Press conference on the results of the European Council

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

19 June 2008

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference on June 19, 2008, reviewing outcomes of the European Council meeting, focusing on Ireland's Lisbon Treaty referendum and rising energy and food prices.
Main themes
Treaty of Lisbon and Ireland's referendum, EU ratification process, oil and food price increases, European Council meeting results, fishing sector subsidies, EU enlargement and integration, immigration and Balkans, Millennium Development Goals, condolences for Spanish soldiers killed in Bosnia
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,204
92nd percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
1.93
4th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

193 sentences in 82 paragraphs

President .- Thank you for attending this press conference, during which I will review the results of the meeting of the European Council. I would like to start by expressing my condolences to the families of the two Spanish soldiers, the two pilots of our Air Force who died yesterday in an accident in Banja Luka, in Bosnia Herzegovina. Two soldiers, two compatriots who were there to guarantee peace and safety, who were taking part in a great mission in which Europe has worked and will keep working hard.

Now then, the European Council has held an intense meeting. It has been an intense meeting because we had to deal with an important issue, namely Ireland's referendum, the expectations after Ireland's "no" vote with regards to the Treaty of Lisbon and some other social, economic matters, namely, the rise of the Price of oil and food, the analysis carried out by the European Union and the Commission about these matters and the strategy that should be followed.

We have also dealt with other subjects, of course, as usual during the meetings of the European Council; subjects concerning immigration, the Balkans and some other issues, such as the observance of the Millennium Objectives and aid for development; but I will focus on Ireland in order to make this press conference as brief as possible, on Ireland, on the Treaty of Lisbon and on the prices of fuel and food.

In the first place, with regards to Ireland and to the results of the referendum, we listened to Ireland's Prime Minister, Brian Cowen, who has explained, on the one hand, the reasons behind the "no" vote, his opinion about such reasons and the need to understand the scope of the "no" vote and Ireland's need to set up a dialogue with the European institutions and keep working and consolidating a situation that otherwise might become a blind alley in the future.

I think that the different Prime Ministers and Presidents of the Republic, the different Heads of State have understood this. We have focused on a main idea: we want Europe to move forward, we want to enforce the Treaty and we want Ireland to be with us. We want Ireland and we do not want Ireland to remain outside the process. This is our main aim for the next few months.

The European Union has already gone through similar situations, even more complex situations on some occasions, and, therefore, we must be confident in the methods, ideas and initiatives that will be implemented slowly but surely once the Treaty of Lisbon comes into force and always following the existing agenda and the most important landmarks of the European Union, specially over the next year.

Besides, almost all the Prime Ministers and Heads of the Government have expressed a firm willingness to go ahead with the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon in our respective countries. Eighteen countries have almost ratified it at the Parliament. As you know, in Spain the Bill Draft on the Treaty of Lisbon has already been sent to the Parliament and, in fact, we will ratify it as soon as possible.

Next 15 of October will be essential and it will be the date in which we will deal with this issue in order to set up a procedure to meet the objectives I have just mentioned: the Treaty of Lisbon with Ireland, in order to move on towards the union and the integration of the European Union, which is absolutely necessary for a better, more efficient operation of the EU.

The second matter we have dealt with has been the evolution of oil, gas and food prices. In our Conclusions we have made an in-depth assessment and we have proposed a set of short term, medium term and long term policies and initiatives.

Firstly, the European Council is concerned about the dramatic, fast increase of the prices of oil and food over the last few months.

Secondly, it is necessary to implement different work strategies: supporting the production sectors that have suffered the most serious, direct consequences of the increase of the price of oil. In this regard, Spain, together with other countries, has supported the work carried out by the Commission in order to set up new subsidies and new margins of manoeuvre for the fishing sector. A new plan will be created in this regard and it will be announced next Monday. This is good news, of course, and Spain is working together with other countries so that this idea developed with the support of the Commission is backed by the Council.

Finally, we also had to deal with the reasons for this dramatic increase of the Price of oil. Thus, we dealt with speculation, with the situation that brought about such increase and with the different reactions to face this phenomenon. Therefore, this is why in our opinion the meeting that will soon be held in Saudi Arabia is something positive; during that meeting producer and consumer countries will deal with this strong increase of the Price of oil.

Following Spain's proposal, the President of the Commission will summon a meeting with the biggest international oil companies, with the main ones, in order to talk about the causes and to think of different initiatives to face it.

The Commission will make more efforts to guarantee transparency in oil markets, to put forward a report including different new measures, if necessary, next October; and we hope to progress in this matter for it is surely a paramount issue as far as our economies are concerned and also for all European citizens, specially Spanish citizens.

Besides, the European Union has ratified different principles concerning energy consumption, principles we have been working on lately. We must save energy, we must be more efficient as far as energy consumption is concerned, we must speed up the different measures to support families and industry, to support alternative energy and renewable energies and to get progressively detached from the energy obtained from oil, from that energy that is directly dependent on oil by-products, namely, oil and gas. I say this because certain countries have insisted on the fact that we should talk about gas too when we talk about oil.

As to the Price of food, there is surely a relationship between the crisis of the "subprime" mortgages and the rise of the Price of oil and food; there has been a considerable change in financial investments, which has contributed to or reinforced this rise of the price of food.

As you know, the Commission has written a report in this regard, giving a first, relevant step, dealing with the causes putting forward solutions; some of these solutions are intended for those countries that suffer the most serious consequences of the increase of the price of food, for those countries where people face a growing risk of suffering the consequences of extreme poverty and starvation. Thus, we have two clear messages, two clear policies: the first one is the creation of a special fund to support agricultural production in developing countries and the second one is the mandate included in the Conclusions of the Council whereby EU countries must meet their compromises as far as the Millennium Objectives are concerned.

The latter makes me feel specially satisfied, as you may understand, because Spain has doubtlessly been one of the EU countries whose aid for development has increased more over the last few years, 0.5 of our Gross Domestic Product, and we are satisfied about the fact that the European Council has firmly urged EU countries to increase their contributions to aid for cooperation for development.

As you also know, that report issued by the Commission is directly related to the upcoming reform of the EU Common Agricultural Policy, to the revision of the reform concerning the EU common agricultural policy and to other different measures, such as the increase of milk production and the elimination of custom charges so as to favour agricultural production. We should say that, to a great extent, this dramatic increase of food prices in the EU and all over the world should make us turn to agriculture, after a period, after a few decades, I should say, during which the different policies were exclusively aimed to reduce the agricultural activities, the production areas, and to provide aids for farmers. But we are doubtlessly facing a cycle change in this sense, a clear, necessary, urgent change. Certain countries, developing countries in Africa need this change urgently, dramatically, for them it is a vital change; but in the case of Europe, this need is clearly present too. And the Commission is surely taking the right steps.

P .- President, you have mentioned a plan for fishing that will be presented next Monday. I don't quite understand whether it will be put forward by Spain before the Commission or whether it will be directly established by the Commission; for over the last two days, the Commission has just mentioned a set of aids to promote a restructuration and to reduce and break up the fleet.

This is my first question. The second one is: the President of the Czech Republic says that he wouldn't give thirty crowns, that is, four Euros, for the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon in the Czech Republic. How much would you bet for the implementation of the Treaty of Lisbon?

President .- This is a serious matter and betting should be out of the question. I have heard the Czech Prime Minister talk about the circumstances his country is going through, as far as internal policy is concerned, and he has expressed his willingness, his willingness to implement the Treaty.

The plan will support fishing and make it possible for countries to set up flexible aids for this sector in order to face the situation we are going through. Of course, it might and it will include restructuring measures. As I have said, it will be announced next Monday, but let me tell you that this matter has been largely discussed, that is, many countries did not agree to it. Therefore, it is certainly a support plan, of course, and we have defended it rather intensely.

My opinion, for I won't make bets, is that Europe needs the Treaty, citizens need a Treaty that will make Europe work better. When the policies implemented by these institutions are more European, citizens will accept them more willingly. Thus, I am confident in the implementation of the Treaty of Lisbon as it is.

P .- President, yesterday, the Minister of Foreign Affairs explained the agreements concerning Cuba and he said that in one year's time Cuba's reaction will be assessed and we shall see whether or not it has been positive; yet, I would like to know whether Spain, the main defender of the withdrawal of sanctions, would also be the main defender of new sanctioning measures should Cuba's reaction be regarded as negative.

Besides, I would like to know your opinion about the threat of the President of Venezuela, Hugo Chavez, to cancel the oil provision to those EU countries that enforce the immigration agreements in the future.

President .- As to the second question, I am not acquainted with those words by President Chavez. His words must always be taken with prudence. Perhaps we should explain the President of Venezuela the meaning of that Directive. It is true that this Directive has been interpreted in different ways and, on occasions, we have even heard opinions that are not really related to the contents of the Directive or to our reality. But you can be sure that we will explain this to President Chavez so as to avoid such reactions. In fact, the Minister of Foreign Affairs will talk to him soon. He will do, if necessary, for they have held a meeting in Caracas, so that the relationships between Europe and Latin American countries may keep being positive.

There certainly has been a change in our relationship with Cuba. We have withdrawn certain political measures that were practically impairing that relationship; and, now, the European Union, following the advice of Spain and other countries, has decided to do so. Of course, Spain has an interest in Latin America and in withdrawing such measures in order to set up a dialogue and, mainly, in order to work for the future of Cuba, a better future, a future backed by Cubans, that's our wish.

We have just implemented this measure, therefore, let's not think of what will come up in one year's time. For the position of Spain with regards to Cuba is clear and, today, our position is shared by the rest of the European Union. We want to set up dialogue in order to improve Cuba's conditions, the living conditions of Cubans; we want to set up a dialogue so that Cuba may enter the democratic arena and form part of the dialogue among these two regions, the European Union and Latin America. And I think that we have taken positive steps, and I think that our diplomats have done a positive job and we hope that Cuba will take positive steps too.

P .- President, I would like to know, on the one hand, what is Spain's position with regards to the support attained by the President of France, Nicolas Sarkozy, with regards to his proposal to reduce the V.A.T. charges on fuel. It seems that next October he will have to justify his stance somehow.

And, if I may, today's news in Spain is the Congress of the People's Party, which is about to start. I would like to know your opinion about the team of Mariano Rajoy, the so-called "dream team". What do you think about that?

President .- Those were Soraya's words.

P .- Those were Soraya's words, the spokesman of the PP at the Congress. What do you think about that?

President .- -So far… I think that in politics such things end up showing up in time, not after the first day, right? We must consider the evolution and….

As to the Congress of the PP, I am not going to say anything, because they are choosing their team. When their ideas become known, we will talk about debates and proposals, which is in my opinion what citizens want to know about. As to people, who comes in, who leaves or… I think that such things are rather unimportant as far as politics is concerned, they are unimportant as far as the reasonable, political dialogue between the Government and the opposition is concerned.

I just hope we will be able to reach agreements during this Legislature.

As to the second question, it was Spain that suggested the Commission's revision of the different measures in case this situation concerning the price of oil may continue, a suggestion included in that extensively debated paragraph, in that report that must be put forward next October. And, of course, it will contemplate all the different measures, including fiscal measures.

As you know, there is a principle shared by almost all economists about the scarce efficiency of fiscal measures concerning the Price of oil, because consumption does not decrease and on many occasions, the consequences can be more beneficial for companies and distributors. That is the norm and that is something that everyone usually agrees on. Of course, the Commission might come to a different conclusion.

In my opinion, we should give a European answer. In my opinion, the most important thing is that the Commission has put forward well-defined proposals regarding the increase of the prices of oil and food; and some of them consist in aids for specific sectors or specific countries that are suffering the more serious consequences of the increase of the prices of food; and also proposals for political actions in the international arena as far as transparency, speculation, dialogue and oil companies are concerned.

In will support the Commission's report, of course. Now then, I think that we should avoid dogmatism and we should consider all the different measures according to the evolution of the price of oil. In fact, I think that public tasks must avoid dogmatism, particularly when dealing with economic matters.

P .- President, as to the V.A.T. question, it is surprising to see that each time Mr. Sarkozy has a problem with Ms. Merkel, he attends a press conference and mentions your support; for this is what he has done on this occasion too. I would like to know whether you think that this V.A.T. discount on oil could be applied in Spain too.

Although it is not related to this, I would like to know whether, in your opinion, the new relationship with Russia could help to solve the question of oil and gas somehow.

And something else, Mr. Camps said this morning in Cadena SER that your Government would not last until 2012. Would you like to say anything about the doubts of the PP in this regard?

President .- The thing is that the explanation should be provided by Mr. Camps, he should explain what did he meant and the political reasons to make such statements.

Politics follows certain principles, namely, institutional seriousness and respect and respect for citizens. We have just held an election, last 9 of March, in fact, and the investiture took place a few weeks ago, according to the Constitution. The thing is not… The Government has not even been working for one hundred days. We know that certain people cannot even wait four days; but, well, citizens and the political procedures should be respected, regardless of one's desires to win, which are logical, and regardless of the fact that some people are sometimes slow in the uptake when it comes to understanding that things take time and that the decision made at the election defines the course of history.

As to the V.A.T. I have just mentioned it. The measure by itself cannot bring about the effects we seek for, namely, make up for the current situation, but, I insist, we should not be close-minded or dogmatic in any way. I think that we must pay attention to circumstances. One of the tasks of politicians is foreseeing the different hypotheses for the future and, of course, reach a common agreement. And I am confident on the Commission because I think that if we are Europeists and we wish to have a strong European Government, we must trust the Commission.

Surely enough, the dialogue and the relationships with Russia are essential, constitutive, absolutely necessary in order to face the problems derived from the rise of the price of oil and energy and some other problems that are taking place at an international level and at a European level. Spain is surely confident on this and it has always defended one hypothesis as a member of the European Union: good relationships with Russia will enable us to do many positive things; without such positive relationships, we wouldn't be able to do many other things.

P .- President, I would like to ask you whether you share the opinion of the Minister of Industry, who considers that the current ceiling for the price of oil is set in one hundred dollars and outside that, we are talking about speculation.

Then, and this is an opinion, considering that the different mechanisms to set up prices in the oil market are rather well-known, do you think that it would be adequate to face the current situation by writing up a report?

President .- The thing is that what you have said, the mechanisms to set the prices in the oil market are not so well-known, and millions of citizens are wondering about that, millions and millions of citizens all over the world, because so far there are no guaranteed theories to ascertain the reasons why the price of a product -the oil barrel - may increase by thirty dollars in just one month, when no extraordinary circumstances have taken place. There are many theories though: the expected demand increase, the change of target in the case of investors after the "subprime" crisis and speculation, a process that is partly derived from this.

Different measures have been implemented and I have just mentioned the plan to support fishing and the intensification of the subsidies to promote the use of renewable energies in families and industries; and we have implemented initiatives, some of them rather new, in fact, and thus the President of the European Commission has summoned a meeting with the main oil companies in the world in order to face the situation and establish its scope and set forth new initiatives.

In fact, the Commission must keep implementing initiatives and evaluating the situation. This will surely yield good results. The good thing about the European Union is that it is the only region that allows the implementation of joint decisions, because all countries are worried about this, except for producer countries, for this has produced the same negative effects upon their economies and, what's more, upon their citizens.

Of course we are reacting and implementing initiatives, within the limits of a globalised world and a market system.

P .- In the first place, I would like to go back to the question of aids. You have mentioned the fishing sector and you have talked about more flexible aids at the national level. I take it that this won't have anything to do with the plan put forward by the European Union, I take it that the Government will also put forward a plan contemplating aids. I would like to know whether this would only benefit the fishing sector or whether it would also benefit other sectors that are also suffering the consequences of the increase of the price of fuel.

In this sense, ex President Felipe Gonzalez put forward several proposals during a congress a few days ago. In fact, he talked about the possibility to use the Government's surplus generated by the increase of the price of fuel to help those sectors that are suffering the most serious consequences of such increase; and he also talked about the possibility to stop speculation in the case of food by purchasing crops by a minimum percentage of their real worth in the future.

I would like to go back to the PP's "dream team", because it is surely too soon to say it, but I think that, say, the presence of women in high positions, among youngsters and politicians, is no longer an exclusive feature of the Socialist Party, for the People's Party seems to have accepted it too.

President .- Yes, it is true, Rajoy and Arenas are starting to get acquainted with politics, aren't they? But, anyway, I think that it is a good thing for those who have been in the background to come up to the foreground. That is a good thing.

This comes to prove that our political ideas are right: that renovation is a good thing, that it is a good thing to have more women in politics… We have been for a few years in this and we can say… I don't think that Javier Arenas can say the same. I know him, I know him but I don't think that…

P .- Yet, it seems to be clear that regardless of the result of Ireland's referendum, everyone admits that the enforcement of the Treaty of Lisbon will be delayed as compared to the initial agenda. This means that, the election to the European Parliament will probably be held before the Treaty of Lisbon comes into force and this will mean that Spain will lose four seats at the European Parliament. What do you think about this?

President .- It is you who are establishing such hypothesis, but we are going to work so that the Treaty of Lisbon may be implemented before the election to the European Parliament. Besides, I think that this is what most of us want.

As to the other questions, the Government has already set up a plan to help the transportation sector, a plan based upon dialogue. We were talking for weeks, from the beginning of April, because this sector has clearly suffered the consequences of the increase of the price of oil; we have set up this plan and we have made the proposal, we have set up a dialogue with the fishing sector; the Commission, like I said, is going to announce a new support plan next Monday and, of course, the Government will always be prone to set up measures to benefit and support those production sectors that have suffered the most serious consequences of the increase of the price of oil.

As to those proposals concerning the guarantees of future crops, or even in other areas, this issue has been widely discussed by the Council. Yesterday, in fact, during the meeting of the European Council, several Prime Ministers mentioned these ideas and, of course, this is one of the initiatives that the Commission is taking into account and, should it deem it fit, particular measures would be implemented.

As to the fund, this idea could be interesting if the context is favourable, that is, provided that the revenues increase, because things are not necessarily so. Although the price of oil is increasing, such increase usually provokes a decrease of consumption and this doesn't necessarily provoke an increase of the State revenues. I just want to make this clear.

P .- One question about immigration. With regards to the Presidency of France, I would like to know whether we have come to an agreement with the French Government with regards to the Immigration Pact, and, more specifically, with regards to the integration contract.

President .- Yes, we have come to an agreement. We have set up a context for the Decisions of the Council, which I haven't mentioned to make things short and, of course, I am convinced that we will reach an agreement about the so-called Immigration Pact during the French Presidency and it will contemplate the main aspects that each one defends. Among these aspects, we defend the irrelevance of the immigration contract.

P .- I have two questions about Cuba. I would like to know what you would say to the members of the Cuban opposition who complained about the withdrawal of sanctions to Cuba, because they consider that we are sending a wrong message to Castro's regime, for they think that the changes that have taken place there over the last few months are merely superficial changes.

Then, given that Spain has always led the common opposition to the Cuban regime, I would like to know whether you will visit Cuba the next few months.

President .- The thing is that I have not thought of that possibility.

As to the first question, I support the general principle beyond particular opinions. Spain has a certain responsibility with regards to Cuba and to the future of Cuba and Cubans; and it is going to act accordingly.

We will act accordingly from the European Union and we want the whole European Union to act accordingly too, we want to get the political support of the European Union, for politics is dialogue. That's the policy we should follow, a policy of dialogue.

If we have witnessed certain symptoms, which we have -I won't comment on their scope, but we have witnessed certain symptoms, certain signs - over the last few months, I think that we must benefit from this dialogue and intensify it. That is what Cubans need and that is what those who are working in favour of certain postulates in that country need. That is what we think and that is the right position, in my opinion; as to the other opinions, time has already proved that they are not really successful.

P .- I would like to ask a couple of questions. Firstly, have you already talked about the so-called "Robin Hood tax" put forward by Tremonti? And, as we are talking about Italy, Spain hasn't beaten Italy off for the last 88 years and we will be playing the quarter-final match next Sunday. You said that Spain would win 3-2 and I would like to know whether you have also talked about this with Berlusconi.

President .- Yes, but I won't talk about this here. In fact, at some point, the UEFA Euro 2008 has been dealt with on different occasions at the European Council. We can say that, in general, I have been congratulated by different Prime Ministers on the performance of the Spanish football team. And yesterday at the European Council, during dinner, Merkel and Socrates were sitting together while Germany and Portugal were playing the football match. These is the interesting side of the European Union, this is what enriches us.

P .- Is Spain going to win?

President .- I think that we have more chances than ever. Of course, Italy is a dangerous rival. They have won many tournaments, they are world champions and they know how to play and make the most out of the last moment. But Spain has a good team, an exceptional centre and a great defender. I think that this match is going to be amazing: 3-2 for Spain.

As to the first question, yes, this has been talked over. At least two or three Prime Ministers have talked about this possibility, a special tax for producers in order to make up for the increase of prices and, of course, this is one of the issues the Commission must take into account and evaluate. This is what it is for, in fact.

I insist, yesterday we held one of the more intense debates, one of the longest ones in a European Council, concerning a particular subject, namely, the increase of the price of oil, and different possibilities, initiatives and proposals were put forward and they will now be analysed by the Commission, apart from the ones it has already adopted.

P .- According to Spain, would this be more positive than the V.A.T. reduction?

President .- The thing is that it is difficult to consider the efficiency of a particular measure to make up for this situation. The measure regarding this tax consist, of course, in using the existing resources in order to help those sectors that are suffering the most serious consequences.

In fact, the most efficient measure, considering the rules of offer and demand, would be the reduction of the demand, because the reduction of demand is the best way to exert pressure upon the offer. This is true for all economic levels and for all types of goods, oil in this case.

Thus, we must focus on… Apart from the question of climatic change and renewable and alternative energies, this can also be viewed from the point of view of public transportation and the serious, efficient reduction of oil consumption. If the EU -which consumes almost 18 per cent of the world's oil- was able to reduce consumption, producer countries would surely take this into account and consider the market prices in the oil market.

Thank you very much.