Press Conference of the President of the Government after the General Assembly of the United Nations

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 September 2007 · Press conference of the President of the Government after the General Assembly of the United Nations

Context
Zapatero addressed press after Spain's participation in the UN General Assembly in New York on September 24, 2007, focusing on climate change commitments.
Main themes
Climate change, UN General Assembly, multilateral cooperation, polluting emissions reduction, European Union climate leadership, Spain's environmental policy, renewable energy, technology transfer, international development aid, Millennium Development Goals, global economic growth and sustainability
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,487
89th percentile
Sentences
141
78th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.29
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

141 sentences in 66 paragraphs

President .- Good morning. I would like to make an assessment about the main aim of the beginning of the period of sessions of the General Assembly of the United Nations, whose main subject has been the way the challenge of climatic change should be faced.

As you all know, the United Nations is a guarantee, a warrantor of an international system that must face those essential problems that transcend countries, regions, and whose natural context is the International Community as a whole.

The United Nations have traditionally dealt with security and peace. Later on, it has developed its leadership in the fight against poverty and inequality.

The Objective of the Millennium is, doubtlessly, the great issue; just like in the area of international order for security, all the actions carried out by the Security Council involve the most outstanding components of that international system of unbalance.

The United Nations are now facing a third great worldwide objective, that is, exerting its leadership in the fight against climatic change; a climatic change that is seriously endangering welfare, progress, health and the expectations of thousands of human beings.

Thus, I would like to congratulate the General Secretary of the United Nations, Mr. Ban Ki-Moon, on this initiative, for he convinced a very high number of Heads of the Government and State to take up the responsibility to put forward coordinated, multilateral measures about climatic change.

According to our agenda, there will be two decisive years, from 2007 to 2009, in order to set up changes in order to face the high risk, the progressively higher risk of polluting emissions. Thus, a series of aspects have been defined as priorities, namely: the adaptation that this involves, in the first place; in the second place, the mitigation, mitigating the effects of climatic change; in the third place, supporting renewable energies and, in the fourth place, financing the challenge of the fight against climatic change.

I would like to tell you that the European Union is an area that has already led the fight against climatic change. It has taken up compromises, such as reducing in 20 per cent the polluting emissions, which might reach 30 per cent, if the International Community, and certain countries in particular, assume their compromises.

Of course, Spain is going to observe its responsibility in the reduction of polluting gas emissions. I would like to provide some data that I consider relevant and that were provided yesterday, during our dinner -which included twenty five countries-, which was held in order to deal with the degree of compromise and with the future of consensus, of multilateral availability: Spain is the country from among the eight great international economies, from among those countries with a higher Gross Domestic Product, that has grown more, from the economic point of view, the one that has created more employment and the one that has reduced in 4 per cent its percentages of polluting gas emissions during 2006 and, besides, we have reduced our electric consumption too. These are good data. The key, of course, has been the support to innovation, research, development, energy rationalization and energy saving.

To sum up, the most developed countries may keep growing, they may keep creating employment and, at the same time, they may reduce polluting gasses. In fact, dialogue with those countries that have the right and the duty to keep increasing the welfare expectations for their nations will play the most important role. It is there that the International Community and, in particular, the developed countries have to meet an obligation that must be led by the United Nations, and that obligation involves the transfer of technology so that the productive processes that use more advanced, polluting technology may be progressively substituted by new technology, cleaner, more innovating and respectful with environment.

Thus, I would like to carry out a positive assessment, because this Summit against Climatic Change has made the awareness of the Governments arise even to higher levels. And I am fully convinced that they are going to play a decisive role in the negotiation processes that will take place during the next two years.

Apart from that, as you all know, during this visit to the United Nations I have held several bilateral meetings, which I talked about yesterday. I also held a meeting with the General Secretary of the United Nations, during which we reviewed in depth all the compromises of Spain with the United Nations; the outstanding increase of Spain's Aid for Development, the Cooperation that, as you all know, has increased from 0.22-0.23 per cent when we entered the Government to 0.5 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product in the Budget for 2008.

Thanks to the United Nations we have increased considerably our voluntary contribution, to practically all the programmes that are being developed in the different areas of the fight against poverty, in favour of health, in favour of education and in the case of migrations, and we are giving an example, as a country, with our contribution to the United Nations in order to face the most lacerating, delicate issues that are devastating many countries in the world, many of the countries that form part of the United Nations.

The peace missions were also analysed, peace missions with which Spain has a compromise, in particular, those in the Lebanon and Afghanistan; the analysis of the situation of both countries from the point of view of security. And, of course, as I have been reiterating to the General Secretary of the United Nations, the compromise to keep supporting the Alliance of Civilizations that, as you all know, is going to celebrate its first debate and initiative forum in Madrid next January, where there will be representatives of Governments, Non Governmental Organisations and civic organisations in favour of dialogue, understanding and approach between different cultures and civilizations.

P.- There has been a conflict for thirty years and Spain is not directly involved in it although Spain has an essential interest in it, and that is the Sahara conflict. Do you think that there are real grounds in this moment for a definitive solution of this conflict?

President .- This is what Spain wishes. Now there is a direct dialogue among the parties and it is being channelled from the place it should be, from the United Nations. Let's give it some time for, of course, Spain has the most constructive attitude in order to be able to contribute to this dialogue so that it may yield satisfactory results.

You might have heard me say, more than once, that the solution to the conflict of the Sahara implies a political agreement between the Kingdom of Morocco and the Saharawi people, and, in particular, its representative, the Polisario Front. After more than thirty years without a solution, experience and common sense are telling us that the agreement is the only solution possible and, if this agreement is carried out under the auspices of the United Nations, with the support of the United Nations, with the leadership of the United Nations, the solution will have a long-lasting future.

P.- I would like to know the position of Spain with regards to the future status of Kosovo. We are rather monothematic over there. You talked about the Sahara and the negotiations and the discussions have been taking place for thirty years. Do you think that there is a special hurry to solve the status of Kosovo? Do you support the position of the United States, which is convinced that the only solution for Kosovo is independence? Do you think that this is going to influence other countries, especially in Europe?

President .- Spain's position is framed in the European Union. We deem it very important, due to geopolitical reasons, that the position concerning Kosovo must be European and that there should be the outmost agreement within Europe. This position must respect International Law and, of course, it must achieve the greatest consensus possible.

Therefore, during the next few months, we will have a decisive agenda concerning the future of Kosovo in front of us and, of course, Spain will defend the most constructive position inside the European Union, but also the most respectful one with regards to International Law; respecting, of course, what other countries have to say, in this case, the United States, as you have hinted at in your question.

P.- President, we are monothematic too. I would like to know how did you feel yesterday, when you greeted Mr. George Bush; whether you felt comfortable and whether you perceived it as a cold greeting or not.

That in the first place.

Then, as you said yesterday that you would also leave Catalan politics for today, I would like to ask you about the declarations of Mr. Pasqual Maragall, in an article in which he affirms that the condition to approve of the Statute of Catalonia was your own resignation; a condition that, according to Mr. Pasqual Maragall, was imposed by you.

President .- I have not read anything about this, neither have I read anything concerning those declarations of Mr. Maragall that you are referring to and, thus, I am not going to say anything on this matter. I will call him, though, to find out whether he said that.

As to the first question, yes. The truth is that I must say that this is a bit monothematic, but… I am not sure about whether some feel it that way or whether those who put it forward feel it that way. For me it seems very natural.

I have met President Bush on several occasions, as it should be, during international meetings. Yesterday, at the dinner, I greeted him with the same normality with which I greeted all the Presidents that attended the event, and he greeted me as well, in the same natural way. Surely enough, if such circumstances were seen the very moment they are happening they would not seem so interesting, for they are not so interesting - not at all - when one is going through those circumstances. We had an interesting debate during that dinner, with very constructive positions.

Now then, I have already said this today and I will repeat it anew, there is a good relationship with the United States of America as far as politics, economy, and culture... are concerned. They are well known and there has only been a secondary discrepancy, which is also well known and affects the sovereignty of each country. One of the things I have always respected more in all Governments, and in particular in the case of the Government of the United States, is their zeal to defend their sovereignty. Spain also defends its sovereignty and its own decisions; for it is a democracy.

P.- President, taking into account your insistence in talking about the leadership of the United Nations, it seems that you are not convinced about it, or that you are not convinced about some other initiative, such as the one put forward by President Bush this week in Washington. That is to say, the fact that you insist so much, is it due to the fact that you think that there is some kind of danger for someone could carry out a unilateral initiative, acting alone with regards to something that is evidently affecting the interests of many people?

President .- With that statement I have buttressed - trying to give the United Nations the maximum support - the words of the General Secretary of the United Nations. Everyone knows that for the Government that I preside, the axes of foreign politics favour, in the first place, the defence of the system of the United Nations, of the leadership of the General Secretary and of international legality and multilateralism. And, if there is an issue that needs multilateralism, that issue is how to face the challenge of climatic change. Why?

Because for such a relevant issue an efficient answer can only be provided through a wide agreement between the most developed countries, the ones who are developing and the poorest ones, which are the ones that suffer the most negative effects on many occasions.

The European Union has issued a document on climatic change, it has set forth a series of duties. I think it is a good thing to have more initiatives; but they all must be developed under the leadership of the United Nations. For the UN must lead the negotiation process that we are going to face during the next two years in order to achieve a new agreement and in order to involve as many countries as possible. What will make us efficient, from my point of view, in order to achieve such agreement will doubtlessly be the leadership of this organisation, as has always happened with the great international and multilateral conferences.

P.- Yesterday, when you talked about Iran, you refused confrontation scenarios and you said that the mistakes that had been made over the previous years should not be made again. Were you thinking about the Iraq war? The question is: do you think that the United States is already making or is going to make in Iran the same mistakes it made in Iraq?

President .- We are in New York, the United States, and I would not like to discuss a particular policy. I have already spoken and I think that my words follow a coherent trend of thought as far as foreign policy, security and the approach to the international order are concerned.

This institution was born in order to avoid conflicts, it was born after a great period of destruction, the Second World War, and it was born in order to guarantee peace. The Chart of the United Nations contains words and ideas that we must keep up, support, defend and apply on a daily basis; each time this institution, either at the Security Council or through the leadership of the General Secretary, avoids a conflict, approaches a conflict, it is fulfilling its duty.

Therefore, let's resort to all the chances offered by dialogue before a particular vision or a particular decision may involve confrontation.

P.- Last year, Spain donated seven hundred Euros to the UNDP, I think. After this great donation, there has been a controversy about the UNDP, first, because the audits have not been shared with the member States who had given the money and secondly, because reprisals have been taken against those who have denounced it in the case of North Korea; and more recently the UNDP has said that it is not going to accept the ethics office to investigate the complaints concerning its employees. Being an important contributor to the UNDP, I would wonder whether a follow-up of the money handed in by me had been carried out by it and whether an explanation on and how it was going to be spent would be provided.

President .- Public resources must be managed with the greatest transparency and with the greatest guarantees, those belonging to the United Nations too, of course, and they have their own control systems, whose reinforcement will always be accepted by us. This is not going to limit our growing efforts - the efforts we have been making so far - to contribute to the programmes of the United Nations because each time these contributions take place -last year our contributions amounted to more than five hundred million Euros- we are deeply convinced and deeply sure that lives are saved, that the children receive an education that they did not receive before, that children get vaccines that they did not have before and that people receive the food that they did not receive before.

We are supporting a very relevant action from Spanish cooperation, because there are great population groups that are going to be provided with the main element for life and development, that is to say, with water, with access to water -which is not available to millions of citizens all over the world-; and not for want of water, but for want of investments, for want of supply systems, for want of depuration or for want of sanitation systems; thus, this is going to be the main subject of the Iberoamerican Summit that will be celebrated in Santiago de Chile next November, and during which we are going to implement powerful instruments in Latin America.

P.- About this subject, and to finish with it, the leader of the opposition, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, said this morning, in Madrid, that it is not normal for the representative of the eighth world power not to be able to have a conversation with the representative of the first world power. I would just like to know your opinion about this.

President .- This is a trite subject and it does not contribute to the public debate. It is true that some are not characterised by their originality or by their initiative when it comes to incorporating new subjects to the debate about the future of our country and about the things that citizens are concerned about. But I am here, in New York, and I do not want to start up a controversy neither with Mr. Rajoy nor with anyone else.

P.- Today, we have seen President Bush demanding the United Nations to make Cuba observe the right of association and the right of freedom of expression.

There are other countries in Europe that are also subscribing the position of Cuba. What are the specific measures that your Government is going to take in order to strengthen the Cuban opposition and, in particular, so that different parties may present their candidatures during the elections, so that someone may have the right to be a great loser, and maybe with Spain as one of the main observers?

President .- I represent a country and a Government that know very well what loving freedom and democracy means, because they suffered a very hard dictatorship for a long time, forty years. And the truth is that our present experience of thirty years of freedom and democracy is exciting. We suffered a lot in order to defend freedom and democracy. Many people in our country suffered a lot, many people had to wait and, fortunately, many people made a democratic transition, with wide agreement and consensus.

The wish of the Government of Spain as far as Cuba is concerned involves stepping towards a system in which the participation of citizens may be a constant factor, that is the line of action we may follow from dialogue, contributing so that Cuban citizens may live better, which is the objective of all of us, and, of course, always with the maximum willingness to reach an agreement in the International Community, from the European Union to the United Nations, instead of implementing unilateral policies.

P.- President, today, it has been announced in Spain that social aids are going to be raised to 3,500 Euros in certain cases. I would like to know whether this is the limit or whether it would be possible to extend those aids so that they start to be implemented from the first of January, instead of from July.

Besides, and I know that you are not going to like this one, I am going to insist once more on the question of the greetings. Why when you greet each other you do not keep talking to him for a while? Could we say that you do not hit it off, say?

President .- The truth is that we can reach the limits of absurdity; I will tell you, honestly, that although not in this occasion -for he entered and greeted other members too- but in the meetings that we have held so far or the last time we met during the Summit of the NATO I have been talking with President Bush about different things that belong to a more relaxed, private area.

I would like this not to give way to some pathologic syndrome, really. Our relationship is normal, we greet each other normally, we know that we have had different opinions with regards to an essential matter and we respect each other as we are democratic and free countries, and also well-mannered, correct persons.

P.- Isn't it a bit surprising the fact that he did not make any comment about the soldiers in Afghanistan? Did he transmit his condolences to you later on? Thus, do you subscribe what President Bush said during his speech concerning the reform of the Council of Human Rights, does Birmania subscribe..?

President .- I am sure there is no reason for a leader of a Government to subscribe a whole speech. I think that all the speeches I have listened to yesterday and today, at the General Assembly, contain things I share and things I do not share completely. It would be, of course, a tiring interpretative task for me to say what I share and what I do not share completely.

Besides, I am completely convinced that President Bush, for I am not sure that he had learnt about the news from Afghanistan… Whenever we have gone through a tragic event and a death we have received the condolences of the American Administration, and on certain occasions, President Bush, during the meetings that we have held, has personally praised the effort that Spain is making, of course both in Afghanistan and also in Lebanon.

This is how these things go, and they take place in an atmosphere of good relationships and with an attitude of solidarity among us.

P.- President, yesterday you told me that you would talk about Catalonia today, so I would like to ask you about the fact that the Catalan political parties fear a confrontation if the National Criminal Court identifies the persons - more than three hundred - who burnt photographs of the King in Gerona during the last weekend.

President .- I am to answer something that I would like to comment on.

As you all know, the Law whereby a subsidy of 2,500 Euros to promote the birth rates is established is still being debated with the Parliamentary Groups. I know that several Parliamentary Groups have proposed that the amount should be increased in certain cases in which it can be considered that they demand a higher subsidy from the social point of view. An agreement has already been established with several Groups and, of course, the final result will logically be the one established by the Parliament.

I think that the essential thing is that this Law will be a turning point for social policies in Spain, for this is the first time for our country to adopt a measure to support the birth rates with such economic relevance and, therefore, a measure that supports families and places us -as I have explained on previous occasions- among the European countries that provide more support to the birth rates and also, of course, with a relevant progress as far as supporting families is concerned.

In fact, if the positions of other Groups and the amendments they put forwards in order to reach this agreement prove to be reasonable, such as the proposal to increase the amount under particular conditions that may affect the birth rates or the family that receives this subsidy, I will find them adequate.

We are going through a moment in Spain in which we will save money. Let's have a look at the public surplus that we are going to achieve this year, it may achieve approximately fifteen or eighteen million Euros; and let's consider that the Social Security System has saved 35,000 million Euros during the last three years. Thus, our financial scenery is very healthy, unlike any other economic power in the world, for they all have a deficit, and this makes it possible for us to implement social policies. Is there something better in terms of social policy than supporting families, than supporting a young, hardworking couple that wants to have a baby? For this is the usual profile of those who have a baby in our country!

As to Catalonia, we must respect the Law and the actuation of the institutions that have been constitutionally established in order to ensure that the Law is observed. Of course, I think that the Catalan political parties must contribute to a message that I deem absolutely essential, namely, that we must respect, generally speaking, everything concerning public life. One may express oneself and exert the greatest freedom of expression without trespassing and becoming offensive. This is possible in a democratic country and I hope that all the political parties in Catalonia will transmit this message to those whose actuations do not defend any idea at all.

When ideas are defended that way, one's arguments are no longer valid, regardless of the idea.

I hereby make a calling to those who express themselves or to those who say that they have the right to transmit their political or ideological positions freely: do it respecting the others and, thus, respecting the Law.

P.- What do you think of that account of the conversations with ETA, made by the Basque press?

President .- I must confess something: I have not read that document because it was published the day we were coming to New York. I would just point out a couple of principles or conclusions that are clearly reflected in our perspective ever since the process was interrupted: in the first place, Spain's democratic Government made a great effort in order to put an end to violence; a great effort to dialogue and surely enough, everyone understands that it was carried out under quite difficult circumstances given the political atmosphere at that time; in the second place, the Government maintained, as it has constantly assured to citizens, the democratic principles and the principles of respect to the Rule of Law.

These are the two evident conclusions. With the perspective that we have gained over the last few months, after the interruption of the cease-fire and with what I have heard concerning certain declarations by people from a radical environment or by those who have not had the courage to get detached from violence, it is quite evident that the option of ETA to keep using violence is a very serious mistake, a great mistake, nothing but an error; and that the majority, the great majority of the citizens of the Basque Country, even those who live in places in which there has been, historically, a very particular sensibility with regards to this matter, have not understood it and that now they will have to adapt to the circumstances determined by democracy.

I am very sorry that some are using the fight against terrorism for a political purpose and it is very sad, taken into account the profuse utilization of this matter.

Thank you very much.