places where democracy is held everywhere in our cities, open their doors wide and that debates can be organized everywhere in our territories. That is also why we are launching the digital platform "Let's Talk Justice," which will be online starting today and will transparently gather contributions.

The second condition is to not rule out any field, any subject, any audacity. The lesson from the past years, which applies as much to justice as to many other areas of public action, is that adjustments, marginal improvements, often are no longer sufficient. We must rather think of sometimes radical solutions, even if it means addressing debates that have for too long been either ignored or become almost forbidden, even if it means shaking up some established positions. In a way, a mandate of freedom, if I may say so, to these Estates General to be able, in a spirit of system, to approach with the greatest ambition the proposals that will be made. So part of your work should allow for addressing very practical and efficiency-related issues and may lead to rapid realizations. Another part must take on the challenge of raising profound questions that, for some, will nourish the upcoming democratic debate. And this is a good thing because they will nourish it based on established, documented work, and opinions can be expressed based on the consolidation of studies thus conducted. The Keeper of the Seals will, following this speech and this day, define the scope of the field and entrust by letter an ambitious mission in this sense to the President of the Committee of the Estates General, Mr. Jean-Marc SAUVÉ, whom I thank for accepting this new commitment, and will personally ensure the smooth running of the work.

The third condition is that these general states be a free, open, and independent exercise. To achieve this goal, I wished for a committee composed of 12 recognized women and men, including the two highest magistrates of France and the two chairpersons of the law commissions of the National Assembly and the Senate, to ensure, based on the terms of reference, the proper conduct of the process and to work on a report that will be submitted to the Keeper of the Seals before the end of winter 2022. So, without preempting either the debates or the proposals, without being, far from it, either exhaustive or prescriptive, I would like very simply this afternoon to mention the two major issues that I believe should be explored within the framework of your work.

The first is the restoration of the civic pact between the nation and justice that I mentioned a moment ago. Justice is an essential organ of the rule of law and our democracy, as you very well stated yourself earlier, in that it considers all victims and all parties with equal attention and consideration; it ensures reparation; it decides on penalties for the guilty with the dual purpose of punishing and reintegrating them into society; it substitutes, to quote the philosopher Paul Ricœur, the distancing of the protagonists for the short-circuiting of vengeance. It is this link that we need to strengthen, the Justice-Nation pact that we need to restore. This first requires guaranteeing the independence necessary for the impartiality of justice, which is the foundation of our citizens' trust. By nature, justice must constantly cooperate with the executive and legislative powers, but without ever depending on them; with the Government responsible for civil and criminal policies and with Parliament responsible for the drafting and oversight of the law. But for it to do so without suspicion, its independence must be clearly established. That is why I relaunched a constitutional reform at the beginning of my term, which aimed in particular to strengthen the conditions for the appointment of members of the Public Prosecutor's Office in terms of independence. The political conditions did not allow this reform to succeed during this term, that is a fact. But the general states must be an opportunity to relaunch the debate. It is necessary and salutary.

This greater independence must be accompanied by greater responsibility for magistrates. This concerns responsibility within the framework of disciplinary procedures that respect the rules established in 2007 by the Constitutional Council. Beyond that, the recent opinion issued by the Superior Council of the Judiciary - of which I welcome several members present here, including several members of the committee - offers avenues that, on this issue of responsibility, deserve to be explored and even, I would dare to say, retained, and while fully respecting the jurisdictional act, allow for real and substantial progress in terms of responsibility. My conviction is that we must also move forward in these areas.

Restoring this Justice-Nation pact also requires us to question some elements of our own organization. Is the French singularity with a unique body of magistrates the model that best guarantees impartiality? Is our model of investigation more effective, more conducive to trust? Are our organizations, the distribution of work between judges and officials, the Office and the scope of the judge in need of evolution? In this regard, it seems that we must legitimately look at what Europe shows us and how it can inspire us. Justice also plays an essential role in that it properly stages the founding values of the social pact. Our fellow citizens are attentive to the loyalty of the procedure, to the possibility of asserting their rights and dignity. You all recalled this with your words as well as our compatriots who expressed it just now. It is therefore also legitimate, in this context, for your work to question our procedures and deep categories: the complaint, the investigation, the trial, the penalty in order to determine whether, in all matters, they are still suitable or need improvement. The scope of this second series of remarks is vast, I am aware, it simply aims to indicate to all stakeholders and to the committee in particular, the great latitude it has to address these issues. For I believe that it is in some of the systemic responses to these questions that lies a part of the greater efficiency and humanity that we could bring to all those who make the law in our country. Restoring the Justice-Nation pact then involves ensuring the capacity of justice to take into account the major social changes, those that our fellow citizens are experiencing and that we are all experiencing.

The first major change that we cannot ignore is, of course, that of social networks. Justice is progressing every day in taking into account phenomena that, like violence against women, like incest, are revealed by victims on social networks and where denunciation campaigns are being set up. These phenomena, which have accelerated in recent years, have a positive dimension in that they liberate the voices of victims and allow for the revelation and establishment of truths and thus better reparation, but also better protection. However, the risk of these new movements is, in a way, the entry into an era of uncontrolled and real-time disclosure, sometimes of slander, sometimes of vengeance, in any case, two phenomena that trample on the protection of the parties and notably the presumption of innocence. This is a dangerous drift for our democracy that requires us to consider how to quickly address all these phenomena whose procedural scope must be modernized to be faster while guaranteeing the rights of all parties from the outset. The other phenomenon, I am not exhaustive here either, but the other major phenomenon that we have been experiencing for several decades and which tends to accelerate, is primarily - should I say, under the influence of Anglo-Saxon countries - the criminalization of social relations. Officials, doctors, scientists, elected school principals. This movement, orchestrated by citizens who have often become prosecutors, has increasingly gained ground in our social relations. I believe that the general states must shed light on this evolution that has largely occurred quietly in order to assess its consequences. And to see how to preserve our society, sometimes from excesses, but also at other times to see how, collectively, we must adapt to these new responses. The work of the general states can rely on several available reports on these subjects, particularly the one submitted to the Keeper of the Seals by Elisabeth Guigou on the essential question of the presumption of innocence, which has been impacted by these two major changes that I have just mentioned.

The fourth element of remark on this pact of trust, to restore it. This requires, beyond the question of independence that I have just mentioned, finding the right terms in the implementation of the responsibility of elected officials and public officials in this context of criminalization. Indeed, when officials: ministers, civil servants, elected officials are cited in a procedure for a crisis that is still ongoing, we are far from the calm and balance that I mentioned earlier. And the situation we are collectively experiencing raises a question that can put the judicial authority in tension with the other powers. We must therefore, on the one hand, redefine the terms of political responsibility. It is because the political world has somehow lost the culture of responsibility towards citizens that the search for other forms of responsibility is being exercised. And we cannot deny it. And redefine the fields of criminal responsibility of officials, elected officials, and ministers. I myself had proposed at the beginning of my term the idea of abolishing the Court of Justice of the Republic. The circumstances render this reform obsolete today, but the logic remains more current than ever and the reflection must be calmly deployed. The recent proposals from the Council of State can nourish your work and, fundamentally, I will share my conviction with you, everyone must be responsible for their actions and decisions. It is necessary to distinguish each time between the most individual acts, the most individual decisions and those made within the framework of the service or mission.

We must never make public decision-making impossible. We must never fall into a situation of public impotence, nor take away from the people the choices that, in a democracy, must ultimately always be theirs. It is in this balance that we must recover the question of the responsibility of elected officials and public officials.

Finally, restoring this pact between the nation and its justice requires transparency and evaluation. Justice, like all institutions, must present accounts and the terms of its management to the nation, in accordance with Article 15 of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. This is indeed the responsibility of justice collectives, whether it be a court, a tribunal, or a service that is responsible for reporting to the nation on the resources allocated. On this subject too, we must undoubtedly rediscover the salt and substance of our Declaration of the Rights of Man and the preamble of our Constitution.

The second major area of reflection for these general states, in my eyes, is that of justice as a public service. Indeed, if we have reached this level of distrust as you described to me, Madam First President, Mr. Attorney General, it is because justice today is unable to fulfill, as everyone would wish, as fundamentally everyone would wish among our fellow citizens, the role that should be its own: to quickly resolve the conflicts that mar society. To resolve them while taking the necessary time for the quality of decisions and procedures and with the consideration and humanity that is appropriate for the justice of men. When a landlord takes several years to obtain the payment of overdue rent, when an employee takes an average of 16 months to find out whether their dismissal is justified or not, it is not illegitimate that trust diminishes. When there are difficulties in following and understanding a procedure as you very well described earlier, Madam, when the perpetrator of an offense is placed in detention, sometimes more than a year after the commission of the acts, sometimes even when their life has changed, it is legitimate that because we fall into human situations that, by common sense, seem unacceptable, the collective organization that is ours is questioned. All of this falls under justice as a public service. All of this falls under the fact that all of us are at the service of our fellow citizens. The delays and burdens of the public service of justice satisfy no one today, neither the victims who feel a sense of generalized impunity, nor the police and gendarmes who feel useless, nor the magistrates and lawyers who are part of this malaise and who themselves experience the same frustration, nor even the guilty for whom, in too many cases, the penalty loses its meaning with the durations I mentioned. These general states must therefore be an opportunity to think about a modern public service of justice, to retain only three notions that seem particularly important to me: effectiveness, clarity, and openness to society.

Effectiveness, first and foremost. I am picking up on one of the themes dear to the philosopher Simone Veil, but we must ensure that our great principles of law find a translation in the concrete lives of individuals. That justice is not simply a principle, but a lived experience. Effectiveness is primarily about ensuring that everyone has access to a solution of justice. Here too, it is a very clear spring from the few minutes we have just spent together. Much has been done in recent decades for access to rights, and I want to acknowledge here the commitment of several judges, staff from the Ministry of Justice, and parliamentarians who have worked so hard on this issue. Justice points have also been created in services. The Government, more recently, has enhanced legal aid to strengthen the quality of defense for the most vulnerable. But the question we must address during this General States is how to do more? How to set up, for example, digital platforms to access the law more simply, more quickly, without formality, without having to travel? How to also ensure that the most modest in our society have easier access to the right to justice when they are faced with so many difficulties? It is a question of resources. It is also a question of organization, of the simplicity of our organizations, because all complexity and formality distance the most vulnerable from the law and justice. Therefore, we need to think deeply about the blind spots that remain, which are in a way the cursed parts of our access to law and which require, I would say, more than just working on legal aid, even if it is absolutely essential, but a work of organization, simplification, and sometimes human responses and welcoming our fellow citizens. I hope that you can again propose very freely new avenues, concrete improvements that have not been considered until now.

Effectiveness also consists of reducing, while respecting the quality of procedures and decisions, the time between the complaint and the judgment so that each party can resume the course of their life as quickly as possible. If we are not able to achieve this today, it is because our judges, our clerks, our administrative staff are overwhelmed by an ever-increasing flow of cases. Just for civil justice, there are 2.2 million additional cases each year, a colossal price, whether it concerns divorces, adoptions, or conflicts, labor, urban planning, and so on, which are crucial in the daily lives of our fellow citizens. Also, to guarantee the effectiveness of the public service of justice, there is obviously the issue of resources. I mentioned it earlier. The Government has invested, the justice programming law has allowed for the recruitment of 700 judges, and under the proximity justice initiative, more than 2,000 contractual staff have been deployed in one year. Never before have such efforts been made, but it is truly through profound choices that we must also respond to this transformation we are experiencing, profound choices related to the scope of what is called "the Office of the Judge" that we can also really address these problems. We have in the field of civil justice, which, too often still, no longer attracts and which is nevertheless an essential mission, expanded mediation, for example, for divorce, and simplified this procedure. I hope that the General States will study how we can be bolder, more radical on this subject. Why not reserve access to judges for the most complex or important cases or, conversely, consider a more suitable organization where access would be simpler, faster, reserving the technicality of certain cases for other forms of organization? Annie's testimony illustrated very well earlier the necessity of this speed for a simple case, which gives the feeling of being subjected to inhumane treatment. Such changes would allow judges, all our magistrates, to be at the heart of their profession and to make decisions that are no longer under the pressure of numbers, but with the strength of the law and all the humanity necessary to perhaps also reconsider the distribution of tasks with clerks, justice officials, and to open new perspectives for other legal professions. I know the tensions that these reforms sometimes create. If we transform an organization under constant law and reduce the matters that go before the judge, all professions are impacted and can legitimately say you are taking away our material, and thus, our activity. But I believe that other legal professions, such as lawyers, can also contribute by considering new missions or participation in these mediations, in these conciliations, to be actors in these new forms of conflict resolution. Considering new perspectives. The ultimate challenge is that the lives of our fellow citizens are no longer suspended, as if put on hold due to delays, burdens that are not the responsibility of the engaged actors of justice, but which are our collective responsibility as they are the consequence of our inability to reform a system that has become exhausted. Therefore, I invite you on this subject to carry the maximum ambitions by also lifting sometimes the constraints that may have existed between professions to, if I may say so, try to deploy with the utmost common sense and humanity the way to approach these issues to gain in efficiency and speed in service to our fellow citizens. If for this, it is necessary to de-judicialize certain areas, we should not exclude it a priori.

Effectiveness also requires that justice gains in competence and technique in areas of litigation that, for some fields, have become very specialized. And I am, in a way, starting at the other end of the chain. I was talking about everyday justice, civil justice, which is the daily reality for millions of our fellow citizens. But on the other side, if we talk about effectiveness and justice, our justice must also adapt to an increasingly complex law, increasingly driven by the evolution of international and European norms, to litigations that have become more complex. Our judges are indeed frequently confronted in civil and economic matters with cases of such scope and complexity that their means are no longer adequate today. They often have to face conclusions submitted by very specialized law firms, whose analysis requires such work that it makes any quick judgment impossible. To equip judges in the face of this phenomenon that continues to accelerate, we need, on the one hand, to rethink training and career paths, and on the other hand, to develop mobility, perhaps in other administrations, also in other sectors, so that judges can acquire professional, human experiences that will be useful for better judgment. And finally, and above all, I would dare to say, work to better surround judges with adapted, specialized teams and provide more resources for these litigations.

Effectiveness, finally, is that of penalties. I have mentioned in this regard the reforms implemented in penal and penitentiary policy. We are here, I believe, in a subject of execution, of implementation, but I invite the committee and all contributors to the General States to seize all avenues for improvement on this subject to help us continue to improve this essential field where the dignity of a society is also judged.

Another essential axis, the second that I wanted to mention to improve the public service of justice is that of readability. You all touched on this subject earlier. There is first a matter of the production of law and norms. If we talk about readability, let us first look at where the norm comes from and the quantity produced. The Government has tried in recent years to improve things. There have been some points of improvement. We produce much fewer regulatory norms and we have reduced the number of autonomous decrees by more than four times. We have also drastically reduced the number of circulars, as they are elegantly called in jargon, in flow and in stock. But let us be realistic, the normative inflation is everywhere. It is first in the fact that our system, which was designed with a center that was the law, has itself become decentralized. Because the norm produced, which increasingly governs our relationships in all fields of society, is increasingly an international and European norm. This proliferates and accelerates. This is a challenge for social and economic actors, for all of us, but it is a challenge for our judges, for the entire functioning of the public service, of justice, for lawyers, for all those who have worked on these essential matters. Then, as a response, we have collectively contributed to legislative inflation. This matter contributes to the unreadability of our law. And on this, things are not improving. The laws are more numerous. They are each time, in a way, swollen by the right of amendment, which is a completely legitimate right of Parliament. But it is clear that on this subject, a reform of our Constitution will be necessary. Because today, the Government and Parliament are somewhat chasing after the proliferation of norms that is external to them and the changes in society to legislate even more. And the accelerations that the last 15 years have shown are not sustainable, neither for society nor for our justice. This matter, I present to you, it is not a gift, Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen members of the committee, Ladies and Gentlemen, but I present it to say that we cannot approach and legitimately address the subject of readability without being honest about first the production of norms and consider that this subject requires deep reflection and will call for a constitutional revision on the role of the Government, of Parliament in this matter that must be conducted. If no reform can be completed during this term, I hope that you can engage in this reflection around this simple theme, that the law does not resolve everything.

Readability must then be that of our existing codes. However, our laws, our procedures have sometimes reached such a level of complexity that even seasoned professionals, justice, law enforcement have sometimes difficulty navigating them. So, what about our fellow citizens? Our codes, and notably the Code of Criminal Procedure, mix increasingly difficult-to-reconcile logics that undermine intelligibility and sometimes the proper application of our procedures. You know this infinitely better than I do. That is why I announced, during the Beauvau of security, the rewriting of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This is an essential but highly delicate matter. Criminal procedure is the twin sister of our freedoms, and the Code affirms the presumption of innocence in its preliminary article, which addresses the issue of searches at the crack of dawn, it is the one that grants the right to remain silent, it is the one that allows your son, when he has done something wrong, to notify his parents by phone from his police custody, it is the one that provides enhanced investigative means in terrorism cases, etc. It is therefore an eminently important subject that must be treated with both audacity and caution. But if we talk about readability, we cannot remain in the current situation.

Legibility is finally a matter of intelligibility and follow-up. This first requires investing in the education of our fellow citizens. For the law to be understood, it must be somewhat known in its foundations and in its functioning. And it seems to me that your work could usefully enlighten public decision-makers on how to improve the knowledge and understanding of our law throughout society, starting from the basic education of all our fellow citizens. Professor, you know better than I do how much this subject already exists, but I believe we must be clear-eyed; it is still heterogeneous, undoubtedly imperfect, and it is an essential issue for living well in society. It is about understanding the functioning, the rights that are ours, and being able to receive, in a way, the decisions we are confronted with. Speaking of intelligibility and follow-up also means discussing the language that justice employs. Justice today speaks a language that, too often, remains marked by technicality: the technicality of codes but also of its own logic, and it often remains little comprehensible to the layperson. This is a task that I believe is essential if we want to hope for a more harmonious and happier life in society. We must therefore move towards greater simplicity and pedagogy. I also wish for us to make progress in the follow-up of complaints and cases. Gwendoline, I believe I am not betraying your name, perfectly mentioned this earlier. We wait a long time, we do not know where the procedure stands. There is a form of paradox in our society: we live in a world where we can track, in a way, the package we ordered down to the minute. But when it comes to what is at the heart of our lives that keeps us awake at night, we do not know where it stands? We feel like we are disturbing everyone when we ask about the status of our own lives? Common sense, here too, must lead us to change our practices, to do so by giving ourselves the means to do it. It is a question of organization. It is also a question of humanity. It is also a question of technique. And I believe we must first clarify the follow-up, better define the interlocutors, but also better utilize the digital revolution which can, on this subject, offer services to users, to our fellow citizens and allow for immense qualitative leaps. In particular, what we call in very good French our legal tech, all these companies involved in the digital transformation of our practices, allow for extraordinary innovations; they must be associated with reflections on this matter and with these elements of legibility, accessibility, and simplicity.

Finally, the public service of justice will be all the closer, all the more human, as it is in its very construction, in the training of those who contribute to it, open to society. There is, and I do not underestimate them, a fundamental tension that we must have the courage to face. We must both guarantee the impartiality of judges, and therefore ensure that they are not tied to any interests in society. And we must be particularly vigilant on this point. At the same time, we must guarantee, as I mentioned, their good knowledge of increasingly technical matters that society transforms, and have the human knowledge of profound social evolutions. So, what to do? The answer cannot be in closure or retreat. That is not true. I therefore wish for you to take up these subjects, that of the training of judges, which is fundamental, and in particular a greater openness at all levels of the National School of the Judiciary, but also the subject of pathways to other missions or with other professions. In the same way for other legal professions, particularly the profession of lawyer, this work must be conducted on training and career developments. We measure the democracy of a country by the treatment of its lawyers, and I want to ensure that lawyers, an institution at the heart of justice, bearers of respect for individuals, including respect by the judicial institution, are therefore present at the heart of your reflections. It is for this reason that the president of the National Council of Bars is a member of the committee; I hope you can also consider the evolution of careers, pathways between professions to mark and complete this openness. Openness is also that of a justice that resembles our society in terms of parity. I want to take this opportunity to salute the extraordinary advances of recent years and the results you mentioned earlier, Madam, which show that in this regard, in many areas of training, we have a situation that is more advanced than in many other jobs and professions, but we must continue to work to truly achieve parity. But we must continue to work towards openness in terms of social diversity and openness to the entirety of society in the legal professions. Everything must be put on the table and considered in terms of openness. This is necessary for good legibility, good effectiveness, and good functioning, therefore, of this public service of justice.

Ladies and gentlemen, having already been too long, I am aware that I am not addressing many essential questions that have sometimes been the subject of significant reforms during this term: I think of juvenile justice, judicial protection of youth, or prison administration. And there are many others. I am also not addressing other subjects that I am sure you will raise, which Madame the Defender of Rights will also highlight, as this independent administrative authority also helps to improve the daily functioning of our justice and the rule of law in our country. I want, to conclude and before you begin your work, to simply make a few essential reminders. The first is that our democratic model is based on what we call "the rule of law," which passes through the state of justice. Acting to strengthen justice is therefore an essential struggle, and I weigh my words, a struggle of civilization. We must reform it, modernize it, and seek to strengthen this civic pact that I mentioned between the nation and its justice. But we must always defend it. It is the duty of every citizen. A democracy that allows distrust to settle and justice to be attacked is a democracy that undermines its own foundations.

Our justice, then, has long been built in the dialogue of judges at the European level. This dialogue has also accompanied the political construction of Europe. It preceded it. It progresses through texts such as the European Convention on Human Rights, which France has joined sovereignly and which are fundamental tools for defending human rights. This French and European humanism that makes us who we are and distinguishes us must be defended. I am astonished, to remain modest, in our debates today, to see that as soon as there is a problem, we revert to this old French malady of saying it is Europe; but Europe is us. It is us who made it and chose it. It is us who built it. All the texts to which we are subject, we built them in our discussions, then signed them, then ratified them sovereignly. What is this affair? We must therefore defend them. And so, we must continue and preserve this dialogue of judges, and we must continue to complete this work, and sometimes, as we do at the national level, change the European norm, but through political work that leaders and elected officials must carry out, that the parliaments elected for this purpose must conduct. That is it. And let us not forget our foundations. France will continue to defend everywhere the protection of the rule of law because it is its universal vocation. That is why, for example, I intervened recently in favor of those who participated in the creation, even imperfect, of a rule of law in Afghanistan. That is why we decided to establish, which will soon be completed, the Fund for Democracy in Africa. That is also why I announced a few days ago the relaunch of the fight for the universal abolition of the death penalty. This is the vocation of France, and it is the one we pursue.

Ladies and gentlemen, the professions you do, or to which you aspire for the younger among us, tear lives from arbitrariness, guarantee our freedoms, protect all citizens without distinction. That is why they are so beautiful and noble. That is also why they are inseparable from an immense responsibility. And the first of the responsibilities that is at the heart, at the core of the act of judging, is that of doubt. Not the doubt that paralyzes, not the doubt that prevents, no, the doubt that imposes not to yield to the tyranny of immediacy or emotion, which unfortunately our societies sometimes elevate to the paradigm. The lucid doubt that allows, as Gisèle Halimi said, to keep our eyes open and thus to progress, to move forward. This is the whole meaning in my eyes of these general states, to collectively doubt with lucidity. To lay everything out, our practices, our collective preferences, our organizations to better build the future.

So, I count on you, I count on you to make these general states not only a chance for justice but a chance for our country. As for me, you can count on my full commitment. I will always be on the side of those who act, as Pascal writes, to strengthen justice, rather than on the side of those who, by criticizing it, tarnishing it, ultimately justify only one thing, force and violence. So, good work, be free, demanding, and determined.

Long live the Republic and long live France!