Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

17 February 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on February 17, 2009, addressing municipal corruption and transparency.
Main themes
Municipal corruption, urban planning corruption, anti-corruption measures, transparency in local government, town hall financing, parliamentary oversight, Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, investigative commissions, political accountability, land law reform
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,379
65th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.23
75th percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
66th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 55%53%
  • Economic 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

89 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Uxue Barkos, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Ms. Barkos.- Mr. President of the Government, the most recent alleged cases of corruption are compromising, among many other things, because in the current economic situation they also undermine a certain climate of trust, especially the good name of the Town Halls. And this is the question: does the Government plan to take measures to tackle corruption in the Town Halls?

President.- Ms. Uxue Barkos, I will tell you that the Government has been working in recent years to strengthen all mechanisms in the fight against corruption and, specifically, against corruption in the urban planning sector, where a significant volume of municipal competencies undoubtedly lies.

These have been measures that have reinforced the means and functions of the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, and thus the creation of the figure of the Coordinator Prosecutor for the Environment and Urban Planning has also been established; police resources have been strengthened with the creation of specific groups of the Police and Civil Guard against urban crime; furthermore, the Land Law, in which various specific provisions aimed at combating urban corruption were introduced; regulatory reforms in local matters regarding the obligations of publicity of the assets and interests of government members, as well as the tightening of their incompatibility regime. These are measures that have been implemented.

It is true that the set of cases that are leading to investigations or actions by the Justice system or the Prosecutor's Office shows that there is a fight against what can be criminal behaviors affecting a relatively small number of Town Halls, in any case, relative to the more than eight thousand municipalities that exist.

Moreover, I will tell you that, of course, the Socialist Group and the Government will always be open to considering new preventive regulatory measures that can strengthen the prevention against irregular or criminal behaviors.

Ms. Barkos.- Mr. President of the Government, I also want to emphasize one of the statements you made: there are few Town Halls involved in relation to the volume of municipal entities across the State. And you enumerate a series of really interesting measures but, in light of the headlines of these days, it is evident that they are not sufficient; there is more material for action.

I will highlight two measures: the first, to resolve a pending issue since the beginning of the democratic era, which is the financing of the Town Halls, as they are the custodians of the largest number of social services to be provided to citizens. Their lack of financing turns them, in many cases, into a true Achilles' heel of our system, especially in relation to urban issues. And I repeat that I am not the one saying this; it is said by the cases that day in and day out are dominating the pages of the newspapers.

But the second measure is entirely political in nature: transparency, Mr. President of the Government; transparency in promoting not only greater collaboration with the Justice Administration in cases where it is required, of course!, but also political transparency. Your party has requested this in cases such as the Madrid espionage, referring to other issues, with an investigative commission, such as those of the Town Halls near Madrid: Boadilla and Majadahonda; but, apparently, you act with a double standard, because that same transparency in the form of an investigative commission is what your party has prevented in a case of "b boxes" or "c boxes." For the moment, the Prosecutor's Office continues to investigate in a Town Hall where you do govern, in the Navarrese locality of Cintruénigo.

Political transparency, therefore, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and accepting, alongside judicial investigations, something we have seen here, such as investigative commissions. Mr. President, do you think that looking the other way, not betting on political transparency in any Town Hall, regardless of who governs, is confronting corruption?

President.- Ms. Barkos, we basically agree. I would make a nuance regarding what represents the need for improving the financing of the Town Halls. Unfortunately, many alleged cases of corruption or crimes in the municipal sphere do not relate to the financing needs of the Town Halls, but rather to other types of needs, certainly, much more immoral.

Secondly, I will tell you that, of course, absolute transparency and in all places and in all areas. I have no doubt that this will also occur in the case you refer to. Certainly, that is my position and that of my party.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gaspar Llamazares, from the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President, what do you think of the proposals for free dismissal from a certain Fernández Ordóñez?

President.- Mr. Llamazares, you are referring to Mr. Fernández Ordóñez, I imagine?

I will tell you that he has given a conference in which he spoke, among other things, about the need to reform labor institutions. It is true that the headlines..., even I understood that a strong statement had been made regarding what the cost of dismissal could be. The reading of the conference, which I do not know if Mr. Llamazares has done, has some nuances, because what Mr. Fernández Ordóñez spoke about are the formulas that allow us to increase productivity, reduce unemployment figures, and improve workers' wages. And he expressly stated that the debate he was raising was completely detached from those who reduce it to whether or not to lower the cost of dismissal.

In any case, in case there is room for interpretations, I will clear them up in advance. You already know what our position is, the position of the Government: we are not going to promote, to support, any labor market reform that represents lowering the cost of dismissal and weakening workers' rights; moreover, what we want is to strengthen the social protection of workers in a situation of unemployment. That is my position.

Mr. Llamazares.- I am glad, Mr. President, that you recognize Mr. Fernández Ordóñez. He is not a stranger in the conservative; you appointed him Governor of the Bank of Spain and, moreover, the worst of all is that he is not alone. In recent days, Mr. Almunia has come to support him in the proposals for lowering the cost of dismissal, Mr. Solbes understands him, and you seem to explain it.

In any case, you are responsible for the agitation of the employers at this time around free dismissal, linking agreements to free dismissal and to tailored employment regulation files.

But, in addition, you said that this was a sign of democratic health, the debate, and it is not true, Mr. President, because the debate among the economic institutions of the State, of which you are responsible, translates into disorganization, disorientation, and stagnation in a situation of economic crisis. You cannot be, moreover, both the opposition and the Government, you cannot threaten with the right and pat with the left, and you cannot be the unions and the employers at the same time. That is not healthy from a democratic point of view; that is totalitarian. In that sense, Mr. President, I consider that such statements are not healthy.

But what you should do is not only clarify yourselves but also seek agreement and concertation. Izquierda Unida has made a series of proposals to you and the unions have also made proposals to protect workers more; there are a million unemployed without social protection; to end arbitrary EREs that are currently resulting in free dismissal; to ensure that financing reaches companies and citizens and to change the development model. For all of this, we need a Government that governs, a Government that clarifies itself, and a Government that, governing and clarifying itself, is capable of concerting -- social concertation that is pending -- and is capable of negotiating and agreeing.

I conclude. You are not a debate club, Mr. President, nor are you sociocultural animators. Leave that to others. We in this Chamber have to debate, and you have to govern. Nothing more.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Llamazares, for your advice. I take note of them.

I will tell you two things in this regard. The position of the Government, of the Socialist Party, and of the Socialist Group is clear, and we are, in line with what you pointed out, working to reach an agreement within the framework of social dialogue with two objectives: to strengthen unemployment protection and to incorporate new measures to stimulate employment, fundamentally to capitalize unemployment benefits to be able to enter the labor market and incentivize part-time contracts or work; and improvement, I insist, in unemployment protection. That is the line of work.

However, do not ask me, Mr. Llamazares, that people do not express their opinions with a certain freedom. It should even give you some peace of mind, and I suppose to all Groups, that there are institutional leaders, such as the Governor of the Bank of Spain, who has his autonomy and functioning statute, who can express an opinion in one way. Certainly, I do not demand fidelity in thought, because I believe that this is part of other models of political work. What I demand is qualification and competence.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, what is your opinion on the fact that the Minister of Justice goes out to dinner and hunting with a judge from the National Court, that the General Commissioner of the Judicial Police and a prosecutor go with them, that this happens on the day when a summary is known that is being instructed by the judge who wants to turn it into a general case against a party, that that weekend a multitude of information is leaked about people whose honor is being attacked and they are left defenseless; and that this is not the first hunting trip they have attended together?

I ask for your opinion on this matter, and I will give you mine: it is a degrading, shameful act, it liquidates any appearance of separation of powers and impartiality of Justice, and casts a veil of suspicion over the Minister and the judge. I want to know your opinion on this matter and whether you will dismiss the Minister of Justice today, as the minimum rules of democratic play demand.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the Minister of Justice has explained the circumstances in which the event you refer to occurred and has even given an assessment of it.

For my part, I must add: political responsibility, both in the opposition and in the Government, requires that we have respect for the strength of our Rule of Law which, fortunately, since the enactment of the Constitution has shown that it works and has demonstrated that it is capable of maintaining the full independence of judges, in which I firmly believe, of each and every one of the judges and in all and each of the circumstances, producing effects in a political sphere or in a political group sometimes and in another at other times. We should be responsible in that sense.

On the other hand, Mr. Rajoy, as you know, fortunately, that Rule of Law grants guarantees of defense and guarantees of resources to all. And, in my opinion, in democracy, when we are talking about Justice and the Rule of Law, those of us who have political responsibilities should not exaggerate. Speaking of shameful and despicable things that have been published in recent days or weeks, there are things that do seem shameful and despicable to me, but not precisely those to which you refer, Mr. Rajoy.

Mr. Rajoy.- Undoubtedly, the President refers also to what has happened in Ciempozuelos, Pinto, and Getafe.

Mr. President of the Government, you are not going to dismiss Mr. Bermejo. Well, I will tell you the following: you become responsible and a guarantor of Mr. Bermejo's hunting trips, of the price he may or may not have paid for them, of the use of a property of the State Heritage such as Quintos de Mora, and of the non-compliance with the ethical code that you presented with great fanfare at La Moncloa, where transparency, exemplarity, neutrality, and austerity are discussed. You become responsible for the judges' strike, the first in the history of Spanish democracy, and you become responsible for the actions of the Prosecutor's Office and its abuse of power.

Today, by not affirming here the dismissal of Mr. Bermejo, you become Mr. Bermejo himself and indissolubly link your policy to the actions of a judge who has acted irresponsibly.

If you do not find it shameful and an affront to the separation of powers that a judge of the National Court, on the same day that a case is made public, on the same day that a series of people are left defenseless, goes hunting with another judge, I do not know what you would find shameful; but, certainly, from a democratic standpoint, this event would not occur in any civilized country in the world. Mr. Bermejo must be dismissed.

President.- Indeed, Mr. Rajoy, perhaps that is what sets us apart. To me, the facts, until there is a ruling, from Ciempozuelos, or Estepona, or Boadilla, all seem equally shameful, regardless of the political color of the administrations involved. That, on one hand.

On the other hand, I appeal to calm and responsibility for the respect of the work of judges, police, and prosecutors. I believe that is a contribution we owe to the citizens. Let the rule of law function.

I know, Mr. Rajoy, that your favorite sport, in the absence of other ideas, is to call for the resignations of ministers. Allow me to say that I cannot satisfy you on this point.

What I do find important to highlight to the citizens is one thing, Mr. Rajoy: you come here to raise not the problems of the Spanish people, but your own problems, which you do not know how to solve or cannot solve. That is the issue.