SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC AT THE RECEPTION FOR THE FUTURE OF FRENCH RESEARCH.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

7 December 2023 · Reception for the Future of French Research

Context
Macron addressed scientists, parliamentarians, and academics at a reception on the future of French research, celebrating Nobel Prize wins and outlining his vision for science policy.
Main themes
French research and science policy, intrinsic value of science, innovation and economic growth, combating scientific relativism, human and social sciences, Nobel Prize recognition, decarbonization and climate change, artificial intelligence, aging societies and social models, geopolitical competition, academic authority and legitimacy, research funding and reform
Duration
~82 min
98th percentile
Words
9,843
98th percentile
Sentences
365
97th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
13.5
62nd percentile
Syntax
3.28
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%45%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Technological 3%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 6%

365 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Madam Chair of the Culture Commission of the National Assembly,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen academicians,

Ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and qualities,

Dear friends,

I am very pleased to welcome you here after the work you have just conducted to discuss science, research, and innovation. First of all, because we meet at the end of a fruitful year for French science; I am obviously thinking of our Nobel Prize winners.

I think of the teams that have been recognized alongside them and several of our organizations after the awards of previous years. This shows, if it needed to be reminded, that France is a great country of research and must remain so.

Nevertheless, one might ask: why rush to talk about research at the end of the year when the world is shifting, when there seem to be so many urgent priorities? Because I believe that discussing research and science is a priority for the country today even more than yesterday, and that staying the course, or rather clarifying it, making decisions today for the present, but also for the near future or the distant future is absolutely essential, as the period we are living through shows the essential role that science and research play for our country and more broadly for our Europe and for the world, at least in three respects.

The first is that science itself, the search for truth, the desire to build a collective progress of knowledge and better living in society is an intrinsic value and must regain its place as an intrinsic value in our society. We saw this during the pandemic, because it was undoubtedly the moment of simplification, if I may say so, the most extreme, when each of our compatriots was watching for information and the advancement of knowledge to understand a virus that was changing their daily lives, then the discovery of a vaccine that would allow them to regain freedom. But this period was like a metaphor for what is sometimes, over a longer time, the relationship to science and research. And we also saw how, in our societies, this relationship could be shaken by new relativisms. So fighting for science and research today is also fighting for fundamental elements of our society and the capacity to build a possible life and, ultimately, an enlightened humanism, that is to say, scientific and technological advances, but also philosophical advances, a way of conceiving it in society.

That is why I will return to this several times, but I do not separate the sciences here, and I believe that in particular the human and social sciences have to illuminate the advancement of technology or the so-called hard sciences in order to be able to progress together in society.

This first battle for science and research is absolutely fundamental, as I said, it is necessary to clarify it to attract more and more young people to join it. It is fundamental in a world where relativism has gained more and more ground and where the great risk is, in a way, a form of dismantling of academic and scientific authority. Because then, society would no longer place its collective investment or its humanist belief in the right places, and then society would no longer move forward.

I believe, to quote one of my mentors, that legitimacy and authority — which several of you have in this room, and I say this with great humility as far as I am concerned — come from the fact that you have read more books. And that represents something of a knowledge order, of a legitimacy recognized by peers, which then allows for conducting research, but also to say things in society that have weight and value.

Next, because science and research allow for building the growth of a society through innovation, and this is a very important element. It is a very important element because our societies are living through a highly constrained equation. We are democracies and mature societies that have a strength, it is a social model built over time, generous, and societies that are aging and that face massive investments to support the aging of the population, the digitalization of our societies, to face climate change, and geopolitical upheavals. There is only one way to respond intelligently to this issue, which is to create more wealth in order to allocate it to its priorities. There is no society of degrowth possible with the social model that is ours. And so we are in societies that must at the same time decarbonize, be more energy-efficient, face their aging, and deal with a geopolitics that requires us to continue to rearm and be in competition with major challenges that are very capital-intensive, from space to artificial intelligence and beyond.

The only way to do this is to continue to reform. I believe that, including the unpopular reforms taken this year, working longer when we live longer is what allows for creating more wealth and financing science. So I am consistent in my approach, and we cannot then lament consequences for which we would have cherished the causes. I think above all that it is by innovating and creating more wealth that we can finance all this. In this regard, science and research play an absolutely fundamental role for our societies, even more vital than in catching-up societies, in societies whose economic models, in a way, give them more flexibility.

We need to continue to seek to create, to invent, and then to deploy increasingly strong innovations.

Finally, it is a fundamental issue of sovereignty. We are increasingly confronted, here too, with a non-cooperative geopolitics of knowledge which is, I would say, an accelerated recomposition of the world in which we live. I wish, I fight for us to continue to have open science, living on cooperation and openness among researchers, regardless of geopolitical troubles. But look at what is happening in the world in which we live. We saw during the pandemic, for the first time in a long time, non-academic cooperation coming from the East, the non-sharing of information on certain data. We see right now, even among researchers who cooperated and who had cooperated very well during the Cold War, the end of cooperation due to Russia's decision with our own researchers in many fields. And especially, even more so when we talk about quantum, artificial intelligence, we have a geopolitical competition that will structure our sovereignty. If we do not have certain building blocks of knowledge, innovations, and technologies, it is highly likely that we will be outside the major advances, excluded from them, perhaps relegated, and that, ultimately, in these areas as well as in space exploration, true elements of our sovereignty today and tomorrow are at stake.

For these three reasons at least, I consider that discussing knowledge, science, and research is absolutely essential because we are talking about priorities, rather the foundations of what makes a nation, its independence, and the capacity to shape its future. This is what justifies that we have, over the past few years, deeply reinvested in our national education, our higher education, and our research, and that there is a coherence behind all this: consolidating knowledge, fighting against determinisms and inequalities, the PISA tests have shown again, for middle school, that they were very present. And so from the repetition of small classes in CP, to the shock of knowledge in middle school that was presented by the Minister two days ago, the transformation of our school orientation, the reform of vocational high schools, the first cycle of university, etc., it is a continuum that holds its coherence through the desire to place knowledge, the transmission of knowledge at the heart of the life of the nation. And through the investment and transformations that we want to continue to carry out in higher education and research, a desire to collectively improve our system for the purposes I have just mentioned.

So, in this regard, if I had to make a quick and lucid assessment, as lucid as possible, the position I am in tends to always try to defend everything we have done. And I am always a fervent defender of the executive's actions; I also try to be consistent. But if we look at things lucidly, as I said while congratulating our Nobel Prize winners, our Fields Medals, etc., we are a great nation of research; the presidents and chairpersons of research organizations who are here know this. They carry excellence with our universities, our university hospitals of French research; our academicians present here also know this all too well. Nevertheless, we have experienced difficult moments in recent years as well. I cannot tell you that the fact that France was watching for the discovery of a vaccine and sought it from neighbors was a sign of formidable health and justifies some triumphalism on our part. So yes, yes, one could say that in the two societies that discovered it, there was a Frenchman, that is true, Moderna. And yes, I would say even more because there is a form of strange defeat. The very principle of messenger RNA, it was discovered by French scientists, who were awarded for it. The question is how, at a certain point, we lost the thread and did not manage to keep it with us, at least to be at the heart of this competition and this excellence. This is just a symptom, and I do not want to summarize everything to a vaccine. Things are much more complex, multifactorial than that.

Nevertheless, if I try to take stock of our difficulties, of what we have begun to correct and what we need to do, because that is a bit the objective. For more than two decades, we have had too much disinvestment in our research, which has been reflected in setbacks in several disciplines in terms of publications, in degraded rankings, and so if I had to look at the structural difficulties we found in 2017, it is primarily a chronic underinvestment in our research. I do not want to address the figures here, but the salaries of our researchers were 37% lower than the OECD average. The budget of the National Research Agency had decreased by 38% between 2010 and 2015, and we had reached a funding rate of around 10%. With these figures, it is difficult not to generate a lot of frustration.

Next, we had — the past must be partially corrected — an organization of our research that was too complex, too compartmentalized, suffering from overly burdensome and time-consuming administrative procedures. On this subject, I would say that the past can still be conjugated with the present, in part.

Our third structural illness, if I may say, is a significantly degraded link between research and innovation, which is historically a French weakness despite the efforts made by the ALLÈGRE laws, all the work on valorization, what several universities and organizations had tried to build.

Fourth, a tendency towards a French garden and the absence of differentiation in the paths of universities and organizations, which means that, in a period of limited resources, there were somewhat limited resources for everyone, sometimes without discernment and affecting more the competitiveness of teams that were most subjected to international competition. And fundamentally, a disease of the system, here too, I would not completely conjugate the disease to the past, which means that we constantly ask for reports from observatories, from evaluation systems, but we draw almost no consequences from them. And then the last point, a very strong insufficiency of private funding which is linked, which is the result of French deindustrialization, faster than in many of our neighbors, and its sectorization which means that French economic forces are rather in areas that seek less R&D, and also the fact that structurally France has fewer SMEs and ETIs in sectors that require a lot of research, and large groups that have tended to internalize this research and work less with French research actors.

If I had to, in a rush, define the major difficulties of our research, weaknesses that have accumulated over the past 20 years, that is about it. France has thus fallen from sixth to ninth place between 2005 and 2017 in terms of volume but also in the quality of publications, the top 1%. And even if the indicators are always imperfect, we were also a country that had regressed the most in recent years on these subjects, with insufficient participation and applications for major European research projects and insufficient large structures present in international rankings like Shanghai or others.

So, for the past six years, we have tried to correct things, and I really want to commend the work of Frédérique VIDAL, and then Sylvie RETAILLEAU, and with them, all of you, and we have partially corrected things.

First, I believe we have collectively strengthened our university sites with the ORE law, accelerated the investment logic on university sites that had been launched over the past ten years, relying on the reforms that were made in 2008, reinforcing and accelerating the strengthening of sites such as Saclay, PSL, Aix-Marseille University, and building on the maturation of the last decade. There has really been a phase of acceleration that has allowed for an even stronger site logic. And this is a dynamic that has paid off in recent years, as we have seen with improvements in major international rankings.

Next, we have committed real public resources to research to reverse the underlying trend. When I say this, we have caught up, not at all over-invested, because I sometimes hear the debates that can occur, not in this room, but rather outside. The research programming law was enacted in December 2020. So, it is insufficiently taken into account in the rankings because there is always a two-year lag effect. It begins to unfold in 2021. But it brings on its trajectory an additional 25 billion euros to our research over ten years. And this is a catch-up that brings us today to a level comparable to the public part in the United States and the United Kingdom. We are still, in the public part, significantly behind our German neighbors who continue to invest more than we do in public research and higher education. And that is what we need, with this trajectory and this review clause, to catch up on the core of the difference we have in terms of funding, as I mentioned.

There remains the private part where we are much less significant than the British or the Americans, for example. And this is true for both research and higher education. And we spend, for example, much more per student from a public funding perspective than many Anglo-Saxons. But overall, we have less investment because there is much less private investment. And in research, it is the same. So we have this element to catch up on. But we already have microeconomic effects from this historic reinvestment, which are, again, I say, a catch-up; I do not consider that we are at the end of the road, but we no longer have, in our country, researchers hired at less than two minimum wages, which was very much the case before 2017. We have had about a 20% increase with what has been done in the last five years at the beginning of careers. We have more than 1,000 new doctoral positions created, 15% increases in operating funds directed towards our laboratories, young researcher chairs that are now much more numerous and better supported with 400 new positions and 49% of researchers recruited from abroad. This is also a reversal of the trend we had known over the last 15-20 years. The Pasteur Institute, the Imagine Institute, for example, have also been able to attract international talent with historic investment in talent and infrastructure. What we have also been able to do and started to do in certain areas, I think of exascale high-performance computing and a few others. That was the other important element I wanted to revisit regarding what has been done.

The third element that has been corrected is that we have relaunched a sectoral innovation policy that relies on the strengths of our research. And so, in recent years, on artificial intelligence, on quantum, on biology and health, we have relaunched, I am not exhaustive, but sectoral strategies that, I believe, have put resources in place and have improved the link between fundamental research, applied research, development, and innovation. The plan on artificial intelligence, we were one of the first in Europe, and then we tried to Europeanize everything we could. But with the three AI initiatives, the investments in research chairs in particular, some of you are indeed proof of that. We have also built a real dynamic around Inria Startup Studio. Our strategy on quantum, launched as early as 2021, has allowed for the emergence in two years of a real startup ecosystem, which I believe is the strongest today in continental Europe for sure, and one of the two best in Europe. But we are still far from competing with the Americans and the Chinese for the moment.

And then, we launched a health and innovation strategy. We are investing 7.5 billion euros, which has allowed us to consolidate the IHU, develop announced bio-clusters, and work with our university hospitals, Inserm, etc. We have consolidated the work with the public investment bank, research organizations, and universities and multiplied this effort with France 2030, which has allowed, within the framework of this total investment of 55 billion euros, to have an additional 13 billion euros for research and higher education through about forty priority research programs and equipment, the famous PEPR in a wide variety of fields ranging from endometriosis to hydrogen. And I will have the opportunity to come back to this.

All of this means that we have significantly improved several issues, the capacity to innovate through these sectoral policies that rely on the substrate of interdisciplinarity, fundamental research, and the solidarity of our historical research. Research organizations have also begun their transformation with universities, university hospitals, and schools to build more partnerships with startups and the economic world. This is what we have tried to correct in recent years. I am talking about resources, structural effects, dynamics both nationally and at the site level. Now, I think there are still many things that are not satisfactory.

First, and this is coming from everywhere very clearly, we have just talked about it again, our collective organization is not an element of efficiency, and I think it weighs on us. We have a French specificity that stems from the coexistence of several institutions of different natures: national research organizations, universities, grandes écoles, higher education institutions that each conduct their work with a coordination and a sharing of tasks that sometimes still lacks. And on a national scale, this disordered fragmentation prevents us from focusing on major shared challenges, sometimes prevents us from being sufficiently responsive in case of emergency, and diminishes our ability to be attractive in the world.

Next, we have a system that is too opaque and sometimes wastes energy due to excessive creeping bureaucracy. And that is very clear; we have restored public funding, we are improving things, but not enough in my eyes. But above all, we consume an enormous amount of research time due to bureaucracy and administrative complexity, which is the result of our organization. I want to say that all of us here in this room are co-holders of this bureaucracy. We cannot cherish complexity and the structural elements that each defends when speaking for themselves and lament the bureaucracy it generates. And today, it is true that a researcher in a UMR must interact with several administrative interlocutors, fill out a file in one format on one software when it comes to the university, another when it comes to their recommended supervisory organization, and start over on a third or fourth if they are doing a research project with a third party. So we have a superposition of supervisory bodies and managers that makes life completely impossible and generates this bureaucracy. It is a waste of time, a loss of clarity, and also inefficiency in evaluations. And this is what makes it so that even if we increase resources, even if we go faster, etc., we have teams that spend a considerable amount of time essentially doing administrative paperwork to obtain funding for the research program that allows them to live. And this is really a waste of researchers' time and public money. Because we are only talking about public money. It is public money that prepares calls for projects or processes things. It is public money that finances locally the response to these projects, and then looks at and unfolds things or processes them. It is crazy. And it is still crazy that collectively, with so much intelligence involved, we manage to generate this. I say this for all of us, so we should do a hackathon, as they say now, and sit around the table, with artificial intelligence and many other things, we should be able to crack this thing. It’s crazy! So we have made very complicated reports; the minister asked Mr. GILLET for a report, with work conducted by the Academy of Sciences… But the truth is that all of this should spontaneously happen. I say it, I own it, but I think we should do it much more simply, much more strongly. And this is the result of too much complexity in organizational terms, and it is the fact that we have placed belonging to structures and statuses above the efficiency of functioning.

And then, we have not fully addressed a structural illness that I mentioned earlier, meaning that we have put more money, we have been faster on many issues, but we still finance far too many projects and not enough teams, and we still finance far too much on short-term timelines. Because, in fact, we still do not draw enough consequences from evaluations. And that is a reality. And the evaluation illness that I mentioned or these weak consequences drawn remains true today; we must be clear. And we have not yet completely succeeded in addressing the issue of private funding. So now, what to do to look to the future and build it together?

First, I wanted to fully embrace what I told you earlier and place science at the heart of our decisions. That is why I decided to establish a Presidential Council for Science, which was installed today. I want to reassure you here; it is not intended to play the role that the scientific council played during the epidemic, dear François, even if obviously, there will be missions of foresight and research elements. It is not intended to replace our academies, dear Alain, which continue to inform us, which have their history, their influence, their prestige, and which I want to associate even more with decisions. But it is to allow at least once a quarter to exchange freely with me to be able to tell us what is going well, what is not going well, help us see the emergences that we need to start thinking about. In a very free manner, also alert on dysfunctions, try to build new projects, and try to go towards much more disruptive elements, independently obviously of the public policies that need to be decided or what is the normal life of the Government and what the Minister carries, what the organizations decide, or otherwise. So, it is not a substitute element of competition with research organizations or academies; quite the contrary. But fundamentally, where to concentrate our efforts? Are we at the level on emerging issues? Are we on the right path, etc., etc., with freedom of speech and method? The objective is that at the highest level, this Council helps me in the orientation, alert, and monitoring of decisions made.

Next, I want us to be able to clarify several elements regarding the management, organization, and implementation of our research policy, which are essential. And indeed, beyond placing science at the heart of our decisions, the second principle is clarity in the management of our organizations. I have described what is not working, and I think that to do this, we need, and for me, the right timeframe is the next 18 months; that is to say, we need to finish the proposals.

We have the GILLET report, which is a first step. I will come back to it. We have several other milestones in the coming months. We need to start for the next school year to do everything we can on these matters. But for me, within 18 months, we need to have, on everything I will mention, tried to carry out the transformation. 18 months seem realistic and ambitious to me, but I think it is essential, as I said earlier, because going faster is obviously unrealistic; it would be impossible in my eyes. Going slower risks discouraging all those who want to believe in these transformations and the resolution of the problems I mentioned, and it risks stagnation. But I think we have brought about transformations that sometimes, in the past, we have not succeeded in carrying out together.

In clarifying the role and thus our organizations, the first point is that the Ministry of Higher Education and Research must create a true function of steering and strategy. Once I say that, it is not just a word in my mouth; it is a function that the central administration has historically been very poor at performing because it was not designed for that. And it is true... it is true for the Ministry of Higher Education and Research, and it is true for many ministries that increasingly oversee operators because when you have accustomed people, organizations, and administrations fundamentally to decide, to control, a priori, it is very difficult to get them to engage in strategy, steering, and evaluation.

These are not the same talents, so we need to deeply reform things and support them. If we look honestly at what has been done after the 2008 reform of university autonomy, the fact that very few consequences have been drawn on the central administration means that we have done very little with autonomy. I will come back to this, but I had the chance to be with France Universités a few days ago, and we talked about our famous COMP. We have collectively produced a lot of acronyms, namely contracts of objectives, means, and performance. It is true that when we look at what we are actually steering with these contracts in terms of real expenditures overall, we want to say that the people who are willing to prepare, document, and evaluate them are heroes; they are the best COMP.

Presidents, look at me, it is 0.8 or 1% of the university budget. Objectively, we will not convince anyone that this is called autonomy. It is not true. So, that means we have not made the right decisions and that we should not remain in the middle of the river. So, this is real work; effective oversight knows how to define priorities. The ministry is the one that must aggregate elements of interdisciplinarity, be able to be an interlocutor that guides, stimulates, questions these major operators like universities, initiates evaluations, and knows how to draw the consequences from them. Behind this first pillar of clarification, there is obviously the function of evaluation. I truly wish that, and this is one of the tasks I have asked the minister for and I know how much she believes in it, we simplify the evaluation system, drastically reduce the number and frequency, but build a consensus to really draw the consequences from it. Today, a poor evaluation has virtually no consequences on a research team. This means that collectively, if we want there to be fewer, we must accept to say that for a research team that has a poor evaluation, we accept to close it, but conversely, for a team that has a good evaluation, we know how to trust it and give it team funding for 3 years, 5 years that will allow it not to seek projects, to focus on its fundamental research or on the search for major European projects or partnership contracts, etc. This is the second pillar of evaluation.

The third element is our national research organizations. I wish for us to succeed in transforming our major national research organizations into true program agencies. To this end, each agency must become increasingly strategic in its field and participate in defining priority research themes, organize scientific monitoring for all researchers in its area of expertise, interact with international European counterparts, and ensure the development of research infrastructures. Each transformed ONR into an agency will thus have a real mandate and will have the resources to steer the programs entrusted to it. On the major challenges of our time, we are thus moving towards a principle of specialization by program agency, even if, as we know, some agencies are more generalist than others: climate, biodiversity, and sustainable society at CNRS, naturally linked with Ifremer for the oceans, with IRD for sustainable development, to name just a few and illustrate the necessary coordination of our forces, agriculture, sustainable food, forests, associated natural resources for INRAE, decarbonized energies, digital, software at INRIA, health at INSERM in close connection with our university hospitals, components for systems and digital infrastructures at CEA, space naturally at CNES, etc. Program agency also means the ability to dare more and to give full academic freedom to the best and to know how to better support all emerging teams of excellence. What we do not yet know how to do enough today, recent evaluations show, the agencies will also have a strong mandate and resources to encourage them, I know that it is your will, to take risks, to move towards more disruptive research, breakthrough innovations, to prepare the major research programs of tomorrow and thus allow, in essence, to support over time the teams of excellence that you will have prepared, selected, and to whom you give more visibility and depth of field. This is a true revolution in approach. This is a true revolution in organization. But I believe in it. And I think that this is what will allow us to be truly competitive and to follow through on this logic.

So, I will be told legitimately in this context, what becomes of the universities? Precisely, universities must evolve to take a central place as leaders in organizing and managing scientific research in their territory. While foresight and the definition of national programs are major, research exists in an essential continuum and is done in a site logic. Teaching, training, research, dialogue with society, the socio-economic world, social and environmental responsibility, also a role with our international counterparts, links with the clinic when we talk about our university hospitals, and these links, this logic of both site and multidisciplinarity are absolutely essential. And it is at the level of universities that this is played out, with universities, at the level of sites, of university poles that we wish to continue to strengthen.

Building its identity, its scientific policy on a site, developing its collaborations with businesses is also a tremendous challenge with this permanent dialogue, this constant tension between a national policy and a local priority. And so, this is what we truly want to establish. And ultimately, at each university site, we should be able to have a unique manager following local exchanges that must be defined for each unit, making them fully responsible for the administrative support of each researcher. And without going into details, we will initiate a real effort to simplify the burden of administrative procedures for our researchers. There, right now, with local team steering and a reorganized evaluation. It is therefore through this site logic that we will create more real autonomy and above all more simplification of management. This does not detract from the quality of the science that will continue to be done in this dialogue with research organizations, peer management, with the national dialogue that will continue to be regulated by peers, but which will allow for real efficiency on a site logic and infinitely simplify the lives of teams. More fundamentally, this implies that our universities strengthen their autonomy, develop their capacity to operate this management, and that we build together the means for this full responsibility. For this, we must move forward without taboos, and this is what we must do in the coming months to prepare for it. We talked about it with France Universités, that is to say, looking at the issues of governance, economic model, and indeed, building real contracts of objectives, means, and performance with much more incentive funding. And I want universities that are ready and willing to make the boldest proposals and allow for the management of human resources, which are on their site with a real logic of delegation of this function. And we can very well have, and it goes above, I know, because the minister has forbidden me to say the word status. I mentioned it earlier at the presidential council; you have ministers for whom I have a lot of affection. I always pass what I am going to say to them first to see if they agree or not, because afterwards, they are the ones who will do it. And then, really, she told me, "if you say that you have changed the status," first, I said, "in Mr. Gillet's mission that we were not going to do it, there you go, it will immediately be an uproar. Everyone will get in the way, and we will not be able to do anything." So I did not say that we were going to reform the statuses. But in the end, what do we want? We want you to be able to train, recruit, retain the best researchers in the world and attract them. We want this to be done in a very great academic freedom and thus that it be decided among peers. But afterwards, we still want to simplify everyone's life and that it be at the level of teams, that things are decided with much more freedom. And I am unable to say, in essence, whether there should be 100% research time for the same person throughout their life, and it is probably an absolute stupidity of our system. All this because they entered at 25 into a system, and perhaps that same person will at some point want to do a bit more teaching. Things according to disciplines, according to their life, their choices mean that we may want to do more teaching, more research, more clinical work at some point. The statuses are not protections today; they have become elements of complexity. So I sincerely invite you, you are much smarter than I am, all of you in this room, to change them yourselves. In my opinion, that is the best thing to do; that is to say, we must preserve research time for people who are very good, who want it, or others. To say that, in my opinion, for very good researchers, I speak under the control of people who do this, I have a lot of admiration. Some consider that teaching nourishes their research. And I truly believe that we have an approach, and we have in a way on this subject trench wars that are of another age. We will continue to provide more resources, and I will be the guarantor of that before you.

We do not manage scarcity with the reform I am proposing because we are reinvesting; we have this programming law, I will come back to it, and I want us to continue to invest more. But if we want to simplify our structures, to help you tackle bureaucracy, let us create real funding agencies that stop directly managing personnel. Let us create real autonomous universities with site logics and have teams that are managed at the site level. But then, with the possibility of moving from one to another and thus national fluidity and mobility, according to teams, and interdisciplinary mobility, much more than today. I was told this earlier. Because the logic of status, do not be mistaken, creates interdisciplinary rigidity today, so let us create this freedom. I believe, in any case, that what we are saying is good for universities because, in essence, what I propose to them is that within 18 months, we open the second act of autonomy and move towards true autonomy with real multi-year contracts where we have reformed governance, you have the means to commit as a university and university collective to objectives, and at the end of the contract where they are evaluated. You have visibility, and in doing so, we will implement a real revolution for our researchers because it will be an element of simplification. I will come back to this. Multi-annuality, autonomy, evaluation. Concretely, if we have such a model, if a new pandemic were to occur, public authorities would turn to Inserm — which would have previously defined and supported all the research laboratories on vaccines in the territory, would be, as it is the team, regardless of its affiliation within its university, the best placed and in connection with the Pasteur Institute, the university hospitals, the universities — to steer, if I may say so, the national strategy with real teams that would have a much simpler management.

In the same way, regarding ecological planning, we have laid the first foundations of a complete plan where the challenges for France in 2040 are massive. It is exactly the same ambition set. CNRS would build the national strategy, would have all the reference labs with partners, research organizations, laboratories, structures, schools, and would be — and will know, since this is not the eventuality of a pandemic, it is the certainty that we must indeed advance on this plan — to identify the best elements of solutions, research in decarbonization, energy, etc.

The other element that goes with this simplification is an assumed differentiation. I do not want to reinvent a French garden here. Not all organizations and sites will move at the same speed, even if some have already begun to take this turn. What we must build, and this is intangible, is that we must have quality higher education everywhere, we must have quality research everywhere, but we know that in certain disciplines, we must accept differentiation, and this is not a logic of Paris against the provinces or necessarily large sites against the provinces. The example of La Rochelle, for instance, is probably the best illustration that in certain disciplines, it is entirely possible to have a university site that decides to focus on a sector where it has an ecosystem that allows it to conduct world-class research and have a better team. Therefore, we must help it to move much faster. But it is not true that we will have the best competitive world research in all fields, in all universities, and that we must therefore provide the same resources to everyone or somehow advance everyone in the same way. That would not be realistic. So let us start right now by entrusting the major organizations with the management of our major thematic programs and our research programs for France 2030, let us accelerate risk-taking, which will allow for an element of differentiation for the best who do not yet have enough public funding with the research programming law, let us allow until 2025 the time to take all the measures to implement these transformations also in program agencies, but starting now, therefore within 18 months, what I want from the CNRS, the CEA, INRAE, INSERM, INRIA, all the organizations, CNES, is truly to use this money from France 2030 for the priorities we have already defined. Beyond the credits that are theirs, to accelerate on these priorities and to initiate this work of differentiation that is theirs and to work with other organizations, universities, schools, and university hospitals in this direction. Similarly, let us experiment with our universities to build enhanced autonomy. But I want those sites that wish to move faster to be able to do so and for us to give them freedom, not to be necessarily homogeneous. And perhaps within 18 months, not all university sites will be ready to move towards objective, means, and performance contracts as ambitious as those I described. And we will have to perhaps accept a system that allows for a transition at multiple speeds, and that is not a problem. And on this, I also want to say that we must accept to have a differentiated system that gains in flexibility because it is the only way, in any case, to create the collective trust that will allow us to move forward.

Then, all of this must obviously be accompanied by simplification and more trust for our researchers. If we have clarity in the organization, if we have clarified management units and greater autonomy for our universities, it will lead to greater simplicity for our researchers. And I say this because everything I have just said, if we say it is not possible, we will not do it, etc., we will continue to have complexity at the level of research units, whether we like it or not. So I can be told, “You are doing things, but it is too slow, it is too complicated, etc.” but we must move the entire system because we will continue to have mixed units, which is a tremendous strength. We just need to ensure that we are not hindered by these complexities. And so, on this subject, I want a real shock of trust. We need to relieve our researchers from responding to specifications, to avoid waiting times on projects that are sometimes too long. We mentioned it again, even when we have priority projects, it sometimes takes 18 months to obtain funding, which is crazy. All of this must be done in several ways.

First, for the so-called white project calls, or in good Breton, curiosity-driven. So, with the research law, we have given meaning back to the project calls of the National Research Agency and we have made, I believe, these funding sources more credible. We have started to reduce deadlines, we have given much more capacity. We must drastically reduce response times, I know, which should be similar to those currently in place for business aid. And we must aim to halve them, to go from one year to six months, which will require mobilization from everyone at the ANR, I know, but also for the evaluations I mentioned. National project calls will see and will see their amounts increased and concentrated on large-scale research projects that meet international standards lasting 5 years, which will also help avoid uncertain and variable successive funding. And for white projects, it is the same logic as the one I mentioned, that is to say, moving towards team funding with longer durations, with more substantial funding, which allows these teams of excellence to be freed from the multiplicity of project calls and the time lost on this subject. Simplicity must be an absolutely constant requirement, and for that, we will implement measurement tools for researchers to have real-time measures of simplicity and to bring transparency to this subject. And there, fundamentally, I call for collective goodwill. I believe we do not have an interest in deploying an administrative tool to do this, but to ask the best researchers to help us have measurement instruments and to have, in a way, state startups that will help us do this. You all have, much more than I do, the intelligence to allow for real-time measurement, so to speak, of the complexity experienced by researchers. It must be deployed everywhere to allow us to track inefficiency, and fundamentally, all structures, ONR as well as universities, must make human support for researchers a priority. Where our entire system has somehow retreated into itself because it has suffered 15 years of budgetary drought and where the collective administrative culture is more one of distrust. And so we have much more imposed a logic of control than of support.

We must also think about facilitating bridges between program agencies and universities to gain fluidity. And I also say this clearly, it goes with what I mentioned about statuses, as many different statuses within the same public policy are certainly not effective or pleasant for the actors, and so we must also move towards the rapprochement of paths. And fundamentally, you have understood, I think that what I am proposing to you, which is the result of years of discussions and companionship with you, is a true collective revolution. But I do not believe in a grand evening imposed from above with legal texts. I believe there is a sufficiently shared observation that the system is not working well to say collaboratively, we can find much more intelligent systems. The bridges between the various statuses are part of this. And it is an element of simplicity. Clarity in the chain of responsibility, simplicity for the actors, you can see, these are absolutely key elements to rebuild our system, to free up research time, to also give greater visibility to teams, and to increase our attractiveness, I would say attractiveness towards the researchers we train and sometimes lose, attractiveness towards the young doctoral students who are sometimes under your responsibility, whom we must convince to join research, and attractiveness towards the best researchers abroad whom we want to bring back. There you have the heart, if I may say so, of the collective transformation that I propose to you in the next 18 months. Placing France at the level that is ours and at the ambition that is ours also requires us to value all our areas of excellence.

And I mentioned in my introductory remarks, I also think in this regard of the social sciences and humanities. In this area, France is also a nation of excellence that has created real disciplines, which has been able to carry them, and from sociology to anthropology has built its academic and research excellence. What I want is for us to also strengthen our social sciences and humanities, to integrate them into the same landscape, the same organization that I have just described. To do this, we also need to better structure them so that they regain their influence and visibility. In this regard, several of our priority research programs have already been dedicated to the social sciences and humanities because they will be an absolutely indispensable lever for our organization and the transformation that is ours. For example, the PEPR dedicated to artificial intelligence and digital technology closely associates our social sciences and humanities, and I wish that we launch in the coming weeks research programs dedicated to social sciences and humanities focused on priority themes on which we know we need insight. The evolutions of our democracies, the question of work, the stages of life, heritage, religions and civilizations, but also the consequences of climate change, the evolutions of our habitats and ways of life. I only mention a few. These have been the subject of a strong consensus. These works will allow our perceptions and judgments to be more enlightened, and will also root our public debates in facts again. More broadly, the entire field of research must better rely on the resources of creativity and curiosity in society. And I know that the aspiration in this regard is for more strong interdisciplinarity and transdisciplinarity. And there too, we experienced it at the heart of the pandemic, the insights from anthropology, sociology of medicine, or other disciplines were absolutely key to accelerating the dissemination of certain innovations or certain best practices that were essential for achieving scientific results when we spoke of the collective approach. On this, we will therefore continue to make our efforts, and I also say this at a serious moment for us collectively, we will continue to intensify our efforts to support open science and open-source projects, where in many countries, they are increasingly threatened. You see, everything I am trying to outline, which is the result of collective exchanges, is a complete change of philosophy, of organization both at the national level and within the intimacy of our structures, of our research. I believe the country is ready for this because there have been many successful or failed reforms, because we are in a phase where we have begun to catch up on the backlog that has accumulated and we are reinvesting, and you know my determination to maintain this course. And I believe that today, we must make decisions with a truly irreversible character. All of this, of course, must be accompanied by resources. In 10 years, two five-year terms, we will have engaged in historic investments and profound organizational reforms.

I said that the budgetary recovery is already underway with the LPR and France 2030. I announce to you that nearly one billion euros from France 2030 are already being unlocked to initiate the first works in the coming weeks and to pilot new programs, take more risks, and retain the best in all fields. I think of the example of mathematics, where we will invest massively in research in the field because, here too, we know the elements of fragility that have been highlighted by several of you in a recent op-ed. I also believe that we must continue to strengthen the support mechanisms for the attractiveness of our young researchers to bring back the most promising to France and to keep those who might be tempted by research. In this regard, if we have reinvestments to make, I want to prioritize this point immediately. The junior professor chairs are functioning, the mechanisms, particularly in health, have been established with exceptional support amounts for each position that will be announced soon. On this, we will certainly need to amplify, sustain, and extend them to all sectors because this dynamic works. I also wish to increase our capacity to mobilize more private funding to accelerate investment in our research. I said it, this is the point where we are the most behind compared to our major comparables. Therefore, the goal is that, through the reforms I just described, our teams also have more time to seek partnership contracts or to foster the emergence of startups and business creation in our laboratories. We have already accelerated a lot in recent years; we must continue this movement, which is one of the funding levers for our research by the private sector. I am also very confident and I call on all actors from the entire world of French innovation and technology, including startups, French Tech, and through them, everything we have managed to develop in recent years in deep tech, the companies that have begun to emerge and have grown larger, whether in the health sector, energy, space, or the most technological sectors, have a much stronger reflex of collaboration with public research. All this development that we are successfully achieving, which makes France the most attractive nation in terms of funding in these sectors and the leading nation in terms of startup creation and development, must have an effect on our public research and its funding. Therefore, we will also be very vigilant to ensure that all these emerging actors forge links, maintain their links, and develop even more significant connections with public research through research contracts and, likewise, through patent logics or startup creation.

I also wish for the links to be strengthened with our largest groups. Work has been done in recent years by the National Academy of Technology, ANRT, and several others, to have more doctors in our large companies at the highest level. I believe this is an absolutely essential change sociologically, and we will continue to support it. We will also be vigilant to ensure that the largest groups rely more on public research.

Then we will multiply joint funding efforts for research infrastructures. Whether we are talking about supercomputers, infrastructures, quantum or artificial intelligence, certain areas of innovation in space exploration, or computing capabilities or discoveries in material and particle physics, the amounts are such that we increasingly need to succeed in mobilizing public-private projects, and it is essential to guarantee open source and the capacity for open science, but to have approaches where we mobilize major French and European private actors in this direction to have research infrastructures at a critical level, where otherwise we are sometimes exclusively competed against by private actors. I think of computing capabilities today, when we look at them, which would place us outside the capacity to be competitive.

Finally, we also need to mobilize European funding much more. Several of you have testified about the major European research programs. Here too, I wish that we could make this a priority project for our organizations and our universities. To seek more credits and major research projects from Europe, and we will continue to fight for our major projects of common European interest, the famous PIIEC, which have allowed us, in several disciplines, to mobilize massive funding for innovation, but also for research and especially to pool efforts among Europeans. I believe that in many of the areas we are discussing, we can have a multiplier effect in this regard. And finally, next year we will have a review clause that should allow us to redefine priorities and thus recalibrate new ambitions for public research funding by 2030, based on this evaluation and accompanying the structural changes I mentioned. These are the main points I wanted to build here, but fundamentally, all the major challenges that are ours, whether it is the protection of our nature and the climate challenge to achieve carbon neutrality, artificial intelligence and its consequences on our society, the ability to be at the heart of space exploration, the disruptive adventures that will take place there, the exploration of the deep sea and also the disruptive innovations that will be decided there, developments in health, personalized or predictive medicine, and so on, we have revolutions that impose on us the need to succeed, and we must together drive these transformations.

What I have tried to outline broadly today before you, which once again is the result of a lot of work in recent months, I would say in recent years, is based on the credibility of the last few years and the first transformations we have built, but requires in the next 18 months significant work and a lot of courage from all of you, because none of the transformations I just mentioned is natural. And many of the things I have said here may have been said or attempted, then interrupted. I believe we have already conducted many transformations and evolutions that allow us, particularly over the next 18 months, to carry out this work. You understand that several meetings in the coming months will be scheduled with the Minister, who, with you and based on the initial work, will move forward on this. We will already have, for the summer and next autumn, massive developments in the elements of simplification and the first milestones on what I just said. But for me, autumn 2025 is truly the culmination of these transformations and the vision I just mentioned. This requires regular meetings that we will have with each other. Perhaps we will need to adjust certain points, perhaps we will need to transform, adapt, gain flexibility, be perhaps more ambitious here, be more pragmatic there. I believe that is how things should progress. And fundamentally, what I propose to you is a collaborative transformation where the spirit of research is put at the service of our collective administrative organization. It seems to me the best way to advance and truly transform our research and higher education system. You will have me at your side. And to conclude, I would simply like to say two last things before sharing a drink with you.

The first thing is that behind all this, there is a very great trust from the nation in you, in all your peers, and in all those who turn to research, knowledge, and higher education. And I say this under this ceiling where the arts and science support the Republic, because I believe that the challenge of our Republic, and France plays a particularly important role in the concert of nations, is indeed to place knowledge, science at the heart of choices, decisions, and collective life. Behind everything we are doing and deciding, sharing, there is this will to say that the search for truth, the academic freedom that must accompany it, and the desire to place knowledge at the heart, rather at the top of the Republic, is vital for it. Because the Republic was built on these values and principles, that of human dignity above which nothing is built and that of liberal democracies that can function as long as citizens are enlightened, meaning that they are well-educated minds capable of deciding and being masters of their choices, and that they are citizens well-informed by a rational, objective decision, nourished by science, which allows them to react to the decisions of leaders, to validate or invalidate them, but with full knowledge of the facts. There is no Republic, no democracy that survives long without a strong, open science, based on academic freedom, and thus it is a principle of interested trust, if I may say so, that is mine, interested in the life, vitality, and solidity of our democracy.

The second thing is that behind all this, I know I can count on you to create vocations. Because our responsibility is also to ensure that tomorrow, young boys and girls, perhaps even more young girls because I do not forget the need to attract talent, particularly in certain disciplines on this side, join in turn research, higher education, clinical work, and can continue to make France a great nation of knowledge, of understanding, of research. A great nation at the service of science and to which science brings so much. That is why I am with you today. I believe in everything I have just told you. I will fight by your side for this to happen, and in any case, you will know that I will be by your side in the months and years to come, for this to come to fruition. Thank you. Long live the Republic and long live France!