Interview with the Prime Minister in "Financial Times"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

4 June 2008 · Interview with the Prime Minister in Financial Times

Context
Zapatero gave a Financial Times interview on June 4, 2008, discussing Spain's economy, labor reforms, and energy policy amid a global economic downturn.
Main themes
Spanish economic resilience, real estate sector adjustment, labor model and collective bargaining, foreign investment, fiscal surplus and public finances, energy policy and renewables, nuclear energy moratorium, productivity and technological innovation, infrastructure investment, women's employment
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,201
62nd percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

142 sentences in 48 paragraphs

(Translated transcript of the interview conducted by Leslie Crawford)

Q.- In this change of economic cycle, Spain seems to be more vulnerable than other countries, given that foreign investment flows have financed about a third of growth. What can your government do to cushion the blow and encourage continued investment?

President.- We are doing very well in terms of growth. And we are also doing well in terms of overcoming difficulties. Spain continues to generate confidence in the global economic system. Proof of this is the fact that in 2007 we witnessed investments worth 45 billion euros and that we have become the third largest global investor, after the United States and France. All the agencies dedicated to making assessments continue to grant Spain their highest solvency ratings. We are going to witness a significant adjustment in the real estate sector that will involve quite substantial figures. However, we have the strength, more than other countries, to overcome this.

First of all, public accounts are healthy, with a fiscal surplus and a debt level of 35% of GDP, which would be the envy of many. Secondly, we have a solid financial system: our banks have not had any problems during the financial crisis. We have a bank - Santander - that recently announced the largest profits in the first quarter worldwide. Thirdly, there is a prevailing climate of social harmony, with agreements between companies and unions. Fourthly, and thanks to the budget surplus, we are seeing significant investment in infrastructure and productive investment in general. By 2010, we will have more high-speed train lines than any other country in the world. And there is firmness in our ability to use technological innovation to improve productivity, which is the great challenge of the Spanish economy.

We are also very strong socially, as demonstrated by the incorporation of women into employment and economic activity. This has been a great change in Spain and one that we must continue to work on. It is interesting to note that although unemployment is rising, employment among women continues to grow.

We have the will to move forward with more reforms. These reforms will give Spain a greater role in sectors such as logistics, energy, and telecommunications. Another good thing about Spain is that there is no fat in the public sector. There is no dead weight in the economy because basically everything has been privatized.

Q.- May I ask you about the reform process? Are we going to see labor reforms in this legislature? Since business leaders are now calling for greater flexibility in collective bargaining processes, especially due to the difficult operating environment. They want more freedom to set wage levels.

President.- We have a very good labor model, based on agreements between employers and unions. Therefore, I intend to keep this model intact. Our economy must become more competitive by being more open and more capable of competing in sectors such as transport and services and by improving productivity. That is how we add value to the Spanish economy. In my government, workers' rights will not be eroded.

Q.- So, there are no plans to dismantle the collective bargaining system?

President.- No. The parameters of collective bargaining will only change if employers and unions agree.

Q.- So, the people involved will decide?

President.- Exactly. This is the best route that can be taken.

Q.- So, what role will the government have in this reform process?

President.- To promote, support, and accompany the process. This is the best role for any government in a modern and dynamic economy.

Q.- Do you think that the investment rate will drop somewhat this year, given the difficulties both in Spain and in the global economy?

President.- It will probably drop a little. The data from the first quarter showed that within the 2.6% growth, the pace of investment was at healthy levels. Investment in capital goods, for example, was a stimulating 6.5%. The productive sectors remain strong. The automotive sector, which is very important in Spain, grew by about 4%.

Q.- You mentioned earlier the energy sector. It seems that Spain is at a crossroads in this area. On one hand, there are your commitments to meet the emission targets set by the Kyoto Protocol, while on the other hand, there is this government's commitment to a moratorium on new nuclear generation facilities. How do you reconcile this? Will your government have to reconsider the whole issue of nuclear energy?

President.- A bet on nuclear energy would be an easy option, but not the best long-term bet. Supporting the nuclear option would erode interest in renewable energies, which add more value and provide greater momentum for research and development. Our position is very clear: we will maintain our schedule for the closure of nuclear plants, except in exceptional circumstances. However, we are not in favor of promoting new investment in nuclear energy.

Q.- Is this due to your own principles, because of safety and waste issues, etc., or because of Spain's commitment to developing a renewable energy industry?

President.- In politics, principles should go hand in hand with practical options. I have never understood how, once in power, someone can abandon their principles or sacrifice a practical option because it goes against their principles. The world has an energy option, which has been under-exploited, that has been studied little, and that is renewable energy. In Spain, we have been very firm on this, and this must be the way forward. Although it is true that renewable energy is expensive and cannot be done without the support of the public sector, it is an important investment in the future.

Q.- Spain is working on an interconnection with the French electricity grid. If I may be a bit impertinent, is there any difference between a kilowatt of nuclear energy imported from France and a kilowatt of nuclear energy produced in Spain?

President.- No, there is not, except for the future cost of producing a Spanish kilowatt of nuclear energy. However, the point is that the interconnection will also allow Spain to send energy to France, and this could very well be electricity produced from renewable sources. Each country has its options. France has invested heavily in nuclear energy, but it has a lot of water, which is an important component in the process. Spain, unfortunately, does not have that kind of water availability.

Q.- What kind of energy policy does Europe need at this moment? Will Spain have a strong voice in this debate?

President.- There are two principles around which European energy policy must be based: security of supply and cooperation. The first has a lot to do with the relationship with Russia and, in the case of Southern Europe, with Algeria. When we talk about cooperation, it must be cooperation in the area of research and development, at the corporate level. Not all countries can aspire to have national champions, with a short-term perspective on their largest companies and their global ambitions.

Q.- And how should Europe's relationship with Russia be?

President.- It must be a positive relationship, for geopolitical reasons, to ensure stability and balance, and because the European Union must gain relevance in the world. And having a good ally in Russia is a valuable advantage in terms of world order.

Q.- Regarding Southern Europe, it seems that Spain has much to offer the European Union. Its cooperation and assistance policies towards Africa, for example, have been well received. What can Spain do to focus the European Union's policy on the Maghreb and Sub-Saharan Africa?

President.- Everything we have done over the last few years responds to the same idea. We need a Europe with more relevance in the world, and this relevance is achieved through ambition and cooperation. I always say that we do not need a policy on Africa but a policy with Africa. It is the most needy continent in the world, and we must offer it hope.

Q.- Spain has been criticized by its EU colleagues for its liberal immigration policy. More recently, we have seen how Italy criticized it, while on the other hand, Silvio Berlusconi himself has been attacked for his tough immigration initiatives. First, has Spain's approach been misunderstood? And second, is a common European immigration policy possible, given the differences in opinion?

President.- Thanks to experience and dialogue, I believe we have made progress. I would say that in the next four to six years we will be able to consolidate a common immigration policy.

Q.- Starting from where? What will be the main points of consensus?

President.- We must start with legality. That is, one must be on European soil legally. However, at the same time, Europe must always respect human rights. It is the hallmark of the European Union.

Q.- Would Berlusconi's proposal for prison sentences for illegal immigrants violate human rights?

President.- Europe cannot lose its greatness over a few measures of questionable effectiveness. What we need to do is be effective in the fight against illegal immigration. And the most effective tools are cooperation and dialogue with the countries of origin. We are not going to solve immigration problems here (in Europe). We have to do it there (in Africa). Once the problem is here, it is difficult to solve. How are we going to remain indifferent to a continent where 30% of the population lives in absolute misery? How are we going to close our eyes to the fact that we are facing great migratory pressure if we do not change the reality of Africa? If African governments see Europe's effort to help develop the region, they will cooperate by taking measures against emigration and human trafficking.

Q.- If we analyze immigration in Spain for a moment, do you think there are too many foreign workers in the country?

President.- Traditionally, immigration moves by the hope of improving one's economic situation. In Spain, employment has grown enormously thanks to the large influx of immigrants, who have become part of the country's economic development. As economic growth slows, it is obvious that it is necessary to reduce the immigrant workforce. Still, and despite the fact that unemployment is starting to rise, there are still certain sectors of the Spanish economy that can only employ immigrant workers, such as the agricultural sector. That said, the best way to alleviate migratory pressures is by helping to create jobs in the countries of origin.

Q.- During the recent electoral campaign, you promised to create 2 million jobs over the next four years. Given the severity of the slowdown, do you still think this is a realistic goal?

President.- There are still four years ahead. Spain does not shy away from adversity. I still have a lot of confidence in the country.

Q.- Some of the (more populist) measures adopted as a palliative against the slowdown were announced during the electoral campaign. Had it not been for the elections, would your government have considered better ways to spend the money than, for example, offering a one-time tax cut of 400 euros?

President.- In fact, we have the privilege of being able to resort to both types of measures. We are going to return a total of 5 billion euros to Spanish families to help combat the rising prices of food, etc. But we are also going to accelerate investment in infrastructure to help offset the slowdown in real estate construction. We have the money to do it thanks to robust fiscal management.

Q.- It is very likely that, as a result of the slowdown, the construction sector will lose weight in the economy. What sectors do you think will replace it as a driver of growth?

President.- We have two sectors that are doing well, which are industry and services. In the first, we need to improve competitiveness and productivity through innovation, and in the services sector, we need to improve efficiency. We also plan to improve the business environment by reducing bureaucracy. Spain is one of the countries with the most rules and regulations. We need to reduce administrative burdens on companies, for example.

Q.- Second terms are typical moments for heads of government to focus more on foreign policy and less on domestic issues. We have already talked about Europe. How do you see Spain's relationship with a United States led by McCain or Obama?

President .- Until the presidential elections in November, the world is waiting when it comes to addressing major issues such as global security, climate change, and the food crisis. I hope that November brings a new dawn to face the new challenges of the world. The world wants the U.S. to cooperate on issues like Kyoto, geopolitical stability, and dialogue between civilizations. Spanish foreign policy will always reflect the values of its society - a society built on equality and opportunity. It is the kind of world we all have to work towards.

Q.- So you would like to see Obama in the White House?

President .- I like Obama, yes.

Q.- Does a Democratic President mean a closer relationship between Europe and the U.S.?

President .- Europe and the United States are allies, but they could share their goals more.