Transcript of the speech by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, on the transformation of the health system "Taking care of everyone"

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 September 2018 · Presentation of the reform "Taking care of everyone" on the transformation of the health system · Élysée Palace, France

Context
Macron addressed healthcare professionals gathered at the Élysée Palace in September 2018 to express gratitude and outline his vision for reforming the French healthcare system.
Main themes
Healthcare system reform, caregiver recognition and malaise, patient-centered care, chronic disease and aging population, public and private hospital medicine, life expectancy and health outcomes, welfare state modernization, healthcare spending and supply regulation, medical research and innovation, working conditions for caregivers
Duration
~82 min
98th percentile
Words
9,848
98th percentile
Sentences
326
96th percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
15.5
80th percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 72%71%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

326 sentences in 112 paragraphs

My dear friends,

Thank you for being here today in this room at the Élysée, and I believe it has been a long time since your professions were gathered at the Élysée. I wanted to do this, some will say because of my long companionship with this profession, but above all to express my gratitude to all of you, students, caregivers, hospital doctors, private practitioners, researchers, academics, directors of establishments or organizations.

I know that your work is sometimes challenged today by contradictory injunctions, by reforms that are experienced as permanent, and I also know that there are impatiences, sometimes doubts that may drive you.

Yet, and this is the first reality I want to remind you of here, thanks to you and your efforts, our healthcare system remains our strength and our pride. It is thanks to your extreme dedication that the system still holds. Moreover, the French people, your patients, recognize this. They hold all healthcare professionals in very high regard. And allow me, here today, on their behalf, to thank you and to solemnly express our republican recognition.

No one wishes to be treated anywhere other than in France; many of our neighbors envy the excellence of our healthcare system. We are attached to our model that combines public and private hospital medicine with liberal medicine.

Thanks to this original model, France is the country where, by the age of 60, the life expectancy of French women and men ranks second in the world. It is in France that the out-of-pocket expenses for households regarding their health are the lowest in the world. It reached less than 8% in 2017. And this is primarily due to a high level of coverage by Social Security and all those who cover these risks, which is an achievement that I intend to preserve.

But, and this is a second reality, even if the satisfaction of treating and saving is always present in the daily lives of caregivers, a sense of malaise has now deeply settled in. The evolution of working conditions, the relationship with patients often presented as "hindered," the feeling of not having the time to do what is essential, and the lack of career advancement prospects, especially for those working in public hospitals, are all realities as well.

My ambition is clear; I want what we call the healthcare system to be one of the pillars of the welfare state of the 21st century, a healthcare system that prevents and protects against today's and tomorrow's health risks, but also a healthcare system that can accompany the life paths of each of our fellow citizens.

1958 was a turning point because the organization of university hospital centers allowed the return of medical excellence in care and research to hospitals, which had until then been mainly considered as dispensaries. It was a real change in approach. Today, we must again work towards a paradigm shift. It will be of equivalent magnitude to adapt to the evolutions of science and our society, to new pathologies and the care needs of patients, to the challenges of research and innovation, to adapt to your aspirations as caregivers and to refocus our system around the patient.

I want to express to you today my confidence in our ability to succeed collectively. This will not happen overnight, but we must start right now and work hard, even if it takes 2 to 3 years. We must restructure our organization for the next fifty years.

To do this, what observations do we share? I said our healthcare system has strengths, but it has been considerably weakened in recent decades. Why? Because it was designed for a society where people did not live as long as they do today; it was designed to treat acute pathologies and was conceived at a time when the supply of care corresponded to the needs of society.

And gradually, in recent years, several developments, some of our doing, others linked to the broader evolution of our society, have put it under strain.

First, we thought, and it was a dogma for several years, relatively ecumenical on the political level, that we could reduce healthcare spending by regulating it through supply. So we thought that reducing the number of doctors, the number of facilities, would reduce the number of patients; it did not work, and the lag effects being what they are, the decisions made sometimes 20 or 30 years ago are now having full consequences. And the corrections that, I will return to, we could make will only have their full effects in 10 to 15 years.

Then society changed, precisely because our healthcare system has been effective, and thus we live longer, longer in good health, and the pathologies that our system has to treat are no longer the same. They are increasingly chronic pathologies, increasingly pathologies related to an aging population, and thus this system of care as organized is no longer adapted to these few evolutions I mentioned. This creates tension in terms of access to care, and we see it every day when faced with the difficulties of finding a general practitioner or obtaining an appointment within a reasonable timeframe, which is linked to the fact that the number of available consultations with general practitioners has decreased by 15% in 15 years, even as the population aged, and access to specialists has become increasingly difficult, with specialties having great heterogeneity among themselves. Medical offices, emergency services, and medico-social establishments are saturated in this regard.

Tensions then arise in terms of the working conditions of healthcare professionals, many of whom feel they are losing the very meaning of their profession, their vocation, due to the administrative and financial constraints they face. And also because the new generations of doctors aspire to different practices, and this is a reality we observe every day to better reconcile personal and professional life, which can also lead to creating tensions in supply in certain areas.

Finally, financial tension is linked to the challenges of aging, the development of chronic pathologies, and the costs of therapeutic innovations that test our ability to preserve our model of solidarity-based health in the long term, to which our fellow citizens are fundamentally attached.

All these tensions are not, however, inevitable; nothing, among our neighbors, in some of our territories, initiatives, and local experiments are managing to trigger new organizations and can inspire us starting today.

In many territories of our country, we have already begun to move, based on these observations, and I look around us; several countries have conducted profound evolutions that have allowed them to respond to these challenges, without drama, without crisis, and without renouncing the values of solidarity and the demands of quality.

They did not respond by spending more, but by organizing better, because our healthcare system does not primarily suffer from a problem of underfunding; it suffers from a real organizational handicap; the organizational model is no longer adapted to either demand or supply of care.

France, when I look at the figures, currently devotes a considerable share of its national wealth to its healthcare spending, about 11.5% of its gross domestic product, which places us third among OECD countries after the United States and Switzerland, and ahead of Germany, Sweden, or Japan. It is not a question of doing less, and I will return to this point, but it is also not a question of saying, for convenience, that it would suffice to spend more for everything to get better; that would be false.

Aging, the legitimate demand of our population, innovations in both medications and medical devices create a dynamic of spending, and it is indeed through collective reorganization that we can respond to the challenges I mentioned.

Let us be clear; if the overall budget we allocate to health is high, but everyone considers it insufficient in their daily lives, it is definitively because our care organizations, our modes of resource allocation are not the right ones. They are not adapted to the evolution of more complex, more chronic pathologies that require more coordination among professionals and more prevention.

Indeed, our system prevents poorly, and the observation is now established. In France, we treat well, but we are not necessarily healthier than our neighbors because we prevent resolutely less well than many of our neighbors, particularly in Europe. And in doing so, heavier and therefore more costly pathologies settle in, and in mirror, our system suffers from too many unnecessary acts, from over-medication because we arrive too late or in a system that is too blind that performs too many acts.

Our system then remains atomized, compartmentalized, unbalanced, with too many city professionals who still practice too isolated, health establishments too often competing with one another, sectors of the city and the hospital that do not communicate enough, an outpatient shift that should lead to more treatment without resorting to hospitalization that still struggles to materialize, and remuneration modes that encourage a race for activity and acts.

The hospital concentrates its dysfunctions and risks implosion without comprehensive transformation, as the hospital is becoming, in the most strained or troubled areas, a dispensary welcoming all health and social emergencies, developing more and more activities to survive financially, while at the same time being asked to perform more advanced interventions, to enhance the excellence of its clinical research, to continue efforts in training, and to facilitate care pathways in the community.

The hospital has modernized with new organizations, new financing modes, but today the hospital is at the end of what it can do to remedy our collective disorganization, and this is particularly true for its emergency services.

This race for activity has become insane—everything in our system encourages it—because it loses sight of quality. And the situation is absurd in this regard; we are doing more and more in certain activities, the relevance of which is not always proven; 30% according to evaluations of costly acts serve no purpose, and we cannot meet the demand for basic care in proximity. And by doing acts, we expose ourselves to doing more but sometimes poorly. For example, for all patients suffering from heart failure, we re-hospitalize twice as many in France as in the United Kingdom, 30% more than in Switzerland. Patients and caregivers alike suffer from this system I have just described and its absurdities.

We owe it to them, we owe it to you, to break this vicious circle in which we have locked ourselves to regain the spirit that presided over the construction of our healthcare system, with a commitment from all, not the hospital on one side, the private practitioners on the other, and patients that we would forget in the process, no, by trying to place all the actors of this system in a cooperative approach that will allow us to respond to these challenges.

So faced with this observation, what is, what should be in my eyes, the vision for the future of this healthcare system? It is a system that must better prevent, be centered on the patient, and on the quality of care.

Better prevention first; I mentioned this by citing this French paradox where we treat very well, but we are not healthier than our neighbors because we prevent resolutely less well. From the commitments I made before our fellow citizens, I called for a revolution in prevention, which would resolutely shift our system and your practices from a curative approach to a preventive approach.

The minister, whose commitment and work I salute here, dear Agnès Buzyn, has been leading this fight from the very first days and on a daily basis, with vaccines made mandatory, which have sparked some debates, the fight against tobacco, cancer screening, and 100% coverage for optical, dental, and hearing care, essential so that our state of health does not deteriorate even further. And the establishment of the health service starting this school year.

40,000 first-year health students will carry out their health service this year to teach good practices in prevention, primarily in schools, among children and young people who need it most, in rural areas or disadvantaged neighborhoods, but also because better trained in prevention from the start, they will be different healthcare professionals and will have contributed to deploying more preventive actions in these priority territories.

All public policies are concerned, and the entire government must be committed to this Prevention Priority Plan adopted last March. When, a few days ago, the Prime Minister and the Minister of State presented a Bicycle Plan, it is also within the framework of a prevention policy and an improvement of the health of our fellow citizens. When Parliament votes in the second reading on a bill regarding food and agriculture, it is a prevention policy aimed at developing organic farming, the quality of food, particularly in school cafeterias and collective catering.

When we ban neonicotinoids, it is a policy of prevention and health; social pricing in cafeterias or breakfast in disadvantaged schools presented last week as part of the Poverty Plan is a health prevention strategy. And it is this spirit that must permeate the actions of the government and parliamentarians in the coming months to continue this essential work.

The second axis is the quality of the healthcare system serving the patient. We must indeed move from a quantitative and budgetary approach to healthcare offerings to a patient-centered approach, pragmatically speaking, because we have seen over the past few years that the one who decides in our healthcare systems is the patient. It is neither the government nor the one who reimburses nor even the doctor; it is the patient who chooses, which has sometimes led us to try to impose measures or reorganizations from above. If the patient does not decide for themselves, does not understand, does not support them, they are not effective.

It is not up to them to adapt to the system, but rather the system to adapt to their needs. And it is around the patient that the response of caregivers must be built, in proximity, and coordinated in a network. Thus, structuring primary care is the top priority. Because it is from this essential lever that many of the responses to the tensions we are experiencing depend. The response to the population's demand for care, the acceleration of the shift to outpatient care, the alleviation of pressure on hospitals, the improvement of working conditions for healthcare professionals in the community—all of this relies on better structuring of primary care.

The healthcare system of tomorrow is a network of primary care, which includes all healthcare professionals in a territory, regardless of their status, and which guarantees the population permanent access to scheduled or unscheduled care. The caregivers in this network can be hospital staff, private practitioners, doctors, nurses, midwives, pharmacists; what matters is that everyone, in their place with their expertise and competence, can intervene at the right moment, in a coordinated manner with their colleagues and as a team.

The patient must always be able to access a primary care physician, an emergency response, and specialized medical expertise when necessary. This approach precisely requires us to stop opposing hospital staff and private practitioners, general practitioners and specialists, doctors and other healthcare professionals, and to finally build a collective functioning.

Tomorrow, caregivers will work increasingly in the community and at the same time in hospitals. And this priority for primary care must be coordinated with excellence in clinical research, innovation, training, and cutting-edge technologies; the target in my eyes is this collective, decompartmentalized, coordinated practice.

So the transformation strategy that you have been working on since the launch of the work by the Prime Minister last February must lead us toward this target. Minister Agnès Buzyn will have the opportunity to detail all the measures planned to support this transformation. There are many, as all professionals are involved, but I would like to particularly emphasize three orientations and sets of measures that will mark this path of transformation.

The first orientation is to build the system around the patient, and first and foremost, simply to allow them to access the care they need. This is the top priority, as I mentioned when talking about the target we must pursue. In this regard, the absolute priority is to regain medical and caregiving time available for our fellow citizens. To start, we must ensure that we train enough doctors; for that, we cannot be satisfied with the current system, which has an absurdity that is a problem for all of us, as it is evident to all our fellow citizens.

Today, it is a waste that concerns 25,000 students each year, 25,000 students who, overnight, go from being excellent high school students to those who fail for the first, second, or third time in their first year, at the same time that our fellow citizens are suffering from difficulties in accessing care, at the same time that when they go to their local hospital, they realize that it only functions because we rely on temporary doctors, whose payment methods burden the same hospital budget, in this vicious circle that we know, and where we have 10% of doctors graduated abroad.

The system is absurd, and we must therefore face it. At the same time, our companies are looking for talent in biotechnology, in research laboratories, and are seeking these same skills. I have long expressed my conviction on this point, and the ministers have proposed a complete renovation of health studies, particularly medical studies. The numerus clausus will therefore be abolished to stop maintaining an artificial scarcity and to allow us to train more doctors with a renewed selection method and to strengthen the qualitative dimension and the level of training in health studies.

This is the work that the ministers will carry out in the coming months to rethink, after the necessary consultations, medical studies. But let us not be deluded about the immediate effectiveness of such a device; we are currently suffering the consequences of decisions made decades ago, as I mentioned, and our decisions on the numerus clausus will have a symmetrical impact in 10 to 15 years; we must therefore activate all levers today to move faster.

There are already students who wish to join medical studies or medical training after spending a few years in other university fields, in sciences, in biology, where they have acquired similar and complementary skills. We too often require them to enroll in the first year and go through the gauntlet of rote learning and exams, which is also absurd.

Starting in the 2020 school year, there will no longer be an exam at the end of the first year, meaning no more PACES, this acronym synonymous with failure for so many young people. Tomorrow, all students enrolled in a bachelor's degree, regardless of their specialty, will be able to join the medical curriculum in the second, third, or fourth year, and the ministers will detail all the training for health professions that will thus be renovated, to promote pathways between professions, common teachings, the possibility of continuing or resuming training, and participating in research activities.

By valuing and fully evaluating the skills needed in medicine, skills that have a relational and sometimes written dimension, where, it must be said, the current system, essentially based on multiple-choice questions, does not fully allow for the proper identification of these skills, which are only identified much later in the curriculum, with, again, a certain waste.

To all those who might see in this reform a renunciation of the excellence derived today from the end-of-first-year exam, I say that this training pathway will remain selective, will be more open, more vibrant, will attract more varied and equally excellent profiles, and will also be based on the principles I mentioned that better correspond to the reality of daily medical practice.

But to free up medical time, to have more consultations, more patients welcomed, the greatest short-term gains therefore come from a different distribution of tasks. We have already allowed vaccinations to be carried out by pharmacists; we must continue to relieve doctors of tasks that can be performed by others, much like orthoptists have allowed ophthalmologists to be relieved of certain tasks or nurses who support general practitioners in screening, monitoring, and therapeutic education for their chronic illness.

On this subject, there is a better distribution of tasks and time among the different healthcare professionals. And this will be more rewarding for all of them. To free up even more medical time and ensure that doctors can treat more and better, we must allow them to be supported by professionals who perform simple tasks for them, such as taking blood pressure or temperature, preparing for the consultation, advising and following the patient's journey, and taking on part of the administrative management and coordination tasks; this goes hand in hand with a revaluation of all health professions—

(Sound of glass breaking)

I hope there are no injuries—and of the contribution that everyone can make in the medical follow-up of the patient; otherwise, this is the right time and the right day to have a workplace accident. Everything is fine.

It is in this spirit, and to this end, that we will create medical assistants, that is to say, professionals who will assist doctors, long established in the medical practices of our neighbors. These health personnel will accompany and relieve the doctor of simple tasks, contributing precisely to the patient's care. These positions will be funded for all doctors, first, general practitioners and specialists, for whom access to care difficulties are identified, as long as they practice in a grouped manner and commit to objectives and results. Taking on new patients, shortening waiting times, prevention actions, unscheduled consultations.

So how many medical assistants will we finance, these professionals who will help our doctors in the coming years? As many as needed to support this movement in all territories, the first will arrive in priority neighborhoods for access to care and in under-dense areas, starting in 2019. Professionals estimate that we could gain between 15 and 20% of medical time with such an organization; the goal of the five-year term must be to deploy at least 4,000. This would represent a gain of medical time equivalent to nearly 2,000 additional doctors given the current organization, but if the movement is there, if the need is there, we will finance as much as needed. Because it is at the heart of the reorganization of all these professions, and it is an essential evolution.

We must finally pay particular attention to the most deprived territories, where we cannot replace our doctors who are retiring, these so-called medical deserts that are today a source of anxiety for many of our fellow citizens, for their elected representatives, rightly so. These medical deserts are not only in rural areas; on this subject, let us not be mistaken, they are often found in the outskirts of large cities, in the most difficult neighborhoods, in very rural areas.

And so it is a multiple France, but it is the France that is demographically falling behind, it is the France that today can no longer attract businesses, that can no longer sufficiently attract new doctors, this part of France where the population is aging, and where therefore the needs are new, and with the aging of the population, the aging of the medical demographic, and where at the same time that needs continue to grow, doctors are retiring and are not being replaced.

The number of retired doctors has doubled in the last ten years, and unfilled departures are concentrated precisely in these most rural territories and in difficult urban neighborhoods.

Today, we have nearly 20% of the population located in these priority territories for access to care that we call under-dense areas. So what I have just mentioned is a first response, and it is in these areas that we will promote the reorganization of healthcare professionals and investment in these medical assistants to free up useful medical time, support them, and also encourage these practices, a form of organization that young healthcare professionals favor. But we must also acknowledge that legitimate impatience is present.

So, we all know the debate by heart here. Should we impose constraints? Should we not impose constraints? I have said this for a long time, and this long companionship with healthcare professionals has taught me a lot in this area. Unilateral constraints coming from above may please – I understand that very well – the elected officials in these territories and be an immediate response that one proposes to their fellow citizens: it will not work. It will not work. One of the problems today in our medical demographics is that more and more young doctors, or less young ones who have been trained by the system, are stopping practice due to these constraints. This is a reality. And so, if we start today to say: "We are going to completely impose the mapping of medical graduates," I think we will have a lot of trouble meeting this challenge. In any case, it would be a fallacious response, a rhetorical one, so I do not believe in it.

But we must also, and I ask that the ministers take this into account in the redesign of medical and health studies, succeed in addressing some absurdities where the territorialization and the constraints we impose throughout the course of studies do not correspond to the needs we have afterwards. And I think that on this subject, we have collectively a lot of progress to make, and I believe we can improve the system without talking about constraints, by allowing more mobility for students, by avoiding concentrating students in the same areas, and then being surprised that students who have been in these most metropolitan areas do not necessarily want to go to the most rural or most difficult areas. I close this parenthesis.

Nevertheless, if we do not manage at some point to have a system that collectively organizes the distribution better across the territory, it is obvious that these debates regarding constraints and the obligation to settle will continue to rise. But in the short term, I believe that through this spirit of trust, of collective action, we can have a more appropriate response. First, by continuing to guide and encourage the installation of healthcare professionals in these areas, by developing structures – health houses, collective installations, and the support I just mentioned – but also by financing positions in a somewhat innovative way that corresponds, I believe, to what we can offer.

Also, I wish that starting in 2019, 400 additional positions for general practitioners in shared city/hospital practice could be financed and sent to priority territories, employed by the local hospital or a health center to offer consultations. I bet that this exceptional measure will be attractive because we see that younger generations are demanding a more significant collective practice, sometimes salaried, than before. The Minister will conduct negotiations within two months to calibrate with you the incentive dimension of this measure, which must be real to be effective and to meet this ambition, and this device will be focused on the most critical territories.

It is both about supporting and accelerating the movement of health houses, but it is also about starting with proof to show this porosity that we must organize between the hospital system and the liberal system by offering attractive remuneration, an organizational framework on the ground for these healthcare professionals that is more suited to contemporary choices. This is therefore the first axis of this transformation that I wanted to recall and defend here: that of allowing better access to the care that the patient needs.

The second orientation that I want to emphasize today in front of you is that of building a system around the patient by allowing them to be cared for in a fluid and coordinated care pathway. This idea is not new. We have been talking about it for years, if not decades. It is the one that has led to the implementation of the referring physician, the care pathway, to change, thanks to the cooperation of all learned societies, the modes of organization and reimbursement. But as chronic pathologies develop, the coordination of different specialists has become today even more essential than yesterday, and coordinated practice must become a reference.

We know very well: a patient suffering from diabetes must have around them a small team with their general practitioner, their endocrinologist, their dietitian, their nurse, their podiatrist, their ophthalmologist… It is this team that must share information in real time, allow the optimization of care to support them and live in the best conditions. This first and foremost requires the deployment of new digital tools. Here too, I feel like I am speaking to you about a long-awaited issue. We know that these tools are currently insufficient. They are compartmentalized, leaving aside the patients who are, after all, the primary stakeholders. I would even go further: nothing will be possible without a radical update of the digital architecture. It is imperative to coordinate the actors, to personalize care, to relieve caregivers of their administrative tasks, to also develop artificial intelligence and deploy new treatments.

We must equip ourselves in the next three years with a real digital service offering that allows patients and healthcare professionals, precisely those who take care of them, to share medical information and communicate with each other in a completely secure manner, obviously respectful of both professional secrecy and the confidentiality that everyone wishes for themselves. This will start with the shared medical record that we will deploy nationally next November. Finally. But it must go much further by providing all insured individuals with a broader patient digital space, enriched with useful information and a bouquet of health services and applications. It will also be about developing with and for healthcare professionals the essential territorial digital tools for good coordination.

In the age of artificial intelligence, what we need to deploy is the digital system that allows all healthcare professionals as well as patients, the former to perform their functions as they should today and the latter to benefit from this personalized medicine that is emerging. And this is not a trend, a whim, or simply a technical change. What is emerging is a profound revolution in medical practice. We must therefore place it at the heart of the system and its redesign, knowing, too, that this transformation will allow for a better distribution of tasks and enable healthcare professionals to focus much more on value-added actions. And I want this objective of personalized medicine and these innovations to be placed at the heart of these reorganizations and this strategy for the precise interest of the patient.

The best organization also involves greater responsibility for healthcare professionals in organizing the response to the health needs of the population in their territories. We know these needs. It is the care of every patient by a primary care physician. It is the response to unscheduled care within the framework of the continuity of care during the day. It is the development of a structured telemedicine offering. It is the follow-up and coordination of interventions around the most complex patients, particularly upon discharge from hospitalization or to prevent hospitalization, or to ensure the maintenance at home of fragile and elderly individuals. It is the development of prevention programs.

We all know these needs. And to meet these real challenges for which we have an obligation to deliver results, all professionals in a territory must commit, work together, and bear collective responsibility towards patients and the population. The framework for this commitment will be the establishment of territorial professional health communities that must also bridge the gap between healthcare facilities, particularly local hospitals, and the medico-social sector. It is about enabling and encouraging all professionals in a territory to work together and organize together because it is in their interest, where we see today in too many situations non-cooperative strategies, if I were to use a euphemistic term, which are corrected how? By services that are put in place and that allow for treatment, in the most urban areas, of night emergency services. But is this completely satisfactory? Not always. Or which lead to shifting the burden onto one actor in the system: the hospital and its emergency services with the conditions and risks that we know and the burden on hospital facilities, and thus, a system where everyone, in the end, becomes a loser.

I want us to be able today, in these relevant territories, to have true cooperation among all healthcare professionals beyond the boundaries of status and positioning, and that all those who are responsible for the health of a population share this responsibility. We must ensure that these professional communities cover all territories by July 1, 2021. I trust local initiatives to deploy in very large numbers. I do not want to make these professional communities a kind of top-down system that should be the same model everywhere in the territory. There are several initiatives that have already emerged today. They need to be encouraged, they need to be developed. They will probably not take the same form depending on the territories. What is certain is that people need to talk to each other, to organize together around the patient. To encourage each and everyone and to ensure that we have these communities that must cover between 20,000 and 100,000 patients by 2022, I want precisely that isolated practice becomes progressively marginal, becomes the aberration, and can disappear by January 2022.

So, I know what this type of statement can provoke in terms of reactions from liberal healthcare professionals. I also know what the stakes and expectations are, and I also see what the aspirations of the new generation are. I am not here to impose an obligation that should be seen as a constraint accompanied by some kind of sanction, but I am instead stating a principle that the law must affirm, an objective that must become a reality, and for that, we must give ourselves the means. And instead of constraints, I want to prioritize incentives. A demanding incentive, focused on the results to be achieved. We will thus commit to financially supporting all professional communities that will be created within the next 18 months for a duration of 10 years.

Furthermore, for professionals, certain elements of existing and future remuneration should tomorrow be reserved for those who engage in this new model of cooperation. I also wish to offer willing professionals the opportunity to go further, faster, to opt for a remuneration that completely shifts from fee-for-service to a flat rate for the care of populations in their territory. This is the logic in which we must engage, and rather than impose, I want us to strongly encourage those who will proactively enter this dynamic.

It is therefore on this basis that I wish to allow initiatives to unfold in the territory. It will then be up to define, in future contractual negotiations with healthcare professionals, the terms of this new pact, and I hope they will succeed because such a reform is always stronger when it comes from an agreement rather than from a law. And I believe that this is the spirit of what has been worked on since last February and the philosophy that I am presenting here before you. We all have an interest in working to set our healthcare system in motion in this direction. In this regard, it is no longer possible for patients in emergency situations not to know whom to turn to and for us to always end up, as I said, at the hospital, overloading services that should focus on vital difficulties.

We have here the most emblematic example of our dysfunctions and the necessity to reposition the hospital in its rightful place. We must reverse in this regard the spiral of congestion in hospital emergency services that welcome vital emergencies day and night, but also many patients who could be treated in consultation. It is estimated that at least one in five visits to the emergency room would fall under a general medicine consultation or sometimes, indeed, these same procedures could be done in a lighter structure: a technical platform for radiology, suturing, or medical analyses, we know that well too. But why today do people go to the emergency room when they could go to consultations? It is not for pleasure, obviously, but almost by reflex, as an obviousness that we have allowed to settle in recent years and most often also for a reason of availability. It is that we no longer find doctors outside the hospital at the end of the day or early in the morning and sometimes for a financial reason: it is that there is no need to pay upfront.

Non-vital emergencies must therefore be able to be managed in the city by professionals organized within their professional community, in connection with their local hospital; they will need to organize collectively to ensure a continuity of non-scheduled care during the day, every day until 8:00 PM.

Initially, I was in favor of saying until 10:00 PM, but I was told that I would open an absolutely impossible war if we said until 10:00 PM, so I am reasonable and I said 8:00 PM, but it would be wonderful if we could find an agreement until 10:00 PM, sincerely. Because when we look at the emergency numbers, there are a lot of them between 8:00 PM and 10:00 PM, so I have trusted the minister, the director of the CNAM, and all the professionals who will have to conduct this negotiation; I am convinced that we can find an intelligent solution until 10:00 PM. But I said until 8:00 PM today.

So it is obvious that doctors will be compensated for this and that it will also be necessary to organize, as in the hospital, the advance of costs for patients; therefore, the system needs to change. I am not saying that we should push people to have the same organization, the same constraints, for this continuity of care. I am telling you that we will indeed push people to better organize themselves, we will support them financially, help them to be better compensated when they organize, that they have medical assistants, and for those who provide continuity of care, that there be a real incentive and thus that we also help them with their equipment and compensation.

In the areas where the situation of hospital emergencies is most critical, I really want this organization of non-scheduled care, as we say, and therefore city emergencies, to be implemented by 2020 at the latest. In parallel, we must make emergency services much more responsive to vital emergencies. Our system, as we have seen, is not always as efficient as it should be and does not guarantee either the quality or the speed of care across all areas of the territory. And on this, I want to say a word for all those who keep our emergency systems running; if we have had cases that have sometimes made headlines, it is not their fault, it is the fault of our organization. If they were not there day and night to already keep the system running, to already ensure every day the excellence of a system as it exists and the ability to endure both the extreme stress of those who present themselves to the emergency room and the quality of that care, we would not even have the luxury of discussing it.

And so they are the first victims of this currently unsatisfactory organization, of which I want to say a word for all those who are either regulators or healthcare staff in our emergencies; they have sometimes been stigmatized in recent debates, it will be up to us to define responsibilities, but if there is a primary responsibility, it is ours; we must not shift the blame onto this or that person.

So this subject is eminently complex; I know that several works are underway, particularly on the unique emergency call number; proposals have been made by representatives of emergency physicians, firefighters, and parliamentarians, and by the end of the year, a decision will be made based on the proposals that will be made in the coming weeks by the ministers of Health and the Interior. But I am well aware of the importance of this subject and the reorganization that we must undertake on this point.

Finally, the third direction I wanted to share with you to build this system around the patient is to guarantee them the quality of care, regardless of where they live in the territory. We must tackle the question of this quality of care without taboos because it is hypocritical to say that it is the same across all of France. A hypocrisy, we know well, is linked to where one lives, to the accidents that may have occurred in the organization of the supply of care, to the network available, to the privileges that can be activated to gain access as quickly as possible or to the best professionals; and thus we have a very French way of addressing the issue of waiting lines, which is that we have organized privileges and parallel systems that work well for those who are best placed in the system, making it viable but which at the very least does not resolve the situation for a very large majority of our fellow citizens.

And on this, we must set things right. Hospitals and local clinics must do much more primary care. Leading establishments must focus on specialized care, and I know that a reflection is underway within your conferences on the future of the hospital-university model, the performance of research, and health innovation to arrive at proposals by your December meetings, which will coincide with the 60th anniversary of the founding act of the CHUs by the so-called Debré ordinances of December 1958. But to put it concretely, I prefer that a patient undergo a major operation 50 kilometers from their home, with the highest level of quality, if they can then do their rehabilitation, their postoperative follow-up as close to home as possible, surrounded by their loved ones in a local establishment. To make them believe that they can have this cutting-edge surgery in their local establishment is false; to make them believe that this local establishment must be closed because it is local is also false, because we need it to organize this offer as close to the ground as possible.

And so, in this regard, each hospital must focus on the care for which it is most relevant. The organization of the activities of the establishments will therefore adapt according to three redefined levels: primary care with general medicine, geriatrics, rehabilitation, non-scheduled care; specialized care with surgery, maternity, specialized medicine; and ultra-specialized care or cutting-edge technical platforms.

For public establishments, this gradation of activities will continue to be organized around hospital groupings of territories that must continue to be developed, but I want this distribution of activities from proximity to ultra-specialty to also concern the private sector so that both public and private establishments can develop shared technical platforms, associate themselves within the framework of a territorial health project to meet the needs of patients without unnecessary and harmful competition.

We still have too many territories today where we block projects for the installation of cutting-edge equipment because there are competitive games between the public and private sectors, where we do not meet needs, where we do not have the right organization; we think we will do everything at all levels until it breaks and we completely close the local structure.

I believe that if we manage to reorganize things around this gradation, these three levels, and we establish this principle, we can usefully advance towards a better quality of care. Thus, certain medical activities will need to be strengthened in proximity when others will need to concentrate in expert establishments. Some activities will need to close in certain places when underutilized technical platforms become dangerous or when the absence of qualified doctors does not allow them to be secured. But these structures can be reused either for primary or first-level services or for postoperative follow-up as close to the family as possible and to also relieve cutting-edge structures during the postoperative period. I do not wish to close a service, an establishment for financial reasons, but I will not keep open a service in which none of you would send your children.

I thus ask the Minister of Health, but I know that consultations have already begun on this subject, to define a modern and attractive status for local hospitals, which must be a priority in the coming months. All establishments will have to reposition themselves and will be concerned by this transformation of the offer, from the smallest local hospital to the large AP-HP, and this work must obviously involve all stakeholders, all care offers – liberal medicine, private, sectors associated with public service – and obviously local elected officials.

Access to quality care also means tackling more strongly non-relevant procedures and evolving the funding model to value the quality of patient pathways. I have already said, I want us to move away from a kind of system that has shown all its limits, which promotes the race for procedures and activity, as embodied today by the famous T2A, in favor of a funding model that promotes prevention, supports cooperation among professionals, and places quality as the primary objective of care. As I committed to, starting in 2019, the financial incentive for quality will be significantly increased in hospital establishments. It will rise from a budget of 60 million euros today to 300 million euros. Furthermore, starting in 2019, we will begin the shift towards a greater proportion of funding based on quality by creating a flat-rate payment for two chronic conditions: diabetes and chronic kidney failure instead of activity-based pricing.

By 2022, this more incentive-based pricing system for pathways and quality of care will have become the main component of funding for both the city and the hospital, and we will have finished with pricing solely focused on activity, whether it is T2A on the one hand or the exclusivity of fee-for-service payment. This access to quality care is also, finally and above all, allowing healthcare personnel to regain a calm working environment and a fair revaluation of their work, particularly in hospitals.

The road will be long to reverse the vicious circle I mentioned earlier. This transformation must be accompanied as closely as possible by the healthcare teams. The hospital, I have said several times, is on the front line of the transformations of the health system and has experienced very strong budgetary pressure in recent years.

In this context, we must question more specifically the working conditions of hospital professionals to restore meaning to their mission and perspectives for their careers. Supporting the pathways of caregivers, their professional projects must become a reality in all hospitals. The management, in particular, of the second halves of careers must become a privileged moment. This is true in all professional fields; it is even more so for caregivers.

This requires reinvesting in social dialogue on work organization and skills development. It will also involve better training for those who accept responsibilities, recognizing through incentive measures the roles of management, whether medical or nursing, whether it concerns the president of the medical establishment commission or local health managers.

Healthcare professionals on the ground expect more flexible, supportive management and expect us to provide the means for this management to do this work. In hospitals, we can train good doctors, good managers; we can also train managers, and I know that the representatives of directors, doctors, and all the staff are convinced of this. Decisions will thus be made to value and compensate new so-called advanced practices for nurses, an essential link in our healthcare teams. This modern form of practice allowing paramedical professionals to be recognized for competencies that are legally the domain of doctors, desired for more than 10 years, is finally possible.

Particular attention will be given to nursing assistants, whose skills and training framework will be updated to better respond to the realities of their practice. Employment conditions in the second half of their careers will be the subject of specific reflection, and I confirm that a financial effort will be implemented, particularly for nursing assistants working in nursing homes.

In terms of hospital organization, things must also be clearer; I want to restore the service to its rightful place, as it is the reference space for caregivers and the place for patient care. Not to restore isolated strongholds; I certainly do not want to enter the much too complex debate for me between services and poles, of which I have understood that I would not be able to grasp the essence, but rather to promote a framework that fosters a sense of belonging to an organized collective whose missions, objectives, and procedures are known and shared.

In listening to many healthcare staff in the hospital, I was struck by one thing: they felt somewhat dispossessed of the evolution of the hospital over the past few years and the recent reforms. Dispossessed because we may have grouped services together in an attempt to create complementarities and moved decisions to the level closest to patients, moved because we created a management administration that has sometimes distanced or disempowered healthcare staff. And sometimes healthcare staff may have also settled into this mindset, considering that if it was like this, they no longer had to be co-actors in the evolution of the hospital. And we may have collectively weakened the strength that is a caring collective to whom we must give all the recognition and responsibilities that go with it.

And so, for this, I want to place the physician at the heart of governance. We need to strengthen the participation of physicians in strategic steering by better associating the Medical Commission (CME) with medical decisions; the CME must have a say in hospital decisions and be able to take its own share of decision-making. Empowering practitioners in the implementation of decisions implies that they feel involved, and for this reason, representatives of professional communities will join the supervisory board of their local hospital partner. Hospital groupings will be equipped with a genuine medical establishment commission whose competencies will be expanded, but I also want physicians and their representatives to take a more active role in the direct decisions of hospitals. And I wish for the possibility already opened to hospital practitioners and PU-PH to lead hospitals to be fully realized during the next appointments and to be more widespread.

We will also need to modernize the status of hospital practitioners to provide more flexibility in career progression and in the diversity of practice modes. Here too, we need to break down barriers; a physician should be able to easily transition from practice in the city to practice in the hospital and vice versa, and especially to combine the two through mixed practice, which should become increasingly common.

In essence, many barriers that we have established over the past decades must fall; we have gradually installed the barrier of limiting the non-direct hospital practice of hospital practitioners or PU-PH. The result is clear: hospital directors or department heads present in this room can say how many positions are to be filled. Thirty years ago, this was unthinkable; unthinkable, the most prestigious positions are no longer filled in hospitals because the ability to organize freely, to weigh in on decisions, to be justly compensated when looking at competitors in the private sector, is no longer there, and therefore we must respond to this through reorganizations, in terms of the ability to decide and participate in decision-making, in terms of the ability to organize by also breaking down the boundary with the organization, with the city, and with private practice.

In this regard, the diversity of medical practice is most often neither valued nor recognized, and it is essential that all the missions of the hospital practitioner—clinical, non-clinical, managerial, institutional, research, teaching, innovation—be statutorily recognized and integrated into service obligations. This is the best guarantee of sustainable involvement in the functioning of the hospital institution.

And this reorganization around quality for quality is all the more essential, whether it concerns hospitals or private structures, as we have a real revolution in terms of innovation to drive. And we will also pursue this in our budgetary and industrial choices. The coming years will be guided by a clear strategy for medication, which was announced last July to professionals. We need to give them visibility, focus our funding on innovation, but we can become—or rather, regain—a great land of innovation in medications. If we give ourselves the means, we can also become one of the champions of artificial intelligence in medicine, medical devices, and the organization of the healthcare system. We have an advantage: our Jacobinism, the concentration of all health information in the same regulated structures, protecting individual interests, is an unparalleled opportunity; only the Chinese, who are less respectful of individual freedoms, have such a centralized organization. Almost no other country has this capacity to cross-reference citizens' health data for therapeutic purposes in a fully monitored framework; it is unprecedented. We have excellence in research in CNRS, INSERM, our university hospitals, private research structures, and biotechnology start-ups; we must seize this revolution today. And it makes the transformation I mentioned around quality even more imperative because it will allow our healthcare professionals, both in hospitals and in private structures, and through this partnership that I want to rebuild, to work together and be the actors, also the co-producers of this collective innovation.

What our health needs is not a miserable discourse; it is a discourse of ambition. We are not going back to 1958; we have to invent the next 50 years of our healthcare system, with the real strengths I have mentioned, the challenges we must meet through collective intelligence and some decisions, but we have to invent a healthcare system that is emerging. We can do it if we give ourselves the means.

So some skeptics may doubt, and I will conclude on this point: why would we succeed today? First, because we are stronger for what we have not succeeded in, and many things have been attempted, perhaps in a piecemeal manner, sometimes blocked, but I believe that today we are at a level of maturity of the observation that is evident. We are at a level of suffering in certain services, in certain parts of our country that is real and tangible. And as I have said several times, I do not believe in purely curative or symptomatic responses; I do not believe that the answer to what we are experiencing in many of our territories is simply to say, put in more money, change nothing in the system, we just need public money, that is the only problem. That is false; it is everything we have just discussed, and I believe that the maturity of all actors, our collective maturity, means that we can do it today, and that it is indeed a bit of this dynamic that has always animated our country.

I have often said it, and I have sometimes been reproached for it: France is not a country that reforms in small steps; that is not its deep social political culture. It is a country that makes great transformations, which make our country a pioneer, a leader in one sector or another, and which then, when difficulties arise, locks itself into the certainty that the great transformation made 30 years earlier was the right one and that it is always right, until the evidence emerges. The evidence is here.

So it is not about making yet another small step, and that is precisely why I believe we can do it and succeed. It is about building a deep transformation that will lead us all to change our reflexes, our habits, and I believe that is what you expect from us and, deep down, from yourselves.

We know where we want to go, and we will get there by investing because we believe that this horizon will allow us to better prevent, to have better quality of care, to have a system centered around the patient.

So I committed to an ONDAM, as we say, of 2.3% for the five-year term, which was a real effort, but proportional to what is asked of local authorities and the State, legitimate, but I am aware that given the transformation we are discussing, we need to invest today to address short-term issues that we know, whether it concerns the situation of hospitals in overseas territories, the AP-HP, the AP-HM, or psychiatric establishments where we know we have emergency situations that will require urgent measures. But we also need to finance, starting next year, the recruitment of medical assistants, the establishment of these professional communities, the remuneration of new advanced practice nurses, and everything I have just mentioned.

That is why we will concentrate an additional part of the future investment plan on health issues and transformation investments, and we have decided to push the ONDAM to 2.5%, thus investing an additional 400 million euros on these priorities for next year.

Beyond this investment, to achieve this, a bill will be necessary to support the evolution of health studies, governance, mixed practice frameworks, and funding modes, and it will be on the agenda for the year 2019 so that innovations and initial measures can begin as early as 2019 through the Social Security financing bill, but so that everything we have discussed can be fully deployed from the end of 2019 and completely by the beginning of 2020.

This is to give you the milestones and clarifications, but beyond this subject, to tell you that this challenge, and I know you are not here to be convinced, is one of the essential challenges for our nation. First, because it is what our fellow citizens expect from us. When we ask the French what matters most to them in their daily lives, health always comes out on top. Then, because it is what is expected of a great nation, and it is what we owe to both patients and those who have dedicated their lives to caring for others.

And so for all these reasons, I hope that the spirit in which you have worked since last February, of cooperation and demand, can be continued in the coming years to achieve the right agreements, the right transformations, simply because I believe it is the right moment, it is time, and we are capable of it.

Thank you.