Speech by Emmanuel Macron at CRIF, Louvre Palace, February 20, 2019.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

20 February 2019 · CRIF annual dinner · Louvre Palace, Paris, France

Context
Macron addressed the annual CRIF dinner at the Louvre Palace on February 20, 2019, condemning a surge in antisemitic acts across France.
Main themes
Resurgence of antisemitism in France, recent antisemitic murders and attacks, French Jewish heritage and memory, Holocaust remembrance, government failure to combat hate crimes, call to action against antisemitism, France-Israel friendship, tribute to Jewish French figures, desecration of Jewish graves, far-right and nihilist violence, universal human rights
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,762
84th percentile
Sentences
185
87th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.34
82nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 51%50%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

185 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Senate, Mr. President of the National Assembly, Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council, Prime Ministers, Mr. Minister of State, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, Madam Mayor of Paris, Madam President of the Île-de-France region, Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians, Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors, Ladies and Gentlemen Religious Leaders, Mr. President of CRIF, Ladies and Gentlemen.

Like each and every one of you, I would have wished that this dinner - the second I have the honor of attending as President of the Republic - be held under more serene circumstances. We would have spoken with emotion of Claude LANZMANN, what he gave to France by joining the resistance at the age of 18, what he offered to the world with his monument

SHOAH

, this immortal work against the inexorable work of forgetting over time. We would have remembered Marceline LORIDAN, who passed away in September, and her tireless efforts to transmit the memory of the genocide and her audacity. Of Georges LOINGER, who left us in December, taking with him a life of heroism, he who saved nearly four hundred Jewish children during the Second World War. We would have relived together that sunny morning in July when the French people gathered on rue Soufflot to commune around the blue, white, and red coffins of Simone and Antoine VEIL. Simone VEIL, who drew from the unspeakable horror of the camps the strength to further elevate through her struggles for memory, for women, for Europe, the universal work of France. We would certainly have revisited the 70-year friendship between France and Israel, which the 2018 cross-cultural season brought to life and which President RIVLIN's visit to Paris in mid-January sealed. Perhaps we would even have exchanged views on René CASSIN's role in drafting the Declaration of Human Rights, this common grammar of nations, of which we just celebrated the 70th anniversary.

Yes, each and every one of us would have liked to discuss all of this. This Jewish part of the French soul, this history of French Jews that has contributed to making our nation beautiful and great. But the moment we are living calls for a much graver discourse. For several years - and the situation has worsened in recent weeks - our country, like the rest of Europe and almost all Western democracies, is facing a resurgence of anti-Semitism that is undoubtedly unprecedented since the Second World War.

Once again, for several years, anti-Semitism has been killing in France.

It is indeed that the faces populating our consciousness this evening are not only those of the heroes I have just mentioned but also those of the martyrs recently murdered because they were Jewish. Mireille KNOLL, this 85-year-old Parisian who survived the roundups but not the murderous madness of her executioners, Sarah HALIMI, this mother of three children seized in her sleep, assaulted and then thrown out of a window by her murderer, Ilan HALIMI, this young man in his twenties kidnapped, tortured, murdered. And then the victims of the Hyper Cacher attack in January 2015 - Philippe BRAHAM, Yohan COHEN, Yoav HATTAB, François-Michel SAADA - those of the Ozar Hatorah school - Jonathan SANDLER and his sons Aryeh and Gabriel and little Myriam MONSONEGO shot at point-blank range. We do not forget them. The twilight of the twentieth century had allowed us to glimpse the possibility of a lasting retreat of anti-Semitism. The dawn of the 21st century reminds us how tragic history is, how sad passions are at work, how darkness returns. And that a son of Polish Jewish deportees who loves France, its language, to the point of becoming a member of the Académie française, is insulted by a hateful crowd while returning home, that in Paris on a restaurant window the inscription “

Juden

” is painted surrounded by swastikas, that on the town hall of the 13th arrondissement the face of Simone VEIL is covered with the same swastikas, that in Alsace dozens of Jewish graves are desecrated as if an attempt had been made to erase the dead of all these people, that Jewish religious representatives, anti-racist activists, journalists are insulted, threatened - dear Joël MERGUI, dear Ariel GOLDMANN, dear Philippe VAL, dear Hermann EBONGUE - that in a shared nihilism, a shared violence, rejecting the sacred and anti-parliamentarism, churches and elected officials are attacked. I could unfortunately continue this list and speak of what too many anonymous individuals suffer and do not even dare to say.

In the face of this unacceptable situation, it would be false to say that we have done nothing. We have condemned much, adopted plans, often for years and years, voted on laws sometimes. But we have not been able to act effectively. That is true. And if we are where we are today, it is indeed for that reason. And this litany that I have just recounted is our failure.

Too much indignation. Too many words. Not enough results.

The time has therefore come for sharp, concrete actions.

Because I do not want to become accustomed to these words and these indignations. “There is something worse than a perverse soul,” wrote PÉGUY, “it is a soul that has become accustomed.” We do not have the right to become accustomed souls.

First, name the evil

, which increasingly hides behind the mask of anti-Zionism.

I said it during the 75th anniversary of the Vel d'Hiv roundup, anti-Zionism is one of the modern forms of anti-Semitism. That is why I confirm that France, which, as you recalled, endorsed it in December with its European partners, will implement the definition of anti-Semitism adopted by the International Alliance for the Memory of the

SHOAH

. This is not about changing the penal code, much less preventing those who want to criticize, as you reminded Mr. President, Israeli policy from doing so, no. Nor about revisiting subjects we know and which are those of international politics - and on this subject, the French position is known and we debated it last year. It is about clarifying and strengthening the practices of our law enforcement, our magistrates, our teachers, enabling them to better fight against those who hide behind the rejection of Israel the very denial of Israel's existence. The most primitive hatred of Jews.

In the same way, there will be no complacency regarding boycott practices and BDS, which have been condemned several times in France and will be condemned again.

Next, face the reality without filters.

Yes, alongside, unfortunately, traditional anti-Semitism, there is a form of anti-Semitism based on radical Islamism.

Yes, this ideology is corroding some of our neighborhoods to the point of forcing an unbearable internal exodus. Yes, it is to a republican reconquest of these territories that we must dedicate ourselves. This is what we are doing when we create police and gendarmerie positions in 45 of them, multiplying the involvement of all state services, the National Education, all civil servants, and methodically deploying a plan to combat radicalization. And in this matter, let us not yield in any way to the block-to-block opposition in which some would like to confine French society. One religion against another. One stigmatization against another. No. The Republic protects all citizens, all consciences, all words, and it cannot accept, under any circumstances, that in the name of a distorted religion or any philosophy, the worst is committed, because it is the Republic, because it is our freedom.

Track and punish those who commit anti-Semitic acts.

Nothing is more unbearable for victims than the absence of sanctions. Nothing is more incomprehensible for our fellow citizens than the feeling that “everything is permitted,” which animates the sowers of hatred and undermines the authority of the State. I call, for this purpose, regardless of the fatigue, I know, all victims of anti-Semitic acts to file a complaint as soon as they are insulted or attacked. They should be assured that everything is being done to support them in their efforts, from the training of our police and gendarmes to welcome and listen to them, to the possibility of filing a complaint online, which has just been voted with the adoption of the Justice Law. It must be implemented as soon as possible. On this subject, we had become accustomed, it must be said, to uncertain practices; complaints that were not always taken; complexities. Things have now been simplified in the Law. They must be applied in practice. They require that nothing be accepted and that no habit, in a way, be taken. Everything is also being done to gather evidence. Specialized teams of investigators and gendarmes will be created in all territories, based on what has been started in Aix-en-Provence, in partnership with the Camp des Milles Foundation. You then mentioned, Mr. President, the so-called virtual anti-Semitism. It is only virtual in name. In this faceless hatred, which believes it is free from all rights, lie the seeds of hatred that then spills into the streets and commits the worst. This slow poison that leads nearly 2 out of 5 French people, primarily informed via social networks, to believe in a global Zionist conspiracy. This too, we must combat with strength and clarity. We have already begun work with platforms like Facebook, which has chosen France to launch a fund endowed with 1 million euros in favor of civility and against hatred, and which has accepted the presence within it of French regulators and lawyers to improve certain practices. I said last year, in front of you, on this subject, my desire to carry a demanding project at the European level. Work has been done to make it possible, and you mentioned it, the report by Madame AVIA and Messrs. TAIEB and AMELLAL in this regard. Propose concrete things. The European fight must continue but it is too slow, and we can no longer wait. That is why Deputy Laetitia AVIA will submit, as early as May, that is to say, at the first possible parliamentary window, a bill to combat hatred on the Internet, incorporating the proposals of this report. In this regard, we must draw inspiration from what our German neighbors have been able to do, effectively and pragmatically. Impose judicial, penal, and financial sanctions; call for the responsibility of individuals, as well as platforms. It will be about putting an end to the eviction strategies deployed by foreign sites that, regularly changing servers, are now very difficult to block. In this context, the question of anonymity will obviously be raised. It is, too often, the mask of cowards. And behind every pseudonym, there is a name, a face, an identity.

Should we ban anonymity everywhere on the Internet? I think that we could go down this path in some respects towards the worst. We will therefore need to think twice about it. However, what we cannot accept is that because there is anonymity, content is not removed promptly, that identity is not sought and not provided. There are still platforms today, like Twitter, to cite the bad examples, that wait weeks, if not months, to provide the identifiers that allow for judicial procedures against those who have called for hatred, for murder; that sometimes take days, weeks to remove such identified content. What this text will therefore carry are clear provisions imposing the prompt removal of all content calling for hatred and implementing all techniques to identify individuals as quickly as possible and finally calling for responsibility, including on a legal level, for the said platforms. We need to adapt our sanctions to the digital society; we must also give ourselves the means to prohibit the presence on a social network of individuals guilty of racist and anti-Semitic remarks, just as we prohibit hooligans in stadiums, or at the very least ensure that convictions for racist and anti-Semitic acts are published for those who commit them.

The shame on these urgent issues must change sides. It must no longer gnaw at the victims. It must weigh heavily on the aggressors. Finally, because the period calls into question who we are, France must also draw new red lines, and we will do so through concrete measures and decisions that the law allows us to take today. That is why I have also asked the Minister of the Interior to initiate procedures aimed at dissolving associations or groups that, through their behaviors, nourish hatred, promote discrimination, or call for violent action: Bastion social, Blood & Honour Hexagone, and Combat 18 to start.

Name, pursue, punish, but of course, finally also, educate.

We must never lose sight of the long-term nature of education, culture, and the moral and spiritual elevation of all, for what we are experiencing today in our society, in our country, speaks volumes about our own past failures. About what we have allowed to settle in subtly, about what we have no longer wanted to denounce, about what we have perhaps sometimes forgotten to say. If history has shown that knowledge is never an antidote to hatred, we know that ignorance, without a doubt, is always a fertile ground. Our teachers, our professors demonstrate exemplary commitment to teaching the memory of the Holocaust, and are admirably supported by institutions such as the Foundation for the Memory of the Shoah or the Memorial of the Shoah. The Minister of National Education has early on committed to this fight to clarify, as you reminded us, Mr. President, all the ambiguities that may have existed, to train more, to be even more demanding. And in this regard, the State will support the Memorial of the Shoah even more than it currently does. DILCRA is providing assistance today. This will be significantly increased by the Prime Minister in the coming weeks.

These teachers, these professors are still too often left to their own devices, especially when, in these neighborhoods plagued by radical Islamism, discussing the Holocaust, the situation in the Middle East, has sometimes become impossible. These teachers, these professors will always find the Republic by their side. At the national level, a rapid response team has been established, which provides them with a solution within 24 hours as soon as a difficulty arises. In each rectorate, clear messages have been communicated, so that everything is said, every problem, as soon as it is observed. But too often, we have also seen, in these neighborhoods of the Republic, in recent years, children leaving public school, let us speak frankly, to go to private contract schools, regardless of the faith, in order to change neighborhoods, because something was happening that the child or the parents themselves did not dare to say. That is why I have asked the minister to implement specific actions and to conduct an audit of all establishments marked by the phenomenon of the school dropout of Jewish children.

When such a dropout occurs, it says something. Sometimes, about what we did not want or could not see, about what was no longer being said. Beyond that, the school must fully play its role as a republican bulwark against prejudice and hatred, but also against what gives rise to it, the empire of immediacy, the reign of a form of absolute relativism. The teaching of the scientific method, of the historical method, will be reinforced. All children in France will be made aware of the long duration of great civilizations, this long duration dear to Braudel, which brings the taste of tolerance and humanism. But returning to these fundamentals, to the heart of our education, what had sometimes been forgotten. It is also at the heart of education, to regain the means to fight against what has settled in subtly, the "everything is equal," the absolute immediacy, the relativism that corrupts everything. My dear friends, it is for actions, and we will have to account for them, and I will account for them. That is why I wanted to be before you this evening. Because anti-Semitism is not the problem of the Jews. It is the problem of the Republic.

It is because those who think that anti-Semitism only concerns a few, that a community in the Republic, that they never forget our history, communicate what we are. Anti-Semitism is simply the hatred of the other. And by the way, look closely at the forms it takes. The hatred of the Jew is at once the hatred of the communist and the capitalist, the hatred of external forces and the enemy within. It is all hatreds added together. Anti-Semitism has taken on all faces, has fed on all extremes. It is the hatred of a single face: that of the other, and moreover, an other who resembles us. Anti-Semitism is the problem of the Republic because it is this avant-garde hatred, but which is always accompanied by the procession of other hatreds to which you have referred, and in the times we are speaking of, it is these other hatreds that are also awakening: hatred against Muslims, racism in all its forms, anti-LGBT racism, all forms of hatred are awakening with it, against elected officials, against authority, against parliamentarism, against the sacred, churches and all religions, against what has made us.

Yes, for all these reasons, anti-Semitism is the question of the Republic and of France. Because at the heart of our intertwined histories, there is all that they no longer want to see. I will not reiterate here the procession of great figures who have made our country, from Rashi to Bergson, Proust, Simone Veil, Robert Badinter. France owes so much to those who have built it, step by step, who have taught it the universal, who have given it this face. But what too many of our fellow citizens in our country still ignore is that for centuries and centuries, great Jews, great commentators of sacred texts, have been in France, who have said so much of these texts, and are known around the world, that the greatest commentators of the Bible and the Talmud, Jews, have been in all our villages, and have sometimes made these villages famous to those who have never set foot in France. Eliezer de Touques, Samuel Ben Salomon of Falaise, Simbah of Vitry in Moselle, Samson ben Isaac of Chinon, Moïse d'Evreux, Thérèse Ben Elia of Corbeil, Moïse de Coussy, Isaac Ben Samuel of Dampierre, Samson of Sens, Eliachim of Chalons, Jacob of Pont-Audemer, Matatia of Avallon, Salomon of Château-Landon, Meshoulam Ben Nathan of Melun, Eliezer Ben Samuel of Metz, Joseph Tobelem Bonfils of Limoges, Ayim Ben Isaac of La Rochelle, Menahem Ben Salomon Meri of Perpignan, Jacob Ben Makir of Montpellier, Aaron Ben Perez of Avignon, Abraham Ben David of Narbonne, so many names known around the world, because they have said something of the Bible, because they have contributed to universal knowledge. They were from these villages and these towns that are our country.

So, when I hear some say "we are at home," who would want those not to be, look our history in the face, for all that it is. The history of France is beautiful, of its universals crossed, of its Jews who came from the ends of the earth to love our country, to fall for it and to make it reach the universal, and of all its French people, who wanted to take, love, and carry a religion, because one could carry it freely and with pride in our country. This is the history of the Jews and France, long before the Republic, long before we even begin to speak of France. This is what we are. We are at home. All of us. Yesterday, in Quatzenheim, I felt ashamed. I was with the residents of this small commune in Alsace and I felt ashamed. And we looked at these desecrated graves and I said to myself: "what they want is, deep down, to ensure that no one can rest in peace." After shame comes anger. The anger to want to find answers immediately. To respond to hatred with another hatred. Deep down, I told the residents of the commune: "you are the true face of this commune. We will clean the graves" and above all tell them how much those who did this should be ashamed. They are not France. They are not the French. The graves of the French and Jews hold our soil like the trees planted for them. They are rooted, and this rooting is our Nation. So yes, I know my friends. There is something ungrateful in that moment for the task that is ours. Barbarism has a force. It is immediate. It stuns. It fascinates some. And it plunges others into consternation, sometimes into despair. And barbarism has an immeasurable force compared to the intelligence or the construction of a rational action that is ours. It is precisely this force that it seeks.

So we will not win this fight in a day; but I want to tell you one thing this evening. We will never get used to it.

We will always have the demand for truth, for freedom, for fraternity and for intelligence, which is the only response to this barbarism. The demand for courage that must be our mission. That of the Republicans that we are. It is slower, sometimes less visible. Sometimes we will stumble, but let us yield nothing. My dear friends, last Friday, I received in my office the mother of Ilan Halimi. And she had, facing her, a painting by Pierre Soulages. I told her: "this is what we have to live." Many thought that black was not a color and that nothing could be done with it. A genius, celebrating his centenary this year, said: "by tirelessly working the black with the brush, with the knife, by drawing my lines, by putting my shapes in it, I will make the sun live in it. I will make the light exist in it." And she saw before her eyes this painting coming to life. And this black was no longer black. It was the Outrenoir of Soulages. We will not erase the evil in our society, neither by a law, nor by a speech, nor by an act; but we must all together be the fighters of this Outrenoir, of these lines of force, of this tireless courage, of this form of humanity and intelligence that we must give, even to the black that exists in our society, because it is there; but we will hold on, and in the end, we will win.

Long live the Republic, and long live France.