Press conference of the President of the Government after the FAO Summit on food security, climate change, and bioenergy.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

2 June 2008 · FAO Summit on food security, climate change, and bioenergy · FAO, United Nations

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference at the FAO World Summit in Rome on June 2, 2008, outlining Spain's response to the global food crisis.
Main themes
Global food crisis, food security, hunger and poverty, FAO Summit, Spain's foreign aid commitments, agricultural production revival, speculation and financial crisis, Africa development, bioenergy and oil prices, global governance, Doha Round, investment in infrastructure
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,427
81st percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

124 sentences in 49 paragraphs

President.- Thank you for attending this press conference.

Today we held a Summit at the FAO, United Nations, to address one of the major problems facing the international order and society as a whole: the issue of the food crisis as a consequence of rising prices, which generates an expectation of more hunger and more poverty.

The issue is not so much that food prices are rising significantly; the issue is that there are many people who cannot afford these food prices and, therefore, face a greater risk of hunger and even losing their lives.

I want to congratulate the United Nations, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, and the Director-General of the FAO for convening this Summit. This Summit must be the starting point of a global mobilization to fight against this food crisis that threatens us all: it threatens some in their ability to live, and it should threaten all of our conscience, because the world has enough food and because the world has achieved sufficient economic development, and it must achieve a balance and distribution that allows the vast majority of its inhabitants to access food security.

I want to thank the Director-General of the FAO for the special recognition he has given to Spain as the country that has reacted first to the food crisis, incorporating fifty million euros more in a path that in the last four years has multiplied in some programs up to four hundred times what our country had been allocating. Therefore, we are as committed as anyone and the first to fight against the acute, urgent, serious food crisis in the immediate term.

And the immediate term also involves addressing the speculation that is occurring for various reasons in prices and in the accumulation of harvests for the future. It surely has a lot to do with the financial crisis originating in the United States and the shifting of investments from one sector to another, and also with the impact that the escalation of oil prices is having. Behind these phenomena, which provoke so many effects of serious imbalances and situations of vulnerability for people, there is a common underlying problem, which is the need for greater governance of the issues that affect us all in the world, in an open and globalized world, and that certain situations quickly provoke an extension of the circumstances.

But we know that, in addition to a serious and urgent food crisis that threatens one hundred million people, especially in Africa, which is the continent that suffers the most hunger and where there are the most injustices and inequalities; in addition to that, this crisis has caused the world to look back at agriculture, which had been relegated to the background for decades -- I look at the Minister because she knows it well -- to reconsider some things: that we must again stimulate agricultural production; that we must again allow farmers to have decent living conditions in rural areas; that we must allow those who today cannot produce to be able to produce and, therefore, to recover or acquire for the first time production capacity; and that we must satisfactorily conclude the Doha Round within the World Trade Organization, so that there is an increasing balance between the possibilities of agricultural production and the marketing of agricultural products.

But Africa is the continent that needs to produce to address the challenges it faces in the future. Today it has around 900 million people, but by 2020 it could be at 1.4 billion people if it maintains its growth rate and birth rate, which represents a risk for poverty and misery, and its increase on that continent.

It is absolutely essential, therefore, to invest in Africa: to invest in infrastructure, to invest in productive capacity, and to invest in irrigation. Hence, for the various cooperation programs in all these areas of food aid and investment aid, I can announce today that the Government of Spain will allocate five hundred million euros in the next almost four years, aimed at addressing what represents the food crisis in the countries that suffer it the most and to boost productive capacity, investment, and infrastructure.

As you know, Spain has also offered to hold a High-Level Meeting in the fall to evaluate the applications of the framework, the plan, that will be approved here in Rome, and also to approve a Charter of Food Security Rights.

Finally, as you know, in addition to participating in what this important Summit represents for the fate of millions of human beings in the world and our dignity as human beings, I have had bilateral meetings with the Secretary-General of the United Nations; with the President of Tanzania and President of the African Union; with Prime Minister Berlusconi, the Italian Prime Minister, and also with the President of Senegal, President Wade, with whom I just had a brief meeting, a mini-summit, a mini bilateral meeting. Certainly, all of them have yielded positive results.

You know that we have a wide range of relationships that we logically deploy with intensity, both in Africa and with the United Nations, where we have addressed a significant number of issues, and also with the Italian Prime Minister, Silvio Berlusconi. It was the first meeting after the elections in Italy, but it was not the first meeting between Silvio Berlusconi and José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, because during the time he was Prime Minister we had several meetings, always positive, because it has been easy to work and will be easy to work in the future with the Government of Italy.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to ask you two things. In your speech, you mentioned that there should be a debate on the use of biofuels. I would like to know what the position of the Spanish Government is on this issue.

Then, in your meeting with Mr. Berlusconi, have the problems that existed between the two countries been resolved, or will they remain, because you talk about a common European policy on this matter, but we see that your positions are very different in some cases from those of Mr. Berlusconi and also from the proposal of Mr. Sarkozy?

President.- Regarding biofuels, first of all, there is no unanimity on what the impact of the expansion of biofuels is or may be on the rise in prices. There are opinions for all tastes, for the moment. We tend to think that the expansion of biofuels has had, or is having, a limited effect on this price escalation of fuels.

Of course, there needs to be an open and ongoing debate on this matter. We are very clearly inclined in favor of what are called second-generation biofuels, and you know well that Spain has a very incipient development in this area.

We believe that the commitments set by the European Union as objectives must be fulfilled. That is our position.

Secondly, regarding Prime Minister Berlusconi, on most of the important issues that our societies face today, from an economic, social, and environmental point of view, if there is a political response from the European Union, we will address them with greater guarantees of effectiveness. And I have clearly identified three issues: migration policy, energy, and the food crisis. It is not that we want to do it or not; it is not that we are more or less pro-European; it is that we are obliged, whether we want to or not, because energy problems transcend, of course, what is a country. They are global, and from a greater force, such as Europe, a response can be given for greater energy security.

Migration problems affect us all and have similar origins for most countries, similar characteristics in their development, and also in what is life for integration or coexistence in each country.

We have not addressed, although Prime Minister Berlusconi has taken the consideration to explain to me the legislative measures they have incorporated, the situation. He has clarified some things for me; some things that, from his point of view, have a much smaller dimension than what may have seemed in public debate at some point. I appreciate the clarification he has given me, and certainly, what we have agreed on is to work together, especially in the European Union, and to share experiences in the face of a phenomenon that at certain times has a very clear problem.

Will we agree on everything? Probably not, as with France. And it is true that we are talking about a matter where the search for legal responses is almost permanent, because the needs are pressing.

I conveyed to Prime Minister Berlusconi an idea that is essential for us: the most effective response to illegal immigration that must be combated is cooperation with the countries of origin, because to repatriate, to enforce the law, we must have the capacity for the countries of origin to accept the return of people who attempt to or are illegally in each of our countries. And that is achieved with diplomatic, political, and cooperative effort. I wish a national law would suffice, but it does not, and we all know that.

Then, the extent of the responsibility that an illegal immigrant has towards a country or the time they may be held for identification can be discussed. That is debatable. I would like us to unify positions, and I can assure you that legal responses to a phenomenon of this nature can have less effectiveness than the capacity for cooperation of Europe and all countries together.

Q.- The Government is introducing the crime of illegal immigration in Italy. Many ministers of your Government have criticized my country for implementing a xenophobic policy. I believe there is a difference between the policies of Spain and Italy. Do you think the same as the Spanish press writes every day?

President.- Let’s say there are two distinct issues that I wanted to clarify and that I find important: first, there has been no qualification from the Government of Spain regarding the Italian Government, absolutely, but rather about the risk of certain circumstances that have occurred locally and some popular reactions; second, each country has its laws. Personally, as President of the Government, I have not modified the laws on immigration in the four years I have been in charge of the Government. I have worked with the laws of the previous Government. Why? Because, I insist, I wish the response were to change laws; it would be easy.

Therefore, let us not lose sight of the horizon beyond what one might consider regarding the criminal responsibility of a situation of illegal immigration, because I suppose that when it is done, even if it is nuanced, as a case of a possible aggravation of a penalty, it is done to seek an end. No one can aspire from principles to understand that the color of race or the search for work can be a circumstance that leads to a conviction. No; it is done with an end. Inserting the Penal Code into immigration legislation seeks an end, which is to prevent illegality.

Therefore, the question is: is it effective? We will see. For now, I believe we must have enough prudence to see if it is effective. I convey my experience as President of the Government, because today in Spain we have achieved double the returns and repatriations of immigrants attempting to enter illegally. How have we done it? With politics, with diplomacy, and with cooperation with Sub-Saharan Africa.

Now, each country has its circumstances. As you can understand, I am not an expert in knowing the social circumstances, the volume of legal immigrants, how entries are occurring here… That is not my task. I make an abstract reflection and add: and to collaborate among all European countries, Italy and Spain, because the challenge is considerable. Everyone knows it is not easy, and the leader who, when we have eight hundred million people suffering from hunger in Africa, says it is easy to fight against illegal immigration is not telling the truth to their citizens. It is difficult, but I do have the conviction that, defending principles, of course, of fundamental rights and cooperation, more results can be achieved than by any other means.

Q.- Mr. President, I was going to ask you a series of questions related to the economy in Spain; all are connected.

This morning, on Radio Nacional, the Vice President of the Government, Pedro Solbes, said that his estimate -- this very morning -- for the growth of the Spanish economy was around 2.1 percent. Since the last official growth forecast was 2.3 percent, does this imply a reduction in the growth forecast that the Spanish Government officially makes? That on one side.

On the other hand, the unemployment data that has been released today is the worst for the month of May since 1996, and the Popular Party has already rushed to say that these are the worst unemployment figures in democracy. I would like to know if with these new data we can already talk about a crisis or if we continue to speak of a deep economic slowdown.

President.- I don't know. We can convene a seminar of economists to define the terms of the things that are happening and of the evolution. It is much simpler, and all citizens know it: the economy in Spain was doing very well and now it has stopped growing as it was, and we are in a situation with difficulties. And what I have said these days and today I reiterate: our country has assets, has strengths, and has capabilities to recover, when international circumstances improve, a path of high growth.

We are here and saying it when we are at a Summit to address a food crisis as a consequence of a price increase like the one that is occurring and knowing that oil has doubled its price in the last year, there is no need to go further in what the explanation is.

Regarding unemployment, what is most evident --some always look at the data they look at-- is that today, despite the increase in unemployment by fifteen thousand people in May, Spain has the lowest unemployment rate of the entire democratic period. That is what is happening, fortunately, in the last two years.

It is true that we now have a trend where unemployment, which had been decreasing significantly, down to 8.5 percent, is rising; but always at levels that are among the lowest in democracy. It is worth evaluating the situation we are in.

And regarding forecasts, I believe that what Vice President Solbes has said I fully support. It may be very interesting to discuss whether it will be one-tenth less or one-tenth more; what is important is that we are going to take a new package of measures, as I explained the other day, alongside those we have already taken. By the way, the most important ones are not yet in force because the return of five billion in favor of families through personal income tax will start to be felt at the end of June and, therefore, it is still not an effective measure. But on June 23, I will announce new measures, more structural in nature, for the medium term, to strengthen our growth possibilities.

Q.- Mr. President Rodríguez Zapatero, terrorism has affected both Spain and Colombia and the world, and it is also a cause of hunger. Now, that this FARC-ETA alliance has been revealed through some documents found in FARC computers, what is your reading of this alliance, which is really concerning?

President.- The State Security Forces and the Spanish Justice will logically analyze that data that has appeared and that has emerged from the supposed documentation found in FARC. We must be cautious about the scope of that information, we will be, and it will be evaluated; but, so far, the elements we have on the table advise us to be very cautious in order to work, because throughout the journey of the fight against ETA that Spanish democracy has had with such intensity, some of the information has not always been confirmed. ETA tends to be a terrorist group that for many years has had great distrust in everything it does and, therefore, tends to work very independently. That is the constant. I do not mean to say that there could not have been any existence.

But, in any case, the collaboration, of course, between Colombia and Spain, between governments and between the State Security Forces of both countries, in their case, will be full. I have no doubt about that.

Q.- I wanted to ask the President of the Government if, when addressing the problem of immigration, there is, in addition to what he has explained, a different perspective between the left and the right in Europe, as could be seen, for example, in the last electoral campaign in Spain, where different ways of addressing this problem were raised, and if currently the Spanish Government, within the European Union, has not found itself in a minority situation when proposing, from a leftist perspective, what the way to address the problem or phenomenon of immigration is.

Also, to go to a specific issue, I wanted to know if the five hundred million you mentioned at the beginning would be a supplementary contribution to address the situation generated by the escalation of food prices or if we are talking about programs that were already underway by Spanish cooperation.

President.- First of all, I believe that we should not have a debate around immigration policy about left or right. Of course, that is not the pulse or the climate that exists within the Council of the European Union. And I say this, I believe, from a certain coherent political position because, when I started my task at the head of the opposition, I proposed a pact on immigration that brought together the left and right in Spain. Why? Because it was about the lives of human beings with great difficulties and, honestly, I think that the less partisanship there is in the debate around the phenomenon of immigration, the better we will appear to the world and the better we will be as societies.

That does not mean that, in the face of any phenomenon you address, such as immigration, one does so from principles or from values. I do. In the electoral campaign, I expressed it: I am not going to modify my principles regarding the defense of fundamental rights of people nor in what it means to have a skin color, suffer economic exploitation, or have to leave your home. No, I am not going to change my principles; but I am willing to share measures and policies that are effective, which is what it is about.

Spain has opened a path, and I can assure you that not only are we not alone, but rather, we are looked at for the capacity we have achieved to establish that bridge of understanding and cooperation with many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa, because we are the country in Europe that manages to repatriate the most people.

We have also talked about this with Prime Minister Berlusconi, and he also wants to do it. He has serious problems with some countries. And France also wants to do it. However, you will not see me in immigration policy announcing major legislative reforms; but you will see me multiplying aid for development cooperation, you will see me opening Embassies and Consulates in Africa, and you will see me being the first country to respond, and with more money, to a serious global food crisis.

I said it from the podium this morning: what cannot be is that, with this food crisis and with the inability to cut the increase of hunger in the world, there are OECD countries that reduce their development aid. Spain is not going to do it, it is going to increase it, and now we have economic difficulties; but I am convinced that the Spanish people know that addressing the economic difficulties our country has is as important as trying to prevent deaths from lack of hope of being able to eat in Africa.

Q.- It is a question that seems less important for the world, but it is more important for Poland. It seems that you are a new idol, a new model for the young Polish left. Do you know their leader, Mr. Napieralski?

President.- No.

Thank you very much.