Words of the President of the Nation, Javier Milei, at the presentation of his book at Luna Park.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

22 May 2024 · Presentation of the book "Capitalism, Socialism, in the Neoclassical..." (Festival of Freedom) · Luna Park

Context
Milei addressed supporters at Luna Park on May 22, 2024, presenting his book 'Capitalism, Socialism, in the Neoclassical Trap' at a self-described Festival of Freedom.
Main themes
Libertarian and Austrian economics, capitalism vs. socialism, neoclassical theory critique, economic growth models, book presentation, freedom ideology, cultural battle against socialism, Argentine politics, Davos speech, intertemporal macroeconomics
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,288
92nd percentile
Sentences
243
93rd percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 78%73%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

243 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Javier Milei: Hello everyone. Thank you very much to all those who have come here, to this true celebration of freedom. First of all, besides thanking the Chief, my sister, I also want to thank each of my ministers who are present; thank the deputies and senators who are here celebrating the Festival of Freedom. And since one cannot be ungrateful, hey, we must thank the one from the Book Fair Foundation, who, with the attempted boycott, gifted us this celebration. Thank you, Kirchnerists. It seems you were going to need more than ten rooms, José Hernández, to accommodate this.

Well, now let's go, because deep down I come to present my recent book called "Capitalism, Socialism, in the Neoclassical Trap." And, in fact, the subtitle is "From Economic Theory to Political Action." Therefore, the book is structured in three blocks. The first block is the introduction, in which we present the most emblematic speeches we have given since we have been in politics.

In that sense, the first of the articles in the introduction is the acceptance speech for the honorary doctorate at ESEADE, which is an article where I trace how my thinking has evolved over the years, from being what is called a post-Keynesian, a Marxist Keynesian, to proudly becoming a disciple of the Austrian school, libertarian liberal, anarcho-capitalist.

Then, the second article is basically the talk, the speech from Davos, the day we told the world: 'Argentina is present and comes to lift the ideas of freedom like no one else in the world.' The third conference that appears in this introduction is a conference I gave at CIPAC in Washington, where I explain the risks involved in embracing neoclassical ideas regarding monopolies and, in light of that, how economic regulation ends up destroying economic growth. It is true that this article could be part of what is part 1, which consists of technical articles, but given the relevance of that speech and how it complements the Davos speech, you will find it there. On the other hand, the closing of this section is basically the opening speech of the Legislative Assembly, that famous speech where I stood in front of Congress and told them everything we, the Argentine citizens, wanted to say to their faces, and we said it.

I can assure you that I would accompany you singing, but I would violate the independence of the powers. Don’t you think I already have enough messes? Good.

Hey, Mondino is going to ask me for overtime.

Well, in what is called part 1 of the book, it deals specifically with the structure of this idea of capitalism, socialism, and democracy. And there you will find five articles: there is one that presents the problem from the perspective of the history of economic thought, and it is where I try to trace the problem within economic theory, which later I will explain, all these problems arise from neoclassical theory. There is a second article that presents the same problem, but from my field of specialization, which is economic growth, and that article will later be linked when we go to the macroeconomic model in part 2.

On the other hand, the third article is the article, if you will, where it is mostly concentrated; it is an article that is in English, published in Palgrave of Austrian Economics, where they called the most important Austrians in the world. It seems that some, who know a lot, forgot them and, by mistake, among them. And in that article, it will be, it is an article, moreover, written in honor of Jesús Huerta de Soto.

And then you will find an application to taxes, and that part closes with an application to the cultural battle and the design of policies, and how to confront and fight head-on against the socialism of the 21st century, and the strategy they have been building based on Gramsci with the logic of the group known as the São Paulo Forum, and now Grupo Puebla. That is to say, those enemies who suddenly try to overthrow this government because they want socialism and misery to continue.

Regarding part 2, what is presented there is a model of intertemporal macroeconomics, which serves to understand how I view these problems. Where, in addition, what you will find is that all modern macroeconomics is written in terms of economic growth. Basically, from my point of view, at the intermediate level, because at the advanced level the best book is that of Doctor Federico Sturzenegger, who is present here. There is a book by Barro, called Macroeconomics, which works with the idea of the Solow model. In that sense, I replicate the type of exercise, then I raise the problems he has, Solow, and the first patch appears, due to a problem called dynamic efficiency, which is the first patch is the Phelps rule, but it is only one problem.

That model is then improved and put in terms of mathematics, specifically, intertemporal, with intertemporal optimization, which is a network, an improvement on the Ramsey model of 1928, which was done in the mid-1960s by two economists, one called Cass and the other called Koopmans. However, despite that, they could not find a way to explain economic growth. I mean, moreover, when those models were tested in real life, they only explained 15%, and the rest was called residue. I will say this: the model explained nothing, everything was outside the model. In that sense, a couple of patches were made, which I also explain how it is fixed, which is the incorporation of human capital or the incorporation of technological progress, and in this way you can explain economic growth.

However, the problem is that all those elements are given exogenously, that is, everything is at random and the dynamics are described at random, therefore, it is a patch with which economists coexist, but we must know that it is a patch. But I will tell you something, because my next book—which I will write with Doctor Demian Reidel, who is over there, that genius over there—we found the solution, so I am already warning you that the one coming behind has the solution.

And then, what you do is… economic thought evolves towards real cycle models and then exhausts a set of assumptions so that it reappears to Solow and becomes manageable for the general public. But, unlike Barro's model, which descends through the labor market, in this case we descend through the capital market. By descending through the capital market, we not only derive the demand for labor, but also, as capital is what companies call assets, on the other side we have debt and equity, that is, the financing of companies. And that allows us to integrate the capital market with the monetary market. And in this way, everything is integrated: money, capital market, and the real side of the economy. It is a rather fun contribution.

And, naturally, this ends with the extension to an open economy. But the core of the book is what is called part 1, which is what is precisely called "Capitalism, Socialism, and the Neoclassical Trap." So, the first thing to think about is, well, it’s funny because some tell me: “Hey, you work 16 hours a day, I say when do you write? Well, when do you read?” Well, I do what I can.

But, in fact, this paper or this work, if you will, started 11 years ago. I was basically… it is supposed to be my specialization, economic growth, with and without money, and I encountered a problem that we regularly encounter as economists when we look at growth problems, which is called "the hockey stick." There was an economist—may he rest in peace—named Angus Maddison, and what he did was estimate the GDP per capita of various countries around the world throughout history, generally going back to before the year zero of the Christian era, but there is no difference. So, generally, you will find a series from the year zero of the Christian era to the year 2000, and obviously it has updates.

And what is interesting is that when you look at GDP per capita during the 1800 years of that series, GDP per capita is practically constant. The only increase it had was 40% in the 16th century, that is, after the discovery of America. And that, spread over 1800 years, meant that the economy grew in per capita terms by 0.02%. That is to say, you needed 3,500 years to double GDP per capita. The economy moved very slowly, very slowly. What is interesting is that by the year 1800, there were 800 million human beings on the planet, that is, we did not reach one billion, and when you take the year 2000, the population multiplied almost eight times and GDP per capita multiplied by 14 times.

That in economics is a huge problem, it is called increasing returns. And the first to see this was Adam Smith with the idea of the pin factory. But increasing returns in economics are usually associated with the presence of monopolies, and for neoclassicals, monopolies are bad because monopolies punish welfare. And the question is if in the year 1800, 95% of the world's population was below the extreme poverty line and in the year 2000 that number was less than 10%, having multiplied the population by eight times and having living standards like we have never had in the history of humanity, can you explain to me how it makes sense that concentrated structures are bad? It was obvious that there was a problem there, and that is what this is about.

Faced with that problem, I said, then, "I have some strange problem with micro." After almost 25 years of teaching micro, something is wrong. And there I had the fortune to come across an article, "The Wonderful Murray Newton Rothbard," the father of anarcho-capitalism, called "Monopoly and Competition."

The first thing is that it is an article that you can find in Spanish, and the translation was done by Alberto Benegas Lynch father, that is, the father of the national hero and the grandfather of Berti.

I remember that after 3 hours of reading that 140-page article, I finished reading it and said, “everything I taught about market structure for 25 years is all wrong.” And that’s when I became an anarcho-capitalist Austrian, everything. It was a total revelation.

Because the problem of monopoly, you first have what Hasley called, the difference between the good and the bad economist in the book "Economics in One Lesson," which is the difference, is that while the bad economist only looks at one sector, one period, the good economist looks at general equilibrium, that is, not only looks at one sector, but looks at all the other sectors and not only considers short-term effects but also long-term effects; that is, the bad economist works with a partial equilibrium model of a single good and a single period to a general intertemporal equilibrium model.

So, for example, a certain car brand may have a monopoly over that car, but it also competes with others, and there is substitution. And you can compete one with another. But now I will make it more violent. Let’s suppose we have a case of a company that produces cell phones and competes with nine others, so you have 10 companies competing and now a company appears that manages to make a cell phone with much better features and at a much lower cost, that is, a better quality good, at a better price, what do you think will happen to the other nine? They will go bankrupt. And what is wrong with that? There is nothing wrong with that, it is wonderful, if you now have a phone ten times better, ten times cheaper, and you have a lot of money left to spend on a lot of other things, let’s go.

Of course, but there we are going to say something uncomfortable to politicians, and that is that in reality the only monopolies that are bad, which is the true definition of monopoly created by Lord Coke, a visionary Lord Coke, and it is the one Adam Smith takes that monopoly is when the Monarch or the feudal lord gave a company the power to be the only company that sold that product in that place and that if someone violated that, the full force of the State would come down on them. That is to say, the monopoly is bad when the one in the middle is the State. Therefore, the problem remains the damn State.

Therefore, the inspiration started at that moment, and it was then to find where the problem was in the neoclassical instrument. The other element that the article has, because notice that it is called "Capitalism, Socialism, and the Neoclassical Trap," that is, that the neoclassical system constitutes a trap and I mention capitalism and socialism. I take that from two authors: one is Ludwig von Mises and the other is Friedrich von Hayek.

If you review Mises' work, Mises will tell you clearly that there are only two systems. On one side you will find free enterprise capitalism, free enterprise capitalism. And on the other side, opposite, you will find real socialism. Now, those are the two poles. And the other book that I use as a reference in this is a book that just turned 80 years old, which is "The Road to Serfdom." What is the argument of "The Road to Serfdom"? If I miscalculated the number of years, I apologize. I mean, it’s roughly that.

In that sense, what Hayek pointed out is that when a fatalistically arrogant politician intervened in a market because he believed there was a market failure, the emerging result was that it functioned worse. And in that situation, it unleashed more violence and frustration from the politician, leading him to have a greater degree of intervention. Consequently, individual freedoms were lost as the economic system functioned worse and worse. That is why the road to servitude, the path to misery, the trap that leads us to misery is socialist goodism, because it demands more and more intervention and the economy will function worse, while we have less freedom and the mechanism of coordination and information generation is blocked.

In fact, Milton Friedman had put this in other terms, and with that genius that Milton Friedman had for these kinds of things, he said: "Often, the State's solution to a market failure is a much worse solution." We certainly have a good example with Argentina. So, if we had to understand this, the first thing to understand was what the market was. And this is very interesting because my experience interacting with many economists is that when you ask them what the market is, they don’t know. I mean, I don’t know, it’s like a doctor not knowing what a leg is. I don’t know, it’s strange. So, this led me to explore what the definition of the market is, at least my definition. I understand the market as a process of social cooperation where property rights are voluntarily exchanged.

Now, the point is that if there is private property, consequently, there is no State. That makes sense because what does the price system do? The price system is a mechanism for transmitting signals, coordination, and adjustment. That is, when you make a transaction, a price is recorded. That price becomes a signal that coordinates the agents; some will be buyers, others will be sellers, they will start to interact, and as supply and demand differ, prices will change until equilibrium is found. Obviously, if the State intervenes in private property, that generates noise in the price and, therefore, the market becomes uncoordinated. And then, things start to function poorly.

So, while that is very attractive, it also put me in conflict with friends because it put me in conflict with those from Chicago, who are also liberals, but are neoclassical liberals. They are liberals, stop messing around, come on. I mean, let’s not get into the purism of the twenty-fifth series behind Taylor’s development, because otherwise, the leftists will eat us alive. Otherwise, we can go back to those who held meetings and an elevator was too big for them, that the vibe they are putting into the talk is fun, but I’m supposed to be talking about economic theory.

So, what happens? You will find that in the Chicago tradition, well in the neoclassical tradition, the only element for which the State exists is because we are facing the presence of market failures. Therefore, the only thing that justifies the existence of the State and the collection of taxes is for the State to correct these market failures. But what happens? That definition did not map for me with the definition of the market. And in that sense, my reflection, which will obviously seem a bit extreme to someone like everything I do. In that context, one of the things I say is: market failures do not exist. If you consider that there is a market failure, the first thing I suggest is that you check whether there is State intervention. Because if there is State intervention, the problem is not the market, the problem is not the people, the problem is the politicians.

But obviously, if I left the definition there, it was very light. So, to make it a little more reloaded, I said: ‘And if you believe, even so, without the State, there is a market failure, go and do the analysis again because it’s wrong.’ And the interesting thing is that the neoclassical analysis and economists, I believe that at some point we definitely got sick and lost our compass. What is a model? A model is a simplified representation of reality. Now, if the model does not map with reality, what does a normal reasonable mind do? It throws away the model and looks for one that maps with reality. Well, the neoclassicals went so crazy that they call it ‘market failure’. So now we have to find out why economists do that. So, to find where the origin of all this is, what did I do? I went to daddy, not you, to Adam Smith. You and your business, what do you do… The father of the creature is there. The mother too.

So, what did I do? I went to Adam Smith. And the most interesting thing is that Adam Smith contained a model of economic growth. The guy, Adam Smith is to economics what Gauss is to mathematics, someone who was 200 years ahead of his time. Of course, that’s why he was also a bit crazy, no one paid attention to him. I mean, Gauss was much more complicated.

Here I go, I’m almost there, but stop spoiling the titles.

Basically, there are two driving ideas in Adam Smith: one is the idea of the pin factory, which was what he said that if a person dedicated themselves to making a pin alone, they could produce 20 pins a day, but if they divided that activity into 15 different activities, per capita productivity would jump to 5000 pins a day. An idea that the division of labor leads to increasing returns, that is, the fundamental element that explains economic growth was in Adam Smith, a work published in 1776, but which he had started writing in 1766, ten years earlier. And the other idea, which is one of the most wonderful ideas and that everyone was fascinated with, is the idea of the invisible hand. And it is that each one, guided by their own interest, leads to the maximum general well-being. Therefore, we do not need anyone to intervene in the middle; with us doing what we want to do, it is enough and more, as long as we do not mess up anyone's life.

So, there, as there could not be a party pooper who ruined everything and who considered Adam Smith as a crazy person, I mean, the one who saw it was called crazy, then he invented the idea of diminishing marginal returns. It was a pretty simple idea. He said: well, people arrive and what do they do? They settle in the most productive land, and when more people arrive, they go to lands that are increasingly less productive. And in that way, diminishing marginal returns appear. Basically, Malthus wanted to explain something truly aberrant, which was called ‘the iron law of wages’, which said that as per capita income rose, the passion of the sexes led people to have more children, and as they had more children and marginal productivity was decreasing, there came a moment where it found an equilibrium. And if the population extended beyond that point, then real wages were destroyed and people starved. And how did Malthus come up with the idea to correct this? With birth control, whose modern versions are abortion clinics.

By the way, if you go and read the book of Shemot, that is, the second book of the Pentateuch, that is, Exodus, you will find that even at that time it was a mechanism to massacre populations that the Egyptians were using to wipe out the Jews. And if you want more, here in time, what is inspiring the entire murderous agenda today is the Club of Rome. When the files of this man Nixon were declassified, what was found is that, inspired by all the predictions of the Club of Rome, which said that when we reached the year 2000 there would be no room for more people on the planet and there would be an energy blackout and that would reduce food production, and we would die and be left with a billion. So, they suggested promoting the abortion agenda. That is to say, what they believe is so advanced with the abortion agenda is an agenda that is over three thousand years old and is an absolutely murderous agenda by a couple of fools who did bad math.

“But Mr. Milei is a denier of science.” So, the analysis continued, the economic analysis. Obviously, in the heirs of Malthus are David Ricardo, John Stuart Mill, and after John Stuart Mill, two sinister figures appear like Rodbertus and Karl Marx.

But, faced with the resounding failure, for not being able to have a good theory of value, something that the leftists still have not learned, the subjective theory of value appears and the neoclassical school emerges. And there appear three strands: the Austrian School, which comes from Menger, from a book called ‘Principles of Political Economy’, which is from 1871; a line that descends from William Stanley Jevons and another line that descends from Léon Walras, which is the line of general equilibrium. In that line of general equilibrium, when mathematics is applied to economics, a derived effect is that a man named Vilfredo Pareto appears, whose ideas influenced a nefarious leftist named Mussolini, who invented the doctrine of fascism and who openly declares that he hates liberalism, saying “everything within the State, nothing outside the State, and nothing against the State.” Hey, how ignorant, they call us fascists, right?

And the idea of Pareto optimality was that if you had a situation where you could improve someone without worsening anyone, grab it with Pareto. Let’s see, we can go back to Pareto optimality, I assure you I’ll finish in a little while and the main course with Adorni, with Espert is coming, but I’ll finish three things and we’ll go.

Hey, thank goodness they finished… we couldn’t go to the Book Fair otherwise, we would have had to leave in an hour. This way, we can be here all day.

Let’s go to the idea of Pareto optimality. The idea of Pareto optimality said that if you had a situation in which to improve someone you had to worsen another, then you were at an optimum. If you had a situation where you could improve someone without messing up anyone's life, you could make a Pareto improvement. That is, there was no optimum. And if you correct those situations, when those gains in well-being are exhausted, you are at Pareto optimality. So, the idea for a stationary economy seemed quite reasonable.

Now, what happens? As we said, that world that existed from year zero to 1800 disappeared with the industrial revolution, and the economy began to grow and improvements in quality of life began to be noticed. And one of the things that economists began to realize is that there were increasing returns, that is, that the world that Malthus had proposed to confront Adam Smith made no sense. So, two economists appeared, one Alfred Marshall, the other Allyn Young, who began to explore how to explain economic growth, that is, how to incorporate the problem of increasing returns into economic theory. And in parallel, economists began to work on the microeconomic foundations to generate structures of competition with monopolies. So, there appears the model of monopolistic competition by Chamberlin, and on the other hand, the theory of monopoly by Joan Robinson.

Now, all this was happening back in the 1920s. The Great Depression came, the Great Depression meant a strong setback for the Austrian School, and in the face of that setback suffered by the Austrian School, even though there were other things to explain this problem, one of the darkest things in the history of humanity alongside Marxism appeared, what appeared? Who? Keynes, good!

Well, then, that meant blowing up all economic analysis. It meant going back, in fact, it implies in some sense, in terms of value theory, going back to the labor theory of value. It meant breaking a lot of things. But, obviously, as a sinister and inconsistent mechanism, starting in the 1950s it began to fail and started to function poorly. Faced with the situation where it began to function poorly and where, evidently, that idea of the multiplier was violating the budget constraint, the economy began to seek to resume the tradition of respecting the budget constraint. And, based on the work that had appeared on the existence of equilibrium at the beginning of the 20th century by a mathematician economist named Abraham Wald, the works of McKenzie, Debreu, and Arrow appeared. I’m going to share a little secret, I’ve told it once, I’ll tell it again. Look, the model, when I read Debreu’s model, a Hebrew book, called "Theory of Value," I can assure you that it has a mathematical beauty that is super inspiring. I’ll tell you something, I could almost say that I enjoyed it more than my first Playboy. It’s a poetic license.

So, what do those models do? They work on the idea of existence, uniqueness, and stability. That is to say, whether equilibrium exists, whether it is unique, and whether it is stable. In other words, if you introduce a disturbance and it moves away from equilibrium, whether the model returns. In that sense, what is the point? Up to that point, there is no problem, because you need to build a topological construction so that a fixed-point theorem can be applied, like Brouwer's or Kakutani's, depending on whether you are working with mergers or correspondences. The problem arises when, without considering what was behind that mathematics, they want to introduce the idea of optimality. And when they go to introduce the idea of optimality, which was deeply related to the idea of the invisible hand, they start demanding that those functions begin to generate maximum values. And that means that if I have demand functions that come from maximizing utility, supply functions that come from maximizing profits; therefore, if those functions are continuous in a compact, closed, bounded set, with those characteristics, if the functions are continuous, equilibrium exists and is unique.

In that case, and also if we assume that direct effects outweigh cross effects, it is also stable. Now, to achieve the property of optimality, I need maximization, and for that, neoclassical economics erroneously demands that those functions be, in order to have a maximum and for it to be unique, strictly concave. And that is false because you could have an increasing function and when it saturates at the limit, you would have the maximum. Moreover, in that case, I mean, that problem would perhaps imply an empirical problem related to the nature that there would be only one company left.

But, in reality, the analysis is poorly designed. And from this nefarious mechanism, problems arise because working with constant returns to scale does not allow us to explain economic growth. And when we have these non-convexities, we call it "market failure," and then we fight against monopolies or we fight against public goods. How many times do politicians tell you, "No, because this is a public good and it should be provided by the State"? Look, the best example created of public goods was invented by Samuelson, which were lighthouses. A public good has two characteristics: one is the issue of rivalry, no, a good that has rivalry is if I consume it, another cannot consume it. That is rivalry in consumption. And the other is non-exclusion; if it is given to me, I cannot exclude others; for example, light, I am consuming this light and, however, there is no rivalry in consumption, all of you could consume it, it is not a problem, and moreover, the one who is giving me that light gives it to me, cannot exclude you, that is, the lighthouse has those characteristics, it is precisely the definition of a pure public good.

Then, a lawyer appeared who did not have his head contaminated with all the neoclassical apparatus and went to the meetings organized by Milton Friedman at his house in Chicago. I tell you that poor Ronald Coase was bullied like a character in a novel, poor Coase, he charged like crazy, but the guy was a genius. So, what did he do? Ah, with lighthouses, that is, they are public goods. So, what did he do? He reviewed all the lighthouses of the 19th century. What do you think he discovered? They were all private. Come on!

Other problems that arise are cases of externalities, which were also resolved by Coase by assigning property rights. Then there are the problems of asymmetric information, and the private sector also has its own solutions to deal with moral hazard problems, adverse selection, and create its own signaling. Or are we not indulging ourselves with the revelation principle?

And another case is what is called "the coordination failure." The clearest example is what is called "the prisoner's dilemma." But no one realized that when they make the assumption to have the prisoner's dilemma, the prisoners cannot interact. That is to say, it is not that the solution cannot be found; the solution is not found because in the middle is who, the damn State that does not let them interact. Therefore, if you lift that assumption, there is no problem of the prisoner's dilemma. Therefore, all this idea of market failures, because it does not map against our ideal model of Arrow-Debreu, only serves to favor State intervention, and every time the State intervenes, it generates an additional falsehood in the functioning of the market that demands more intervention; and in that way, they end up condemning us to damn socialism, which is what we have to fight against once and for all. Thank you very much.