Press conference of the President of the Government at the Desk of the Congress of Deputies.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 October 2008 · Press conference at the Desk of the Congress of Deputies · Congress of Deputies

Context
Zapatero addressed journalists at the Congress of Deputies on October 20, 2008, discussing Spain's role in global financial reform talks amid the international financial crisis.
Main themes
Spain's inclusion in international financial summit, reform of international monetary system, G-8 and G-20 membership, Spain-France bilateral coordination, Sarkozy proposals on EU sovereign bonds, international financial crisis response, judicial independence in Spain
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,983
75th percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
8th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

130 sentences in 56 paragraphs

P.- I wanted to know if you had spoken with the French President, Nicolas Sarkozy, and what he said to you.

President.- Yes, I have spoken with President Sarkozy, who always holds Spain in high regard and works in very close collaboration with the Government of Spain. We have had very intense coordination in recent times.

We have been exchanging opinions on what the most appropriate format should be to hold an international summit on the reform of the international monetary system. I believe that President Sarkozy is absolutely sensitive and understanding of the importance of Spain's presence.

In any of the formats being considered, which have not yet been decided, as you know, nor the date of the meeting, in my opinion, Spain must be there. Furthermore, I believe that this opinion is shared by President Sarkozy and, in my opinion, there should also be the presence of an important Arab country, because it is usually a geographical area that is not typically represented in major international forums.

Consequently, we have talked, we have exchanged opinions, and we have agreed to continue talking, as is logical, and I explained to him that Spain, in my opinion, due to its economic weight and what its international financial system represents, must be at that great International Summit called to reform the international monetary system.

P.- President Sarkozy spoke this morning about the reform of the G-8.

President.- He said something that is true. He did not organize the G-8 in his day, as is known, nor does he decide for the G-8, as is evident, because, as its name indicates, there are eight countries.

On this, I wanted to reflect. Spain has never been in any of these major international conclaves: either G-7, G-13, or G-20. This is the situation I have encountered. I believe this will change, and in my opinion, there are objective reasons for it to change, due to Spain's weight.

You will always hear me say that I have not fought to be in the G-8, even though we are the eighth largest economy in the world; but when there is a meeting, nothing less than to address the reform of the international monetary system, and with Spain being the eighth largest economy in the world, and having a very powerful and solid financial system, Spain must be there for objective reasons, and in my opinion, the objective reasons are making their way.

P.- Has President Sarkozy committed to defending Spain's presence?

President.- President Sarkozy is very sensitive, as I just said, to Spain and to the objective arguments. He has done very well in his work regarding Europe's role in the eurozone in the face of the international financial system crisis, and I am convinced that he will do very well in his work for the convening of this international summit.

P.- President, this morning President Sarkozy launched an interesting idea to present at this summit: to issue sovereign bonds from the European Union to prevent large national companies from falling into the hands of other sovereign governments that are now taking advantage of the low stock prices. What do you think of that proposal?

President.- I think it needs to be studied. From this crisis of the international financial system, we are drawing useful and positive lessons, such as how developed countries need external financing from other countries or how, for example, the functioning of the Eurogroup, at the level of leaders, of countries, needs to be reinforced, in my opinion; and, of course, many conclusions about the reforms that strictly affect the international financial system or, rather, the weakness of the international financial system because, if there had been a proper system for what the international financial market represents, we surely would not have seen a crisis as severe as the one we have witnessed in recent weeks.

P.- What did you think of the judges' attitude today?

President.- I have great respect, as President of the Government, for the judges of this country. They fulfill their jurisdictional function, they have a constitutional mandate of the utmost relevance, and they do so with absolute independence, which is guaranteed constitutionally and which all powers respect scrupulously.

It is true that the law teaches and the judges apply the law, and they know better than anyone that there are times when there may be decisions that do not please certain groups and that the instruments of reaction are guaranteed in the legal system. An appeal is made when a citizen has a judicial resolution with which they do not agree and appeals. There is a system of guarantees. The same happens when it affects a secretary of a court, or, in their case, a judge.

We have a broad system of guarantees, and perhaps it is worth remembering, for citizens and for any activity they carry out, including, of course, that of judges and that of officials of the Administration of Justice.

The work carried out by the General Council of the Judiciary, as the body that governs the judges and has disciplinary responsibility, must be a task respected—of course it should—by all; it should be respected. And also in this country, freedom of expression exists regarding the decisions of a body such as the General Council of the Judiciary, which is not jurisdictional.

You know that my view as President of the Government is that the Government must be very respectful and not assess, not comment on, the resolutions of jurisdictional bodies. And believe me, some of them would be worth discussing! But I think the Executive should have that attitude. My opinion is different when resolutions from the General Council of the Judiciary are produced, which has a completely different constitutional nature from that of exercising jurisdictional function, that is, issuing judgments.

P.- President, if I may return to the previous topic, are you aware that if this summit is held and Spain is not there, the criticisms will be directed at the Government you lead?

And, if I may also ask, have you spoken recently with Gordon Brown, who was the main supporter of Spain's presence?

President.- And if Spain is there? The answer is that the other question can also be asked.

I have explained it: I fulfill my duty, and my duty as President of the Government of Spain is to assert my country. Until now, it had not been achieved, and with this, I do not want to criticize anyone, because you know that these groups, once consolidated, tend to be static, permanent, and it is very difficult to enter and very difficult to exit. This is how it is. It happens with the G-8, just as with other groups.

My duty is to work for Spain to be where it should be for what it represents as a country, where it deserves to be and where it can also contribute ideas to a matter of such significance as the crisis of the international financial system. And I will do this with arguments and reasons. Certainly, in my experience in the field of international relations among serious and friendly countries, reasons carry weight and matter.

P.- Besides the need for Spain to be there, perhaps it is also necessary for other institutions to take on more importance. When you said that more prominence should be given to the Eurogroup as such, could that be a way for Spain to...?

President.- No, no; they are different planes. Spain is already in important international bodies for the supervision of the financial system. But here we are talking about a summit that has a kind of... It is a constituent summit and a constituent summit for the reform of the international financial system, which will likely determine for decades how the rules are played, in a globalized world, regarding the movement of investment capital among all countries. Therefore, it has extraordinary importance.

For those of us who believe in international relations, in rules, and in the possibility of governing things, reforming and changing what the international financial system represents to make it fairer, first of all; more transparent, more for the citizens and less for the interests that often go unseen, and making it more for the citizens means making it more accessible and more controllable by governments and institutions; it has great importance, and I must ensure that my country is there. If we succeed, it will be a merit of the country; if we do not succeed, obviously, I already know what will happen.

P.- President, which Arab country are you thinking of?

President.- I believe that as the current balances are established, in addition to the weight and importance of the different formats (G-8 plus G-5, which is G-13, or G-20; I will not enumerate the countries because it would be endless), there does seem to be a certain gap in the existence of an Arab country, because there must also be a certain territorial perspective and that the entirety of the continents, and therefore all latitudes, do not feel excluded from this summit, which will be a first summit. Logically, given that it is such an ambitious task, as I have just described, and a constituent task, it will have to develop in various phases with many meetings over a certain period; although, in my opinion, we should hurry, because the sooner we establish the foundations of the new model, the more security we will give to the markets.

Look, and I said this yesterday from the podium, at the paradox we are experiencing: the markets do not trust the markets. And governments, the public sector, must ensure that the markets regain confidence in the markets. This is the situation.

P.- What did you think of Mr. Rajoy's intervention in this debate?

President.- An opposition intervention, just like the one from a year ago, two, three, or four; the same.

The opposition I have seen from Mr. Rajoy always has the same tone, similar content, and I get the impression that this may be useful for a certain strategy; but, in my opinion, it lacks a dose of substance, constructive; constructive and concrete, because it must be said, if an alternative to the Budget is presented that consists of less income, what expenses are going to be cut. But we must talk about specific items.

He says: "we must reduce the current expenditure of the Executive." From the current expenditure of the Executive, what should be reduced? The fuel for the cars of the Civil Guard and the Army? That is current expenditure; they are the large operating items of essential public services. What should be reduced in expenditure? What are the items that are not shared from the perspective of social spending or infrastructure? This is having an alternative; the rest are mere rhetorical flourishes, criticism for the sake of criticism, which he can certainly do, and he has been doing for years, to the Budget and so on.

But, getting to the heart of the matter, I believe that the Budgets have two essential components: one, to maintain the functioning of the major public services: security, defense, and social policies, which for me is also security, national security: pensions, scholarships, housing assistance, birth assistance…; and, two, productive impetus: infrastructure and R&D+i. Those are the two major decisions of the Budget and having the prudence to ensure that the deficit is a reasonable deficit, in a context where the deficit will be a common note in most countries because, when we have a situation of such a loss of economic momentum, we must make an effort in public budgeting. If we were to make a choice to cut public spending now, what we would simply do, apart from harming social policies, would be to bet on recovering our capacity for economic growth later.

P.- President, has President Sarkozy explained to you if there is any country that wants the format to be limited to the G-8?

I also wanted to ask if he has discussed the issue with Gordon Brown.

President.- No, I have not spoken with Gordon Brown, but you know his position, which he conveyed to me quite some time ago and which he reaffirmed at the European Council meeting.

It is likely that there is no country that opposes. What happens is that, having already established formats, when it comes time to open them, we know what happens. I understand this perfectly. A door is opened for there to be a demand from many countries. This is logical and happens at all levels; it happens in international relations and in any type of political relationship. There are established formats that are classic: the G-8 and the G-20.

What have I proposed? I have proposed that, given that this summit is about the international financial system, Spain's economic weight and role in the financial system is more than evident for it to be present and play a relevant role. I have always proposed this, as I try to do, in terms of reasonableness.

And I emphasize that if there is any political leader in Europe who is sensitive to Spain and to Spain's arguments, it is President Sarkozy. This is what I have observed since we coincided in our mandates, since he became President of the French Republic. Therefore, he is making efforts and will continue to do so, without a doubt.

President.- Spain contributes, among other reasons or arguments, one very powerful one: that we have the regulation, the supervision, and the institution, the Bank of Spain, which has delivered the best results so far for the solvency of a financial system. I said it graphically yesterday in the debate we had: we have seen financial giants, colossal entities, fall, and we are seeing how even our smallest Savings Bank survives. This is another argument. Therefore, we have things to contribute and things to say.

The Government has been working on this issue for some time, and we want things to be done well, in an orderly manner. Why? Because the European Commission has created a high-level group to put ideas on the table for the reform of the international financial system. A Spaniard will be in that group, and therefore, we want the proposal to be a European proposal, to have a European document, because that will give it all the strength to move forward in that direction. If we come up with twenty-seven proposals, they will surely dilute and have much less impact.

We will work with the Commission, and we are already working with the European Commission, providing ideas, suggestions, so that this high-level group concludes with a work that represents the roadmap for the reform of the international financial system; although, without a doubt, many other countries will contribute.

Q.- There is a pending promotion of a G-8 reform. What can be known about it?

President.- Who decides the reform of the G-8? Of course, no one takes responsibility here. I said a moment ago that I found myself in this situation. There has been a G-8 for a long time, by the way, and these things are difficult to change. But when there is an event of this nature and a circumstance of this nature, the one who is truly the eighth economic power in the world cannot remain silent.

There is also a G-20, which was formed in 1999, and I have never understood why we are not there. But we know that these things are sometimes difficult to articulate. What I want is to change this situation; I want to change it. I want to assert Spain's weight with all our friends in political and diplomatic terms, because, moreover, allow me to say that there is a broad understanding, because people know what Spain weighs in the world today.

We will try. No battle is won if it is not attempted.

Q.- I wanted to know if, after facing the problems of the financial system, facing now the first Budgets of this Legislature, with so many total amendments, it does not give you vertigo.

President.- And do you really think this is a quantitative problem? I think there has been some Group that has presented a total amendment that would be eager to support the Budgets. I am fully convinced of that.

In any case, the Budgets are expected to have sufficient support. The Government has a political capacity for dialogue and to reach agreements with practically all the Groups in the Chamber, except with the main opposition party which, as has been seen today, does not seem very enthusiastic about that idea. Therefore, we will work with full confidence.

What I want to tell the Spaniards is that all the economic measures, those we have taken for the financial system, those contained in the Budgets, or those we may continue to implement at the right moment, will have the solidity, security, and confidence that we demonstrate day by day with parliamentary support.

Q.- (Inaudible)

President.- The Vice President is a serious person, he gets to the economic issues and does not usually waste time on the excesses that this type of debate tends to accompany political leaders.

I believe that Vice President Solbes has rigor as a standard of operation, and it seemed to me, because I could not see the second reply… By the way, I just left the hemicycle, I know that Mr. Rajoy made a reference, but perhaps sometimes before speaking one should ask to speak with Mr. Sarkozy, because he had scheduled the time to talk with him, and I left, just to not interrupt, to wait for his call. But it seemed to me I heard, because I was waiting for the call, that Mr. Rajoy brought a reply, once again, quite elaborate. So, he has listened little to Mr. Solbes.

Thank you very much.