Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Los Desayunos de TVE"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 January 2008 · Interview on the program "Los Desayunos de TVE"

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on TVE's 'Los Desayunos' programme on 28 January 2008, during the pre-campaign period ahead of Spain's general elections.
Main themes
Tax rebate of 400 euros, electoral campaign commitments, fiscal policy, minimum pensions and wages, PSOE programmatic proposals, criticism from Popular Party, economic situation of families, inflation and cost of living, democratic accountability, personal income tax reform
Duration
~58 min
95th percentile
Words
6,921
95th percentile
Sentences
272
94th percentile
Readability
53
70th percentile
Grade
12.0
46th percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

272 sentences in 110 paragraphs

Pepa Bueno.- Mr. President, good morning.

President.- Good morning.

P. Bueno.- Welcome to "Los Desayunos."

President.- Thank you very much.

P. Bueno.- How are you feeling in this pre-campaign? These days tend to be exhausting, right?

President.- For now, we are not in an electoral campaign.

P. Bueno.- In pre-campaign.

President.- We are in pre-campaign, but I feel good, eager. Ultimately, for a political leader and a candidate, as is my case, an electoral campaign is always a moment of intensity, exciting, and in which you have to give your best to, logically, receive the maximum support possible from the citizens.

P. Bueno.- And days of promises. The latest, the one you made on Sunday at the PSOE Political Conference, Mr. President, has not left anyone indifferent, and we just saw it: returning 400 euros to each taxpayer. What is this?

President.- It is a commitment; not a promise, a commitment to the citizens, a commitment like those I have made in this Legislature in economic and social matters and that I have been fulfilling, such as the 30 percent increase in minimum pensions, the increase of the Minimum Interprofessional Wage to 600 euros. It is a programmatic commitment, like others in the electoral program: reaching minimum pensions with a dependent spouse at 850 euros, for people living alone at 700 euros, or the Minimum Wage at 800 euros. It is a commitment in fiscal matters.

In this Legislature, we have made a 6 percent reduction in personal income tax, and for the next Legislature, taking into account the economic situation and the public savings we have, the surplus, I understood that it was appropriate to make a new reduction in what represents personal income tax and a reduction that was economically efficient, fiscally moderate, and that, in addition, would also help families who, logically, this year have had and are suffering from a rise in prices. I believe it is good for the economy of Spain and for the economy of families, and therefore, what surprises me is that a programmatic commitment, like other commitments that other parties have, is accused of being electoralist. I really cannot understand it.

P. Bueno.- It is not a shock measure; it is a commitment to fiscal policy for the entire Legislature?

President.- It is a reduction of what taxpayers pay by 400 euros to wage earners and pensioners. It is a measure with a vocation for permanence until, if we have a majority, there is a reform of personal income tax. But I also think it is a programmatic measure made in time and form. What would be, from my point of view, somewhat unseemly is if I had taken the measure while in an electoral campaign, being the Government, because it would compromise the Government that comes out of the polls with a reduction of five billion in personal income tax, which is the cost of the measure. That would be unseemly.

P. Bueno.- That is the claim, for example, that we are going to hear, the one that says "if it is so necessary, do it now."

President.- If now are the elections. Now it is time for elections, and it is evident that the entire political, fiscal, social, and employment program will be endorsed by the citizens. To all political parties, some of which have become very excited, I think we need to ask them a question. I ask Rajoy and the PP: will they vote against in Parliament when, as soon as the Legislature begins, this measure is proposed, which I will take to the Government after the first Council of Ministers, if we gain the trust of the citizens? Will they vote against this measure? Let them tell the citizens, let them say it.

In democracy, citizens win based on the fact that political proposals, when the polls arrive, are concrete for two reasons: one, because this way you have the capacity to be demanding with whom you have given your vote, and it is easily verifiable whether you fulfill or do not fulfill; and, two, because the set of concrete measures and commitments we put before the citizens clearly guides what the political project is, the general sense, that you want to give to your government action, as we have oriented it in this Legislature by making the largest increase in minimum pensions of all Legislatures in democracy or making the largest increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage.

With those commitments, citizens have many more elements to know what the orientation of your Government is.

P. Bueno.- We are trying to clarify this measure, what it would consist of, who benefits, and how it would be paid; but, since you mentioned the Popular Party, we have just heard Mr. Aznar accusing you of buying votes and of caciquism, Mr. President.

President.- I believe that Mr. Aznar has a truly unusual opinion of the citizens of this country. There is not a single Spaniard of whom one can think that their vote can be bought. Spanish citizens are part of an adult democracy; they have demonstrated their political intelligence and their condition as citizens. I find it an insult to the citizenry, simply.

This is a political commitment from someone who is running as a candidate for President of the Government. This and many others, I insist. All those who are insinuating that have a very poor opinion of the citizens of this country. I have a very good one. I have full confidence in the Spanish people; they know how to judge commitments. They may agree with this measure or with others that we have in the electoral program, but people will vote freely. Or do some of you here believe that some people are influenced in that sense and will assume that their vote is for sale?

This is a much more serious country, and we have a great citizenry. What we have are very small politicians.

P. Bueno.- Another thing, Mr. President. If you win the elections, you are President of the Government again and fulfill your electoral commitment to return the 400 euros...

President.- What is evident is that, based on what you have said, no one doubts that I will fulfill it, just as I fulfilled the commitment I had with the citizens to withdraw troops from Iraq on the first day. No one doubts that I will fulfill it. What is good is that citizens know whether they will vote for this measure or not because, when I proposed the birth benefit of 2,500 euros, there were also criticisms that said everything, when I have to acknowledge that it is a measure that seems very positive to me for all families. To date, 196 families in Spain have already received 2,500 euros for the birth of a child.

Then we brought it to discussion in Parliament, and those who had raised the tone were asking for more. Come on, please, be a little coherent, a little serious, and respect what are natural procedures.

So, do the Popular Party and the other parties have the right to make proposals for tax cuts, and the Socialist Party and I do not have the right to make proposals and acquire commitments? It seems to me that, simply, the debate is perverted.

My opinion, do you know what it is? My opinion is that they have not been able to make a single proposal in economic and fiscal matters in four years of opposition, not a single one. I am not even talking about social proposals, which being the Popular Party, it is normal that there are no social proposals; but not even one fiscal and economic in four years. And when the Socialist Party or when I make a concrete proposal that everyone can understand, because tax reforms are often difficult to understand for citizens because they are very technical matters, they do not like it, probably because it has not occurred to them.

P. Bueno.- I see you a bit hurt or surprised by the reaction that the measure has provoked?

President.- The truth is, I jokingly commented before coming in here that if there is this controversy because I propose tax cuts for workers and pensioners and a refund of what they would have to pay for the year 2008, and there is this controversy, I do not want to think if someone, a Government, had to say one day that taxes need to be raised. With that, I could understand that there would be that controversy, but when you are proposing to return money to citizens and reduce taxes, I think we could debate it calmly and not say things about vote buying or caciquism, because, really, it is offensive to the citizenry to think that citizens are swayed by one proposal or another, regardless of the economic scope it may have.

P. Bueno.- Let's go with the proposal. What about those who are left out of that proposal? It is for pensioners and wage earners. What about the self-employed, as Nativel Preciado complained? What about those who are now below the exempt minimum, below 9,000 euros?

President.- The proposal is designed for those who have to pay, logically, and for wage earners and pensioners who have a different regime, from a fiscal point of view, than those who earn income from business and professional activities. This covers more than thirteen million citizens, eight million households, of which approximately three and a half million represent two people, a couple, normally, and therefore, it will mean eight hundred euros; there are 800,000 households where the reduction will be noticeable in three cases because they have three contributing individuals, and there are another four million where there is an individual taxpayer.

That is the universe, that is the measure, and, of course, there is, as is known, a reform that affects a part of the self-employed, which is in the personal income tax itself, which has not yet been applied and that before it is applied, no conclusion can be drawn from it; a reform that affects those self-employed whose income comes from 70 percent from a single company. But, I insist, the reform has entered this year, and it must be evaluated if it could be extended to them. What is clear is that it affects the regime of wage earners in this country and pensioners who, as is known, are equated.

P. Bueno.- And those who are below the exempt minimum, Mr. President, who must also be having a hard time in this moment of inflation?

President.- Yes, but there is no negative tax. That is to say, what we are doing is reducing for those who pay for a reason, of general interest, because it is good for economic stimulus, it will contribute to economic growth and will create around one hundred thousand jobs that can be created with the injection of one hundred billion euros into the economy; and, in addition, it responds to what is an economic logic.

We have saved, we have managed well, we have a surplus above what was expected, and therefore, we can stimulate the economy and help families. That seems to be a logic, and what common sense says, taking into account that, I insist, this is five billion and the surplus we are going to have this year exceeds twenty billion. That is to say, it is a prudent measure that keeps us, of course, without any problem all the social commitments that have been acquired in this Legislature and that are of great importance in terms of Minimum Wage, scholarships, minimum pensions, the Dependency Law, and the Equality Law. Let us see if we can have, as a society and as a country, the confidence that it is true that we have been a country that has gone through difficult economic and social stages, that today we can be one of the strongest economically and socially.

Of course, when one puts on the table that we have a surplus that will be above 2 percent, which Germany, France, England, Italy, the United States, Canada, or Japan would envy, which have public deficits, it is logical that we take measures that help the economy at a time when there is a tendency towards deceleration and that we help families at a time when they have to be making more effort due to the rise in prices and mortgages.

P. Bueno.- The measure has also received criticism from the left, even from the unions. Probably, viewers have approved that word "progressivity" that everyone is trying to explain in recent hours and is so difficult. The baby check was, is, the same for all, for all couples who have children; with this measure, the same reduction is announced for everyone, and those on the left say that this is not fair.

President.- From the left?

P. Bueno.- Gaspar Llamazares said it here yesterday.

President.- Allow me to say that the main left-wing party in this country is the Socialist Party. With all due respect to Gaspar Llamazares, we are broader.

Gaspar Llamazares's position is coherent, and I have discussed it with him many times. He never wants taxes to be reduced and always wants taxes to be increased. I believe that it is a view that is outdated, even from my point of view, on the left. Taxes are a tool, not an end; logically, a tool that you have to adapt to the economic conditions of each moment and each country. I believe that a country that has a reasonable, average tax burden can perfectly, if it has a policy aimed at redistributing, sharing, and making great social policies, as has been demonstrated in this Legislature.

The measure is progressive, and everyone understands it easily: a person who has to pay four hundred euros has their payment reduced by one hundred percent; that is, those who pay the least have everything they have to pay reduced, and if they have to pay less than four hundred, obviously also one hundred percent; a person who pays one thousand euros, who contributes one thousand euros to the Public Treasury, has their payment reduced by 40 percent, and those who pay two thousand euros, by 20 percent. It is very progressive.

Now, can anyone say that any employee who has contributed to the surplus, because everyone has contributed to the surplus, should not have anything reduced, even though 400 euros is clearly a small amount for those who pay the most to the tax authorities, perhaps reaching 5 or 1 percent, depending? Look, I believe that this is a country where all citizens who contribute and have contributed to the surplus should be treated with a certain consideration.

The measure is very progressive and universal for employees and pensioners. Simply, when one reflects a little on what we are talking about, it is understood; perhaps with a clearer example: a community of neighbors that has had a surplus in its accounts, in its contributions, decides to return money to those who are part of the community and decides on an equal amount for all, regardless of the neighbors who have contributed more because their apartments are much larger. It seems progressive, doesn’t it? It seems that if those who have paid a lot are going to receive the same as those who have paid little, it favors those who have paid little and, therefore, is progressive.

Q. Well .- In any case, does this measure not imply the admission or recognition that we are in a moment of economic uncertainty? Between the diagnosis made by the PP that there is a crisis and the diagnosis made by the Government and the Socialist Party that there is no crisis, but rather a slowdown and we are well prepared for it, in the middle are the citizens. There are also worrying indicators, Mr. President, such as unemployment: the unemployment data, like rising prices and these financial turbulences that we do not quite understand, but that do not sound good at all. In any case, are you not concerned that there is a distance between the Government's discourse and what citizens see in their daily domestic economy?

President .- There is an objective approach to be made to almost everything, and we should do it to the Spanish economy and the situation we have. The Spanish economy is going to close the year 2007 growing at 3.8 percent, having created jobs and having positioned itself at the lowest unemployment rates in our democracy. I want to remind you that when I came to Government, the unemployment rate was above 11 percent and now it is at 8 percent.

In other words, is this situation regarding employment better than it was four years ago? Evidently. It is also true that we have now had a bad unemployment figure, an increase in unemployment, but from a much better situation than we had four years ago and, therefore, with a greater capacity to address and respond to what is a process of economic slowdown from a very high level of economic growth that the Spanish economy has had, above the European average, above the major international powers and with a situation of economic strength and strength of public accounts that allows us to face it with calm and security.

Notice that the measure we have just taken to reduce income tax is five billion euros in a surplus of more than twenty billion, in a surplus! Spanish public accounts have never enjoyed a surplus. We have always been with the anguish of owing a lot, and now we are among the developed countries that owe the least, which is certainly difficult to accept because historically we were among those who owed the most.

We have a capacity to finance public policies like we have never had to continue making social policies and to continue making infrastructure policy, modernization policy, and to reactivate the economy, to help the economy and to ensure that this slowdown is a smooth slowdown.

Therefore, my message is one of calm and confidence. How could it not be if we have demonstrated that we have the capacity to grow economically, to save, and to distribute?

Q. Well .- Why are we not in London today, Mr. President? Why is Spain not at that Summit being held in London with Germany, France, and Italy to talk about the economic situation?

President .- Because it is a Summit of the European G-8 countries. That is why those who are there are there, neither one more nor one less.

Q. Well .- We are almost in a position to be in the G-8, aren’t we, Mr. President?

President .- But we are not. I have never even considered it as a goal. The G-8 has the scope it has; the same ones have been there since it was established or a few more, practically.

Of course, we are not there, and no European country is there other than those that are part of the G-8.

Q. Well .- Would you have liked to be there?

President .- The truth is that it depends on what the content is. At this moment, perhaps, it is not an issue that affects Prime Ministers more directly what the financial turbulences represent. We are all more concerned about what the Federal Reserve does today with interest rates. Surely, the stock markets, since you asked me about the stock markets earlier, will evolve today based on the expectation of whether the Federal Reserve of the United States lowers interest rates or not. And surely Europe, depending on what happens today at eight o'clock in the evening Spanish time, will be attentive to what the reaction of the European Central Bank may be in the coming weeks regarding interest rates.

This allows me to close with a reflection, which is that a European government, when there is a situation of economic slowdown or rising prices, does not have monetary policy in its hands; it cannot modify interest rates; it is the European Central Bank. I have at my disposal, fundamentally, fiscal policy, as a government, and that is why we have acted with fiscal policy that, without a doubt, will bring positive benefits to the economy.

Q. Well .- President Rodríguez Zapatero, did you make a mistake in explaining in the interview with Pedro J. Ramírez that there had been contacts with ETA after the T-4 attack?

President .- I have always characterized myself as a person who, even in a matter like anti-terrorist policy, gives all the explanations. Honestly, I believe that I am the President of the Government, at least, who may have been so clear in principles, convictions, and transparency before citizens when facing a dialogue process in such a delicate matter as the fight against terrorism.

What I deeply regret is that from the first day of exercising the task of Government, in anti-terrorist policy, regardless of the circumstances we have lived without dialogue or with dialogue, with strong action by public authorities, by the State Security Forces and Corps, or with processes of illegalization or without illegalization of the so-called abertzale forces; whatever happens, whatever happens, I have always had a very harsh opposition from the right of the Popular Party in anti-terrorist policy.

It is the only area where they should never oppose; the area where, as leader of the opposition, in the four years prior to my Presidency of the Government, I gave all my support every day to what represents the fight to end violence or reduce it to the maximum.

These are the principles with which I have conveyed to citizens what my task has been. By the way, I do want to emphasize that, of course, I will have the opportunity to debate this issue with Mr. Rajoy, and I will stay here for now because I believe that will be the most appropriate scenario; but I am...

Q. Well .- But I was asking you about the opportunity to explain it now and not having done so before.

President .- If there is neither now nor before. That is to say, when there is a matter that may be of interest to citizens, I have always told the truth, within the prudence that I must have and maintain. When it comes to the fight against terrorism, the security of the State is at stake, and the security of people, of people who may have tried to work with all their best efforts to see the end of violence.

That principle of responsibility that the Government and the President of the Government have in the fight against terrorism has always been respected. I think about the future and hope that it will be respected again in the future because the interest in the fight for freedom, for democracy, and for the lives of citizens is at stake.

Q. Well .- Is it electoralist to illegalize the PCTV and ANV now, and not to have done so before?

President .- I expressed it a moment ago: if it is done, it is criticized; if it is not done, it is criticized. If it is done before, it would have been criticized; if it is done now, it is also criticized.

The fact is that I have never felt, not a single day, in my action as Government the support of the Popular Party and Mr. Rajoy in the task of fighting terrorism. I have not felt it for a single day. Four years ago, when the Legislature ended, I could tell citizens, and citizens know that it is so, that there was not a single day in which I did not give all my support to the Aznar and Rajoy Government in the fight against ETA terrorism.

This is what has changed. It has not changed that there is a dialogue process; there has been one on many occasions; it has not changed that there have been contacts; there have been in democracy on many occasions, and surely, citizens understand this and also know that a President of the Government can say it like this. What has changed, the only thing that has changed, is that the Popular Party has made the fight against terrorism carried out by the Government its essential opposition objective. And I hope that citizens say that they do not like this change and that what they want to see is an opposition being understanding, supporting, and pitching in the fight against terrorism.

Q. Well .- Polls say that the crisis of Gallardón is taking a toll on the Popular Party in the latest polls and that you are distancing yourselves from the famous technical tie. In this campaign, the errors of the opponent play more than your own proposals, Mr. President. It’s a bit sad, isn’t it? Is that so?

President .- It is true that it is difficult to analyze opinion polls, and it is even more difficult to draw definitive conclusions before citizens go to the polls. I have great respect for citizens. Citizens vote freely every four years and do not vote for a specific thing that happens one day and that changes the state of opinion or mood; no, citizens vote for a four-year task, for the things they consider you have done well, also for the things they consider you have made mistakes in, and also for those in the opposition. They evaluate what has been done in the opposition over four years, whether they liked it or not, and, of course, on the projects that each of us presents for the future. But to think that the polls determine because there has been a proposal or because something happens with Gallardón? No.

It is true that Gallardón, more than a concrete fact, represents a whole category. The question is how is it possible that someone like Gallardón does not fit into the lists of the Popular Party and where the Popular Party has positioned itself in ideological political terms. And it is also worth making a consideration: what kind of leadership is that which does not integrate the majority, all those who want to contribute and that, fundamentally, is pending on what others do or is dependent on what others do or say.

Q. Well .- Speaking of mistakes, was there any mistake in the negotiation process of the Statute of Catalonia?

President .- The negotiation process of the Statute of Catalonia is a process that was subjected to an intense debate, as is appropriate when reforming a Statute of Autonomy, first, in the Parliament of Catalonia and then in the General Courts.

The resulting text is a good text. It is a text that increases the self-government of Catalonia and that respects the Constitution, from my point of view. Therefore, I believe that, beyond the fact that the debate and the course of it had different incidents, the result is positive just as it has always been when we have advanced in self-government in our country.

One of the keys to the economic success of territories or Autonomous Communities approaching in per capita income and development is that we have a State of Autonomies. Therefore, every time a Statute of Autonomy is reformed, if it is done well and if the principles of the Constitution, of cooperation, of cohesion, and of solidarity are respected, it is good for the country.

Q. Well .- It has been a very reformist legislature. Laws have been passed that have a significant impact on the lives of citizens, such as the Dependency Law, the Equality Law, the Statute of Autonomists, the Gender Violence Law, or the law that allows marriage between same-sex people. What do we have left? What would be the horizon in terms of the extension of rights?

President .- Extension of rights? Indeed, it has been a very fruitful legislature that allows the citizens of this country, all, to have more freedoms, to be recognized in their rights, and for no one to be discriminated against.

For the next Legislature, we are proposing, and we are committed to making, a Law of Equal Treatment and Non-Discrimination in any circumstance that may arise from differences between people, which must cover education, business, health, and all aspects of social life. We want to guarantee that there is effective and real equal treatment, because there are always areas in a society where there are citizens who, for one reason or another, do not have equal treatment. And public authorities first, the Law, but then the effectiveness of the Law must address that situation.

P. Bueno .- You said "power will not change me" and that is very unhuman. It is even inhumane, because all circumstances change people, and of course power does too, if only because it teaches things, right? If José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero becomes President of the Government again, what mistakes would you not make?

Presidente .- I have expressed them on some occasions. For example, the AVE in Barcelona was a mistake in what it represented in the final phase of a section of the work. It is true that the mistake is a mistake in the development of a project that a company undertakes, but the responsibility is, logically, of the Government. Therefore, we must reinforce all guarantees when executing large public works and be prudent. It is common for these works to succeed, because we have great companies, 99 percent of which have guaranteed success.

Secondly, I have acknowledged the mistake I made on December 29, 2006, a day before the serious attack at T-4, stating that within a year we would be better in the fight against terrorism.

I have recognized more mistakes, but, well, I am not willing to recall them. What I do not know is whether this is very common, in terms of democratic tradition, in our country.

P. Bueno .- I appreciate that in any case.

Presidente .- Sometimes they tell me "don't keep acknowledging mistakes and so on," but I don't know if that is very common. Certainly, in the more recent memory of the person I succeeded in office, I have not noted any acknowledgment of mistakes, and the truth is that it is commendable, because the list would be enormous just in objective terms.

Nativel Preciado .- Mr. President, I have so many questions for you, but Pepa has already indicated to me that I will not have time to talk about relations with the Church, the Abortion Law, and citizen insecurity; so I will stick with the first one, which is relations with the Church. Why do we maintain a Concordat with the Vatican considering that we live in a secular and non-confessional State? Why is the Church financed in the General State Budgets?

Presidente .- It is perfectly compatible, what represents the affirmation of a non-confessional State, which is what the Constitution says and which responds to my profound convictions, with what I would call a secular society, where no one can impose any morality or belief and where those who pretend that faith should be legislated must abandon any hope, because civil rights are legislated, not a belief or a faith.

Our Constitution also establishes that the State must have preferential, singular relations with the Catholic Church. That is to say, there is a kind of mandate to ensure that what is the majority confession, in religious terms, of Spanish citizens has a reasonable relationship with the State; a relationship that has been maintained since the democratic transition, which translates into various agreements of an economic nature and others, and which, of course, I have maintained because I believe it responds to a reasonable principle that emanates from the Constitution and that exists in many other countries, beyond the attitude of some parts of the hierarchy of the Catholic Church.

Of course, it is a question that is logically subject to debate. I know that there are many citizens who believe that this should change, should be reformed. My position is that we must be prudent and rise above what is a conjuncture, an attitude, of some very belligerent and very disrespectful cardinals or bishops with what the laws approved by Parliament represent, and give it a perspective a little beyond.

Esther Palomera .- You started this interview by saying that no one doubted that if you won the elections on March 9, you would fulfill that commitment of the 400 euros that you announced last Sunday. My question relates to anti-terrorist policy. Do you consider that the credibility you have in social matters and the extension of rights is the same as you have today in this country in anti-terrorist matters? I ask you this because there have been three occasions in which, not just the Popular Party, but the citizenry in general, thinks that you have not been sufficiently clear regarding the so-called peace process. To give you an example, I believe it was after the verification of the so-called ceasefire when you told us that the left abertzale was not the same as Batasuna and when we were told that after the T-4 attack all contacts with the terrorist group had ended. The question is: does President José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero need to make an additional effort to be credible going forward in anti-terrorist matters?

Presidente .- This Government has done everything in its power, and specifically the President of the Government, from day one to end terrorist violence or reduce it to the maximum, in situations of dialogue or no dialogue. And it has been the first Government to seek Parliament's support for a dialogue process, which represents having the greatest endorsement and also represents having the greatest will for transparency.

What has happened, unlike other moments, is that there has been an attempt to oppose and to maintain a permanent attitude of questioning and criticism of a dialogue process that, in my opinion, has not strengthened, in any way, the terrorist group ETA. And I insist, time will give us perspective, and I will surely have the opportunity to debate it directly with Mr. Rajoy, about the situation we are in now, the situation from four years ago, how it has evolved, and the results of an anti-terrorist policy.

But, look, I have maintained three principles before the citizenry: first, to fight and work to the limit of what a democrat can represent and do to end violence; second principle, I would never pay, nor can democracy do so, any political price to end violence; and, third, I have maintained the principle of transparency within what represents anti-terrorist policy because there will not be another period in which a dialogue process has been more subjected to public scrutiny, parliamentary action, debate, and criticism. Those are the three principles I have maintained, and the proof that I have maintained them is that, logically, ETA has lost twice in this process: it has lost an opportunity, a new opportunity, that democracy had offered it, and it has lost because it is today weaker.

Miguel Angel Liso .- One of the first laws that your Government promoted, Mr. President, was against gender violence. I remember some of your statements about this Law in which you said it would be a strong law and would have resources to improve and try to overcome this scourge. To this day, we are not better off, or we are even worse. I do not know if you have a certain feeling of failure on this issue. What more can be done in the face of a phenomenon that indeed has a significant social impact?

Presidente .- The Law on Violence against Women is a law that has provided more support to women at risk of being victims of abuse, both in terms of preventive work and in terms of social support for those who suffer it; and I want to remind you that there are many people who today have certain rights and benefits that they did not have before. And, without a doubt, it has also represented a great effort of global awareness of society in the fight against gender violence.

The figures remain, and therefore, there is still a lot to be done. I have said it many times: if there is something I cannot stand and that produces the greatest possible rebellion in me as a citizen, as a human being, and as a man, it is macho violence. It produces the greatest rejection in me, and I believe it is an effort that, of course, the Government and all of society must lead with all our commitment. I am convinced that not only the Law but also support actions and social awareness will help us win this battle, because it is a battle, in which I am absolutely convinced that all citizens are committed and that it is worth it.

P. Bueno .- Mr. President, this house, Radiotelevisión Española, has signed an alliance with the YouTube portal so that any citizen can ask their question, whatever they want, to the candidates in these elections. You already trained in "I have a question for you," on Televisión Española, and citizens asked you questions there. Would you dare to debut this format here, right now, with a couple of questions?

Presidente .- Yes, yes. Of course.

P. Bueno .- Let's see a couple of questions pulled from the web.

Ciudadana .- How do you plan to maintain pensions and public services in a time of crisis while lowering taxes?

Ciudadano .- What will the Government's position be regarding the current labor precariousness, not only in terms of salaries but also in terms of working conditions?

Presidente .- I have explained it, and it is to reiterate the commitment. We are going to increase social benefits and we are going to reduce taxes on labor income, as I have said and as is already known, by 400 euros each year. This is possible because we have saved. We have saved. The Social Security has a savings fund of 53 billion euros. And, as we have greatly increased our number of employed people, of people who work and contribute, we can raise pensions.

I will give a figure: in what will represent the fulfillment of the commitment to raise minimum pensions, reaching 850 euros and 700 with a spouse and for people living alone, respectively, will practically double minimum pensions in the period I have been in charge of the Government. Perhaps, for me, it is the most intimate satisfaction I have. This is thanks to what? Thanks to the work of the people and thanks to the fact that people are working more, more jobs have been created, and there are more social contributions.

Therefore, I not only say to the person who asks that we are not going to maintain, but that we are going to increase social policies because we can do it. I know it is difficult for a country, I insist, that has always been in debt or that has had a deficit to quickly incorporate itself into what represents having a surplus and having a debt that is perhaps the lowest of all the major economic powers. We are at 36 percent debt in relation to GDP. We have economic leeway, leeway in public accounts, and if the Government and the public sector have saved a lot, it seems reasonable that it helps a little to families that many of them, as is known, have many debts. This is quite reasonable and, moreover, economically, I insist, efficient.

Labor precariousness. We have signed an agreement with the unions and with employers for stability in employment, an agreement that is working. The latest data from the EPA, which was bad in terms of job creation, was good in terms of reducing temporality. We are already at 30 percent and we came from 34 percent.

The path to greater stability only goes through agreements between employers and unions, and by increasing the productivity of the Spanish economy, that is, the capacity we have to do things better, with lower costs. That has a lot to do with training and has a lot to do with companies' investment in R&D+i.

But I am convinced that this year 2007 we will end up significantly improving the productivity of the Spanish economy, which is one of the great historical subjects that allows us to see how our growth model is improving, and the most direct way, practically the only one we have in the Spanish economy, to improve wages is to increase productivity and to improve per capita income and continue gaining positions in Europe in per capita income is to improve productivity, because in employment increase we have practically reached the ceiling for what represents increasing per capita income.

We have surpassed Italy in per capita income and now we have the goal of surpassing France in per capita income in the coming years, four or five years. We can do it. I do not know if in the collective imagination it is sufficiently encouraging regarding our possibilities of surpassing a country like France in per capita income.

P. Bueno .- Prime Minister, thank you for coming. Good luck.

Presidente .- Thank you very much. Luck must be earned, and much more so when it comes to the vote of the citizens. It must be earned.