Words of the President of the Nation, Javier Milei at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), in Washington, United States.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

24 February 2024 · Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) · Washington, United States

Context
Milei addressed the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in Washington on February 24, 2024, expanding on his Davos remarks about the dangers of statism.
Main themes
Free market economics, critique of neoclassical economics and market failure theory, opposition to socialism and statism, private property rights, price system and economic calculation, Western civilization under threat, libertarian conservatism, technological progress vs. interventionism, Pareto optimality critique
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,888
85th percentile
Sentences
158
82nd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
41st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 66%65%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

158 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Hello everyone. I am the lion. I love you too. Long live freedom, damn it. It seems that what was said as a neighborhood phenomenon has grown a little larger.

First of all, thank you very much for this invitation; regarding today's conference, given the impact of the Conference in Davos, where I pointed out that the West is in danger due to the advance of statist ideas, today I will focus on the technical foundations that supported those political assessments in that conference. In this sense, I will focus on how neoclassical economics and its view of market failures are functional to the advance of socialism and how that destroys economic growth, putting a brake on improvements against well-being and the fight against poverty.

Regarding the genesis of this problem, the problem is a methodological problem between models vs. reality. Since reality is always very complex to analyze, it is analyzed with models, but – in general terms – when the model does not map with reality, one corrects the model, discards the model, and the problem with the neoclassical world is that, faced with this problem, where the model does not map with reality, they get angry with reality, calling it a market failure.

The origin of this problem has to do with when they start studying the normative qualities of competitive equilibrium, that is, while the analysis focused on existence, uniqueness, and stability, that did not constitute a serious problem from a political point of view. And in fact, the problem appears when the normative analysis enters alongside Pareto analysis. Basically, the idea of Pareto optimality is that I cannot improve someone without worsening another. Specifically, if I am in a situation where I can improve someone and I make an improvement for someone without worsening another, that is called a Pareto improvement. And obviously, when those opportunities are exhausted, it means we are at Pareto optimality.

And it is there that the definitions of market failures appear, which have different names; one is non-convexities, that is, the existence of increasing returns, or to put it more popularly, concentrated market structures and monopolies. Other cases are externalities: public goods in asymmetric formation and the "Prisoner's Dilemma." And in reality, all these elegant definitions are all elements that enable state intervention and with that the advance of statists and socialists. But to make it less abstract, I will give an applied example: let’s suppose we are at the moment when we were lighting ourselves with candles and Ericsson had not yet arrived; obviously, at the moment Ericsson appears with the light bulb, all candle manufacturers go bankrupt. Naturally, if we had paid attention to the interventionists, today, instead of having this beautiful conference, with all these lights, we would still be using candles; that is how socialists ruin our lives. Luckily, let’s discard Pareto optimality and move forward with technological progress.

So the first thing we need to understand is what the market is, to have a good definition of what the market is. In this sense, the market is a process of social cooperation, where property rights are exchanged voluntarily. In fact – since exchanges are voluntary – it is not possible to talk about market failures because no one would be engaging in self-flagellating actions. Therefore, when we define the market well, all definitions of intervention collapse.

On the other hand, it is also very important to be clear about what the institutions are on which the idea of the market is built. Two very important institutions are private property and free markets free from state intervention, because – basically – if I am going to be exchanging property rights, it means that private property is important. And if the exchanges are not voluntary, there is no place for the intrusive and violent presence of the State.

In this sense, when an exchange is made and someone delivers a good in exchange for money, that establishes a historical record, called price. And that historical record, called price, is a mechanism for transmitting information, which also becomes a coordination mechanism because it makes some people suppliers and others demanders.

And since the quantity demanded does not necessarily coincide with the quantity supplied, when demand is greater than supply, prices rise and in the opposite case, they fall. That is to say, there is an adjustment process. Ultimately, private property and free markets determine the functioning of the price system and that is what allows for economic calculation. And this shows why socialism in none of its forms can work, in the most extreme case because there is no private property, therefore, the exchanges required by the market cannot be made. And, secondly, the lighter versions that allow for the existence of the private sector, the intrusion of the State creates noise in the price system, and the more State there is, the more violence there is, the more distortion there is, and the worse the system functions.

Another important institution for markets is what is called free competition, but not in the neoclassical sense of perfect competition, but in terms of entry and exit. And on the other hand, there are two very important institutions which are the division of labor and social cooperation. The division of labor was best explained by Adam Smith: one person alone could produce only 20 pins, but if the task were divided into fifteen, each could produce 5,000 pins, we are talking about 75,000 pins, but what is the problem if there is no demand for 75,000 pins, there will not be so much division of labor. And this combined with the idea of social combination ends up being absolutely destructive for socialist ideas. One is: I could be hating him, but I need him to buy my product, therefore, inexorably I have to treat him well. That is why, as Bastiat said, "Where trade enters, bullets do not." And promoting free trade is promoting peace.

At the same time, the market as a process of social cooperation is a tremendous bomb against socialism, because if exchanges are free, it means that both parties involved in the exchange benefit. Therefore, there is no room for the theory of exploitation, there is no room for surplus value, there is no room for Marxism and socialism.

At the same time, it is important to point out that in the logic of the market, a successful entrepreneur is a social benefactor, because in free enterprise capitalism, it is only possible to be successful by serving others with better quality goods or better prices. And if that entrepreneur is not doing well, another may appear who can provide the same good at a better price, or the same price, better quality, and that will lead to the bankruptcy of the inefficient and will enhance well-being; And therefore, entrepreneurs are social benefactors because they provide us with better quality goods, at a better price, while creating jobs and progress throughout society. Therefore, let us embrace entrepreneurs who are the foundation of prosperity.

Therefore, given this introduction, it is worth facing, now, where the neoclassical dilemma lies. This within the theory of economic growth and its empirical evidence is called: "The hockey stick." If you look at history, from the Christian era onwards, GDP per capita between the period from the year 0 to 1800 was practically constant. However, from 1800 to now, it has multiplied by more than 15 times, and in that same period, the population in 1800 was 800 million human beings, and today it has multiplied by 10. That is to say, productivity per capita has increased and, in addition, GDP has increased nearly 150 times, to the point that we are in the best moment in the history of humanity. All this, despite the existence of the State. And in this same period of such significant economic growth, extreme poverty fell from 95% of the population to 5%. However, this presence of increasing returns means that there are concentrated structures, that is, there are monopolies. So, the question is: if so much well-being was generated, why does neoclassical theory say that monopolies are bad, if it has brought us so much well-being and such a drop in poverty? And in reality, as Murray Newton Rothbard, the inventor of anarcho-capitalism, would say, the problem is that neoclassical analysis is wrong. Let’s suppose I have 10 companies competing to make cell phones, and one of them discovers a technique to make a phone of better quality at a better price, naturally there are 9 companies that will go bankrupt. However, would any of you complain about having better phones at a better price? Therefore, out with neoclassical theory.

So, let’s see where those errors of neoclassical theory lie. In the simplest version, it is because they say that the monopoly price is higher than that of competition and that the quantity produced is lower than in competition. However, that analysis is wrong because it has several problems; first, because it is only a partial equilibrium analysis, it only considers equilibrium in a single market, and does not consider the rest of the economy. That is to say, I have the monopoly over Javier Milei and you have the monopoly over yourselves, over each one of you, and that is not a bad thing; fortunately, we are all different, thank God. Moreover, we celebrate our differences because we do not like the gray uniformity of socialism. But it is not only wrong for being a partial equilibrium analysis that does not consider the rest of the markets, but also, it is so crude that it does not consider future effects, that is, the impact in the future of these market structures. In fact, this reminds me of a beautiful book by an American economist and thinker, Henry Hazlitt, called "Economics in One Lesson," which said: "The difference between a good economist and a bad economist is that the bad economist only looks at the market in one period, while the good economist looks at all markets and not only the present but also the future." Therefore, this would show that the traditional analysis of monopoly and for which they are regulated is part of a bad economic analysis. And if, in addition, we take the role that profits play as an element to generate economic growth, furthermore, interfering with profits negatively impacts growth. So, the question is: what is the true answer, or the true foundation of this analysis? And in reality, the answer is not in economic analysis, it is in the mathematical structure that uses general equilibrium. Basically, it has to do with the analysis of Pareto optimality and the problem of non-convexities in the production set. Pareto optimality, for the existing equilibrium to be Pareto optimal, both consumers and producers should be maximizing. And the problem is that when we have increasing returns we have convex production functions and the problem with those functions is that a maximum cannot be found. Naturally, that is also a mathematical error because if I have increasing returns I can find a maximum if I use all the endowments of the economy and then another problem would arise that I would end up with only one company; but that which seems empirically correct also has another conceptual error because it basically implies ignoring the nature of the firm and among other things, it overlooks the fact that firms are run by human beings and naturally when you want to work more to produce more, the opportunity cost of free time grows phenomenally. What good would a job offer of 12 million dollars a year do you if you had to work 7 days a week 24 hours? You would clash against your own humanity. However, neoclassical analysis treats firms as if they were machines and not as businesses that depend on human beings.

Finally, another of the criticisms made against monopolies is that they generate less quantity produced in the economy and that is also false because that money that monopolists earn can evidently be channeled into consumption and generate production and employment in other areas of the economy.

Now let’s make a couple of cases that will irritate Keynesians even more. What happens if those large profits are saved? That savings turns into investment in other companies and that generates growth in product and employment in other sectors. Nothing is lost. Or let’s suppose this monopolist is so ambitious that he wants to invest everything in his own company. So that all his savings turn into investment. But that investment means more capital, more productivity, higher wages, and at the same time more production of the good, therefore, prices fall, therefore, higher wages and lower prices, therefore, it is all a gain in well-being.

Moreover, since we can no longer find more attacks on the monopolist, since if he consumes it generates well-being, since if he saves in the financial system it generates well-being and if he saves and invests in himself it also generates well-being. Now let’s think about what happens if the "damn entrepreneur" decides to bury that money. Then no one can access that money.

What is going to happen? The amount of money in the economy will be reduced, and prices will fall, benefiting the entire population. Moreover, this bad businessman will benefit those who have the least because they are the ones who benefit from deflation. Therefore, all we have just seen is that all the analyses that justify intervention only create more State and greater harm to the people.

Thus, to conclude this presentation, I will show how socialist intervention destroys the economy. And basically, this attack by socialists comes from two points of view. On one hand, there is the regulation of monopolies, which, by regulating monopolies, undermines the effect of increasing returns and causes economies to stagnate. If it were regulated under the neoclassical ideal, the quasi-rent would be zero. Therefore, we would be in a world of perfect competition where there are no incentives to grow.

In essence, it aborts the process of creative destruction as described by Schumpeter. Because these processes of creative destruction stem from the idea of solving some societal problems that allow for more money, and that is what generates technological progress and growth. Therefore, if I regulate profits, if I regulate earnings, the problem I will face is stagnation. Aside from the fact that regulating prices and quantities implies destroying property rights.

In fact, I will tell you about a case from a country I know, called Argentina. A country that entered the 20th century as one of the richest countries in the world and that today is ranked 140th globally, with over 50% of its population living in poverty and more than 10% in extreme poverty. And when one looks at the number of regulations, one will understand why.

Within our government teams, we have discovered, for the moment, 380,000 regulations that hinder the functioning of the economic system. And indeed, our two major requests for measures, the DNU and the Law of Bases, proposals that aim to give more freedom to Argentines, move towards more competitive market structures, and above all, eliminate corruption from politics, we encounter great resistance from the beneficiaries of this decadent system, which impoverishes good Argentines in favor of the corrupt elite. Where the corrupt elite is made up of thieving politicians who place their privileges above the well-being of Argentines, by patronage-seeking businessmen who do business with corrupt politicians, by corrupt media outlets that are very angry with us because we eliminated official advertising, also by union leaders who focus on their businesses against the people, and additionally by those professionals who are functional to the religion of the State who live by defending these corrupt individuals. Therefore, they will become aware of the great fight we are waging. But we will not give up on making Argentina great again.

The other major threat from which socialists and statism attack is basically the discussion between efficiency and distribution, where capitalism is pointed out as a hyper-individualistic system and is compared to socialist altruism with other people's money. Always with other people's money. And this aberration is carried out in the name of social justice, where Hayek spoke of weasel words. Where every time an adjective was added, it meant the complete opposite. In fact, as the great Jesús Huerta de Soto says, social justice is violent and unjust; it is neither just nor social nor anything, it is an aberration.

First of all, it is unjust because it implies unequal treatment under the law, and the redistribution that social justice entails is robbing one to give to another. This makes social justice, in addition to being violent, unjust. In the same vein, this is aggravated by the idea of unlimited democracy. That is to say, democracy was originally designed to respect the rights of the smallest minorities, the individual. But when socialist ideas enter and the idea of unlimited democracy comes in, populism enters. But to avoid leaving it too abstract, let me give you an example. Suppose four wolves and a hen gather. Now we are going to vote on what to eat tonight. They just ate the hen. Essentially, that is also what happens in the economy; the goose that lays the golden eggs is the segment that generates wealth, but due to the way income is distributed, 80% of the population has an income lower than the average income. And that is when the populist politician appears, saying that we must take from the rich to give to the poor. Not only Venezuela, Argentina, and all of Latin American populism. And when that happens, the benefits are destroyed, and economic growth is destroyed. If you want it in practical terms, Argentina is a country that produces food for more than 400 million human beings, and the tax pressure on the food-producing sector is 70%. That is to say, the State takes the food of 280 million human beings. Despite this, there are 5 million Argentines who cannot afford to eat thanks to the damned State.

Another part that socialists also discuss, which has to do with income distribution, is that they say the system is unjust. There is a beautiful book by Israel Kirzner called "Creativity, Capitalism, and Distributive Justice." And that book starts from the hypothesis that Kirzner states, the capitalist system is more productive, but if it were truly unjust, there would be no reason to defend it. In that sense, it works on two ideas; it works with Locke's principle of appropriation, that whoever discovers something keeps it. If you discover something, you are the owners of it. And the other idea is Hayek's, which is the market as a process of discovery, which implies that there is not a pie to distribute, but that pie is created as production occurs. Therefore, if that pie is discovered while you advance in the production process, it is logical that that pie should be appropriated by the one who discovered it. Therefore, now the system is not only more productive, but it is also the only system that is just.

And the truth is that we have the socialists more than in checkmate; I would say… for that reason, I will give you one more, I will give you a bis. Naturally, when one regulates monopolies, regulates companies, what were competitive processes, and at the same time introduces the concept of social justice, that evidently leads to stagnation. And that stagnation, given the growth of the population, leads to the gradual impoverishment of that country. And how do they correct this? They correct it with the murderous agenda of abortion. A murderous agenda whose origins we can find with the Egyptians trying to exterminate the Jews or with Malthus's case with his treatise on population and the iron law of wages that promoted birth control; or more recently - in the late 1960s - the Club of Rome, where the Club of Rome said that since the world was moving with fossil energy and since those energies are not renewable, they predicted that by the year 2000 those resources would be exhausted. And yet, that situation would generate a lack of food for everyone and that we would die, and that only a billion people would remain on planet Earth. And based on that, today, with the declassification of Nixon and Kissinger's files, we know that they proposed that murderous agenda of abortion; where, for example, (INAUDIBLE) has more locations than McDonald's worldwide. But fortunately, they were wrong again because today there are 8 billion human beings living in the world. However, they do not cease that murderous agenda; in fact, post-Marxism, in the face of its economic defeat, has shifted its class struggle battles to other aspects of life, for example, environmentalism; where it poses the struggle of man against nature, blaming humanity for global warming, when this has already happened four times in the history of planet Earth and humans did not live then, and where to correct this problem, the neo-Marxists cannot think of anything other than exterminating humans. If we truly had a resource problem, we should be looking to colonize other planets, not condemning ourselves to death. In fact, all those analyses against population growth are false, so I want to leave you with the case of a very optimistic economist named Julian Simon, who pointed out that population growth brought more technological progress. For example, he pointed out that there was technological growth driven by demand, where basically having more people and facing problems of scarcity and so on affected the price system and generated new reforms and new technological progress to solve those problems, and on the other hand, he pointed out technological progress driven by the supply side, where - for example - the chances of having a Mozart are much greater if there are 1 million people than if there are 10.

In short, the message is the following: do not let socialism advance, do not endorse regulation, do not endorse the idea of market failures, do not allow the advance of the murderous agenda, and do not be swayed by the siren songs of social justice; I come from a country that bought all those stupid ideas and went from being one of the richest countries in the world to being ranked 140th. Therefore, do not give up your freedom, fight for your freedom, because if you do not fight for freedom, they will lead you to misery. But I also want to leave you with a message of optimism; Argentina seemed like a country of sheep condemned to poverty as marked by socialists, and I remember when I started my political career to become a National Deputy, I said: I did not come to guide lambs, I came to awaken lions. And it was thus that every day we awaken more lions, and the message of freedom not only led us to the presidency of Argentina but we are also awakening the whole world. Therefore, do not yield in the fight for freedom, long live freedom damn it! Long live freedom damn it! Thank you very much.