Words of the President of the Nation Javier Milei at the LXV Summit of Mercosur, in Montevideo, Uruguay.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

6 December 2024 · LXV Summit of Mercosur · Montevideo, Uruguay

Context
Milei addressed the LXV Mercosur Summit in Montevideo on December 6, 2024, advocating for free trade reforms and criticizing protectionist policies within the bloc.
Main themes
Free trade advocacy, Mercosur reform, common external tariff critique, intra-regional trade decline, economic liberalism, protectionism failures, Argentina's economic history, trade agreements, market integration, prosperity through trade
Duration
~9 min
33rd percentile
Words
1,134
33rd percentile
Sentences
39
24th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 74%74%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

39 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Good morning to everyone, to my fellow presidents, to the chancellors of our brother countries, and to all the authorities of the member countries of Mercosur. I hope we can have a fruitful conversation about our common bloc and move forward on the right path, which is none other than deepening our ties to promote trade and, with it, bring prosperity to our peoples.

While I come here today in my capacity as president, I would like to speak mainly as an economist and take advantage of this day, having already passed more than 30 years since its founding, to recall the original mission of Mercosur and jointly assess whether it has lived up to its original forecast. Because institutions should not be evaluated by their intentions, but by their results.

In the late 1980s, with a completely fractured world, after decades of the Cold War and ideological politicization, Mercosur emerged as a way to seek to integrate the markets of our countries, eliminating tariffs, bureaucracies, and double taxation, with the ultimate goal of establishing a common free trade area. Unfortunately, simultaneously and as a result of the prevailing ideas of the time, which we believe were misguided, a system of common external tariffs was proposed to try to protect the industry of our countries, believing that this would bring benefits to our citizens. Unfortunately, the road to hell is paved with good intentions and, as Professor Huerta de Soto has pointed out, “whenever the State intervenes, it generates a worse outcome than what existed before it intervened.” Therefore, it is no surprise to a liberal like me that the result of these measures has been the opposite of what was intended. The common external tariff not only made the importation of productive goods more expensive, making our local industries more costly and, consequently, less competitive, but it also closed off countless trade avenues. What happens with trade is that it functions like a two-way highway; to sell freely, one must also be willing to buy freely.

However, both due to the rigidity of the common external tariff and the countless non-tariff barriers that we have invented over the years, both Mercosur's trade with the world and intra-Mercosur trade have deteriorated. From 1995 to the present, the participation in intra-zone trade of all countries, except Paraguay, has significantly decreased, with Argentina and Uruguay being the most notable cases. Having such high tariffs increases the cost of living for all our citizens and denies them the opportunity to acquire better goods at better prices, that is, it denies them the possibility of improving their quality of life. It is no coincidence that from the mid-1990s to the present, Mercosur's share in world trade has decreased from 1.8% to 1.6%. Consolidating ourselves into a common bloc not only made us grow, but it has also harmed us, while neighbors like Chile and Peru opened up to the world and established trade agreements with the key players in global trade, we locked ourselves in our own fishbowl, taking more than 20 years to close an agreement that we are now celebrating, which is still far from being a reality.

It cannot be surprising, then, that the economies of our neighbors have grown so much more than ours, while they have free trade agreements with more than 20 countries; we have similar treaties only with the rest of South America, Egypt, and Israel. While the responsibility for Argentina's failure largely falls on decades of destructive economic policy, Mercosur and its restrictions have also been an obstacle to the progress of Argentines. Chile exports 50 times more cherries than we do; it exports 50 billion dollars a year in copper, while we export zero. How many new markets could we have developed if we had been open to the world? My point is that the last 20 years of economic policy have left Argentina in a deep hole, and today the entire society is making an immense effort to move forward. We cannot afford to let commercial opportunities pass us by; we need them like water in the desert.

Just as we have learned from the mistakes of the past in fiscal and monetary matters, we must also learn from the mistakes of the past in trade. Over the last 20 years, we have missed the opportunity of our lives; we went against the grain of the world during the cycle of greatest commercial integration in global history, which resulted in the greatest development of emerging countries ever seen. While the rest of the planet expanded—thanks to trade—we said no to the United States, which offered a free trade agreement across the continent. But that rhetoric disguised as nationalism has cost our citizens dearly. Do you know what the only way to defend the interests of our nations is? By promoting free trade, because free trade generates prosperity. Because as Julio Argentino Roca, the greatest nationalist in our history, said, “trade knows better than the Government what is good for it. True policy consists, therefore, in giving the hands the widest freedom.”

In summary, Mercosur—which was born with the idea of deepening our commercial ties—has ended up becoming a prison that prevents its member countries from taking advantage of either their comparative advantages or their export potential. This problem is not new, but if we continue to pretend to cover the sun with our hands, it will become increasingly difficult to solve.

I would like to invite you, as brothers we are, to open our eyes and be intellectually honest; let us accept that this model is exhausted and seek a new formula that benefits us all, so that we can all trade more and better, because it is trade that generates prosperity and will end the great scourge of Latin America, which is the abject poverty of our peoples. Let us gain autonomy, without failing to respect the agreements that unite us, and if what unites us is to trade freely among ourselves, I propose that we loosen the ties that today suffocate us instead of strengthening us.

This bloc cannot continue to be a straitjacket that limits our countries. We must leave behind this stage, characterized by mere administration of agreements; the excess of regulations and the implementation of norms that hinder both internal trade and trade with the rest of the world. Because if the bloc is not a dynamic engine that facilitates trade, that drives investment, and improves the quality of life for all citizens in our region, what is its purpose? I hope that, without ideological blinders, we have the intellectual honesty to ask ourselves the difficult questions and the courage to make the necessary decisions.

May God bless you all and may the forces of heaven be with us. Thank you very much.