Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 October 2008

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on tax fraud, the underground economy, and regional financing during a government control session in Spain's Congress on October 14, 2008.
Main themes
Tax fraud prevention, underground economy, public revenues, economic crisis response, regional financing, banking crisis intervention, autonomous communities funding, social spending, tax compliance, government spending priorities, wealth inequality in taxation
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,462
67th percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
38
32nd percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.57
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%61%
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

75 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- I refer to the question, the terms of which the President of the Government already knows: What actions will the Government undertake to combat tax fraud and the underground economy, in light of the current economic crisis and the consequent decrease in revenues, to increase the resources available to meet social needs and regional and social financing?

President.- Mr. Ridao, as you know, the Government has taken on the objective of combating tax fraud and the underground economy since the last Legislature. In February 2005, we approved a Tax Fraud Prevention Plan; a year later, in March 2006, we approved the Tax Fraud Prevention Measures Plan, which represented the regulatory specification of the Government's position; we have increased investigative resources, with specific programs related to operations involving high-denomination banknotes, 500-euro notes, or for fiduciary structures that conceal the true owners of investments. The actions have doubled since 2004, reaching 1,313 in 2007 from 649 actions in 2004.

The results are very positive: three and a half years after the start of the Plan, there has been a notable improvement in compliance levels, with tax revenue growth far exceeding that of GDP. The accumulated result during the years 2005, 2006, and 2007 amounts to twenty billion euros in revenue from control actions and voluntary regularizations in the tax field. Twenty billion euros is a lot of money, and it is enough to compare it with the figures being discussed these days.

But we agree, and I imagine that is your intention, to continue with the effort, and for that, we are working on the Tax Fraud Prevention Plan, which we hope to have ready soon. This update will revolve around two major areas of action: promoting voluntary compliance and controlling risk areas.

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President of the Government, your Government's slogan is that since there is a crisis, there is not a euro. We will not deny the crisis nor the consequent decrease in public revenues, but it is also true that there is not a euro depending on the purpose, because in a few weeks we have gone from a Government that said the financial market should self-regulate to a Government that has put up to 150 billion euros of public money to address the banking crisis. That is a cost, by the way, much greater than the cost of regional financing in 2006, which was 110 billion euros.

You excuse yourselves with the crisis to avoid addressing the real spending on regional, local financing, dependency, or immigration, and even launch trial balloons with the aim of controlling the health spending of the Autonomous Communities, projecting even a false image of an altruistic State, of a State that is a good manager, and of Autonomous Communities that, for their part, are something like an insatiable leech that squanders public resources.

You have said that you will take advantage of the crisis to clean up the economy, and in the meantime, you insist on squandering six billion euros with the four hundred euro tax rebate and are going to spend 3.5 percent more on personnel. You yourself have 644 advisors and a budget of 48 million euros, Defense is going to spend seven times more than on dependency and twenty-five times more than on immigration. Furthermore, you do nothing to tackle an underground economy and tax fraud that, no matter what you say, is 23 percent of GDP, according to ten international organizations. For some reason, we are, after Greece, the second in the entire European Union in terms of tax fraud, with ninety billion euros that are not collected each year. And the most important thing is that 70 percent of the resources of the Autonomous Communities depend on the good tax management that you carry out.

Spain, no matter what you say, is the country in the world where workers and employees pay more than employers: six thousand euros on average in income tax; Spain is the country where large properties are declared in wealth, 700 taxpayers for 3,300 large owners; where fourteen billion euros are laundered and where 500-euro notes proliferate, which is 70 percent of the...

President.- The truth is that the path to end up talking about regional financing has been a bit labyrinthine. To start from 500-euro notes and tax fraud to get to that...

This country has built an increasingly effective Public Treasury. This Government has managed to put twenty billion euros more into the public coffers in the fight against tax fraud, which is an amount equivalent to what we are going to pay for unemployment benefits, which is a major social policy this year.

This Government has improved regional financing by injecting for financing...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, last week the Governor of the Bank of Spain appeared before the Economic Commission and, among other very judicious and reasoned points he defended, he stated that to face the international financial crisis that afflicts us "the financial entities that wish to survive, as he said, will have to seek ways to strengthen their structures that will inevitably include, mergers." I believe this assessment is indisputable, but I wanted to gather your opinion on it.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, it is evident that our financial system has known, since the transition to now, numerous processes of mergers, integrations, and restructurings, as usually happens in all business areas and, in particular, in the financial system.

It is evident that, when there is a moment, like this one we are living, of serious crisis, it is likely, not only in Spain but in other countries, that situations of merger or restructuring will also occur, within the wide range that exists.

It is no less true that, as we have stated, the Spanish financial system is in good health. The facts are quite evident: it is one of the few developed Western European countries where no financial entity has gone bankrupt. But, logically, the Governor of the Bank of Spain rightly points out that this hypothesis is probable and that, logically, if it occurs, with the natural impetus of the entities themselves, we will have to collaborate to have a more rationalized, more effective, and more competitive map of our financial entities, without, logically, as you can understand, the President of the Government pointing a finger at any specific one.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, I am glad that you subscribe to this point the postulates of the Governor of the Bank of Spain which, on the other hand, are not new or original. They are practically shared in a generalized way by economic and business agents, and by all European and community financial and monetary authorities.

Precisely for that reason, it is surprising, and very surprising, the attitude that your socialist colleagues in the Basque Country are maintaining regarding the merger of the Basque savings banks, because they are not only opposing the merger of those savings banks outright, but they are also embarking on extensive advertising campaigns aimed at aborting those that are already underway, those that are in project.

Look, I have here a press dossier, which if you are interested I can make available to you, that highlights this campaign. For them, the circumstances are never right to undertake a merger that now, in these times, in the critical situation we are living, is more necessary and more urgent than ever. They have also resorted to all kinds of excuses to defend their theses. They first told us that the proximity of the municipal elections made it impossible; then came the consultation; after that, the general elections, and now it is the regional elections.

The fact is that they always reject the merger, always, and they do not want it either at three or two. What has been proven to be a good operation in other territories of the State (in Andalusia, in Madrid, in Galicia, or in Catalonia) turns out not to be valid for the Basque savings banks, for which some special and singular economic norm must apply.

Mr. President, please tell them that the thesis of the Governor of the Bank of Spain also applies to the Basque savings banks and that the merger will also be good for them; and tell them because the voice that comes from Madrid is for them like the voice of God.

President.- I thought that your question and your intervention were aimed at the global reflection of the financial system, more at this moment, and that it was, therefore, driven by a general interest. I have noticed in the development of your question that it had a much more concrete direction and a much more limited interest.

In any case, I reiterate --more limited, I have not said anything more than that-- what our position is. The processes of merger and restructuring among financial entities, in this case of savings banks, can make sense; they have already occurred and we will surely see more in the future; perhaps now, this moment accelerates it and they must be done well. Of course, with consensus, respecting the plurality of what the merging savings banks may be, and, in any case, through various modalities: there can be processes of dominant integration or there can be strictly contractual integration processes; there is a wide range. Of course, these things do not usually go well if they are attempted to be imposed. I believe it is reasonable to combine efforts and energies in the financial system, but not to impose...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, everyone, including you, says that Spain is going through a serious financial crisis.

You have announced measures to alleviate the situation of Banks and Savings Banks as much as possible, and I have expressed our willingness to support them, because we are in a certainly exceptional situation.

However, I have demanded two things: that these measures also serve small and medium-sized enterprises and families; and that there be transparency and control, because it does not seem reasonable that 150 billion euros, that is, twenty-five trillion pesetas, remain in the exclusive hands of the Government and the Ministry of Economy and Finance. That is why I have requested the intervention of the Bank of Spain, that is why I have asked for greater control instruments, and you have said that you find these requests correct and that, in addition, you will agree with the Popular Party on the decrees for the development of the Royal Decree Law.

Since the aim is to provide confidence, I would like you to commit here, in this Chamber, because I believe this would be good for all Spaniards.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as we had the opportunity to discuss yesterday, the Government wishes, makes the effort, and will make every effort so that the two Royal Decree Laws to support the financial system, which is the same as supporting the economy of companies, families, and the whole country… If we are in a plan of understanding, I remind you, because that is the objective!

Therefore, as the Government understands that it is good for the country that those measures have the maximum parliamentary support, especially when it comes to measures that have had the support of the entire European Union, the Government is fully in agreement to establish control mechanisms that have the greatest guarantees, that the Bank of Spain plays a decisive role, that there is more parliamentary control than we have proposed, and of course, that we agree on all the fine print of the regulatory development required for the implementation of this measure.

I believe that is positive to reassure the financial system, so that it feels stronger and more supported, and, of course, so that all citizens have the absolute tranquility that the public resources that will be committed, not to subsidize, that will be committed, to guarantee or to lend to financial entities, will be, of course, and will count on all the guarantees of what should be a democratic system when it comes to the public resources of citizens.

Mr. Rajoy.- This Chamber has heard your words, and I hope that you will act accordingly.

However, Mr. President, apart from there being a financial crisis in Spain, there is a real economic crisis, that of families, that of companies, that of unemployment, that of mortgages, and that of prices. You have not made any important decisions in that regard, and the ones you have made seem to me to be in the wrong direction, because in this time when we are debating a lot about the financial situation, about our financial economy, about our Banks and Savings Banks, you have made a decision that is to raise the gas tariff by 9.6 percent when the National Energy Commission recommended an increase of 5.1 percent.

You, in a crisis situation like the one we are experiencing, have increased gas prices by 20 percent this year. This harms five million Spaniards and benefits two Spanish companies. If we add to that the increase in electricity prices between 11 and 15 percent so far this year, you will understand that your measures do not precisely contribute to alleviating the situation of Spanish families.

I would like you to explain why gas prices have risen by 20 percent this year and why you have not addressed the requests of the National Commission on Energy, and I would like you to tell us why, in addition to addressing the situation of financial entities, which I agree with, you do not address the needs of small Spanish businesses and families.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, it seems you forget that the price of oil has risen, and what it has risen, which fortunately is moderating. Mr. Rajoy forgets that the Government has frozen the price of the butane cylinder, which undoubtedly has the most impact on social groups with less purchasing power. Mr. Rajoy forgets that this Government, in this situation, has decided to raise minimum pensions by 6 percent, which you did not raise in any situation. He forgets that this Government has decided to raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, that it has not frozen the salaries of public employees, that it has increased scholarships and all social policies thinking of families and citizens with lower income.

That is what he forgets and what he never says...