SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE OCCASION OF THE RECEPTION DEDICATED TO THE MEMORY OF THE HARKIS.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

20 September 2021 · Reception dedicated to the memory of the Harkis

Context
Macron addressed Harki veterans and descendants at a memorial reception on September 20, 2021, acknowledging France's failures and seeking historical recognition.
Main themes
Harkis recognition and memory, French state responsibility and betrayal, Algerian war legacy, loyalty and military service, historical truth and reconciliation, national memory and collective identity, exile and displacement, duty of recognition, Franco-Algerian history, parallel and irreconcilable memories
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,179
78th percentile
Sentences
169
85th percentile
Readability
63
92nd percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.81
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%41%
  • Ceremonial 27%27%
  • Geopolitical 17%17%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

169 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Madam Minister, thank you very much for your work and your words today,

Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament,

Ladies and Gentlemen Senators,

Mr. Grand Chancellor of the Legion of Honor,

Ladies and Gentlemen Elected Officials,

Gentlemen General Officers,

Madam Director General of the National Office for Veterans and Victims of War,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of memorial or mutual aid foundations and associations, Ladies and Gentlemen Academics, Historians and Experts, dear Benjamin in particular, Ladies and Gentlemen,

The history of the Harkis is great and painful. It is great because it is a story of soldiers, a story of honor, a story of French men and women and the history of the French. It is painful, and your words, all four of you, have shown it, because it is the story of rifts. A rift between two countries, a rift with your homeland, a rift with your families who remained in Algeria, your friends, your languages, your cultures and traditions, but always a rift among the French. It is the tragedy of a loyalty betrayed multiple times by the massacres in Algeria, by exclusion in France, and then by denial and refusal of recognition.

Your history is our history and it is now well established. It has been told, written by you, by witnesses, by historians, but it remains too little known by the French. That is why I have set this meeting. This is not a meeting with the Harkis; it is a meeting with the truth, with France, with a part of us. I say this today, before the day of September 25, because I know how much what we are saying will awaken multiple debates dictating our history with the Algerian war.

I fully assume that France recognizes the multitude of these memories and destinies related to this war. These stories are parallel. They are sometimes irreconcilable. They are, for some, incomparable to one another. We must assume them all and recognize each one in order to move forward and live together. I will not judge before you today the choices of the leaders of that time; it is not the role of a President of the Republic. It is the role of historians, and it is their role to be able to do so freely. And I cannot say what I would have done in their place. This war of independence for some, civil for others, profoundly shook our country and so many generations. What happened then, between French men and women, was this decree, between Athens and Sparta, of silence and the duty to forget in order to simply continue living together, to no longer speak, to refuse to remember, to open every subject. Your stories that you have recalled and your anger that is expressed and continues to be expressed show how much these moments, today, we must have the courage to reopen, to say and to assume, but without taking anything away from other memories, and without leading us to compare destinies or have a system of equivalence. But everyone must now know how to listen to each other, recognize, and give a place, the place that belongs to it, to each memory in the life of our nation.

Your ancestors served France during the First World War. Your grandfathers and fathers served it during the Second. You, here among us, dear Serge, or your fathers, served it during the Algerian war. And whatever the reasons for their commitment under our flag, the Harkis lent their strength, shed their blood, gave their lives for France, between 1914 and 1918, 1939 and 1945, 1954 and 1962. Nearly 200,000 of them bore our colors. They were interpreters, scouts, trackers, warriors, they stood guard, held positions, secured strategic points, sometimes entire villages or vast areas. They fought. In the Atlas, in the Aurès, in Kabylie, in cities as well as in the countryside, everywhere in Algeria, the Harkis rendered eminent services to France. They served France. They risked everything, their property, their lives, those of their families, and many lost everything. France has duties towards those who serve and defend it.

The Harkis have been, have always been, and are French, by the blood shed, the battles chosen, and their birth, each time. However, after the Algerian war, France failed in its duties towards the Harkis, their wives, their children. On March 19, 1962, it was the end of the fighting, relief for many, anguish for so many others, the beginning of the ordeal for the Harkis, the cruelty of reprisals, exile or death. Most had no choice, even if there were officers who kept their oath of loyalty to their men. This was the case of General François MEYER, whom I elevate today to the dignity of Grand Cross of the Legion of Honor, who disobeyed in order to embark dozens of men and families for France. Of Lieutenant Yves DURAND, who accompanied his Harka to Ongles in the Alpes-de-Haute-Provence, or of André WURMSER, who defended the Harkis all his life. I extend the salute of France to these lucid and loyal men. They had the greatness of soul and the kindness of heart that our country lacked at that time.

Between winter and spring 1962, France hesitated to open its doors to the Harkis with a first yes for a handful of them, a few tens of thousands, then a refusal out of fear of terrorist infiltration from one side or the other, with a prohibition on anyone helping them. Finally, and it is the honor of Georges POMPIDOU, the formal decision to welcome them. It is not my role, as I said, to judge the decision-makers of that time. It is the work of memory and history, of academics and historians. But the facts are there. Stubborn, cruel. This welcome was not dignified, and half of the repatriated Harkis were relegated, sometimes for years, to camps and forest hamlets. There were even families of Harkis confined in prisons, yes, prisons. They had to leave a land that was theirs and that of their ancestors, the land that housed their homes, their property, their traditions, the land where they had built their lives and forged their hopes because they had borne the arms of France. And here they found in this country they had served, our country, their country, not an asylum, but a straitjacket, not hospitality, but hostility. Bars and barbed wire, curfews, rationing, cold, hunger, overcrowding, disease, exclusion, arbitrariness, and racism, in contempt of all the values that found France, in contempt of the law, in contempt of all justice. The doors of the school of the Republic were closed to their children, to your children, to you, in contempt of the future. What I am talking about were the 1960s and 1970s, and it was in France. This was the terrible fate of the Harkis: excluded, subjugated, hindered, French, always banished from their native soil, scorned on their host soil.

For you and your families, it was an abandonment, an abandonment of the French Republic recognized since 2001, as you recalled a moment ago, and up to the responsibilities recognized in September 2016. All my predecessors have spoken on this subject since 2001. And I tell you for France, the France of the Enlightenment and human rights, it was worse. A failure to itself, to what it wants to be, to what it must be. Yes, by depriving veterans, their wives, their children of their fundamental freedoms, by not offering their children the same education as all young French people, by refusing to recognize, despite your struggles, despite the work of history and so many dictated letters. France let go of their hand and turned its back on them. In the face of those who had loyally served it, our country was neither faithful to its history nor to its values.

That is why today, on behalf of France, I say to the Harkis and their children, in a loud and solemn voice, that the Republic then contracted a debt towards them. To the fighters, I want to express our gratitude. We will not forget. To the abandoned fighters, to their families who suffered the camps, prison, denial, I ask for forgiveness, we will not forget.

Since then, the Republic has regained its footing; it has recognized the sacrifices made and the suffering inflicted. The time of unspoken words, the time of denial is over. France has committed itself alongside the Harkis on the path of truth and justice; it has acted, voted laws, helped, supported, and initiated a work of memory that we have intensified in recent years. It honors the Harkis and their children, their history, their resilience, their struggle.

And today again, I will shortly present the insignia of our national orders of the Legion of Honor and of Merit to Mr. Salah ABDLEKRIM, who shed his blood for France and who was cited twice in combat, to Mrs. Bornia TARALL, daughter of Harkis who has tirelessly committed herself to diversity, equal opportunities, and identity.

It is now a matter of repairing as much as possible these rifts: rifts of history, which you carry in your flesh. The memory of the Harkis, the honor of the Harkis must be engraved in the national memory. This history, we tell it, we teach it, and we will continue to heal its wounds as long as they are not closed, through words of truth, gestures of memory, and acts of justice.

That is why the Government will present, before the end of the year, a project aimed at inscribing in the marble of our laws the recognition and reparation towards the Harkis. I commit to this. This law will not aim to dictate what history or truth is, because I deeply believe that this is not the role of a law; it is the work of historians, once again.

I have been hearing you for a while now, Madam, speaking out loud, including when those who defend your causes are present. And that is also why… I know that the angers are irreconcilable, but if you allow me… Madam, what I want to tell you… But you are here. But I know. But what we are talking about today… But in what you express, Madam, what Mr. expresses. Yes, but I do not make empty promises, but there is something. Come, come. No, sit down. What I would like you to understand is that, even among you, what you have… But I know. You are here, Madam, and I am here before you. What I would like you to understand, to you, because I have been hearing you for a while now, Madam, you express yourself every time one of your colleagues speaks. You do not listen to me much and you express your anger. And I know you too. But yes, but I can. I will finish and I do it with a lot of affection and a lot of respect. But what I would like to tell you…

What has happened and what we have been describing for a while now, which has been said that I am trying to express with the words that are mine, is the uniqueness of what you have experienced in the history of France and the Republic. But this uniqueness has also been marked by deep divisions. And the fact, it struck me every time I went to meet you on the ground, the fact that you do not recognize each other in your struggles. But in doing so, I say this very sincerely and it is true of all the memorial struggles that have been led by several who are here and who also carry other memories, other struggles of forgetfulness. Each story is unique. What you describe, Madam, and which is moving is unique. But is it more respectable… No, but is it more respectable, more important, stronger, more just than the pain of your neighbor in front or that of Serge CAREL, who fought and was abandoned on the ground, than others to justify shouting louder? Not necessarily. Your strength is also in respecting each other's memories. And so, what I would also like you to touch upon is that there is something exhausting for some who lead your own struggles and defend you to consider that stronger than the recognition or the path we are taking together, which does not repair what has happened and which cannot repair it. There is also the capacity, at a given moment, to try to collectively accept that anger projects itself into a taste for the future. There are no words that will heal your burns and what you have experienced. But there are none, Madam, you are right. But there is, on the other hand, I cannot do anything about it, through words, to repair 40 years, what am I saying, 60 years of the life of our nation. But we must all together make this journey, from where we are, with the injustices suffered to try to reconcile and move forward and therefore to continue. I said that we will carry, the Government will carry, and Madam Minister will orchestrate the work with the work, and I know that our deputies and senators who are here will work on it: a bill of recognition and reparation.

I said it, this text is not intended to define what history is, it is not the work of a legal text. This has sometimes been done. I believe that it is not the role of a law. And because I also do not want to enter into a memory competition on this subject. Why? Because I know very well what the repatriates, the conscripts, our military will tell me. It is not for a law to… in a way, lay the groundwork for history, that is not the role of a law. What is true is that there is a singularity regarding the Harkis. It is the military abandonment and then the abandonment and mistreatment of families on our soil. That is a specificity. And therefore, the recognition of these two facts, which are historically established characteristics that are singularities of the Harki issue, must be included in this law, and this law will aim, this is its main purpose and what justifies a legal text, to establish a national commission linked to the service of the National Office of Veterans and Victims of War, which will oversee the process of collecting their testimonies and reparations.

On this subject, I will be clear: it is about repairing first for the first generation and being able to revalue the allowances for veterans and their widows, it is a duty. Why? Because, here too, they were treated worse than others and that is an established fact. Then, it is about collecting testimonies and repairing for the second generation who had to live in the camps, who had to live in the forest villages or the homes in undignified living conditions and the lack of access to school for children. And I also say this very clearly: it is not about establishing reparations for others who lived in different situations because the cases are also individual. It is not about establishing reparations for subsequent generations or for women and men who did not have to live under the same conditions. Because otherwise, we would open situations that, in a way, would not be fair in relation to what the Republic has had to endure. I am touching again on the heart of the singularity today of what we are talking about. On the other hand, I believe that this commission for reparations also aims to address the issue of children and grandchildren for their education and their access to equal opportunities.

You said it, no monetary compensation will repair what happened, there are reparations to be established because in this case it is about the French Republic. This is also one of the singularities of the Harki issue. It is not a parenthesis in our history, it is the Republic that did all this, up until recently, and therefore it must assume the conditions of reparations for those who had to experience it. But we must also support the education of children and grandchildren, the families who wish it, and alongside whom we must stand.

It is the honor of the Harkis to have fought for France and to have fully integrated into the national community through blood, through work, despite obstacles and hardships, bringing with them the wealth and talents that are theirs. A harka, literally, is a mobile group. The Harki, literally, is one who advances.

Today, the daughters and sons of Harkis are officers, non-commissioned officers, professors, historians, lawyers, magistrates, senior executives, journalists, diplomats, mayors, painters, writers, filmmakers, artisans, merchants. They are exemplary French destinies and they are our pride. And in this regard, let me be clear this morning, everywhere in the country, when one insults a Harki, one insults France.

For decades, you lived in a country where what you are was an insult and is still an insult in many places in the Republic. And for decades, you left a land where the obsession of the leaders up to today was and still is not to let you return, even to mourn at the graves of your parents and grandparents.

There is something of the stateless memory and justice in what is the condition of the Harkis. This is what makes this singularity in the Republic. And today, this is what I want us to repair together. We do not repair every destiny. I understand that, because there is something inconsolable in what each and every one of you has experienced. But we have to rebuild for you and for what the French nation is, a justice that restores to each their place: the rightful share of memory, the reparation of what has been suffered, and the rightful pride of what you are.

That is why it is the honor of France to recognize and repair its shortcomings, to support and assist those who defended it, to grant the truth and gratitude of the French Republic to its children who served it and who suffered. Finally! But this path, this journey of recognition, will continue to take time, I know. And we will need a lot of humility, but through this law, I want us to be able to write a moment that will finally allow families, children, grandchildren to be recognized, restored in their dignity and proud to be what they are, to be French.

Long live the Republic and long live France!

General François MEYER, on behalf of the French Republic, we elevate you to the dignity of Grand Cross of the National Order of Merit.

Mr. Salah ABDELKRIM, on behalf of the French Republic, we make you a Knight of the Legion of Honor.

Mrs. Bornia TARALL, on behalf of the French Republic, we make you a Knight of the National Order of Merit.

Thank you.