Speech by the President of the Republic on the occasion of the 80th anniversary of the CNRS

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

26 November 2019 · 80th anniversary of the CNRS

Context
Macron addressed researchers and officials at the CNRS headquarters in Paris to mark the 80th anniversary of the French national research organization.
Main themes
CNRS 80th anniversary, French research model, freedom in research, fundamental research, interdisciplinary research, science and knowledge, history of French science, research institutions, applied and technological research, university-research continuum, French scientific legacy
Duration
~20 min
67th percentile
Words
2,457
67th percentile
Sentences
71
47th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
15.3
78th percentile
Syntax
3.50
94th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
7th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%37%
  • Geopolitical 20%20%
  • Economic 17%17%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

71 sentences in 3 paragraphs

Thank you very much. Ladies Ministers, Mr. President and CEO, Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents, Mr. President of the Conference, and Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of organizations and universities, Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians, researchers, you have perfectly acknowledged each in their ranks and qualities, so I will be brief.

I am very happy to be among you today, first to, as you just said, and starting this discussion, celebrate a page of history and these 80 years that we have seen celebrated around the world through the short video you just showed, which I believe is also a testament, an illustration of the international recognition of what the CNRS has managed to achieve over these 8 decades through your work, because I recognize many faces, and regardless of the disciplines and all that has already been made possible. And indeed, as you said, the very history of the CNRS is not linear. You recalled the winding paths that knowledge and science sometimes take; the same goes for institutions, and it has been the same for the CNRS. It is still astonishing to note that an institution like this, an organization like this that enlightens, thinks about the future, about research, was created 80 years ago at a time when the history of France and Europe might have seemed more obscured than bright. These are not the times of reconquest and post-war; these are times of transition. And I believe that we must indeed pay tribute to those who made it possible. You mentioned Jean ZAY, Léon BLUM should also be mentioned, and dear Antoine, those who preceded you: Jean PERRIN, Frédéric JOLIOT, Hubert CURIEN, and many others. So if I am here today, it is not simply with you to celebrate this past, however glorious it may have been; it is also to express my attachment, but not an attachment to preserve, an attachment, if I may say so, sensitive, of conviction, deep to what the CNRS represents, that is to say, a model of freedom in research. There is not one model of research in the world, and we have our specificities that go along with, I would say, our own turpitudes and our own ailments. France is this strange country where generally we have conceived things that we wanted to make work, pardon me, Mr. President, apart from the university. Since the Collège de France, we have this somewhat strange history, and perhaps we are arriving at a moment in our collective history where, thanks to what we are collectively doing, we will be able to reconcile all of this. But the CNRS is part of this history, and so when we wanted great research, when things were shifting, we said we needed this great organization. And so this model of freedom, as you recalled, is also the one that allows these winding paths, this time, this freedom offered to researchers, what we have sometimes called the status, but which is fundamentally the preservation of a framework to be able to work well and have research that enlightens, irrigates, and which has gradually managed to work with all partners, whether it be French or international research. This model of freedom, by coming here first to debate with you and to be present among you, I also wanted to say and reiterate that I think it is relevant. I believe it has helped the country in many conquests, and I think it remains relevant because the way knowledge progresses, the way discoveries are made will retain some of these fundamentals and invariants, if I may say so, which are that it is not possible to trace everything, to have short timeframes everywhere, to have measurement everywhere. And so what this model brings to the French system, to our collective organization, is precious. Then, because it has allowed us to give a place, to build, to consolidate fundamental research. And to think, moreover, about the continuum, as you just recalled in your remarks welcoming us, Mr. President and Director General, between fundamental research and more technological or applied research. And I believe that this is also a strength. We need this fundamental research, whatever the disciplines present here, and which you have also recalled very deeply; we need interdisciplinary dialogue, and I believe increasingly so because the frontiers towards which we are heading somehow combine these interdisciplinarities and mean that we increasingly need to break down silos. And I think very deeply that the last 20 years have also allowed our collective organization — whether it be mixed units, the work of universities, other research organizations, hospitals, companies — to show that we have gradually managed to break down our research as well. And you recalled the number of startups; we could also mention patents and the collaborative research that is thus done. Beyond this message of attachment to this model of freedom, and you mentioned it when talking about the project that the minister has been carrying for several months, which is also the subject of a whole inter-ministerial effort with many of her colleagues, but which she assumes, which she carries with you with a lot of work, and I want to thank you, researchers, teacher-researchers, students, engineers, research staff, all those who do research in France, which is this programming law. And if I am here, it is also to express my conviction that it is not simply an attachment to this model of freedom but that it is also the matrix with the entire ecosystem, as we say, of what we need for the country. There is no great country without strong knowledge, research, and higher education. There is none. First, and you recalled it, for economic reasons. We are in an economy of innovation and skills where disruptions are profound, rapid, radical, whether it be in energy, communication technologies, artificial intelligence, or others; they are eminently interdisciplinary, they go much faster. And so we need today a public and private investment that is commensurate for deeply economic reasons as well. And so we cannot think of French and European economic power without thinking of strength and investment in research. We have been talking about 3% for decades; I believe this objective must be reaffirmed but by also giving ourselves through this programming law the means of the public share that we allocate to it. I think we need to face the truth of the numbers; this will be one of my objectives in the coming weeks and the announcements at the beginning of next year. The second thing, as you also said, are reasons of sovereignty. Whether we are talking about biomedical research, which is a fundamental subject on which we have a lot of comparative advantages, a very strategic subject that is also at the heart of the health strategy carried by the minister through the individualization of medicine and many other strands on this subject, whether we are talking about artificial intelligence, whether we are talking about communication technologies, each time we have issues of sovereignty. If we do not carry this research at the French and European level, we are strategically choosing to depend on those who will do it. And even though I am aware that this is not necessarily your daily reality, and I do not speak to the community that has, if I may say, the most sensitivity on this subject, and I completely understand it, you belong to scientific communities that are borderless and profoundly international, and that is the strength of research. At the same time, we cannot underestimate the fact that we are in a world that is refracting and where there are geopolitical choices that will go along with research choices. 5G, like Chinese or American artificial intelligence, may not be the same as European artificial intelligence or 5G, nor for the medical choices we will have at a certain moment. And so I also believe very deeply in the necessity of investing in our public research because I think it is a choice of sovereignty, because it is the condition for, at a certain point, not to depend on other sovereign choices, on powers that will have made advances, and where, at a certain moment, what is of the order of this open international cooperation refracts because it is about sovereign choices, because they must be implemented either through the state or through large companies, and we return to more national or geographical realities. We must ask ourselves this question. It is posed to us today, and it fully justifies this reinvestment, and also because it is, in my eyes, an ethical and profoundly political choice. If we want to choose the world that is being built on all the subjects you have begun to mention, if we want to be able to ask these questions beyond sovereign technological choices, it is also the possibility of setting ethical limits at a certain moment, and thus, to build our own interdisciplinarity, when we talk about artificial intelligence, to have mathematicians work with the best specialists in robotics, computer science, but also with philosophers, linguists, etc., to ask questions about the profound cognitive, organizational implications, and at a certain moment consider that we have, through our own scientific approach and our own choices, to also set the ethical, philosophical, and political limits of what we are building. And we can only do this if we invest again much more deeply in our public research, with the ripple effect that this has on private research, but I think that one does not go without the other and that one cannot substitute for the other, and that we are in any case facing radical choices. For all these reasons, the coming weeks are, for me, an important step in preparing the future of the country and the continent, because, as you said, for me, this French strategy is part of a European strategy, and I prefer to be perfectly clear because there have been, on this subject, sometimes too many ambiguities: the ambition that I want for our country is neither an ambition of substitution nor through Europe; it is additive. We need to assume stronger and clearer organizational budgetary choices. I think we will also talk about this, and it is a simultaneous approach that I believe in. It is not simply more resources; it is also knowing how to work on our own barriers, on what has made it so that sometimes we have not been present at all appointments, and thus on the deep reforms where perhaps, in France, we have alternated between reforming without putting in money or putting in money without reforming. We need to do both. But this French choice must also go with the reaffirmation of a European choice, that is to say, the confirmation of a greater ambition at the European level. It cannot be done by reducing, if I may say, a European ambition. And so the fight that we must also lead in the coming weeks, beyond the preparation of this programming law, is to reaffirm the importance of major European programs, including those we have recently launched, those that have also marked... You recalled the importance of the ERC; we talked last week with several researchers involved in these major programs, but to say that Europe must be present at the rendezvous of these major research programs and that it must put in more resources. And when I compare Europe today to China or the United States, we must be lucid; regardless of the national efforts we can make for the main countries, it can only go by adding to a stronger European effort, and so this is also the fight we will have to lead in the coming weeks and months, and this is what I came here to reaffirm, in a way, because what we are talking about is at the heart of all contemporary issues and, if I may say, of the great moments of transition. I said, this choice of investment, of trust, will go with a choice of openness, openness which is a reality, which is your daily life internationally and in Europe, but also openness towards other French institutions, universities, research organizations, hospitals, grandes écoles. This new ambition must lead to even more breaking down of barriers, opening up to businesses, society, which you perfectly recalled a moment ago. It must be combined with, in a way, the combination of the long term and the ability to have reasonable demands regularly, that is to say, to also give ourselves evaluation times. We say to ourselves: if we put in more resources, it is legitimate to look at where things are going, at a pace that corresponds to that of science, which cannot be every 6 months nor even necessarily every year, but which is not the absence of oversight either. That is not true that it exists; in any case, it only lasts for a time. It is therefore this turn that we need to take, and in essence, I will conclude on this point.

I have sometimes compared our time to that of the 1930s, so I will not compare this year to the year 80 years ago, but I am sure of one thing: all our challenges today need science and knowledge to be addressed, the technological challenges, the challenges of society's capacity to meet them, thus its own understanding, the anthropological challenges that are ours in the face of these changes, the climate challenge, the organizational challenge. So we need science more than ever. And at this moment we are living, we are experiencing, at the same time, perhaps one of the greatest contemporary crises in the relationship with science and scientific truth. We see it every day on social media, in the media as well, where the questioning of fact, of veracity, is daily. This makes me even more convinced that this investment is a necessity, but this investment reminds us, if I may say so, of what is at the very root of the CNRS and of this struggle for 80 years, which is that there is, in the CNRS, something of what I call the French spirit of resistance. To have confidence in the future of our country to establish a research organization like this in 1939, one had to already have the spirit of resistance. The very history of the organization has shown this in the years and decades that followed. It is the same spirit of resistance that we need today. The President of the Republic and the government will be there, but the spirit of resistance is something that is shared and that adds up. I am counting on you.