Interview with the President of the Government on Antena-3

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 February 2009

Context
Zapatero gave a TV interview on Antena-3 on February 22, 2009, explaining the resignation of Justice Minister Mariano Bermejo amid controversy.
Main themes
Ministerial resignation, Minister of Justice replacement, political accountability, hunting license controversy, Mariano Bermejo, cabinet decisions, government integrity, opposition criticism, administration of justice reform
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,215
92nd percentile
Sentences
224
91st percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
11.3
37th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

224 sentences in 89 paragraphs

President, good evening. Thank you very much for joining us on this day that is supposed to be complicated.

President.- Thank you very much for being here, for inviting me to this interview. The day? Yes, I had to proceed with the replacement of the Minister of Justice, decide on the new Minister of Justice, and that always requires a time of conversation and dialogue with both individuals.

G. Lomana.- I will ask you, therefore: Has the Minister of Justice resigned or have you dismissed him?

President.- He has resigned. He has put his position at my disposal. Whenever there was any controversy surrounding him or when the opposition attacked Mariano Bermejo harshly, he would say to me: "You know, President, that my position is always at your disposal." On Thursday he reiterated this to me, and on Friday, and I told him we would talk later. Today he told me again that he understood that at this moment he was not in a position to resolve the problems that Justice has, due to the situation that has been ongoing for some time, and that he had taken that position to solve problems, not to be a problem, nor to be a problem for the socialist project.

This attitude is exemplary. I believe that the attitude and what Mariano Bermejo has done today is an example of how political responsibilities are assumed and how one can come to a position and leave without seeing, as we have seen so many times, people clinging on, even in much more difficult circumstances.

Therefore, I want to publicly thank him for the work he has done, the attempts he has made to improve Justice, and for deciding to leave this responsibility, because he understood that he could be more of a problem than a contribution at this moment.

G. Lomana.- You spoke this morning, in fact. What reasons did the Minister give you? Did he resign because of the hunting without a license, because of the "free for all" in Quintos de Mora, or because of his meetings with Judge Garzón and the head of the Judicial Police?

President.- We must be measured. He resigned for a reason that is decisive: he considers that, to face the challenges that the Administration of Justice has at this moment in improving public service and addressing the situation with the judges, given what has occurred and the strong criticism he was receiving, he was not the right person and that another person, a new energy, should take charge of the Ministry of Justice. I think that is absolutely reasonable, understandable, and, I insist, commendable. It deserves applause to have that attitude, because we all have the natural tendency to defend a minister from your Government, the Socialist Group, and the Socialist Party, and for him to make that decision to say "I do not want this to be detrimental"...

G. Lomana.- But I ask you and please answer me, if you will, with a "yes" or a "no" because what I am going to ask is very brief. Do you think a minister who hunts without a license should remain in the Government?

President.- I believe that a minister must have everything in order. The truth is that we are not facing a fact that has excessive gravity, but all the rules that can and should be followed must be complied with.

He has explained that it was, as is known, a situation of pure forgetfulness. We know that we have a situation in Spain where each Autonomous Community requires a hunting license and he did not have one from Andalusia. It is a fact, a circumstance, that makes him feel the responsibility to resign to avoid creating more problems for the Government. And I support him and value that decision very positively.

G. Lomana.- If he had not resigned, when would you have asked for his dismissal?

President.- It is a hypothesis that cannot be predicted or ventured.

G. Lomana.- In any case, you did not ask him to resign.

President.- My experience is that all ministers, all of them, ministers and ministerial women, logically have a disposition and, as soon as there is some circumstance of excessive criticism, which is the subject of controversy—I will not give examples, because I could give examples of ministers and ministerial women that have been in my time, the first thing they tell you, at least in my case and I do not know if with other Presidents, is: "President, I do not want to create a problem for you if you consider that… you know that my position is permanently at your disposal."

It is never necessary, but in this case the initiative has been his. I appreciate it and value it, because I understand that if one considers that in a circumstance they are not in the best conditions of spirit or strength to take on all the challenges that the Administration of Justice has at this moment and improve it, and the citizens know that there are many, it must be understood and supported.

G. Lomana.- So, I understood you correctly: you would not have dismissed him.

President.- It was not my intention.

G. Lomana.- Perhaps because we are in an election campaign?

President.- No. When you have the responsibility of government, you cannot think about an election campaign or another, because in this country we have election campaigns almost every year. Now it is the Basque Country and Galicia; then we have the European elections; then the municipal elections will come, then the general elections… No, in the responsibility of government, in the task of government, you cannot be thinking about an electoral calculation. When there is a minister who reasons very sensibly that he considers he should leave that position to another, you have to listen to him and attend to him, and, in this case, we share that reflection.

G. Lomana.- The resignation, President, occurred on the day when two prominent, two relevant, members of the Socialist Party, Patxi López and José Bono, expressed criticism against the Minister Bermejo's hunting activities. Did this clamor have to arise within the ranks of the Socialist Party for this decision to finally be reached?

President.- The truth is that the Socialist Party always has a backing and support, which in my case has been very notable, for the President of the Government in his decisions; but people express their opinions freely and I know this morning we discussed it, Minister Mariano Bermejo and I, that the hunting or certain hunting activities in particular do not sit well with the sensitivity of a part of the citizens; other people love hunting, and that is also very respectable.

But we discussed it and it is normal for there to be voices in that direction, although I believe that everyone can admit that we are not facing any behavior that deserves social reproach like some of the other behaviors that unfortunately are seen at some point in public life. It can be understandable as something that is not liked or debatable. Many people have hobbies that are debatable, but not to produce a reproach and an exaggeration as we have seen and heard at some point.

G. Lomana.- Why did you not take the opportunity, President, to make a broader reshuffle with Bermejo's departure?

President.- Because it was not my intention. My intention was to respond to a situation that the minister himself had raised to me and therefore I have no idea in mind to make a government change. At this moment the Government, especially all the ministers in the economic area, is working focused on an ambitious, demanding plan that requires a great task and great dedication, to respond to the serious economic crisis. Logically, that is my priority: that they work and that they are fully dedicated.

G. Lomana.- Well, the head of that economic area has just said, as we saw in the news, that he feels envious of Bermejo because he is no longer in the Government. With this minister, are we going to get out of the crisis, Mr. President?

President.- I had not seen it. I have seen it now and I think it is very clear that they ask him, "Are you envious of the Minister of Justice?" He says yes, and anyone who knows Pedro Solbes, who although he may not seem like it, because he seems more like a serious person, a very serious person, I would say… But for those of us who know him very closely, Pedro Solbes has a sharp irony and it is evident that he made a joke.

I can tell you that I am with him day by day and that yesterday we left Madrid at seven in the morning to go to Berlin, we returned at eight in the evening, and he is engaged day by day with the seriousness of a person with his background in the service of the general interest. He has more than thirty years in different Governments. He was already Director General in the UCD Government, then he was in Felipe González's Government, then he was a European Commissioner, and now he is Minister of Economy and Vice President. It is a great trajectory of public service and daily commitment.

He has that fine irony, he made a joke, and the one who should be congratulated is the journalist who asked him the question, because it was a question that had substance, right?

G. Lomana.- A month ago, scandals affected the Minister of Development, also from the economic area you are talking about. Do you think it is a joke that she went to Siberia to learn how to manage snowfalls, or do you think it is a great idea?

President.- It seems absolutely reasonable, as if she were going anywhere else, to learn about eventualities that may arise. In any case, I would like to clarify that, when referring to scandals, she must have been referring to management criticisms. The Minister of Development does not have, nor has she exercised, nor has she had any scandal problem. We had a problem at one time with a snowfall that occurred in Madrid especially, with an impact at Barajas, controversy and criticism; it was explained what had been done, but nothing more. I think that anything that tries to know the best techniques to respond to problems like a circumstance that is not usual, certainly in Madrid, nor at the Barajas Airport, which is a heavy snowfall, is reasonable.

G. Lomana.- Management problems with the AVE, with the roads, with Barajas, with Carmel… When you said she was a good minister, were you really serious at that moment?

President.- You see, we are going to become the country in the world with the most kilometers of High Speed next year, with a High-Speed model and operation that is studied by many countries and admired by many countries; our High Speed. I repeat, next year number one in the world in kilometers of High Speed and next year, also in 2010, the country with the most kilometers of highway in Europe. We have remodeled all the airports; the Prat Airport is yet to be inaugurated, but there is a modernization of the major airports in our country, and the growth in infrastructure is truly spectacular.

Therefore, she has a management. What happens? She has a ministry in which under her responsibility are the highways, the High Speed, rail transport, ports, and airports. It is a large ministry and from time to time it is normal for there to be or have some problem in her management; but the overall balance is objective. The data is there, in the immense transformation of infrastructures that is so important for development, for the economy, and for the structuring of our country, because in this Legislature we are going to see how High Speed reaches many Autonomous Communities, just as it has reached Barcelona. A few days ago, a year was completed. The High Speed between Madrid and Barcelona is an absolute success, as it will be soon in Valencia, a little later in Galicia, and in all the Autonomous Communities, also passing through León.

G. Lomana.- On a scale of one to ten, what score do you give your Government?

President.- That is for the journalists.

G. Lomana.- But dare yourself.

President.- That is for the journalists, who are very fond of giving scores. Citizens score at the polls. A year ago we had the elections and the Socialist Party, which came from being in Government, obtained the majority trust, had more votes and more seats. Therefore, I understand that the citizens approved us; but in democracy, one must always be with the highest demand to seek that support from the citizens.

G. Lomana.- We will talk about the polls shortly, but will your Government, this one you have now, last until 2010?

President.- My intention is that it will.

G. Lomana.- We are already talking about elections, about the elections next Sunday. In Euskadi you aspire to govern. With what support? With the Basque Nationalist Party or with the Popular Party?

President.- We aspire to be the first political force, but let us wait for the citizens to speak. We are in a democratic system, the polls must speak, the people must vote, and when the citizens vote and we see the composition of the Parliament, we will have to evaluate the different alternatives for government.

What I do understand and consider is that it is good for there to be a change in the Basque Country, and that change is represented by Patxi López, who is the future. Why? Because he has, as he has demonstrated, a capacity for understanding and a capacity for dialogue with all political forces and with all social sectors. That is what Euskadi needs most. I believe that Ibarretxe, the project of the Basque Nationalist Party, is exhausted and that now a new time of Patxi López would be very good for the Basque Country.

How to govern? We aspire to be the majority force and to have the greatest possible support. The agreements to form a Government will depend on the Socialist Party of Euskadi and, in particular, on Patxi López, who will be the one to establish the agreements, the dialogues, the pacts, to form a Government if that is the will of the citizens or, if not, to be, logically, in the opposition.

G. Lomana.- But you are the Secretary General of a party that includes the Socialist Party of Euskadi, and you won't tell me that you are not going to set some guiding lines for me to know if the Basque Nationalist Party can be the one to give you support or not. In other words, do you rule out that support from the Basque Nationalist Party? Do you rule it out or not?

President.- It is quite reasonable that, being regional elections, it is the Socialist Party of Euskadi that decides, especially since I have full, full confidence in Patxi López, in his good judgment and in his good work as he has been demonstrating, because since he has been at the head of the Socialist Party of Euskadi, the increase in electoral support from the Basque citizens, who have seen Patxi López and the Socialist Party of Euskadi committed to the fight for peace, for understanding, and for the end of violence in Euskadi, with a high sense of responsibility, has been impressive. We have had a very large increase in popular support, my confidence is complete, and I am sure they will do well and that the Basque citizens will give them broad support.

G. Lomana.- And in Galicia, have Touriño's expenses twisted the campaign? What do you think about a regional president like him spending 480,000 euros to remodel his office or spending two thousand euros on an office chair?

President.- I cannot endorse the figures you present, because I really do not have sufficient certainty about them. But I will tell you one thing: our style is a style of austerity, and I believe that this is the style that citizens value. What does seem a bit sad to me is that some, like in this case the Popular Party and Mr. Rajoy, have been unable to say anything to the Galicians other than talk about Mr. Touriño's office. Why? Because they cannot have any other debate. They cannot debate how Galicia has fared, which has grown economically above the Spanish average. They cannot talk about the fact that employment has been created in Galicia above the Spanish average, that it exports above the Spanish average, nor about the social policies that the Galician Government has implemented, nor about modernization, nor about support for universities and research, because today Galicia is a new economic and innovative reality. They do not talk about that, so much so that the candidate of the Popular Party has refused to debate.

I believe we should have… The Popular Party should exercise a bit more prudence, because today we have seen a good example, and allow me to return to the first question to see how we should position the political debate. Today, while Mariano Bermejo was resigning as Minister of Justice, Mr. Trillo, who had the responsibility, as a minister, for the Yakolev-42, as the Association of Family Members of the Victims reminded us today, was demanding more and more and criticizing; at the very moment a minister was resigning. This does not happen in any country, these attitudes that the Popular Party has, in any European country. A minister resigns and they say "you did what you had to do" or any other circumstance; but criticizing him and criticizing him when he is resigning, someone who had at one time the responsibility for the disastrous management of the Yakolev-42 disaster…

This is what citizens, I am radically convinced, contrast, and therefore, I think that running a campaign like the Popular Party has attempted in Galicia with these things is a bit, in my opinion, sad. It is the best expression of the lack of ideas, leadership, and cohesion that the Popular Party has.

G. Lomana.- We will talk about the economy shortly, but first a nuance. We, Antena-3 in Galicia, offered a two-person debate that Mr. Touriño did not accept, just as we offered a two-person debate in the Basque Country where Patxi López, however, did accept.

President.- I am not aware of that, but what I do know is that we have seen how the Galician television, which is the natural place, has promoted a debate…

G. Lomana.- But Antena-3 still has both debates open and we have five days of campaigning left or four days.

President.- But I am not surprised, because you see that it is not easy for the leaders of the Popular Party to go to the debates. I had to make many efforts to get Mr. Rajoy to finally attend a debate in the last elections; I did not succeed in the first ones. I think it is essential that, when there are elections, there are debates among the candidates. Proof of this is the interest they generate among viewers and the clarity there is when contrasting one idea with another.

G. Lomana.- We still need to talk about the economy; I ask for brevity in your answers…

President.- I will try, I assure you.

G. Lomana.- …especially because I know you really like this economic topic, and here it will cost me a bit more.

You have just returned from Berlin, and there the European leaders have prepared for the upcoming G-20, the next G-20 meeting. Will we be, as in Washington, with many photos and little concreteness in measures to tackle the crisis?

President.- It must be understood that Washington was about coming together, which is an essential first step, and saying "let's work together to face a reform of the financial system, after what has happened with the serious crisis we have." There, a work program was launched, and now, in London, we need to decide on the work program from Washington. What we did yesterday in Berlin was establish the priorities that we Europeans are going to defend at the G-20: regulation, transparency, global supervision, eradication of tax havens, early warning of financial risks, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank as the main supervisors of the system, and increasing the funds of the International Monetary Fund to prevent risks.

I think this is important because it provides security. It gives security to citizens, it should give security to markets, it should give security to companies, and it should give security to investors that the governments we represent, which account for 80 percent of the world's Gross Product, that we will be at the G-20 meeting, will agree and will work in the same direction and in a coordinated manner to respond to a crisis that, as Chancellor Merkel said yesterday, is an unprecedented international economic crisis, as we are experiencing. I think she defined it very accurately.

Therefore, security in the coordinated action of all, knowing that we have a difficult situation at the international level in the financial system and in the economy, in the real economy.

G. Lomana.- You spoke for the first time about the crisis in this very studio on July 7. Do you apologize to the Spanish people for not having made decisions earlier?

President.- We have made decisions from the very first moment. What happens is that I always find this debate about whether we knew or did not know very amusing. Everyone has been surprised by what has happened, especially after the summer, when we saw the most important banks in the United States, European banks, and a global recession fall, that is, a slowdown and a retreat in economic growth, as had not occurred since World War II.

I am also surprised, and it is an argument that I have not usually employed… On this, one cannot attempt to hide, nor not hide. If the economic data is public, daily, in all economies, in all democratic countries! One thing is that you have forecasts based on that data and others can make other forecasts. But nothing can be hidden. It is the most, allow me to say, absurd, demagogic, and ridiculous thing I have seen and heard in my life about the economy. If the data is public every day: the unemployment data, the industrial price data, the inflation data… All the data.

G. Lomana.- Nevertheless, President, I am not talking about hiding, but about taking time to react. That has been my question: taking time to react.

President.- We have been, and this can be verified, perhaps the second or third government that has launched the most ambitious plan in response to the crisis, the Economic and Employment Stimulus Plan. We are practically talking about 5 percent of the Gross Domestic Product in public investment and public spending, which amounts to fifty billion euros. And we have been among the first governments to approve our plans and, in any case, we were in tune with the European Commission.

I will make a brief explanation so that it is understood that the response must be coordinated. For example, regarding the crisis in the automotive sector, our cars export 85 percent outside our countries. If there are no coordinated plans to increase the demand for car purchases in Germany and France to maintain production in our country, we do not have a response to the automotive crisis. Now the expectations for car purchases in some European countries are improving due to support plans for demand, for car purchases, like in Germany, and that will positively impact our factories to better protect employment.

Therefore, the action has been coordinated. We are in a global economy, in an Economic and Monetary Union, we share the single currency, and in the face of a serious, very serious problem, the response can only be global. In our country, the economic crisis has a singular impact, which is unemployment. That is our main task, our main challenge, and, of course, where we need to focus specific economic and social action, because it has a lot to do with the attitude of employers and workers.

G. Lomana.- The worst, according to Solbes, will come in 2010. Will we have, when that year begins, four million unemployed or more than four million unemployed?

President.- I think it is not worth it, because then what happens happens with the forecasts. There are many people talking about how high unemployment will rise, and what seems important for the President of the Government to convey is that we have a serious situation with unemployment. We hope that in March and April we can curb what is a permanent increase, and that will continue, in unemployment, for various reasons; but unemployment will continue to rise.

But what is important for me to say? It is important for me to tell citizens that they can be assured that they will have all the social protection and all the support during the time they remain unemployed; and to the whole society, that we have put all the mechanisms in place, and we will put more if necessary, to return to a path of growth for our economy and job creation. That they can be assured that families and individuals who may be in a situation of unemployment or who may lose their jobs will have that support, that they feel secure, and the whole society feels secure that we will overcome the economic crisis and that the international context will be fundamental; but we will overcome it, we will emerge strengthened, and we will return to job creation and try to return to lower unemployment rates, as we achieved not long ago.

This country was able to reach the lowest unemployment rate in its history a year and a half ago, and, of course, I am convinced that as soon as we have better conditions, we will return to creating jobs. Now we are going to go through a few months, a few difficult quarters.

G. Lomana.- I ask for brevity, President. I wanted to ask you now about the financial system, of which you said ours was one of the best in the world. Do you still think so? Do you believe that there will not have to be interventions of banks or savings banks here as has occurred in other places in the world?

President.- There is an evident fact: so far that statement seems quite reliable because we have not had to intervene. We have not seen any bank that has had problems, and look at those we have seen in all countries: in the United States, in England, in Germany, in France… It has been impressive. Our financial system has held up, our banks are solid, and if necessary, we are now seeing a process of merging two savings banks, which can be a good path for some entities, some savings banks, it will be done, of course, with the full support of the Bank of Spain, which is responsible for managing our financial system and has proven to be a great bank for this task.

What I can say is that our banks, our large banks, the banks that have more relevance in the financial system, are in good health, and therefore, we can be calm from that perspective. And this is an advantage we have when we come out of the crisis compared to other countries. If mergers or restructurings need to be done in the realm of savings banks, the Bank of Spain will do it with the savings banks, as we are seeing now in a process. If more needs to be done in the future, it will be done; but I can also provide a lot of security in this regard about our financial system.

G. Lomana.- We are in the final stretch, and I will ask you a series of very short questions. Tomorrow you will meet with the parents of the young woman murdered, Marta del Castillo. What will you tell them when they ask for the death penalty, excuse me, life imprisonment?

President.- The first thing I will do is try to console them, to give them my affection, which I know is the affection of all Spaniards and the solidarity of all Spaniards; to explain to them everything that the Police are doing, and we will also talk about the penalties provided for those guilty of this abominable crime, this horrible crime, and what the constitutional situation is.

I understand very well that the parents of this person who is so present in the consciousness of all Spaniards want to see the guilty spend all the time in the world in prison. It is a feeling that we all understand, and that feeling has led to the progressive incorporation of reforms into our Penal Code, and now we have a reform underway, always from the perspective and principles that emanate from the Constitution. Technically, the Constitution does not contemplate the death penalty, but we have taken steps and will continue to take steps to ensure there is a severe, severe enforcement of behaviors like those we have unfortunately experienced.

G. Lomana.- Mr. President, we are finishing. With this overview that we have reviewed, are you at your worst moment? Just say "yes" or "no."

President.- Personally, I am doing well, I am feeling motivated, with a very, very clear horizon of the strength and capacity of this country. And, allow me to say, but seeing the other political forces and seeing how our main adversaries are doing, I can say that we are, or that I am, quite well.

G. Lomana.- Is your wife your main advisor?

President.- No. Not in politics. My wife is the person with whom I share my life, whom I have been in love with practically since a 23-F like today, because I remember that day well. She is, without a doubt, the best thing that has happened to me in my life, Sonsoles.

G. Lomana.- And what is the best advice she has given you for these days, today?

President.- Today I mentioned it to her in the morning...

G. Lomana.- And she said "dismiss Minister Bermejo."

President.- No. Not at all! Rather, she has affection for him and cares for him.

I am fortunate that Sonsoles is a person who always supports me in everything that represents my political task, which she does not like and does not intervene. Very rarely does she give her opinion. Perhaps that is what makes me work with all the strength and conviction. My father gave me some advice some time ago, that is true, and now he gives me less as time goes by. I also appreciated it, but in my family environment, I am fortunate to have support and a lot of affection.

G. Lomana.- Mr. President, I sincerely wish you the best for this upcoming Sunday in the Galician and Basque elections.

President.- Thank you very much.