Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Noticias Cuatro," from Cuatro Televisión.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

6 June 2007 · Interview on the program "Noticias Cuatro" (Cuatro Televisión) · Cuatro Televisión studios

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Cuatro Televisión in June 2007 to address the collapse of the ETA peace process and ceasefire breakdown.
Main themes
ETA ceasefire collapse, peace process failure, political dialogue with ETA, rule of law and democracy, Basque terrorism, Popular Party criticism, government duty to pursue peace, ETA's political objectives, limits of negotiation with terrorists
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,207
97th percentile
Sentences
346
96th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

346 sentences in 155 paragraphs

Iñaki Gabilondo: Mr. President, good evening.

President: Good evening.

I. Gabilondo: Have you been deceived or have you deceived yourself, Mr. President?

President: There is only one entity that has failed miserably in this process, and that is ETA, which once had an opportunity to abandon violence, to leave behind so much pain; a violence that is absolutely rejected by all sectors of Basque society, by the vast majority of Basque society. That is the only failure, that of ETA.

I. Gabilondo: Do you have any doubt that perhaps the Popular Party is right when they say that you have been mocked and that, while you believed we were making progress, they were reconstituting commands, rearming, plugging gaps? What if the Popular Party is right?

President: The Popular Party has done too many things, from my point of view, in this process and has not helped at all. That is my experience.

I must affirm that, as President of the Government, I not only have the right but the duty to attempt a process that would lead us to the end of violence, and I have done so fulfilling a duty and also fulfilling a commitment, with my principles, not to pay a price and to maintain, above all, the rule of law, democracy, and the principles of our coexistence in freedom.

I. Gabilondo: Do you know why ETA decided to declare a ceasefire and why it has decided not to declare it? What do you think motivated them to take that step and what do you think has motivated them to break it?

President: They have done it nearly ten times in the dramatic and tragic history they have been part of in this country for almost forty years. Their objectives are clear; they are objectives aimed at achieving political ends, and certainly, with or without a truce, sooner or later, I can assure you that violence will never achieve any kind of political objectives.

I. Gabilondo: But when did you realize that ETA was never going to abandon its weapons unless it obtained some kind of...?

President: I think we need to have a certain perspective. When a process of this nature begins, and we have already had different dialogue processes during the democratic period, no one has a predetermined ending of what may happen.

I said, when the ceasefire began and when I committed to the Spanish people to dialogue from certain principles, that it was going to be hard and difficult, very difficult. Obviously, the process has not concluded in the way we would all have liked: in the end of violence.

I. Gabilondo: But at what point has it stalled, shall we say?

President: ETA poses political objectives that, certainly, as President of the Government, it will never achieve while maintaining violence. Absolutely...

I. Gabilondo: And hasn't that been clear from day one?

President: From day one, they posed what could be certain proclamations, which we have seen were included in statements; but in what has been the contact, they wanted to talk about politics, to dialogue about politics, and, of course, politics can only be done and decided in democratic institutions and with the radical absence and elimination of violence, terrorism, attacks, and murder. That is the principle.

I. Gabilondo: They would have told you that on the first day.

President: Absolutely, of course.

I. Gabilondo: But you maintained hope that this, however, could be addressed by ETA.

President: We maintained the objective of deactivating and achieving that they desist and that they assume that never, neither before, nor now, nor tomorrow, would democracy, any government, yield to political proposals, but that there was only one destiny, the end of violence, and from there, what could be representation, participation, and political debate.

I. Gabilondo: How many high-level meetings have there been, shall we say?

President: There have been some meetings. I must be prudent and reserved because, in this process, as everyone can understand, there have been people who have committed a lot; people who have participated not only from our country but people from outside our country, who have tried to help generously, to whom I am very grateful, to see the end of violence. For obvious reasons of discretion, reserve, and security, I must be very prudent.

In any case, I could tell you that, from the point of view of what could be contacts or dialogue, let’s say, quite indirect, it has not been a very long process in time because, as everyone can understand, there are many difficulties and complications to produce. Therefore, it has been, from the point of view of real time, a short process.

I. Gabilondo: I said that because, now that it has ended, we know, for example, that when Aznar was President, there was a call and he himself said that there had been a second one that ETA later canceled; and it is known that when Felipe González was President, there were three or six meetings in Algiers, I don’t know exactly now. That’s why I was asking you now, having concluded, not naming names, how many meetings there have been.

President: There have been direct and indirect contacts. I must be prudent and responsible, as there was surely prudence and responsibility in other periods regarding these types of issues. There have been indirect and direct contacts in more than one period when there has been an expectation of having an opportunity to reach the end of violence.

I. Gabilondo: The matter, let’s say, in its preliminaries starts when Eguiguren and Otegi maintain relations and, at a certain point, you decide to give that type of meeting an official blessing. Were you at that moment betraying the Anti-Terrorist Pact?

President: Absolutely not. If there is one thing that is evident, it is that the Anti-Terrorist Pact is a proposal that I made, while in opposition, to the Popular Party, and I will tell you why: because it came from deep within me, as a Spaniard and as a political leader, as a democrat, to put all my strength and energy to help the existing government, which was that of Mr. Aznar, as it could have been that of another president.

That was what I told him on the first day: "you have my unconditional support, a blank check, for one thing only, which is the anti-terrorist policy." And I fulfilled that for four years. I did it from the opposition, which is more meritorious, because every government wants to have unity, consensus, and support in anti-terrorist policy, in a policy that does not distinguish between ideologies, times, or generations; that attacks democracy, freedom, and the coexistence of all. As it is an attack on all, we must all support those who have the responsibility, the difficult responsibility, as they have had and I have had as President of the Government, to combat, to pursue, to stop, and to try to eradicate violence.

I. Gabilondo: But, I repeat, the Otegi-Eguiguren meetings constituted a...

President: It was an expectation, but not only that, nor even the fundamental one. There have been other pieces of information or other expectations that encouraged a possibility. And today I repeat: my obligation, not only my right, my obligation, as President of the Government was to try; to try from the principles of defending the rule of law, democracy, coexistence, and the rules of the game that we have maintained. And, of course, I would have liked to have the support, as President of the Government, that other presidents had throughout the democratic period.

I. Gabilondo: The intention was to establish a conversation with ETA so that ETA would abandon violence and then open, if that was the case, a certain conversation at a party table. It was not opened, but the possibility of it being opened was also explored. In those explorations, progress was being made...

President: All in a very incipient period or process. Why? Because the central question in this matter is whether ETA has or does not have a clear will to abandon arms. Then we can talk about whatever.

I. Gabilondo: But you first believed you could verify that they did.

President: We had to approach to try to verify. I would not have forgiven myself for not trying to verify, not trying to know, not trying to contact, if it had been true. Do you think any President of the Government could allow themselves not to try, not to probe, not to work in that direction? It would simply be irresponsible as a Spaniard and as President of the Government.

I. Gabilondo: There are things you can discreetly share, others you may not share, but there is one that you definitely have to dismiss. Pernando Barrena told us in March that there were signed commitments between you and either Batasuna or ETA.

President: The truth is that it is absolutely and radically false. The best proof is, unfortunately, the statement we received from ETA in which they say that the Government has not yielded and that the Government has maintained positions that, on the other hand, it was absolutely logical for us to maintain.

I. Gabilondo: Agreed. You fulfill your duty by approaching and trying: you start by talking, you do not acquire commitments, of course, you do not sign them; but what is it? Optimism or blindness when signals start to arrive that you, however, do not seem to perceive? In September: hooded individuals appear in the Oyarzun field shooting into the air in a truly insolent appearance. The following month, 350 weapons are stolen in Vauvert, near Nîmes. Were they not signs that there was no will to end the violence?

President: In the truce of 1998, there was intense and permanent "kale borroka" and the expectation was maintained, and the work was maintained to conclude that opportunity. I reiterate once more: if there is a minimal opportunity, if there was a minimal opportunity, my duty was to try. Moreover, my duty, and I believe the obligation of all, is to support that possibility, among other reasons, because absolutely throughout this time the Government, as I committed to the citizens, also with the majority support of Parliament, which was the first time this was done in a dialogue process, maintained the principles, maintained the commitments with the citizens and the democratic rules, the rule of law, the Constitution, and the laws at all times.

I. Gabilondo: That glimmer of hope, which despite the appearance in Oyarzun remains and which despite the theft of weapons remains, does it remain after December 30 when Barajas is blown up and two Ecuadorians are killed?

President: At that point, the hope is, from my point of view, and for me, minimal, practically nonexistent.

I. Gabilondo: What information did you have the day before when you made the big slip by announcing that next year was going to be good, just a few...?

President: That we could be better within a year.

We have an evolution of what has happened. It is quite reasonable, but it is not an opinion of the President of the Government, but rather it has been a widely shared opinion that during 2003, 2004, and 2005, until December 30, 2006, that is, more than three years, there is no fatal victim of ETA, at the hands of ETA; there is no murder. This had never happened since the constitution, since the organization, since this terrorist group was born.

This was, without a doubt, a factor of expectation, and knowing what terrorist groups are and the history of similar processes that have been lived, there is a strategy that some have used in some of those processes, which is to try to negotiate with violence and commit some attack. There was the clear case of the Irish process, which fortunately for them ended well at the time, after three years of secret conversations and after nine years of peace process.

But, obviously, the expectation, my expectation, regarding the possibilities of positively concluding the process of ending violence with the brutal attack they carried out in Barajas was practically reduced to nothing.

I. Gabilondo: Practically, but not reduced to nothing, because three months later they send De Juana to San Sebastián and now we have learned that, in addition to humanitarian reasons, some kind of door was wanted to be left ajar.

President: De Juana was on a hunger strike, serving a sentence, of which he has approximately a little over a year left, and the State has two obligations in this regard: one, to try to preserve life, because he is a prisoner who is in the care of the State and, therefore, of the Government, as a primary responsibility to try to ensure that he recovers; he had a clear risk situation regarding his health—and when he recovered, in the opinion of the doctors, his health, although he has sequelae, according to his own information, a decision had to be made, and penitentiary policy is part of anti-terrorist policy, of prevention and of guaranteeing anti-terrorist policy.

Evidently, the circumstance of the moment when, in the critical situation of the hunger strike, the Government decides to transfer him to a hospital in San Sebastián is different from the moment of his discharge, which coincides, moreover, with what is the rupture and the statement from ETA.

It is a penitentiary policy that the Government must apply always within the margin of the Law, just as it has been done in other times, just as a penitentiary policy was applied during the truce of 1998 when, without any clear expectation, Mr. Aznar's Government transferred a number of prisoners, a very high number of prisoners, which, by the way, my Government has not done.

I. Gabilondo.- Other circumstances, therefore. ETA announces that it opens all fronts and the Government says it closes all doors and goes, therefore, De Juana Chaos to prison. A hunger strike has probably begun again. If in a little while, because the doctors say that, as a consequence of the previous hunger strike so recent and that he is not taking medication, his health may be in danger shortly, shall we repeat?

President.- Let us not anticipate events. If that situation arises, logically the Penitentiary Institutions will have to make the appropriate decisions, always with an obligation that the State has, which is to try to preserve the life of those in its charge as much as possible, such as the inmates.

I. Gabilondo.- Do you understand that what happened with De Juana Chaos was a mistake? It has certainly come at a great cost, from a public perspective, in terms of image, etc. Would you repeat it in the case of De Juana; at that moment, I am not saying...?

President.- I have said that it responds to what is a penitentiary policy at a given moment and at another given moment, before the breakdown of the ceasefire and after the breakdown of the ceasefire, trying to preserve life, which seems to me to be a fundamental objective.

Many things have been said about the decision we made with De Juana Chaos, even led by the main opposition party, very serious accusations and very strong insults. That is what, in my opinion, should not happen again.

Those who have made those insults, those accusations, in my opinion, are the ones who should be regretting having done so, as time and again they have said during this period that we had ceded, that we had surrendered, Navarra... I do not know how many things we have heard, I do not know how many things, without at any moment having heard, from the Popular Party, as President of the Government, not a single word of support, of encouragement, of solidarity, which I have received from all European Governments and what I have received and have from the United Nations.

This is what has been regrettable, from my point of view, in this process and this is what can never happen again. This is what should make many people reflect.

I. Gabilondo.- Mr. President, new circumstances, therefore, as well. The penitentiary policy is interpreted differently. And what about the other policy? Would it be possible, for example, to urge the illegalization of Acción Nacionalista Vasca?

President.- It would be possible to do what the Government has to do, which is to guarantee compliance with the Law. If there is a breach of the Law, do not have any doubt that the Government will apply it with all rigor and with all force, within the limits of the Rule of Law and within the scope of the powers that the Government has and that Justice has.

I. Gabilondo.- The fact that in ETA's statement they welcomed with satisfaction that large number of votes received by forces like Acción Nacionalista Vasca is not a piece of information regarding the connection of Acción Nacionalista Vasca with ETA to urge its legalization?

President.- The Government has complied with the Law regarding Acción Nacionalista Vasca and I want to remind you that Acción Nacionalista Vasca is a legal party since the 1930s, which has lived in democracy all this time without anyone having accused it of illegality, that Mr. Aznar's Government gave it a significant amount of money as a result of the restitution of the confiscated assets of the Republic and that, therefore, it has its rights. When the electoral process arrived, the State Attorney's Office and the Prosecutor's Office made an effort to investigate, an effort to determine those candidacies that could be used or that could be, according to the Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court, contaminated, as it is said, or presence of Batasuna and, therefore, a succession of Batasuna. And that decision has been ratified by the Constitutional Court in the second instance and, first of all, by the Supreme Court.

Let us adhere to the Rule of Law and to the laws, and, of course, I reiterate: if someone breaches the Law of Political Parties, whatever the acronym, including ANV, of course Justice, urged by the Prosecutor's Office and urged by the State Attorney's Office, will take the appropriate decisions. That is what we have done in all cases.

Many things have been said during this period, too many, with too many falsehoods. During this period, 92 alleged members of ETA have been arrested, during the ceasefire period, and since I have been President of the Government, three hundred alleged members of the terrorist group ETA.

And I will tell you more: the State Security Forces, the Civil Guard and the National Police, are strong, motivated and, of course, with the utmost dedication to guarantee our security and to guarantee the freedom of citizens, which is my main objective, logically, after the statement of the breakdown of the ceasefire by ETA.

I. Gabilondo.- In the conversations that have taken place with ETA or its people, has the topic of Navarra come up? Has the topic of Navarra been proposed by ETA? Have the Government's messengers flirted with the topic of Navarra to any degree?

President.- Many things have come up in the conversations, as it cannot be... But I have already told you that anything that is political matter or content, that only had one channel: the legitimate representation of the citizens; and, of course, any debate or any approach with a radical absence and end of violence.

I. Gabilondo.- Mr. President, does the breakdown of the ceasefire modify in any way any political strategy? I know that what will happen in Navarra must be decided by the Navarrese socialists, that is what you are going to tell me; but I also suppose that you have something to say to the Navarrese socialists. Does what has happened with the ceasefire and the breakdown of the ceasefire modify your point of view regarding what the Navarrese socialists should do in Navarra?

President.- No, absolutely not. I believe that the Navarrese socialists... Our candidate, Fernando Puras, is a person with a lot of credibility, who has very clear ideas, who is going to have a dialogue process, who is having a dialogue process and who, from our principles, without taking into account what has been said about the Navarrese socialists and about Navarra, what we hear in certain demonstrations; how society was divided and strained in Navarra, will make the decision based, first of all, on the interests of Navarra; secondly, on the interests of the whole country and, thirdly, on the interests, logically, of the Socialist Party.

From my point of view, one cannot make an opposition policy based on false assumptions, much less when we are talking about terrorism. Navarra has always been one of the elements that has always been present in the use, by some sectors and by the Popular Party.

I have heard a positive statement from the President of Navarra, Miguel Sanz, in support of what had been my statement after the breakdown of the ceasefire by ETA. I hope that is the line and that sanity and responsibility are recovered, which advises supporting a Government when it faces terrorism.

I. Gabilondo.- I know it is difficult to know, but what impression do you have...? The fact that you were accompanied, of course, by the legitimacy of the State, that you were accompanied by the legitimacy of a Parliament that had mostly endorsed you; but the fact that a very high percentage of society and the main opposition party did not accompany you, has it weakened the Government's possibility in its negotiation with ETA?

President.- I have had and felt very broad support from political groups, all except the Popular Party, which is the main opposition group; but also a very strong support from the citizens who, in a reflection that is quite common sense, told me: "if there is an opportunity, try it." Does it involve risks for the President of the Government? Undoubtedly, but it was my duty, it was my obligation and my conviction to try.

The culprit of what is happening is ETA. Who breaks the ceasefire is ETA and who has not had the will and courage to end this horror of crime, of murder, of violence, of terrorism, is exclusively ETA. That said, would it have been good for the Government, for Spain, for democracy and for the Rule of Law to have the support of the Popular Party? Undoubtedly. Everyone can understand this. For that, one must have, as I mentioned earlier, that attitude.

When I took over the leadership of the Socialist Party, I went to see Aznar and told him "you have my full support in the anti-terrorist policy" and I gave it at all times. I never publicly disputed and we went through very tough, very difficult moments. Laws were changed, decisions were made and they always had my support. And one later realizes over time that not everyone feels politics the same way, not everyone has the same internal response regarding their country, regarding what it means to defend freedom and to try above all to eradicate violence. Not everyone does things the same way.

I am very proud of how I have done it, in the opposition giving my full support to the Government, and in the Government facing the duty I had to try to end violence, even knowing that the Popular Party was from day one in a strategy of permanent attack. I have it very engraved.

In the State of the Nation Debate of 2005, in May 2005, when the ceasefire had not yet arrived, the leader of the opposition told me from the podium that I was betraying the victims with my anti-terrorist policy, which is one of the most intolerable statements that can be made in a democracy, when one was and I have been for these three years making the utmost effort, putting all my effort, all my will and all my intelligence to eradicate that which I hate the most, which is violence; that which Spanish society detests the most and that which constitutes the only great problem that this country has, which is terrorism.

I. Gabilondo.- Excuse me, President, but how do we know who is to blame for the two parties being divided? Because you accuse the Popular Party of disloyalty, that you would have wanted them to be together, but that...

President.- No, no; the Popular Party, no.

I. Gabilondo.- ...and the Popular Party says that you have wanted to corner the Popular Party.

President.- But if the reflection is so evident. If it had been another circumstance, another political leader, another President of the Government, there could be doubt, but in my case, I have to say it so bluntly, there is no doubt and I have all the moral authority, all, because in the four years of opposition, of opposition, which is more compromising, which is more difficult, I gave all my support to the Government of the Popular Party in anti-terrorist policy; all. No one has been able to dispute it.

Moreover, when I proposed the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism, which they have brought up so much and have claimed, I received almost an initial reaction of contempt, I remember it very well and I continued and managed to get us to sign it. It was very useful and the Government of the Popular Party felt strong combating terrorism in difficult circumstances.

I have that credibility, I have all the moral authority. I will not tolerate anyone disputing it. And now I add: as President of the Government, one still wishes to have even more consensus and support.

Allow me, the Spaniards must know and I want them to know that the disunity has been the result of the Popular Party choosing as the axis of its opposition strategy the anti-terrorist policy from day one. Do they have the right to do so? Surely. It is their decision, it is their responsibility. My opinion is that it is bad for the country.

I. Gabilondo.- Have you been loyal to Rajoy in the information?

President.- Absolutely.

I. Gabilondo.- Has Rajoy been loyal to you in the use of information?

President.- I value what I do and I do not want to make any judgment. You will not have heard me in my political, personal life, of disloyalty, of lack of loyalty; no. I am not going to do it either with Mr. Rajoy, whom I am going to see on Monday. I have given the information that I deemed appropriate and that was the substantial information; but I have to say that it was the same, because there was a pre-established script, a pre-established speech, that has been repeated and that all Spaniards have heard in these three years, of harsh criticism, of disqualification, of statements of surrender, of concession, regarding anti-terrorist policy.

For me, this is already in the past. Simply, the only experience and the only lesson I can try to convey for the future, for the immediate and for what is to come, is: this can never happen again. Democrats cannot be divided, confronted, with coarse disqualifications, when it comes to fighting terrorism, to trying to end terrorism; it cannot be.

And I will tell you: as always happens in democracy, each one has their responsibility. I have fulfilled mine, absolutely, in my period of opposition and in my period as President of the Government. But I must tell you more, it did not surprise me that the Popular Party began to oppose with ETA terrorism; it did not surprise me.

I. Gabilondo.- Why did it not surprise you?

President.- Because I saw what your attitude was at the beginning of the Legislature and I saw it with what had happened with the tragic attack of March 11. A democratic political party, which has been for years, for two years, letting society believe that behind that barbarity that cost the lives of 192 people there could have been something strange, that there was a conspiracy, that there was an implication of who knows who, but it was suggested, to overthrow a Government and for a political party to benefit; since that started to be formulated, I knew perfectly well and was very aware that I was not going to have a single minute or a single day of support and collaboration in what is the anti-terrorist policy. Notice that I even went to a Commission of Inquiry about March 11, now that the trial is reaching its final part and is being conclusive, of course, for all Spaniards; even so, I went there to respond and explain what had happened when I was the leader of the opposition and while the Popular Party was in Government. I have to regret it.

I. Gabilondo.- You know that there are those who say that ETA has Rodríguez Zapatero by the train cars. I don’t know if you have heard this phrase, which is often repeated on a radio.

President.- Honestly, saying that seems to me a cowardice that I do not accept under any circumstances. I have had and have great democratic patience, but there are things that are so abominable that they are simply unacceptable; unacceptable in the condition of any human being and much more in a democracy.

I. Gabilondo.- Let’s look ahead. On Monday you will meet with Rajoy. After what you have told us, it does not seem that you will have much hope, but on the other hand…

President.- But I say more. When I just said that I am convinced that from the first day the Popular Party has decided to oppose the issue of ETA's anti-terrorist policy, I say: they will do it until the last day of the Legislature. I anticipate it. Spaniards will be able to verify whether it is so or not.

I will make every effort, and it is also my responsibility, to achieve the maximum consensus, the maximum dialogue; but there is a principle, which is elementary, that has been upheld during these thirty-some years of common, globally common, policy against terrorism: terrorism is not a public discussion, the anti-terrorist struggle against ETA is not a public discussion. The moment there is a public discussion, there is no longer the will for consensus.

I remember perfectly that in the four years as leader of the opposition I spoke privately with the President of the Government… In the first stage; then I no longer did because it was difficult for him to receive me, unlike what happens now that I always call, receive, and am eager to talk with Mr. Rajoy as many times as necessary. But certain things between parties, in anti-terrorist policy, must be discussed in a space of discretion, simply. When a party makes a public banner, brings it to public debate, not to mention Parliament, with initiatives of anti-terrorist policy, it has very little will for consensus and for serious and in-depth discussion.

I. Gabilondo.- Excuse me, Mr. President, but if on Monday you are going to meet with Rajoy, with the ideas you are expressing and with the forecast you are making regarding your intention, what hopes can we citizens have that on Monday you will reach an agreement that heals, even if only fundamentally, the wounds that separate the two main parties?

President.- I believe that each one must assume their responsibility. I, of course, tell you what I would have done as leader of the opposition with a breakdown of the ceasefire by ETA; what I did every time there was an attack and what I did every time something happened that ETA did: go out to public opinion to say: the Government has all my support and all my solidarity, and here I am to lend a hand. That is what I would have done and that is what I am going to ask Mr. Rajoy.

I insist: I feel with all the moral authority because I did it and, moreover, it produces trust in the citizenry. The citizenry cannot understand that there is opposition with anti-terrorist policy and cannot understand and does not like it at all, and they are absolutely right, that there is a public debate on how to combat ETA, on how to seek the end of violence.

I, of course, am going to do everything on my part and doing everything on my part is to guarantee a framework for dialogue that is not subject to public struggle because, if there is a framework in which we can talk calmly, without having to be in public discussion, we can advance.

I. Gabilondo.- Moral: has this ended? Have you come out chastened or has it been a chapter in a long and difficult road?

President.- Of course, we are at this moment, although I believe that Spaniards are aware, in a difficult situation. ETA has just announced the breakdown of the ceasefire and I am very interested in reiterating three things: that I will act firmly, for with the same firmness that I have sought peace I will act in defense of the Rule of Law, of freedom and of the peaceful coexistence of Spaniards; that I will work for the unity of all parties, not only thinking of this immediate moment, but thinking of the future so that we have that climate, and that I will also act intelligently.

Today, and it is well understood, I absolutely only have my thoughts on how to better defend the Rule of Law, on how to guarantee the freedom and security of all citizens.

I. Gabilondo.- Do you consider it possible that, if an attack occurs, you will be blamed?

President.- That would be the last straw! I have to express myself that way. After forty years, where we have all known how to react with ETA, against ETA, in the face of ETA, in the face of pain, in the face of the victims, that would be the last straw!

But I must say that in these three years they have already said serious things. I prefer to forget some of them. Things that we have heard, that I have seen reproduced in the media, in certain mobilizations, very serious things, I prefer to forget them and I prefer that the political period we have ahead be a period in which that radically disappears from the way we understand our differences in democracy.

I. Gabilondo.- If one day, with Rajoy or any member of the Popular Party of the President of the Government, another opportunity arose, they initiated a process and you were in the opposition, would you remember what you lived through to settle a score or would you repeat what you did in the opposition and what you are expressing in your words?

President.- I have tried throughout my political life to be coherent and coherence, when it comes to principles, moral principles, is very easy to maintain.

I cannot criticize a Government when it is facing a terrorist group; whether something goes well or goes badly... I cannot. The problem is that I cannot, it is that I cannot.

I remembered these days with a friend: when I proposed the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism and when I made that policy of unity, I had criticisms because they said that it helped the PP Government, that it strengthened the PP. I had criticisms, even from the media. I still remember in some episodes, even jokingly, how I was criticized for being, in quotes, too lenient, helping too much, supporting too much the Government of the Popular Party. Do you know what happens? That, of course, I did not see, when it came to the anti-terrorist struggle, a Government or a party, or a Government of a party; I saw the Government of my country and my country trying to defend itself, trying to end terrorism.

I. Gabilondo.- There are many things, but we do not have much time. So I would ask you to be brief to address some other issues.

Are elections being brought forward? Does this Government and the Government program have oxygen for the Legislature, or has this already been flattened?

President.- There is no reason. The Government has a stability that it has demonstrated throughout the Legislature. It has developed and still has to finish an ambitious legislative and reform program that is yielding enormously positive results for the country. We are going to have a legislature with three million more jobs, we are going to have a legislature where the trend of precarious employment to stable employment is reversed; a legislature with laws, such as the Equality Law; a great achievement, such as the Personal Autonomy Law, so that the elderly and disabled are not alone, are helped, and their families; a legislature in which new rights have been won for people, to recognize their individual freedom, and a legislature that I want to have a central theme in the last stage, which is the fight against climate change and a whole broad package of measures and reforms that we are going to inspire so that our country is at the forefront of climate change, in the defense of the environment and nature; in addition to very important laws that are approved.

Look, we are about to approve the Statute of Self-Employed Workers. There are more than three million self-employed workers in this country. This is not normally in the public debate. Self-employed workers who have historically not had the same rights as salaried workers and, however, with this Statute they will be practically equated in rights to those of salaried workers. This is still to be finalized.

I. Gabilondo.- However, with all the things that you have indeed done, some of which could have enough substance to justify a Legislature, such as the Dependency Law, you have not managed to lead the debate; you have been dragged by the debate.

President.- It depends on who leads the debate, right?

I. Gabilondo.- In the public debate, you have had great difficulties in fitting those issues.

President.- The public debate is made by the media and political actors, right? So, it makes me laugh that they say that… I sometimes hear that criticism of "there is too much talk about the issue of terrorism and ETA," and they are the same ones who are talking all day about terrorism and ETA in the talk shows or who at rallies demanded that I talk about ETA terrorism every day, when there were certainly many other issues that needed to be addressed in these municipal and regional elections, such as housing, education, health, and urban planning.

Allow me, the Government has carried out an intense legislative calendar, of profound reforms; an economic and social policy that has placed us at the forefront in many things. There is no more than to see how all that action is recognized. That has been the "leitmotif" of a large part of our policy and, as corresponds to a responsible Government that has never hidden and that has faced the public, we have tried, logically, to end violence, which was our duty and our obligation.

I. Gabilondo.- But the Government is very blurred at this moment. I do not know if it is something that happens because you want it to happen or it happens without wanting to; but you are exposed, very alone, and people in your Government who have a lot of weight, for various reasons, are not at this moment: Rubalcaba because he is dealing with what he is dealing with. What is happening with María Teresa Fernández de la Vega, who has been a great captain and is now missing?

President.- I do not know why that assessment is made. In the last forty-eight hours…

I. Gabilondo.- It is not an assessment, it is the impression I have.

President.- It is the impression, but I believe that it is not an accurate impression. I have to tell you that. In the last forty-eight hours, members of the Government have been: the Minister of Justice, the Minister of Defense, the Minister of the Interior, the Minister…

I. Gabilondo.- In the last forty-eight hours maybe yes, but what about in the last month and a half?

President.- And in the last month and a half. What happens is that, I have a good memory and you will surely remember that this has always happened in Governments. I remember perfectly hearing it said, with President Aznar, that President Aznar had a lot of prominence, that he was alone, that the Government was weaker; then there were changes, fewer changes… And I still remember the stage of President González. It all sounds familiar, it is something quite habitual.

Something happens, something happens that in a media society, of course, the President of the Government, when he appears normally, is the one who has the most direct prominence in public presence. But I can assure you that we have a Government that has worked on all fronts, with reforms and with results, with policies and with results, which is the most important. Surely citizens will give us the grade, when it is time, and they are the ones who in democracy give the grade, usually in general elections.

I. Gabilondo.- As a citizen, I want to tell you that the Government seems to me to be very blurred.

President.- I believe that the Government has outlined a transformative project…

I. Gabilondo.- Of course.

President.- …economically and socially, and in civil rights, very positive.

I. Gabilondo.- But it has been abducted by the ETA issue and practically…

President.- Now, if you tell me that this Government has renounced propaganda, I tell you yes, because it has renounced propaganda. Compared to other Governments, there are no massive advertising campaigns, as is well known. It has renounced propaganda. If you tell me that this Government has submitted to public and parliamentary debate more than any other, I tell you yes.

I found it amusing to hear yesterday the spokesperson in the Senate from the PP tell me: "Hey, you promised to revitalize Parliament!" And I said to him: but this is the first time you have the opportunity to ask a President of the Government in the Senate. This is what this Government has done, just as I have appeared more than any other President in Parliament.

We have been in favor of a democracy in which the Government is responding all day, exposing itself, answering and replying; but, certainly, in a democratic society, the Government is not the one who sets the agenda of the media. Fortunately, it is not the Government.

I. Gabilondo.- It would be again. Okay, okay.

President.- No. It is like that and I think so. Sometimes I have experienced that any minor news related to terrorism opened the news broadcasts, perhaps on the days we were approving a law like the Equality Law, which grants so many new rights to women and men, to fathers and mothers, so that they can have a better reconciliation of family and work life.

But beyond that, and understanding that, as is logical, the fight against ETA and terrorism occupies an important place, because it is the most serious problem this country has, I believe that citizens value and know very well what this Government has done better and what it has done less well. And in due time, they will judge, fortunately.

I. Gabilondo.- We no longer have time for other very important things, but you have to tell me something about Madrid. To know who won the elections, they add councilors, they add... There is a much simpler way: some are happy and others are sad; those who are happy are the ones who have won and those who are sad are the ones who have lost. So you have lost.

President.- Excuse me. You will not have seen me sad about the electoral result, because it would only be missing to be sad about an electoral result in which, in relation to what the objective of the elections is, which is to govern, and that is what elections are for in democracy, we are going to be able to govern more Autonomous Communities than we had, maintaining all the ones we governed, and a very important number more of provincial capitals, from fifteen to twenty-four provincial capitals, and it had been decades since the Socialist Party was in that situation, and having more councilors than anyone.

I said it: is the Popular Party happy with the elections? I am happy too. I think this is very good in democracy. Did we not do well everywhere? Of course we did. In Madrid, we had a bad result and, what is more important in democracy, there was a quick reaction.

In our party, responsibilities are assumed, there is an imprint of democratic spirit. Rafael Simancas has resigned, there will be a congress and I hope that this congress marks a new stage, of renewal, so that the citizens of Madrid have an alternative political offer that they deserve. We take responsibility where things have not been done well and no one is left waiting for anything; responsibility is assumed. Or has the Popular Party not had bad results in many places?

I. Gabilondo.- In the Basque Country, for example.

President.- Has anyone evaluated what percentage of support the Popular Party has in Catalonia and in Euskadi? Have they made any self-critical reflection?

Allow me to go a little further: Mr. Rajoy dropped seven points in the general elections for the Popular Party; Mr. Simancas has dropped five. Mr. Rajoy took his party from an absolute majority to the opposition, which has no precedent. He did not assume any responsibility. It seems that responsibilities, and I am glad it is so, I am glad, are fundamentally on the side of the Socialist Party. I believe that we admit when we win and when we do not win and, more importantly, we know how to win and we also know how to be when we do not win and not blame anyone, nor invent conspiracies or fables.

I. Gabilondo.- Now we really have to conclude. Two very quick things.

Was it a good idea for Miguel Sebastián to do the photo in the debate with Gallardón?

President.- After how it has happened, surely Miguel Sebastián himself would think about it again. But let me tell you one thing: I have found the things and the attacks that have been made against Miguel Sebastián absolutely unfair. He is an honest, integral, enormously valuable person; who, in addition, had the courage to propose himself to be a candidate for the Mayor of Madrid and the coherence to, in the face of a bad result, listen to the citizens and say "I am leaving." We have to get used to in democracy that sometimes you win, you have successes, and other times, you do not. Fortunately, it would be...

I. Gabilondo.- Did you like Guerra's ironic comment?

President.- Well..., no; I did not like it.

I. Gabilondo.- Are you still an anthropological optimist? Some will say you are starting to be an "antropoilogical" optimist.

President.- The truth is that pessimism has never created a job; pessimism has never made our Gross Domestic Product improve; pessimism has never made citizens have more rights and pessimism has never made social policies stronger. Pessimism has never built anything, nothing, and even more so what is catastrophism.

Of course I am optimistic. I am optimistic for Spain and I am optimistic because I trust in this country, in a country that has gone through thirty splendid years and that has great possibilities for the future. Yes, I am optimistic. Moreover, I am convinced that those who do not have that will, that desire and that optimism of trust in a country, frankly, I do not know how they can be in the front line of politics and less want to be, as I want to be, President of the Government of Spain. I could not understand getting up every day, fixing a problem, seeking a solution and implementing a decision if you do not have that strength and that desire. It seems impossible to me, simply. It was already so when I was the leader of the opposition; I mean, it is not... And I exercised the leadership of the opposition with an optimistic tone, with a positive tone, because I think that is much more enriching for our country.

In democracy, the role of the Government is as important as that of the opposition. This is the greatness of democracy. And I hope that citizens can value that an opposition can be useful and, above all, is useful if it is responsible, if in some case or on some issue it is willing to contribute, and that a Government does what it has to do when it faces things and when, moreover, it is capable of being calm in the face of certain things.

I. Gabilondo.- Good night.

President.- Good night and thank you very much.