Transcription of the joint press conference of the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, with Vladimir Putin, President of the Russian Federation in Saint Petersburg.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

24 May 2018 · Joint press conference of Emmanuel Macron and Vladimir Putin · Saint Petersburg

Context
Macron held a joint press conference with Putin at the Saint Petersburg International Economic Forum on May 24, 2018, where France was guest of honor.
Main themes
France-Russia bilateral relations, multilateralism and international cooperation, UN Security Council responsibilities, French foreign policy independence, historical ties between France and Russia, Saint Petersburg Economic Forum, World War II commemoration, European contradictions and reconciliation, dialogue and diplomacy, Peter the Great and shared history
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,228
78th percentile
Sentences
100
63rd percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
15.8
82nd percentile
Syntax
3.40
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 63%62%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

100 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen,

First of all, I want to thank President PUTIN for his hospitality, and indeed, as he has just reported, we have just had a one-on-one exchange, followed by an expanded discussion that was, as is always the case between us, extremely direct and frank, but I must say longer than our teams had initially planned because it was very fruitful and allowed us, I believe I can say, to exchange in depth our visions of our histories and our contemporary duties.

A little over a year ago, we were together in Versailles, and we then walked to see the exhibition on Peter the Great that was organized and told the story of Peter the Great's journey to France to meet Louis XV, since with Louis XIV, it was a missed rendezvous. And here we are today in his city and in a place that is not innocent in light of this history, in this city of Saint Petersburg that he wanted as a window to Europe, where he brought many artists and intellectuals of his time, as Catherine II would later do as well.

And this place, this city, I believe, reminds us of what binds us very deeply, and that is also why when in 1966, General de GAULLE wanted to come and deliver a great speech and make a significant political gesture, he chose Saint Petersburg to pay tribute to the heroic resistance of Soviet soldiers and Russian civilians besieged by the Hitlerian army. And tomorrow, I too will go to the necropolis to pay tribute to the soldiers who fought and fell, but also to the civilians and all the victims of the siege of Leningrad during World War II.

The Normandie-Niemen squadron had a motto, and it is never far from our minds when we think of these moments in history. We flew in the same sky. And that is also part of what this is about, thinking also of the few French fighters who stood alongside your city and your people. Your city, Mr. President, because Saint Petersburg is indeed the city that saw you born, grow, study, and administer, and which today brings us together on the occasion of this International Economic Forum to which France is indeed participating this year as the guest of honor alongside Japan, and I want to thank you for this invitation.

And in doing so, we continue the historical thread in which we have chosen to frame our exchanges, and I am convinced that our two countries have the vocation and interest to define, to borrow the words of DOSTOEVSKY that we were discussing earlier in his speech on PUSHKIN, a true ground for reconciliation for all European contradictions. This is undoubtedly part of what we are talking about when we speak of the relationship between our two countries. We have all the European contradictions that inhabit our peoples to address, but we know, and we have known in the past – and we will know it tomorrow as well – how to build a true ground for reconciliation.

We have a historical partnership; it is there, and it is strong, and France and Russia have in common that they have inherited from their predecessors a special place, that of a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. And this special place in the times we are living in obliges us, and we discussed this with President PUTIN. It obliges us because I believe that today, we have no other choice but to believe in and defend what I called a few weeks ago a strong multilateralism, that is to say, a grammar of our international relations that believes in cooperation, that believes in the rules we have set for ourselves, that wants to respect them, but that considers that these rules are not simply words that would apply to the weaker or those who do not know how to enforce them.

This responsibility that is ours implies a constructed, constant dialogue and independence. And President PUTIN knows it; France's foreign policy, under my direction, is fully independent. We never align ourselves with anyone; we make our decisions for ourselves and by ourselves; we believe in Europe to amplify its strength; we also wish that these decisions, when taken, can be respected while taking into account the interests of our partners. And our dialogue with Russia is an element of this independence, as is our belonging to a democratic and sovereign Europe, as is the relationship we also have with our ally, the United States of America, and this is constitutive of the strong multilateralism I mentioned.

We speak to everyone, and that is the mark of our independence. We do so in a direct and frank manner; that is the mark of our reliability. I am very aware of the misunderstandings that may have existed and settled between us. A part of these misunderstandings, I must say even the essential part, is not attributable to us, but they are there, and we must therefore know how to return to them. We know the terms of the debate, but I wish here that we could move forward together, and from our first exchanges with President PUTIN, it is on this basis that we wished to work.

This strong multilateralism, this independence of French foreign policy also goes hand in hand with a few principles that I believe in. I believe that we must work, that it is in our joint interest, to defend our collective security, that we must also defend our values everywhere, but that we must also respect the sovereignty of peoples everywhere, and I clearly oppose any pretension to want to substitute ourselves for their choices. And on this ground, I have been clear from day one; France takes positions, it builds alliances, it can intervene when the non-respect is evident regarding certain rules that had been established with real international legitimacy, but never to substitute itself for the sovereignty of a people.

I also respect the enhanced role that Russia is taking in its regional environment and in the world, particularly in the Middle East. And with this regained role comes also greater responsibility, and I am fully aware, and I know that President PUTIN has it in mind. At the same time – and the President knows it – I expect Russia to also respect our interests, our sovereignty, that of our European partners with whom our solidarity will always be unwavering, and we have also discussed this. I believe that we can collectively move forward.

Ultimately, what we need today, given our history, this moment, and the rules we have set and the interests that are ours, is to continue to build a common trust, and I wish for my part that Russia understands that France is its credible, open, and reliable European partner for preparing the future. And I believe that the discussion we had went in this direction. I proposed to President PUTIN to engage with France in the definition of this strong multilateralism that should allow us to lay the foundations of the contemporary world order, a multilateralism that is no longer the empty shell of ideological confrontations, but that produces results on clear bases and allows for concrete solutions. This is in the interest of our countries and, I believe, what also drives us.

It is with these principles and in this spirit that we approached the major international issues that President PUTIN has just revisited. On the Iranian issue, the three European signatory countries, as well as High Representative MOGHERINI, clearly stated from the American decision that we would remain in the agreement and that the agreement of July 14, 2015, was for us an agreement that we signed and that we must respect. And I wish for all signatories to remain in the agreement and preserve it. Thus, we decided last week in Sofia, at the European level, to equip ourselves with the instruments and guarantees for companies to ensure the full effectiveness in all respects, including economically, of this agreement. But I also wish that we could work with all those who have an interest in ensuring that this effectiveness is full and complete and that our companies can also find pragmatic solutions with other countries and other companies that have an interest, as some companies have indeed done in recent days, to preserve their interests when they are very exposed to the United States, to the American market, but that we can guarantee Iran the viability of the projects that have been launched.

At the same time, I wish for Iran to remain fully committed to the nuclear agreement and not to resume any activity. In this regard, I consider that the latest information transmitted by the IAEA goes in the right direction and is reassuring. I told President PUTIN this desire; I believe we share it, and we both acknowledged this common will to preserve this framework that seems useful to us for regional security. I also told President PUTIN what our other concerns were, and I believe I can also say that we share them: nuclear activity after 2025, ballistic activity, and Iran's regional activity. I wish that we could engage with Iran – and I have had the opportunity to say this twice to President ROHANI – in a dialogue on these subjects. But it is clear that this dialogue is only possible if we can collectively arrange this credible framework of the 2015 agreement, which we are in the process of doing.

And so I believe it is consistent that we work together regarding Iran to engage right now in a frank, sincere, but essential dialogue for regional security that allows us to advance on all these subjects. You received the Israeli Prime Minister a few days ago; I think he also spoke to you about it. We both know all the friendly, allied, or respected powers in the region. They do not necessarily have the same reading as we do of the situation, but we cannot underestimate their concerns and interests. And so, to avoid any escalation, our will is to build this broader agreement in the region with Iran and to work together to do so.

In Syria, the intensification of tensions between Israel and Iran also demonstrates the risk of a large-scale escalation. The time has clearly come to bring all the powers concerned by the Syrian crisis to the table to achieve a political resolution of the conflict. President PUTIN said it; there are today two formats that exist: the so-called Astana Format and the so-called Small Group Format that we constituted a few months ago. These two formats are complementary, and on the Syrian issue, I have always been clear; our priority, our will, is the eradication of terrorism and the fight against Islamist terrorism. And even though we have made very clear decisions and always had clear positions regarding Bashar EL-ASSAD and his policy, the French policy is not to proceed from the outside with any regime change or transition. Since May 2017, our policy has been to build an inclusive political solution that will allow the constitutional framework to be developed, which will allow all the Syrian people, including Syrians who had to flee, to vote and choose their rulers.

This is the endpoint of the political process that is ours, and I believe I can say that our discussion in this regard was extremely instructive, at least for me. And so we wished, as President PUTIN said, to establish a coordination mechanism between the Astana group and the Small Group. This is a very important advance in terms of managing the Syrian dossier for me. We can have different sensitivities, of course, but we have a shared will for stabilization, a shared respect for the sovereignty of peoples, a shared desire to bring the dossier to a conclusion while being inclusive and building long-term stability. And so this coordination mechanism, our teams will build it in the coming weeks, but its purpose will be to have a parallel but common agenda for discussions for both groups and to build together – and this will also be our responsibility – the convergences that will allow, I hope, this political solution. In any case, I believe a lot in this option that I have been calling for for several months, and I must say I am extremely satisfied with the progress of our discussion in this regard.

I also proposed to President Putin that we could work concretely together on the ground in humanitarian terms. Indeed, I decided a few weeks ago, at the end of April, to reinvest in humanitarian engagement and in particular to reinvest 50 million euros to finance non-governmental organizations present on Syrian soil. On this subject, we will work in the northwest and northeast with these organizations, and I wished for us to do so in close coordination, including in the area that is under the control of the Syrian regime, to do it closely with Russia. I believe this is what you have also been wishing for over the past few months, and that this progress is also likely to make us collectively useful on the ground and allow these non-governmental organizations to work better and access the populations with the most severe needs.

Regarding the fight against terrorism in Syria, the coalition is completing the reduction of the last strongholds of Daesh, and we agree that in the decisions we make regarding Syria, the need to prevent any resurgence of this organization must be fully taken into account. On chemical weapons, we have disagreements; we know them, we have shared them, but I wish for us to work on an international level to establish a new independent, impartial, and permanent mechanism that allows for the attribution of responsibility for the use of chemical weapons, and that the coming months can be usefully contributed to this point.

Finally, on the situation in Ukraine, the peaceful resolution of the crisis in Donbass is the key element for a return to calm relations between Europe and Russia, which is in all our interests. I told President Putin that the coming months would be decisive if we want to end this conflict. The President just said it; there is no other solution than the implementation of the Minsk Agreements by all parties based on the very concrete proposals we made with Germany. There will be a meeting of the technical groups in the coming weeks, followed by a meeting of the foreign ministers in the Normandy Format, and I hope we can find concrete progress on this point as well.

In terms of the bilateral relationship, we have – and President Putin also mentioned it – discussed the always sensitive issue of activity in cyberspace and cyberattacks, and we both wished to inaugurate a process that until now did not exist but that we will implement for the exchange of information and very concrete handling of situations to build a common framework that allows us to regulate this cyberspace already between our two countries and with the ambition of trying to work with our partners on this absolutely crucial issue.

We have a very vibrant economic relationship, as the President recalled, which makes France one of the very first economic partners in terms of employment as well as investment and undoubtedly the most reliable economic partner over time, even in the most difficult times. Tomorrow at the St. Petersburg Forum, the French delegation will be very significant, proof that our companies are present and wish to support the economic and social modernization of Russia, the diversification of its economy, its scientific and technological development, and continue to play this role of the leading foreign employer in the country. And despite the sanctions, despite the difficulties, they are present, as are our researchers, our artists, our thinkers, and I believe this presence is essential.

We have also noted the very good progress of the work we launched a year ago. We have made significant progress. The Trianon Dialogue, which is this forum in which we wanted to bring together representatives of civil society, the academic and cultural world. Intellectuals and scientists have worked actively. It has allowed for renewed exchanges between our civil societies. Two digital platforms have been launched in France and Russia to facilitate the circulation of initiatives and ideas, and the French and Russian members of the Coordination Council of the Dialogue will meet together for the first time physically during this visit tomorrow. This is an important result for developing these ties, and it has also allowed several young French people to be selected as part of a competition and to discover your country, which also forges these relationships over time.

Today and tomorrow, we are formalizing several agreements, a total of about fifty framework agreements. And beyond the business agreements signed in front of us, agreements from our major research actors, regardless of the sector, space, civil nuclear, energy are being highlighted alongside sciences, research, culture, heritage, higher education, with the creation of new dual degrees for our students in St. Petersburg, right here. The year 2018 is also the Year of Languages and Literatures marked by the success of the Paris Live Salon, which follows the Year of Cultural Tourism in 2017, with the immense success of several exhibitions dedicated to the CHTCHOUKINE collection in Paris and St. Louis and the Relics of the Sainte-Chapelle at the Kremlin Museum in Moscow.

It is also culture that we have come here to support within the framework of this Dialogue, including with the Minister. We will be there tomorrow to celebrate the anniversary of Mr. Petipa, whom many people in Russia think is French, or rather Russian, but he was above all French and from Marseille, I must say, but he played an essential role, because Russia trusted him, particularly at the Mariinsky and in the creation of many ballets that have forged our common cultural history, our identity.

On all these subjects, we wish to continue to work together, continue to dialogue, continue to advance, and it is in this demanding but willing dialogue that we wish, with President Putin, to outline a bit of this century that is opening up. French children have learned about the vastness of Russian territory by reading "Michel Strogoff," they have sometimes been scared listening to "Peter and the Wolf," they have dreamed thanks to the ballets of Marius Petipa. There are many people when traveling in the cities of the Volga, asking visitors about the hotels where the author of "The Three Musketeers" stayed. Russian heroes have inhabited the French imagination, and Dostoevsky would probably not have been himself without the influence of France and French authors.

All this cultural history is what obliges us because our imaginations are common; they are European, they are European. And it is especially when history becomes complicated that we must try to make it simple, to know where we come from, to acknowledge disagreements, but to seek to act. And so I wish that France and Russia of tomorrow will live up to their history to, in this uncertain world, build their destiny. Thank you, Mr. President, dear Vladimir.