Speech by President Javier Milei at the Forum of Industrial Entrepreneurs of Paraguay

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

16 September 2025 · Forum of Industrial Entrepreneurs of Paraguay

Context
Milei addressed the Forum of Industrial Entrepreneurs of Paraguay in September 2025, speaking on the cultural and ideological battle for freedom.
Main themes
Cultural battle for freedom, battle of ideas against the left, political violence against conservative leaders, free market economics and the invisible hand, spontaneous order and price system, libertarianism, anti-statism, Charlie Kirk tribute, Adam Smith and Milton Friedman, wokism, youth outreach
Duration
~70 min
97th percentile
Words
8,417
97th percentile
Sentences
350
96th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%49%
  • Social 28%27%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

350 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Thank you very much. It is a great pleasure to have the opportunity to be here speaking to you. The topic I chose to talk about today, which is so important for youth and so important for the ideas of freedom, is the topic of the cultural battle. Naturally, it is a very special moment for those of us who defend the ideas of freedom and who literally defend it even with our own lives. In that sense, the first thing I want to do is pay tribute to the dear Charlie Kirk, who has literally given his life for the ideas of freedom. I had the fortune of meeting Charlie at a meeting in Mar-a-Lago to which I had been invited, and that is when I saw him. And after the tragic episode, I also learned that he had been in Buenos Aires, in a building very close to the hotel where we were living during the campaign. And it was very interesting because the name of the hotel is “El Libertador,” and the most interesting thing about it is that the color of the hotel is violet. And that day was the day that Argentina was painted totally or practically totally violet, and that is when we began this journey to make Argentina great again, hand in hand with the ideas of freedom. And I mention the case of Charlie Kirk because of the enormous task he undertook, linked to Turning Point USA, where basically what Charlie did was go to different places to debate. So he would sit in one place and debate with people, they would ask him questions; he was basically in 3,500 places in different universities and student venues, where they would ask him questions and he would basically respond. That is to say, he was someone open to debate, discussing ideas. But it seems that this irritated the left and wokism too much. And so when they could no longer fight on the plane of ideas, they directly decided to kill him. In essence, it is always validated that the left is always and everywhere a criminal, murderous, and impoverishing phenomenon. And in this case, it was no exception.

Moreover, they have killed Uribe; they have killed an important leader in Japan; they attempted to assassinate Trump; they also attempted to assassinate Bolsonaro. Very recently, during a caravan, they threw a cobblestone at us, which would be like a very large and heavy stone. If it had hit us in the head, as it was thrown from a building, it could have killed us. Or one that was thrown at us head-on and bounced off the hood of the truck, which, fortunately, I was able to dodge. Therefore, it seems that defending the ideas of freedom has become a little more risky; if it is riskier, the return is also greater. So it means that we are winning the battle of ideas and they have to resort to violence.

Beyond that, what we also have to understand is the nature and complexity of defending the ideas of freedom. It is not a simple battle, and even our approach is almost an anti-intuitive approach. Because, in essence, if one wanted to put it in metaphorical terms, we would be bringing to society the idea of the invisible hand, while on the other side the claw of the State is proposed. And essentially, the problem with the metaphor of the invisible hand is that it tends to be anti-intuitive for people. The invisible hand, which is the metaphor that appears in the second book of Adam Smith—the first was “The Theory of Moral Sentiments”—appears in the book “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations,” in Book Four. Basically, the idea of the invisible hand is that each person, guided by their own interest, leads to the general welfare. There is an article by Read called I, Pencil, which explains how this mechanism works in society and how people cooperate to generate a simple pencil. Moreover, for those who do not access the article and want to see it on YouTube, there is a segment from the series Free to Choose, which is a book that Milton Friedman published along with his wife Rose Director, which basically (well, it appears as Rose Friedman in the title of the book, because they were already married) features Milton Friedman in the series showing a pencil. So he says, for example, where the graphite comes from, which is what the lead is; the wood, the paint, the rubber, the copper where the eraser is assembled. So, he shows how millions of people coordinated spontaneously and unknowingly to generate a simple pencil. Which, have you thought about if you wanted to make a pencil? You couldn’t do it. However, it is a coordination mechanism where millions of human beings in different parts of the world cooperated through the price system so that you, for a minimal part of your work, can simply access a pencil. Therefore, it is a phenomenal coordination process. But it is an abstraction. So, one of the things that when you want to tell this story, it is important to keep in mind the idea of I, Pencil.

But not only that, because on the other side is the idea of the claw of the State, of planning. And in reality, of course, when one is dealing with their own life or their own business, companies clearly plan: they plan what they are going to produce, what stocks they are going to accumulate, what they plan to sell, at what price, how they are going to finance themselves. So there is the idea that, in rigor, one makes a plan, sees it tangibly, and believes that it could be extrapolated to the aggregate. And that is a huge mistake because there is a phenomenal phrase from Hayek that says: “The more the State plans, the less the individual plans.” And this is very interesting because if the State were to plan everything—the quantities, the prices of inputs, the price of those who sell—what does a company have to do? Nothing. And the problem is that, to solve that issue, you would need to have perfect information about the preferences of all agents in the economy, past, present, and future. You would need to know the time preference of each of those agents, you would need to know the initial endowments of that economy and how technological progress could change things that before... think that 250 or 300 years ago no one knew that oil existed or if it could be used for anything, or even that the internet existed. Or look at how a cell phone concentrates a lot of goods, the amount of goods you would have needed to have in the 1980s, and we are not that far away. So, in that sense, what needs to be clear is that, in addition, they would need to know the shape of the production function and also technological progress. And the reality is that this would imply that those who make decisions are omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent. That is why Hayek, in his last work, called it “the fatal conceit.” Because the only being that has those characteristics is God. That is to say, the only one who could solve such a problem is the creator, and clearly no human being is up to the task of solving that problem. Consequently, every time socialism is applied, socialism fails. And since the results are also totally opposite to what they seek: when they want to create jobs, they generate unemployment; when they want to reduce poverty, they explode it; when they want to control prices, prices go up. That is to say, everything they do, the result is always the opposite.

So, in that sense, what one has to understand is that at least since human evolution we have developed one of the most impressive mechanisms and also created in an impersonal way, which is the price system. It is a phenomenal coordination mechanism, that in the face of… if there is an earthquake where the trees with which the pencil is produced are generated, you will see that pencils will become more expensive and consequently will be substituted by another product. And no one needs to coordinate it, that work is done by the price system. Therefore, the first thing to be clear about is the challenge we have to explain something that is abstract, that is anti-intuitive, against something that seems logical. And that what seems logical actually ends up generating catastrophes and that what truly works is the anti-intuitive. That is why I strongly recommend reading I, Pencil, I recommend watching the series Free to Choose, and I recommend reading Hayek, regarding what has to do with spontaneous order, what has to do with the use of information, the use of knowledge in society, which is how the functioning of the free market economy is explained.

Going into this, it is not only us who are interested in explaining how the free market economy works. There is a truly beautiful and wonderful work that I would say has been fundamental in terms of politics in my life: it is a work by one of the greatest exponents of the Austrian school of economics, which is Israel Kirzner. Israel Kirzner has a book called Creativity, Capitalism, and Distributive Justice. And in that book, he makes an extremely challenging statement: he says “in light of empirical evidence, the capitalist system is enormously superior to the collectivist system, to the socialist system,” or as Huerta de Soto would rightly call it “statism,” which can be from the right or the left. Because the problem, in essence, the discussion today in strict rigor, is against statism, whether it is from the right or the left, and the enemy is the State.

So, in that conceptualization, what Israel Kirzner proposes is important. He says: it is true that the capitalist free enterprise system is much more productive. However, socialists, collectivists, statists dismiss our system as unjust. And the fundamental point of Israel Kirzner is: if that were true, the capitalist free enterprise system would not deserve to be defended. That is to say, if the system were indeed built on unjust foundations, it should not be defended. This is the difference when one is oriented and guided by ethics and morality or is guided by a utilitarian issue. And believe me, sitting in the chair I am in at this moment, the fundamental difference when making decisions is the ethical and moral issue.

And in that sense, Israel Kirzner's book, using Locke's principle of appropriation and using Hayek's idea of the market as a discovery process, manages to prove that the capitalist free enterprise system is not only superior in productivity but also superior in terms of ethical and moral values. Therefore, we do not defend capitalism of free enterprise for a utilitarian reason; we defend it because it is right, because it is defending the values of a correct society.

And if one wanted to have a guide on how to orient their actions, on how to think about problems, it is very important to take as a reference the definition of liberalism from the greatest reference of the ideas of freedom in Argentine history, which is the dear Professor Alberto Benegas Lynch (son). I have repeated this phrase to the point of exhaustion, and I can assure you that I will continue to do so because it is a guiding principle for us. And he says: "Liberalism is the unrestricted respect for the life project of others, based on the principle of non-aggression and in defense of the right to life, liberty, and property." And when you have those values clear, you can frame the analysis of any policy: is there aggression or is there no aggression? What type of aggression is tolerated under the framework of the ideas of freedom? Always in a defensive manner, never in an offensive manner; that is to say, it is always in self-defense. There is also the respect for life, not only for those who have already been born but for those who are yet to be born, who are in evolution. Therefore, I clearly have a tremendously pro-life position, and I say it clearly, and I am totally against abortion, just so you know.

Not to mention the value of freedom. Look at this: the more laws you have, the more regulations there are, with each regulation and each new law determined from top to bottom, you will see that with each law, a little freedom is lost and ceded. That is why, when you have those countries with tangled legal systems, full of regulations, you lose freedom; you lose freedom at the hands of a bureaucrat who, with a single signature, can end up ruining your life.

And we also talked about the right to property, and this is related —it also enters and touches— the issues of what the institutions are on which this system that we defend is built, and the first fundamental institution is private property. Without private property, there is no economic calculation, and Mises had already demonstrated this in 1922 in his book Socialism, where he basically shows the impossibility of socialism due to the impossibility of making economic calculations without the right to property. This implies understanding how the price system works: when a voluntary exchange takes place between two individuals, between two people, where one of these people delivers a good in exchange for another good that acts as money, that generates a historical record called prices, which is the amount of money in exchange for a certain good. That historical record called prices is a signal, which generates that the signal is a mechanism for transmitting signals to society, and that makes some agents at that price decide to be suppliers of that product and others consumers or demanders of that product. That is to say, people coordinate regarding that price as buyers and sellers. And naturally, the quantity that is desired to be bought may not coincide with the quantity that is desired to be sold, and that generates a mechanism of adjustment, that is, a modification in the price. That is to say, the price system is a mechanism of coordination, of signal transmission, of coordination and adjustment. But the central axis of this entire process is triggered when the transaction is made, and at the base of the transaction is the right to property. The right to property lies in the fact that the one selling the good is the legitimate owner of that good, is the owner of the good, has ownership over the good, or what money they would be willing to accept for delivering someone else's good. And clearly, any price, anything is fine if you are delivering something that is not yours, and the same happens on the other side, because if they are paying with something that is not theirs, clearly that makes it not valued either, and therefore, that is trading at false prices. Therefore, the way in which prices are generated implies respecting the right to property, and if the right to property is respected and it is the people themselves who put their goods, their money into that transaction, then the price is indeed the signal that we are looking for to travel through the system to coordinate it and that, if there are disagreements, it adjusts via the price.

Therefore, when you go to the socialist solution, which blocks the right to property, the process automatically becomes uncoordinated, which is why every time we say you have socialism, you have scarcity, you have misery, you have hunger. Why? Because the coordination system is destroyed because there is no private property. And associated with this is the second institution of free enterprise capitalism, which is basically free markets free from state intervention. When you have a market that is intervened, when you have a maximum price, this is very interesting, because you go, read an economics book, they draw the supply curve, the demand curve, and they do not explain that behind that there is a matter of the right to property. In general, textbooks do not usually explain the reason for the hypothesis of the short arm, that is, when you set a maximum price —that is, below equilibrium— there is less supply than demand. And why does that happen? Because if you are curtailing the right to property, at that supposed price you will be offering less, because it is less that you will keep, because the profits are lower, and if they are lower, you will produce less. That is why, if you have aberrant laws, for example, like a supply law... when does the supply law appear? Because after controlling prices, scarcity appears, and as a consequence, the state's club wants you to produce at a loss, and that is not sustainable: in the long run, it ends up eliminating the business. Moreover, it is often said that this is done in favor of the most vulnerable sectors; however, by generating the restriction of supply, the price ends up going towards the arm of demand, at a higher price. And who are the ones who can pay higher prices? Those who have higher incomes. Therefore, the most harmed by price controls end up being those who wanted to benefit, who were the most vulnerable sectors. That is to say, see how state intervention always causes harm. State intervention always makes the remedy worse than the disease. Those who are interested in seeing a book directly on this, I propose you read a book by Ludwig von Mises called Interventionism: The Myth of the Third Way, so you can see all the damage that the state causes when it intervenes. Or I propose you read Man, Economy, and State, by Murray Newton Rothbard, where they basically explain the different interventions of the state and the damage that state intervention causes. Naturally, if you want to see how the free market economy works when you remove the state from the equation, I recommend that from that work you read the third volume, which is Power and Market, where it basically explains various issues in this regard.

The third institution is free markets, but not free in the sense of free competition, not in the neoclassical sense, because in the neoclassical sense the model is so precarious, to put it one way, the model of perfect competition, that if you look at it, there is everything but competition, because they are all price-takers. Consequently, as Hayek said, the perfect competition model is so ridiculous that it has no competition. However, from the Austrian perspective, or the Austrian school of economics, the idea is more similar to what in the neoclassical format is called the theory of contestable markets, developed by William James Baumol, Panzar, and Willig, where it has to do with free entry and that, when you have a model that has free entry and exit and, in addition, the average cost functions have a flat bottom, you could derive situations that are Pareto optimal, even if you had only one player in the market, and that if the demand curve cut the average cost curve in the decreasing section, you would have a solution similar to Ramsey's, which is the second best. It is, ultimately, a very interesting analysis that leaves all those who like intervention in a very bad position. On the other hand, a very important institution, especially for us liberals, is the one that has to do with the division of labor, which also works with the fifth institution, which is social cooperation. This is very important because the division of labor implies recognizing that, thank God, we are all different, that we all have different talents, different virtues, and that we can seek ways to associate or cooperate with other individuals so that we all are much better off. In general, those who study economics and study international economics, when they do the part of real international economics, will find a model that is Ricardo's model, that of comparative advantages, which came to improve Adam Smith's model of absolute advantages. In Adam Smith's model, you were more efficient in good A and less so in good B, and another person appeared who had exactly the inverse qualities. So, you had incentives to trade, but the problem is what would have happened if a person appeared who was better than the other in everything? In that context, there would have been no trade. The great contribution of David Ricardo in this —which the Austrian School of Economics calls "Ricardo's law of association"— is that there is room for everyone in the market. And even if you had an individual or a country that is better in everything than another country, better in everything, there would still be a division of labor, because you would specialize in the things that you are relatively better at, and then you could live much better dedicating yourself to what you are relatively better at, and buy from another, even if they are less productive, and you will have a gain in well-being. And everyone would have a gain in well-being. This is important because the division of labor promotes trade, promotes, fundamentally, greater productivity, and promotes higher living standards. And, moreover, there is a detail not to be overlooked that is in a phrase by Bastiat, which says —(AUDIO CUT)— cooperating, who do not know each other, and says: “And moreover, they could even hate each other, and still all cooperate peacefully for the common good.”

In short, then, we now have a system where those who are successful are successful by serving others with better quality goods at a better price. That is to say, in this story, entrepreneurs, creators are social benefactors, they are people who risk and put their lives on the line to generate a much better society in which we all live much better. That is to say, in our worldview, the entrepreneur, the creator of new goods are social benefactors, they are the heroes of humanity, they are those who have made this world infinitely better, and that is based on capitalism, on saving, and on hard work, as the great professor Miguel Anxo Bastos would say.

So, now we know who we are, we know what our proposal is, and moreover, every time our proposal has been implemented, it has been a success. Those countries that are freer are 12 times richer than the repressed. The growth rate is double that of the repressed countries, there are 25 times fewer poor in the standard format, 50 times fewer in the extreme format, the lowest decile of the distribution in the free country is better off than 90% of the population in the repressed country. That is to say, the system works. The ideas of freedom bring prosperity. Therefore, we are backed by theory, we are backed by empirical evidence, now we have to know what is on the other side and basically, the first thing to understand is what it is based on. The question is, if Marxism was defeated on the plane of economic theory, in fact, there is a book by Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk called “The Conclusion of the Marxian System,” basically where he demonstrates all the errors and aberrations of that monster created by Marx. Where it is fully refuted. That refutation, moreover, as it derived from Menger's Principles of Political Economy, when the subjective theory of value is developed, Marx himself did not publish the second volume of “Capital,” because he had been intellectually defeated and it was published posthumously. But not only that, but this work of Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk was later deepened by Ludwig von Mises in his work “Socialism.” Moreover, it was further deepened in Hayek's work, which is his most popular work “The Road to Serfdom,” and then we have the works of Murray Newton Rothbard or Jesús Huerta de Soto with his doctoral thesis “Socialism, Economic Calculation, and Entrepreneurial Function,” where it is systematically proven that socialism does not work, that statism does not work, that collectivist ideas do not work. If you want something more philosophical, you can go to Ayn Rand, where you clearly have in the novel “Atlas Shrugged” precisely the philosophical basis or you can also see it in Robert Nozick's “Anarchy, State, and Utopia.” So, they were refuted on the plane of ideas and one could say, but, because what is most interesting about socialism? is that it sounds good, it sounds nice, it sounds pleasant and what is the problem with socialism? is that where it was applied, it failed and the reality is that when the wall fell, the wall of shame, back in 1989 it did not demonstrate the superiority of socialism, but rather demonstrated its profound failure.

That is to say, empirical evidence had turned its back, and in reality it is a mistake to consider that the fall of socialism occurred in 1989. The fall of socialism had already occurred in 1961, the day they had to build the wall. That is to say, one day the East Germans saw that they could not cross to the side of the Western economy. That same day was the day socialism failed, because clearly people were not leaving the western side for the eastern side, but were fleeing from the eastern side to go to the western side. I do not see people in Miami getting on sharks to go to Cuba, everyone is trying to leave Cuba for Miami.

Moreover, there is a beautiful book on economic growth by Charles Jones, which in its third edition has an aerial photo, actually a photo from space, of Korea at night. North Korea is dark and South Korea is fully illuminated. Therefore, and this is also important for the action of young people in defense of the ideas of freedom. If you are in the dark, do not complain about the darkness, turn on a light, turn on the light of freedom. So, if you have been refuted theoretically, if you have been refuted by empirical evidence, why do you continue to hold the same position? And the basis of all this is envy, hatred, resentment, which leads to unequal treatment under the law, which leads to violence and which obviously has no problem killing human beings if the ideas require it. Whether it is the 150 million victims of communism or a simple man speaking, debating, and demonstrating that their ideas are wrong, and in that situation, they have no choice but to shoot him in the head. That said, the central axis—why do I say this?—because it could be a matter of personal dislike. Basically, the essential problem lies in the theory of value. All collectivist ideas are based on the labor theory of value. The labor theory of value holds that the value of goods is determined by the amount of labor you add. It seems reasonable, but it makes no sense because I can spend a lot of hours building a straw house and how much will they pay? And suppose you can make another one that exists in a few hours with a 3D printer. Are they going to pay more for the first one because it took more hours? No. They will not pay for that because it will be of no use to them, because the first rain or at the first change, the house will catch fire. That is to say, things do not come, value is not determined by the amount of costs it has. In fact, if that were the case, bankruptcies would not exist because you could load all the costs you want and as a consequence, you could charge whatever price you want, so there would be no bankruptcies, and yet, if there is something that proves capitalism, it is that you compile the list of the 100 richest people throughout the 20th century and you will see how they change from decade to decade. Because it is precisely related to the fact that the creation of wealth depends on whether demand validates that project. The one who determines who has capital in the economy is not the one who buys the machines, but the consumer with their act of consuming that determines whether good A or good B exists. You can make a wonderful good B, but if people do not want it, you will go bankrupt.

So, the theory of value is subjective. Moreover, the value of things, a bottle of water at this moment has a certain value, now surely, in the middle of the Sahara desert with 40 degrees, well, you would pay much more. Consequently, value is subjective. So, and if that was already refuted by Menger in 1871 and in parallel by William Stanley Jevons and Léon Walras, why do these people continue to hold this? Because it allows them to explain Rodbertus's theory of exploitation, which is the one Marx is inspired by to derive surplus value, and which basically states that if the value of goods is determined by the amount of labor they have incorporated, all the differential between price and labor value is exploitation, and they associate that with the unjust structures of property, capitalist institutions, and therefore, private property must be eliminated, and there they would reach the panacea, and every time they destroy private property, all they do is destroy the system, because they remove the price system and therefore the system goes adrift and ends up generating misery.

But then the question is if it failed in theory, if it failed in practice, why do they keep doing it? And there is no other answer than envy. The essential engine of collectivist theories is envy, but they cannot openly accept it. They cannot openly accept that what drives them is envy, hatred, resentment towards those who do things better. That is why they despise merit, that is why they want everyone to be equal, that is why they suffer from what is called the Procrustean syndrome. Procrustes was a person who lived in Greece, in ancient Greece, and was fanatical about equality. So he invited people to his house, invited them to eat, and got them drunk. Then when they were drunk, he proposed they stay overnight. So when they were in bed, if they were too long, he would cut their legs; if they were too wide, he would cut their arms; if even so their head stuck out, he would cut off their head; and if they were too short, he would stretch them. That passion they have for egalitarianism is a savagery, it is pure violence. Imagine if I liked to play basketball. But look at what basketball players are, what do I have to do to have equal opportunities, what, do I have to cut their legs? I want to play against… now I think of playing tennis, so I want to beat Djokovic; for there to be equal opportunities, do I have to chain him to the court so he cannot move and thus there is equal opportunity? What would the result of the spectacle be? It would be a horrific and dreadful spectacle. Because, moreover—and this is what hurts socialists the most—that famous equality they talk about always has to be downward, they always equal downwards. When you present this to them, they say: “No, no, no, we do not want to equal downwards; we want to equal upwards. That is, those who are well will be well; but in reality, it is those who are poorly who will be better.” Well, I will tell you something: that is a lie.

Because one of the things that also characterizes socialists is that they violate budget constraints. If you have an economy where someone produces 100 and another produces 60, there is clearly an inequality, but how much does that economy produce? 160. What is the problem if I want to make everyone earn 100? That economy will have to produce 200 and does not produce 200, it produces 160. Therefore, the only thing left is to bring both down to 80. But what is the problem? That the one who generates 100 and is given 80 will then say: “Why should I produce 100 if they are going to leave me 80?” So what does he do? He lowers to 80. And then what happens? The one who produced 60 continues producing 60 and now from 160 they have dropped to 140 and now they have to re-equalize at 70 and when you continue like this, how far will you end up? You will end up all equally poor in the worst of all. That is why the misery that is generated is generated, and that in dynamic terms, that is why they are increasingly poorer.

But another of the things you will have to deal with in the cultural battle is what is called social justice, which is nothing more aberrant and unjust than social justice. As Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto says, “social justice is unjust.” The question is: who here is in favor of theft? Is anyone in favor of theft? Moreover, not only that: who is in favor of unequal treatment under the law? No one. We all want there to be equality before the law, we are all against theft. However, what is social justice? It is theft plus inequality before the law, because you are going to steal from one group and give it to another, discretionarily; with which, while one is being robbed, another is being given a gift. It is inequality before the law, and also with the aggravating factor that it is preceded by a violent act, which is theft: you are violating property. Consequently, it is an aberration. So, in that sense, it is very interesting. And what drives the desire for that equality? We just saw it: envy. That is why it is very interesting when Thomas Sowell says: what is social justice? Well, social justice is envy plus rhetoric. That is to say, they cannot publicly accept that they are envious, they cannot accept that they are resentful. Consequently, they wrap it in a passion for egalitarianism, and deep down what they are hiding is envy, hatred, and resentment.

And that leads to… And, on top of that, with the cowardice that they do it using the repressive apparatus of the State. That is, the worst of worlds. So, also in another passage, Thomas Sowell says, at what moment did humanity stop considering envy a capital sin, to become a virtue, and that is not all, that is not all, because, moreover, any system that works, no matter how free it is, if individuals are guided by envy, that system will be destroyed. There is a joke that is often made that says: Pedro had a little sheep and was very happy with his sheep and he was happy with his sheep and Juan was deeply envious because Pedro had a sheep and was happy with his sheep. That is to say, instead of being happy to see Pedro happy with the sheep, Juan was deeply resentful and one day while walking, he finds a lamp and a genie comes out of the lamp, then the genie of the lamp tells Juan to make a wish and he would grant it. Clearly, one of the things Juan could have asked for was to bring him 100 sheep, after all, it would be granted. However, what does he ask for? That Pedro's sheep dies. That is socialism. That is to say, they do not care about being worse off. That is to say, they do not care about being worse off as long as the other is worse off, and when you have a system with those characteristics, when you have a society with those values, that society will inevitably self-destruct.

Moreover, a society… look at this, very interesting: when one talks about Sodom, what was the characteristic that Sodom had? Sodom did not respect one of the principles of liberalism, which was property. That is to say, in Sodom the Ten Commandments were violated, because basically it was allowed to steal. Therefore, it was total chaos. That is why the Creator sends a chosen one and says: “Well, if you want me to save them, get me 100 just people.” He does not get them. “Get me 50.” He does not get them. “Get me 10.” He does not get them. “Get me one.” Neither. Therefore, he decides to condemn that people. And when he is leaving with his wife, he tells her not to look back; and the wife does look back and turns into a pillar of salt. Why do you think she turns into a pillar of salt? Because at that moment money was salt. That is to say, it was a city perverted by envy and by theft. And the material theft: money. Consequently, that society destroys itself, and whoever looks towards there will become what? In that same material.

So, if the collectivists had stopped here, it would be much easier. It would be easier to find the refutation. However, they advanced in the argument and the current argument has to do more than anything with what they call social rights. In fact, all this arises from a work by John Rawls, with whom Robert Nozick debates, and basically what he proposes is the hypothesis of the veil. So, you are on one side of the veil, on the other side are those who live, and there are some who are very rich and some who are very poor. If you are risk-averse, basically what are you going to choose? A middle solution. So, if you… it has some problems because that hypothesis because people do not fall from the air. They are not on the other side of the veil by chance. They are there because they are the result of the action of two human beings, a man and a woman who decided to have a child or for some technological reason. It is not that they appear behind the veil and you are doing the math, to see what to do on the other side. No, it does not work that way, it is a nice metaphor, but it does not work that way.

But, aside from the initial fallacy, it is interesting to understand now the State as an insurance: that is the interesting discussion. There is a wonderful book by an author named Robert Murphy, called The Theory of Chaos, and he says: “Well, I want to think about what an anarcho-capitalist society would be like.” Well, the anarcho-capitalist society would have a complete insurance system. So, what is the State in essence? The State is an insurance. And what does the people ask for? An insurance for health, an insurance for education, insurance based on defense and security. So, when one understands this, and understands the aversion to risk, then now they stand in a different place in that debate. There is a book by Hayek very, very criticized by the harder branches of liberalism, called The Road to Serfdom. It is a book that has three books, and in books 1 and 2, you read Hayek and he seems like an anarcho-capitalist, and in book 3 he says: “Well, but people want the State, so how do I solve it?” So, he gives a practical guide on how to resolve in practical life that people want the State. Because there is something that is very interesting: what happens if your car is on fire and you want to buy insurance? Who is going to sell you that insurance? No one is going to sell you that insurance. Well, the State promises to sell you insurance at the very moment your car is on fire, and there they sell you the solution of the State. What was the most emblematic case? The pandemic. The State takes care of you. In Argentina, we discovered that “the State takes care of you” was a lie. We paid a huge premium for that insurance, and if we had done things like a mediocre country, we would have had 30,000 deaths, and yet we had 130,000. That is to say, we paid very dearly for the insurance, and at the same time, the system, when put to the test, did not work. That is the lie of the State.

That is to say, for each of the things that the State offers and proposes, there is always a solution that, implemented from the private sector, can be done much better and more efficiently. And what we should seek, as Hayek suggests, is the way to finance it. But beyond that, it is important to know what issues they will attack. Precisely, what they will work on is fear, and they will want to scare people. So they will say, for example, during the 2023 campaign, they kept saying that I was going to close the universities, and yet, not only were they not closed, but we also have our accounts up to date. And some universities, for example, do not want to be audited. And yet, we are indeed providing the funds. However, they continue to scare people by saying that we want to close them, which is false. It has been almost more than 20 months since we have been in power and we did not do it. Moreover, they kept saying that we were going to promote organ sales: there is no organ sales market. They kept saying that we were going to allow kids to carry guns and shoot each other in school: that is not happening either. In fact, under the management of Minister Patricia Bullrich, we have the lowest crime indicators in Argentine history.

So, they also need to know that due to this aversion to risk that people have and that they want to have certain things, we must find a way to do it more efficiently so that people are not afraid, because basically what they sell is security and certainty, but look, the security they sold and yet, when it comes time to act, they always fail. So, there lies the challenge, to demonstrate that the way they do it is inefficient. For example, right now we have 40,000 km of national roads. We are entering a bidding process for 10,000 km of sectors that are indeed profitable. So, in that case, it will be resolved through the private sector with the bids, and those that are not profitable will be assigned a budget, and whoever provides the best solution will take care of resolving those roads. That is to say, in such a way as to make it efficient and to be as close as possible to the market mechanism. So that the distortion is reduced and those goods are available. But of course, it is much easier to have Vialidad and say that we are going to build a lot of roads as was done in another government and that as a consequence of it, there is a person who is under house arrest because the money for the roads was stolen.

Because, fundamentally, what you have to deal with is that those just causes, those noble causes pivoted on the fear of human beings —which they are in charge of magnifying and using to scare people, they manipulate people through fear, because that is what these people do: they manipulate society by filling it with fears—; so, you have to know how to face these types of issues to be able to unmask them. Because another thing they do, and they do it very skillfully, is that in all those places that are so sensitive to society, behind those noble causes they hide all the scams of the thieving politicians. They use those noble causes to create armies of public employees, who are not really public employees, they are not public servants: they are political militants. And those political militants generate a drain of resources that makes the service that the State will provide of worse quality, that reaches fewer people, that does not reach those who need it, that degrades the provision, when the counterpart is that these political militants enrich themselves at the expense of vulnerable sectors and noble causes. So, when you want to eliminate those spurious expenses so that more resources reach those who truly need them, they will say that you want to exterminate a sector or that you want to eliminate something, when in reality what you are doing is defending those privileges and those scams that those political militants have.

And, moreover, there is another element that is also very important and that you need to know, and it is that those militants who are within the structure of the State, fundamentally, when their political sign is in power, operate as thought police within the structure to purge it of those who think differently. And when their political group is not in power and an opponent is, they use those same militants to undermine the functioning of those institutions. Therefore, as you will see, this not only requires knowledge and cultural battle, but it requires a lot of fortitude because every time we undertake structural reforms in favor of good people, the bad people will be sabotaging the reforms all the time.

And fundamentally, then how do you combat this? Well, first of all, you have to read, guys, you have to study. You have to go and not only know the side of the library that is sympathetic to us; you have to read our library and you also have to read the library from the other side. Economic analysis is also very helpful because it allows you to organize the categories on which the discussion takes place and to see the consequences it has in dynamic terms. On the other hand, there is a fundamental element in all this, which is: every time you have to evaluate a matter of this type, there is a fundamental issue, which is a matter of ethical and moral values. And so you should always make decisions thinking in terms of ethical and moral values, because when you think in ethical and moral terms, there is no room for doubt, there is no utilitarian solution that is valid, because you know what things are right and what things are wrong. You know that stealing is wrong, you know that killing is wrong, you know that lying is wrong, you know that coveting others' goods is wrong. It is no coincidence that the left is so antagonistic and pursues with such violence those who defend Judeo-Christian values, stigmatizing them as fundamentalists, as anti-science. False. Because, fundamentally, you with your beliefs are not bothering anyone, you do not affect, you do not harm anyone, you do not alter anyone's life, you do not touch anyone's property or freedom. Therefore, you can believe in whatever you want. But of course, what is the problem? That capitalism is built on the foundations of Judeo-Christian values, and that is why they attack people of faith, and that is also why they attack Israel with such violence. Because, fundamentally, Israel is the bastion of the West, because it is the foundation of Western culture. And they try to take down Israel to try to take down capitalism.

Finally, another concept that is wonderful, I remember that months ago I had the honor, the privilege of receiving in Argentina Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto. The CIADE decided to award him an honorary doctorate and since I had received the last honorary doctorate, I was called to give the speech praising the contributions of Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto, and there I reviewed all his contributions and pointed out that the contribution that had impacted me the most from Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto is what is known as the theory of dynamic efficiency. In fact, after he was awarded the doctorate, I announced that when we were going to be decorating Professor Huerta de Soto, we held a talk when we decorated him in the Salón Blanco at Casa Rosada, about liberalism, and in my case, I spoke about this contribution of Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto that I find so, so, so wonderful.

This theory of dynamic efficiency is very important because it relates to economic growth, to the way in which maximum economic growth can be generated in an economy, and it is interesting because it had a previous discussion about Pareto optimality and all the objections that many of us liberals have regarding the issue of Pareto optimality and all the policies associated with it, starting by saying that it cannot be that something that is efficient is unjust. That is to say, you cannot kill justice at the altar of efficiency. It cannot be that you justify carrying out violent and unjust actions in favor of a supposed efficiency. That cannot be. That cannot take place, it cannot be that to gain efficiency you have to implement unjust actions, and the corollary of that is that everything that is efficient must necessarily be just, and this is very interesting, because to be clear about what is just and what is not, you do not need to know about economics to maximize growth and well-being and prosperity; what you really need to do is embrace the correct ethical and moral values, and clearly the correct ethical and moral values on which Western civilization was built are Judeo-Christian values, and that is what free enterprise capitalism is built on, and that has allowed the greatest civilizational feat in the history of humanity.

Therefore, now you can understand why I close my speeches the way I do. Therefore, may God bless you all. May the forces of heaven be with us. And long live freedom, damn it, long live freedom, damn it! Thank you very much.