Speech by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, before the Council of Europe in Strasbourg.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

31 October 2017 · Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France

Context
Macron addressed the Council of Europe in Strasbourg on October 31, 2017, marking France's deep ties to the ECHR and outlining key challenges facing human rights in Europe.
Main themes
European Court of Human Rights, human rights, European civilization, French commitment to human rights, state sovereignty vs. court authority, threats to human rights, historical roots of rights, Council of Europe, globalization challenges, emerging scientific and legal challenges
Duration
~70 min
97th percentile
Words
8,431
97th percentile
Sentences
354
96th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
59th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%49%
  • Geopolitical 23%22%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

354 sentences in 159 paragraphs

Mr. President of the European Court of Human Rights,

Mr. Secretary General of the Council of Europe,

Ladies and gentlemen judges of the ECHR,

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors,

Madam Keeper of the Seals, Minister of Justice,

Madam Minister to the Minister of Europe and Foreign Affairs, in charge of European Affairs,

Mr. President of the Constitutional Council,

Mr. First President of the Court of Cassation,

Mr. Attorney General at the Court of Cassation,

Mr. President of the Litigation Section of the Council of State,

Mr. Prefect of the Grand Est Region,

Mr. President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Ladies and gentlemen deputies and senators of Bas-Rhin,

Mr. First Deputy Mayor of Strasbourg,

Ladies and gentlemen,

The European Court of Human Rights is a unique achievement that honors Europe in at least two respects.

First, because it was built on the ruins of the Second World War, as you have just reminded us, to offer, in response to barbarism, shared principles of humanity and respect.

Second, because over the years, it has made Human Rights the common good of all of Europe, so to speak, its hallmark, even before any prefiguration of a European community. It thus prevails in a circle of countries much broader than the current European Union, making the convention that underpins it, its law, its judgments, the cement of a unique set of nations.

What makes your role unique, ladies and gentlemen judges, is that you work passionately in the service of 820 million Europeans belonging to the nations that have ratified the European Convention on Human Rights.

France's attachment to the principles advocated by this Convention is longstanding. The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen of 1789 is, of course, its main anchor point. But its roots go even further back, into the soil of Renaissance humanism, into the ancient heritage, into the conception of the human being that France has forged over the centuries, along with it, of freedom, emancipation, and education.

The Human Rights articulated during the French Revolution, then reaffirmed and reinterpreted several times by the great thinkers and statesmen of our country, are inseparable from this deep identity that begins long before. It is not insignificant that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was made in Paris in 1948; and it is not trivial that a French city, Strasbourg, is today your home port. Rest assured that for us, the French, this carries a very strong meaning.

As I said, this Europe goes far beyond the borders of the European Union. It is a Europe in the most historical sense of the term, from the Atlantic to the Ural, a Europe that extends to its ancient borders, such as Turkey. The borders of this Europe are not those of a legal entity or even a political one. They are those of a civilization.

The 47 member states have recognized a common rooting in these principles that the Court upholds. They have admitted that a part of their law, their beliefs, and their principles lies there. And the defense of Human Rights belongs to the history and heritage of Europeans. We do not defend them only for the citizens of today! We defend them because we owe it to the citizens of yesterday, who fought for these Human Rights, and to the citizens of tomorrow who must be able to benefit from them.

Political and geopolitical developments often blur this unity. Multipolar globalization sometimes comes with a certain temptation to call it into question. And yet, beyond the circumstances, beyond political and governmental regimes, belonging to this community of 47 remains. The anchoring in a shared foundation endures; I rejoice in this, and we must constantly oppose this factual, historical reality to all those who, in our globalization, see only a planetary process of dilution of reference points. The European Court of Human Rights is and remains a major reference point for Europeans.

This situation should not obscure the many challenges that remain to be addressed. The first that I will raise, from the perspective of France, is that of the relationship between the legal sovereignty of states and that of the Court.

The second challenge is that of the growing threats that our time confronts us with and that compel us to invent legal and political balances to ensure the respect of Human Rights.

The third challenge is that of a world that shakes us. It is the emergence of certain challenges, of contemporary phenomena as well, notably scientific, of which we have not fully grasped the implications, but which will tomorrow collide with our legal order, for it is today that we must apprehend them.

The project of freedoms is for us, the French, a question of our honor, but also of our very being. General de GAULLE expressed it in 1941, saying that "there exists a pact 20 times centuries old between the greatness of France and the freedom of the world." I believe it too, and this confers upon us particular duties.

France's attachment to the European Convention on Human Rights and to the Court that upholds its rules is, as I have said, profound. I cannot fail to mention here, as you have done, René CASSIN, who, after leaving his mark on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which we will celebrate the 70th anniversary of next year, had the foresight to understand that the rights thus proclaimed could not be guaranteed and therefore effective without a mechanism of recourse subordinating states to the primacy of individual rights and that the relevant level for such a mechanism was the European level.

It was also a Frenchman, the second judge after René CASSIN, who succeeded in imposing, during the negotiation of the Convention, the idea of a jurisdiction tasked with ensuring that states respect it and render binding judgments.

Contributing to the paternity of these mechanisms, France perhaps believed for a moment that it was exempt from ratifying the Convention itself. It did so only in 1974. And it was not until 1981, under the impetus of Robert BADINTER, that it subscribed to the right to individual recourse.

In doing so, France certainly underestimated, in René CASSIN's words, "the price to pay to set an example." This is now done.

However, this example must be concrete. That is why I am pleased that the litigation concerning France is, as you kindly reminded us, decreasing. Our country is no longer experiencing, at present, mass litigation related to structural failures of its legislation.

Moreover, the proper execution of the Court's judgments is essential to defending its authority. In this regard, France constantly reiterates its attachment to the binding force of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights within the framework of the follow-up ensured by the Committee of Ministers. It actively participates in discussions regarding the improvement of the execution process, as it did during the negotiations of the Brussels Declaration.

The Court has also played a major role in France in terms of criminal procedure by inviting the French state, through its decisions, to strengthen the guarantees for citizens.

It is thanks to it that a person in police custody benefits from the assistance of a lawyer during interrogations, that they are notified of their right to remain silent. It is also the Court that has allowed for the improvement of the legal regime for telephone interceptions and that has enabled the creation of a specific legal regime for individuals apprehended at sea, during the law of June 3, 2016.

Of course, these developments do not always come easily, and France sometimes faces difficulties in executing certain particularly complex judgments.

However, I want to reaffirm the importance for France of the unconditional obligation to execute the Court's judgments. I would like to point out that in 2000, France established an internal recourse allowing a person who obtained a judgment of condemnation from the ECHR, in criminal matters, to request a re-examination of the case before national courts. Very recently, in 2016, it extended this possibility to civil judgments.

France aims to be exemplary because that is how one gives strength and effectiveness to an international institution like the European Court of Human Rights.

Nothing would be easier than to practice avoidance, half-measures. Some sometimes invite us to do so. But in the long run, this would have the effect of undermining the authority of the Court, compromising it, and ruining it, and that would be irresponsible.

I see those who would like to lead us down this path, who would like us to cynically play the strategy of having one foot in and one foot out. During the French electoral campaign, voices were raised calling for France not to give binding force to the Court's judgments, to even go further at times.

Is this, therefore, a loss of sovereignty? I do not believe so. It is the intangible respect for the principles that are ours and for conventions that we have sovereignly consented to sign and ratify. For the law also has its sovereignists, quick to call for the defense of European values but who believe that each will be a better interpreter sheltered behind their borders.

For my part, I defend a European justice, conceived as a space for dialogue and complementarity. Dialogue between European judges, which I wish to be supported between the Courts of Strasbourg and Luxembourg while awaiting the European Union's accession to the European Convention on Human Rights. Dialogue also between the European judge and the national judge.

What makes the strength of the Convention system is that it offers external control, thus a surplus of impartiality and objectivity on disputes. Your perspective, ladies and gentlemen judges, is a different perspective, complementary to that of the internal judge, capable of identifying the gaps, the errors that the internal judge can sometimes, like anyone, let slip.

But let us go further. What do we place at the center of the work of our national judges? Human Rights! Thus, what makes the strength of the Convention system is also that national judges are the first judges of the European Convention on Human Rights.

We have therefore not handed over our legal sovereignty to the Court! We have given Europeans an additional guarantee that Human Rights are preserved.

It is a formidable collective protection, for we thus protect together, the population of member countries from illiberal temptations, but also from those cases where politics defends outdated interests or practices contrary to these rights.

This reality is rooted in the traumatic experience of Europeans. In this feeling that democracy is a fragile good that must be surrounded by care and safeguards, this was the experience of the men of the war generation, and particularly of René CASSIN and those who worked with him.

Seventy years later, who would dare to contradict them? Who would seriously say that the worst is behind us and that we can diminish the strength we give to the universal principles that unite us? Who could think that these risks of illiberal democracy, of retreat, of surreptitious or overt questioning of our values and principles are now far from us?

The truth is that the ECHR was a visionary work and that this vision still protects us today, protects our fellow citizens, and that we must remain faithful to it.

It is your jurisprudence that is directly at the origin of the decriminalization of homosexuality in Ireland, of the abolition of corporal punishment in British schools, of France's adoption of legislation that regulates telephone tapping, or even of the admission of women into the German army.

These developments did not come without debates, without contestations. We look at them today, however, as self-evident, as indisputable elements of our common foundation of fundamental rights wherever the European Convention on Human Rights prevails. This abandonment of sovereignty that some fear is in fact only an absurd nostalgia for practices that our principles should have prevented and that our habits have preserved for too long.

Moreover, one of the fundamental principles of the system for the protection of Human Rights enshrined by the Court is indeed that of subsidiarity, expressly mentioned in Protocol No. 15, which France has ratified and whose entry into force we hope for soon. The primary role of national authorities is thus constantly reaffirmed by the Court!

The Court is not intended to replace it and to constitute a fourth level of jurisdiction! The primacy of national judges is in no way called into question, and I want to emphasize the quality of the dialogue that exists between the Court and national jurisdictions.

The recognition of the national margin of appreciation is obviously the key to this quality of dialogue. The Court recognizes it for States in the implementation of the rights enshrined in the Convention, the scope of which, however, varies according to the freedoms and rights protected.

By respecting the primary role of national authorities to preserve and guarantee the rights and freedoms protected by the Convention, the Court has achieved a delicate balance, sometimes challenged, and your task is all the more difficult as it must deal with cases arising from different legal systems, with culturally diverse traditions and societies, and with moments of tension that may sometimes exist.

Yet it has managed, by creating a jurisprudence that is both flexible and demanding, to respect this diversity without betraying its primary mission of protecting Human Rights. It is the indispensable respect for national particularities and specificities that has also allowed you to establish your full legitimacy.

Thus, the Court, seized with the law of October 11, 2010 prohibiting the concealment of the face in public space, after recalling the wide margin of appreciation enjoyed by France in such a domain, recognized the notion of "living together," put forward by the French government, as part of one of the legitimate aims within the meaning of Article 9 of the Convention, and allowing in this case the restriction of the freedom to manifest one's religion, which is the wearing of the full veil.

The Court also took into account the specificity of the French concept of secularism, to rule that the non-renewal of the contract of a social worker working in a public hospital who refused to remove her veil in the course of her duties was not an infringement of the freedom of religion.

I could thus multiply examples where the Court has ruled on very sensitive societal issues, where the perception of traditions among our different member States was profoundly different, and where in doing so, it has helped the States concerned to achieve greater equity without forgetting their history.

France, for its part, has only been able to progress in light of these rulings. The presence today of representatives from the French supreme courts – and I thank them for that – attests that France finds in this interaction with the European Court of Human Rights a path of enrichment and progress.

But this dialogue can go even further. I point to the establishment in 2015 of the information exchange network between the Court and the national supreme courts – the Court of Cassation, the Council of State, the Constitutional Council – which today includes 62 jurisdictions and 34 States.

I also wish to pay tribute to the pedagogical approach of the presidents of the European Court of Human Rights who come to engage in dialogue with judges and authorities of the States to explain its role and its area of intervention.

This dialogue will undoubtedly be strengthened with the entry into force of Protocol No. 16, which establishes the possibility for the highest courts of States to submit requests for advisory opinions to the Court on questions of principle relating to the interpretation or application of the rights and freedoms defined by the Convention or its protocols.

This protocol will complete the legal framework built around the Convention on Human Rights and will further solidify the dialogue between national jurisdictions and the Court. It will also allow for better organization of this debate, by enabling, on an optional basis, the solicitation of this opinion, instead of sometimes accumulating numerous cases.

That is why France has resolutely initiated the ratification process of this protocol, with the secret hope of being the 10th State to ratify, thus allowing this protocol to enter into force. For I am convinced that it will significantly strengthen the European legal foundation in terms of Human Rights and will bring about collective progress in this area.

It is a virtuous circle that over the decades we have built together. It protects us and it protects our fellow citizens. It creates, among the 47 members, a form of legal harmony. It makes Europe a unique haven for Human Rights. It would therefore be a mistake not to complete this construction.

It would be a mistake because many threats today are testing the solidity of this edifice; testing our will to firmly uphold it, to ensure its durability. And in the face of current challenges, we must hold even firmer. We must hold even firmer. We must sometimes also reinvent the grammar of our collective action.

The first of these challenges, you mentioned, Mr. President, is terrorism. We are fighting against Islamist terrorism with determination. But we remain within the framework of the rule of law, and notably under the control of the judiciary.

Security is the primary mission of the State, which must protect its citizens and ensure the security of its territory. This mission must be carried out resolutely in respect of rights and freedoms. This security is the condition for our freedoms to be fully respected and to find their framework.

The French Declaration of the Rights of Man guarantees safety, that is to say, the assurance for the citizen that the power of the State will not be exercised over him in an arbitrary and excessive manner. To confuse safety with a security obsession would be to go astray. And I say this all the more strongly because, let us not be mistaken, this terrorism targets both the government or the State and European society, its customs. We are attacked for what we are.

France has been attacked at its core for several years. And these attacks have not only killed our fellow citizens. They have sought to attack the moral consensus that is ours, that of all of us Europeans. They have sought to attack this common foundation that we have built and whose foundation is Human Rights.

Jihadist terrorism wants to lead us to abandon principles that are an essential part of ourselves. It wants us to believe that these principles are our Achilles' heel, whereas they are our irreducible strength. I would even go further: defending freedoms is not only a right, it is a duty. And they must be defended by the State, of course, but also by citizens. What is at stake? Well, our society of freedoms, the state of civilization in which we live.

Nevertheless, we must recognize that we were not adequately prepared for the jihadist terrorism we are currently facing. The methods employed by our assailants, their very behaviors, the deadly ideology leading to previously unprecedented acts, the enduring nature of this threat have led us to profoundly reorganize our law.

That is why I wished to equip France with an adapted system, to strengthen the security of our fellow citizens, but also to exit from the state of emergency, which is an exceptional state.

I said it very early on and I have often explained, we had to exit from the state of emergency. The state of emergency was useful, particularly in the first weeks, the first months following the attacks of 2015. But its usefulness has diminished over time.

The state of emergency is not the state of exception. Under no circumstances has the rule of law been suspended in France! Judicial oversight has been maintained; ordinary courts have obviously continued to function and no exceptional justice has been set in motion. The Constitutional Council has set a framework and limits. Freedom of the press has in no way been hindered; Parliament has continuously evaluated the system.

But the state of emergency, designed to address a situation confined in time and activating general measures, could not be extended indefinitely, even as the threat is enduring and characterized. This is Islamist terrorism.

Thus today what I want is to protect France from a permanent terrorist threat through a common law framework. To those who think that only the state of emergency would protect us, I respond that they are mistaken. I know that I will not convince them and that starting tomorrow, there will be many controversies in France on this subject.

But the state of emergency has unfortunately not prevented several attacks in our country! The state of emergency is no longer effective! The state of emergency is no longer proportionate and adapted. To those who think that we should exit the state of emergency without any other changes, I tell them that they are mistaken in the same way. Because the threat is there and we had to adapt, in the face of this enduring risk, our rules, recreate a framework, consolidate it by evaluating it.

France will therefore exit the state of emergency tomorrow, November 1st. It does so, equipped with a new law on Internal Security and the fight against terrorism, which complements the system established over the past few years.

Our challenge is to effectively protect the French against a permanent and multifaceted terrorist threat within the framework of common law. The measures it provides for, in limited number, are targeted, proportionate, and exclusively related to the purpose of preventing and combating terrorism.

This law guarantees a very high level of security to our fellow citizens, while strengthening the protection of freedoms, notably through increased judicial oversight, and an intervention by the judge of freedoms and detention for home visits.

I have heard – you have certainly heard – the criticisms that have sometimes been made against the draft law. The Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe himself has expressed concerns and doubts, also voiced by non-governmental organizations in France.

Other criticisms have been expressed, supporting exactly the opposite, and the irresponsibility of the government. These diametrically opposed criticisms could indicate a form of balance or proportionality dear to the European Court of Human Rights.

But it seems to me rather that the process of adopting the law shows how much we have progressed and how France is a rule of law.

First of all, because the democratic debate took place. The text was prepared by the government in a debate among ministers, rich and enlightened by the Council of State. Civil society expressed itself; I myself received a large number of non-governmental organizations, some lawyers, and I asked them to propose amendments to the text.

What was then only a draft was able to be improved throughout the process. We thus made it a point to place the judge, both administrative and judicial, at the center and to strengthen their role.

The debate continued in Parliament; the national representation further improved the text and adopted it by a very large majority, well beyond the group that supports the government. Above all, the parliamentarians further enriched the safeguards, the balances of this text and established a principle that I consider particularly healthy in these matters: that of a meeting, an evaluation set for three years to establish the assessment of the provisions. If certain measures prove unnecessary or inappropriate, they will be removed. On the other hand, if technological changes or terrorist strategies require it, the law will be supplemented.

Rather than chasing after every event, every change, by taking one text after another, we have built a framework that is intended to last, but to be reviewed in light of the facts, within the framework of the balance found.

That is why I consider that this text of law is both effective, respectful, and protective. It allows France to fully align with the common law of the European Convention, and thus to exit the framework provided by its Article 15.

Aware that the international balance is precarious, the founding fathers of the Convention indeed provided, to preserve its application, a provision allowing States confronted with exceptional circumstances – of war or public danger threatening the life of the Nation – to go beyond the restrictions authorized by the Convention temporarily, and under the control of the Court: this is Article 15 of the Convention; this so-called "derogation" clause, often misunderstood.

France, following the terrible attacks of November 13, 2015, made the decision, based on Article 15 of the Convention, to inform the Secretary General of the Council of Europe of the establishment of the state of emergency, and since then, the government has renewed this information at each extension of the state of emergency.

As I have emphasized, France's invocation of this clause has in no way meant that France has disengaged from its international obligations regarding Human Rights; quite the contrary. We have maintained our action within the framework of our international commitments in this area.

Thus, the measures taken are only those that are absolutely necessary, to the strict extent that the situation requires, and they can in no case infringe upon the most fundamental rights. Beyond the texts, the mindset that governs the application of the laws is indeed decisive.

I had the opportunity to express myself recently before the security services to pay tribute to them, to tell them that guaranteeing individual freedoms, even when the level of threat is extreme, is one of their missions and one of the noblest. And I reiterate here, and it is at the heart of our motivation to close this chapter of the use of Article 15, to exit in France from the state of emergency.

It is because I deeply believe in the balance thus found. We must resolutely protect our fellow citizens, but we must equally resolutely protect human rights and our fundamental rights because it is at the very heart of the fight we are waging against Islamist terrorists. This is precisely what they would like us to abandon or to put on hold indefinitely.

The challenge we face is somewhat akin to the one posed to CHURCHILL during the war when one of his ministers, explaining that it was necessary to pay for cannons, asked him to reduce the budget for culture, and CHURCHILL responded by saying: "But then, what is the point of fighting?" It is somewhat the same when it comes to defending our fundamental rights. What is the point of fighting if it is to decide not to apply them anymore since that is precisely what they seek.

I insist, the "project of freedoms" is a transcendent project and indeed the only one that matters, the only one that is aligned with the spiritual ends of man if one believes in his intrinsic dignity.

During the state of emergency, more than 10 events or demonstrations were organized each day in Paris; this freedom to express oneself, to march, to contest has been preserved, the French democratic vigor has been preserved. France has never yielded on its principles, its values, it will not yield, but today, here before you, it confirms its full commitment by exiting the state of emergency and sustainably building the framework of security and full respect for rights.

There is another phenomenon that challenges our rules and our habits, it is the challenge of migratory flows, what is today called the issue of migrants. I am speaking here of those women, those men, those children whom geopolitical upheavals push to our borders to seek protection from us, in Europe. I have expressed strong convictions on this subject regarding the right to asylum. I will accept no discourse or practice that calls it into question.

Those who seek asylum do so because of dramas and persecutions, but above all because they seek the dignity of legal subjects that their countries deny them.

Consequently, it is out of the question to alter our own system of rights. On the contrary, we must strengthen it, make it fairer and more effective, more effective because fairer and vice versa. We do not serve the cause of refugees by refusing to discern the merits of each application, by refusing returns because refugees essentially seek not only material shelter but a space of rights forged over centuries at the cost of great suffering and struggles, a space that has a history and a cost.

That is why I wish for France to better welcome those in manifest need of international protection and that their dignity be preserved at all costs.

I am aware that this is not always the case, that despite the speeches I have made since July, it is not yet the case everywhere. I will track each of these excesses, each of these disrespectful acts. I know that this will sometimes take time, but I will do so in this spirit of efficiency and justice, of humanity and severity, by telling you things truthfully and precisely. I want that in our country, everywhere, we welcome with dignity those who seek asylum. But I want that at the moment we welcome them, a necessary control begins which is the very condition for the proper exercise of our laws and our rights.

Today, we take weeks, sometimes months, to administratively process a procedure before OFPRA begins its work and then the appeals are also too long: it takes an average of 18 months for someone who has entered our territory before all these procedures are completed. We treat them poorly when they arrive. Too often, we leave them without shelter, on the street, we make them wait, we integrate them poorly once asylum is recognized or residence permits are issued, but we control insufficiently.

Our excessively long delays have a consequence, which is that those who, at the end of this procedure, have neither asylum nor a residence permit are only marginally returned. We must do the exact opposite. And this small revolution that I wish to bring about is one that consists, from the country of origin or the safe third country, in starting to see where protection is possible and where asylum can begin to be granted, to be uncompromising with those who do not fall under the right to asylum, to drastically accelerate our procedures so that within six months, including appeals, we can see clearly, that the decision made is notified, including to the administrative services, and enforceable, that our retention times are adapted on a European level to effectively return those who do not have these titles at the end of the procedure.

Today, we do not have the right humanity; but we also do not have the efficiency that allows us to explain this policy to our fellow citizens. I cannot explain that women and men sleep on the street while they await a residence permit. I cannot further explain that women and men who have been denied such a permit or asylum remain permanently in our territory without any papers, can enjoy benefits paid for by the French, without any control, nor effective return.

For human rights to live, there must be rigor, there must be efficiency, and we see it in this challenge of migration as in that of terrorism, if we want our democracies to regain the essence of principles, the full respect of their rights, they must also know how to be strong, to stand firm, to enforce these principles in their entirety, but to ensure they are respected when these principles are no longer upheld. We are at the exact opposite of this desirable balance.

Thus, the coming months will be relentlessly dedicated to transforming our practices, our organization aimed at fiercely combating the criminal exploitation of misery, dismantling everywhere these mafia groups often linked to terrorism that create these networks, treating with humanity those who arrive on our territory, but also rigorously returning those who do not have the right to stay.

One last challenge is imposed on France – it is endemic – I want to talk about prisons. France cannot be proud of the conditions in which a number of people are detained on its territory, due to chronic overcrowding, with an average occupancy rate of 139%. This rate reaches unsustainable levels in certain establishments. For several years, this overcrowding has been expressed by an unbearable statistic, that of the number of mattresses on the floor, which stands at around 1,300.

The Defender of Rights, the General Controller of Places of Deprivation of Liberty have consistently denounced this. The Minister of Justice, present here with me, has launched a vast reform project that will address this challenge.

There is, of course, the opening of additional places and the creation of new resources, but more fundamentally, what this unsustainable problem of prisons in our country signifies is the very subject of punishment, the very status of punishment in our country, in our societies.

Indeed, our dysfunctions sometimes lead to imposing sentences when they are not necessarily the most useful response. They insufficiently lead to a rigorous examination of their proper application, and it is enough to look at the last 15 years to see that as we have produced prison places, we have imposed sentences and filled these prisons. And I am well aware that continuing in this way would not be an end in itself.

It is therefore essential to have a profound, philosophical and practical reflection on our penal policy, its deep meaning, the place of punishment, but also the indispensable reintegration of the inmate into society. In the prison conditions that I have just described, there is no room for this patient, sometimes thankless work that consists of giving a chance, a place to someone who has committed a crime or an offense and who is serving their sentence.

It is therefore essential that we can rethink the meaning of it, take advantage of the legal revolution, reform the judicial organization, the procedure, also think about increasing the effectiveness of sentences, their full execution, but also develop so-called alternative sentences.

I particularly wish to develop the use of community service, which represents only 7% of the sentences imposed, whereas as a reparative sanction, it relies on the active participation of the convicted person and has a pedagogical dimension.

It must also be a factor of reintegration and can be a gateway to employment. The major difficulty lies in the fact that it requires coordinated mobilization of all actors: judges, probation and reintegration services, local authorities, businesses.

This project is immense, Madam Minister, and you are aware of it, but you have emphasized several times that it is an essential project for our society. Not wanting to see this cursed part of the national community, seeking to hide it, to expel it sometimes, to make it live in undignified conditions, is to condemn oneself to not allowing anyone to regain their place in society, which is the very meaning of punishment, which is the very meaning of our shared civilizational struggle, that is to say, the end of the death penalty, the idea that at some point, we have redeemed this debt to society.

Not giving oneself the means, not building the conditions for it to be effectively so, is to condemn oneself to increase the harm to society as a whole, recidivism, radicalization sometimes which also feeds on these overcrowded prisons.

That is why I plan to create, within the framework of the work that the Keeper of the Seals will have to conduct, an agency to oversee and develop community service, so that confinement is not the only horizon, so that incarceration is not the breeding ground for extremism, failed lives, broken destinies.

Behind these challenges, we see, behind these three major challenges, the question of making our rights effective in the sense that Simone VEIL meant is well posed, and nothing would be worse than self-satisfaction. A country that is satisfied with 25% youth unemployment is not exemplary; it violates the right to work in a way. A country that accepts that hundreds of thousands of citizens cannot read is not an exemplary country; it violates the right to education, one could say.

I am aware that the road to emancipation in France is still long. It is at the heart of the economic, social, and legal struggle that we will have to conduct. But the three challenges I have just mentioned are essential, and we must together rise to them.

Making these rights effective also means allowing you to function normally, to render your decisions in the best possible time. 50,000 requests reach you each year. Nearly 54,000 were assigned to a judicial formation of the Court in 2016. The Court has certainly managed to evolve and adapt. Protocol No. 14, which came into force in 2010, has allowed for better functioning of the Court by rationalizing your working methods to cope with the ever-increasing number of requests.

A few figures illustrate this evolution: the backlog of cases at the Court was less than 10,000 at the end of the year 2000, it reached a record figure of 160,000 cases in 2011 before dropping to 65,000 at the end of 2015; more than 63,000 cases are currently pending judgment. Efforts to reduce this backlog must of course continue, particularly through the prioritization of cases involving the most serious violations.

But if I cite these few figures, it is because more than for any other jurisdiction, your judicial statistics are also the precise and relentless barometer of the situation of human rights on our continent. They reveal the structural and sometimes very worrying problems faced by certain members of the Council of Europe because three-quarters of these cases concern only five countries.

They also indicate that the response to the congestion of the Court is a shared responsibility between it and the member states. It is up to the states to prevent violations of human rights, to execute the judgments of the Court correctly and promptly, and this is for me a fundamental point of vigilance. It is our direct responsibility, it is political and pragmatic, and I wish that the question of the means to ensure the sustainability of the functioning of the Court but also that of the correct execution of its judgments be at the heart of the future French presidency of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe in 2019.

However, sanctions are not everything. The Council of Europe also has, among its bodies, daily watchmen, enlightened and attentive observers whose task is to prevent violations of human rights, to promote their respect, to assist member states in a journey that is not always straightforward, and to lead them towards the highest standards in democracy, human rights, and the rule of law.

I wish to pay tribute to them here. I am first thinking of the European Commission for Democracy through Law, better known as the Venice Commission. Its unique role as an independent expert on constitutional issues has been essential in supporting the countries of Central and Eastern Europe and the Balkans towards the rule of law. Its expertise, now recognized well beyond the borders of the Council of Europe, as 14 non-European countries are now members, is just as indispensable to us today. The Venice Commission can be seized by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, which it does not fail to do.

This was the case with the constitutional reform in Turkey or, more recently, with the Polish law on common courts, as well as the bills on the National Council of the Judiciary and the Supreme Court. But it is also often seized by the states themselves. This is the case, again this year, with the law on education in Ukraine or a bill on referendums in Armenia. I believe this is a very strong sign of its authority and the recognition of the independence and impartiality of its expertise.

I also think of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe. A true "pilgrim of human rights," the Commissioner aims to promote, in complete independence and often with a great freedom of tone, which has not spared France, I must say justly, the effective respect for human rights in the member states he visits throughout the year. It is to this eminent and indispensable position that France has presented the candidacy of Pierre-Yves LE BORGN’, and I want to express my full support for him here.

But beyond these challenges, we are today shaken by international changes and profound transformations that are taking place and which, I must say, regardless of the commitments I have just made before you to address the three issues I mentioned and the relations between France and the ECHR, challenge the balances that are ours and make it possible in several places in our Europe for a regression of human rights.

We must look at this situation with lucidity. It does not weaken the Court, it does not weaken the Convention; it can collectively weaken us if we decide not to address it, not to look at it, or to do so inappropriately.

Just yesterday, human rights seemed self-evident. Many of the states signatory to the Convention even aspired to join the European Union when they were not members. But we are now in a situation where several member states are evidently, almost openly, not respecting the very terms of the Convention, challenging, at least seeking to do so, the legitimacy of it or of the Court: in Turkey, in Russia, to name just these two states, but they are not the only ones; this risk is at work.

Because we are witnessing the resurgence of authoritarian regimes or a fascination in many places in Europe for illiberal democracies, and it seems to me that this is where the coherence and strength of the responses we must provide to the challenges I have just mentioned lie.

If democracies are weak, if we consider that protecting human rights means tying our hands but not protecting our fellow citizens, that protecting our values would mean accepting the great excesses that sometimes threaten the coherence of our societies, the risk we expose ourselves to is that everywhere in Europe, the fascination for illiberal democracies or authoritarian regimes progresses.

That is why I believe that the response we provide is our attachment to our principles, through a strong democracy, with a steady hand; it is the indispensable balance that allows our peoples to maintain the consensus that is ours.

But today, several countries have tipped to the other side, either out of fear, or because extremes have taken over, or because authoritarian drifts have prevailed.

What are human rights when civilians are targeted, when entire populations are cut off from all humanitarian access, from basic care, from food, as is the case for hundreds of thousands of people in Syria, when children are turned into human shields or human bombs?

Our human rights are regressing in many places beyond our jurisdiction: in Syria, in Libya, in Myanmar. They are threatened when, everywhere, as is the case today, including on the European continent, and not only in situations of crisis or conflict, the authoritarian regimes I mentioned are advancing, fed by the temptation of retreat.

For all these reasons, respect for human rights is being undermined. They are seen as a weakening by those who seek to combat or reduce them, whereas they are a strength, a specificity, whereas they are universal. They are presented as an option when they are an obligation.

In the face of these drifts, particularly within our ranks, we must confront the situation and denounce it without ever resigning ourselves. This is the work that the Secretary General is doing, which you are leading, and for which you have my full support.

We must speak to everyone, and this is the method I have adopted since day one. It is of no use to exclude those who today do not respect our fundamental rights, those who want to turn their backs on their own history.

My deep conviction is that the fate of Russia or Turkey will not be built by turning their backs on Europe since these two great nations are anchored to Europe, since their history, their geography, their literature, their political consciousness have been built by engaging with Europe.

Therefore, we must always tell them, denounce not by closing the door, not by excluding them from everything, not by allowing them to exclude themselves from everything, but by engaging in this intense, difficult, sometimes thankless dialogue, marked by small victories and sometimes small defeats, but which consists of holding the thread because their peoples deserve it, because their fellow citizens are Europeans, because the nationals of all these countries, regardless of the choices of their leaders, deserve that we fight for them, deserve access to this right, to the protection of their rights.

We will therefore do this and continue to do so because I do not believe in the supposed opposition between our values and our interests, and I am aware that injustice, impunity, and the violation of rights are not only the consequence but the very fertile ground of instability.

The countries that are most often summoned before the ECHR are full members of the community gathered around the Convention, and they must remain so. This is, in any case, my deep conviction and what I will work for. This is also why I will continue to speak to everyone, to assert our arguments, to carry our voice and our values in Turkey, in Russia, and elsewhere, without accepting the slightest concession, but without resigning myself to the slightest silence.

On the contrary, it is a renewed demand; it is about affirming confidence in what we are because at some point that we will not have waited for, the light will come, the deep interest will reappear, where the peoples will rise up, and we will be there.

Respect for human rights is a legal obligation. Their defense is a political and diplomatic act. It is a struggle with the weapons, fearfully effective, of dialogue. Naivety in this matter, like renunciation, are often just other names for powerlessness.

With you, with all the countries, whether or not they are signatories to the Convention, I want to be very clear: France will not accept any criticism of human rights intended to camouflage an agenda, to promote supposedly superior national interests; it will not allow itself to be drawn into debates suggesting that human rights are merely the translation of "values" that are inapplicable elsewhere in the world.

Our values, these rights that you defend, are universal. Sometimes it is necessary to let some people find their way. We must refrain from lecturing others from our countries, especially when they are plunged into situations of great difficulty, insecurity, or the fight against terrorism, but we must always hold on to the thread, the very thread of what has made us, avoiding confrontation as well as denial.

These are the three convictions I wanted to share with you today. Your work, our work is also profoundly challenged by innovations at the heart of our societies. You mentioned it by talking about surrogacy and children born outside our borders through this means. Our civilizations are alive. Mentalities are evolving, social structures are evolving. Technological changes are profound, and beyond these new geopolitical facts that I have just mentioned, which shake our balances, we will have in the coming years debates that will also challenge our vision of human rights, our discussions on human rights.

Augmented humanity, big data, technological innovations such as bioethics will inevitably lead to essential debates within our societies. None of these debates will be simple. None of these debates in France will be conducted in brutality or a peremptory conception of political fact that would overshadow the consciousness and the indispensable play of consciousness, philosophical and religious convictions. But it will be necessary, to live in society, that rules of law are gradually established because the facts will gradually be there.

We must therefore begin to rethink the protection of rights, including constitutional rights, in a deterritorialized world where humanity itself is being transformed. This will also be one of the challenges of the decade because if it is true that France values scientific progress and is not afraid of what is happening, it is determined to uphold the principle of equality. After the fundamental rights recognized in 1789, the rights of claim recognized in 1946, a third period is now opening, that of new rights for which we will need inventiveness and for which I hope, within the framework of the constitutional work opened a few months ago, that we can reflect. We are ready for it.

You see, ladies and gentlemen, upholding human rights is a struggle, including for countries like France, which are deeply attached to them. The European Court of Human Rights is more than ever an essential bulwark to protect the nationals of the 47 member states from drifts, totalitarian temptations, and the dangers posed by the world to come.

What is being tested today is the unity around the ECHR and the Convention it upholds. What is being tested is the commitment to this daily struggle. We must not cease to fight for this unity to remain. For this commitment to endure, we must fight against the temptations of retreat, cynicism, or the spirit of renunciation.

Europe, ladies and gentlemen, must take pride in having created a supranational body responsible for upholding human rights. It is a structure that we must leave intact to future generations and that we must adapt to the challenges of the future. This will be a struggle. This struggle must be tireless. This struggle must always be renewed. This struggle will also be that of France because in this area, to borrow the beautiful phrase of Victor Hugo, which was also one of Clemenceau's mottos, there will always be more promised lands than gained grounds.

This conquest of promised lands is our age-old mission; it is our duty; it is our history, and France will never cease to take its full part in it. Thank you.