Speech by President Javier Milei at the closing of the IAEF Congress

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

21 May 2024 · IAEF Congress

Context
Milei addressed the IAEF Congress closing session in Argentina on May 21, 2024, presenting his government's theoretical framework for dollarization.
Main themes
Endogenous dollarization, monetary theory, general equilibrium models, critique of Keynesianism, nominal anchor, nature and functions of money, barter economy, relative prices, Argentina's economic reform, currency stabilization policy
Duration
~79 min
97th percentile
Words
9,505
97th percentile
Sentences
395
97th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 91%90%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

395 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Good afternoon. Thank you to everyone present here. Thank you IAEF for the invitation and above all for allowing me to fulfill my word, that I said that if I were president, I would return. So in that sense, thank you all. Basically, the talk I have prepared is about our model towards dollarization, which technically would be called endogenous dollarization. In this sense, the talk will have three parts: the first part relates to the nature of money, because it seems that some economists have essentially forgotten where money came from, how money appeared, what the functions of money are, because this has very strong characteristics and implications in terms of how one thinks about the existence of money and its incorporation into the economy. Once I have closed that conceptual issue, the second part of the talk will deal with the inclusion of money within a general equilibrium model, how an economy functions with this, and there I will also pause on something that economists are supposed to know but do not know - and I know this - which is the problem of the nominal anchor. In this way, I will discuss different ways of how to anchor the price level. And finally, I will be addressing our concept of endogenous dollarization. Obviously, to explain the issue of endogenous dollarization, what has to do with the timing, the steps, and so on, relates to the enormous task being carried out by Toto Caputo, Pablo Quirno, Santiago Bausili, and all their team, which is a true luxury and an honor to have such professionals working with me to move this country forward.

In that sense, if there were no money, we would be what is called a barter economy. Now, in a barter economy, you derive demand functions, but there is something that is very important because this has to do with the intellectual contamination generated by Keynesianism, because, basically, Keynes, who was not an economist and who had only taken a 6-month economics course with Alfred Marshall, did not understand the difference between general equilibrium models and partial equilibrium models. Basically, when one takes a microeconomics course, in the first microeconomics course one takes and when one starts the first part of a microeconomics course in general - the newest textbooks are a little different - but basically it starts with consumer theory and from there the demand curves are derived. In general, those demand curves will depend on all prices and income. But that is in partial equilibrium, that is not in general equilibrium; extending that idea of putting income in the demand function in a general equilibrium model is a gross conceptual error. That is to say, when you are thinking about a general equilibrium model, you have to incorporate the fact that your income will depend in a barter economy on how you sell and exchange your endowments, or in an economy that incorporates production, the possibility that you work, that is, that you sell your leisure in the labor market and in exchange receive a salary. What happens? By only considering all the prices in the economy, in the derivation of the system of quantities you will determine how much you will receive for selling your endowments, how much you will receive for selling leisure in the labor market, and when you will receive profits based on the shares you have in firms. Therefore, those demand functions will only consider prices. And the same applies to supply functions. Therefore, the excess demand functions of a general equilibrium model have two characteristics: first, that no quantity indicator appears, income never appears, it never appears. And, in addition, those functions are homogeneous of degree zero. That is to say, they depend on relative prices. And that also has a mathematical counterpart which is the idea of the aggregate budget constraint, you can look at it that way or as the law of the market: if N minus one market is in equilibrium, the remaining one is too. Therefore, the system cannot be determined, the solution, the equilibrium price vector cannot be determined in absolute terms, relative prices are determined. That is the first point. Now, the first thing to be clear about is that in no way can a model called general equilibrium contemplate income in the behavioral functions. I mean, that is a technical aberration. So, when some economist comes and tells you that they are doing general equilibrium and they put income in a behavioral equation, start to distrust.

The second, another aberration that Keynes committed, all these things are in a book of mine called ‘Unmasking the Keynesian Lie’; the other issue is the interest rate. That is to say, when you see an economist who tells you that they are doing intertemporal general equilibrium, well, first check if the model is truly intertemporal, because it is probably a single-period model. If it is a single-period model, the interest rate makes no sense as a criterion. The interest rate exists because time exists, not because there is a Central Bank setting the interest rate. The interest rate has to do with the fact of transferring consumption from the present to the future and vice versa or if you decide to invest and then transfer production from the present to the future, for example. That is to say, the interest rate exists independently of whether money exists; it exists because time exists. And moreover, the interest rate is not just anything. In reality, the interest rate is basically the relative price of present goods in terms of future goods. That is the interest rate. That is why when in some texts, not all, when you can determine the interest rate, which is also called the Wicksellian interest rate, it is determined by the interaction of saving and investment. Now what is saving? Saving is future consumption. So, when the interest rate rises, it means that present goods are more expensive than future goods. Therefore, what will you substitute?: present consumption for future consumption. That is why, when the interest rate rises, saving increases. At the same time, if the interest rate were to fall, it means that future prices are higher than present prices. In that context, what would be convenient for a company to do? Instead of selling today, sell more tomorrow. What is that called, that transfer of production from today to tomorrow? That is called investment. And there you have the traditional upward-sloping saving curves in interest rates, downward-sloping investment curves in interest rates, and that interaction determines the interest rate. And the interest rate is an intertemporal coordination mechanism that has nothing to do with the existence of money. Therefore, when you find an economist who takes and puts the interest rate and income, distrust them because they are a fool. First reflection on this.

Therefore, when I construct the excess demand functions, if you have all present prices and all future prices of goods, that will be a general equilibrium model with intertemporal characteristics. And basically what you will find is the equilibrium that is when the interest rate is the same for all, then the model that is matched in present and future terms, and that can be again without the existence of money, I do not need money to be there. Now, money exists for another reason, not to determine the interest rate. Basically, the barter economy has two problems: the first problem it has is the double coincidence. Suppose I want to buy bread, but there is no baker who wants to buy my services as an economist. Well, maybe I buy my services indirectly by voting for myself to be president. I don’t know what exchange I would have preferred. Aside from that, well yes, if I lived off the State, surely not, I’m costing him too much. So, in that sense, what is the problem? I have to find someone, a baker who wants to sell bread to me in exchange for me giving him economics talks. Which is a bit complicated, especially in an extended society. And even so, there is a problem that, when I solve the double coincidence problem, I have another problem which is indivisibility: because I might only need one kilo of bread, that is, I am not going to give an economics talk for one kilo of bread. So, there appears an indivisibility and what I would give for a talk for that kilo of bread is also useless, because it has that indivisibility. So, in an economy where these problems arise, many exchanges start to be lost and the level of well-being falls substantially. From that, man did not start to cry or see that the State would fix his life; no, no, man created money. What did man discover?: that there were goods that were exchanged much more than others. So what did he do: he started to look for those goods, not to consume those goods per se, but basically to exchange them later for the good he needed. That is, the emergence of money is actually an indirect exchange good. So, for example, when man was nomadic, the first type of money that appeared was livestock. Why? Because basically people moved with livestock. So, the first type of money that appeared was livestock. When man became sedentary, then other types of products began to appear, for example, people ate a lot of bread, so the indirect exchange good that was most traded in an economy was what? Wheat. They did not buy or sell wheat because they wanted wheat per se, but because it was basically the one that was most exchanged. In other societies, linen was used, in others tobacco was used, there were different types of models of products that were used as money. But basically it is an indirect exchange good. This is fundamental because it is not that you demand it because you want to have it, but that you use it to make transactions. This is not a minor issue regarding how one has to think about money. Now what happens? One of the problems that, while it could serve as a unit of account and for making transactions, you had another problem, which was not a store of value. That is to say, over time those goods had: a negative interest rate, over time they were worth less. It’s like an ice cream: if you do not eat the ice cream in time, what is the interest rate of the ice cream? Negative, it will melt in your hand.

So, faced with that situation, to correct the problem of the store of value, metals began to be used. And there basically two metals imposed themselves: gold for large transactions and silver for smaller transactions. Now there is a character from a comic that I particularly love, which is Zorro, Zorro is a great character as a character because he was a fabulous anarcho-capitalist, because what was the plot of Zorro about?: Zorro had two types of enemies: obviously Monasterio and all his soldiers, that is, the State, who came and took resources to take them to Spain… well, just today I mention Spain. I already have match point with Pedrito. Despite what the progressive media says. That is the first point and the second point was the city, it was close to the port and there were many thieves who robbed. Imagine that you are going to make an exchange, what do you carry with you: money, gold. Nothing is like carrying a label that says “rob me, rob me, rob me.” So, they attacked him, everything and Zorro not only fought with the State’s thugs, but also fought with whom? With the thieves. Because in reality, if the thieves won, what was the problem? There was less commerce and, therefore, the quality of life decreased, that is, the Heckscher-Ohlin worked perfectly there. That is to say, Zorro took care of making Heckscher-Ohlin work.

So, in that sense, basically what appeared then, what was it? Certificates for gold and silver that were deposited in institutions, which later came to be called banks. So they were kept there, and then you would issue against those papers, and then the other party would go and cancel it; there was a clearing system, until who got involved? The State. But well, that is part of another story. So, this is what implied the emergence of money, but we must not forget the fundamental element, that money remains an indirect means of exchange, it is a derived demand: it exists as a counterpart to the intertemporal consumption path that you want to access, it serves for that. That is to say, no one takes pesos or whatever to the wooden suit, no one takes all that to the junk, it is useless, on the other side it does not buy. In other words, it does not buy at all. So, fundamentally, that is why money exists, but money has that characteristic. That is to say, it is more of an inheritance, as Professor De Pablo would say, it is a calculation error. So, in that sense, now we find ourselves in a general equilibrium model, we have already seen the characteristics of a general equilibrium model, whose excess demand functions are homogeneous of degree zero, there are only prices, the prices of present goods, the prices of future goods, the relative price relationship between present and future goods of each type of good must be mapped so that the entire model is arbitrated at a unique interest rate, which is what is called the Wicksellian interest rate and which coordinates intertemporally the economy between the present and the future. That said, when you incorporate money into that general equilibrium system with N minus one equations being in equilibrium, the remaining marked one is also in equilibrium and you could only determine N minus one price; now by incorporating one more excess demand equation, you can determine one more price. And if you determine that money is the numeraire, that is, that it has a price of one, you exchange 10 bills of 100 for one of 1000. In other words, there is no… except when there is a problem of a lot of cash circulating, but setting aside the anomalies, you exchange it for a relationship that the number gives the same. In other words, that price is one. This is called numeraire and this allows all prices in the economy to be ordered in terms of nominal scale. That is to say, you have determined the amount of money with the numeraire which is the price 1 and, therefore, all nominal prices within the system are determined and the system can be solved.

Under those characteristics, this is interesting, because if I have that the demand for money, then it is a derived demand and it is a derived demand from all the excess demand functions that are in the rest of the system, it has the same characteristics as the functions of the system that I have up there. Therefore, and that depends on what? It depends on what are called the deep parameters, I would say Robert Lucas Jr., may he rest in peace; that is to say, it depends on preferences, it depends on technology, and it depends on endowments. That is to say, they are very hard parameters, unless you have some hypothesis by which you are going to determine the technological path, but if you want to determine the model you have to do it and it is like making a linear combination, it is not a problem to solve that. In that sense, it means that the real demand for money, under normal conditions of pressure and temperature, to put it in some way, is a granite issue, it is practically a constant that has to do with the path, that is, the real demand for money function depends on the consumption path throughout history, from today until the end of humanity, so to speak. And that, basically, is an absolutely granite issue. And that in equilibrium is equal to real balances, that is, the nominal amount of money divided by the price level. Therefore, given the real demand for money when the Central Bank determines the amount of money, what it is doing is determining the nominal scale of the economy and, therefore, determines the price level. That is to say, it determines that system all the prices of the economy. Hence the monetary nature of inflation. Why? Because to the extent that you increase the amount of money, you are modifying the nominal scale of the economy and consequently modifying the price level. Hence the famous phrase by Milton Friedman: inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. So, moreover, in real life there is no such thing as the neutrality of money; basically, why is there no such thing as the neutrality of money? Because for the idea of the neutrality of money to hold, I modify the amount of money and that has no impact on the real side of the economy, except on the price level. For that to hold, two assumptions must be met: the first assumption is that there is only one good, now, if there is only one good there, that economy has no intertemporal nature, because if I have only one good, how do I differentiate between today's goods and future goods even if it were the same good? The same good today or tomorrow is not the same. So, there I have that assumption. And I also need another assumption, to have the representative agent: that everyone has the same preferences, so that when I throw money at them, they all react in the same way. And that there are also no redistributive effects from including money. So, if I assume one agent, one good, one period, and of course, when I increase the amount of money, everything goes to price, because I am not giving the possibility of relative price changes.

Thus, if there is something that the Central Bank can do, the only thing it can do is harm. Therefore, the best thing the Central Bank can do is nothing. And if the best thing the Central Bank can do is nothing, it is better not to have it, because a political criminal may always appear who wants to use it to defraud people. If not, look at what has happened with Argentina's monetary history since 1935 onwards. Therefore, what is important is what is called the Hume-Cantillon effect, which has to do with the way in which money enters the economy and how it changes relative prices in the process. This is not a minor issue because if there is something that also produces a huge annoyance for me is when they talk about pass-through. In reality, inflation is always everywhere a monetary phenomenon, which occurs due to an excess supply of money; when that excess supply of money is generated, whether because the supply increased or because the demand fell, or both things happened at the same time, money loses purchasing power, and all prices in monetary units rise. Now, what happens: since the dollar is a financial asset, it rises first and then the other prices rise. The best expression of that, or the best explanation is what is called the Hume-Cantillon effect, and that can be done and can be looked at with the exchange rate, money and how they move. So, let’s suppose, for example, a shock in which the demand for money falls, people now want to get rid of money. How does the fall in the demand for money generally act in Argentina? I demand less money and start demanding dollars. So, the price of the foreign currency rises, the price of the dollar rises, the exchange rate rises, I have a devaluation. Behind that, the price of tradables rises, behind that, wholesale prices rise, behind that, retail prices rise, and finally, wages rise. That is to say, in the process I generate a brutal redistribution of income in favor of the tradable sector and to the detriment of the non-tradable sector, further back in the queue, which is labor. Therefore, there you have what pass-through, there is no pass-through, it is a problem of the dynamics of how prices adjust. That is to say, the analysis of pass-through is an abuse of the use of mathematics. I love it when an economist comes and says: “Well, what happens is that the pass-through is much higher when there is higher inflation and is lower when inflation is lower.” Obviously, it is a problem of abuse in statistics. That is one case. The other case is when the excess supply is generated by an impulse to supply. So, you now inject money, what is going to happen: first, retail prices will rise, at the same time that retail prices rise, wages also rise. This causes external accounts to deteriorate and, at the same time, wholesale prices also rise, and after that they end up devaluing. That is to say, notice that there the pass-through, then works in reverse. How does it work, how do you explain it? Besides, imagine that you generate a problem due to the excess supply of pesos and then after you devalue due to that excess supply of pesos, you say: “Well, now I have to correct the real exchange rate, because actually looking at that number…” What? I say for you to see the number of errors that are made analytically.

So, now let’s go to the problem, now we enter the second part, which is the problem of the nominal anchor. The nominal anchor basically has four ways to determine the nominal anchor: one is to fix the amount of money. If I know that real balances, that is, the amount of money divided by the price level is equal to the real demand for money, and that under normal conditions is a fixed number, the price level will be determined by the quotient between the amount of money and the demand for money. As I increase the amount of money, that will generate a higher price level. Now, if you also do this systematically, as you will be generating inflation permanently, that will make it even worse because then it will cause the nominal interest rate to now scale with inflation, and that will force not only to have higher inflation, but also in the middle with the fall in the demand for money due to higher inflation you have a jump in the price level. Therefore, in the end, you have less real balances in the economy; therefore, you have less of one good; therefore, you are worse off. So not only is money not neutral, but it is also not super neutral and when you do this, as you also generate redistributive effects, you affect savings and investment decisions. And when you do that, you modify the interest rate and when you modify the interest rate, you modify the capital structure. And when you do that, you also modify all the demand for labor. So, of course, when you end up making an expansive effect and left the entire structure of the economy unbalanced, the day you stabilize you will break capital on one side, on another and it will have to be recomposed on another side. Consequently, in the transition, yes, you will generate unemployment. Because now that we are lowering inflation, now what is the problem? Yes, unemployment is generated. And of course, obviously, if we are cleaning up the mess that was made over the last 20 years, not to say since 1935 onwards.

So, that is the case of the nominal anchor when you fix the amount of money. So, if I fix the amount of money, what I am doing is determining the price level, and if I was coming from issuing, we were at 28 points of GDP and 3 in the last year and of course the day you fix the amount of money, what is going to happen? With all the lags you are going to have, yes, you are going to have inflation. Yes, of course, and yes, because it has to do with the lags, all prices are readjusting in light of the monetary disaster that was made in the last four years, especially in the last year, where the equivalent of 13 points of GDP was issued directly and indirectly. Now, there is another way to anchor the price level, which is by fixing the exchange rate, which has been the most regularly used in Argentina. And, in fact, the most successful program in Argentine history was convertibility, which was basically anchoring the exchange rate. When you fix the exchange rate, given that we are a small country - for now, embracing the ideas of freedom we will return to being a big country, but for now it is worth the assumption of a small country - you will have the international price level given. Therefore, given the exchange rate, given the international prices, that determines the local price level. And, obviously, given those two things that are fixed, the local price level must also be fixed. And if I have fixed the price level and the demand for money, therefore what comes out by default? What comes out endogenously?: the amount of money, the amount of money within the economy will be basically determined by the demand for money. That is why, the one who best explains this, who has the most clarity on this is Arriazu, one of the people who best understands this, because it is determined endogenously and, basically, only when you issue against the demand for money is that it is not inflationary, or at least does not generate a loss of purchasing power for money. These are ways of looking at it, for me the problem is seigniorage. But beyond that, the point is that if you issue against the demand for money you do not have inflation problems, so to speak.

And this was seen very clearly in convertibility, because you basically issued against the demand for money, and what that allowed was for prices to drop quickly. Still, now afterwards… well yes, I’ll do it now: there are differences between the program we are implementing and convertibility, because basically convertibility, it is true, reduced inflation faster than we did, that is one point, I do not deny it, but basically some things happened in between. Before convertibility, there were two hyperinflations, the one under Alfonsín, roughly 5000% wholesale, and the one under Menem after the Bunge & Born plan and the Erman plan, I don’t know how many versions there were, there were two hyperinflations. That is not minor, because what that does is destroy the monetary aggregates. Therefore, any scheme that you set the exchange rate, what happens? You had a lot of demand for money going forward, which means that this very dynamic of the demand for money would help you anchor the price level. Regardless of the fact that you fixed the exchange rate. That is the first point. The second is one of the things we are doing and it seems that many overlook, is that we are stabilizing without violating property rights. The work of Mr. Quirno, who is here, and the work of Mr. Bausili, - I don’t know if he is here, where did they leave Santiago? - basically they are doing it without violating property rights. Because perhaps you don’t remember, you were kids, but there was something called the Bonex plan and, in fact, a bunch of lying econochantas kept saying that we were going to expropriate, and the most interesting thing is that we are taking longer in stabilization, basically because we have decided not to expropriate. And we also cannot determine when we will finish this process, because as it is a market process and the market is the decision of individuals, we depend on how individuals decide. Therefore, we cannot determine the speed of the day. What day do you open the cepo? I don’t know. Because as we are doing it in the market, it is determined by the people, is that clear? And, moreover, we do not set any price, such as the exchange rate, and we also did not call the businessmen to not touch the prices. By the way, yes, we make a huge effort and Toto works enormously on that, going and explaining to everyone: “Hey, the nominal scale was not that, it is another.” And you, that no one questions that they believed that the nominal scale was going to be another. If there were beasts who said that the exchange rate was going to be 10,000, there was one who said “no because it dollarizes it will do it at $7000.” I mean, where was the one who said that account? Luckily, he got few votes and almost disappeared, he is one of the people with the most negative image, with whom he made the account, do you know who made the account?

That is another of the models. Another way you can do it is with what is called the commodity standard, the commodity standard is fixing the price level. So, evidently fixing the price level, given the demand for money, obviously the money remains endogenous, in the methodology or terminology of Olivera it is called the commodity standard, this scheme is useful to think if you have a dirigiste mindset and in that dirigiste mindset you want to control prices. That is to say, for those who like to control prices this model is tailor-made, because what does it do? It fixes prices. In fact, the Austral Plan one of the things it did was not only fix the exchange rate, but it also fixed what else?: it implemented price controls and, in fact, convertibility fixed the exchange rate, it did it by law and they also called the businessmen to understand that that was the exchange rate. None of those things, we do none. So, now you between the price level and the demand for money, will determine then the amount of money in the economy. Then there is another model, which is when you fix the amount of money looking at wages. Obviously, it is called the labor standard and basically assumes a concentrated market structure, so that prices are a markup of wages. So, once you determine the markup of wages, you determine prices, given the prices and given the amount of money—excuse me—the demand for money, the amount of money is determined. That is to say, the amount of money also remains endogenous. This model combined with the previous one, or in some combination with the previous one, either the commodity standard or the labor standard, between those two is often used for what are the models of distributive struggle.

Now, the important thing is to understand that inflation in all these models remains a monetary phenomenon. Because basically, whether prices went up, or wages went up, as wages went up then prices go up, that is what triggers endogenous money, which in the endogenous money models that are usually studied in Argentina, like by Walras' law, N minus one market is in equilibrium, the remaining one is, it omits the money market. But that does not mean it is not a monetary phenomenon, it is a monetary phenomenon, because in fact endogenously the model validates monetarily all the time. Therefore, those who talk about multi-causal inflation using these models are also other fools and I won’t even count if they grab and say that a gap of 60% is fine and then complain about the cepo. We all know who I am talking about. So there you have all the models, basically of nominal anchor. Moreover, inflation targeting has a problem, what is it? It has no nominal anchor, which is what in Olivera's terminology is called credit standard. There you have two types of problems; there is a problem that in a general equilibrium model that does not make sense because, look, we agree that Moreno was a villain, hey, come on, good, okay, thanks, if we didn’t have to take out the GPS. Well, wanting to control the interest rate is worse, because it means that I want to control not only present goods, as Moreno did, but I also want to control future goods and believing that I will hit the Wicksellian rate implies a truly monstrous level of arrogance. Well, the problem of inflation targeting, first that, again, the interest rate we saw that it did not have, so it is a Keynesian wash, in a strange model, that has nothing to do with the general equilibrium model and if you do that, what is the problem? You need to control all prices now and, moreover, no, in the logic of that model you cannot anchor the amount of money because the logic of that model, as they determine the interest rate in the money market, which is a monstrosity, in the money market the purchasing power of money is determined, but given that Keynesian monstrosity, the problem is that you cannot determine the amount of money, because it is determined endogenously. So, how do you do it, how do you anchor the model? Basically what you need is to have expectations anchored. So, when you have expectations anchored, given the present prices you can determine the future ones, with that you determine the demand for money, by determining the demand for money the nominal amount of money is determined and given that, you determine the price level. That yes, you have to have expectations anchored, lest suddenly a fool called Chief of Cabinet appears and, for political reasons wants to modify the interest rate because he doesn’t like it, and ends up sending everything to hell and causing a government to lose elections. We know who I am talking about too, you know who I am talking about.

So, but this is the important thing, to understand the role of the nominal anchor, because if we do not understand the problem of the nominal anchor, we do not know what we are talking about, we do not understand the nature of stabilization. Because, now yes, what I am going to do is, I am going to get into what we are doing and how we are heading towards endogenous dollarization. Basically when we arrived, I know it by heart I don’t know why I brought my glasses, but when we arrived we found twin deficits of 17 points of GDP. You know that four points of GDP is a yellow light, eight we got a punch, imagine 17, I mean, the punch was here. Not only that, but of those 17 points, 15 were explained by the fiscal deficit, where five were in the treasury and 10 were in the Central Bank. That is to say, the quasi-fiscal deficit, that is what the Central Bank generated, generated 10 points of deficit. This is not a minor point, because when you build a stabilization program it has three elements, it has a fiscal adjustment, it has a monetary adjustment which in our case is the cleaning of the Central Bank's balance sheet and it has a currency issue. We made an adjustment of the exchange rate and it was not just any exchange rate, the exchange rate when back at the Hotel Libertador with Toto and his team, we said where to set it was that this exchange rate plus the PAIS tax, remained close to the market exchange rate. Because in this way we minimized the excess demand for foreign currency. Therefore, we minimized the excess supply in the goods market, in the labor market and, therefore, although we were going to implement a painful solution in fiscal terms, where that increase in savings would not have investment as a counterpart and activity would fall, employment would fall, and if real wages would fall, because we were clarifying the economy, by doing it that way the damage was much smaller. Because then those who complain appear, saying: “I shouldn’t have set the exchange rate at 600,” but it happens that in that model if things went well, there would also have been more inflation than we had and now they are the same ones who complain about the lagging exchange rate. That is to say, please recalibrate the model well because the accounts are being made wrong, then. But they are not going to accept that they were wrong, but they are going to fuel that the model has to explode because they were not wrong.

But aside from that, it was not the only problem we had, the gap. Then we had phenomenal stock problems, for example, we had debt maturities in pesos equivalent to 90 billion dollars. What a job you took on Quirno, huh? Not only that, we had the problem of the SIRA, which were like 50 billion dollars, we had the problem of trapped dividends, we had the problem of remunerated liabilities, which the previous government so amicably, we had the Leliqs that were for 30, 60, 90, 120 and 180 days, turned everything into one day. I’ll explain to you why they did it, do you know why they did it? Because they believed that we were going to release everything without looking at the stock problem. And if we released everything without looking at the stock problem, we would generate hyperinflation, and in January there would be another government. Just that easy. But we didn’t give them the pleasure, we are finishing, close to finishing May and we are still here and with inflation falling. So, that is basically what we found. So, in the fiscal area what did we do? We moved to a zero deficit policy. I was surprised and I saw some presentations from some analysts who claim to know a lot, who said that fiscal policy was inconsistent. If I go to zero deficit, what is interesting about zero deficit, is that then I do not increase the debt; if I do not increase the debt, given the product, the debt-to-product ratio is non-increasing. Moreover, if it expands with the population alone, it is already decreasing, therefore, I am solvent, therefore, clearly the fiscal policy becomes consistent. Think that, having fallen the agreement with the International Monetary Fund, therefore, we had a huge problem of 25 billion dollars that were maturing, mostly with multilaterals, having the agreement fallen with the Fund, Toto and his team fixed this in two weeks, sorry in a weekend with the Fund, incredible. When you came, we were coming from a history that under normal terms would have taken us three months. Why? Because precisely this policy was super consistent, in fact, it is so consistent that the country risk of 2900 dropped to 1200, and if it weren’t for the policy not stopping to put sticks in the wheel, we would have already passed the barrier of a thousand points a long time ago. But don’t worry, because we are going to keep insisting, so at some point we are going to break that barrier and we will continue to lower the country risk.

Moreover, when we said we were going to make this adjustment, everyone said it was impossible, that it couldn't be adjusted by more than one point, after which, not only, let’s see, in the midst of desperation I inform you… I mean, we wanted to close the accounts and, well, we aimed for five and we went a bit overboard, we adjusted seven in the Treasury. Well, now we are recomposing, but in that dynamic, fine-tuning is a bit complicated and fine-tuning is fine, on the Excel sheet, in real life it is a bit more complex, but that thing that said it was impossible to adjust more than one point per year, they found that we had adjusted seven points in the first quarter. Not only that, but already in the first month of management we had generated a financial surplus. So, instead of accepting that they were wrong, “nah, that’s not a chainsaw, it’s scissors plus a lot of blender.” I mean, let’s see, we cut the number of ministries in half, we cut public works, because we don’t believe in public works, we cut discretionary transfers to the provinces outright, we fired a huge number of public employees and every time contracts fall, more public employees are let go, we reduced a lot of social plans that were scams, or have you ever seen the number of corruption cases reported from Human Capital? I inform you that we are the Executive Power, therefore, now it is in the hands of Justice, don’t ask me for it. We found the mess, we reported it, and now it is in the hands of Justice.

So, was there no chainsaw? There was a tremendous chainsaw and then let me explain something, when the blender is permanent, it is also a chainsaw. So, those who said that it was not possible to make an adjustment of more than one point of GDP. So, what do they do now? No, because the problem now is the quality of the adjustment. Come on, mediocre failure, you couldn’t do it because you didn’t have what it takes to do it. In contrast, the Lord and I have decided to put in what needed to be put in, let’s see if you believe it’s easy to put up with these spending maniacs, degenerates of public spending. Notice that the only thing they are doing now is sending projects to Congress, for what? To break our fiscal balance. I inform you in case you are interested, that any project sent from Congress that wants to break the budget and blow this country to pieces, I will veto it, I don’t care at all. Obviously, they will do it for electoral purposes to try to undermine us electorally. But we will explain to the people what they are doing, look how it backfired when they went with the issue of a noble cause for universities and then people realized how a cause was prostituted with a lie and in which the entire political caste got involved, and it ended up in a photo of the ghost train. Principle of revelation, besides we are now exporting it to the principle of revelation and how well it works.

So, the other thing that was very important in all this is the cleaning up of the Central Bank, one of the things that the Central Bank published recently was the disaster caused by Kirchnerism in this last stage it was in. That is to say, they broke the balance of the Central Bank by 45 billion dollars, they bankrupted it. It is not a minor issue to bankrupt the Central Bank. Because do you remember someone, the one with the gastronomic metaphor, saying that the Central Bank is bankrupt is not a joke. Because, then, if I have the Central Bank bankrupt, what is the problem? That to restore what I have in assets, versus what I have in liabilities I need the price level to rise, for what? To liquidate the liabilities. So, if I have a price level that liquidates the liabilities to the point that it makes the net worth reach zero, the more bankrupt I am, the higher the price level I need. So, if one takes today’s price level with the future price level, the slope of that is what? Inflation. So, as I go restoring and cleaning up the balance of the Central Bank, the implicit price level, how is it?, is much lower. Therefore, I am lowering the inflation rate. Mr. Bausili, in charge of the Central Bank, has already restored 25 billion dollars, so imagine the huge work he is doing to kill inflation. But that is not the only mess they left us there, we have other problems, one of the problems we have is that we have endogenous issuance through two rather perverse mechanisms, one is the remuneration of remunerated liabilities, which are the passes. Well, this past week, in a fantastic operation coordinated between the Central Bank, Santiago Bausili, and Mr. Pablo Quirno, one third of the money that was in the remunerated, we basically transferred to depend on the Treasury. And why could we do it now? Because in the meantime we were generating trust, we were generating fiscal results, so we were able to build a curve of pesos, and because now we have a peso curve, thanks to the huge work of Mr. Pablo Quirno, we were able to transfer one third of the remunerated. So, as we lower the interest rate and transfer remunerated from the Central Bank to the Treasury, in this way, we will end up eliminating one of the mechanisms of endogenous issuance.

The other mechanism is a perverse mechanism that is the puts, where there is co-responsibility with the IMF, because since they did not want to finance the treasury they preferred the credit risk of the Central Bank and invented that monster of the puts. So, when we finish with the remunerated, when we finish with the problem of the puts that we already have, we are on the right track, it will end and we advance in the reform of the financial system, the issuance by the financial sector will end. As we have financial fiscal balance, we do not need to issue for the treasury and, therefore, we will leave the exchange rate free and we will not issue anymore. Once we have that situation, we will send a law to Congress where monetary issuance will be considered a crime, a crime like a crime against humanity, it will be an imprescriptible crime. So, if we issue money, the President of the Central Bank will go to jail, the entire board, the President of the Nation, the Minister of Economy, and deputies and senators. That is to say, all those who work to issue money will all go to jail. You can tell me ‘well, but if they overturned the convertibility law and robbed Argentines at that very moment of 14 billion dollars, which today must be like twenty-something thousand, why wouldn’t they do it again?’ Well, because it will be considered a crime against humanity, it will have the same characteristics. So, yes, a government may come and do it, but then another may come and imprison them all for doing that, which will complicate things quite a bit, I mean, they will end up in jail.

But not only that, but there is also an additional issue: now I will have a fixed amount of pesos, and remember that I said that the demand for money is indeed a derived demand from the intertemporal consumption path, you need to have a permanent increase in income to permanently increase the consumption path. Are we clear so far? Therefore, as we restore economic growth in the economy and there are reasons to explain this, basically, first, because we are starting to bounce back, because real wages either match or exceed inflation, and in terms of food, they are winning by a landslide, because food inflation is coming in very low. Second, because after 20 years of savage populism, punishing capital, they ate up the capital; by eating up the capital, the value of the marginal product of capital, which in financial terms you want to beat from the cash flow of the firm, or if you want given a WACC, the VAN of the cash flow of the firm is positive and very large, given all the capital they ate up, what happens is that this will generate investment, even if we didn’t make the reforms. And as if all this were not enough, there were 15 points of GDP that the State was sucking up, generating crowding out, and now there will be what? We return it to the people. Think that we assumed discussing hyperinflation, because in fact the wholesale inflation of December was 54% and that means annualized 17,000, which—by the way—the last data was 3.4 and if you take other indicators of wholesale price systems, they are below 3. Therefore, the stabilization process is working very well. That’s funny, they say: “there is no stabilization plan.” And why is inflation coincidentally going down? I mean, I ask, because it has to go down from 54 to 3, but aside from that, what is important? That 15 points of savings will return to finance investment. And, therefore, from discussing hyperinflation, today we are discussing that mortgage credit is returning. That is to say, the dream of owning a home is returning, young people could not think about having a car and now they think they can have their own home. It’s interesting, all in five months.

So, in that context what we are going to have is that the amount of money in pesos is fixed. But, what happens?, if I generate economic growth and if I implement structural reforms, we will grow much more, which, if Congress doesn’t take it away from me now, I don’t care, I will try again. And I will try as many times as I can, and if they don’t let it pass, the beating we are going to give them electorally next year will change the composition of Congress and we will be able to pass all the reform. Because so far, look, the biggest reform was Menem’s, the Bases Law is, as it is today in Congress, five times bigger and not only that, but we also have the 300 reforms of the DNU, so we are eight times bigger. Let me tell you something: we still have 3,200 reforms pending. And you know what? We are going to do them. Sooner or later, we are going to do them, I don’t care how much will they have to block the dirty politics, I don’t care: we are going to do it, we will not stop until Argentina is the country with the most freedom in the world. Yes, we are going to do it.

Therefore, as long as the economy grows permanently and that implies a permanent increase in consumption, the counterpart is that it will increase the demand for money. So what is the problem I have now if I left the amount of money fixed? It is that since I have a flexible exchange rate, the currency will appreciate, but also another thing that can happen and will happen, how was the increase in the demand for money resolved in convertibility? People would go and sell dollars to the Central Bank and that’s how they injected pesos, in fact, we talked about that endogenous mechanism, well, but now we are not going to issue. So how do we do it?, we will allow currency competition, so let’s suppose, just to make it easy now, that the dollar can be used and we allow the dollar to be used as another currency; as the demand for money increases, the only way to monetize the economy is how? With individuals putting dollars into the economy. So what is going to happen? They will find themselves in a situation where the pesos are fixed and an economy that grows increasingly has more dollars, and increasingly has more dollars, always the same pesos and they make transactions in whatever currency they want. Consequently, the peso becomes something like a museum piece and when it is very small compared to the amount of dollars, what do you think we are going to do? We are going to dollarize and there the peso will disappear, and the dollarization in a currency competition system, because there are people who are afraid, “no because in reality, the appreciation and I don’t know what…” Enough with the fear, enough with the fear, so much fear of freedom, so much fear of prices. There will be currency competition. So you will be able to use, you saw that some talk about a basket of currencies? Well, you will be able to use whatever currency you want; you can use the dollar, you can use the yen, you can use the renminbi, you can use the pound sterling, the franc, you can use whatever you want, I don’t care, use any of them. Therefore, there you would have a model of a basket of currencies, but instead of being determined by a bureaucrat, the weights will be determined by the market, they will be determined by individuals with their decisions to buy and sell in whatever currency they want. But the truth is, why go for something so intellectually short?

There is a university, Francisco Marroquín in Guatemala, which is the first libertarian university in the world. You, in one of the hallways, when you are walking, for example, come across some strange murals and they have a little glass on the side with that same drawing. Well, those were the banknotes that they had in Guatemala before having a Central Bank, which were issued by coffee companies. Guatemala has one of the best coffees in the world, so the money was issued by the coffee companies themselves. And it was in their interest, and that money was backed, why? It was backed by coffee. That is to say, it was a serious commodity standard. So, in that context, the reality is, ‘if I dedicate myself to producing coffee, why don’t I make my transactions in terms of coffee?’ ‘If I am in the oil sector, why don’t I do them in terms of WTI?’ ‘If I am in the gas sector, why don’t I do them in BTU?’ ‘If I am in agriculture, why don’t I do them in soybeans?’ In other words, I use the currency I want and make use of it, which means that the risks of currency mismatches will collapse, you will be able to be matched as much as you want, the savings you will have in terms of insurance coverage is enormous. That is to say, look at how it will also lower transaction costs for the economy. And what appreciation, the problem of appreciation is no longer discussed, I believe that some economists do not want this kind of thing, I don’t know if it’s because they don’t want to think or because their scam will come to an end. Imagine if they want to make the little graph of the real exchange rate, what are they going to live on? Go and work on something serious.

So, in that sense, what I want to say is that this is the monetary regime we are aspiring to, a situation where when we finish with all the issuance mechanisms, the amount of money remains constant and the economy begins to dollarize endogenously. There it dollarizes and everyone will make the transactions they want, then the government will set a currency in which it will be paid, I don’t know, the dollar, and the problem is over, the problem is over, and if you have dollars, you collect dollars, you pay in dollars. What’s the problem? Do you do it in another currency? Well, since there is free competition of currency and you convert it however you want, you take it, change what you need to pay taxes, and that’s it, what’s the problem? It wasn’t that complex. And in this way, we will achieve not only stabilizing the economy, which is what we are doing, but what happens is that some say, “but he said he was going to do it instantly” … Now, it’s incredible that now they tell me that I said I was going to do it instantly and when I explained during the campaign that it required time, they told me “oh Javier Delay.” Man, the level of opportunism and intellectual dishonesty here is tremendous. So, as we clean up the Central Bank, we will be able to move to this zero issuance regime and with the competition of currencies, this will start to happen where the peso loses relative weight within that, and there, automatically, we dollarize, we end inflation forever, we take the knife away from the killer monkey that is politics. They are not going to mess with us anymore with inflation, and we are going to get to work on continuing to make structural reforms so that Argentina, in 35 or 40 years, becomes a power again. Thank you very much.