Press conference of the President of the Republic following the extraordinary European Council.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

6 March 2025 · Press conference following the extraordinary European Council

Context
Macron addressed press following an extraordinary European Council on March 6, 2025, focused on Ukraine support and accelerating European defense investment.
Main themes
European defense investment, Ukraine support, European security, ceasefire framework, security guarantees for Ukraine, European strategic autonomy, Russia's threat to Europe, EU financial mechanisms, peace negotiations, military aid coordination
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,091
86th percentile
Sentences
183
87th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
11.3
37th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

183 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for your patience. We have just concluded the exceptional Council that was held today and, with it, an essential discussion for the affirmation of the European Union's own interests. First, support for Ukraine and for security in Europe, then to accelerate our investment agenda in European defense. These were the two topics of our exchange today.

I had the opportunity to reiterate this yesterday to the French people: we have entered a new era, and in the face of growing uncertainties, Europeans must create their own certainties, so to speak, first for Ukraine, which was the subject of our discussion with President ZELENSKY, the conclusions adopted, then the discussion this evening, and obviously for the short-term security of Europeans, and in a more structural way, through the plan we have adopted. I want to thank the President of the European Council, Antonio COSTA, for facilitating this exchange and these decisions today, and President VON DER LEYEN for the plan that was submitted to us. Indeed, the moment we are living is serious for Europe, everyone is aware of it. And from day one, we have made strong choices, those of supporting Ukraine in the face of Russia's war of aggression and, in doing so, supporting its independence and freedom. What is at stake in Ukraine is obviously the security and sovereignty of that country, but it is also our security.

This European Council has therefore acknowledged the continuation of European financial and military support for Ukraine, and some fundamental principles that must guide us on the path to a solid and lasting peace. In this regard, the key principles that we agreed upon at the Paris meeting on February 17, confirmed later in London, have been validated by all. We want peace for Ukraine and by Ukraine, and the Ukrainians want it even more. President ZELENSKY reiterated this himself at noon today. We want a solid and lasting peace, meaning a peace that guarantees Ukraine's sovereignty and that is not a reward for the aggressor, nor a capitulation, nor a ceasefire without guarantees, an experience we have already lived through in 2014, as I reminded yesterday.

That is why the idea of a sequence that we have supported in direct connection with President ZELENSKY, with Prime Minister STARMER and Chancellor SCHOLZ, was discussed at length today and approved by all, the idea that we would first move towards a ceasefire that can be measured and verified, a ceasefire in the air, at sea, and on civilian infrastructure, which could then allow for discussions on what constitutes security guarantees in the broad sense, ranging from strengthening the Ukrainian army to the presence of European or non-European forces on Ukrainian soil, to other types of guarantees. In this regard, I have invited all colleagues who wish to participate to the meeting that will be held in Paris on March 11 with our chiefs of staff.

In this regard and beyond, the priority, of course, is to support Ukraine and its army in the very short term. These are the choices we have all made, in a coordinated manner, in recent days, by reinforcing or accelerating the aid packages already decided or by mobilizing our main operators to meet the most urgent needs of the Ukrainian army. In 2025, the European Union will provide Ukraine with 30.6 billion euros under the Ukraine Facility and the G7 HERA initiative, funded by, as you know, the interest from frozen Russian assets. And we have confirmed the availability of Europeans to urgently increase our military support for Ukraine and to respond to its most pressing needs in equipment, while also examining all initiatives to achieve this. Beyond these short-term elements, this European Council has decided to accelerate investment in support of European defense, and this is directly linked to the context I have just recalled and because the shared analysis by all member states is indeed that Russia, as I also reminded the French people yesterday, poses a long-term existential threat to all Europeans, and therefore also to France. We are also convinced and we respect that many of our historical allies today have other priorities than Europe and that, indeed, we can no longer reap the dividends of peace. This observation led us, as early as 2017, to launch an unprecedented strategic exercise, then to pass two military programming laws that have resulted in doubling the budget of the French armed forces. But after the awakening of the Versailles agenda deciding on strategic autonomy for Europeans, these are now decisions that mark, in terms of defense, a shift to action. With the 150 billion euro loan from the Commission guaranteed by the Union's budget, member states will be able to borrow at the best market conditions for financing that will allow for short-term equipment, and therefore in a more immediate manner. The subsequent decision on more flexible rules of the Stability and Growth Pact will allow for the release of defense investments at the national level by member states. Several programs from the European budget, notably structural funds, are being reprioritized by the Commission to be used, again, for defense spending. The European Investment Bank is mobilized, or rather remobilized on its assets and activities. And obviously, the European savings, which we know to be abundant, will also be used and mobilized for the European defense industrial base, notably through the Union of Capital Markets.

All these short-term actions, and I thank the Commission once again for this work, have been validated. We have also provided additional guidance for the white paper, which will be finalized by mid-March and which will then prepare for additional decisions, particularly on financing, because beyond the very short-term measure of the 150 billion loan, we need to find indeed more sustainable common financing. I have been able to make several proposals on this and I can return to them if you wish in the questions. What is also important to me is the method behind this. It is that we obviously need to spend more, to invest more in our defense, but what we support is that these expenditures should not be for the purchase of off-the-shelf equipment that would again be non-European equipment. And as you know, this is what France has supported for several years, which has also been acknowledged, which requires defining priority areas, those on which we have either dependencies or competition between European and non-European solutions, air defense and anti-missile systems, artillery systems, including deep strike capabilities, missiles and munitions, drones and anti-drone systems, strategic enablers, including for space and the protection of critical infrastructure, military mobility, cyber, artificial intelligence, and electronic warfare. In these areas, the method is to identify the best contractors and the best companies we have, the existing programs, try to accelerate their pace and increase their production capacities, and ask each member state to re-examine ongoing orders to see if it can prioritize European orders, revisit the currently overly burdensome rules of procurement procedures, and thus simplify the rules for awarding these contracts, also revisit the very costly and non-competitive rules of geographical return that exist for many of our programs, space being perhaps one of the first tests and, I say, on a day of European space success with the launch of Ariane 6. We are therefore there, and it is a true surge of European investments that is being decided today, which is only a step, before the white paper, of additional decisions that will come in this semester at the Council level, but a deeper articulation, as you have understood, of our European defense industrial and technological base.

These decisions, for me, are a key element of what I called yesterday in my wishes, and on which we are also mobilized at the national level. That is to say, given the threat and whatever happens in Ukraine, we need to increase our defense capabilities and we need to build, over the next few years, autonomous defense capabilities for Europeans. I welcome the choices that have been made today, but also the very broad consensus that has emerged from our exchanges and that marks, in my eyes, a great lucidity of Europeans and a deep strategic awakening. We will therefore have, in the coming weeks, to draw all the consequences from this, in economic terms at the next Council, in terms of defense and security in the coming weeks, through new decisions. I will now answer your questions.

Journalist

Thank you, Mr. President, you mentioned this meeting of the chiefs of staff of the countries that are ready to provide guarantees in the context of a peace agreement in Ukraine, if it occurs, which will take place on Tuesday. You invited, if I understood correctly, also heads of state and government to participate. Can you tell us how many countries are ready to participate in this meeting and, beyond that, in the coalition for these security guarantees? And so, is the coalition, the Franco-British plan or the French plan supported by the British, I don't know how to call it, starting to take shape? Can you tell us where that stands and when you will be ready to present it again to President TRUMP, in particular, in Washington? And on this point, have you been able to make progress on the backstop, the potential safety net that many countries are requesting from the United States in order to be able to commit themselves to providing guarantees? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. On the initiative we have taken in connection with President ZELENSKY, with Prime Minister STARMER, with Chancellor SCHOLZ and several colleagues who are in support, and I want to thank Norway, the Netherlands, and several others here, we have essentially tried, through a series of sequences that have been constructed, to avoid a ceasefire that would be negotiated hastily without any guarantees. This proposal for sequences has been discussed continuously over the last few days, through exchanges with our Ukrainian friends, with President TRUMP and his teams. As you have seen, therefore, starting next week, and this is a very good thing, there will be a resumption of discussions. And so, the idea is that this can advance during the negotiations that will resume at the negotiator level in Saudi Arabia at the beginning of next week. And thus, for the first time since the beginning of this process, which was also one of our objectives, there is indeed a process that exists between the United States and Ukraine at the level of these negotiators to be able to advance on this scheme. We are making concrete progress to see what is accepted by each side and to ensure that this sequence, which allows for first building a measurable ceasefire, then the conditions for security guarantees, confidence-building measures, and ultimately a lasting peace can be followed. And so, it is in real time, so to speak, now, but there would be no hidden plan or plan that would be prepared. Action is taking place every day and so contacts are ongoing. I had a bilateral meeting with President ZELENSKY on this subject earlier. Just before meeting you after the Council, I had an exchange with Prime Minister STARMER, and we will have the Americans in the coming hours. So, we are making progress and we will see what can be achieved in the coming days at the level of the negotiators in Riyadh.

Thank you very much. Indeed, I think that today, as you can see, we are using what has not been taken from both the previous plan and other existing unused funds. And so, the Commission has done what needed to be done. It reacted very quickly on a legal basis that allowed it to do this and mobilize these funds. This is very useful because it allows for rapid decisions, rapid orders, and thus accelerates the programs that are currently in the hands of our major industries in Europe, but it is not enough. What we will support is indeed the idea that we can then have common financing because I think that the freedom, the budgetary space that is left at the national level is not a satisfactory solution because there are many differences between member states. And if we really want to have major European programs and have a European industrial base, we need European financing.

And so, what we will support is indeed that we can move towards innovative financing. Some propose to have the ESM as a basis, I am, for my part, in favor of looking at this solution, but also at the idea of a European defense loan, which would allow us to look more broadly at financing major defense efforts such as artificial intelligence, both being linked and both being key to our strategic sovereignty and autonomy. And I think that such financing is all the more relevant as it would allow us to bridge what will otherwise happen very quickly in our economies, which is the beginning of the repayment of the loan made during the COVID period, which will start from 2028. And so, you can see that the challenge for our countries is today to increase their national financing on priority issues and their major investments, including defense.

But this is not, in a way, responding to the repayment of loans that date back to yesterday. We need to give ourselves depth of field. And when we look at the aggregated level of the European Union or even the eurozone, we have an under-indebtedness of this space compared to the United States of America that gives us a lot of room. And I insist on this, the next 5 to 10 years, the DRAGHI report as well as the LETTA report have shown this very well, and the geopolitical situation accelerates this, these are the 5 to 10 years where we have massive investments to make if we, Europeans, want to rise to the level of the threat, if we want to respond to the investment needs in artificial intelligence, because the race is now on, and if we want to meet the challenges of decarbonizing our economies regarding everything we call green technologies. And so the priority is to mobilize common financing to do this now and to have rather repayment deadlines that will come when we have passed this hump, so to speak, and when we have secured equipment that allows us to be credible for ourselves, when we will reap the dividends of decarbonization, because in a few years, we will have these dividends. We are currently investing massively in our interconnections, in our networks, in our nuclear and renewable programs. All of this will allow us to be much less dependent on the cost of fossil fuels. And so we will have the dividend, so to speak, or the return on investment in 5 to 10 years. And so, I think that the right solution for Europeans is indeed to massively mobilize financing through the markets, in common, to show this common signature and to be able to do it particularly to go further in terms of defense. In parallel, I am in favor of having own resources. I mentioned several avenues this evening, including the famous digital tax that has been discussed for several years. I think the time is right to finally address this. It should be a European own resource, but we also need own resources to address this. We need a new leap, as we managed to do during the COVID period. On all this, I have obviously started the discussion with future Chancellor MERZ, and so we are making progress. Our teams are exchanging in real time. I think it is indeed an important moment for Franco-German convergence, and I will have the opportunity to discuss with him again in the coming weeks.

I have seen, however, between the COVID period and today, many developments on this subject. And you have seen it yourself: many states or political leaders who were once totally opposed to any form of common debt now support it if there are, indeed, the programs I mentioned behind it. On nuclear deterrence, I explained yesterday what it was about. What I proposed is to open a strategic conversation with the member states that were interested in advancing on this subject. Several of my colleagues have come to see me, and so now we will open a phase where our technicians will exchange. We will look exactly… We will open a dialogue that is both strategic and technical, and there will follow exchanges at the level of heads of state and government to see by the end of the semester if there are new cooperations that can emerge.

Let us look with lucidity at the situation we have been living in for three years. Why are Europeans, and all, more broadly, in this situation in the face of Ukraine? Because you have a nuclear power that is the aggressor. And so, quite legitimately, Europe must ask itself the question of nuclear deterrence for itself, in the broad sense.

Journalist

Good evening, Mr. President. I am a Russian journalist in exile here in France, thank you to the French Republic for hosting us here in Europe. I have a question about the reaction. Mr. President, thank you for your efforts, and your initiatives inspire optimism, but not for everyone. Have you heard the reaction from Moscow, for example? Mr. PUTIN was upset after your speech yesterday and stated, I quote: "There are still people who want to return to the time of Napoleon, forgetting how it ended." What do you think about this? And Mr. TRUMP also reacted to the issue of NATO. I quote him: "My biggest problem with NATO is that if the United States had a problem and called France, do you think they would come to help us?" That is Mr. TRUMP's question. What do you think of this reaction? And I have a more serious question, Mr. President. Donald TRUMP legitimizes Mr. PUTIN today. He has restored relations with Mr. PUTIN, with Russia. But you, as the leader of Europe today, are you personally ready to talk again with Mr. PUTIN? And when? Because in Washington, you also mentioned that after Bucha, it was impossible. And now, is it possible? Has the time not yet come to talk with Mr. PUTIN? Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you very much. On your first question, I know President PUTIN well, so if he reacts like this, it is because he knows that I spoke the truth and that I know he can betray the agreements he signs, and that he has already done so, and that I am here to testify to that, since we were with Chancellor MERKEL the guarantors, through the Normandy process, of the Minsk agreements that he deliberately violated. Then, I think he is making a historical misunderstanding, and I am surprised by him. Napoleon led conquests. The only imperial power I see today in Europe is called Russia, and it is a revisionist imperialist of history and the identity of peoples. Our will, we, is to be a power of peace and balance. Ultimately, everything we do, including the choices, by the way, to arm ourselves to avoid the war of tomorrow, are choices of peace. And so, I think President PUTIN should return to that vision. In any case, it is a historical misunderstanding in the reference. It is probably that he was stung by the fact that we have unmasked his game. If there is a ceasefire, it is not to make peace durably, it will be to better resume the war. To the question of whether France would come to help the United States of America, I will invoke our centuries-old history. LA FAYETTE came, PERSHING made the journey in the opposite direction by invoking this memory. I was, just a few days ago, alongside American veterans who had made the journey to Omaha Beach, and so many others have done so. We have always been there for each other. But would I dare to remind you that not just the French, but the Europeans were there when Afghanistan was sounded. And by the way, they were not politely warned when Afghanistan ceased. So, we are loyal and faithful allies. Let anyone who dares to doubt look simply at the contemporary history that is ours. It simply justifies what we have for the United States of America, what I have for its leaders, respect and friendship. And I think we are entitled to demand the same, because our history shows that we deserve it. I am ready to talk to President PUTIN when we have considered, with both President ZELENSKY and our European partners, that it is the right time. But now, we are entering a phase of discussion, of negotiations that, at some point, will fully justify discussions with negotiators and leaders. So the answer is yes. I will take one last question before I leave. Go ahead.

Journalist

Good evening, following what you just said, there was a statement a few hours ago from Marco RUBIO, the U.S. Secretary of State, about the depth of this war, where it comes from, etc., with the message he conveyed. That is to say, for him, we are in a war between the United States and Russia. In fact, Ukraine would only be a sort of proxy. That is the term he used on television. It is a rhetoric that is also employed by Moscow. What is your reaction to this way of speaking from those you still qualify today, obviously, as our allies, but thus this kind of rhetoric that is changing? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

I believe that it is inappropriate. I first believe that this war was unilaterally triggered by Russia. There was no intention from NATO, nor from any ally, nor from the Europeans, to threaten Russia's security through Ukraine. I can tell you this, and none of my predecessors, by the way, would say otherwise: we have always ensured this, and when proposals came, for example, to extend NATO, it was France and Germany that rejected it in 2008 in Bucharest, and it was no longer reconsidered afterwards. And so, in recent years, was there a form of pressure, tension, or a project, as I sometimes hear, of extension that would have justified a Russian reaction? It is false. This is a tale, a bad tale. There is only one aggressor, it is Russian, and it has decided to do so through imperialism, through a desire for expansion and a will to conquer Ukraine. Remember, by the way, three years ago, we were told that it would be a special operation that would take three weeks. And this operation, by the way, was conducted from the east and from the north, with several hundred thousand soldiers coming towards Kiev, which was liberated, as well as the north of the country, by the Ukrainians.

Then, I believe it is inappropriate to qualify this, because in a way, it absolves the Ukrainian leaders of responsibility. For three years, as far as I know, there have been no fighters, neither European nor American, on Ukrainian soil. We have helped, we have financed, we have provided capabilities, but the brave ones who fought for their territory and for their sovereignty are the Ukrainians, not us, nor Americans, nor Europeans. And so, to want to say today that it would simply be a discussion between Americans and Russians is to dispossess a people that has resisted for its survival of its dignity and its struggle. I believe that is not what we should do. So, no, it is a war of resistance of Ukraine against Russian aggression. That is all it is, and I believe we must continue to name it correctly. Then, peace will first involve the Ukrainians with the Russians at the table, but also the Europeans, as they are supporters and it is also about European security, and obviously, the Americans and other allies who have come to their side and who are important contributors on the financial and military level. There you go. I think that by naming things correctly, we can find a useful solution. Otherwise, we move forward sideways. I wanted to set the record straight. I will have to leave. Thank you, thank you very much.