Interview with the President of the Government on the program "On Days Like Today," from Radio Nacional de España.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 June 2008 · Interview on the program 'On Days Like Today', Radio Nacional de España · Radio Nacional de España

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Radio Nacional de España's morning program on June 18, 2008, addressing Spain's economic situation amid global financial pressures.
Main themes
Economic slowdown vs. crisis debate, Spain's economic strength, social protection policies, unemployment and job creation, public investment and infrastructure, optimism and confidence, oil prices and Euribor, housing assistance, high-speed rail and highways, education and technology investment
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,099
97th percentile
Sentences
328
96th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.5
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

328 sentences in 129 paragraphs

President.- Good morning.

J.R.Lucas.- First of all, thank you for being on Radio Nacional. For us, this is a very important, historic visit for this station.

President.- Thank you very much. Thanks to you and all the professionals at Radio Nacional de España.

J.R.Lucas.- Mr. President, is there a crisis or is there not a crisis?

President.- It is true that there have been recent events in the economic world, such as the rise in oil prices, an excessive rise in oil prices, or the increase in the Euribor, which is causing a rise in mortgages, or the crisis in the real estate sector in the United States, which has generated problems in credit financing for businesses and individuals, leading a part of the citizenry, and it is understandable, to have a perception of crisis. We have difficulties and problems, but Spain is today an economically strong country.

We are the eighth largest economy in the world; we have good public accounts; we have a good social protection system like we have never had before; we have twenty million people working, the lowest unemployment rate in history; pensions that are progressively increasing; unemployment protection that is higher than ever; and significant assets to face what is a process of difficulties.

But, I insist, I understand that there are citizens, after experiencing years of economic growth, of job growth, of wealth creation in the country, even though now we have a very significant slowdown, who have that feeling, who have that perception, which we will know how to recover from and that, as soon as international circumstances allow us, we will grow strongly again.

J.R.Lucas.- So, there is no crisis.

President.- The important thing is that we have confidence, as a country, in ourselves. We know what we have been able to do, to grow more for years than the European average. We will continue that growth and we will maintain all our possibilities for well-being and development.

There is no interest… I have said that there is a significant part of citizens who have that perception and, if citizens have that perception, it is logical to deeply respect it. The obligation of a Government is to respond to the most immediate problems, which for us is to attend to, support, and help the social sectors with the lowest income, as a top priority, that is, those who may face unemployment; continue to raise minimum pensions; maintain the increase in housing assistance and the increase in scholarships.

All of that we can do; we are doing it and we will continue to do it, and, of course, ensure that the country is as well prepared as possible for the moment of recovery. This is called maintaining productive investment and we will do it with infrastructure, in technological capital, and in Education so that, I insist, we can grow strongly again.

J.R.Lucas.- Mr. President, you are evidently exuding optimism. It has to be that way, too. You are looking at a horizon of solution to the crisis or the economic situation and I insist on the question again, because the terminology seems to me to be not a minor issue in this case. Are you not fleeing from the use of that term out of fear that worse things may still come in the near future and to see how you will be called then?

President.- If you gather ten economists here and ask them to define the situation, there will surely be ten opinions on a definition of the situation, which, in my opinion, has little importance. Some call it a crisis; others, a slowdown… Objectively, what do we have? Difficulties and problems that we did not have on the horizon a year ago, when economic growth in Spain was above its potential; now we are growing below our potential. We were creating jobs and now it is much harder for us to create jobs. We had a public surplus and now, logically, we have to dedicate a significant part of that public surplus to support the sectors with the most difficulties.

That is the reality: a growth that we were experiencing strongly, which has now slowed down, and we will work to make this period as short as possible.

What is the most important thing that Spanish society should know? The most important things are two: one, that we have resources and political will, certainly due to the identity that this Government represents, to maintain and strengthen social policies, to support workers, to support pensioners, to support those who need a scholarship, and to support those who may try to buy a home.

Secondly, we have assets as a country to take the path of recovery of growth to our potential as soon as there are better international conditions. Why? Because today Spain has capitalized in a very powerful way and we will be, in just two years, the country with the most kilometers of high-speed rail in the world, we will be the country with the most kilometers of highways and motorways in Europe, and we have been increasing our technological capital.

This is what a country needs to know that it can withstand when things become more difficult and that it can relaunch itself strongly in the coming times. And, in addition, we have an asset that many countries facing difficulties would wish for, because this is an international situation, which is social dialogue, agreement, understanding, that exists between employers, unions, and the Government, which is an exercise of responsibility but is, above all, a powerful message of confidence in ourselves and a commitment to know how to provide adequate responses to specific problems.

J.R.Lucas.- We saw that yesterday, indeed. After the meeting in Moncloa, there was a general sense of unity and a commitment, moreover, from the Government that no significant decision would be made without consulting the so-called social agents. You speak of starting to design a "roadmap" by July or August, but what decisions does the President of the Government have in mind to resolve this situation in conjunction with employers and unions?

President.- In July we are going to approve, let’s say, what is an agenda of topics on which we will propose, from the Government, decisions and, therefore, agreements. And another part of the topics will be the subject of dialogue with all social agents, with employers and unions.

Where should we work prioritarily? I believe that in social dialogue, in addition to maintaining the commitments in social policy that I have committed to, especially with the unions; that is to say, pensions; that is to say, unemployment protection; that is to say, application of the Equality Law; that is to say, development of the Dependency Law; we need to address two important reforms for the medium term in our economy: one, the role and effectiveness of public employment services in generating employment, in providing an adequate response from people who are unemployed or who aspire to employment for the first time. We still have an evident mismatch and we want the Public Employment Service to be much more effective. And we must also involve the Autonomous Communities in this.

Secondly, Vocational Training. We need, this country needs, to strengthen or improve what we have come to know as Vocational Training, because the work, the task, or the field of mediation between what is the training process in our country, in technical and professional areas, and the demand for employment that often does not have coherence, is not adequately harmonized. It is a fundamental task to improve Vocational Training.

Thirdly, social protection, pensions, Social Security. We made an agreement in the social dialogue process of the last four years, one of the twenty agreements we made in social dialogue, and now it is up to the Toledo Pact to re-examine that situation in case any new reform needs to be introduced to continue guaranteeing our solid pension system in the long term.

Fourthly, industrial policy…

J.R.Lucas.- Sorry to interrupt you. It is solid, despite what the Bank of Spain says.

President.- But the Bank of Spain always… If one looks at the reports, I know that now, in this context, it may have a bit more of the traditional interests of the Bank of Spain, it always raises an alert about the need to introduce reforms in our pension system in the long term. In the short and medium term, our pension system is very solid; we have a Reserve Fund of 56 billion euros, which we have never had in history, as is well known, and we have the capacity to increase minimum pensions. Despite this period of economic difficulties in public revenues and challenges, Social Security revenues continue to grow by 7 percent.

That is to say, there is a solidity of the system, because we have more than seventeen million affiliates, but it is always advisable to be attentive to incorporate reforms. That is why the Toledo Pact was born, that is why reforms have been introduced and applied; now there are other new ones in application and we will be able to act in that direction.

In addition to that, what do we want to address in dialogue, in the social pact? What initiatives are we going to put on the table for employers and unions? I insist, industrial policies for competitiveness. Improving the productivity of our economy is advisable in many sectors, especially in sectors that technologically take over from construction, which was an activity that had great strength in Spain, which is reducing and which, in the medium-term horizon, logically will not have the dimension it had in recent years, in 2005 or 2006, which was excessive.

These are the most important topics in social dialogue. They are all significant issues for Spanish society and address, in the short term, alleviating, maintaining an important level of social policies that we can maintain because the country is strong. Surely, those who have already experienced it in other moments of difficulties know that what was discussed was about cuts in the labor field or in the field of social policies; now, no, now we have the possibility, due to having a surplus, logically the Government has some merit in this, but it is not the most important; the merit is of the country, for maintaining those social policies and for doing what we are doing in these months, which is to accelerate, to bring forward investments in public works to help activity because, since the beginning of the year, in the months we have had this year, we have already tendered nearly seven billion euros. Those tenders will turn into work in the coming months and it is a considerable amount of economic activity and, also, of job maintenance.

J.R.Lucas.- Mr. President, I do not know if you have received that perception, but I have been able to detect on the street, among listeners, even myself, with the recent strike or, let’s say, the transport stoppage a certain feeling of unprotection. Suddenly, fifty trucks come and create a bottleneck in the economy of a country.

President.- As much as in the economy of a country..! I believe everyone knows that a transport strike is one of the difficult things to address in a situation. Now, with more days passed, perhaps we will have a more objective analysis or assessment of how the Government addressed that situation.

I will give some data. We have been negotiating with the transport sector since the end of April. In a sector that is very divided into different organizations, always with 80 or 70, I don’t care, percent of the sector we maintained that dialogue and reached agreements. A minority part was at the table, but, above all, was trying to protest in a way that represents manifesting with trucks that, logically, is very disruptive, gravely disruptive, to coexistence.

I want to remind you that the strike practically started on a Monday and that by Wednesday the effectiveness of the State Security Forces, especially the Civil Guard and the Police, had practically reduced to nothing the capacity to block roads, to prevent and cause serious disruptions, as occurred in Madrid. It was just under 48 hours and surely all citizens know, because they logically have to understand and comprehend, that the State Security Forces have to know, in each circumstance, what movement they are facing. We are talking about the whole country, about thousands and thousands of kilometers of highways and roads and about a deployment that we had to make of twenty-five thousand police officers and civil guards.

It was 48 hours, and we deeply regret the time that citizens were affected, harmed. There have been, without a doubt. It is true that there was a certain climate of shortages, which may have been exaggerated; but, in my opinion, both what was the political track of negotiation, as well as the track of guaranteeing in the shortest time possible, attending to what represents putting thousands and thousands of trucks on the roads, with a serious disruption effect, I believe the response was reasonable.

Simply put, I can refer to what may happen or is happening in other European countries, where facing this situation is logically difficult, and the Government must have a proportional response to situations that could be very tense, as unfortunately was the case, even, in one instance with the loss of life of one of the strikers, and knowing that those who have the operational capacity, the capacity to respond, to know when, how, and where, are, logically, the State Security Forces and Corps, whom I want to congratulate from here because many citizens will have seen how the Civil Guard has engaged in a task that is not easy, which has been day and night, trying to prevent trucks from doing something they cannot do, which is to cut off the free movement on our roads.

Can they manifest? Yes. Can they demand? Of course. Is the Government sensitive to what the sharp rise in oil prices represents for certain sectors? Of course it is. And we are always willing, as we have been, to approve a package of measures, but not at the expense of the entire citizenry for that demand.

J.R.Lucas.- Mr. President, transporters, but also farmers, fishermen, and public officials are beginning to mobilize. Do you feel strong enough to regain the lost trust of the Spanish people, especially in economic matters, I insist?

President.- The truth is that I have just obtained that trust in the elections of March 9.

J.R.Lucas.- I am referring to the confidence indices that you know perfectly well are measured in specific magnitudes and that have fallen in recent weeks.

President.- That is always relative, isn’t it? Because that has to be measured at each moment and in each circumstance. What I am absolutely convinced of is the strength of our country and the goodness and strength of the project I represent; the project of modernizing our country and the project of extending the projects and social policies that have characterized the last Legislature and that will continue to characterize the next Legislature.

Listeners can be assured that in this we will not lack either tenacity or capacity for commitment. Moreover, I do this from a political force, the Socialist Party, that is united, that has no doubts about what it is and where it is going, and that, therefore, has a logical capacity to represent that social majority, and to set the course and destiny of a country that, as it has been in recent years, will continue to be a country of growing reference in the world for its economic importance, for its cultural importance, and for the importance of its policies of commitment to values as necessary in the international order as peace, human rights, and development cooperation.

If we are the country that is going to be at the forefront in what affects development aid, do not doubt that this means we can have confidence in ourselves.

The Government has, logically, to work, sometimes in easier circumstances and sometimes in somewhat more difficult circumstances, and everyone understands that; but we know what we are doing and we are convinced that the course is the right one.

J.R.Lucas.- Are there difficulties, Mr. President, for measures adopted by the central Government, such as aid to dependents or rental assistance, to reach their intended recipients due to bureaucratic problems or, in some cases, political problems? What should we tell the citizens? Just to be patient, to wait?

President.- Rental assistance is reaching people. I want to say that in the last report that the Minister of Housing gave in the Council of Ministers, we were already talking about nearly forty thousand aids to young people. Logically, this is one more social policy, with aid of 210 euros per month. I believe that the number will increase and will exceed one hundred thousand young people who will receive rental assistance, which, by the way, must continue to be promoted in our country.

The Dependency Law is an ambitious law that builds a new system, a new benefit, in the Welfare State that, surely, families with dependents would wish for its immediate application; but it is being developed in conjunction with the Autonomous Communities. There are already a significant number of people receiving benefits. I must say that it is not uncommon for some people on the street to tell me, "I have just received, or my family, or my mother, has already received a benefit, either a financial amount or a caregiver."

The law will reach all families that need it. It is true that we would all like it to arrive sooner. Some Autonomous Communities have collaborated more intensively than others, have been more effective than others, but it will reach everyone. And, of course, in terms of the implementation of the system, compared to other major pillars of the Welfare State, it will not be a slow implementation. What happens is that it has a process: first, a law was approved; several regulations had to be issued; agreements had to be made with the Autonomous Communities; the assessment units had to be configured; assessments by specialists of the people requesting dependency had to be made; once that assessment is done, it has to go through an individual approval process… In short, the process of being in a Rule of Law.

I understand that, sometimes, we would all like it; the President of the Government, the most… When I made the decision to return six billion euros from the income tax through the famous four hundred euros, which is to help families, with an income or an increase in income, which is six billion euros… That is to say, what families will receive is one trillion pesetas. What families will receive starting from this month’s payroll, from June until December 31, will be one trillion pesetas, which the Government takes from public coffers and says: since we have our accounts in order, we put one trillion pesetas in families, in the payrolls of workers, unions, and self-employed, to help them a bit with the rise in mortgages and the rise in prices.

I would have liked it to be automatic, but we are in a Rule of Law. A Royal Decree Law has to be approved, it has to be validated in Parliament, a regulation has to be approved, the Tax Agency has to set up all the mechanisms for companies to do the task they have to do in the payroll, and by the end of June it will be noticeable.

Why do I say this? I say this because it is true that this week there is talk of "no measures are being taken." Twenty economic measures have been taken since we came to Government. The first Council of Ministers was a Royal Decree Law on economic measures, among others, the four hundred euros; but we have just taken the measure to eliminate the Wealth Tax, which will be another 1.8 billion euros that in 2009 will go to the families of this country because they will pay zero on their wealth. And that, logically, has some deadlines for coming into force.

All economic measures will practically start to come into force, to be effective in the concrete perception of citizens, starting from the end of June, with the payroll at the end of June, and for a good part of the first months of 2009.

Francisco Medina.- You spoke of perception, and following up on what you said, I counted yesterday and it turns out that these days, I believe it was Tuesday, it marks exactly one hundred days, the famous one hundred days, after the elections; that is, the one hundred days that are always given…

President.- The one hundred days are counted from the moment the Government is constituted.

F. Medina.- Well… But don’t spoil my question because it’s a pretty round hundred days.

President.- But the nuances are important sometimes, because, of course, one wins the elections, but then has to form a Government, has to undergo an investiture, be supported by Parliament, and form a Government. But, well, one hundred days since the elections is also an emblematic date and allows me any global assessment.

F. Medina.- And it allows me to ask you, speaking about perception…

President.- Excuse me, excuse me.

F. Medina.- No, no; on the contrary, you are right. It is always the one hundred days of Government, but we have those one hundred days since March 9 and many feel that the Government, in some way, is blocked, that the Government is not present. In Parliament, for example, it seems that the Popular Party is being more active despite the crisis.

My question is: Has the shock from the economic situation led the Government to take a step back, digest the situation, and say before we get started?

President.- The truth is that active, active, the one who has been in this stage has been the Popular Party. I am not saying that the activity has been good or bad, I do not evaluate it; but active, active, the Popular Party has been. While in the Popular Party we were hearing whether Rajoy yes or Rajoy no, or whether Esperanza was going or not, or whether Costa was showing up or not, the Government was approving Royal Decree Laws and economic measures. It is true that this may have occupied less interest in the media because, normally, when there is an internal debate in a party, that takes up most of the time.

The Government was preparing social dialogue, which no one can imagine started yesterday on a good note, because they were called for the first time yesterday, without prior work; the Government was preparing Bills that it has sent to Parliament; the Government was preparing the entire budgetary scenario for the next year, approving the spending ceiling; the Government was solving the problem we had, which fortunately nature helped us with, of the drought, and we were, logically, approving projects and initiatives, and we are. It is very curious, but a comparison of what has been the start of these just over two months of Government in terms of Bills, decrees, and decision-making exceeds what has been the start of other Legislatures.

But it is true that there is that feeling, perhaps because economic problems create a demand from public opinion, let’s say, for reactions and responses in day-to-day life. And it is true that we must react. We are doing it, but, you see, as important as the measures taken, which fortunately are those we can take to help families and businesses, not cuts… Notice the difference: there have been other moments of economic difficulties and what there were were Royal Decree Laws restricting labor rights, which led to a general strike. Now what we are experiencing is that the Government is making decisions to return money to families, so that workers’ payrolls are somewhat better, or to maintain social policy, to increase minimum pensions.

These are all political decisions and planning of the Government, but it is true that that feeling in front of… Is oil rising a lot? People say: can there be a response? In my opinion, it is a response that goes beyond our own country. Of course, it seems absolutely exorbitant to me the price at which oil has been set. It is inexplicable that a commodity in two months goes from being worth 80 dollars a barrel to 135 dollars without anything happening in the world. This must be addressed at the international level. I hope that in this European Council, which we start today, the European Union addresses it, that we European leaders address it, and that we send some response, because it has a tremendous economic importance.

F. Medina.- You were joking about the Popular Party, with a joke, following the tone we had… I cannot resist: how has it been seen, from the Government, from the Socialist Party, and it has even been seen with concern what was happening or what is happening in the Popular Party?

President.- With concern, no. It would be a somewhat absurd exercise to say that we see it with concern. I believe that political parties in democracy have their periods of change. When a project ends, a new project must normally emerge. Sometimes, that new project takes longer or takes less time. The Socialist Party experienced in its time, when it lost the elections in 1996, a period of changes, modifications, and it is normal for it to happen in the Popular Party. We view it, of course, with democratic respect. I think that is important, unlike perhaps other moments when we had problems.

Secondly, all we wish is to have a feasible common space for dialogue on important issues.

But my wish is that they have a good congress and that the Popular Party, which represents an important electorate in this country, finds its line. Sometimes it takes longer, I insist, and sometimes it takes less time. We also have a Congress two weeks later and, of course, we want it to be a congress not to contemplate the problems of the PP. It will not be like that; it will be a congress that bets on policies of change, reforms, improvement, modernization, and that the Socialist Party continues to be the party that leads being at the same time and at the same time as Spanish society evolves.

J.R.Lucas.- Mr. President, I would like to return to the topic of the European Council that you are attending today, but first, following up on what you just said, there is not much informative movement, at least, around the Congress of the Socialist Party. Should that lead us to infer that there will not be major changes?

President.- The question of why there is no informational interest perhaps suggests to me that we are in a society where, normally, what generates conflict or disturbance is news. The Socialist Party holds a congress and has a debate with thousands of amendments, important issues for Spanish society. It is true that it is a united, solid party that has no internal problems. It has a leadership that is supported or that I believe will be supported, and therefore, that may be less newsworthy than when there is a party that has as many turbulences, let’s leave it at that expression, as the Popular Party has had.

But I can assure you that this does not depend on the political leaders.

J.R. Lucas.- So, there will not be any major news at the Congress.

President.- There will always be some.

J.R. Lucas.- For example? Something worth mentioning.

President.- Logically, there will be changes in the leadership, as it cannot be otherwise, because there are leaders who have taken on other tasks. I always try and will certainly try, as long as I am at the head of the Socialist Party, to ensure that new people, young people, take on important responsibilities in the party's work, because I believe it is good for any organization to always have new blood injected into the decision-making bodies. There will also be some modifications in the organizational sphere and, of course, it will be a congress of party ambition and national ambition.

Of party ambition because we are the PSOE, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, the Socialist Party with the most popular support in Europe, and because we want to be those who decisively contribute to shaping the ideas that social democracy should have in Europe and in the world at a time when a progressive response to problems is needed.

It is clear that the neoconservative response of deregulation has failed in the United States, and there is everything that has happened with subprime mortgages and a certain disaster of the financial system. Therefore, in the face of climate change, in the face of the food crisis, also a result of a policy in which some of the developments we had were not foreseen or planned, logically what is needed, in my opinion, in the international order is a progressive response. The cause of global problems is neoconservative policies and the responses must be social democratic, progressive policies.

J.R. Lucas.- Aren't you a bit alone in Europe in that battle, because you are the only socialist governing in the Union, apart from Gordon Brown, but they are English, socialists in the English way.

President.- There are a few more: Portugal, Austria...

J.R. Lucas.- But I mean with strength and the capacity to mobilize. We are facing decisions like, for example, what was approved yesterday regarding the Directive on the return of illegal immigrants or the 65 hours. They are conservative.

President.- I would distinguish. Certainly, the 65-hour work directive seems absolutely unacceptable to me. We have expressed our deep disagreement. I believe it is a setback and that it does not help competitiveness at all, as is said in that discourse. Sometimes, there is talk of wages and the need to have wage restraint in democratic societies, but if someone thinks we are going to compete in wages with some of the emerging countries in the world, which are producing a lot, we really know that is not the case. We have to compete by being more innovative, by having more quality in how we produce, by doing things better and by having an appropriate context. Certainly, that directive seems to me a setback.

The directive on migration is a directive that, curiously, despite what it seems, sets limits on some of the things that some countries were doing regarding returns, and that time limit they can stay is a limiting date, which seems to me...

J.R. Lucas.- It is a lot, President.

President.- Indeed. Just look at how much it is that we only have forty days. I mean, it is a time limit, it is not a time that obliges, but it limits.

We have forty days. It is true that sometimes it is a tight timeframe and, for that reason, the Minister of the Interior has at some point talked about possibly extending it to sixty days. But, as I have said many times, repatriation, returning an immigrant who has attempted or arrived illegally in a country, is not in the hands of what a directive says, nor in the hands of what our laws say, whatever they may be; it is in the capacity for political and diplomatic cooperation we have with the countries of origin, because it turns out that, to return an illegal immigrant to their country, their country has to accept them, and they do not accept them based on what your law says, they accept them based on their political will, and that political will depends on how you work in cooperation with them.

That is to say, maintaining the principle of legality in immigration, which we all subscribe to, means entering legally and returning those who enter illegally, requires a policy of aid for cooperation and development, and an understanding in immigration matters, as the Government of Spain does. I explained this to Berlusconi and he has made some adjustments and corrections. Berlusconi is not going to return more immigrants to the countries of origin from which they arrive illegally on boats to his islands because he makes tougher laws, no, apart from what it means for the principles of European values; he will return them if he has good agreements and good cooperation with the African countries from which those illegal immigrants come.

That said, Europe must maintain, and the Government of Spain will certainly do so, the principles of what Europe stands for. Immigrants who are in our country legally must have rights, and we must create policies for coexistence and policies for integration.

J.R. Lucas.- How do we manage the "no" from the Irish, President?

President.- Certainly, what cannot be is that Ireland, with all due democratic respect for those who express themselves in a referendum, can stop such a necessary project as advancing in European integration and that Europe has greater common political capacity.

We live in a certain paradox: the major problems that most concern citizens at this moment are economic, but alongside the economic issues, we have climate change, organized crime, and immigration, as major phenomena of our time, which affect all countries. They are phenomena, as is said in an expression that I sometimes do not like too much, transnational, they are global phenomena, which are beyond flags or borders.

Therefore, the most powerful response must come from the European Union, but at the same time, as that process of union of twenty-seven represents or can generate the perception in many citizens that it is a distant, little close, little intelligible process, there are reactions in the countries where we have the temptation to look only at ourselves and think that the problems come from Brussels. It is not true. The most effective responses will come from a more powerful, more integrated European Union, with more political union and more capacity for effectiveness, so that Europe counts in the world, so that, for example, in the face of energy and energy problems, it can dialogue with one voice with Russia or with the countries that supply oil and gas, and so that, in the face of climate change and what, in my opinion, should be an acceleration of renewable energies throughout Europe, it gives the strength necessary to face all problems.

We live in that certain paradox, but Ireland will not stop Europe nor will it stop the process of confirmation and integration of the European Union. We will have to listen to Ireland today, but we must have the response prepared so that we can move forward. There has been good news: that Great Britain ratified the Treaty yesterday, and therefore, we will continue. Certainly, that will be the position of the Government of Spain, I understand that it is the majority position of European governments, and the institutions must have a response so that Ireland is the one with the doubt and the problem, and not the European Union.

Marc Sala.- Around what you are saying, but what is the response that must be given to Ireland? That is to say, what solution must be provided? A Europe with two speeds in the institutional sphere, for example, as in the euro, which has not worked badly and is incorporating each country as it can, is a good option?

President.- There are various possibilities. It has just happened and we must first know what the Irish government has in mind, which today, surely, will be said in the meeting of the Twenty-Seven, and what they have thought from a legal-political point of view, because we have here a legal terrain that has some complexity, the European Commission.

What I am convinced of is that the majority of European governments will be in the position to move forward through the mechanisms that can be articulated legally and politically and, of course, not to stop a Treaty, like the one in Lisbon, that we need. Why? So that things like this do not happen, that is to say, that a single country can stop Europe, because the rule of unanimity, not in a Treaty, which can be understandable because it is nothing more and nothing less than changing all the legal rules, but in decisions of another nature, less transcendent, of day-to-day, of responding to problems, must be required and not the rule of the majority. This is the essence, a bit, of what we are debating.

Certainly, in the face of regions like the United States of America or countries like China, emerging, if Europe does not ride in the same direction, does not work from a union, each of us will do what we can, but we will have much less strength in a world like the one we live in. Globalization has great advantages, but it also causes effects that we must know how to address, among others, the broader governance than that of classic nation-states.

M. Sala.- On immigration, President. The Government is facing, it seems, a reform of the Immigration Law, which will restrict what is the concept of family reunification and it seems that it also wants to facilitate the return home of immigrants who have come to our country. Are there too many immigrants in Spain at the moment that we need to restrict their arrival and facilitate...?

President.- We must make an immigration policy linked to an idea that has been the axis of our policy, which is linked to the labor market. Immigration equals work. If there is a need for workers in Spain, logically we need immigrant people to come, and they must come legally, they must have their rights, and no one can be working fraudulently here. That is why we made a normalization, because there was a need for work and because many immigrants were working fraudulently and being exploited by certain sectors.

Now it is evident that we have a lower demand for employment. It is logical, because this always works like this, that there is less pressure from immigrants towards Spain, because there is less job creation, and it is also logical that there is a greater possibility of immigrant people in our country who, in the face of not having employment, may think about returning to their country. What do we do? Logically, accumulate the rights they have and give them a support opportunity so they can return. Accumulate unemployment rights all at once so they can return, have a sum of money and with other microcredit policies.

How many will there be? No one knows. I have seen that there are figures of those who will take advantage of it. It is true that there are many immigrant people who may think that, even though they are now in a situation of unemployment, receiving unemployment benefits, they may have a job again tomorrow and prefer that to not returning to their country with economic aid; but the best thing is that we put it into action and that the number, whatever it may be, the thousands of immigrant workers who want to return to their country, which will be very different, will depend on how the country is, can do so.

Immigration must be linked to work; immigration policy must always be linked to the labor market. From that perspective is where immigration policies are correctly addressed. And for the management of legality, to cooperation with the countries of origin and to aid to those countries, because everyone understands that if we have a situation of increasing misery, more poverty, on the African continent, migratory pressure will increase. We can reinforce the borders, we can put thousands of police, we can make the laws tougher, fine; but everyone knows that when the need is so great and affects so many people, the pressure will continue.

That is why the other day I stated in my speech on foreign policy that Africa was one of Spain's great objectives. We have already started in the last four years to be present in Africa with a diplomatic policy of aid for cooperation and now we are going to intensify it because, while there are twenty thousand people a day, that could be a headline that the media could put every day who die from extreme misery, we will have serious problems of migratory movements. Logically, the developed world cannot remain looking the other way in the face of this harsh reality.

J.R. Lucas.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, ETA is still there, but it has come off the political agenda. What a relief, right?

President.- No. The only relief will truly be the day ETA disappears. But it is good, from a political standpoint, and it is indeed positive that the fight against terrorism, against ETA, unites democrats and does not separate them, because it is a long struggle of all democracy and all democrats. Certainly, in that sense, the Legislature has started in a much calmer atmosphere. There is, let’s say, a reasonable understanding, not formalized, not culminating in any protocol act, among the different political forces and between the Government and the main opposition party. That is, in my opinion, the right way to work.

Lucía Yeste.- President, one very specific thing and, moreover, in line with what you were saying: when will that meeting you are going to have with the leader of the opposition, Mariano Rajoy, take place?

President.- I would say that I am ready to have it on the day Mariano Rajoy deems appropriate. It has to be a mutually agreed date, that is logical. I understand that he has had the Congress process and that he has the Congress. When he sees that it is the right moment. The issues we have ahead are important, which is to try to reach an agreement on the renewal of institutional bodies, justice, the Constitutional Court, anti-terrorism policy, the Spanish Presidency of the European Union. I hope we have it as soon as possible. Certainly, it seems to me that he has said before the summer, he said it here.

J.R. Lucas.- He said it yesterday here, yes.

L. Yeste.- There is little time left. It will also depend a bit on you, on your schedule.

President.- I know that journalism always moves very quickly, but there is still more than a month left, because we have all of July and part of June still. Forty days in politics and in work activity are quite a lot. So, we can have it, I hope we have it, and, moreover, I hope and trust that it will be in a fairly favorable atmosphere.

J.R. Lucas.- President, I would also like to introduce some of the issues that have come to us through our email or the website of Radiotelevisión Española. Guillermo, from Argentina: "I wanted to ask you if the slowdown in the economy will negatively influence the ability of the grandchildren of Spaniards and immigrants to obtain nationality. Half a million descendants are counting on you."

President.- No, there is no problem. We are simply in the process of regulatory development to comply with what the Law says in this regard and with the provision, because we need to significantly increase the resources of the consular offices. Logically, there will be no delay in this regard.

J.R. Lucas.- "Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, Daniel tells us, I live in the United States because I could not stand the unemployment or the 'garbage contracts', which was all that was offered to me in Spain. When will we have more opportunities as Spanish nationals in our own country?"

President.- We had a social agreement process in the last Legislature, a labor market reform, which has generated a million transformations of stable jobs. The percentage, the rate, of temporality is decreasing in Spain and, without a doubt, we have some characteristics as a country that make our rate of temporality somewhat higher, for example, tourism; we are the second country in the world as tourism recipients and that is a factor that is there.

But it is true that we have a part of the labor market, especially of younger people, of people with degrees, who have contracts that have come to be called precarious or temporary, which need to be strengthened towards stability. We can only do that by increasing our productivity and our capacity to compete, and that is done by innovating, by having more technology in the country and with greater training of people in educational capital.

The evolution must be in that direction, because I am convinced that entrepreneurs, moreover, know and believe that it is better to have the largest possible number of stable workers, at least in many sectors.

J.R. Lucas.- President, I would like to know your opinion, if it is possible to dissociate as President of the Government and as a socialist, from what we are experiencing in Estepona these days.

President.- The opinion is quite logical and it is that the Law and Justice must combat any irregular conduct and any undesirable practice from public management. Logically, that is how it is done in this country, in all areas. It does not matter whether it is a City Council, whatever its political color, or any other Administration or in the private sector.

Let’s say that the response that must exist is a response of support for the work that, in this case, or that has been done by the Police, for the investigation that has been carried out, and, in its case, for Justice.

J.R. Lucas.- I go further. I read you the headline from "El País," which you surely know: "the corrupt plot of Estepona was giving money from a slush fund to the PSOE."

President.- I can say that, as President of the Government, I do not know, logically, the instruction or what the police investigation may have been. In any case, all responsibilities that may arise will be clarified. Just yesterday, the Socialist Party of Andalusia already made some decisions in this regard.

I insist, I can and must affirm that even less so in the ranks of a socialist, of someone who wants to represent the Socialist Party, is any irregular behavior. It is radically and absolutely incompatible with what our project represents in understanding the management of the public and, therefore, I believe that what corresponds is to give maximum support to Justice and the Police in that task.

J.R. Lucas.- And the question of the day, President: what do you think will happen on Sunday against Italy and if that will pose any further problems with Berlusconi?

President.- We need to break the curse that seems to accompany the Spanish national football team. We have great football and, when we have competition at the national level, there is always a problem. Notice how important it is: my opinion is that it is about confidence in ourselves. That is, the country, after many disappointments, always has that question and it seems as if the question is projected onto our eleven players, because there have been many occasions when we could and we have not succeeded.

Let’s put confidence and security. Today the Spanish national team is better than the Italian national team and we must win. Moreover, I believe we will win 3-2.

J.R. Lucas.- 3-2? I was going to ask you, because Rajoy pointed to 2-1. There is no consensus. You too, but by a difference of one more goal each.

President.- Rajoy seems to know quite a bit about sports, it seems - it seems, huh! So, it can be his opinion quite reasonable.

J.R. Lucas.- We note the President of the Government's 3-2.

José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, President of the Government, I insist on what I said at the beginning: thank you for being here tomorrow with us, with the listeners of Radio Nacional de España, in the public radio, which is naturally yours, as it is for all Spaniards. Have a happy day and a happy Government, representing the majority of Spaniards who voted for you.

President.- Thank you very much to you and greetings to all the listeners of Radio Nacional.

J.R. Lucas.- Until always, President.

President.- Thank you very much.