PRESS CONFERENCE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE ENERGY SITUATION IN EUROPE.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

5 September 2022 · Press conference of the President of the Republic on the energy situation in Europe

Context
Macron held a press conference on September 5, 2022, addressing France and Europe's energy crisis amid the Russian war in Ukraine and soaring energy prices.
Main themes
Energy crisis in Europe, Russian gas dependency, energy price inflation, energy supply diversification, climate transition acceleration, energy savings and sobriety, European coordination, winter energy security, renewable and nuclear energy, gas storage strategy, war in Ukraine economic impact
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,293
79th percentile
Sentences
127
74th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.34
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

127 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Hello. Thank you for your patience.

I wanted to take a moment to quickly address the energy and economic situation for our country and for Europe in the context we are experiencing, after holding a National Defense and Security Council specifically on energy, and after intense coordination in recent days, both with the European Commission and with Germany; I was just with Chancellor SCHOLZ on this subject.

Indeed, for several months, our country and our continent have first been subjected to a rise in energy prices that has been largely driven by a very intense post-Covid recovery, a situation that has then been aggravated by the war launched by Russia in Ukraine, given what Russia represents in the fossil fuel market, whether it is gas or oil. At the beginning of 2022, I would like to remind you of the situation: 25% of all energy in the European Union was gas, and 50% of that gas came from Russia. This is the situation from which we are starting. And so, very clearly, this macroeconomic situation that has existed since the end of 2021, followed by the outbreak of the war, has placed our Europe in an unprecedented situation, where what previously seemed to be obvious, namely that we would not lack these fossil resources and that we could carry out our climate transition at the pace we had decided, has been called into question. Therefore, we now have an objective that is primarily to secure gas supply and, as quickly as possible, to accelerate our transition to be able to do without it and, obviously, in this context and in the meantime, to control prices and the resulting inflation. I say this in a context where, in one year, gas prices have multiplied, in the market, by five or six, and electricity prices have reached levels they have never known, with extremely significant speculative phenomena.

From the very beginning of the war, we reacted as Europeans. France held the presidency of the Council at that time. It was the Versailles agenda, from March 2022, that established that we needed to quickly exit our dependence on Russian coal, oil, and gas, with a strategy that consists of confirming and accelerating our climate agenda. The agenda, which we refer to in good French as "Fit for 55," is the agenda we carried during the French Presidency, passing numerous texts. It is the one that allows us to accelerate the exit from fossil fuels. However, we know that it will take several years, but the current situation confirms and reinforces it, meaning that it is an agenda through which we will electrify our uses, move towards more renewables, nuclear, and energy sobriety; these three pillars that underpin both the European strategy and the French strategy.

The second pillar is the one I mentioned: it is to accelerate energy savings, which I will return to, which, in addition to efficiency, is short-term.

The third pillar, of contingencies, consisted from March on of deciding to diversify our energy sources, including fossil ones, to face this geopolitical risk. This diversification has produced its effects but with choices made in some countries to reopen coal-fired power plants, with the licenses we granted ourselves to maintain certain thermal power plants that we wanted to close in France — and this is what we allowed by law — with the opening of new gas terminals — several in Germany that are being finalized — and, in the medium term in France, a terminal in Le Havre that will allow us to receive more liquefied gas. Above all, during this period, we accelerated this diversification by seeking other gas suppliers, which allowed us in a few months to go from the 50% of Russian gas I mentioned to 9% today in our mix. And then, alongside that, in a more structural manner, we are diversifying our production sources to move towards more renewables and nuclear, which, in our mix, is more coherent for exiting this dependence.

Now, at the moment we are speaking, we have, in the short term, two challenges. I think of the question that many of our compatriots are asking: how can we be sure that there will be no cuts and how can we be sure that we will best control prices? Indeed, in the short term, our will is to face, obviously, the coming months and particularly the winter months, and we have prepared — this is what I asked the Government, what all services have done — for a scenario of a cold winter and a scenario in which there would be a complete cut of Russian gas. This is the one, I would say, whose starting assumptions would be the most adverse, with an objective that is ours, which is to have no cuts in gas and electricity and to preserve our economic activity to avoid entering into an economic crisis.

To address this, we have already taken all the measures I mentioned: diversifying and protecting ourselves. The first element was to store. Store gas, since it can be stored to both be consumed by households or to produce electricity. We had set European and French objectives. The objective of 80% that we set for ourselves as Europeans is being achieved. In this regard, Europe is ahead by a few weeks of the objectives it set for itself, which has shown a mobilization of all countries. In France, we are around 92-93% storage compared to our capacities. Here too, we are ahead of the objectives we set for ourselves, which means that we all managed to mobilize, to consume a little less than expected in recent weeks, and above all, to mobilize capacities to store and prepare for winter.

The second key element of this strategy to get through the winter is to save the energy we can save: it is energy sobriety. I really want to emphasize this point because we each have a role to play in this matter, and it is very important. The best energy is the one we do not consume. And so, in this regard, the Government has developed a first series of measures. It has prepared a series of others, and we — I will be simple, the Prime Minister and the ministers will go into detail in the coming days and weeks. But our objective is, through this means, to save about 10% of what we usually consume. This is achievable through a series of simple gestures, by being first in a voluntary logic, if I may say so, and not coercive, by calling for the responsibility of each individual and sharing all the information we have. We are already saving energy compared to our usual behaviors because it costs a little more, it must be said, and because everyone is beginning to integrate this necessity. But if we mobilize, and it is indeed a plan for active mobilization that I am calling for, we can achieve this 10% objective in public consumption, in tertiary buildings, in households, and obviously in all sectors of activity. The Government will break down this plan sector by sector, but each of you has a role to play. A good part of this effort is to lower the air conditioning a bit when it is hot, which is rather the case at the moment, and to try to settle on a heating reference as soon as it starts to get cold, around 19 degrees in the room to maintain the ambient temperature. If we make these small collective efforts, then quite spontaneously, the country will be able to achieve its sobriety objectives. The Government will therefore break down this objective. For me, this sobriety plan is what should prevent us from moving towards something more coercive, which would then be a reinforced sobriety plan, or even rationing, and which, obviously, will ultimately protect us from cuts.

So, you see, in a way, it is by gradation. The first level of general mobilization is voluntary sobriety. And for that, there will be a breakdown sector by sector, a communication effort from the Government, and then we will also try to ensure that each person, that each of our compatriots has tools. I already invite everyone to look at Ecowatt, where you have very concrete information about the energy situation in the country, advice for concrete gestures, and which allows each of us to be, in a way, mobilized. So you see, to face these short-term difficulties, there is storage; then there is saving energy and this sobriety plan, by playing on the responsibility of each individual where they are, from individuals to economic sectors, the tertiary sector, and public administrations.

And then, the third lever is European solidarity. I want to emphasize this point because, in the short term, we have worked a lot on it, particularly in Franco-German cooperation, and I want to tell you here about the coordination and Franco-German solidarity that will be established on this subject, which we have been working on since the beginning of the crisis. If I had to simplify things, Germany needs our gas, and we need the electricity produced in the rest of Europe, particularly in Germany. This has nothing to do with the conflict in Russia, but it is related to a conjunctural phenomenon that today, the installed nuclear fleet in France is facing technical challenges that have led the supervisor of the Nuclear Safety Authority to request work from EDF. This means that we have more power plants than expected that are under maintenance. This adds to the problem I just explained, which means that we are producing less electricity in France than expected, and we need European solidarity. Therefore, fundamentally, we will contribute to European solidarity in terms of gas and benefit from European solidarity in terms of electricity in the coming weeks and months. This will be translated in Franco-German terms very concretely: we will finalize, in the coming weeks, the necessary gas connections to be able to deliver gas to Germany if there is a need for solidarity, and whenever there is a need. Already today, for the first time in a long time, France is exporting gas to Eastern Europe. We will strengthen this and position ourselves to be gas-solidarity with Germany if the winter is difficult and Germany needs it. The work was agreed upon during the council on Friday. They will take place in the coming weeks and are ready for winter.

In the same way, Germany has committed to electrical solidarity towards France, and thus will position itself to produce more electricity, and especially to provide us with its electrical solidarity during peak situations. This Franco-German solidarity is the commitment we made with Chancellor SCHOLZ, and it is one that we will uphold in the coming months, and which is part of a broader European solidarity that has been structured by the communications of the European Commission since the beginning of the summer, which called for solidarity among countries and a sobriety plan throughout Europe, as I have just outlined. This is to get through the winter. If we do what I just said, and if we position ourselves accordingly, our vision is that we can look at things calmly. And so, in a way, the solutions are already in our hands today if we know how to meet the call for sobriety and solidarity.

Then, there is the question of prices, of course, which concerns many of our compatriots. On this subject, the measures are primarily national, and they are, in a way, corrective measures. France was among the first countries to take them, as early as October-November 2021. We implemented a series of shields, particularly in response to the surge in electricity and gas prices. We also took measures regarding the price of gasoline that have increased from the last contributions we received in recent weeks, with concrete effects at the pump these days. In a way, we have avoided a rise of about 50% to 70% in gas and electricity prices for our compatriots. This means that France is one of the countries that has best protected households and small and medium-sized enterprises in Europe. Many countries are now adopting our measures, and this is indeed the direction of the plan announced yesterday by the German Government, which aligns with the logic of many of our measures.

All of this means that today, France is among the countries with the lowest inflation rates in Europe, among the lowest rates in the eurozone, and that today we have maximally protected households and businesses on this issue. Nevertheless, we know that in the coming months, we will need to better target and have a more structural response to help with thermal renovation and the electrification of practices and to target our responses to support households.

This must be accompanied by European measures. The Commission is currently preparing the work - I have had the opportunity to have several exchanges with the President of the Commission - and fundamentally, we have been working on this for several months. I want to state here the position of France regarding the main axes that seem to be emerging. First, we are in favor of common gas purchasing practices. This would allow Europe, by buying collectively, to purchase at a lower price. Therefore, we will continue to act, and I believe I can say that Chancellor SCHOLZ shares this vision; we discussed it a moment ago, to act concretely based on what we have agreed at the European level.

The second point is that if the Commission were to decide to set a price cap on gas purchased through pipelines from Russia, France would support such a measure. It seems to me to be consistent with our sanctions policy and to reduce these prices.

The third point is that we advocate for a European contribution mechanism that would be requested from energy operators whose production costs are significantly lower than the market selling price. There are indeed undue profits being made by market operators today, and the right approach is for a contribution to be requested from them at the European level. This contribution could then be redistributed to the Member States to finance their targeted national measures. This is the approach we support, and it is the approach that France and Germany support. It is the most coherent way to avoid distortions between European countries. It is the fairest, and it would be the most effective. If such an approach could not be achieved at the European level, then we would be forced to consider it at the national level. Already, this is what we have done with certain operators in recent months, as you may have noticed. There is also a Franco-German convergence to defend such a European contribution mechanism if the Commission proposes it in the coming days.

Finally, to reduce price volatility, it seems essential to us to have measures to combat speculative practices that would allow for better regulation of margin calls and hedging practices in the markets that have led to soaring prices and, in a way, the multiplication of real effects on the markets by certain operators. We wish to have at least a Franco-German agreement on this, as we committed earlier with Chancellor SCHOLZ, and our hope is that there can be mechanisms to control these speculative operations at the European level.

That is for the short-term price aspect. Therefore, I hope that the Commission can finalize its work in the very near future, and I want to reiterate all of France's support for the work of the European Commission since the beginning of the crisis and on these measures.

In the medium term, which means in the coming months, we need to continue to move forward at a rapid pace, first to produce more and produce more alternative energy sources, particularly electricity, in France and Europe. That is why I have asked the government to finalize legislative texts to accelerate our renewable energy and nuclear production projects. Today, our pace regarding the work to enable production capacities in renewables or nuclear shows that our projects are too slow. I will be in Saint-Nazaire as soon as possible to inaugurate the offshore wind farm, which I was supposed to do today but was prevented by the weather, which allows me the privilege of being before you and has enabled me to exchange with my German counterpart. But imagine that this project was launched by my predecessor. Therefore, in the face of the challenge we face today, we must go much faster in the production of these renewable energies, and thus drastically simplify things. We are at war; this is a fact. Energy is part of the instruments of war used by Russia, and therefore we must absolutely put ourselves in a position to produce alternative sources of electricity more quickly.

The second point is to accelerate the electrification of our practices and thus to move much faster on the thermal renovation of buildings, on the conversion of the vehicle fleet, and on the installation, as a key model, of hydrogen energy transport at the European level.

Then the third element in the medium term is to reform the electricity market. Today, as you know, this market at the European level has two flaws, and I hope that we can work on this in a Franco-German manner. There is now a Franco-German agreement on this subject, and we have a real convergence of views with Italy as well.

First, we must finalize the European electricity network and multiply European electrical connections so that electricity can circulate in the most efficient and rapid manner between countries.

Then, the price on this European electricity market must be formed in a much more coherent manner and in relation to production costs. Today, the price of electricity on the European market is far too dependent on marginal contributions, particularly those from gas, especially at peak times. This is absurd for countries like ours and some others, and it results in an electricity price that is disconnected from the reality of production costs. This is what leads to certain operators making excessive profits. I hope that the European Commission is preparing to correct this in the short term. Therefore, in the medium term, the European market must not have this distortion, and thus it needs to be reformed. So these are the three main axes in the medium term on which we want to advance.

These are the few words I wanted to share, in a way the axes I wanted to outline to explain what the strategy is, both French and European, in this matter. All of this will lead to the development of a strategy that the Prime Minister and the relevant ministers will explain. First, on the sobriety plan, which will lead to a presentation and especially an exchange with all economic sectors, and then to successive commitments. Then, in parallel, of course, the Prime Minister will also launch structuring exercises for the country: the national low-carbon strategy, the multiannual energy programming, which will be launched this fall to lead to legislative exercises at the end of the year or the beginning of next year. We will have the opportunity to return to this clearly. All of this at the European level will also lead to the Commission's work in the coming days, which will be explained within the framework of the Commission's college. And of course, all of this will be worked on at the next European Council in Prague, allowing us to advance there as Europeans as well. These are the few words I wanted to say before answering your questions.