Press conference of the President of the Republic with Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk in Nancy.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

9 May 2025 · Press conference of the President of the Republic with Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk · Nancy, France

Context
Macron addressed a joint press conference with Polish PM Donald Tusk in Nancy on May 9, 2025, to mark the signing of a Franco-Polish Treaty of Friendship and Enhanced Cooperation.
Main themes
Franco-Polish friendship treaty, European defense and security, mutual defense clause, strategic autonomy, support for Ukraine, NATO and EU cooperation, European defense industrial base, historical Franco-Polish ties, Nancy as symbol of bilateral history, ceasefire and peace guarantees, European sovereignty, bilateral cooperation
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,533
82nd percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
11.3
37th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

174 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister, ladies and gentlemen ministers, Mr. Mayor, thank you for your welcome. Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians, Madam Member of the European Parliament, ladies and gentlemen mayors, elected officials, Madam President of the Departmental Council, Mr. President of the Regional Council, Madam Prefect, ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and qualities, let me tell you how happy we are. I believe I speak for both of us when I say that we are honored to be by your side today to sign this treaty of friendship and enhanced cooperation between Poland and France.

There are obviously the symbols, the history, and I will return to that, but there is also what we feel today and what the residents, through their welcome, have testified to, and the atmosphere that prevails at the prefecture, and then in this Hôtel de Villiers. I want to thank our two ambassadors and all of our diplomatic teams for the immense work that has been done to finalize this treaty. So, it is primarily about friendship, as I said. Franco-Polish friendship is a heartfelt alliance that has its roots across the centuries and is, at its core, constitutive of European history. As early as 1573, Henri de Valois, Duke of Anjou, was elected King of Poland, a fleeting king who later became Henri III of France, and who left, I believe, a lasting memory in Krakow. Then, in the 18th century, there was an intimate, familial bond, thanks to Stanislas Leszczyński, former King of Poland, who found in Nancy a land of welcome and expression, leaving an indelible mark on the city, and as Duke of Lorraine, opening the way for the transformation of the city, but also its rapprochement with the Kingdom of France. And under his impetus, yes, the city became a hub of the Enlightenment, a vibrant point between Polish culture and the French spirit, and we saw that again in this square that bears his name earlier. In the 20th century, Nancy, as its mayor recalled earlier, welcomed many Poles, and the whole region and, may I say, the whole country, especially after the First World War, nourishing the local economy, weaving lasting ties between families and generations. In 1988, the twinning with Lublin, confident in this fraternal complicity, fostering school, cultural, and university exchanges. And Nancy continues to honor this history, which is a living symbol of what Europe can do best, transforming memory into dialogue and peoples into allies. And this is what this treaty of friendship and enhanced cooperation will seal.

First, speaking of defense and security, we share with the Prime Minister a clear and strong conviction. We need a united, strong, sovereign, and competitive Europe, and our joint work, Poland and France, can make a decisive contribution to that. We have a central responsibility for peace and security on our continent, which the Russian aggression against Ukraine has been trying to undermine for more than three years, dare I say for more than ten years. This responsibility begins with our resolute support for Ukraine to achieve a ceasefire, to create the conditions for a robust, lasting peace based on solid security guarantees for Ukraine. Poland is currently holding the presidency of the Council of the European Union this semester. And with Poland and our European partners, we have decided to take on a greater share of our responsibility for our own defense. And this strategic awakening for European defense has been accelerated since the European Council in March, in order to mobilize public and private funding and to invest massively in the European defense industrial and technological base. We know indeed that this independence, this strategic autonomy will only come through an increased capacity for Europeans to produce their own defense instruments, their own weapons, their own munitions, to develop a common culture, to conduct joint operations, but also in all areas of dependency, whether in technological research or industry, should strengthen European autonomy. This is how the Nancy treaty will greatly contribute to strengthening it, as it establishes bilateral cooperation on each of these points.

In this Nancy treaty, we have also decided to send a very clear signal by integrating a mutual defense and assistance clause in line with our common commitments within NATO and the European Union. It is a truly integrated defense partnership that we want to build. It does not replace NATO or the European Union, but it strengthens and operationalizes the link that already exists. In the same way, we are establishing a European preference that will allow us to enhance our capacity to produce together, and not simply to increase our spending to buy what is produced by others. With Mr. Prime Minister, we wanted this treaty because we are both convinced of the need to elevate our bilateral relationship to an unprecedented strategic level and to establish a close dialogue between our governments, ourselves, and all the actors in our relationship, to implement with determination the commitments made today. Our economic cooperation will intensify, with a bilateral economic forum, an annual high-level dialogue on civil nuclear energy, enhanced industrial coordination, particularly in defense and transport. We finally want the Franco-Polish relationship to support our common ambition for Europe, this Europe of industrial sovereignty that I mentioned, reducing strategic dependencies, and we have targeted several future technologies: artificial intelligence, quantum, biotechnology, energy, space, and defense.

This Europe of competitiveness that indeed assumes and defends its own interests also defends fair competition, that is to say, it protects wherever it is not, in order to preserve the integrity of our value chains, to protect our strategic or sensitive sectors, whether in industry, materials, I speak from experience in this city, or in our agriculture. Finally, this treaty gives us concrete tools to respond to the challenges we face, to protect our values, our democracies, our rule of law, particularly by establishing enhanced cooperation to combat foreign interference, cyberattacks, or anything that threatens our democracies. And you understand, ladies and gentlemen, that with this treaty, we come to seal, to recognize a deep friendship that has been nourished by these exchanges, these intersecting lives, and sometimes these august destinies. But we also come to open a new page that alone will make possible the European history of tomorrow, by closing a dark chapter that opened in the 1930s of the last century. When in Western Europe, for a moment, it was believed that the Nazi advance would not affect us and that we did not intervene, even when a city that is dear to you, Mr. Prime Minister, Gdańsk, was attacked.

Then, a second moment, when in 1947, we let down an iron curtain that separated Europe and deprived Central Europe of the prosperity it was entitled to. That is why, even though this curtain had fallen since 1989, even though Poland and many others had returned to the natural course of their Europe, and even though for more than 20 years you have joined the European Union, it must be said, there was still doubt, there were still differences. Perhaps we did not see Russia as the same existential risk. The last few years have reconciled us. And perhaps you continued to believe that the American guarantee was valid for everything, and was certainly better than that of other Europeans. We had not truly demonstrated otherwise. With this treaty, we open a new page, one through which we build irreversible solidarity, a trust built through crises, and particularly those of recent years, and a willingness to assume towards our peoples and for Europe the fact that, from Brest to Krakow, Europe stands together. And this friendship treaty is also that.

We are very proud, in any case, that in Nancy, this treaty is thus signed and that a new page of our bilateral and European history can thus be opened. Thank you very much.

Journalist

I have a question regarding the treaty. Times are not easy. We are not sure that the Americans will remain in Europe. And so there are many Poles who are asking the question: what is the value of these guarantees? You yourself mentioned Gdańsk, the city of Prime Minister Tusk. At that time, on September 1, 1939, we also had an agreement with France. France did not come to help Poland. Poland was left alone. How could you convince the Poles today that in the event of an attack from Russia, of course, not from Germany, this time it will be different? I know there is this doctrine of strategic ambiguity in France. But perhaps there are ways, for example, to have French troops in Poland or other means that would show that France, this time, is very serious.

And a second question, if I may: the political situation in France is also complicated. We cannot rule out that in two years, it will be Marine Le Pen or Jordan Bardella who will be elected president. Marine Le Pen, who is very pro-Russian, or at least, she has said so many times. What will be the value of this treaty at that time if Marine Le Pen or Jordan Bardella are at the Élysée? Thank you very much.

Emmanuel Macron

First, I will try to put into perspective where we are. There is a fundamental fact that changed after the Second World War, which is that we created NATO with mechanisms of solidarity that did not exist previously, including the famous Article 5 that we talk about so much. And this, our two countries have. And it is a real change compared to the situation of 1939 that you recalled.

The second thing is that we are convinced, and I have been advocating this for 8 years, that we need to strengthen the European pillar of NATO, not to exit it, not to weaken NATO, but because, let us be lucid, what our American allies ask of us, administration after administration, and indeed in a fairly bipartisan manner, is to take on more of our share. And so our security must increasingly be our own responsibility. That is legitimate. And that is why I believe in a Europe of defense that is not an alternative to NATO, but that consolidates within it. This is the whole meaning of the recent decisions we have made, the historic moment of March 2022, our Versailles Summit where we affirm strategic autonomy, and in economic and defense matters, we want to do more, and it is in this spirit that this treaty is situated. European preference, cooperation, and indeed, a clause for strengthening solidarity. And what does this clause bring? It operationalizes the solidarities that are provided for in our texts, whether in NATO or in the texts of the European Union that also foresee this. That did not exist in 1939, it is different. And we are advancing, if I may say, a further step on the bilateral level, densifying it, making it more credible. You have, within NATO, American troops deployed in Europe.

The United States represents about a third of the military effort made by NATO on our Eastern flank. If they were to withdraw completely tomorrow, it would obviously be a massive change, and obviously, we do not wish that. But then, we would organize ourselves, and we Europeans would know how to face it. But I tell you, our wish is that they stay, to continue to engage them, but it is also to strengthen ourselves to be less dependent on the randomness of decisions that are not ours. And that is the whole meaning, by the way, of the historic increase in military spending that Poland is making, which is one of the highest levels in Europe. It is the highest, I believe, around 5% of its Gross Domestic Product. And it is what France has been doing for 8 years now with two military programming laws that have indeed led to doubling the budget of our armed forces, with additional efforts that we will have to make. And our conviction is that this treaty, through the choices of cooperation, through the clarity of the solidarity clauses, is a real change and gives even more robustness to these agreements.

Finally, regarding the upcoming political events, as you noted, we are democracies. Does that make us weaker? No. In a few weeks, Poland will vote in presidential elections where two camps, two approaches to Europe will be presented. It will be the same in France in 2027, as it was previously. And I have confidence in our peoples. I believe that, in any case, the events of yesterday and today show us one thing. We cannot succeed alone. And the answer is not in a narrow nationalism. Peace through Europe, peace for Europeans through greater solidarity and cooperation in economic and military matters is more crucial than ever for our countries. And I believe that this sense of history will triumph despite all vicissitudes. That is why I think that what is being signed today in Nancy is eminently solid.

Journalist

In these uncertain times and in light of this treaty which aims to repair past traumas in the event of a threat to Poland, would France be able to act in less than 30 days, Mr. President? And in terms of nuclear deterrence, what do you mean, Mr. President, by making NATO's Article 5 and the European Union treaty operational? What do you mean by operational? How can this happen concretely? What does it mean for a nuclear power like France and for a country like Poland? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Regarding the engagement capabilities of the armed forces, the decision-making processes available to France under its Constitution, the organization of our armies, the constant investments made, and the quality of its personnel and command mean that I have no doubt that, yes, such a deployment would be possible in the face of aggression. And if the worst were to come, I would point out that when Russia decided on this act of aggression against Ukraine in February 2022, we were able to deploy troops to Romania in 5 days. No other European country was able to do it as quickly and with such mass. So, we have this capability, and it will obviously be activated if such aggression were to occur.

As for the solidarity clause in this signed treaty, it involves all components. And as you know, there is the greatest discretion surrounding nuclear deterrence. But in this matter, we have a doctrine. It has existed since the 1960s, articulated with great caution, because its ambiguity conditions its effectiveness. And since the 1960s, with the words of General de Gaulle, the European dimension of this deterrence has been affirmed. And it has been constantly reaffirmed by all my predecessors. And I was able to do it myself a few years ago. This means that in the decision-making regarding what constitutes vital interests, the interests of our main partners are integrated. There you go.

Journalist

Will this treaty be followed by markets in the defense sector, by concrete contracts? And if so, what will their scope be? And does this treaty mean that there will be joint Franco-Polish exercises in military Poland?

Emmanuel MACRON

The Prime Minister has perfectly articulated the matter. To answer your question, we are signing a treaty of friendship and cooperation. It will then be concretely developed, but we are opening fields of partnership that had never been assumed in terms of defense, civil nuclear, and many economic areas. And then, within the appropriate frameworks, companies will do their work. The second thing I wanted to mention, returning to the Prime Minister's remarks that I fully share, is that our Europe has been too dependent on its security and defense on the American ally for too long. That is not the case for France, which has a unique history in Europe and which has an army today that is one of the most effective on the continent and which is independent in all its capabilities from the United States.

That is not the case for Europe as a whole. However, we do not want autarky. We do not want to cut ourselves off, to separate, to remain withdrawn. But in the middle, there is a path, this middle way that we are taking, that of strategic autonomy, which means that, on everything that is essential, we want it to be European and we wish to cooperate with our American allies. But wishing to cooperate with an ally is not the same as being dependent on them. That is exactly what we need to build. And so, in the coming years, that is the challenge for all European governments, to build the strategic autonomy of our Europe. And that is exactly what we are contributing to with this text. Finally, yes, I hope that there will be, and we will organize, joint exercises between our armies in the coming months.

Journalist

Volodymyr ZELENSKY announces a summit tomorrow of European leaders in Kyiv. Will you attend? And what message will you bring? Second question: Vladimir PUTIN demonstrated strength today in Moscow, on the occasion of the commemorations of World War II, alongside the Chinese president, among others. He justified the war against Ukraine as a continuation of the fight against Nazism. How do you react to these statements and to this gathering? And do you approve of the presence of the Slovak Prime Minister? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

There will be a meeting tomorrow that will be partly virtual, partly physical, of what is called the coalition of partner countries for the security of Ukraine, which we initiated at the beginning of the year, and we will participate in this meeting which will be partly virtual, partly physical. As for the trip to Ukraine, for many understandable reasons, we rarely talk about it beforehand, but I have always said that in due time, I will go there, and I can only reiterate that statement.

Then, regarding the parade on November 9 in Moscow, it conveys some very simple elements. First, President PUTIN is on the side of war, not on the side of peace. The bellicose statements he has reiterated, the reality of each day reminds us of that. And those who may have believed that he had a desire for peace are mistaken at this stage. And that is the entire message we will defend in this meeting tomorrow, which is our desire to build peace, but a solid and lasting peace. That is to first achieve a ceasefire of 30 days, which we support with the United States of America, which President ZELENSKY has unconditionally agreed to as he is the aggrieved party, so that this peace of 30 days, which can be guaranteed, supervised by the United States, and we will contribute to it, helps to build what is necessary for a lasting peace, agreements on territories and agreements on long-term security guarantees. That is what will allow for robust peace, the security guarantees being what will deter Russia from restarting the day after, the day after which could be a few months or a few years. And the experience we had between the Minsk agreements and February 2022 has shown us that this is what it is now seeking.

Regarding the statements made by President PUTIN and the comparison between our current situation and Nazism, it is an inversion of values, but he is not the only one and he is now accustomed to it. It is a historical revisionism as well as a profound error. Nazism is a totalitarianism that had its specificities. Putinism is an imperialism. And it now lives only by territorial expansion, the threat to internationally recognized borders, and international disorder.

As far as I know, Ukraine has never violated internationally recognized borders, nor expressed any desire to invade its neighbor. And so, the one who is today the cause of the war, the one who perpetuates the war and the one who threatens peace and, in doing so, the international order, is President PUTIN and no one else. As for the presence of the Prime Minister, I rarely comment on decisions made freely by other decision-makers in Europe. I am not sure that it is the most opportune thing on May 9. I am not sure that it is the best reading of the second half of the 20th century, but there are sometimes paradoxes. Would I dare to simply remind that there has been a difference for many peoples between Moscow yesterday and Brussels today, because he is among those who compare these two capitals.

If my reading of history is roughly correct, Moscow was a capital endured. Brussels, for all of us, is a chosen European capital, freely, by our treaties, by our choices. That makes a big difference, even for those who do not want to acknowledge it. Today is Europe Day, the day we celebrate the founding fathers, this idea, we celebrate it in a wonderful way by signing this treaty of friendship. And I prefer to think of Schuman and Monnet than to make them turn in on themselves.