Press conference of the President of the Government and the Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

17 June 2010 · Press conference of the President of the Government and the Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund · Madrid, Spain

Context
Zapatero held a joint press conference with IMF Managing Director Strauss-Kahn in Madrid on June 17, 2010, to discuss Spain's economic reforms and outlook.
Main themes
Spanish economic reform, IMF assessment of Spain, fiscal deficit reduction, labor market reform, financial system restructuring, eurozone stability, stress tests for banks, pension system reform, services sector liberalization, energy sector reform, economic recovery and growth, public spending consolidation
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,712
90th percentile
Sentences
155
82nd percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
14.8
75th percentile
Syntax
3.50
94th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

155 sentences in 73 paragraphs

President.- Good morning. I believe I recall that it was on May 21st when I had a telephone conversation with Dominique Strauss-Kahn regarding the latest report that the International Monetary Fund made about the Spanish economy, its situation and its prospects, and about the reforms that it deemed appropriate.

That telephone conversation was extraordinarily enriching and useful for me, and I invited him to come to Madrid to delve deeper into that conversation about the Spanish economy, about the situation in the eurozone, and, in general, about the world economy, the situation of the markets, and the monetary system. Dominique Strauss-Kahn kindly accepted that invitation. He has fulfilled it, and we are here today.

We have had a very interesting conversation about the economic outlook, about Europe, about the markets, and about the financial system, and I had the opportunity to explain to him what Spain is doing to emerge strengthened from the crisis, to recover growth potential, to address the fundamental problem of creating jobs again, and to maintain and preserve our financial stability, thereby contributing to the stability of the eurozone.

I explained to Dominique the plan that I had the opportunity to present in Parliament on December 2nd and the compliance with the reforms and measures that the Government is implementing; a plan that, as you will recall -- I will summarize briefly -- included the Fiscal Deficit Reduction Plan, which we intensified in May through a Royal Decree Law with strong adjustment measures and sacrifices for citizens, especially public employees, and the Restructuring Plan for the Financial System, which is about to be completed, to ensure the strength and solvency of our financial system -- the Governor of the Bank of Spain will report on it on the 30th -- to which is added, as a result of the commitment made the day before yesterday by the Governor of the Bank of Spain himself, the proposal to conduct a stress test of all Spanish financial institutions once the restructuring process is completed, which, as you know, will also be done throughout Europe after the debate at the European Council.

It also included the reform in the area of the pension system, which, as you know, is in Parliament under the Toledo Pact, with the document that the Government has already sent to the Chamber, and the labor market reform, which the International Monetary Fund has always considered fundamental and which is already in force with the Royal Decree Law approved by the Government, which must be validated next week, on the 22nd, and which represents the most significant change, the reform, in the labor market that has occurred throughout the democratic period, with a considerable opening to internal flexibility and external flexibility, and with a strong commitment to employment stability.

Finally, I also informed him of other reforms that we have been carrying out and that we need to complete in the services sector, opening our services sector much more to competition, and of the reform that we need to undertake in the energy sector to ensure an adequate cost of energy that favors the economy and industry, as well as the plans related to education and vocational training.

This has been the content of the information I provided to Dominique Strauss-Kahn. Alongside this, we discussed yesterday's meeting of the European Council and, of course, I conveyed the decision, the full determination, of the Government of Spain to implement, to make effective, each and every one of the reforms we have initiated, to demonstrate that Spain can overcome this crisis emerging with a renewed and strengthened economy, and thus also contribute to the recovery and growth potential of the European Union.

In short, reforms, stability, confidence, and a deep gratitude for all the advice, suggestions, and reflections that I always find to be among the most insightful when I listen to the Director of the International Monetary Fund, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, and you can imagine that I hear many opinions about the economy and economic prospects, especially in the last two years.

Thank you very much, and I believe we will move directly to the questions.

Q.- Can you confirm what some media outlets have said that Banco Santander and BBVA have ranked at the top in the "stress test" conducted by the European authorities? I don't know if you can confirm that for us.

And, for both, what is the likelihood that fiscal consolidation in Spain will lead the economy back into recession?

President.- Regarding the first question, logically, the information about that "stress test" must come from those who conducted it, and it was not conducted by the Government of Spain; therefore, I cannot confirm or deny it. The authorities that conducted it must report on it.

Secondly, regarding fiscal consolidation and growth, fiscal consolidation or the reduction of public spending, if we get the reforms right and if the reforms have the strength we expect and generate sufficient confidence, should not affect the economic recovery and, therefore, the maintenance of the growth we have had since the first quarter, even if it is very slight growth.

Mr. Strauss-Kahn.- Good afternoon. I regret having to address you in English, but I believe it is better because, although I am not an English speaker, my English is quite better than my Spanish.

I am here at the invitation of the President of the Government. I have been traveling through Central Europe a few weeks ago, then I was in Germany; a week ago I was in Brussels and Luxembourg, two days ago in Paris, yesterday in Rome, and today in Madrid. I am traveling a lot through European countries because, evidently, there is a concern about growth. When we see the recovery, we see that it is happening very quickly in Asia, in Latin America, and it is not going badly in the United States, with a growth rate a little above 3 percent, but in European countries, in general, growth forecasts remain between 1 and 1.5 percent, and that is where we need to work with governments to try to promote greater growth. And this is the reason why I have made this tour of European countries.

Evidently, many countries, not only in Europe, have fiscal problems after the crisis; it is natural. And, contrary to what is often said, these fiscal problems are not related to the stimulus packages, but to the economic crisis itself.

We have conducted a study for developed economies and have seen that, comparing what was happening before the crisis and after the crisis, the average debt-to-GDP ratio rises from 80 percent to 120 percent in 2014. Of this 40 percent increase, from 80 to 120 percent, only 4 percent is due to the stimulus packages, and the rest is due to the fact that, because of the crisis, there has been a drop in revenues, increased spending on social coverage, for example with unemployment benefits, and more money that had to be injected in some countries for the rescue of the banking sector. And the conclusions of all this are that without those stimulus packages the crisis would have been deeper and more prolonged, and, in fact, the debt ratio would have grown more.

Even so, there has been a very significant and serious increase in debt in some countries, such as Greece; everyone knows that. There have been other countries that are in an intermediate situation, like Germany or France, and other countries that are in quite a good situation, even in terms of debt, and I refer to Spain, where we know that it has a debt ratio that has increased, as in all countries, but which remains among the lowest.

However, there was some concern about all European economies, in general, and efforts need to be made. And I find it very positive that most countries are taking initiatives. Some need to do so more quickly, because they really need to address a significant deficit, and the decisions that the Spanish Government has made are very welcome and I believe they will be tremendously effective. The result, of course, depends on the execution. It is not just about making the decision, but it starts with making that decision, and I am sure that the implementation of these measures will allow the deficit in countries like Spain, and others as well, to be reduced quickly.

Other countries had a bit more fiscal leeway, like France, Germany, and others, and are carrying out more gradual processes starting in 2011, which is positive because it will allow European growth to consolidate and continue to increase in 2010.

So the message, the fundamental conclusion, is that fiscal sustainability must be established, but at different paces depending on the situation of each country.

Of course, not only fiscal reform is needed, and what President Rodríguez Zapatero has said about the results of the "stress test" of the banks is very important. We must not forget that the crisis originated in the United States and, moreover, in the financial sector. Therefore, there are still pressures on the financial sector.

Thus, when conducting these "stress tests" and deciding, as the European Council decided yesterday, to publish the results of each of the banks, it is important for there to be total transparency, which is absolutely crucial because, if no one knows what risks exist in the various banking sectors and who owns what risk, the situation of confidence will not improve. And it must be said that most banks are in a very good situation; some may have a small problem and it may be necessary to inject some capital. But I am sure that the European Council will be able to do that if there is no major problem.

But to regain confidence, it is important to tackle the deficit, fiscal reform, but demonstrating the solidity of the financial sector is equally important, and that is why the results of these "stress tests" are so important.

Regarding growth, it is possible that some of these fiscal restrictions may slow down growth a bit. It is absolutely necessary to have a sound public sector, but that does not necessarily drive growth by itself.

What about growth? That is where, depending on the countries, because each country is in different situations, measures must be taken to promote growth, and here the labor market reform is absolutely crucial. I will not list all the measures that have been taken, but certainly, I believe that this labor market reform is fundamental because a more efficient labor market is needed. It is very important to combat unemployment rates, which have increased much more in this country with the crisis than in others, so clearly, there was a need to focus on the labor market here.

Everyone knows perfectly well what needed to be done, and the measures that the Government has decided are absolutely in the right direction; which, of course, is a reform that must be implemented and must go through the parliamentary process. Even if it has come into force immediately, it must go through the parliamentary process, and we will see if that program of measures can still be improved during the parliamentary processing.

In any case, I find it absolutely crucial that the effectiveness of the labor market in Spain is increased. And in doing so, in my opinion, the Government is not only trying to solve immediate problems but is laying the foundations for two decades of growth in this country, because the growth potential that Spain has is enormous, as has been demonstrated in the last ten years, to the surprise of many. Spain has been the country of the movida, it was the country that was talked about the most, and it was the best example of growth. Now there are difficulties, of course; everyone has difficulties, and we must overcome them.

But, really, the measures that are being taken, although they can always, of course, be improved further, are decisive and crucial measures. And I truly believe that if they are implemented well, and if people understand them, they will be of enormous utility.

Of course, any effort has its price, but if everyone understands that it is absolutely necessary for the Spanish economy to take these measures, the potential of that economy for the next decade will truly be realized, and growth will recover very quickly.

I have a lot of confidence, and that is the first message I wanted to convey. The first is that fiscal efforts must be made everywhere, in all countries, in different ways; and the second message is that I have truly enormous confidence in the medium- and long-term prospects of the Spanish economy, as long as, of course, the efforts that need to be made are carried out, and, from what I see today, those efforts are underway.

I wanted to discuss with the President, with José Luis, the forecasts of the Spanish Government, how they are going to implement those programs and the political difficulties because, of course, it will not be easy to take these measures; but the Government's commitment is full to move forward, and I am sure that all of this is being done clearly to benefit the Spanish economy.

The last thing I would like to say is that I am very struck by the fact that in many countries in Europe, governments of the right, left, or center are acting and making efforts, sometimes in very complicated political contexts, because they have a clear vision of what they need and what is best for their countries. This is an excellent example that politics is not only as it sometimes seems or as public opinion or the media say.

Politics has to do with the future of a country, and what we are currently seeing in Europe, in Spain and in other countries, is true political leadership and a vision of what is truly important for the future of those countries, without trying to evade the political impact that the difficult and tough decisions they are making may have. Many of these decisions have already been made, and perhaps others will need to be made in a year, two years, who knows; but, certainly, it is clear that the correct decisions are being made to move forward.

That is what I wanted to comment on.

Q.- For the President of the Government. Yesterday, in the Declaration that was signed at the European Council, it was expressly stated that "all States are ready, if necessary, to adopt additional measures to accelerate fiscal consolidation." I would like to ask you what other measures can be adopted in Spain.

In this regard, I would like to know if you have considered the possibility that the proposal that the Government presented in the Toledo Pact may have to end up becoming a Decree to reform pensions. In any case, what timeline do you give to those parliamentary discussions before having to intervene?

President.- Regarding the first question, it is a recommendation that is always in the Conclusions of the European Council. The Government does not contemplate, after the measures adopted for deficit reduction and fiscal consolidation, which include the spending ceiling for the 2011 Budget, new measures.

We understand that the process of consolidation and deficit reduction will yield positive results in 2010, and that the planned measures, which are already effective because they have been approved by Royal Decree Law, will also achieve the objective of reaching 6 percent of the public deficit.

What remains to be confirmed depends, to a large extent, on the Autonomous Communities. The Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy has given a favorable response to the part of deficit reduction that corresponds to the Autonomous Communities. I appreciate that all of them have committed to their responsibility in reducing the deficit, and as of today, we do not contemplate new measures.

Regarding pension reform, the Government has sent the document to Parliament. It is known that we are now in a process of appearances by senior officials and social agents, and, as is traditional, in the reform of the Toledo Pact, the Parliamentary Groups must seek an agreement. I would like that work to be expedited, to be as quick as possible, but the Government does not seem to be the one that should set the pace for Parliament; rather, it is usually the opposite, it is Parliament that sets the pace for the Government.

Certainly, the Socialist Group will do everything possible to accelerate the reform. We must be in full discussion of the reform and in a position to have the Bill -- it will be a Bill, it will not be a Decree, that is for sure, because we believe that this matter is very necessary, but not as urgent as deficit reduction can be, because we are talking about reforming the pension system with an eye on the next fifteen, twenty, or thirty years; it will be a Bill, and we hope that this Bill has the maximum consensus.

We understand that talking about the sustainability of our pension system in the medium and long term requires a great consensus, although, as is known, the Government maintains its known positions regarding the reform.

Q.- I had two questions for the President of the Government. One, it seems that there is widespread consensus this morning that yesterday the Government emerged from a difficult situation and did so in an angry manner by forcing the publication of the stress tests and gaining support for Spanish credibility from Europe, after a week in which there have been quite a few attacks and very harsh ones.

I would like your reflection, especially on that specific fact, having emerged from the quagmire, and whether you believe that Spain should still be on alert, as new attacks could be possible. In any case, where do you see the origin of these attacks that we have seen in recent days, those rumors or ideas that have circulated questioning Spain's credibility?

And, if I may joke, is that emerging from the quagmire also extendable to the national football team next week?

Then, as a second question, the labor reform, it seems that it will finally be processed as a Bill. Does the Government have this situation under control or does it believe it can manage it so that it does not end up becoming a labyrinth of amendments that prolongs over time, given that the Government itself has also said that it would like to get that labor reform out as soon as possible?

President.- I will start with the last one. The Government always contemplated that the Royal Decree Law on Labor Reform would have processing as a Law. This has been the case in the vast majority of cases where labor market reforms have been made, and, by the way, reforms of less scope, less magnitude than this one.

We understand that it is a matter that requires and advises having the process of amendments and discussion; but we also understand that this process of processing as a Law must be as quick as possible, and if we have to work during the months of July and August, we will have to work. We need the labor reform, with sufficient parliamentary processing of amendments, debate, dialogue, and negotiations, to be approved as soon as possible, definitively, to guarantee security and to, as the Director of the IMF said, if it can be improved, and undoubtedly the contributions of the Groups can yield that result, improve it.

But, if we have to work in July or August to definitively approve the labor reform, certainly, the Government is in favor.

Regarding the first question, the European Council yesterday and the information, it is true that we have been observing and experiencing since early May a strong pressure on the expectations, strength, and solvency of Spain. Economists say that, in the end, the fundamentals prevail, that is, the objective data over rumors. I have confidence in that. I have always defended the strength, confidence, and solvency of Spain, and all the measures we are taking and the initiatives are to reinforce that confidence.

The publication of the stress tests of our financial entities is the response to seek more confidence. There is no better recipe for generating confidence than transparency.

And, certainly, the reforms we are applying, especially in these months, are also the result of the conviction that a decisive action is required, planned since December, and that we must culminate practically before autumn begins so that the entire framework of reforms and initiatives is clear.

Where do rumors and sometimes comments come from? I am not worried that rumors arise, as there will always be rumors about many things; what worries me is that attention is paid to rumors over objective facts. That is what is relevant.

The European Council yesterday was important because we made a decision by common agreement on the transparency of our financial system which, as the Director of the IMF recalled, is the origin of the crisis: the American financial system, but from there it also spread to Europe. And what we wish for the Twenty-Seven -- certainly, this is my opinion -- is that we address the issues affecting the Twenty-Seven as a great collective project and with a forward-looking vision; a great collective project, which is the European Union, and with a forward-looking vision.

Therefore, it is not appropriate for us to be focusing only on the short term at a given moment; what is appropriate is that we put that vision of the future, and that implies, in my opinion, that if we strengthen European politics and if we strengthen European political union, we will strengthen the capacity for economic growth and prosperity of the European Union.

In the uncertainties about the eurozone, beyond the data from some countries, there is also the political strength of the European Union; the determination to, after having a single currency, move towards a common economic policy and to do together, not only the stability of the financial system and not only the common currency, but the policies to improve competitiveness, growth, and innovation.

As for the football team, even the best have a complicated day. But I still maintain the bet that they will be in the World Cup final.

Q.- I have a question for the Director of the International Monetary Fund and another for the President of the Government. To the Director of the IMF, I would like to ask if he has received similar invitations to visit Portugal and how he sees the situation in Portugal, which is often compared to Spain.

And, continuing with the previous question about those rumors, despite all these measures being taken, the debt of these countries continues to be penalized in the markets and the euro continues to be penalized. What more needs to be done?

For the President of the Government. You have talked about the reform of the pension system. This week the Portuguese Secretary of State was here in the Toledo Pact Commission and presented a bit of the reforms that Portugal made in this area. There is talk of the issue of pension calculation and there is the sustainability factor, which Portugal has introduced. Do you think that Spain can import some of the experiences that Portugal has had in this pension system reform?

Mr. Strauss-Kahn.- Regarding Portugal, I would be delighted, of course, to visit Lisbon at any time. I unfortunately have 186 members of the Fund and travel continuously. I cannot be everywhere. But, of course, I would be delighted to visit Lisbon as soon as I am invited to Portugal.

The situation is not the same, fundamentally because, as I said before, the level of public debt is much lower here than in Portugal, and, moreover, private debt, household indebtedness, is much higher in Portugal. So the situation is not comparable at all. Although there are many cultural and historical ties with Portugal, in this case the situations are not comparable at all.

Measures have been taken and, as you said, sovereign debt continues to be penalized. It is true that there are still very high spreads, but, however, in this last auction, which took place yesterday, a few hours ago, the results were excellent. The spreads are a bit high, but the coverage is excellent, and moreover, those spreads have decreased in recent hours, so the markets do not always, as we know, reflect the reality of the economy. Sometimes they are a good indicator, but they are not the only one, and I would not be surprised at all if over the next few days or weeks the markets evolve differently.

However, the decisions that have been made are the correct ones, and we must convince the markets to restore confidence. It is not only about fiscal measures, but also the labor market and everything else.

On the issue of penalizing the euro, there is much talk in Europe, especially among companies, that it is very good to have the euro at the current exchange rate. I have to remind you that I was Minister of Economy in my country when the euro was established, years ago, and it initially came out at 1.17 dollars, quite below the current exchange rate. And at that time what was intended was to reflect, more or less, the long-term average.

Therefore, what is very impressive and must be evaluated very carefully is the speed with which the euro has moved, although lately not so much; in recent days, yes. A few weeks ago, those sharp fluctuations demonstrated a lack of confidence. But now we are at a level that for many European companies and for many European exporters is a much more favorable level than when the euro was at 1.50 or 1.60.

One more comment on this aspect. I understand, and it is absolutely normal, that most of you focus on Spain, because that is your job; but let us try to have a slightly broader perspective and think that there are many other countries, because we are still in a crisis, that are facing difficulties.

I started this small intervention by saying that recovery is faster in Latin America and Asia, and that is true, but there are many countries that continue to experience the consequences of the crisis, and it would be a miracle, totally impossible, that only two years after the most severe crisis we have experienced, if we think of the date of the collapse of Lehman Brothers as the start of the crisis, although that is not entirely true; two years or two and a half years after that crisis occurred, everything would be as it always was, fully recovered and without any difficulties. It is perfectly natural that there are problems.

What is expected is that this crisis will serve as a positive opportunity to change things for the better in all countries, in different ways, according to the different situations. And here, I want to emphasize it once again, what is being done in the different areas, including in the labor market, is something that will help the Spanish economy in the long term and for many years to come.

President.- Regarding the debt differentials, it is true that yesterday, as the Director of the International Monetary Fund said, the debt issuance was very well covered and today there has been a decrease in pressure. In my opinion, the timing of the publication of the "stress tests" of financial entities will be very important for all European countries. The credibility and solvency of how the restructuring of the financial system is being carried out will be a determining factor for the markets, and we trust that the cessation of rumors will also help to bring calm to the markets.

In relation to pension reform, logically, the Government has been aware of and has evaluated, and undoubtedly also in parliamentary work, all the pension reforms that have been made recently in Europe and also, of course, that of Portugal, which contains some interesting initiatives that I am aware of.

Thank you very much.