Speech by President Emmanuel Macron and exchange with Vietnamese students.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 May 2025 · Exchange with Vietnamese students

Context
Macron addressed students and faculty at a Franco-Vietnamese university in Hanoi on May 27, 2025, celebrating decades of bilateral educational and research partnership.
Main themes
Franco-Vietnamese educational partnership, humanistic values in education, bilateral relations between France and Vietnam, higher education and research cooperation, student exchange and dual degrees, common challenges for younger generations, technology and human dignity, scientific collaboration, cultural and knowledge exchange
Duration
~79 min
97th percentile
Words
9,518
97th percentile
Sentences
468
98th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 34%31%
  • Geopolitical 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Technological 13%12%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Not in focus 8%

468 sentences in 113 paragraphs

Madam Rector,

Mr. Rector,

Madam Vice-President,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Gentlemen ambassadors,

Mr. President of the Academy of Sciences and Technologies,

Ladies and gentlemen alumni and dear students.

I am very happy to be with you today.

I will try not to give you a long speech; I will say a few words about the situation and essentially try to explain why I believe we have a common future, and we will especially try to have something more interactive.

If you would be so kind, I ask you to ask questions as freely as possible. I know that this is always a difficult exercise, but it will be more interesting, including for you, because at that moment I will be completely sure that I am not saying something that is completely off your expectations.

In any case, as you reminded us, Madam Rector, Mr. Rector, this university is the result of a common will and also of the extraordinary work that has been accomplished over all these years. As I address you, standing before you today, I am also aware, with great humility, of all the work that has been done, generation after generation, to build this partnership through knowledge, science, and education between Vietnam and France.

There is the intergovernmental agreement you mentioned from 2008, which has gradually made this university a hub for the relationship and for higher education and research in Vietnam. I believe it ranks about fifth in terms of research in the country. But it is also a hub in partnership with many universities and research organizations, and I salute the directors general and presidents who are here. We have several universities that are very connected to you, but also CNRS, IRD, CNES, CIRAD, CEA, and many companies that are partners as well, such as Dassault and others, in this connection.

I am extremely happy to be here among you, in a country that has made educational relations and teaching one of the cornerstones of the bilateral relationship. I was looking at this on my way here; we have more than 15,000 Vietnamese engineers who have been trained in the French system. We have more than 3,000 Vietnamese doctors who have specialized in France. We have hundreds, and I hope tomorrow thousands, of jurists who will continue to have dual degrees and make our lawyers, magistrates, and all legal professions bridges. I say this with even more humility because we have in the room some of the pillars of this relationship, Lê Kim Ngoc and Jean Trân Thanh Vân, with their connection to Vietnam and all the work that has been done at CNRS over many years, but for the bilateral relationship, they are here and have worked so hard for this relationship, to continue to promote knowledge between our two countries.

Françoise Barré-Sinoussi has also been one of the patient architects of this relationship, and then our joint business school, Mr. Director General, you mentioned it to me upon arrival, is also one of these pivots. I say this, there are, at the moment I speak to you, decades of partnerships, of joint degrees that are represented and embodied by the alumni, associations, and excellence that have presided over this relationship.

At its core, what characterizes it? I believe I can say a form of conviction in a humanistic model, that is to say, in the fact that mutual understanding is important for progress, in the conviction that we must understand the philosophy, the evolution of our societies, the great technologies at work, and that there is, as you just quoted Corneille, a certain idea of man, in the generic sense of the term, thus of the women and men and generations that you are, who must both embrace knowledge but do so in the service of a certain idea of humanity. That is to say, who never considers that a technique or a technology would be superior to the principles that found us and, indeed, to those humanistic values that mean that we place, in Vietnam as in France, nothing above human dignity, this conviction that the free and rational individual is the one who can guide the world. That is what places education at the heart of the project of our two nations.

That is why I am very happy that on the occasion of this trip, we were able to sign new school partnerships, a new school. We continue to consolidate this university, research, and cultural partnership between Vietnam and France.

Once I have said that, trying to ask myself what might interest you and how to tell you that this partnership is not just, at its core, what has united us for decades, but that it is perhaps even more important today than yesterday, I wanted to talk to you about the great transitions that are underway and tell you that, in my eyes, what your generations have to experience, in Hanoi as in Paris or Toulouse or Angers or in all the cities of France or Vietnam that have seen you born and are making you study, is that we have very common challenges in a world that your generations have to live in and which is undoubtedly one of the most shaken, because resolutely more shaken than the one my generation, when we were in your place, had to live in, because you are at the crossroads of very profound transitions, and I believe they touch on what you are learning today, and I would just like to share very quickly a few convictions in this regard with you.

First, we are experiencing a very significant geopolitical transition, and I believe it structures many things, and it partly explains, justifies my presence here today. Geopolitical transition, because, if I had come to see you perhaps even just 10 years ago, so almost yesterday, I would have spoken to you about a confident world, sure of itself, which had very great challenges, I will come back to that. But where, in truth, we managed to build, after the Second World War, great principles. And we are in a world where international law prevails, where democracy is expanding, where the values that place human dignity at the heart of the political project are there and where we have collectively succeeded, since the post-Second World War, in stabilizing the world.

You can see that this is not the discourse I can give you today. It has changed in just a few years. Because we have the return of wars, so your continent has experienced tensions, frozen wars, very strong geopolitical tensions. But at the moment I speak to you, we have war in Gaza, in the Middle East, we have war on the African continent, we have war in Europe with the Russian aggression in Ukraine. Beyond these wars, which are obviously for us, moreover, daily geopolitical battles because we pursue this objective of peace, we have great powers in the world that have decided no longer to respect international law and no longer want peace. That is a very profound change. So, war is back, the sovereignty of peoples and territorial integrity are being contested, including by great powers that are permanent members of the Security Council.

We also have the return of deep tensions, much more than 10 years ago, and we find discreet ways to mention them in the region. But since we cannot give a diplomatic speech at my level by saying that freedom of navigation, maritime freedom is important for the South China Sea, it is clear that something is happening that worries everyone. And the conflict between China and the United States of America is a geopolitical fact that casts the shadow of the risk of a much broader conflict in this major region.

In addition to this, there are disruptions in international cooperation. Several powers have decided to withdraw from the Paris Agreement, and now international trade, which was also governed by rules, where 20 years ago, in your region of the world, we were asking how to fully apply the rules of the World Trade Organization. This question has become obsolete, since the world's largest economy has decided no longer to respect them. It imposes tariffs that change depending on the morning we wake up. We are all currently at 10%, but you, perhaps tomorrow at 47%, the Europeans, perhaps at 50%, and perhaps the day after tomorrow, it will be another figure, because unpredictability has once again become the master.

That is the world you have to live in. It is very different from the one in which I grew up. But it is a fact. Something has gone awry. We live in a world where, particularly due to the disinhibition of superpowers, everything can tip.

It is in this context that I believe the alliance between Vietnam and France is even more important and the alliance between ASEAN and Europe is even more important. Because there is something that binds us. You know that we, the French, I think the Vietnamese are a bit the same. I had one of my predecessors who said that we are a middle power. We do not like to say that too much; in fact, we are quite proud. Always saying that we are a great power. We are a great military, geopolitical power. So, we are a great power. But we are lucid; we are not one of those two great powers in the world, and neither is Vietnam.

But we have an interest in trying to preserve, rather to rebuild, great geopolitical balances of peace and prosperity. That is what I believe. It is at the heart of the European Union's adventure, it is at the heart of the ASEAN project, it is what should found our partnership. So, in this geopolitical moment, this transition or this disruption, Vietnam and France must pursue an objective that is to rebuild partnerships of peace, balance, and prosperity. That is what should bind us, and that is what should also bind ASEAN and Europe. We do not want to depend on great powers. We want to cooperate, but by choosing.

And so, in all areas of play, our education, our innovation, our industries, our health, our energy, our geopolitics, our defense, our objective for the years to come, and undoubtedly at least for the coming decade, will be to reduce our dependencies and to build a path of freedom, this freedom of sovereignty.

This is the project that is at the heart of what I formulated for the region in 2018, which is our Indo-Pacific strategy. I presented it in 2018. We made it a European strategy in 2020-2021, but it is what, for me, is at the heart of this relationship, the freedom of sovereignty. We do not want to depend. We want to be able to work with the Americans, with the Chinese, we want to have the best relations in the world, but we do not want to depend on them. We want our sovereignty, our stability, to be respected everywhere, in Europe as here. It is at the heart of this geopolitical project that is the Indo-Pacific, which also recognizes the centrality of ASEAN, and it is also at the heart of a project that we have carried and of which we are a part, which is what I called the 4P, which is this pact for the prosperity of peoples and the planet that we founded in Paris in the summer of 2023, which connects 70 countries and which consists of saying: we have common ambitions that consist of wanting peace, prosperity, thus fighting against inequalities, and fighting against climate change, its consequences, the disruptions and the disruption of biodiversity, without choosing, and what reconciles a North-South agenda, where often we had opposed them.

That is the first element I wanted to present. We are living a moment of geopolitical transition. Your generation has something unprecedented to experience. And the alliance between Vietnam and France is fruitful, as is the alliance between Europe and ASEAN, because it builds new balances. That is the Indo-Pacific strategy.

In this context, we have a challenge to meet, all of us on the planet, and your generation will have to further accelerate what we have started and what we were very late on, which is the climate challenge, and which, at its core, is this formidable challenge that is an environmental challenge, but also a health challenge, which is to say how we achieve this humanistic vision, but by respecting a playing partner that is indispensable: the planet in which we live, that is to say, to avoid, to reduce, to mitigate our CO2 emissions, but also to adapt to a world that is already warming, and therefore to move away from economies that are too dependent on carbon; how we must preserve and also regenerate biodiversity, because it plays a fundamental role, again, in reducing CO2, but for our balances and our ecosystems; and how we must build a new health in this context.

I link the three because they are inseparable, as we now know. It is a nexus of climate, biodiversity, and health, which is absolutely fundamental. We all experienced this together with COVID, and we will continue to experience it in an accelerated manner. If we disrupt our ecosystems, we will bring about new pandemics, and we will be unable to solve our health problems. This transition, which is both a transition of our ecosystems and an energy transition in the organization of our societies, is one of the most complex challenges to address. This is what we have been trying to build together with our researchers, our scientists, and all stakeholders in recent years. There was an awareness at the Paris COP ten years ago, and we will celebrate the anniversary at the end of the year, but we are all working together to build an agenda. It is at the heart of the 4P that I mentioned, and it is fundamental. It is also at the heart of the partnership between Vietnam and France.

Why? Because Vietnam is a very large economy that wants to continue to develop, to quickly reach an intermediate income level, but to be a wealthy economy. It has remarkably succeeded in the last 30 years with outstanding economic results, but the Vietnamese economy has a challenge: it is too dependent on carbon, primarily coal. That is why France wants to be one of the partners in the decarbonization of the Vietnamese economy. This is what we concluded just two years ago, which is the program for Vietnam's just energy transition, the famous JETP.

We are partners; we have already invested 250 million euros with AFD, and we will invest another 250 million euros, but we want to help Vietnam build this future strategy. Why? Because we have know-how, because France itself has energy, electricity that is quite decarbonized thanks to nuclear power and expertise, but we want to succeed together and meet this challenge, which is a challenge of training, research, development, and industrial partnership in hydropower, energy efficiency, and nuclear power, and that is what we are building.

Just before meeting you, I was with the Deputy Prime Minister, several ministers, and several companies. It is also a challenge of know-how, of changing practices, of transformation.

The second key challenge, and where what you are doing is fundamental, is to succeed in this, that is, to achieve a simultaneous growth and ecology, which I also believe in a lot. For decades, in our societies, there has always been a risk that we have been told we must choose. There are those who are for ecology; they are degrowth advocates, and there are those who are for the economy; they are necessarily polluters. This is total nonsense.

We have, in all our societies, to build models of growth, productive models. You, to reduce inequalities and continue to increase income; we, to create wealth and continue to finance one of the most generous social models in the world, have the same challenge. We must continue to create wealth. We simply must do it while achieving carbon neutrality by 2050, preserving our biodiversity, and taking into account this nexus that I mentioned: health, biodiversity, CO2.

This is possible through the reorganization of our ways of producing, consuming, through our fundamental research and innovations. This is also a challenge of the partnership between Vietnam and France.

The third major transition that you have to experience, and there is certainly a remarkable acceleration over the last two years that we have to live through, is the transition, I would say technological, but fundamentally, it is more than technological. It is the transition of artificial intelligence. In saying this, it is, if I may say so, a transition of transitions, if I had to give a formula, because it also has something anthropological about it.

I wanted to say a few words about it. We held a Summit on Artificial Intelligence in France in February. We tried to build, first of all, projects for France, which I believe is the leading country in Europe, along with Great Britain, in terms of artificial intelligence, but which also faces a geopolitical challenge because we do not want to depend on China and the United States, which are undoubtedly the two major engines of innovation in this field in the world.

But artificial intelligence is undoubtedly one of the most fundamental revolutions we have to experience, both to lead and to build, but whose consequences we must think about. On this, we can debate, and we can return to it in the questions. When we listen to some experts, we get the impression that artificial intelligence is something that will replace humans. I do not believe that at all. I do not believe it is an alternative superintelligence. I do not believe in that. It is the continuation of something that the scientists here, some of whom are much more expert than I am, have been experiencing for decades, which is what we called machine learning and which has always… well, not always, but at least in recent decades, has developed a lot, etc. The only thing is that our computing capabilities have transformed in recent years. We have computing capabilities that have increased exponentially and even more, which have given us the ability to go faster and stronger, and these models of what we call machine learning have begun to touch language. This has created a form of collective destabilization because we have the impression that these learning machines, which were in robotics or other fields, are becoming human because they process language, which is the most intimate thing we have. But they process language, not like you and me; they process it as an extraordinary computing capability because they know how to associate words and arrange them logically and even extremely intelligently.

We are at that point. And so we are at a moment in humanity where we indeed have computing capabilities, innovation, and a transformation of these learning machines and thus of artificial intelligence that revolutionize many things: our way of learning; they are at the heart of the educational revolution; our way of producing because they will completely commoditize many functions; our way of organizing collectively.

The link between artificial intelligence and robotics will also profoundly transform uses, that is for sure. In the face of this revolution, what is our strategy? And this is a bit what we want to do with Vietnam. We are not afraid. And the "we are not afraid" has, if I may say so, several translations. We want to be part of it, so we want to be at the heart of the capacity to innovate, so we want to go faster, stronger; we want to attract investments. We want to train talents, and so we train them in France; we have one of the best schools for data scientists, mathematicians, etc. We want to develop the partnership with Vietnam in this regard. We want to create computing capabilities at home to be more sovereign; that is what we are doing; it is this race for data centers; you are also in it. And we want to have the best artificial intelligence companies and those that stem from it because we want to be sovereign.

But "we are not afraid" also means we do not want an artificial intelligence model to emerge that is not in the service of humanity. We want to be able to think about its balances, its development, and put it at the service of our societies, our balances, and help us go faster in thinking about these ecological transitions that I mentioned, to go faster in the service of science to have more personalized, preventive medicine. There are many ways to have AI in the service of humanity. But we do not want a model that is, in a way, a crazy or uninhibited model that has a somewhat post-humanist vision that aims to enslave humanity to the service of the machine. This is a real philosophical debate; we can return to it, but this is what we advocate.

For this transition, which is now here and is in a phase of acceleration, Vietnam and France have much to do together. You are a country that trains a lot of very great scientists, men and women who have great expertise in commerce and management, like France. We want to carry this same vision together, participate in this competition, and, in a way, we do not want to have to choose between an artificial intelligence that is entirely made in the United States or entirely made in China, or to have to choose between these two models. We want to have, there too, a pluralism of models that alone allows for balances and serves the geopolitics that I mentioned earlier.

As we want an alliance that is not hegemonic, that respects independence, that preserves peace and balances, we want to develop artificial intelligence and companies in this field in a partnership manner, which will range from health, as we will do shortly, to robotics, through energy or others, which participate in the same humanistic vision of this transition.

The last word I wanted to have is on demographic transition. We talk about it insufficiently, but our planet is undergoing a real revolution. We are 8 billion, and we will continue to grow. We are far from the theories that predicted that beyond a certain number, the planet would no longer be sustainable. But this collective demographic transition that we have to experience has, in fact, protean faces.

First, we have a tremendous food challenge; 8 billion on the planet, we still have hundreds of millions of our compatriots, sometimes, in any case, men and women on this planet, who are undernourished or malnourished. But above all, we have not thought about the balances for this demographic change. This exactly ties back to what I just said, which is that we need to think about the innovation that allows us to have a planet of 8 billion and perhaps even a little more.

Especially when I talk about these 8 billion, we have very different challenges. We have an aging Europe and the United States; we have a China that is also beginning its aging, which is a real revolution. Imagine a country of 1.4 billion inhabitants at your doorstep that is becoming old. That is a revolution. And we have extraordinarily young countries, yours being one of them, where we need to provide opportunities.

This demographic transition obliges us to do what? To build new forms of cooperation. We are very far from that because what is happening in our world? It is, in a way, a fear of demographics, meaning that countries that today cannot provide a destiny for their children are in forced immigration, and that is all we see on the African continent and elsewhere, and it destabilizes, but it also impoverishes these countries in the process. The richest countries that have become old are increasingly afraid of immigration because it destabilizes them. Therefore, we must think about new forms of cooperation in this area because we will need organized, chosen migrations that respect the cultures of each, the balances of each country, but that also allow us to build balances on a global scale.

We will need — because I do not want to be longer — two essential things. 1) To consolidate education and training systems in the youngest countries and 2) to also lead the training and transformation systems of our social systems in the oldest countries.

Let me explain. If we want to succeed in the demographic transition that the planet is undergoing, we will need to continue to multiply training, pedagogy, all that we are doing and which is at the heart of this partnership. Because the key is that in all countries where there is a demographic dynamic, we train this youth well.

The challenge is there; if we know how to train this youth, it will be a treasure. If we leave it without training and without economic opportunity, it will be a problem for these countries, a threat, and it will be at the mercy of all ideologies, fanaticisms, or forced migrations. The challenge for training is key. That is why educational policy will continue to be at the heart of the partnership between Vietnam and France, but more broadly in the region. That is why we will continue to invest in the training of all talents and continue to do so at home in France, whether it is at the primary level, at the university level, or in our research.

The second thing is that we need to think about the aging of our societies. This means thinking about the organization of the life cycle in societies like ours, also thinking about health systems that need to be more focused on prevention, on the ability to treat chronic diseases, because they will multiply in aging societies, and thinking about the place of each individual, because, in fact, we are societies that were designed and thought out in their organization in the aftermath of the Second World War, that is to say, with a very different life expectancy and a very different life cycle. This too is a real revolution.

The demographic transition must not be underestimated in what we are experiencing. Based on this, that is why France will continue to invest in its schools, its universities, its research. That is also why I am very happy that we have been able to complete an eighth school on this trip. But it is also for this reason that, and I say this here with great joy at USTH, this new era that we are entering will be marked by more academic exchanges. I come here with the ambition to double, by 2030, the number of our academic exchanges and the students we want to welcome in France from Vietnam. Because I believe this is an essential ambition if we want to succeed and continue based on this very strong partnership that we already have. We will continue to have this unique model that is the French model, but I want it to be at the heart of this relationship and that we double the academic exchanges that are currently ours in the next five years.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, these are the few convictions I wanted to share with you. We are entering a new era. It is at the heart of this geopolitical, climatic, technological, and demographic transition that I have just tried to describe.

For this, I deeply believe that what binds Vietnam and France is a chance, because we have a common vision, we do not want to depend, we have a certain idea of humanity, and we want to meet these challenges by believing in progress, in balance, and in peace.

These beliefs are not mere pious wishes, and they are expressed here by the president of a secular Republic. They are simply humanist beliefs and resolutions for action for the future. You understand, we will do everything to ensure that your generation can succeed, but your generation has immense challenges ahead. I will now answer all your questions. Thank you very much.

Moderator

Mr. President, first of all, a big thank you for this speech, this strategic vision on the major transitions that I think will leave a mark.

Student

Thank you very much. Hello, Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen. I am a PhD student at the USTH laboratory. I am currently working on climate change and historical meteorological databases of Vietnam.

I want to thank you for your speech, which is both very engaging and very inspiring. It is a true honor, not only for me but for all the students of USTH, to be able to listen to you and welcome you among us today.

Next, in your address, I would like to ask you a question. As you mentioned, the transition of technology, artificial intelligence, and digital technologies is taking a very central role in our lives. But it is also when we more often depend on a small number of large providers of our data, our software, our infrastructures. This raises real questions about our independence, our digital sovereignty. Do you think that open source could be the solution for the future? In your opinion, should we invest more in this area? Thank you very much, Sir.

Emmanuel MACRON

You are absolutely right. That is what we are trying to do, and that is why we need to come together to do it. And if there was a need to say that it is a problem to depend on a single entity, what we are experiencing in your field of research, with the American choice to suddenly cut everything, shows that. The decisions made by the U.S. federal government regarding NOAA, for example, jeopardize part of your research field. Because you have a federal government that no longer believes in climate, in the climate transition. It says, "I completely stop, but I put at risk the databases for calculations and also the equipment that were essential for all climate monitoring researchers, for the planet, for the oceans."

In the face of this, what should we do collectively? It is a bit what I was saying, it is the common thread of my speech. We must do everything to depend less. We want to cooperate with everyone, but we must not depend. So yes, in your field, climate, meteorology, we have extraordinary capabilities today for satellite observation. We have computing capabilities, the image with artificial intelligence, which today allows certain laboratories, certain companies, to predict, I say this with great caution because I am under your scrutiny, and there are scientists much more eminent than I am, so I try to poorly repeat what I have learned from them.

But we can, with artificial intelligence, model things much better and therefore predict. It is wonderful for the knowledge of the planet, but also imagine predicting events that will happen, that is to say, an earthquake here, a cyclone there, etc. It is a considerable advance.

Simply, we are still too dependent on certain countries, certain observation capabilities. There are two major champions: the Americans and the Chinese. All the others must continue to work with the Americans and the Chinese, but first, we must always ensure that the system is open. I say this here, I will respond specifically to open source, but the key is that we defend a model of free and open science. That is to say, it should never be up to the leaders to say: we are not allowed to research here or we are not allowed to research there. And that must be a universal guarantee.

That is why we launched, by the way, a few weeks ago, "Choose Europe for Science," to tell all researchers who are hindered in these programs, come join France and Europe, because you have a haven of peace there and we let you research freely.

The second thing is that we must reduce our dependencies. That is to say, we must, in Europe, in Southeast Asia, in Latin America, in Africa, build research capacities, computing, and observation capabilities that are less dependent on the Americans and the Chinese. This is absolutely fundamental. So, we want to be partners, but not depend. And regarding artificial intelligence, we must first continue to train talents in our countries. This is the first key element.

The second key element is that we must have data centers and computing capabilities in our countries so as not to depend solely on American and Chinese capabilities.

The third, yes, we must then ensure that models, whether they are LLMs or all models, are open source models. You are absolutely right, that is what we are developing in France. It is at the heart of the first artificial intelligence strategy we launched in 2018, and then of the second one we renovated, that is to say, we want to launch, at the French and European level, open models. We need these. We need them so that they are not closed on geopolitical bases.

We also need them in the cooperation that is ours.

I say this here because you spoke in French, and I thank you for that. Francophonie is also a key element in this strategy. I do not want to be too technical, and if there are other questions about this, we can come back to it. But when we have a language model, for example, when we then have AI that allows for research, the way you trained your artificial intelligence is a bias. If you only allow English-speaking, Chinese-speaking artificial intelligences to exist, you will have a big problem because their biases will be English-speaking.

That is why we also want to develop, with open source, artificial intelligence models that are trained on French, that is to say, that have knowledge of references, thesaurus, language biases, untranslatables, do not work if you have completely trained them on English. In the same way, we need to train them on Vietnamese. With open source, there is also the idea, for what we call Large Language Models, to have models that we train on multilingualism. I defend Francophonie, I defend it here with you, but Francophonie is a language of passage, that is to say, it is open to others. So, a wonderful revolution, and yes to open source, yes to, in a way, open models, and yes to partnerships between ASEAN, Europe, Vietnam, and France, on talents, data centers, and scientific cooperation on this.

Student

The world is, as you also mentioned, shaken by these technological mutations and international balances. With your experience, what skills do you think we, the students and young graduates, should focus on?

Emmanuel MACRON

I do not want to be prescriptive because I think that all the disciplines in which you are engaged allow, in this changing world, to find a reference point and to succeed. I would be wrong if I told you it is this or that, perhaps also because I am not capable of predicting the world you will have to live in 10 years, in 15 years. But fundamentally, that is a bit the vision we carry. It is a humanist vision, and it consists of encouraging you to have the best possible education. And so, I will not answer your question. Rather, I will try to answer it indirectly. I will not tell you that you need to study biology or data science or I don’t know what, because in fact, I do not have the right answer. But I would just like to share a few convictions.

Study and do so with passion because that is what allows you to learn in one field, in one discipline, but also in many others, in fact, because the approach that consists of learning or seeking depends on the study cycle you are in, you can then deploy it in many other sectors. It is an approach that consists of doubting, learning from books, from your teachers, and therefore having a relationship with and humility towards the knowledge that precedes you, recognizing an academic authority that is stronger than you, questioning that knowledge when you then have the ability to critique and question it.

I believe that this, whatever discipline you embrace, is more necessary than ever in the world we have entered, which is a world, as you can see, where uncertainties are constant, but where there is a risk, it is to enter into post-truth. There is a risk, it is to enter into the leveling of everything and into a form of hyper-relativism that will, in my eyes, lead the world to a form of despair. For me, one of the risks facing your generation is that we say, as I have access to Twitter and I can insist or tell the best chemistry professor in the world or the best philosopher: "you are an idiot" and have more people liking my tweet or following my Instagram, I am stronger than him. That is a bit the world we live in. This world is dreadful. Do not think it is desirable. It is a world of fools.

I think that the one whose thought you do not understand, do not critique, do not comment on with a 140-character message. Try to understand it. I think the moment we are in is a moment that will either consume itself or must make a transition. Studying allows you to have reference points. I do not believe that all words are equal. I think there are people who know and there are people who know less well than others. That is what you learn in studies. It is the principle of academic authority, of peer recognition, it has value. I believe we should not be in a world of invective; we should be in a world of doubt, because we are in an increasingly complex world. Learning teaches you doubt, that has a lot of value.

There have always been controversies in the academic world between the ancients, the moderns, between such theories that wanted to return to such another. We are in a world of invective. Learn respectful controversy. That has a lot of value.

We are, as I said, in a world of post-truth. It feels like everything is equal, images, things. The relationship to truth that you learn in your studies has immense value. Immense because it is what allows us to live in a society with common frames of reference. For all these reasons, I would tell you to continue learning, and then to seek. Whatever the discipline, whether it is medicine, management, biology, or something else, this is fundamental for your generation.

The second thing I would like to tell you is to continue learning beyond that. And in fact, the secret is that you will never finish learning. So, perhaps you will be a researcher, or a teacher, a teacher-researcher, then you can do it in an academic setting, but wherever you are and whatever you are, consider that it is never finished. Because human knowledge is expanding and I think that all those who continue to try to learn, well sometimes trying, because we may have less time, is a personal, mental approach that is tremendously important. Because precisely, it allows us to continue what I just said: humility, respect, and the ambition to know better, to understand better, and therefore to serve a better world.

My third piece of advice is also to say, never think that one discipline is worth more than another, have this somewhat humanistic taste that consists of being as complete as possible. And if you are currently, I don’t know what your discipline is, but learning technologies or something else, be curious about poetry and philosophy. If you are in management sciences, try to understand artificial intelligence and quantum computing. We all have limits, I am the first, but being interested in the rest, trying to have the most universal approach to things, I believe, is important. Here are some pieces of advice and a guide.

But my greatest advice is: do what you believe is good, be free because it is knowledge that makes you free. And freedom begins – to paraphrase Victor Hugo – every time ignorance begins to stop. That is true freedom, through knowledge, and not otherwise.

Student

In 1971, the sixth investment plan of the French state, launched by President Pompidou, highlighted nuclear energy, industry, and high-speed trains. There are similarities with the current project in Vietnam, initiated by Secretary General Tô Lâm, and so, do you consider, with the hindsight and experience of a great country like France, that state planning is capable of advancing countries and ensuring their longevity?

Emmanuel MACRON

Secretary General Tô Lâm presented to me, explained his strategy, and I must say that, first of all, he was a wonderful host and friend during this state visit with my wife and myself. And I am very impressed by what your country is doing, achieving, and, in a way, the new era, the acceleration in which your country has entered. France, after the war, had several planning initiatives that were necessary because we had to rebuild and there was a very significant role for the state. Then, we abandoned planning in our country. Why? Because as the share of the private sector became significant, as we entered a mature, wealthy economy, with more and more innovations, it is undoubtedly very difficult to have planning for all sectors.

You are at a moment in your economic life and with a political and economic organization that is different and therefore justifies this planning. Planning in France has allowed for major projects and it enables great things to be done. And you are right, everything you mentioned is true, the major railway, space, and industrial projects. And by the way, sometimes, the exit from planning has led us not to see things and to miss opportunities. Other times, we have also made mistakes in planning, you know. So, I would not say that there is a single model that works. But I will share some convictions from a country that has done planning and abandoned it.

For example, in ecology, we have resumed a form of light planning, but since 2022, we have an ecological environmental planning, but it is not at all what the post-war plans were. First of all, it is normal in certain sectors for the public authority to have a role of impetus. It is a good thing and it is necessary, because there are sectors where we need to align partners in the same direction, we need to invest so much money, etc., that they do it. That is a yes. But in an economy, the public authority should not be everywhere and at all levels, because sometimes, it is more effective to have private structures. So, there is a good balance to be found.

Secondly, we need to have a political impetus, but it must always be able to be questioned by the private sector and by science. Why? Because you cited very good arguments where the public authority decided on a large nuclear program, which was indeed heavily supported by very prominent scientists. Other times, you know, we made mistakes. You have seen what we called the computing program and others. We launched major public programs and went off track. Perhaps something more open, more contradictory with science could have worked. I think it is very good, even when we have planning or other systems, to have this dialectic of constantly questioning. That is why dialogue with universities, researchers, and all stakeholders is beneficial.

The third element, in reality, what are we saying? The right balance is to maintain a capacity for mobility that the private sector offers, but to have a certain relationship to the long term. Essentially, what the state brings, what planning brings, is a long-term perspective, which is rather a good thing, because we are in a world that can go in all directions very quickly. Does that mean that I think today we need to reintroduce planning in all sectors of the economy? I am not entirely convinced, because we need the flexibility and adaptability that the private sector provides. So, I believe in a complementarity. But, in a way, the lessons I have learned from our past are that there needs to be a role of impetus from the state in the face of certain major technological challenges. The state must be there to ensure sovereign missions and also to finance free education and research.

Then it is very good, even when we have planning or some other systems, to have open, public debates between science, the public sector, and the private sector. And even if we are in a world that is moving faster and faster, it is good to maintain a certain relationship to the long term. We have managed to turn the light back on.

Student

When choosing a destination for international studies, France is certainly one of the countries where tuition fees are among the lowest in the world compared to the quality of education. So, could you explain the specific financial mechanism desired by France that so few countries in the world adopt? Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

I could say this, to be as happy as a student from Vietnam in France. Thank you for this question that might seem naive, but in fact, so many French people no longer ask themselves. And you are right. In fact, if it is not the student who pays, it is the French taxpayer who pays. It is a model we have chosen, but we forget that. And by the way, in our country, we completely forget to mention it. What other country in the world indeed has almost free education, with a third of students being scholarship holders, a third no longer having student health insurance, and it being covered by the public authority? There are none.

So, in our country, we have debates because housing, which is true, is still too expensive, this, that. But your question reminds us that in all the countries where a student like you must travel, studies can sometimes cost tens of thousands of euros, not just for foreign students and for our own, but for students from the country. So, the model that is ours is one where we consider that it is, in a way, the public authority and therefore the French taxpayers who should pay for higher education. I defend this model. So, I think that afterwards, we need to allow flexibility to institutions. I believe in the freedom, in the autonomy of universities, so that the model can be diverse. But I think that this model, in any case, where the core of funding comes from taxpayers, is a good model.

Because it allows progress and has also enabled fairer access to higher education. And I think that is a strength. Simply, the difficulty we have is that sometimes we forget it in our country. So, it needs to be reminded. Because it is a collective choice. We are happy not to pay for university, we are not happy to pay taxes, if I had to summarize things and the daily problems we have to live with. So there you go, that is the French model. On top of that, we have Campus France, which does remarkable work and helps support foreign students. And then, there is always the cost of housing, things that need to be paid by the student. But I believe that this model is a good model and we will continue to develop and consolidate it in the coming years to try to attract the best talents from around the world, to also try to spread these talents across the world. Because if a student like you comes to France to learn at a university in Paris 6 or Montpellier or wherever, she will forge an extraordinary connection with France.

Of course, first of all, it is a human, academic adventure, which is justified in itself. But even for France, in fact, it is an investment in the future to do this. Because through you, I will have someone who will love France, who will then perhaps train many students in turn and make them love France, who may have responsibilities in Vietnam tomorrow and who will never forget or have forgotten Paris or Montpellier, who will have known our authors, who will... And that is priceless. That is priceless. So there you go, the French model, I think it is a good model. It is quite atypical and you are right to promote it, but I would like to tell you that indeed, we have access to university that is among the cheapest in the world, but we also have, and above all, an education that is among the best in the world.

And it is the reconciliation of the two because alongside that, there is a very high quality of higher education research. It is the combination of the two that makes sense. I believe a lot in this model and thank you for promoting it in this way.

Student

As you know, architecture is a profound cultural expression, but also an economic lever, and France is especially in the context of ecological transition and the transformation of territories. So as we know, France is a country of diversity and also of singularity. Could you elaborate further? And how does this diversity manifest? And what are the advantages for students?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. And I will conclude on this point and perhaps have a final word. It is a continent that you have opened. No, France is a great nation of architecture and we are very proud of our architects. There have been several Pritzker Prizes recently awarded to architects of all generations. And we are very proud that, by the way, they export themselves all over the world and come to work here and everywhere else. And as you said, the transitions we are experiencing also lead us to rethink the model of architecture. So, I would be hard-pressed, in fact, I would be unjust to characterize the French school. I think it is diverse and that we have all generations of architecture and that our architects are in a permanent dialogue with their counterparts, their partners, their friends from all over the world. But architecture says something about the society we want. And I have spoken a lot about transition, perhaps in an abstract language, but architecture gives a sensitive content to the life project we have. That is what makes your discipline a true art. That is why we promote it in France with the Minister. It is because we believe in our architectures and our architects are artists.

They allow us to think about the city. You are in a country that continues to urbanize, and thinking about the city through architecture means thinking about its balances, that is to say, the ability to reintroduce greenery, to find balances between the natural and the urban. It also means thinking about services, how to have a sustainable, intelligent city that better considers mobility and other aspects. So all of this, our architects are currently designing. And we have many architects who are architects of a new urbanism, very present in your region, who envision an urban environment that is indeed more human-scale and that gives space back to vegetation. The second thing is that we have — this is more for certain neighborhoods in your area and many capitals that have already been overbuilt — we need to think about the city on the city, that is to say, how to regain height to avoid sprawl, which is harmful to the climate, but also how to think about palimpsest cities, because many of our cities actually have several generations. And so, we have more and more architects who no longer destroy, but who are architects of respect for past generations, for past architectures, for what has inhabited and existed in the places. And so, it is no longer an architecture, if I may say, triumphant or oppressive, but rather one that reinhabits and reinvents.

All this to say that there are several models, as you mentioned, but French architecture has several schools, and it grows… in fact, it inhabits these transitions that I mentioned. And it tries to think of new forms of urbanism, it tries to consider the aging of populations when it is with us, it tries to think about the climate transition by being more virtuous in thermal terms, by being less about urban sprawl, etc. But above all, it brings beauty to this changing world. And in doing so, it is the most beautiful mark of respect for those who will have to inhabit the works of our architects. It is to say that everyone has the right to beauty and to access beauty. So that is also why we defend architecture.

So, it has been illustrated in major projects we have had, in Villers-Cotterêts or at Notre-Dame de Paris, we have great architects and all the craftspeople who have expressed themselves, but it also expresses itself in all the major international projects where our architects are often among the candidates, often awarded, and the projects that we promote, and the scholarships that we give to young architects. We did it in the new world, and we continue to do it in our architecture programs. And so thank you within this university, Professor, for promoting this magnificent discipline.

I would like to conclude by thanking you for your attention, for your questions, and for also fostering this partnership between Vietnam and France. And you have understood, I think that we indeed have this common future. But I would like to say one last word about the French language. First of all, to invite you, when you come, you have to come to Paris, well to France, in the months or years to come, we have just created an extraordinary place half an hour by train from Paris called Villers-Cotterêts, which is the International City of the French Language. Villers-Cotterêts, perhaps you do not know this place, is the city where François I made French the language of administration in France. Then, several hundred years later, it is the city where Alexandre Dumas was born. There was a castle, the castle where François I signed his ordinances, which was in ruins. We completely restored it with the minister, also with architects, scientists, and researchers. And our researchers invented an International City of the French Language there. And by the way, we do a lot of things there on artificial intelligence and the possibility…

Finally, the necessity of having Francophone models. We train teachers, we conduct research on the language. It is an extraordinary place. Come visit! But above all, continue to learn French, to learn in French, and to convince your peers to learn French. Why? Because it is a language that inhabits all five continents. There are very few languages that are native to all five continents, due to the history of France and its overseas territories. The second thing is that it is a language that is not hegemonic; there are very few French speakers who only speak French. French is thought, and will continue to be thought, in multilingualism, in plurilingualism, in constant exchange. This is indeed how we conceive our strategy for Francophonie. And the world we have, in which we will evolve, is multilingual.

The third thing is that this language, by 2050, will be the second or third most spoken language in the world. Why? Because there is an extraordinary demographic dynamic in French-speaking countries, particularly on the African continent. And if you, students, want to seek, work, do business in Europe, Africa, the Pacific, Latin America, French is one of the few languages spoken on these continents. And if I speak, for example, of the African continent, which has an extraordinary future ahead of it, it is by far the first language of this continent and the bridge between all languages. So French is a language of this common future. Therefore, I truly invite you to embrace it with the generosity that accompanies it. And I do not want to be long; I wanted to thank you. And thank you for speaking French today. I want to express my guilt for not being able to do the same in your language. My very great respect for the Vietnamese language.