Words of President Javier Milei at the NOA Economic Forum 2026 in Tucumán.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

19 March 2026 · NOA Economic Forum 2026 · Tucumán

Context
Milei addressed the NOA Economic Forum 2026 in Tucumán, Argentina, delivering remarks linking Adam Smith's liberal philosophy to his government's economic policy program.
Main themes
Adam Smith's intellectual legacy, The Wealth of Nations, morality as state policy, liberal economic philosophy, Juan Bautista Alberdi, Argentine constitutional thought, moral philosophy, theory of moral sentiments, natural law and legitimacy, public policy design, NOA regional economic development
Duration
~75 min
97th percentile
Words
9,036
97th percentile
Sentences
417
97th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 64%59%
  • Social 23%22%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 2%1%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

417 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Hello everyone. Good afternoon. First of all, thank you to the authorities of this forum for inviting me once again to speak. And I like, whenever I come to Tucumán, to remember one of our great heroes of freedom, who is Alberdi, the ideologue of our Constitution. He is one of our great thinkers, not only for Argentina but globally recognized for his work. And obviously, he is the ideologue of the Constitution. In that sense, it also coincides with the fact that we recently celebrated 250 years since the publication of that wonderful work by Adam Smith, which gave rise to the birth of economics as a science, which is that book called An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, which, at its core, are the foundations upon which Alberdi pivots when thinking about the economic and rental system of Argentina.

And, in light of the fact that we, as liberals, carry a government program strongly inspired by these ideas, basically what I intend to do today is to describe the essential contributions of Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations, which have a direct consequence on the way we design our public policies or state policies.

We have recently been developing and presenting an idea that is this notion of morality as a state policy, and the reality is that when one reviews the entire work of Adam Smith, we realize that this was actually already invented, only that we saw it in a different way and in another format. But, basically, it is not made explicit, but it is indeed implicit in the way Adam Smith addresses the issues.

Adam Smith was basically a great professor of moral philosophy. His course on moral philosophy had four parts. There was a part that was basically theology; in general, Adam Smith did not usually make references to theology because at that time some misinterpretations that could be made were quite complicated in terms of results to the point that they could cost one their life. Therefore, he tried not to… And besides, his friend David Hume, for having opinions contrary to the thinking of the time, was marginalized from several chairs and so on. For which reason, Adam Smith tries to be quite prudent on the subject. That does not mean that he did not have a position, but that is part of another story.

And the second issue, the second part of his course, was the ethics part, and it is precisely linked to one of his most well-known works, which is the one with which he actually became famous, which is The Theory of Moral Sentiments, where he basically develops the concept of empathy. But if one reaches the final part of the book, which is when he addresses the topic of the cardinal virtues, he shows his alignment with the Stoics.

Then he had the part of political economy, which is basically the inquiry into the nature and causes of The Wealth of Nations, which precisely covers that part of the course, and the last part was related to jurisprudence. Adam Smith had generated material on this, he had a project to write a book on jurisprudence. Jurisprudence in Adam Smith is not in the sense that we understand it today, as that law that is created from the sanctions of judges, but one must understand it in the logic of his course on moral philosophy, which has to do with the moral question. That is to say, basically with what is just, that discussion on that side.

And in that sense, it is always good to be clear that something can be legal but not necessarily legitimate. When you create norms that go against natural law, that becomes essentially illegitimate, and the natural result is that it leads to bigger problems than those it tries to correct. I say this is not only valid for law, it is valid for almost any order of life.

And that part of Adam Smith's work… he requested that when he died they burn it; and indeed they did burn it. But what could be salvaged were the notes, and with that, his thought on the subject could be partially reproduced. A different fate befell his other essays, where for example there is the history of astronomy, which he also requested to be burned. There they did not listen to him, and they are indeed published.

And the other work known by Adam Smith is all the epistolary exchanges, where undoubtedly the richest part is all the interaction with David Hume. I also have the feeling that he was someone extremely nice and profoundly liberal, because it was Hume himself who took Rousseau to England, someone with whom he clearly thought differently. Rousseau initially took it well, and after the beating he received, he got angry with Hume, and I doubt that Hume took him there to be made fun of. I mean, he took him for the debate. I have that feeling, and they were also very ironic; they were very funny guys when one reads them in the epistolary exchanges.

Basically, what I want to comment on today about Adam Smith are three blocks that, for me, from my point of view, are important to understand Adam Smith, to understand the interaction with our National Constitution and why it is decisive for our government. I do not have the pretension of being, nor generalist, nor of being certain and truthful about what is my opinion of Adam Smith and how it has a direct impact on the way we make decisions.

Basically, I place Adam Smith's contributions in The Wealth of Nations in the logic of three blocks. The first block, where I most appreciate Adam Smith, is the fact that he is someone who wrote 200 years ahead of his time. I used to use a phrase regarding Adam Smith, and that is that Adam Smith is to economics what Gauss is to mathematics. He is someone who was 200 years ahead, only that he had a different character. That is to say, how Adam Smith had a very strong teaching vocation, he was very friendly and so on; in the case of Gauss, he was quite harsh—Carlos Federico—and well, he had only one disciple because he had no patience for people who thought so slowly compared to him. Well, but that disciple was Riemann, right? I mean, the disciple was someone more…

Now the interesting thing is that I thought I had a great definition about Adam Smith, and the reality is that, reviewing material, biographies, and so on about Adam Smith, I discovered that I was not very original in that, that his best student, named John Miller, had already done it. And he said that Adam Smith was the Newton of moral philosophy. So I think that is an even better definition than mine.

Now, why is it important to discuss Adam Smith? Because he clearly was 200 years ahead; he is basically the one who first saw what in economic growth theory is called the hockey stick. The hockey stick is a graph that we owe to an economist named Madison, may he rest in peace, where basically what Madison does, the field is called millennial macroeconomics—it is a field that he basically invented—and he looks at GDP per capita throughout history. The first part he did between the year 1000 and 2000 of the Christian era, then he did it up to the year zero, and the reality is that if one looks at the conditions of man, they essentially did not change until the arrival of the Industrial Revolution.

This does not mean that I think the takeoff in terms of the moment when the Industrial Revolution appears, which is factual, but that there is something that is generated before. I mention this because the version I like most of the explanation of the hockey stick, which is a GDP per capita that is stagnant, with a slight improvement of 40% after the discovery of America, which spread over the time that this series is viewed implied a GDP per capita growth of 0.02%. That is to say, we needed 3500 years to double GDP. And, in that sense, when we reach the moment of the Industrial Revolution, after that, GDP per capita multiplied by 15 times, and the population multiplied by 10. This means that we have lived a situation of wealth generation never seen in the history of humanity.

Now, from my point of view, that situation is… growth processes have a logic of exponential functions, and they start very slowly, and when they find a turning point, they accelerate. I see the Industrial Revolution as that turning point. However, when you see those two periods, you have what is called the Malthusian period, which is the period of stagnation; and then you have the growth period, which no one calls the period of Adam Smith, and I would say that Adam Smith did see it. And that in economics, first it was attempted to analyze with the growth models of the 1950s, the Solow model is the emblematic one; and the problem with that model is that it did not explain real growth. It explained the transition to an equilibrium GDP per capita, but in the steady state of that model, it does not generate growth; it generates convergence, but in reality, in the long term, it does not generate growth.

And all that discussion in the literature made that by the mid-70s, that literature was practically outdated, on the way to extinction until an economist named Paul Romer appeared who in 1983, being a mathematician, a student of Robert Lucas Jr., developed the Theory of Endogenous Growth, and in 1985, Robert Lucas Jr. himself popularized it in what are the Lionel Robbins Lectures, and from there, economists began to discover the theory of endogenous growth, which is what allows explaining the part of the “hockey stick” that rises. In that context, you have a theory that explains pre-industrial revolution—which is the Malthusian theory—and then you have another which are the endogenous growth models. The truth is that the other models in the middle served to reach the endogenous ones, nothing more; it was a process of learning, to put it one way. But aside from that, it serves to explain convergence, that is something quite interesting and positive in light of the problems we face, but there was no unification, and there is a theory called the Unified Growth Theory by an author named Oded Galor, which basically manages to link the two models, the Malthusian dynamics and the dynamics of exponential growth, and he focuses on human capital.

The main invention here then becomes the printing press, and from Gutenberg's printing press, knowledge begins to spread increasingly on a larger scale, and that allows an interaction that has appeared liberal thought and respect for property rights at the center, starting from Locke, then it derives and triggers the Industrial Revolution, and from there we experience. Well, what Galor does is precisely link those two parts.

Beyond how it is resolved to each one's preferences, the important thing is: okay, Adam Smith saw it. And the truth is that standing at the moment Adam Smith wrote, there was not much evidence to see why he had seen it. That is why it is very important; that is why he has more than earned the title of father of economics. Because, at the core, excuse the term, but what the hell do we do economics for if not to make people better off? When you go and read a book on economic growth, unless it is a very old book… all books on economic growth have a phrase from Robert Lucas Jr., which says that when one starts thinking about these problems, one cannot think of anything else. That phrase derives from a talk that Robert Lucas Jr. is giving where he compares two countries and says one is doing well and the other is doing poorly. So he says, well, what explains these differences? And of course, it is economic growth. When one starts to think about that, one clearly cannot think of anything else.

Before the Industrial Revolution, not only did 800 million human beings live on the planet and lived poorly, more than 95% of the population lived below the extreme poverty line. Today that number in a population ten times larger is less than five. In fact, the extreme poverty line is being changed all the time so that the number nine appears, so to speak.

So, in that sense, it is not trivial because we are talking about improving people's quality of life. And that was what he was trying to study in The Wealth of Nations, because it is precisely an inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. And there the central core that explains economic growth and explains much of the issues we discuss today, if I tell you something: in light of how we live today and wanted to explain, well, we need to understand what is going to generate growth from here on out. Undoubtedly, a fundamental role, who will have it? Artificial intelligence. Well, the interesting thing about Adam Smith is that artificial intelligence is the pin factory of the 21st century.

And all those fears and all those dystopian scenarios, which in fact I discussed at the G7, invited not because Argentina was part of the G7, but because Meloni invited me to talk about that, is: let’s discard the dystopian scenarios, they make no sense, they are built on bad economic theory. And I have 250 years of empirical evidence in my favor. And that idea, which is the idea of the pin factory, which has to do with the division of labor, basically the technical name in economics is called increasing returns.

Adam Smith, who was also a fanatic of Newton, because he was an intense fanatic, not a more or less fanatic - the entire Scottish Enlightenment is a fanatic of Newton, moreover - they were people who first looked at the data, they were people who were only excited about looking at numbers and real, tangible things. So, one of the things Adam Smith knows is a pin factory. So you have if a person dedicated themselves to making a pin alone, even if they were an expert, they could make 20 a day. What he says and observes is that if you split the activity into 18 and have 10 people doing it, one of the things that results is that production jumps to 48,000; that is, 4,800 for each one. In other words, there is a phenomenal increase in productivity. That is, the division of labor generates an increase in productivity. This means that by increasing the amount of work, production increases more than proportionally. This in economics is called increasing returns, that is, when you incorporate a factor, production grows more than proportionally.

In general, when you go to a microeconomics book or a growth economics book and so on, and the production function is described, it is not described in that way, it is written in the Malthusian way. That is, production grows, but less than proportionally. In fact, the first to try to refute Adam Smith was Malthus. In light of the facts, if you had hired an econometrician in 1801, they would have sided with Malthus. But it is the virtue of Adam Smith; he saw it. He saw the hockey stick when the hockey stick did not exist.

So basically when you look at the hockey stick, it is Adam Smith. Why? Because the population multiplied by 10, but production did so by 150, that is, it increased 15 times more. And Adam Smith not only raises this issue of increasing returns, but he also says ‘but this has a limit’, that is, this cannot go anywhere, so it does not go to infinity. In a growth book that mocks economists, it says: only two types of people can believe that trees can reach the sky: fools and economists. So it says it is not that trees reach the sky, no, this has a limit. Adam Smith limits it from two sides, one is the size of the market. And this becomes quite evident. I love the example that Juan Carlos de Pablo uses in this regard. Suppose you are a doctor. Well, if you are going to live in a very small town, what is better for you? To be a hyper-specialist in a very particular issue or to be a generalist? The answer is obvious; you have to be a generalist, so it is not even worth discussing. In contrast, if you live in a big city, there is room for you to specialize in different fields. Well, that is the division of labor. You are going to specialize. This pin factory that does the division of labor, why does it reach 48,000 pins? Because it can sell them, because if it cannot sell them to anyone, it will be limited. That is, the division of labor will then have a clash, which is the size of the market.

When they start with all the dystopian scenarios, they say “no, it will leave people out” and the question is what is it that artificial intelligence does? Artificial intelligence for artificial intelligence? No. They make artificial intelligence so that a product has certain characteristics, that it is of better quality, at a better price, and what do they do? They sell it to someone. In principle, we have a limit. There are 8.25 billion people, there is a limit, it does not go anywhere.

And then there is another limit, which economic theory, from my point of view, treats poorly, and that is that to prevent trees from reaching the sky, they impose restrictions on the models. That, with Dr. Demián Reidel, we have corrected in a paper. I mentioned that paper in Davos, at the last Davos meeting, and what we actually say is, well, it cannot go to infinity because fundamentally you have a resource constraint and the limiting resource is? There is a limit, it is labor. You cannot work more than 24 hours a day. You cannot work more than 24 hours a day. Moreover, if you wanted to do it, you could not do it for long. That is, because sooner or later you will collapse with the physical restriction of your human body. So, there is a limit; it is not unlimited either.

In the case we have developed with Demián, the result is that there are multiple equilibria. There are three equilibria. There is an intermediate equilibrium that is unstable and there are two stable equilibria. One is, you become a prosperous society and in the other you become a miserable society, and it all depends on how much effort you put into working. Thus, we return to Adam Smith, an exaltation of work. This also has to do with his religious position, yes. For some, it seems like a criticism; for me, it seems precisely this appreciation and valuation of work.

Now it seems abstract. There is a movie that I love, which is Homo Argentum, and it has a vignette that addresses this problem. They did not address it explicitly because they knew about growth, but they saw it. It is the case when Francella is in a restaurant eating and a boy comes to ask him for something. Then, the waiter tries to get him out and says: no, let him be, and invites him to eat and gives him food, and then he invites him, takes him to buy a cell phone, takes him to buy clothes, takes him to buy shoes. And the interesting part, what is it? That when he is taking him home, he says - it is brilliant -: “you are lucky,” he says. “You have a lot of time, you can dispose of time, while I am like this…” The kid looks at him as if to say “you have a pile, a cake of money and the kid is in the… And when he looks at him, Francella realizes and says: “Well, but if I have to choose my situation or yours, I stick with mine.”

But the important thing is that you could generate two types of equilibria, that is, both are stable, only that one is a poverty trap and the other you will be rich. And so now you are going to start to understand what I am trying to convey: any intermediate equilibrium is unstable. Either you go towards wealth or you go towards poverty. But the determining factor that moves you one way or the other is that you work. And if you have been promoting idleness for 100 years based on that filth of social justice, and you have been promoting parasitism, it was logical that we were going to crash. Call it 2023, Argentina of 2023, was on its way to becoming Cuba with an intermediate stop in Venezuela.

That is, 100 years of promoting idleness, the parasitism of so many leftist ideas, because essentially the left is an idea of parasites. That is, they are people who inherently do not want to work, because if they work, they feel exploited; if they are bosses, they are exploiters; and if they are unemployed, they are unfortunate. So, what do they do? They parasitize the state. The only thing they do in their lives is develop rhetoric so that you feel guilty for their misery and then pick your pocket.

And that, to the Argentines, presented two options for change. There was a more radicalized option that was represented and represents La Libertad Avanza, and there was a non-radicalized one, which we have the honor of having here with us, who competed with me, Dr. Bullrich, and who had the greatness that when people preferred the more radicalized option, instead of opting for a miserable situation, she decided to get involved with this radical change that we have promoted; with which we are making the best government in history, but this is thanks to Dr. Bullrich deciding to put her personal issues aside to build a better Argentina. So thank you very much, Dr. Bullrich.

Therefore, those who escaped the poverty trap and avoided that intermediate equilibrium that was leading us towards Cuba, in reality, it is the merit of the Argentines because they put in the effort and had the courage to change. We only interpret that change.

Therefore, the pin factory is more present than ever, but in different formats. And the other thing Adam Smith does is, because we must also understand that in his time, he said, well, how do I make this model not explode, he creates the Labor Theory of Value and in that way, he ties the whole model to labor. We, with Demian, were able to create a version in line with the value theory we work with today.

Now, did Adam Smith only generate that? No, he did not only generate that. In addition, he described technological progress. Think that The Wealth of Nations was written between 1766 and 1776. That is, he described technological progress. He described technological progress in two ways: One was what we today call learning by doing. He says, well, you took… not only that when you partition the number of activities you start to waste less time switching from one activity to another, that is, there is a time saving, but also you learn to do it better and every day you do it better and better, you become more productive because you learn to do your job better as the activity progresses. But at one point, you discover that there is a way of so much that you learned to do it that allows you to make a leap in productivity to save time. Because fundamentally, work is nothing more than leisure made available in the market. So, what happens? In that context where you value your time, you make an improvement and that makes a leap in productivity. That is called technological progress; with the same amount of time, you produce more. That is, with the same amount of input, you produce more, or you can produce the same, but working less, or with fewer inputs, that is technological progress. That is, Mr. Adam Smith had seen it.

One of the things that happened to me while reviewing all this material for the conference we gave yesterday at the Palacio Libertad is that I discovered that when Adam Smith was rector of Glasgow, he had assigned a workshop in Glasgow to James Watt, that is, to the inventor of the steam engine. That is, Adam Smith saw it and captured it in a model that said: “Well, if we go this way, this will generate wealth.” That is, the guy had already seen it. That is, he was interacting with the steam engine inventor. It is like Jules Verne, yes, of course, why? Because he interacted with scientists; that is also something to consider about how well Adam Smith saw it.

Another thing that is also very important is that Adam Smith, within the virtues he considers, which is prudence, from which self-interest derives, has two dimensions of what he calls prudence. Prudence, the first thing I suggest is that when we use Adam Smith's terms, we think about when he wrote and think that Adam Smith was a super erudite guy, who knew Latin, who knew Greek, and who knew ancient Greek. So he spent a lot of time choosing words. For example, for Adam Smith, sympathy is something quite similar and aligns it with the Greek meaning of compassion; and that, in the terminology we use today, for example, is empathy. We will use this later, in the last part when we then get into politics, in the design of state policies.

In that sense, when you work on traditional savings models, what you do is, a model like Solow, you increase savings and what increases is the steady-state per capita GDP, but once you reach the steady state, the growth rate does not change. That is, you have a one-time jump and forever, then you have to converge; that is a second-order element, but it does not modify the long-term growth rate. It only modifies the dynamic transition; you go from this per capita GDP to a higher one, you will converge, and that’s it.

In contrast, in the Endogenous Growth Theory, when you generate a jump in savings, what is generated is a jump in the growth rate. So you come to a growth path and you will go to a higher one, so the per capita GDP will already be higher, but that does not stop at some point. No, that becomes permanent. That is not minor to the effects of what has happened in the history of humanity in the last 250 years. That is what we economic growth people focus on. Well, I say we do, when I was a serious economist, I did those things; then I dedicated myself to something else. I got into politics, and ended up, by the will of the Argentines, being the President of the Nation.

So, it means that there is an important role for savings. Well, this is not trivial, because on the other side, we have the cavemen, we have the baboons, we have the Keynesians who what do they want to do all the time? They want to promote consumption, consumption, consumption, consumption, consumption, consumption, it is a multiplier, it is a multiplier, it is a multiplier, and the reality is that if you reduce savings, savings is future consumption. That is, when you save, savings finances investment, and that is what generates an increase in per capita product. Because it increases the per capita capital stock and, therefore, the per capita product. Therefore, promoting consumption at the expense of savings is what blows up economic growth.

That is why these savages, when they left, left us with a 15% fiscal deficit in terms of GDP, 5 in the Treasury and 10 in the Central Bank. Obviously, since Argentina was also a serial defaulter, it also had the agreement with the Fund fallen through — how was it financed? By printing money, and in the year 2023, the beasts who throughout the last period they were in government, and we hope it was the last in history, for which we work intensively, financed 28% of GDP with monetary issuance. But, in the last year, they issued 13 points of GDP. That is why inflation was traveling at one and a half daily. It is incredible that those scoundrels who left the wholesale rate at 54% daily, excuse me, monthly, which annualized gives 17,000, come and complain if we have one monthly, which is 13 annually.

And they cannot say that I just started talking about the wholesale rate, because I have been talking about it for a long time since the beginning of the wholesale rate, because it is the one that anticipates. That is to say, sooner or later, if we continue doing our homework and the relative price corrections are completed, the correction of relative prices, a result of the atrocities committed by the previous government, you know what? Inexorably, inflation will end in Argentina.

How do we achieve this? We said we would go to zero deficit in the first year and they said that was impossible, that, with luck, with a lot of luck and a lot of guts, we could reach equilibrium by the end of our term. Fortunately, we came across a gentleman they call Toto who put the accounts in order in a month.

And we fixed the disaster of the Central Bank in six months. And the monetary base has not grown since mid-2024. Therefore, when the effects of the money overhang as a consequence of having had capital controls are cleaned up, when the lagging effects of monetary policy are cleaned up, and when the disaster they caused during the second half of last year, trying to overthrow a government, is cleaned up, when all that passes, it is to be expected that by August of this year, retail inflation will start at zero. Like it or not.

Obviously, the economy is a social science, it is not a natural science, that is, it is not physics; things can happen in the world, there can be a spike in the price of oil, there can be a spike in the price of gas. Okay, that can happen; the price level can jump, which manifests temporarily as higher inflation, but as long as you continue to maintain fiscal balance and tighten monetary policy, as we are doing since mid-2024, inexorably, sooner or later, inflation will end in Argentina.

Therefore, we have the issue of increasing returns. We are preparing for artificial intelligence, we have technological progress, we have the exaltation of savings, we have the exaltation of work. And now comes another part that I love, and that is also part of the discussion of economic theory, and it is the second block that I want to address about Adam Smith, which is the supposed contradiction in Adam Smith between the pin factory and the idea of the invisible hand. The invisible hand, the reality is that some believe it refers to the creator, others to supply and demand, others to general equilibrium, others to laissez-faire, others to Pareto optimality. The reality is that beyond the metaphor that Adam Smith used, which is brilliant because it immortalized his work, I believe that the vast majority have not read The Wealth of Nations; they boast of reading Keynes and have not read him. So, The Wealth of Nations, which is a bit older, I doubt anyone has delved into it with much enthusiasm unless they like the history of economic thought, some of us do. But the important thing is that the idea of the invisible hand, how it was treated by neoclassical economists. The idea of the invisible hand is spontaneous order; it was not original to Adam Smith's idea of spontaneous order. It was something of the time. It was in Mandeville, it was in Hume, it was in different authors. The idea of spontaneous order was floating around and was part of a debate they had at the time, especially in Scotland, a Scotland that, as a result of uniting with England and opening up to trade, and where the Scottish port was much cheaper than Bristol, yes. So, they began to trade tobacco that came from the United States, from Virginia, from North Carolina, South Carolina, New Jersey, New York, Massachusetts, and that generated an explosion of wealth in Scotland. So, the Scottish aristocrats were people who had filled their pockets with trade; they were not like the English. So, they put a lot of effort into education; that is where the Scottish Enlightenment takes on great relevance, and the interesting thing is that the same thing happens in every society that begins to prosper: what begins to emerge? A group of envious, despicable people who start clamoring for income distribution.

And this must also be said. The motive that drives socialists is envy. And they must be told to their face until they feel ashamed of being leftists. Because deep down, if I earned my money honestly, serving others with better quality goods or at a better price, I am a hero and I do not have to give explanations to anyone. And who is the other to say what I am going to do with my money?

There are a couple of fabulous phrases from Sowell; he says: What is social justice? Envy plus rhetoric. And at one point, Sowell asks: Since when did a capital sin like envy become a virtue? That is to say, and this is not minor, because this is what we are going to discuss in the moral realm, which is the way we think about policies. But the most interesting thing about all this is that in that context was Mandeville, who said, well, progress also has to do with rather unsavory virtues, that is, a misinterpretation of how the system works. That is why Adam Smith works on the theory of moral sentiments; there he begins to develop the idea of the invisible hand and finishes it in the functioning of the economic system in The Wealth of Nations. But they also had Rousseau on the other side, who said: “No, no, economic progress brings with it certain virtues; it is better to be a savage,” and he spoke of the noble savage. Not for nothing, when they apply socialism, they end up in a primitive society. So, the idea of the invisible hand that neoclassical theory takes is that, obviously, each one following their own interest leads to maximum well-being; that is in Smith. But Smith did not say what they have to do is what the neoclassicals do, which says, OK, my concern is that equilibrium exists, that it exists, that it is unique, that it is stable. But now I want it to be optimal, so the functions from which equilibrium is derived must be optimal, and that implies that I have to optimize or maximize utility, subject to budget constraints for consumers, and I have to maximize profits for producers. And from there come the demand functions for goods and supply of factors in the first case; in the second, the supply of goods and demand for factors. And those functions, if they find an equilibrium, now it is also optimal.

Now, the problem with that function is that when you take to have maximum profit, maximum profit implies that that function, to be unique, must be strictly concave. That is to say, that marginal returns must be decreasing. So, there seems to be a contradiction in Adam Smith that has to do with the fact that he works with increasing returns; therefore, they are not maximizable functions except at the edge, and it is not coherent with the idea of the invisible hand. The problem is not Adam Smith; the problem is how the neoclassicals interpreted him.

That is why I make a whole point in the Davos speech about efficiency, and I say the correct vision is that of Hans-Hermann Hoppe, because he derives optimality from Locke's principle of appropriation and the principle of non-aggression. And that allows you to derive an optimum without having to adhere to a mathematical structure. Therefore, that controversy that Adam Smith has a contradiction is wrong; it is perfectly consistent. And you can also resolve it in Hoppe's terms, and if you want to resolve that mathematically, we also did that solution with Dr. Reidel. I ask you a question: What are companies? An autonomous entity that does things because...? Do you think that, for example, if companies were as the neoclassical theory proposes, it means that you put a computer and an entrepreneur to run a company, and it is the same? Well, it is clear that this is nonsense.

That said, I ask you a question: What are companies? Abstract entities that belong to no one? Why does an entrepreneur have a company? What is a game? No, let’s see, not a pastime; I don’t know, what do I do? I get into trouble to obtain inputs and generate a product for nothing. Who owns the companies? The entrepreneurs, and what are entrepreneurs? Are they Martians? No, they are human beings who consume things, who have fun, who do something. Therefore, what happens in a company impacts the life of the entrepreneur, of those who have shares in those companies. Consequently, that split between what is the consumer and the entrepreneur is nonsense. It is useful as a mathematical tool; it is called the separation theorem; it is nice. But have you ever seriously thought about the Robinson Crusoe model? When you look at the Robinson Crusoe model, what happens in the textbook? No, first they look at Robinson Crusoe as a consumer, then they look at Robinson Crusoe as an entrepreneur, and then as if he had a problem of multiple personalities… He interacts between himself and a certain equilibrium price. Robinson's life was whether he climbed the tree to get the coconuts or not. And then he checked more or less how much work it cost him and how many coconuts he wanted. It is not that Robinson the consumer plans, and besides, what was Robinson's budget constraint? What was he going to eat on the island if it weren’t for the coconuts? And to have the coconuts, he had to work. You cannot separate that; that is neoclassical economic theory; it does not separate, and that is wrong, and that is why this ghostly figure of Pareto optimality appears, which clashes with the pin factory. I mean, these guys think there is a conflict between the invisible hand and the pin factory. No. They are the same entrepreneurs. In fact, the Austrians say we are all entrepreneurs.

So, the reality, what I have just demonstrated is that there is no such inconsistency, and that in reality this makes us supporters of free competition, of the free market. In this, Adam Smith also had a very pro-competition position, to promote competition. He had an idea of what the equilibrium price was, which he called the natural price; he had an idea of the market price, and he called those things… notice how fanatical he was about Newton that he spoke, for example, of rest and gravitation, which has to do with rest being when they found equilibrium and gravitation being how they move towards equilibrium. So, with which Adam Smith was serious about mathematics. But all this, let’s say, one of the parts that Adam Smith does is annihilate the mercantilists, that is, the protectionists, all the prebendaries. So, I am going to take the liberty of reading you something to see how advanced Adam Smith was, that he saw it all. I am going to take it from a book so that no one thinks it is part of my malice.

He says: “Certainly, free trade between countries was too ambitious a desire, even idealistic. With his usual pragmatism, Smith argues that expecting free trade to be completely restored in Great Britain is as absurd as expecting Utopia and Oceana to be established. Not only are there public prejudices, but something more difficult to conquer, the private interests of many people who oppose it.” Now let’s see who are those who oppose it. “Those people were part of the tribe of monopolists, after comparing the East India Company to an army that could intimidate Parliament.” That is, the regulators intimidating the representatives of the people, a very, very violent thing that he describes. He says: “He describes how the monopolists applauded and rewarded those who defended their privileges. In contrast, the unleashed insolence of the furious and disillusioned monopolists would fall upon anyone who wanted to alter those privileges, even putting their lives in danger.” Two hundred and fifty years have passed, and the relationship with this gang of criminals remains the same.

That is to say, if you… let’s ask the question the other way around, are you against freedom? Are you in favor of theft? Well, the question is why does a politician have to appear who restricts your freedom, so that you cannot dispose of your goods as you please? Moreover, if you had two identical goods, identical in every way, the only difference being the price, and one is more expensive and one is cheaper, which one would you buy? The cheaper one. In other words, you would choose that. So the question is, why would a politician arrogate to himself the power to restrict your freedom so that you buy a product of higher price and lower quality, and to prevent you from doing so, he raises a wall in such a way that you can be robbed? Is it clear that this is an immorality? It is clear that you are condemning people to have higher prices, you are condemning people to have lower wages, you are condemning people to have less production, less present consumption, and less future, and in addition, it restricts their freedom. And you harm almost 48 million people to save three crooks. That said, it is clear that it is profoundly immoral, but also because it goes against freedom, because it goes against property, it is also inefficient because if you could spend 100 on something that they are charging you 400 for, you save 300 and reallocate the resources to another sector that is more productive and therefore will be able to pay higher wages, there will be more products at lower prices with higher wages, that is, it increases well-being.

So, the measure is not only efficient, but we also said it was fair, it is efficient and in addition, 48 million people win and a group of crooks lose. Now the question is, as it says here, now those who defend these barbarities will be applauded and praised by the monopolists, that is, by the privileged businessmen who throw tons of money at journalists, and then you find that you do something for the good of, let’s say, decent Argentines and you find that the journalists are shaking you and that behind that are the privileged, all against decent Argentines and also, the corrupt politicians because if a privileged businessman says, “No, well, but I arrived and that restriction was there,” nonsense.

So, you know that it is unjust, if you know that it is unjust, if someone comes and wants to remove it, you don’t shoot them in the head, you take it and say “ok, fine” eighty years have passed of infant industry, let’s say, I made a mess with all the Argentines, but, OK, someone came and wanted to change things. But the question is, if there is a barrier that can be managed by the government, that allows them to sell something four times more expensive, the question is, do you think that in the other governments there were angels who said “oh, look at this” or did they tell you “come here, between 100 and 400 there is a huge difference,” do you remember that someone said that it could bankrupt a company, that company did not go bankrupt, the conditions of competition did not change, that was said for flat steel, for the pipes they cursed them on television, but then they bought those pipes and the ton of pipe instead of being paid 1400 dollars was paid 4000 and that is paid by all Argentines because that was the pipes through which gas was transported.

So, the question is, are you also in favor of corruption? Well, it seems that there are political businessmen and journalists who are in favor of higher prices, lower wages, fewer jobs, worse quality, and above all, poorer, more indigent people, but on top of all that, corruption. That is why they have politicians, businessmen, and those who fill their envelopes speaking in favor of the criminals. In essence, the method is more or less the same, back then they burdened you with your life. Well, now they do a media slaughter because they have to defend the interests of the criminals of the system. Because among firefighters, they are not going to step on each other’s hoses. So, see if Adam Smith is still relevant.

And then another part that seems super interesting to me… so I am not attacking businessmen, I am attacking crooks. The thing is, they are so perverse that they say “attack the businessmen.” No, I do not attack businessmen, I do not attack honest people; I attack dishonest people. I think it is a fight worth having.

And then, the other discussion about Adam Smith, which is called the Adam Smith controversy, which disputes the contribution of Adam Smith in The Theory of Moral Sentiments and the contribution of Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations; because it says that the virtues he proposes, which is sympathy, what we would today call empathy, in the theory of moral sentiments is tied to the idea of self-interest and that this poses an inconsistency. In reality, there is no such inconsistency. The problem is that the leftists, showing off what they always do, which is the straw man fallacy, the leftists, they do this very frequently, say “You said such a thing” and they hit you based on what you supposedly said according to what they say you said. And one often falls into the trap of wanting to respond that what they said you did not say. These are all the tricks with which the leftists usually play dirty in the debate. And one of the things they did with the concept of Adam Smith is confuse the concept of empathy or in Smith’s terminology of that time, sympathy, with the idea of benevolence. One thing is that I put myself in someone else’s shoes and rationally understand the pain of the other person and accompany them because I understand that the situation is painful; to the idea of benevolence, understood as reaching into someone’s pocket. In fact, one of the virtues that Adam Smith mentions is benevolence and clarifies that benevolence is when you do it with your own, not with someone else’s.

And the other lie they tell is that it is a selfish society. And they mix individualism with selfishness. And that is false. Individualism means that you recognize that each of you is unique and unrepeatable; even with your twins, you would be different. Therefore, they make a sought-after confusion of associating individualism with selfishness. So, selfishness is a situation in which you, in order to achieve your goal, are willing to do anything. And that is not valid because Adam Smith pivots on John Locke and says “here life, liberty, and private property are respected.” When he talks about jurisprudence, which is the moral version of justice, not everything goes.

That is to say, there are things you can do and you don’t do them because they are wrong. Suppose the following: You are a 100-meter runner. What is the problem you have? A gentleman named Usain Bolt. You have a problem that this gentleman is extraordinary, because he even has the luxury of pulling so far ahead of the others that he turns around and looks at them. I mean, pardon the term, but he beats you and on top of that, he also pees on you. Sorry, but I say, he is an extraordinary talent. And the guy who comes in second looks like a fool. Well, in that situation, what are you going to try to do? You are going to try to run better every day to see if you can beat him. The selfish solution is to win at any cost, it is: you can shoot him in the head and then you win. Well, that solution is not allowed. Another solution is to cut off his leg, that solution is not allowed. That is to say, there is a concept of negative rights: there are things you cannot do and that implies respecting life, liberty, and property. If you want to win, you have to run better than him, not kill him, not do like the socialists who want to fill his backpack with stones.

Therefore, not only does that controversy not exist in Adam Smith, but when you go and read the last part of the book The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Adam Smith is very clear. He talks about virtue, that is, the virtues of the Stoics. That is, Adam Smith was a Stoic. That is not minor because it means that there are solutions… I will give you an example: we entered the election year, that is, last year, tightening fiscal policy, tightening monetary policy, and we lifted the currency controls.

Look at what the populists did: they exploded public spending, financed it with monetary emission, which is a scam, and as the exchange rate was escaping, they corrected it by further restricting freedom, with more currency controls. That is wrong. Because it goes against freedom, because it goes against property. And we are not willing to do those things. Can economic policy do it? Yes. But we are Stoics: we are not willing to do it by violating life, liberty, and property.

Because if the policy you apply is unjust, sooner or later it ends badly. That is why Argentina was sinking. That is why we make this proposal of morality as a state policy. Morality as a state policy implies that what is important are moral values, ethics, morality, that is above all at the moment of designing a policy and that has to do with Greek philosophy, with Roman law, with the rectitude of the Stoics, which that part Adam Smith puts in terms of self-control, yes. You could do a lot of things. Probably the one who loses all the races with Usain Bolt has the capacity to grab a revolver and blow his brains out with a shot, but he doesn’t do it because he knows he has to win on the field. There are people who have problems winning on the field and then trade favors arbitrarily. Not only that.

But aside from that, aside from that, there is a question of values. We do not validate moral relativism, it is not that anything goes. That is to say, yes, in a time in history, let’s say slavery existed. Well, but we are not in favor of that, we are against slavery. Killing people is wrong for us, even if for socialists in pursuit of their supposed common good of the idea they have, if they have to kill people, it doesn’t matter to them. They think it is a necessary cost. Why? Because they put the collective above the individual and if the individual doesn’t fit, they liquidate him. No, no, again, and that is where Jewish-Christian values play a fundamental role. Freedom is respected or the first commandment as presented in the Torah says you shall worship your creator, the one who brought you out of Egypt. That is to say, the first commandment in the original version enshrines freedom, but it also enshrines you shall not kill, you shall not steal, you shall not covet your neighbor’s goods, in the capital sins it condemns envy, anger. So, it is not that anything goes. No, no. There are things that do not go. There are things you do not mess with. You do not mess with life, you do not mess with liberty, you do not mess with property.

If you then act according to the values of the West, the issue of efficiency arises naturally simply by respecting the principle of private property, the principle of appropriation of Locke along with the principle of non-aggression and that makes the vast majority prosper and benefit. Therefore, when you act justly, there is no tension between ethical and moral values, efficiency, and political utilitarianism. However, when there is tension, it means that it is unjust and that policy does not deserve to be carried out even if it yields votes.

We, you can say: those are words. No, they are not words, they are facts. Because we are doing it in real life and we know that if we remain upright, the result, although it may be costly in the short term, will be that we will make Argentina great again. Thank you very much.