Speech by the President of the Republic on the occasion of the reception for the Association of Mayors of France.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

21 November 2018 · Reception for the Association of Mayors of France (AMF) Congress

Context
Macron addressed over 2,000 mayors at the Élysée Palace during the Association of Mayors of France Congress reception on 21 November 2018.
Main themes
Local governance and mayoral concerns, fiscal transfers and DGF reform, relationship between central government and municipalities, civic trust and public expectations, mayors' willingness to seek re-election, shared republican responsibility, financial stability of local authorities
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,127
87th percentile
Sentences
139
78th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.14
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 51%51%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Economic 13%13%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

139 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen Ministers,

Mr. President of the AMF,

Ladies and gentlemen Mayors,

I am very happy to be among you. Thank you, thank you for being here, and thank you, President BAROIN, for conveying on our behalf this invitation to all those who were present for this AMF Congress so that we could share this moment.

I believe there are more than 2,000 of you; I am aware that some are a bit cramped. We were debating with the AMF bureau, and we debated a little longer than expected; that explains my delay, and I apologize for it. But we had a good debate.

The goal this evening is primarily to spend some time together, and I will stay with you as long as there are people in this room. This is not a challenge I am throwing at you; it is a commitment I am making because this place is yours.

Last year, I invited a few mayors. This year, I wanted to fulfill the commitment made to report back and to exchange, not to come to the usual room [at the Parc des expositions, Porte de Versailles], which I will do next year, as we discussed with President BAROIN, for the opening of the Congress, but to welcome you in this place because I consider that this place of the Republic is yours. And we share it.

I will say just a few words. Then, what I propose is to respond in a more interactive way to all the questions you may have. Areas have been defined in the room; there are four, including for those who are watching me through a screen, we will take four to five questions per area in order to exchange for a good hour in this format, and then afterwards, I will be among you to perhaps exchange in a more friendly or more personal manner.

I was saying, my dear friends, the Republic, we share it. The times we are living in are not simple. And I will not teach you that. Since I was elected – and I would even say, before – I have seen on the ground the role that is yours, and I see it more and more every day. I am not happy when I read the polls and the feedback on the concerns that may exist, on the doubts that some mayors may have, on their willingness not to necessarily re-engage… This is the symptom of a collective pressure, of a malaise, of something that shakes all public decision-makers. And when I say "all public decision-makers," I mean you and me! Because, indeed, for the citizen, there is the mayor and the President of the Republic, as we often say, and because I am here before you, because like you, I was elected by the French people.

Like you, I feel a desire to act, sometimes much faster and more demanding than we can manage ourselves, I sense a concern in the face of all the changes, there is also sometimes a lot of misunderstanding, because the changes or reforms we engage in are not always understood, and we must have this humility, but I also feel a lot of expectation. When I say that the Republic is shared between us, it is because there is one thing that connects mayors, the President of the Republic, with him the entire government, and that also touches all elected officials of the Republic, it is that there is a tremendous expectation. And therefore, we must not yield to a bad wind that would suggest that the fault lies necessarily with the elected official.

The elected official is the one who has the capacity to act, but they are also the one who is – forgive this familiarity – but "within reach of a scolding" and who can find themselves shaken and who is in a way at the crossroads of all the paradoxes of a society. We are at this point; we share this situation, it did not start yesterday, but it is probably at its peak today.

In the face of this, I made commitments last year, and I want to report on them here. I did so in the letter I wrote to you, so I will not go into detail, but above all, I will respond very precisely to all the questions you will ask.

I had made commitments regarding financial resources. The stability of the DGF in the state budget – afterwards, we will talk about each particular situation. Some are decreasing, some are increasing. The problem is always the same; those for whom it is increasing rarely say thank you. Those for whom it is decreasing feel it! But for the first time in many years, the level of the DGF has been the same for this year's budget, it will be the same next year: 18.3 billion. We are ending years of decline in the DGF, and as I said earlier to the AMF, I am ready to open the reform of the DGF rules.

There are rules… Be careful because… we will collectively applaud ourselves because we are launching a reform, but afterwards, we will have to carry it out, and there too, all those for whom the DGF has decreased, it is not your servant who constructed the multiple criteria of the DGF, it is often the elected officials themselves who pushed for them. They were voted on by Parliament. But what affects you the most is what? The decrease in the number of inhabitants. The problem is that if we stop this criterion, we will have to explain to those who gain that they will not have an increasing DGF, which is complicated also because they have additional burdens, because when they gain inhabitants, they are asked to build more schools, to build more swimming pools, more infrastructure. It is a real choice that will have to be made, but I want us to discuss it because manifestly the current rule is not perfect.

Then, there are other rules that exist that have also led to shifts, particularly the famous NOTRe law which modified the boundaries of intercommunalities, and when some joined intercommunalities that had a richer reference income, they lost DGF, and you discovered that, I must say we did too since it was the mechanical effect of a reform launched several years ago. So, I have good news; this constrained intercommunalization movement, we have stopped it, it is a commitment I made, so it will not change, so this effect will not occur for next year's allocations. The allocations will continue to follow the other rules, but I want us to open the discussion. And we also wanted to maintain the mechanisms of rural-urban equalization and the investment support allocations.

In the same way, the commitment that was made regarding the housing tax has been upheld, and I will also return to this topic if there are questions. A reform will be initiated in a manner that I want to be very concerted in close partnership not only with the AMF but with all associations of local authorities, to deeply reform our local taxation.

The second commitment I made was to loosen the grip. I know well what mayors say: "it is not going fast enough, we would like to do more, and in fact, too often the State prevents us or the administration." Well, do not look far; in any case, in the end, it is me, so I take my share of responsibility because from where I am, I will not tell you, it is this official or that one. The President of the Republic has the power of appointment by the Constitution; if there is something that is not working with people with whom it is not functioning, in the end, I take my share of responsibility. But we will have to collectively make this transformation together. However, I will still recall several in-depth reforms that the government has conducted during this year, in accordance with my commitments.

Loosening the grip on measures that were too rigid in terms of water competencies is what the minister did with all the parliamentarians with a law that came to correct the issue regarding water competency. I know that some wanted to go further, others did not want to; it is the compromise that was built, it allowed for adjustments on this competency.

Loosening the grip is what we did in accordance with the commitment I made before you regarding school rhythms with the Minister of National Education; we gave the freedom to opt out and choose.

Loosening the grip is also what has been done by implementing, and the Prime Minister has followed this with great attention, an unprecedented rule, the one in two rule, when we create an additional norm, we must eliminate two others. I have the statistics at your disposal; we have never taken so few government decrees in the last 20 years, independently of the decrees requested by laws. Why? Because every time ministries came with a decree, we said very well, you want to take a new norm here, then decrees, regulations, whatever the support, you propose two that we will remove. So, there are a few who have succeeded, but very often it is quite virtuous because the decree that was so necessary is withdrawn.

Then this flexibility is what we are advancing on, and on this, the government is fully committed to local public service. Consultation has begun; there is real work, and I want it to be even more intense in the coming weeks with you to give you elected officials more flexibility in terms of hiring, outside the framework of the local public service by allowing more hiring based on contracts. I am very much in favor, as I have also said, of entrusting elected officials, associations of elected officials, with the management of the local public service; there is nothing that justifies that the three public services are tied to each other. And that when the government wants to raise the index of nurses by one point, as was the case under the previous term, it is all civil servants, including local civil servants, who see their index raised with a burden that then falls back on you and which in total represented, if I remember correctly, about one billion euros for local authorities. On this, let us all take our responsibilities; I am ready to loosen the grip and move forward.

In the same way, loosening the grip means adapting this famous NOTRe law that I mentioned, and I have asked the government to work on this, and it is starting to happen in the territories; the prefects will coordinate this work, a discussion to marginally improve everything that was created by the NOTRe law, that does not mean going back massively; I think we should not unravel things, and I said it at the time I was elected, I do not want to go back into debates that sometimes took years on the perimeter of regions, the competencies of this or that, but at the margins of the NOTRe law, we can improve things.

In fact, I see it well when I visit you on the ground; there are intercommunalities that are too large today that have been somewhat constrained. The movement of intercommunalities is good; I am not saying here that we need to go back. We may have disagreements, but intercommunalities allow for the realities of the territory to thrive, and I say this here before the president of the ADCF with whom there is exemplary work. I believe in this movement of intercommunalities, but it is true that it works all the better when it is chosen and when its territorial dynamics are thought out and coherent. However, we can see today that we have, in some areas of the territory, intercommunalities that are so large that we have absurd situations that do not allow us to meet the needs of the inhabitants. This, we need to correct, in a spirit of pragmatism.

And then, loosening the grip is what we want to continue to do in the major public policies we are conducting in health, education, and I do not want to be too long, so I will not detail beyond what is reasonable.

So, it is not going as fast as I would like because it is a cultural change that we need to achieve together. We passed a law that I called the right to make mistakes; there was a very significant amount of work by parliamentarians often in consultation with you to change the relationship of the administration with the administered, businesses, and elected officials, but this does not happen overnight. The law has changed; I promulgated it in September. If I were to conduct a survey tomorrow, I am pretty sure that the realities on the ground have not changed in accordance with the law. I will have the opportunity to express myself, like the Prime Minister, in a few weeks before the state officials. To all the executives of the public service, it is one of the messages I will pass on to them, but it is also the message I wanted to convey to you: we have, I believe, begun to define a working method with the AMF, and everywhere on the ground, I want it to be carried out with our prefects, with your departmental representatives, and with you. It is together that we must support this change in mentality.

The State has historically been built on a culture of control.

and of the norm. We should not lament it; it is also what has made us strong, it is what has created a successful state during the 20th century, which has structured itself in the face of these challenges and which still functions remarkably when we look at the sovereign state, when we need assistance, when we must react very quickly. I still remember in Trèbes, a few weeks ago. Elected officials hand in hand with the state do a remarkable job because we have this strength, we have had this organization. But many of the challenges we face today require flexibility, adaptation, speed, and fundamentally a shift to a culture of support, of solutions, of control, ex post rather than ex ante, of support.

It is up to us to drive this change, and I ask you to help us because I know that this is what you need, which also requires a lot of pragmatic ground-level action. I take my share of humility, a change on which I will constantly insist, that you will hear me repeat, and that we will succeed together because there is no other choice. We can return in our discussions to the National Agency for Territorial Cohesion, which is one of the important instruments for various projects.

I will conclude on this point because it is one we share.

We are facing a moment in the country that is critically important in many respects. We are one of the major countries in Europe that has not managed to solve the problem of mass unemployment and the issue of national cohesion since, fundamentally, the end of the Glorious Thirty. Our model worked very well when we were in a catch-up economy based on the compromise of 1945, and since then we have been trying to adjust things, but we have not managed to recreate a great narrative, and therefore we all, wherever we are on the ground, must manage these dissatisfactions, these blockages, this suffering that has settled in.

Because when we have families that have been unemployed for decades, when we have territories that have experienced the fractures of deindustrialization for decades, it obviously creates wounds, and we inherit them, along with impatience. On top of that, we are at a moment of acceleration in history for our country. There is an acceleration of economic, social, and territorial phenomena; it started a few years ago, but it does not stop. It is the acceleration of a form of territorial transition where our inhabitants have increasingly moved towards the metropolises, have increasingly concentrated where there was activity, opportunities, and where, by the way, the state has somewhat supported this movement by concentrating its presence in the capital and in its metropolises, and where we have collectively allowed a form of desertification to settle in.

It is no longer Paris that is the French desert; it is areas that are driven by global activity and the rest of the country. It continues to be there, and it creates phenomena of saturation in certain spaces; we must not think that everything is fine in the metropolises because it is also where we have concentrated certain populations with problems, with difficulties; it is there that we have difficult neighborhoods. And then there are territories of the Republic that live in doubt because they see their populations leaving, because they say to themselves, "I can no longer attract a doctor, because they can no longer build projects and feel that they are no longer given the means." And alongside that, the ecological transition that we talk about a lot right now because we also see it accelerating, but it is there, it causes anxiety and creates tensions, paradoxical injunctions in our society. Our fellow citizens want to breathe better air; they are anxious for their children in the face of climate change, air pollution as well as warming, but they need to be supported for the changes that this implies in their daily lives, and that is entirely legitimate.

On these issues, there was already a response of support from the government; the Prime Minister presented new responses last week with 500 million euros in support, but we can see that we must collectively invent a new method here too, where we need to better explain things, the common course, share the constraint, and ward off what I consider a supreme injustice that I will not allow to settle in our country, that which would have social inequality coupled with environmental inequality. And that is not new either, but who lives in thermal sieves? Who has been forced to buy second-hand cars that consume much more and pollute more? Our fellow citizens whom we absolutely must not stigmatize but who were already in social difficulty, and therefore indeed we cannot tell them overnight that they must change the world. Nevertheless, we cannot leave them for social or environmental reasons in this situation, and so here too we have a collective challenge, and we share it. It cannot be immobilism; it cannot be an idyllic vision of change saying, "Children, starting tomorrow, it changes, and adapt," it must be built in the territories, it must be built in a shared manner with the spirit of responsibility that characterizes us, and I will return to this if you wish.

Finally, we have a digital transition; it affects everyone, and it requires all of us to restore access to our fellow citizens through equipment; I will return to this in detail if you wish, but to support those who are far from this transformation. We have about 15% of our population that is far from digital tools; we cannot tell them overnight, "Everything is becoming digital, and it’s wonderful." And we must hold a tension together, succeed in being in digital excellence wherever we can, not hinder those who in their businesses, in their commerce, in their daily crafts as citizens want to go further, faster, stronger because it is the future, but not leave behind those who cannot keep up with this movement. And so this too is public investment, it is support, and it is support as close to the ground as possible.

On all these issues of transition and acceleration, the challenge that is ours is therefore to invent a new grammar. Does the solution lie in decentralization as we thought 30 years ago? I do not believe so; I do not think we should reopen Pandora's box of competencies; I say this to municipalities that have a general competence by definition; we have sometimes lost a lot of time figuring out what the right competence was to give to regions or departments only to then untangle what we were doing here or there. Our fellow citizens want efficiency and meaning; you carry it, and I want to carry it with you. The challenge of decentralization that we face is to be able to respond both to the correction of this history we inherit and to these three major transitions and therefore to define much more together the major policies to do so; that is the commitment I made to the AMF office because I believe that good solutions cannot be thought of simply by a few and simply in one place; they must be thought of, irrigated by the experience of the territory, and particularly of the municipalities.

This then requires us to apply it together in a very different way, knowing how to better explain our common objectives and relying on two pillars: access to essential services and differentiation. Access to essential services means building a project where everywhere in the territory, to succeed in these transformations, all our fellow citizens, wherever they come from, must have access, access to digital technology, access to education, to health, to basic services. We know this very well, and we will return to it, I imagine, in your questions; these are battles, it is investment, but these access policies are what we must build together.

The other pillar is differentiation; there is no one-size-fits-all solution for the entire French territory; there are profoundly different solutions, which is why I wanted to initiate this logic of a pact that we have with many territories; we did it with regions, I signed it with three countries at the borders of the North and Aisne a few weeks ago during the memorial journey I was able to undertake; we do it with departments; we must adapt territorial projects and a form of contractualization between the government and elected officials based on the challenges posed to you and those of the population. And we must differentiate the margins of maneuver we give ourselves, the rules, having more flexibility in one place than another.

We have been guided on this path by the overseas territories with which we started this method several years ago and which we have systematized, as with Corsica, with which we have adopted this method and which is beginning to bear fruit.

This logic of differentiation, this pragmatic approach as close to the ground as possible is what we must promote, and I hope that it can be fully enshrined during the constitutional reform that is dear to many of us here, which will allow differentiation to be inscribed in the Constitution.

There you go, my dear friends, I do not want to be longer, and I have probably been too long, but I wanted to share with you first this account of my commitments before going into detail with your questions, but above all this shared vision. I know that your daily life is not easy; that of the government is not any easier, I assure you, even if it does not console you, and I think that in the face of these challenges we have a common responsibility, which is to be together. Because I know one thing: the day when those who carry the Republic and therefore those who have a part of the republican democratic legitimacy in their hands are not together, then we open a formidable boulevard not to populisms; I do not like that term; we are true populists; we are with the people every day, but to demagogues, to those who would like to simplify things, to those who love the noise of daily life, and to those who would say, "I am for less taxes, more public spending, more tolerance, more ecology, no constraints of transition," fundamentally because they are not in the same situation as us, that is to say, without the constraint of public action.

The Republic is the common good; it implies engagement, and you are engaged; it implies being responsible, and we are; being responsible means being accountable, it means telling the truth even when it is not pleasant. This vision of the country that I want to carry with you is that of action in daily life.

I will now answer all the questions you may have. Thank you. (…)