exchanges between Emmanuel Macron, Charles Michel and the students of the University of Louvain-la-Neuve

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

20 November 2018 · University of Louvain-la-Neuve, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium

Context
Macron addressed students and Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel at the University of Louvain-la-Neuve in November 2018, discussing European integration and reform.
Main themes
European integration, multi-speed Europe, treaty reform, European Union democracy and accountability, fiscal and social harmonization, environmental ambition, enhanced cooperation, Brexit, EU institutions and national politics, pan-European political movements, youth engagement in Europe
Duration
~88 min
98th percentile
Words
10,545
98th percentile
Sentences
408
97th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
67th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

408 sentences in 187 paragraphs

Tom, Master's student in European Law, member of the Citizen Code:

I have a first question, the major challenges of our time, whether environmental, social, or fiscal in nature, require, in your opinion, new advances in European integration. If you share the observation of a political impossibility to revise the treaties in the short or medium term, how do we achieve Europe at two or three speeds when, apart from perhaps some progress in defense, neither the enhanced cooperations you advocated, Mr. Prime Minister, nor the informal intergovernmentalism you promote, Mr. President, seem sufficient to produce major advances? Thank you.

Johanne MONTET:

Your question is directed at both personalities. Mr. President?

Michel LIEGEOIS, Professor of International Relations: We will take directly the question from Lorielle...

Johanne MONTET: Yes, we will take the second question.

Michel LIEGEOIS: We will take both questions.

Johanne MONTET: Yes, three questions.

Lorielle, Student:

Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister, first of all, thank you for being here, I personally thank you and also thank you on behalf of "I love Benelux," of which I am a part. My question is this: do you not think that we should put "The Bastards of Europe" on trial, to borrow the words of Jean QUATREMER, who attributes the successes of Brussels to himself while denying any responsibility for its failures to flatter their electorate? To put an end to this hypocrisy of "it's Brussels' fault," should we not give a more prominent place to the institutions of the European Union under the spotlight of national media? Thank you.

Johanne MONTET: After "The Bastards of Europe," we will take a third question, a question from the audience. Where is it? Who is asking it? I don't see a hand... Ah, there we go, it's on! Shall we give them a microphone?

Jonathan, Second-year Management Engineering Student:

My question is, in the last two years, pan-European movements have emerged, such as VOLT, in view of the upcoming European elections. I was wondering what you think of these movements that bring together young people from different countries in Europe.

Johanne MONTET: Thank you for the question, so we will answer one after the other, Mr. President, we are listening to you!

THE PRESIDENT: Thank you very much, first allow me to thank you for this opportunity to exchange very freely with you and to thank the Prime Minister for your welcome and for being here. I am always very happy to speak freely about Europe.

The first question about integration and how to advance towards a more social Europe with real fiscal harmonization and greater environmental ambition. First of all, indeed, I believe in a Europe with multiple circles or multiple speeds; it already exists, and therefore we should not have false modesty on this subject. There is already the Schengen area, the eurozone, and therefore we must have maximum ambition. Europe has always functioned like this, with a vanguard that has a lot of ambition and attracts others. The great mistake we have made, in fact, for the last five or ten years is that we always want to decide everything at 28, perhaps tomorrow at 27 after Brexit; that is not true, it has never worked like that. It is not Europe of the greatest common denominator; it is Europe of the greatest ambition that attracts others.

With that in mind, I think we must continue to pursue enhanced cooperations, as you mentioned, we are doing it in defense, and for my part, I am in favor of changing the treaties. We are reaching a point where it must be done; we should not be afraid of that, but there must be a clear rule: those who are against do not block the others. And I say this coming from a country that, during the last referendum in 2005, when France voted no, blocked all the others, and I think that is a mistake. That is why in the proposed methods, it is Europe at multiple speeds; let us define the maximum ambitions, see who follows, do the maximum already within the framework of the treaties, and accept the principle of changing the treaties and therefore possibly going to referendums or to our parliaments to change them, but based on a project, not on a denunciation of what does not work. And those who are against do not participate but do not block the others, which is a real change in method and will allow us to have a vanguard, and you will see that gradually we will have this core of Europe that works better with this greater social, economic, fiscal integration and a real environmental and food ambition.

This requires a change, and that is the answer to the second question, to indeed change the approach to Europe. All countries have indeed had this approach that consists of saying "when there is a problem - sorry to say it here - it's Brussels" and "if things are going well, it's thanks to me," forgetting, by the way, that very often they had European funding, including for the projects they inaugurated. One, it’s about pedagogy. So should everything be left to Brussels, should we community-ize more? I am not sure; I think we need to clarify what we call cross-financing so that when there is funding, it is more identifiable. But I think then there is a policy, a responsibility of leaders, particularly pro-European leaders, to assume and carry this ourselves and to carry it in two ways. One, each time to say that there are European credits or projects, to signify it, to make it tangible for the population. I was earlier in Molenbeek, there is an association that recognized itself, that said "I received European funding, I am doing this because there is Europe." And, two, to accept that when we have problems, it is often because we do not know how to resolve them completely, that we need more coordination, and it is not Brussels; for me, Europe does not prevent me from doing something or solving problems that I have!

And I will let you in on a secret, Europe is us too; it turns out that when we say "it's Brussels" or "the problem is the other," you referred to a pithy formula from journalist Jean QUATREMER, but it is us, it is the 28 around the table, so there is no need to shift the blame onto someone else! And so, yes, we need to do pedagogy, yes, we need to regain true political courage; that is the battle of the moment, and I believe it is absolutely fundamental for those who believe in this mission. I do not think, however, that we should go in the direction of greater community-ization today; why? Because one of the problems we have is too much European bureaucracy, and one of the problems we have is sometimes that there is too great a distance from the most local population. It is up to the leaders of each country and sometimes to local leaders to also carry Europe and to consider that it is not only the community officials who must carry it; it is a sharing because it is our common project. I am even in favor of having more subsidiarity, which can go along with more European spirit.

Finally, in response to the last question, I deeply believe in the pan-European movement; I am very much in favor of all the youth movements that are emerging, young or less young, and I am in favor of the emergence of a true European demos. That is why I defended the idea of having real European lists; we said cross-border, which worried many people, but we have European elections; simply when we approach the vote, the debates become completely national again. That is why I proposed that there be, based on common sensitivities, a common approach to Europe, a quota of European parliamentarians who are elected on a true European project and by all Europeans together. And I think we will go in that direction if we believe in the strength, in the place of the European Parliament, if we believe that we can, which is my deep conviction, be a more democratic space within Europe; we need more truly European movements that allow dialogue between our different countries, whether among the young or the less young.

Johanne MONTET: Charles MICHEL, Mr. Prime Minister, a reaction to that?

Johanne MONTET: Alright, we will take a small question from the audience; raise your hand high so I can see you because it’s large. There is a gentleman over there raising his hand, behind the lady, yes, you, there on the left, and here we go, we are listening to you.

Maxime, Master's student in History:

I wanted to ask you a question that might be a little provocative, so I will introduce it briefly.

Johanne MONTET: Not too long, watch out for the intros!

Maxime: Not too long, briefly, briefly! In France, with the recent resignation of Nicolas HULOT from your government, we saw the influence of lobbies on climate change policies and how they hindered them come to light. In Belgium, we have the Federation of Enterprises and the Federation of Petroleum Enterprises that have also expressed themselves against the commitments made by Belgium at the various COPs. In France again, TOTAL has used its influence to introduce exceptions to the law on the end of hydrocarbons that it obtained, as they considered it threatened their profits. We have not seen this kind of thing for the small diesel consumers who are currently in the news. So my question is the following: approaching COP24, you said, Mr. MACRON, that you believed that certain countries should be at the forefront, setting an example. What do you plan to do as heads of state of two developed countries, two industrial powers, to implement the recommendations of the IPCC and thus free yourselves from the influence of lobbies that are currently hindering the application of these measures, seeking to defend the profits of large companies that they know are the primary polluters? We know, for example, that 100 multinationals are responsible for 71% of greenhouse gas emissions over the last 30 years, and among these multinationals is TOTAL, which I mentioned earlier, which has managed again with this law on hydrocarbons to influence and delay the fight against climate change. Thank you.

Johanne MONTET: Thank you, we have heard your question, and now we will hear the answers.

THE PRESIDENT: I do not know what you are referring to when you talk about TOTAL and the law on hydrocarbons because that is factually false, but I will respond to each of the points. First of all, Nicolas HULOT said it; he also resigned for very personal reasons that I respect. I spoke to him on the phone a few days ago; he is a friend, a free man. Do not believe that changing things profoundly is an easy task every day, and if he referred to lobbies, he spoke more about hunting than about hydrocarbons, and therefore when we ask questions on such delicate subjects, we must be very precise.

So what is the environmental transition that I intend to lead in France and that I believe in for Europe? Indeed, it is to say we must reduce our emissions; when we look at the figures in France, the last two measured years, 2015, 2016, he mentioned it when he left, we have emissions that are increasing. I was not in charge at that time, and by the way, the work we are doing will have effects, but not for the current year, for the years to come, but I think we will have concrete and real effects. If we want to reduce these emissions, we must work on three things: energy production, the functioning of businesses, and households and mobility. For businesses, we are asking them, as we are asking households, to make a profound evolution since we are reducing the gap that existed in taxation in France between diesel and regular gasoline, and we are implementing what was voted under the two previous terms but not applied, which is what we call a carbon strategy where we integrate precisely on fossil fuels a contribution to be able to increase their prices and finance renewables.

We are implementing it; the strategy was voted at the beginning of the term in a very transparent manner, and we are implementing it with, contrary to what you said, real accompanying measures for the more modest, but it requires changing habits; it is never easy. The Government is indeed currently facing protests on this, and it is in dialogue that we can get out of it, in explanation, in the ability to find both the right pace and the ground solutions. But the strategy is, on the one hand, to tax fossil fuels more and, on the other hand, to have support for the more modest with a conversion aid that consists of saying that we commit, and it will go up to 4,000 euros to help households buy new or used electric, hybrid, or much less polluting vehicles than the old generations.

It consists of saying that we compensate people who need to travel a lot and who cover many kilometers with the mileage allowance, this was announced by the Prime Minister last week, and it means that we support households that rely on fuel for heating by allowing them to save energy and helping them to change their boilers.

Johanne MONTET

: Mr. President, have you explained all this to the French?

THE PRESIDENT

: Yes, and we will continue!

Johanne MONTET

: And yet they are still in the streets...

THE PRESIDENT

: But that’s normal!

Johanne MONTET

: ...and Belgium too.

THE PRESIDENT

: Let me tell you, things do not happen spontaneously, and this is where we collectively need to have a sense of responsibility. We cannot be in a debate in our societies constantly saying "you are not moving fast enough to make the change, the climate transition, ecology, you are in the hands of lobbies, it is not moving fast enough." And when you fight to change things, then you no longer hear those who say that or say "you are in the hands of lobbies" but you are no longer facing the French or the Belgians and all those who are experiencing the consequences of these transitions! Because those who are blocking our change today are not lobbies at all, and I will come to energy production, not at all! I challenge you to see how TOTAL has influenced French strategy, not at all, nothing! We will be the first country in the world to have closed all coal-fired thermal power plants by 2022, I am not stipulating for future mandates, by 2022 in France we will have closed all coal-fired thermal power plants, all of them, there is not a country in the world that is doing that.

I have had lobbies but I also have companies with employees on the ground and the people who give lessons and say "you are in the hands of lobbies" I never see them facing the employees, the employees are indeed in the streets today, they say "you want to kill my jobs!" That is the reality of the world we face, there would not be on one side lobbies and on the other side those who give lessons, we all share the same planet, we all want to reduce emissions, we all want to change the world and change the economic, social, environmental model, at least I really want that. But there is a harsh reality to embrace, as a neighboring poet, certainly French but from the Ardennes, Arthur RIMBAUD, said, and the harsh reality to embrace is to be able to look squarely at those who will lose their jobs because we say we must close coal-fired thermal power plants. We will do it but we must invent jobs for them in new energies, in new professions, we must be able to tell people who had mobility habits "we will help you but you must gradually change behaviors, we will help you, we will develop teleworking, we will develop other forms of mobility, we will support you to change vehicles, to have less polluting and more fuel-efficient vehicles," we will have mechanisms to adjust socially.

And so I cannot let it be said that the TOTAL group has in any way influenced French strategy in France, that is factually false, and the people who say that are lying, I tell you even if you are far away, eye to eye. If I were in the hands of lobbies I would have many fewer problems, many fewer, because I would not have made this transition! If I had followed TOTAL I would not have increased the price of gasoline, that is not in their interest, on the contrary, we also need to know how to move away from the postures we have had for 15, 20 years that prevent us from making progress on these issues and that is the economic, social, environmental transformation. I believe in a new model that Europe will be able to carry but where we must be able to make these transformations, they are not easy for anyone, they upset the companies that are affected, it is difficult for people but it requires pedagogy, having social and economic support measures and not yielding to any lobby.

At the European level, it is the same ambition that I want us to carry, I am in favor of a carbon floor price, we have set up a carbon market, all the groups you mentioned are against having a floor price, I am in favor of it because it is the only way to have a real transition and to say investments will change because we will have a carbon floor price and we will have a real market. But that requires, and we must not yield too quickly to schematism, to have real support measures and therefore to know how to look at our champions and thus to impose a carbon tax at our borders. Because it is not yielding to lobbies to say we have large steel groups, we have large groups that consume a lot of electricity or carbon to produce. If we only penalize them in Europe but continue to import products from China, India, or others that are not subject to the same rules, we will not have reduced emissions at the global level and we will have sacrificed European industry.

It is not yielding to lobbies, it is also about holding all the constraints of a model where we want to change the mode of production, have an influence on the rest of the world but continue to have production and jobs in Europe! And so I am in favor of a carbon floor price in Europe, of a CO2 tax at the borders to compensate for this and to tax products coming from other countries that do not make the same efforts as we do and at the same time protect our companies, you see. So the path of a transition is neither on the side of a form of ethereal truth that would forget the reality of people nor on the side of lobbies because on one side you can do wonderful things but that never exists and on the other you do not move. And believe one thing, we are moving in France and I hope we will move in Europe along the line I just mentioned.

Michel LIEGEOIS

: Thank you very much. It is already high time to move on to our second sequence dedicated to Europe's policies and politics in Europe, we have actually sketched this second sequence with this important question about the ecological transition and so we begin this second sequence here on stage with Anaïs's question.

Johanne MONTET

: Anaïs, we will give you a microphone, it will be simpler, here you go Anaïs, just ask!

Anaïs, Student

: Thank you very much. Mr. President, you are currently in a university, so it seemed appropriate to ask you a question on this subject. Parcoursup, a year ago instead of opening places in universities you decided to limit the number of students having access with a secret allocation algorithm while European legislation prohibits it. You have generalized selection at entry and stalled social mobility. Following your reform, 160,000 enrolled students are turning to private education, more than one in two professional baccalaureate holders did not obtain selection in the main phase and at the start of the school year more than 10,000 students are awaiting an assignment. Against this reform, students have organized and mobilized to defend everyone's right to public education. However, the response to this has not been long in coming, for the first time in 50 years the CRS have invaded the temples of knowledge and participated in their desacralization. Little by little, the conception of what higher education is changes, it is no longer an essential component of society but a place where knowledge is traded. Recently you changed the rules for appointments to the rectorates, now 12 rectors out of 30 can be elected without obtaining a doctorate. No one can understand that to lead a university one does not need to be a scientist but a good manager, and this represents a blatant violation of the principle of collegiality that underpins our European universities.

Johanne MONTET

: The question.

Anaïs

: Yes, sorry, I just have one more little paragraph.

Johanne MONTET

: There are many people and the question is...

Anaïs

: Can I finish my little paragraph, please?

Johanne MONTET

: Go ahead, the paragraph but quickly, quickly, quickly!

Anaïs

: Okay. Just speaking of these European universities you demonstrate this utilitarian vision in your project for a European alliance, a... universities as a vector of power and training for the wealthiest, considering the student as a client, considering that higher education creates elites, that it is normal to pay tens of thousands of euros for a year of studies. This was confirmed yesterday by your Prime Minister when he announced that the tuition fees for students from outside the European Union would increase, a decision that shows the idea that the tuition fees for everyone could increase.

Johanne MONTET

: Now, the question, let’s go, that’s it!

Anaïs

: Yes, sorry, sorry, sorry. My question is the following, how do you plan to protect the university from market forces and fight against inequalities through it? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT

I thank you for this question that is both nuanced, precise, and full of moderation. First of all, I think there is a misunderstanding about the notion of rector, which is not the person who leads the university as the modifications have been made but is indeed an administrative function in France, the rector leading the services of National Education at the regional level. And I am very much in favor of opening up the civil service and there was not much left to justify that the exclusivity and totality of the functions of rector should be held by people who necessarily have a doctorate because these are functions of administrative and pedagogical management. So the administrative competence, the managerial competence is at the heart of the rector's job totally and so you can for example be a very good university professor and have all the titles that would allow you to become a rector but also be a very bad manager. And so that is the power of appointment that gives it and it was important to broaden the pool but I think there has been a misunderstanding related to the fact that you did not put the same reality behind the word rector.

Then, I do not like the idea of protecting the university from market forces, first of all, if the market forces are greed, etc., yes, but there is not only the university that I want to protect from that, I want to do it everywhere. If market forces are what prevents you from making social, environmental change, I do not want to reserve this protection for the university, I want to do it everywhere. I want to make the university as it should be, as it has historically been, the place for sharing all knowledge, controversies, the emancipation of individuals, free knowledge, free choice that allows an individual to be autonomous, that is to say to be able to navigate freely in their life, in knowledge and to move towards a job. Because I believe in work and so I also think that one of the functions of our universities is to guide not only towards knowledge and towards this greater autonomy of the free and rational individual but it is also to accompany towards jobs. It is in this that the idea of protecting from market forces cannot be the idea of protecting from the rest of the world, the university must be open to the rest of the world, on the contrary. The example you give here is wonderful since it is a university that is open to an ecosystem of innovations, entrepreneurship, research whether public or private. I do not like these divisions that are often doctrinal and that do not correspond even to the reality you live here, you are here in this amphitheater because you are at the heart of an ecosystem where the public and private know how to work together.

The problem we have in France is that you have described in an erroneous and caricatural way a reform that makes no sense if one does not understand the situation it addresses. France, it is true in all international surveys, has an educational and higher education system that has deteriorated significantly over the last 20 years. It has deteriorated because, somewhat based on your discourse, for a very long time we had an egalitarian discourse, we said that we must fundamentally lower the average level so that everyone has access, there should be no selection at all, and thus, there was less and less guidance to ensure that everyone had access. The result is that when I took office, 20% of young people could not properly read, write, count, or behave in CM2, that is to say, at the end of primary school. We had about 100,000 young people each year leaving the system without training or work, and we had one of the highest failure rates in the first cycle of university in Europe, meaning people who enrolled in their first year at university but for nearly a third of them, and this is even more true in the most difficult neighborhoods and in certain fields, never completed their year or their cycle. This is a waste for them and a collective waste because they had been poorly guided, because they were inflating fields that were already oversaturated.

This is what Parcoursup responds to; Parcoursup is part of a much broader reform where we have reinvested in the educational project that I deeply believe in and which, if you look at my presidential project, is the first pillar. First, we have reinvested in schools; it is the first time since General de GAULLE that we are modifying compulsory schooling starting at three years old, compulsory schooling to enter school, that is where inequalities begin, they do not start at university, do not be mistaken. Second, we have reinvested in the early years of primary school by reducing the number of students to 12 per class in all the most difficult neighborhoods in France. We have reintroduced annual assessments because assessment is a good thing to support students as well as pupils, especially for those who have the most difficulties. Third, we have implemented innovations in primary school, middle school, and high school, such as homework done to prevent the idea that everything stops at school time and to allow for compensating for family inequalities by saying, "you go home with your homework done to also compensate for things." We have reintroduced guidance starting at the end of middle school by reinvesting to provide support.

Parcoursup is part of this transformation because what is the initiative of Parcoursup? It is to say we guide differently, we study the files; it is not a blind algorithm that preexisted, which was what we called APB, which assigned people according to their choices, first come first served, including in fields where they had no business being, where they had very little chance of progressing. Until now, someone who graduated from a technological baccalaureate could enroll in medicine without any support, without any form of preparatory course; the result was that it was wonderful, they could arrive in medical amphitheaters that were already overcrowded, they had no chance of succeeding, none. They would spend one year, two years, but with no chance, the prerequisites were not there.

Parcoursup is an algorithm that has been made public contrary to what you say, so you are mistaken; it has been made public, I committed to it, the minister committed to it, it has therefore been completely transparent and changed, we are continuing the research work because it can be constantly improved. It is actually a tool that allows for discussing choices and confronting them with the necessary skills so that the choice of your university field can correspond to your basic competencies. And so there is an expression that is then made by the educational teams of the university or higher education program that welcomes you to say, "if you do this, it is better that you first spend six months in this place, six months in that other place," or "here you have no chance of succeeding, and we will redirect you but with individualized support," that is what we will continue to deploy.

This year, as last year, there are young people who did not get all their choices at the start of the school year; why? Because France is facing a much larger student demographic than in previous years. We will have, and this will be true throughout my term, about 50,000 more students each year, which means that I will have about 250,000 more students in university this year. So we will reopen positions, reopen programs, by the way, all over the territory, but every student will have a solution provided to them, rest assured, but it will be adapted, it will be better studied, it will be based on an approach with prerequisites that says, "if you want to go towards this field, then you must first go through these and those academic prerequisites," you need to know that. It is not true that university is a great nirvana where anything is possible regardless of what you did before; that is not true, it is possible if you take a path. Ultimately, it is the idea, as its name indicates, of having a path to support you rather than an open blind counter that allows you to believe for six months, a year that it is possible for you to confront the reality of failure in the first or second year.

This is the reality of this philosophy, and here are also some untruths that I wanted to address, but it is a reform that will be improved every year, which I believe in deeply because for me it is a fundamental fight for our youth.

Johanne MONTET: Quickly before moving on to another question, just to get your reaction, Mr. Prime Minister.

// Comments from Charles MICHEL //

Johanne MONTET: I resist, but I will take the floor to give you the floor. Ah, there is a young girl at the end of the row, no, a little lower, it was the one I had pointed out, it doesn’t matter, it could be the other one too, but since I pointed her out, yes, that’s it, you will think I did it on purpose because it’s her, etc., but no, it’s because I pointed her out, I don’t want to disappoint her! Here we go!

Astrid, Third-year student at Saint-Louis University in Political Science: This is a question that has been prepared by all the third-year students of Sciences Po at Saint-Louis and it is addressed to Mr. Emmanuel MACRON. As the European elections approach, you regularly mention the rise of populism in Europe, but by depicting the democratic debate of the European elections as an opposition between populists and progressives, are we not silencing a whole range of discordant voices that would not necessarily identify themselves in terms of progressives or populists? Consequently, are we not at risk, after the elections, of finding ourselves with a European debate that revolves around the question of whether we are for or against Europe rather than a debate on how to make the European Union more democratic and closer to the people? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT: Thank you. First of all, it is not for me to say that the European debate is structured this way; it matters to me to say what is, for me, the main adversary, which is different, because we can have differences in sensitivity on many things, but if we forget what the main adversary is and the priority of the democratic and political fight we want to lead at the time of an election, we are mistaken. I do not use the term "populist" that often, in fact rather rarely, because I am wary of its approach; I believe in the people and I have the pretension to think, by the way, many people when I emerged on the French political scene said that I was a populist because I was not in the structured democratic scene. I rather speak of nationalists or demagogues, which is different; if being populist means being with the people, I claim to be populist. If being populist means flattering the people in a way that plays into their most reductive fears or sending them back to automatism, that is what I call being rather demagogic. So I oppose nationalists; you may have heard me on November 11, I opposed nationalists and patriots, but nationalists to progressives. This does not crush all debates, and you are absolutely right, there are many different sensitivities, there are people who believe in different forms of Europe, who want to evolve it much faster. I believe in a Europe that is a real economic, social, and environmental power; I believe in a more sovereign, more united, more democratic Europe; there are people who do not have the same sensitivities, and therefore this debate must live.

What I know from experiencing it every day as a European leader is that these sensitivities are becoming less and less audible because there is a summa divisio that is emerging and that is present in Europe between those who believe in European solutions and those who no longer believe in them, and this summa divisio is, after all, more important than the differences we have among ourselves. On issues, for example, of migration that we have in Europe, there are today leaders who very clearly around the table say to you, "I no longer believe in the European solution, I do not want it, I want to return to the national solution." The same people, to take up your reflection, pocket the structural funds, everything is fine, they take everything else from Europe, but they do not like that. That is a real problem because we can have debates, say, "I am rather for this technical solution, I am for being more favorable to this asylum right or that one," you see, those are real debates and it is a very important democratic sensitivity that I do not want to crush at all.

But if I do not first lead the fight against those who no longer believe at all in a European solution on migration, the debates of sensitivities that we have later among pro-Europeans will no longer exist; that is what we see on all points! And do not be mistaken, in my country, in the last European elections, the party that won is the National Front; people have forgotten it, they say, "you are saying the worst," what a nice thing, I have not forgotten, the first European party in France is the National Front, it is the outgoing party! What has it done? Has it improved Europe? I have not seen it. But if in all countries we allow these extreme parties to rise, whose objective is not to have a democratic debate on whether we need a little more social or a little less ecology or anything else, but to say, "I want less Europe, even I want to exit the euro, I want to exit Europe, I want a return to nationalism," we will wake up the day after the European elections and they will have won.

And I am not talking about a fiction here; I am talking about a possible scenario. If no European majority is conceivable tomorrow in Parliament without the nationalists and the extremes, I can tell you that all the debates we then have on our sensitivities, the differences between pro-Europeans or progressives or more conservatives or others will be… And so we must know how to prioritize in the political debate the fights we want to lead, and I very sincerely tell you, I observe that in Europe there are people who believe in the European solution and there are people who no longer believe in it, there are people… So what is your banner? It is not going to work well with the confetti…

Johanne MONTET: This is not the place for a demonstration; I do not know if security can…

THE PRESIDENT: "The blood is on their hands, inform yourselves."

Johanne MONTET: Or else someone can take the floor and ask a question; that might be smarter!

THE PRESIDENT: But you need to say whose hands!

Johanne MONTET: Can someone take the floor and explain rather than demonstrate by asking a question, a simple question?

THE PRESIDENT: Just, I will finish to tell you and I will answer the question.

A student: Why do you beat your… why are you the only country that uses a grenade against its own population?

THE PRESIDENT: Ah no, you are saying nonsense!

Johanne MONTET: That does not seem to me a question but an accusation; in that case, it is a demonstration and security will take care of it.

The student: …in the Mediterranean and you continue, you do not stop, you lie, you denounce…

Johanne MONTET: This is a place for debate, sir, it is not a place for aggression!

THE PRESIDENT: But come, come, do not insult! Wait, gentlemen, do not take him out! No, I neither address you informally nor twist anything of yours. I just say…

Johanne MONTET: This is a place for discussion.

THE PRESIDENT: It is a place for discussion; if you allow me, I will answer your comrade or colleague, you ask your question and I will answer. Do not put papers everywhere because someone will pick them up, it will not be you!

Sir does not want to ask a question, sir wants to demonstrate!

THE PRESIDENT

: But, wait, I will listen to you, but if you have two ounces of respect, Sir, if you have a little respect, I will finish the answer to your colleague and then I will give you the floor. So to finish the answer, which is on a very important subject, I think that this debate between progressives, those who believe in Europe and those who no longer believe in it, is fundamental, and if we do not engage in it, if we somehow consider that our disagreement among pro-Europeans is more important than our disagreement with those who want to dismantle Europe, we are mistaken. I do not want to crush the differences; on the contrary, they are fundamental, it is the whole debate we are having, but I think that this fight that I wanted to establish and that I will continue to carry is essential in our countries.

So, Sir.

Johanne MONTET

: Sir is no longer here, he did not pick up the papers!

THE PRESIDENT

: Frankly, Sir, because he took something you said, it’s nonsense, in France the CRS do not attack students or others! There have been students and many non-students for days and days, if you inquire, including a little dog that had an extremely nice Twitter account in Tolbiac, I recommend it to you, the little dog of Tolbiac who competes with the cat of 10 Downing Street for Twitter account enthusiasts, who vandalized the university, we need to stop the nonsense! Half of the people who were inside have not been students for long, they are anarchist groups, unfortunately, they stopped studying a long time ago and they do not want to go back! I would be very much in favor of them resuming their studies, they do not want to! And so they occupied a university, we let them, there was no intervention, violence against them, there were unfortunately many injuries among our law enforcement, to whom I pay tribute, there were none on their side, and they were evacuated. We are going to spend hundreds of thousands of euros on our universities to repair what they did, which is frankly unacceptable, we cannot defend knowledge when we destroy universities.

Then, we evacuated, since I think he was referring to that, people at Notre-Dame-des-Landes as we will continue to do everywhere, it is not you, because he mentioned that. At Notre-Dame-des-Landes what did we do? We stopped the project which was a project that was no longer coherent from an ecological point of view, but they wanted to continue to settle and prevent people from living normally! When there are conflicts of use in a society, there is no freedom if there is no public order! And that is a point for me that is very important in our debates and that we need to have, we must have rules of civility among us, it is not very civil, I am for debate, you can challenge me, I respond every time, but not to say nonsense, scatter paper and then leave! In the same way, we can be against a project, demonstrate, I have no problem with that, debate, change our minds, I am for this openness, but at some point, when the project no longer exists, and we continue to be there and prevent other free people from working, expressing themselves, doing freely, it is no longer a society! And so there comes a time when public order must be maintained, there is no longer freedom if there is no public order.

Johanne MONTET

: We have 15 good minutes left, come on, let’s make the most of it!

THE PRESIDENT

: You are the holder of public order here!

Johanne MONTET

: There you go, let’s go! There is a gentleman over there in the middle, in my line of sight, there you go. This row, there you go, there you go, there you go! Raise your hand high, yes, it’s you with the glasses that I spotted like that, my gaze fell on you by chance. Are you okay, do you have the microphone?

A student

: Hello Mr. President of the Republic and Mr. Prime Minister. I feel even more concerned by your presence since I am Franco-Belgian, so, I warn you, I can vote for both of you. I am attentive to your answers, I have already voted for you, I say it frankly. My question, let’s get back to Europe after all, is about European defense. Mr. MACRON, I saw that you were quite interested in a European defense despite certain tweets from our American friend, I wanted to know with a rather timid Germany in European integration, with Mrs. MERKEL who is quite weak electorally, what is your agenda and the practical arrangements for a European defense with all the linguistic, logistical issues, etc.? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT

: Thank you. First of all, we are really working on European defense and I think we need to have even more ambition. First, why do I believe in a European defense? Because I think it is a cement because when we look at the primary mission of a State, of a political structure, it is to protect its citizens and we cannot have a strong Europe, more sovereign, more united if when there is a vital risk in one part of Europe we say “I can no longer protect you, I have to call on others.” This is also what makes it so that, you can feel it, in some Central, Eastern, or Mediterranean, Balkan countries, some countries have become accustomed to turning much more towards the United States than towards Europe or towards NATO than towards Europe. Europe is a component of NATO but we must have our own sovereignty because that is what will bring us together, which means that if we need to protect Estonia, Finland, or any other country, we are capable of doing so and we do it.

So I believe a lot in this notion and I think it is a strong cement, it is credibility, it will also be a way to depassion our debate with the Russians, to create a real European defense architecture and it is also a way to respond to what we see even already before President TRUMP on the American side, which is the United States of America looking either more and more towards themselves in a current isolationism, or towards the Pacific, I remind you that President OBAMA said “I will be the first Pacific president” in the geographical sense of the term, and therefore Europe must take its destiny into its own hands. We have already made a structured cooperation in defense, we signed it together, we are in it together with a very large majority of countries and we already have projects that are launched, more than fifteen, in this European defense, concrete projects that engage our armies, our defense industries and that allow us to move forward.

We then have to support this by launching a European defense fund, the debates are continuing but we have taken it to the Council and the Commission was very active too, we must pay tribute to it because it is the European Commission to which we owe a lot on these two subjects, we are advancing very strongly and so we will be able to finance projects including for small companies in the defense sector in this area.

Third point…

Johanne MONTET

: Mr. Prime Minister, oh, sorry, I cut you off!…

THE PRESIDENT

: No, no, just, I will finish very quickly, rest assured, I understood your maneuver!

Johanne MONTET

: I am incorrigible!

THE PRESIDENT

: I proposed a little over a year ago at La Sorbonne a European intervention initiative to bring together our intervention cultures and say we will better coordinate this time not the industrial side but our ways of intervening. We already have several member states that are there, we are structuring it and continuing to develop it. And then you talk about Germany, that will be my last word, in Franco-German we have several projects, a project for the future battle tank and a project for the future combat aircraft that we are doing together, finally in an integrated manner, and the more we can open it to European partners, the better it is to work with countries like Belgium. So it is advancing, I wish we could go even further but we have already done in a year and a half what we had never done since the mid-1950s, at which time, I must say, France had contributed to blocking the European Defense Community project.

Johanne MONTET

Mr. Prime Minister, can we build this European defense together knowing that we have bought American planes?

// Remarks by Charles MICHEL //

Michel LIEGEOIS

: Very well, it is already time to move on to the third sequence, time is passing very, very quickly, the sequence dedicated to Europe in the world, to international relations. I think we will not have much more time than for a single question or if they are very brief perhaps, so I really ask you to make an effort.

Johanne MONTET

: Ah we will group two, three!

Michel LIEGEOIS

: Group two, three extremely brief questions.

Johanne MONTET

: We will do them in rapid succession!

Michel LIEGEOIS

: There you go, I already see hands going up.

Johanne MONTET

: I had a hand over there, I had a young girl here in front.

Pauline, Student in international relations at UCL

: Mr. Prime Minister, Mr. President of the Republic, thank you. My question is as follows, I address you, Mr. President, what is France's position regarding the relocation of the American embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem and what does that represent symbolically? Thank you.

Johanne MONTET

: A second question, there is a young girl there on the edge, I might as well take a boy too.

A student

: Hello Mr. President, hello Mr. Prime Minister. Last May, the President of the United States announced that he was withdrawing from the Vienna Agreement on Iranian nuclear, I address each of you, how do you assess the way in which Iran has fulfilled its obligations under the Vienna Agreement? And precisely what role can Europe play in improving relations between Iran and the United States?

Johanne MONTET

: A third one, there, a girl!

Dilay, Second-year master's student in public administration

: Hello Mr. President, hello Mr. Prime Minister, hello everyone! Mr. President, you mentioned in your speech at the 73rd session of the United Nations General Assembly that we are in a crisis of multilateralism. Indeed, we can see that today at the center of the European Union coexist regimes, leaders with quite divergent ideas and ideologies, and we hear it notably in your rather offensive rhetoric towards liberal democracies in view of the European elections, nevertheless we cannot deny their legitimate place in Europe. My question is therefore under these conditions how to advance the European project by overcoming these divergences and what is the place of your country, France, but also of Belgium, Mr. Prime Minister, in this process? Thank you very much.

Michel LIEGEOIS

: We have very little time…

Johanne MONTET

: We have three minutes if you want to be on time for the king and queen! (She smiles)

// Remarks by Charles MICHEL //

Johanne MONTET

: Mr. President, on these three themes…

THE PRESIDENT

: On the American unilateral choice to move the embassy to Jerusalem, I said it, we do not share this choice and above all I think it is useless, on the contrary, and we have seen in the reactions it has produced on the ground. France continues to defend what, I remind you, is also in accordance with international law, we cannot defend multilateralism if we contest it when it does not suit us, the two states with Jerusalem as capital and these two states is the only way to build peace on the ground. So on the one hand we do not share this choice, we disapproved of it and I regret the consequences it has had on the ground but especially in method. I think the only way to bring about peace is on the ground, by allowing all the protagonists to resume dialogue and build on the ground the possibility of doing so. It is neither in Paris nor in Brussels nor in Washington through unilateral decisions that we will manage to resolve or advance this problem. On the contrary, we are then in a kind of symbolic escalation that has absolutely terrible effects on the ground and that has led to the riots we have seen following this decision. So I think it is a bad decision and I have had the opportunity to say it, it has not had a follow-up since we were announced a few weeks later a broader peace plan that has still not seen the light of day.

On the Iranian nuclear agreement, you are here, so the agreement known as the Vienna Agreement signed in July 2015. As you know, France is a signatory along with Germany and the United Kingdom, we have decided to remain in it and so that is the big difference because here too I believe in strong multilateralism. Recent revelations have shown that the Iranians were probably even more advanced than we thought before the signing of this agreement in terms of progress towards mastering nuclear technology and nuclear defense. Including the most recent revelations show the validity of the international approach that emerged during the years leading up to this agreement.

Secondly, since this agreement was signed in July 2015, the IAEA, which is the competent agency to ensure these verifications, has been able to carry out all due diligence when it has requested to evolve, that is to say, to go for example to verify at our request in universities, it has been able to do so and it has never found any violation of the Vienna Agreement, never. So we have no basis based on the findings made by the IAEA and the signed agreement to say that there has been a violation of what we signed.

Third point, I think we collectively weaken ourselves if there is a state that does not behave normally, that is delinquent and at the moment we sign an agreement with it we are the first not to respect it. That is why Europe has decided to remain in the JCPoA as we call it in good French, so the agreement on the Iranian nuclear, the first consequence, you noted, is that Iran has remained in it. I am convinced that if European countries had withdrawn, Iran would have withdrawn and they would have resumed their activities. So we have today a situation where the pressure is maximum, where new sanctions have been taken by the United States, because Europe has decided to remain in this agreement, is still building solutions to allow this agreement to live fully but has made the political decision with already concrete consequences, the Iranians remain in this agreement and do not resume their nuclear activities, which is a good thing.

The outcome of this agreement, I mentioned it as early as the speech I gave at the United Nations General Assembly in the summer of 2017, is for me to complement this agreement with three pillars, an agreement on Iranian nuclear activity post-2025, a negotiation on the activity of the Iranian regime in the region because it destabilizes a lot, in Iraq, in Syria, in Lebanon, in Yemen, and a binding agreement on Iranian ballistic activity in the region, so that is what we will continue to focus on. But today for me the role of Europe is to be precisely this cement, the guarantor of this strong multilateralism with results, Iran has remained, but also the guarantor of a dialogue that at some point will bear fruit and I think that in the coming months we will return to a phase of dialogue with Iran and the United States on this subject, it is the only way to avoid a regional conflagration and to provide a deep response to this crisis.

Finally, on your point, the foundations of multilateralism both outside of Europe and in Europe. The Prime Minister said it, we see everywhere in the world an illiberal temptation and you recalled it in your question. This illiberalism on the political level, how do we measure it? When we close universities or prohibit universities, when we roll back the independence of the judiciary or drastically reduce it and when we constrain the right to free information and multiply the manipulation of information or imprison journalists. There is obviously the reduction of trade union rights that goes with many other things but these are the three or four symptoms that allow us to identify the retreat of the rule of law and the threats to multilateralism wherever we condemn them, wherever we fight against these practices and we have them in Europe as well.

I think there are two ways to act in Europe, the first is to give no ground to these retreats and therefore to launch procedures, to be clear in the votes in the European Parliament, there was a vote based on a report made in Parliament on Hungary, finally we managed to have a positive vote, and some because we put pressure have come out of their ambiguity, the same ones who had abstained or voted to protect their Hungarian friend, the Hungarian leader, have finally been clear. But we have today European procedures that are too slow, paralyzed, ineffective and that do not allow us to properly protect the rule of law. And I do not want a European Union that would protect wonderfully well and in a nitpicking manner the slightest deviation from public deficits but would never protect the slightest deviation from the rule of law. This is a bit the situation we have entered and it must be one of the debates for the upcoming European elections and for the modification of future treaties. But, one, do not give up this fight, be uncompromising and on all countries where all practices that deviate or go in the direction I mentioned be very tough and consider that it is a violation not only of our treaties but of our DNA, that is Europe! Europe is the only political space in the world that loves freedom, equality, respect for the individual and their fundamental rights, there is no political space in the world where there is this political, economic, and social balance.

Nevertheless, we must not stop at these divisions and that is why we work together including with states that are in these procedures to try to find compromises to advance other subjects and not simply put them on the sidelines saying "we are making no progress", not cease the battle to advance more effectively in terms of migration, find solutions in social terms. For example, we found an agreement with several states that we were often opposed to in order to advance the Posted Workers Directive and address these aberrations, we continue the dialogue on transport and many other subjects. So I am not for creating or putting up new walls in Europe, I am for dialogue with everyone but I am for demanding standards from everyone including ourselves when it comes to principles and the rule of law.

Johanne MONTET

: We can take one last question but short with short answers, sir…

Nicolas de SADELEER, Student at Saint-Louis University in Brussels

: You both, Mr. Prime Minister and Mr. President of the Republic, have spoken a lot about ambitions. The fact that a certain form of European technocracy should probably come down from its pedestal and that the European project should be carried by our fellow citizens perhaps more.

Johanne MONTET

: We said short, sir, I just specify because I am giving one last question really to make the most of the time but we need to go right away!

Nicolas de SADELEER

: Okay, could we in terms of teaching, education, research where we are constantly losing ground compared to Chinese, Australian universities, etc., make a paradigmatic shift by refinancing, by multiplying the funding for research, having a real European project for research and education, would you both be ready to carry this project?

// Remarks by Charles MICHEL //

THE PRESIDENT

: The answer is yes, I believe in a Europe that has ambition in higher education and research, that is why I proposed this idea of a European university to gain precisely in deployment. And that is why, you are right, we need to significantly multiply our European funding in this area, research programs, priority, both fundamental research and applied research, we must not forget the former because if it is not there the latter has little chance of existing. When I look today at the future challenges in terms of innovations, artificial intelligence that we talk about so much, Europe accounts for 10% of the credits invested in this area. And so if we do not wake up, the risk is that the heart of research, investment, and initiatives will be Chinese, American. So yes, we must scale up and profoundly shake up our habits by investing much more and I am in favor of an increase in the European common budget through an increase in own resources allocated to priorities like these. Yes, scaling up on fundamental research, innovation, particularly on artificial intelligence but not only, and with that moving towards more subsidiarity in the functioning of the European research and higher education system.

I believe in large European research programs, I believe in this project of a European university but I believe in less nitpicking bureaucracy where the slightest researcher as soon as they have a European grant spends a week and fills out infernal paperwork to be able to access these funds and thus is forced to hire people almost permanently to have access to these few credits. Today our scheme is "lose lose", we spend less than the great powers and we have more complicated schemes, we must invest more, evaluate much more rigorously and perhaps a posteriori and less a priori, debureaucratize and subsidiarize much more.

Michel LIEGEOIS

: There you go, the timer is merciless and so we are already reaching the end of this beautiful moment of exchange and debate. This morning on a public service radio that I will not name, a columnist was ironic about the possibility of organizing a real debate with 1,000 students but you have proven that it was possible and I thank you for that. So I remind you, technical point, that the audience is asked to wait until the delegations have left before leaving the room and in a few seconds I would still like to thank all those, and I obviously do not have time to name them, who have mobilized tirelessly to make this beautiful event possible. A big thank you especially to the colleagues who facilitated the brainstorming groups within the faculties, I thank the students, you, the female and male students for your involvement, your dynamism. Thank you to you, Johanne, for your valuable help in facilitating and of course a huge thank you to you, Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister, for this very beautiful privileged moment of dialogue and debate.

Johanne MONTET

: Thank you!