Press conference of the President of the Government after the Summit to review the status quo of the international financial system

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 November 2008 · Summit to review the status quo of the international financial system

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference following the G20 Summit on the international financial system held in Washington on November 14, 2008.
Main themes
International financial crisis, global economic coordination, financial market reform, economic reactivation, IMF and World Bank reform, fiscal stimulus measures, financial supervision and regulation, transparency in financial markets, tax havens, emerging economies, Spain's recovery plan, international cooperation
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,830
84th percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
15.1
76th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

130 sentences in 63 paragraphs

President .- Good afternoon; good afternoon or good evening, depending on the country.

I would like to comment on the meaning of this international Summit that has focused on how to face the crisis of the international financial system and the economic status quo.

I will make an assessment in the first place. I think that this Summit has been very positive, because we have attained the two goals it had to attain, in my opinion: in the first place, it has served to pin down the Governments that represent 95% of the gross world product; in the second place, it has served to enhance the eagerness to cooperate and to attain consensus, because in order to overcome the current situation and resume economic growth, order and stability it is necessary for all countries and for the largest world economies to cooperate constantly. This has pervaded at all times during the summit and, thus, I think that it has been a very positive summit.

The conclusions include four main ideas: the conclusions included in this document, agreed on unanimously, and the political conclusions that have been taken into account during all our discussions.

First conclusion: commitment to attain economic reactivation. If it was the financial crisis that generated the current situation, at present, our main concern is world economy and its difficult prospects.

Thus, the Governments that attended the Summit have committed to promote economy and demand in the economies of the different countries by implementing fiscal measures, mainly through productive policies, that is to say, through investments in research, development, innovation, infrastructures and energy.

Those measures must be coordinated in order to be efficient. The unanimous conclusion of this summit has been that specific, individual country answers are hardly efficient. The largest world economies must coordinate their answers, just as happened when we started to recover from the collapse of the financial system, a recovery that started when the Eurogroup made a coordinated, firm decision last 12 October.

Thus, the first great goal is the economic reactivation. Let me remind you of the fact that the European Commission will put forward an action plan to reactivate economy in Europe next 26, a plan that will add up to the existing actions and plans implemented by the different European Governments, which we will analyse during the next European in December. And let me remind you of the fact that next 27, in the Parliament, I will explain citizens the recovery plan that will be implemented in our country in order to reactivate economy, a plan that will be coordinated with the European Union and with the other 27 EU members.

Second, unanimous conclusion: it is necessary to reform the operation of the financial markets; it is necessary to reform them in order to guarantee order and safety in the financial markets and not to substitute them, I repeat it, just to guarantee order and safety:

- Guaranteeing order and safety means that there must be rules and that these rules must substitute discretionary decisions.

- Guaranteeing order and safety means that there must be transparency in the activities carried out in the financial markets.

- Guaranteeing order and safety means that we must set limits to the activity of fiscal paradises, which - in my opinion - must disappear; limits to the qualification agencies; limits to the incentives granted to certain compensations; it means that it is necessary to give pre-eminence to corporate social responsibilities, to the good management of both companies and financial entities; and this must also be taken into account in order to qualify the activities of financial entities.

- Guaranteeing order and safety in the markets means that it is necessary to implement an efficient supervision, as the one implemented in Spain, which I referred to yesterday during the supper with the leaders that attended this Summit, that is, a supervision that may serve to control the activities carried out by banks on the spot, a supervision that may develop more guarantees to face risks, a supervision that may guarantee greater permanent solvency in banks. A supervision that may guarantee order and safety.

Third goal: the reform of the institutions that form part of the international financial system, namely, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. What should be the goals and aims of this reform? It should be aimed at providing greater legitimacy and capacity to the International Monetary Fund and to the World Bank, which have been asked to keep increasing their activities in the meantime by the leaders attending the Summit, and to do it quickly in order to help those economies that are facing difficulties, the emerging economies and those that are facing an even worst situation and cannot defend themselves against this wide-scope international financial crisis. This greater legitimacy of financial institutions must match the economic reality in the world, where emerging countries are progressively becoming more representative.

Thus, this must be the task, the goal of the reform of the International Monetary Fund and of the World Bank, apart from a greater capacity: greater resource capacity, greater prevention capacity against risky situations and, therefore, a more influencing role in the development of the international financial system.

Finally, fourth shared conclusion: we, the countries that represent 95% of the Gross Domestic Product, have committed to do away with protectionist measures. It would be a great mistake for us to establish protectionist measures, forced by the economic difficulties and by the difficulties of the international financial system. In fact, we think that the soon culmination of the dialogue process to guarantee market liberalisation that is taking place at the Doha Round will help economy. An explicit mandate has been issued so that the Ministers of Economy may reach a global agreement to close the Doha Round by the end of the year.

These are the four main great ideas that we all shared, four ideas that represent 95% of the gross world product.

In my opinion, the expectations for economic recovery and to fight the risk of a generalised recession as well as to guarantee the progressive recovery of the international financial system are greater today than one week ago, because this Summit has brought about certainty and agreement. It has brought about a set of reforms, which will take some time, of course, as everyone can understand, for it is the international financial system and the institutions in charge of managing that international financial system we are talking about.

In my opinion, we have three urgent tasks to do now. The main priority for us is for those measures that we have implemented in many countries, those measures that involve public resources and that are aimed at guaranteeing the operation of the financial system, to start yielding results. The situation has improved, but it must still yield further results. Thus, the Government, represented by the Vice President and Minister of Economy, is going to set up a constant dialogue with the Spanish financial entities in order to favour and motivate liquidity, which we are starting to recover, for we must recover it, so that it may also be a way to enhance credit recovery.

In the second place, as I have just said, we are going to work intensely in order to coordinate the actions implemented to reactivate economy in the European Union, with our partners, taking into account the next Summit in December, a Summit that in my opinion is going to be very important.

Journalist.- Mr. President, you have said that you though that this Summit had been positive. Spain has attended an international Summit at last. I would like to ask you whether you know if Spain is going to take part in the subsequent meetings of the G-20 or of the G-22, as Brazil seems to have proposed.

President .- We have been working with our European partners, as a country, in order to prepare this Summit; bringing ideas and explaining the importance of Spain as the eighth largest economy and as a country whose financial system works, a country whose financial system has proved to be efficient.

We are going to keep on moving in this direction and, as I have already said, they must recognise our contribution and our work. This first step has been a very important step for us. It is the first time Spain takes part in such a transcendental Summit and we will keep doing things well in order to consolidate our position. For we are working to serve Spain and to serve Europe and the whole International Community, because I think that we can contribute, that we can propose interesting experiences and, mainly, we have the willingness and we are determined to work with the others.

This Summit and the orientation of the answers provided have served to prove that a certain vision of these first years of the 21st century is imposing, a vision that has to do with multilateralism and with the joint efforts of the different Governments and regional institutions, institutions such as the European Union.

In this sense, it is in this direction that Spain and my Government have always worked and we feel at ease because we are sure that this is what the challenges we are facing demand, challenges that must be faced, challenges we cannot avoid. I said it during my speeches, I said, literally, that the financial crisis was very serious, but I also said that poverty, hunger and extreme poverty in the world were even more serious and we cannot forget about these matters. Thus, observing the Millennium Goals is for Spain a priority, an essential objective, and I have said this at the Summit, as well as the fight against climatic change.

The reform of the financial system, the reactivation of economy in Spain, in Korea, in Brazil or in any other country and the fight against climatic change need global answers that must be provided by countries, Governments and institutions. And today the different Governments, the different ideologies and the different continents have learnt that that is the only way.

Thus, this is the way Spain is going to work on as any other.

Journalist .- Two questions. I take it that the fiscal policy intended as a stimulus for economy will involve lower taxes, to say it bluntly. I would like you to confirm this. Are you going to lower taxes?

Then, has the G-20 asked Spain to carry out any specific task? Does Spain form part of a work group? Is there something we must do?

President .- The development of the programme, the action plan, will depend on Brazil, which presides over the G-20 this year, the United Kingdom, which will hold the presidency after next 1 January; and Korea, which will be presiding it next year. Of course we will be at the disposal of these three countries for anything they deem adequate; Spain will be ready to contribute and take part in those actions they deem necessary.

Fiscal policies are a matter of a wider scope, that is, they involve the contribution of the public sector through the use of public resources to the reactivation of economy and to the enhancement of demand. Let me tell you that our country, our Government, has already been implementing an important fiscal policy, reaching nearly fifty thousand million Euros between 2008 and 2009; public resources that have been devoted to citizens, families and companies. And fiscal policies involve, of course, the acceleration and increase of productive investments, which are the most solid factor to fight a situation of economic recession or stagnation.

But we must keep observing our postulates. The efficiency to face a situation of future recession in the European Union must be guaranteed by a coordinated action. This is what we are going to focus on, until the next EU meeting, next December, a meeting between the Governments and the Commission, which will play a leading role. In my opinion, important, essential initiatives will be put forward then. I have already mentioned some, but some of them are going to be especially important for our country, namely, the actions intended to support the vehicle industry, which are going to be set forth by the different EU Governments and by the Commission. And there is another one, one which will depend on the Commission, of course. And today I have had the chance to comment on it with the President of the Commission, Durao Barroso, and with the Commissar of Economy, Joaquín Almunia.

Journalist .- In spite of your optimism as far as the analysis of the conclusions drawn during the meeting, your communiqué is rather generic. When you talk about coordinated policies to promote reactivation and growth, what specific coordination mechanisms have been foreseen or discussed, because the document does not mention them?

As to the reform of the operation of the financial system, have you considered the possibility to create an organism or regulatory commission, as had been said at some point, as a specific way to regulate or modify the operation of the great financial institutions?

President .- As to the first question, the document that contains the conclusions is rather specific, in my opinion, rather technical, and it provides in-detail information. It includes dates, not just for the next Summit, but also for the different actions that must be developed over the next few months.

Coordinating fiscal policies. There are two essential instruments: first, as I said a while ago, is the measure implemented by Spain, namely, lowering taxes, which provides families and companies with more resources; and, second, the increase of investments. These are the two great instruments.

The different Governments are implementing all these measures. And it is necessary to coordinate them as much as possible, because, I insist, we are convinced that if they are coordinated they can be more efficient.

In particular, I was yesterday talking to the president of the International Monetary Fund and I we were commenting on a fiscal incentive, an increase of public expenditure, an increase of one or two points of the Gross World Product would result in a growth of the Gross World Product, a growth of one or two points, with the maximum coordination.

China has just announced a great plan to encourage demand, the European Union is going to coordinate those efforts and, surely and logically enough, each countries will implement adequate measures taking into account its own circumstances. The whole idea is that by enhancing demand in every particular country should benefit the rest of the countries and this can only be done if we all implement measures in this direction in order to promote investments, trade, consumption and demand.

We are going to do this at a European level, taking into account that China has announced an important set of measures in this direction, taking into account that the United States, whose Government is about to change, will also do it and, thus, the Governments of the countries that represent the greatest percentage of the Gross World Product will be following a clear direction to favour demand, turning the public sector into a leader - in this specific situation - of the economic activity. We must wait and see what are the actions implemented by the European Union.

As to the supervision, the document states that it is necessary to improve it, to coordinate it, but it also states that we must wait for its specific development.

I think that we are going to move on fast as far as the coordination of regional supervision is concerned, as well as at the level of European supervision, while the coordination of the supervision at higher levels, that is, at the international level, will move on slowly.

Journalist .- You talked about the aids for the vehicle sector and you said that there won't be protectionist measures, how can that be?

I would also like you to make an assessment about the proposal put forward by Barack Obama to devote 700,000 million dollars to the banks in order to rescue the vehicle industry, which was something President Bush did not want to encourage during this Summit.

President .- Let's wait for Barack Obama to enter upon office as President and let's wait for him to announce the economic measures in his action plan. But with regards to the vehicle sector, I think that it is necessary to wait for the announcement of the Commission, the announcement of the action plan which will not include protectionist measures. I think that a sector that is undergoing difficulties must receive long-term aids, mainly, taking into account the productive activity and taking into account research, development and innovation.

But this has come to prove that protectionism is not a solution for almost anything; quite on the contrary, it complicates things more in the medium ter. This has also been assumed by the different Governments.

There are many experiences in this sense and if the vehicle sector is undergoing difficulties due to the reduction of the demand, we must prepare the sector and make it more productive and cover new demand domains, which, surely enough, will be found in many markets, for our vehicle industry -both the Spanish one, of course, and the European on-is highly competitive.

Journalist .- Mr. President, a couple of questions.

Firstly, did you comment on responsibilities? For you sort of mentioned it at the beginning, but it seems to me you've forgotten it now.

Secondly, out of curiosity, what did you feel while that photograph with President Bush was being taken and what is your opinion about the picture with all the leaders this morning at the National Building Museum - the most important thing in today's Summit, in my opinion - ?

President .- I have felt courtesy. I have already said that in such meetings, when you are with a leader, with the President of a country, you must be courteous, and, by the way, this has been the attitude of the President of the United States at all times, I must stress this. As you all know we have had many dissensions, yet, he has kept up a courteous attitude during the meeting, and I must recognise this.

The photograph with all the leaders is a transcendental issue. It will be remembered in the future and let's hope it will be remembered as the moment in which things changed. We brought order to chaos, we brought safety to the financial system, which was characterised by the lack of safety and confidence, and we worked in favour of a fairer, more balanced international order as far as the relevance of the emerging countries and the fight against inequalities and poverty are concerned.

Now it is Governments that must attain the goals set up here today, with the strength of 95% of the Gross World Product, the great world economies and the emerging economies, working together, which is what really matters…

As to the responsibilities, nothing has been said. But I can tell you that even though this is a specific matter as far as the reform of the norms of the financial system are concerned, in my opinion, we must open a debate and implement more measures to help citizens and to contribute to the relationship between citizens and the financial system. W must set up a category of citizenship rights with regards to the financial system, a sort of charter of rights, which, in fact, has to do with transparency, information and training.

One of the main problems citizens must face at present is the difficulty to know and understand most of the financial products and the consequences derived from using them. I think that transparency is not just intended to bring tranquillity to investors in the different markets, to let them get acquainted with the different products or to let them know the risks derived from the different financial products; transparency, in my opinion -and we must work on this-is something that will benefit citizens and their relationship with the financial systems. This would be a new citizenship right, the right to receive correct, faithful, understandable information.

Journalist .- President Sarkozy has just attended a press conference and he has said that Spain will rather surely attend the subsequent Summits about the crisis. I would like to know whether you have been told anything of the kind during the different conversations you have held.

Then, it seemed to me that you were talking about the supervision system implemented by the Bank of Spain during last night's supper. I would like to know whether you have talked or not during the plenary session and why.

President .- Well!, I was trying not to repeat things, for, if you must make two or three speeches, you cannot say the same all the time.

I always trust Mr. Sarkozy. I have nothing else to say, and I would like to thank him once more for his zeal, his praiseworthy determination, because Spain is an important economy. We have a great weight as far as the financial system is concerned, we have solid banks and, mainly, we want to work and find solutions. This is what we have been doing so far and we like to do this in particular in the European Union, cooperating with our European partners, because together we will be stronger.

Journalist .- Something related to what you have just said. Since you trust Mr. Sarkozy, I would like to know whether you share yesterday's comment of Vice President Fernández de la Vega, who said that "Spain has come out from the corner of History", or whether you'd rather wait and see what happens in further meetings of the G-20.

President .- What I really want right now is to overcome the economic crisis, I want citizens' confidence on the future of economy to increase day by day, I want the Government to work hard over the next few months and I want this collective efforts we must make to contribute to the recovery of economy next year and to employment creation.

This is my goal right now and I have said more than once that in life, in general, it is the way people and countries are seen by the others that counts, it is the recognition of the others that counts. This is what I consider important and, as to this Summit, knowing that the work carried out by Spain over the last thirty years has been recognised and knowing that its position at present has been recognised is the most important thing for me. What we must do as Spanish citizens and what I intend to do as President of the Government, is keep on proving to the International Community that we are worth it, as a country, that we can make great contributions and that we can work together, this is what we want, and nothing else.

Thank you very much.