Speech by the President of the Republic on the occasion of the international conference "The Cry for Peace" organized by the Community of Sant'Egidio.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

23 October 2022 · International conference "The Cry for Peace" organized by the Community of Sant'Egidio

Context
Macron addressed the Community of Sant'Egidio's international 'Cry for Peace' conference in Rome on October 23, 2022, amid the ongoing war in Ukraine.
Main themes
Peace and war in Ukraine, role of religion in peacemaking, multilateralism and international dialogue, Russian aggression and European security, nuclear power and conflict, sovereignty and self-determination, interfaith cooperation, limits of diplomacy, just peace versus capitulation
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,756
84th percentile
Sentences
151
81st percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 51%48%
  • Ceremonial 23%22%
  • Social 23%21%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

151 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Gentlemen Presidents,

Dear Sergio,

Eminences,

Beatitudes,

Your Excellencies,

Very Reverend Fathers, Very Reverend Mothers,

Gentlemen Grand Rabbis and Rabbis,

Ladies and gentlemen high representatives of Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Ladies and gentlemen religious dignitaries,

Gentlemen Presidents and former Presidents of the Community of Sant’Egidio, Ladies and gentlemen,

First, I want to express the immense honor of being among you today, but at the same time, when I was invited and accepted the invitation, I first thought: they are inviting the President of a secular Republic that has a sometimes complex history with religions. Then I thought: they are inviting the President who is at the head of diplomacy, but also of the armies of a nuclear power in the midst of a war that is returning to Europe. It is a strange moment to come and talk about peace.

So I first asked myself, dear Andrea, if you were really a friend? Echoing Molière, I thought: what am I doing in this mess? Talking about peace now, when every day, we have to explain that we will hold on, that we must talk about defeating the adversary, about victory, and that everywhere across Europe and around the world, we are essentially waiting for words that are more often bellicose.

I also remembered those moments that have deeply marked me in recent years, moments of exchange; you had the kindness to mention the Bernardins, and I also remember the Hôtel-de-Ville of Paris, the exchange with the Protestants, just a few days ago, at the Great Mosque of Paris, the Grand Rabbi surely remembers it too with the Jews of France. And then the places I have traveled around the world, and I see here several friendly faces from Jerusalem to Mosul to the far reaches of Africa and the importance of this dialogue.

When I called Andrea RICCARDI yesterday, I asked him: but what do you expect from me? He replied with something that comforted me. He said: "Tell us what you expect from religions at this moment." First, someone who responds like that is quite rare for a President of the Republic. That’s when I thought: this is what I will try to do. But above all, I believe that in the moment we are going through, your working days, this dialogue you have established, has something that, by its very approach, responds to the situation we are living. Because deciding to bring together all religions, but also philosophical families, convictions, leaders, associations, is to act concretely for this multilateralism of several orders, but it is to create a dialogue and thus the art of a form of imbalance.

As I said, it is at a moment when we only talk about victory or defeat, accepting to be somewhat untimely, and to talk about peace. That is why I am before you today.

So I would like, as I mentioned briefly, to talk about the moment because talking about peace and calling for peace today can have something unbearable for those who are fighting for their freedom and give the feeling of being somehow betrayed. And I say this in a country that has known occupation and where sometimes those who defended peace could not be understood and were experienced as bearers of defeats. Let us not allow peace today to be, in a way, captured by Russian power. It is not their word. It does not belong to them. They have even done the opposite. And peace today cannot be the consecration of the law of the strongest, nor a ceasefire, which would consecrate a fait accompli.

So we are talking about peace, about this cry for peace that you have decided as a title and a call, and you will work together during all these days at the very moment when Ukrainians are fighting, to resist, to defend their dignity, to protect their borders, their territories, and their national sovereignty. But a peace is possible, the one that they alone will decide, when they decide, and which can respect their rights as a sovereign people.

So yes, we are speaking in this context, and let us try to reflect with you; I wanted to try to see why this war in Ukraine is shaking us so deeply. First, because you said it, President MATTARELLA just now, it marks the return of war on European soil, and our Europe had succeeded in the miracle of driving war from its soil until now. Then because it involves a nuclear-armed power. Nothing justifies this war. Nothing explains it.

But trying to step back in this moment and to try to understand, I who have lived these last years and who have not ceased to speak in particular with President PUTIN, I have tried to see what could have brought us to this point because when you are one of the leaders of this world and you have tried to re-engage Russia in the concert of nations, to prevent, including just a few months ago, this war, you cannot every day fail to ask the question: how did we get here?

I have no answer. I do not know if there is a complete one. I think there is probably not a single one, and I think no answer justifies, explains, or legitimizes anything. I think first that this war is the result of an exacerbated nationalism, fueled by Russian power, which has fed on the resentment and humiliation born from the dislocation of the Soviet Empire. Then, it has nourished itself, reinforced, by progressively isolating itself from the rest of the world, the epidemic having undoubtedly helped in this regard, and building the conviction that threats were there and that somehow the attack on its existence was the project of the rest of the world or the West, to quote us. And then, it has consolidated, constructed by a form of historical revisionism, transforming contemporary history and even modern history into justifying what is nothing but an imperialist and colonial project consisting of invading its neighbor. That is what has, I believe, happened methodically in recent months and years.

This war is today that of a power that has sought to justify it and has constructed its own reason, its own narrative, but I am not sure that it is the war of the entire Russian people for all that. And that is where, to begin to answer the question posed by you, Andrea, working underneath, patiently, is essential. Speaking to the Russian people and to their consciences is essential. This war cannot be entirely theirs today.

Then, today, we have very clearly, and until the last minute we will do so, decided to sanction Russia, to stand by the Ukrainian people to help them resist, from an economic, humanitarian, military point of view without being a party to this war so as not to globalize it. But so that at some point the Ukrainian people can choose peace and so that they choose the moment and the terms of a peace that they will have wanted.

Which means that there is a perspective for peace and it will exist at some point, and that at some point, depending on the evolution of things and when the Ukrainian people and their leaders will have decided in terms that they will have decided, peace will be built with the other and today’s enemy around a table and the national community being there.

I say all this bringing you my part of a provisional and imperfect interpretation of what we are living, but because we would not remain apart from what is happening today. And even though we are talking about peace, it is a perspective and we must build it. There is today a people that is aggressed, attacked, and on the other side are leaders who have decided to launch an assault, to invade and to humiliate.

To stand aside thinking that there could be a form of equivalence or that we could remain neutral, I believe, is to acknowledge that we could accept an international order where the law of the strongest could become the general law and where domination or the status quo could replace our rights. I do not believe that.

This war is here, therefore, and it collides with our Europe, it disturbs us, changes our lives, and I do not want it to make us forget the other wars that you have mentioned, the one in the Caucasus that the Armenian people are suffering, the one in Syria, in Iraq, the one in the Horn of Africa, the one in the Near and Middle East, on the African continent, Mozambique has also been mentioned, or around the world that today shakes entire peoples, pushes them into misery, famine, sometimes exile.

Talking about peace is also talking about what traverses our societies that are not necessarily at war but that are experiencing the return of violence and living through the moment we are going through, oscillating between the return of anger and great fears, doubting the truths that allow us to build a common ground. Where so many in our societies are plunged into a form of solitude which, I believe, is one of the great dramas of the times we are living in and where in many of our countries, particularly in Europe, our peoples have this feeling of losing control of their lives, their history, their bearings.

I say this because this trouble, in a way, that we are living and that traverses all our societies, even when they are not at war; this anxiety that arises from solitude, from a form of relativism that is becoming generalized, from the immensity of the challenges we face – that of climate change, that of the great inequalities linked to our contemporary organization – fundamentally gives rise to and brings back, even in our Europe, the seeds of war.

They always have the same roots: the closed nationalisms that we must never confuse with patriotism, but which are the will to retreat and exclude the Other and to dominate one people, one nation over another, the rejection of the Other in our societies, what I would call the dreams of purity that run through our societies and that summon all the simplifications of the world. This can be the dream of ethnic purity, like the dream of religious purity. But they are there, in our societies, to sell a form of absolute good, consisting of saying that the solution, in the face of these doubts, these troubles, this shaking of consciences, is to return to a unique truth and to clear enemies that must be fought. You see, I come before you worried.

So in the face of these challenges, that of war in Europe, that of the wars that exist elsewhere and the seeds that are returning in our societies, what can religions do? I think they can do a lot and that the politicians we are, I say this in the generic sense, as women and men who have decided to take care of the life of the city, need them. First, because we all – government or state leaders, association leaders, business leaders, and religious leaders – must try to draw the right diagnosis and act together.

Then, because I think that if political speech can do a lot in what it gives meaning, in what it can bring meaning. It is today touched in many of our societies by the distrust that is the sister of the observation I have just made, but because neither laws, nor decrees, nor decisions that we can make are sufficient. Souls and peoples cannot be administered. So I think that religious leaders have an essential role as they contribute to the fabric of our societies, to these relationships between individuals and to a long-term relationship.

I think that in the context I have just mentioned and in the face of the situation I have just described, your role is eminent. That of first, but I will not take it up here because I do not want to be long, as I had mentioned several times at the Bernardins, in particular, the gift of wisdom, commitment, and freedom that we must expect from religions.

Then, I think that religions and religious leaders have a role of resistance in the face of the madness of the times. And resistance, I will try to say from where I stand and from where I speak, is precisely to never justify, to be trapped or to support political projects that would enslave or deny the dignity of each individual. I think that in this regard, this duty of resistance is essential. It is essential because the risk is there and what I describe is happening. We all know how the Orthodox Church is today manipulated by Russian power to justify its actions - a duty of resistance. We know in our societies and we also know in certain nations how Islam is invoked to justify political projects of domination. We also know in our societies how other religions have also been used in our history for political projects of domination, of marginalizing part of humanity and dominating the other.

If I speak of a republic where the state is separated from religion, religion is in society and it has an eminent role. But in doing so, it has this role of never allowing projects that, in its name, or diverting it from its primary purpose, which manipulating its precepts, can lead to the opposite of what it defends.

This duty of resistance of religions, which I see as essential, as you have understood, is why I have just advocated for it before you. It consists of defending the dignity of each person, of never yielding, in a way, to the impulse of purity that some would like to invoke, of defending respect, the duty to care for the most vulnerable, and also of providing an essential response in our societies that we cannot fail to provide: that of rooting and that of salvation.

These few key points that I have just described are, in my view, crucial in this mission of resistance. When war is present or when the turmoil I have tried to describe very briefly returns to our societies. Every time a hegemony establishes itself, when the negation of the other is present, religions play an essential role in defending the few principles I have just mentioned. This is particularly what I have seen at work and what the Christians of the East defend from Lebanon to Mosul, passing through Armenia, carrying an indispensable part of ideal and a capacity to dialogue, to not yield to what would be the law of the strongest, which inevitably leads to the erasure of the other.

The last thing is that I believe religions obviously have a message of universality to convey. I say this from a country, a nation, a people that has this in common with your religions, which has always claimed to have a part of the universal, and this is a pride of France. I believe that a French person is one who thinks they have a universal message; it is in our genes. But what is this universality?

First of all, it is not a discourse, a religion, or a truth that would dominate the rest of the world. Universality is not hegemony. Furthermore, it is not the idea of dialoguing with oneself. It is not, in a way, sameness, ipséité to return to the ancient concept. Universality is primarily a requirement regarding oneself. What I do must be applicable and explainable everywhere in the world. It is a will to understand what we do on a global scale and to dialogue with others and to seek the irreducible part of the universal in each of us.

Universality is precisely what aims to build this unity of human nature and to recognize, thereby, because it is the underlying principle, the dignity of every human being. That is why universality is, in my eyes, the best antidote against contemporary relativism, the best antidote also against the fracturing of the world that we are witnessing, which consists, in a way, of enshrining in too many places in the world the law of the strongest or of relegating certain principles to a form of historicity or regionalism, because we see today voices rising everywhere around the world, from Asia, Africa, and Latin America, telling us: equality between women and men is a Western notion. What you defend here or there is a Western notion. No, the dignity of every human being, gender equality, the values that we uphold and that religions defend, are universal values in that their foundation is the dignity of every human being, as they intertwine, as they progress in societies through an incessant dialogue between religions, between political formations, and because they outline a horizon that I do not believe can be surpassed.

Above all, this universality, to which you contribute historically, philosophically, and for which we need you more than ever today, is the one that helps to prevent humiliation and consequently, resentment. For all the wars that we see today looming and the divisions in our societies arise precisely from this. The humiliation of the weakest, of the forgotten, of those who have not digested their history because we have not built the path to do so, and the resentment that arises from it, which justifies the war of tomorrow.

This is the task that is ours if we truly want to rise to the height of this cry for peace. Not simply to cease arms today, but to track down everywhere the humiliations and sources of resentment. They arise every time this universality is forgotten. They arise every time one comes to disrupt the just order that only these universal principles allow to be built. In preparing this free reflection before you, I was diving back into a small text from 1795. To tell you the truth, it is the small text in one of those original editions that I will offer tomorrow to the Holy Father, Kant's project of perpetual peace. And in these first principles, he says: cannot be recognized as a peace treaty, one that would carry the roots of a new war. Then, he develops it much better than I will here: any text, any peace that denies the place of the other, even of my enemy, is not a peace treaty. This is the immense difficulty of peace. It imposes this universality that I have just described, but a step towards the other and thus a imbalance. This is what makes it precarious and that when times are difficult and turmoil reestablishes itself, it is often so fragile in the face of bellicose discourses and those who would like to make us believe that the truth is purer than that. Peace is impure, deeply, ontologically because it accepts a series of imbalances, discomforts, but which make this coexistence with the other as myself possible.

I say this here for our friends who come from all over the world, Europe and particularly the European Union are a treasure in this regard, and we can say this because we have built our Europe on millennia of civil wars. Europe was the continent that had the greatest expertise in wars. Religious wars, political wars, hegemonic wars. And our European Union is this small treasure of peace because we decided that we would build a balance based on the knowledge and understanding of the other, the absence of hegemony. There is no stronger in our European Union. There are only equals and the conviction that our future was together. I believe that this message of Europe is a message with a universal vocation. And it is the same thing that we need to find, President Mattarella, President Riccardi mentioned it in their remarks, in the balance between the South and the North and in this new dialogue that we must know how to build. It is a balance of respect, reciprocity, and justice.

Paul VI spoke of development as the new language of peace, and it is the project that we want to carry, the one we have tried to carry during the pandemic and from health issues to education issues, to the essential question of climate, to the question, of course, of economic inequalities. We must rebalance the world if we truly want to build peace. We must have the same strength of spirit that we had as Europeans to end our civil wars on a planetary scale, all together, to find the ways and means of this universality that requires more justice and respect for the other.

In this regard, and to support many of these projects in health, education, climate, and the agenda that we want to build, which is fundamentally that of solidarity investment, I need you and your role is absolutely essential.

I will not prolong my remarks any further; they are largely imperfect and resolutely incomplete, and I accept that. But fundamentally, I wanted, since you have given me the opportunity, at such a grave moment for our continent and for all of us, to tell you that there is a possible humanist project. And for this humanist project that needs to be reinvented, religions, the great philosophical families have an essential role to play, for this humanist project will rest on the respect of each person, justice, recognition, and courage.

I will conclude on this old value. It takes a lot of courage to want peace, to preserve it, or to restore it. And the true courageous ones are here. It takes a lot of courage. First, the courage of imagination, as you have admirably said, Andrea. Because imagining peace in times of war is the greatest of the unthinkable. But it takes courage to hold peace as soon as it is possible, a form of restlessness. I told you that peace was impure; it is always restless. Because building peace is always accepting the part of the other. And so I do not know if it is a cry that we need, but I think we surely need a slow task of each day, but indispensable. And we will need a lot of courage for that, and I know that we are capable of it. This courage to build peace and, in a way, to always live on its border. Thank you.