Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

3 June 2008 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on Basque self-government commitments and rising fuel prices during a June 2008 Spanish Congress of Deputies control session.
Main themes
Basque self-government and autonomy, parliamentary accountability, party program commitments, transfer of competencies, R&D policy in Euskadi, fuel price crisis, support measures for agriculture and fishing, transport sector, coalition politics in Spain
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,304
64th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.0
56th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%55%
  • Institutional 28%27%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Social 3%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

82 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, from the Basque Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, do you know this logo? I suppose you do, right? It belongs to your party, to your party's delegation in Euskadi. Look, this document I have in my hands was approved by you approximately two years ago, when you were already President of the Government. At that time, you presented it in Bilbao, in a grand presentation, with great fanfare, and said that it was something like the roadmap that the Basque socialists proposed regarding the self-government of Euskadi. Well.

This document, titled "More Statute for More Well-being. Bases for the Update and Reform of the Statute of Guernica," on its tenth page includes a specific provision regarding scientific and technical research. It literally states that "there is a pending transfer in this matter" and adds —and I quote it verbatim— "and after the definition of the assumed and unassumed burdens in the area of R&D+i, the corresponding amounts will be allocated within the Quota, deducting the corresponding amounts based on the competencies assumed by the Autonomous Community of the Basque Country in this matter."

The problem, Mr. President, is that just yesterday —not even twenty-four hours ago— the Chamber rejected, with the vote against from your Parliamentary Group, an initiative from my Group that exactly and literally reflected this proposal. That is why I ask the question that is registered: Do you not intend to comply even with the public commitments made by your party regarding Basque self-government?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I appreciate your deep knowledge of the political positions and programs of the Socialist Party of Euskadi. It is a good path for you, without a doubt, Your Honor, and the party you represent to walk down a very appropriate path.

If the problem we have at hand for dialogue between the Government of Euskadi and the Government of Spain, between the Basque Nationalist Party and the Socialist Party of Euskadi, is the scope and possible transfer of competencies in the area of research, I believe it would be a reasonable ground.

I am afraid, Mr. Erkoreka, that we are in another matter; rather, that you are in another matter. Moreover, I regret this because you know, and in these four years we have demonstrated, that our capacity for dialogue, understanding, agreements, and progress in self-government exists. Self-government, not misgovernment.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Indeed, it is a good path, Mr. President, but not for me, as I am from another political party; for you, who are from the same political party, who is your boss. It is a good path for you to know and fulfill, and I come here with your program, with your public commitments.

Regarding other proposals, we can debate as much as you want in this Chamber or outside of it; but I have come here with an initiative that reflects one of your proposals, a proposal, a public commitment made by you before the citizens of Euskadi, whom you are deceiving once again, and you vote here against what your Basque socialist colleagues approve in Euskadi, blatantly disavowing them, Mr. President.

That they were not going to vote for our proposals we already knew; that the proposals agreed upon by us with your socialists will not be included, also. But, come on, for your own proposals not to be approved, gentlemen, is the height of absurdity.

Do not deceive the Basque citizens any longer, Mr. President. Tell them the truth.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I propose an agreement: we scrupulously fulfill the program of the Socialist Party of Euskadi and you comply with and respect the Constitution and the Statute of Guernica.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, the average price of a liter of diesel has reached 1.308 euros; that of gasoline, 1.228 euros; so far this year, automotive diesel has risen by 35.8 percent and gasoline by 12 percent; and agricultural diesel has tripled in three years and is reaching a price of one euro per liter, when in 2005 it was exactly 0.30 euros/liter.

In light of this situation, has the Government planned to adopt any support measures for productive sectors such as agriculture, transport, or fishing?

President.- Mr. Duran, we share your concern. The data you have provided is absolutely correct. I want to remind you that in the last Legislature we already adopted support measures for the agricultural and fishing sectors to mitigate and prevent the effects of rising fuel prices; some of them are still in effect, such as ICO credits. We also adopted measures regarding the transport sector.

Today we have a difficult situation again. We are promoting, within the European Union, together with France, Italy, and Portugal, the adoption of measures to address this situation, especially for the fishing sector.

Regarding the road transport sector, we have agreed with the National Road Transport Committee to establish three working groups that have held ten meetings to date, in which multiple support measures are being evaluated. Among them, I would highlight enhancing the bargaining power of companies in the sector, facilitating the adjustment of prices to costs, and promoting energy efficiency measures.

As you know, we are in that dialogue process, and I hope we can reach a support agreement for the most affected productive sectors by the significant rise in fuel prices, which is undoubtedly having a very negative impact on their economic activity.

Mr. Duran.- I would like, however, for you to specify the measures for this Legislature, not regarding the previous one. The rise in fuel prices —and you know it, and this Chamber is, in any case, a threat, especially to this model of economic growth, but especially for the sectors mentioned. Their viability is threatened in the short term, and in this sense, we should not be surprised by the demonstrations called by the agricultural sector, or the strike called by the fishing sector, or the strike also announced by the transport sector for June 8.

You mention the European Union, and you know, Mr. President, that the European Union not only allows but, in any case, asks member states to adopt concrete support measures for these sectors.

In this sense, therefore, it is necessary that the Government does not cross its arms and adopts measures in the short and long term. In the short term, I will suggest two, Mr. President of the Government: on the one hand, to the extent that the European Union already admits and specifies those measures, adjust the Objective Estimation Regimes of the IRPF and VAT as a concrete measure to reduce the taxation by modules applicable to the sectors of agriculture, fishing, and transport, in accordance with the new structure of expenses and costs as a consequence of the price increases that I previously mentioned and that you found to be in line with reality.

Secondly, the second proposal, therefore, Mr. President, collaborate with the affected sectors, with agriculture, with fishing, and with transport, so that producers, or in the case of transport those who provide the service, do not have to absorb all the cost increases on their own and, therefore, the Administration can help.

Finally, a long-term measure, Mr. President, very important and on which all the priority of our country should pivot: to research in energy savings and efficiency, as well as alternative energies applicable to the mentioned sectors, that is, agriculture, transport, and also what refers to fishing.

President.- Mr. Duran, some of the ideas and measures you have proposed are what the Government is working on in dialogue with the affected sectors. Regarding the European Union, it particularly affects the fishing sector. Specifically, we are studying the adjustment of the IRPF and VAT modules; we did it in the past and we can study it and do it again. We are addressing horizontal measures to ensure the competitiveness of the petroleum products sector and reduce our dependence on oil; certainly intensifying what represents energy efficiency and reducing the exposure of our productive sectors to the volatility of fuel prices.

All these measures, and some others, are in the dialogue process that, fortunately, coincide with some of those you have pointed out here.

We will make every possible effort. The Government's will is clear to support these productive sectors, and I hope we can reach an agreement with them.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, a week ago I asked you here about the situation of the Spanish economy and the measures you were going to take. You did not respond much, except that we were better prepared than anyone. I am going to give you some data that we have learned this week, that is, since last Wednesday: the CPI is at 4.7 percent, 0.5 points higher than in April; the inflation differential with the European Union is at 1.1 percent, 0.2 percent higher than in April; the registered unemployment figure for May is the worst since 1979; the external deficit increased in the first quarter by 19.1 percent and today it is 11.3 percent of GDP; today the OECD in its forecasts says that Spain will grow by 1.6 percent this year, less than the average of the European Union.

And there are many more data in these seven days about retail sales, car sales, mortgage formations, or the tourism sector. I will not go into it, as there is no time, but I will tell you one thing: the confidence of Spanish companies and families is at a minimum, and you seem not to be aware of it. That is why I have to ask you what you are doing, what you are going to do, and what you think about all this, because it seems that you do not care, but the Spanish people do, because we are talking about their lives, and that is very important.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I believe it is not advisable to ignore the difficulties nor to exaggerate them. The Spanish economy has had a cycle of high growth, it has had a period of great job creation, and now, fundamentally due to international circumstances, we have a process of deceleration and loss of the capacity to create jobs that we had.

But the Spanish economy has, beyond the cyclical data, which I could have provided others, such as the positive data on investment in capital goods, or the industrial production data that we will have, the Spanish economy has important assets: the first asset, sound public accounts; the second asset, a solid and strong financial system, thanks to the good management of the Bank of Spain, our banks, and the financial system; it has twenty million people working, which we have never had in a period of deceleration; and it has, above all, a capacity of its entrepreneurs and workers to know how to work and move forward in a situation of more difficulty or less difficulty.

Confidence in our economy is reflected in the data on foreign direct investment. In 2007 we had 43 billion euros, a record; and in the first three months of this year, 2008, 3.5 billion euros, after a disinvestment in Spain of 600 million in the first quarter of 2006.

There is confidence in the world about the Spanish economy because it has made a good journey, and I assure you that we have known how to grow the economy very well and create a lot of jobs in Spain. We will know how to face this difficulty, move forward, and see how Spain grows strongly, because that is the spirit and attitude of the Spanish people, of entrepreneurs, and of workers.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, I am not asking you as a commentator; I am asking you as a ruler who has to make decisions.

Look, there is no confidence in the Spanish economy, but I am not saying it; I will give you data from these seven days: the latest CIS survey says that 46 percent of Spaniards see the economic situation as bad or very bad, nine points more than a month ago; the Consumer Confidence Indicator from the ICO fell by 7.4 points in April, and Eurostat's Economic Sentiment Indicator fell by one point; it is the worst data since 1993. And you are in phrases, talking about pessimism, optimism, and you even said, very recently, that maybe we need to hold a seminar among experts to see if we are in crisis or in deceleration.

But that is not the issue; the issue, Mr. President, is that you have to say how to face this and how to remedy this situation, because you are the President of the Government of Spain. Families and companies are having a very hard time and do not want comments, jokes, or quips; they want measures and want you to behave like a ruler and make decisions. That is the issue.

President .- Mr. Rajoy, you should not rely so much on the polls. I think it is not good.

Let’s look at the real data: confidence and the rating of the Spanish economy remain positive in the international context. What is the Government doing to help families? Putting five billion euros into their income with the reduction of four hundred euros in personal income tax, increasing minimum pensions, housing assistance, maintaining the investment pace in infrastructure, in R&D+i, and fostering social dialogue and social concertation. What we are not going to do is…