Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

26 May 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on May 26, 2009, addressing regional participation in EU institutions.
Main themes
Autonomous communities participation in EU institutions, Spanish federalism and regional competencies, EU Council of Ministers representation, common fisheries policy in Galicia, CAP reform and dairy quotas, Spain-EU institutional relations, Senate reform, regional autonomy versus central government
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,545
68th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
15.5
80th percentile
Syntax
3.52
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 81%79%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Economic 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

81 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Xesús Jorquera, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, what is your Government's willingness to allow the Autonomous Communities to negotiate directly in Brussels on matters related to their exclusive competencies?

President.- Mr. Jorquera, as you know, the European Union is a union of States, and representation before that institution is channeled through the General Administration of the State, which represents the whole nation, Spain, the Spanish State. That is the reality applicable in Europe and in Europe.

However, it is a reality that has not prevented the Government from opening important avenues for autonomous participation in the Council of Ministers of the Union itself. Thus, in 2004, the Government agreed with all the autonomous governments on a model of autonomous participation; a model in which, in the meetings of the formations of the Council corresponding to competencies that are more clearly autonomous (Agriculture and Fisheries, Environment, Employment, Social Policy, Health, Consumer Affairs, Education, Youth, and Culture), there is a representative of the Autonomous Communities who can integrate into the Spanish delegation and also participate in the preparatory working groups; an essential element of that model in which the participating Autonomous Community does so in the name and representation of all the Autonomous Communities, defending, as Your Lordship well knows, a joint position agreed upon in dialogue with the other Communities and fully integrated into the Spanish delegation.

This model began to be used in 2005. It has been fundamentally incorporated into the new statutory texts, and in just four years, the Communities have participated 126 times in the Council of Ministers. They have coordinated their positions with the State without exception and have been able to intervene verbally, by the way, on occasions in Catalan, Galician, and Basque.

In short, this is the position and the path, which we understand to be correct, that is being responsibly and usefully utilized by the Autonomous Communities, without prejudice to the improvements and developments that the practice of the system itself may advise in the future.

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, we do not deny that progress has been made in recent years, but from our point of view, there is still much ground to cover. While in Spain the mechanisms for the participation of the Autonomous Communities are very limited, and always from a subordinate position to that of the central Government, this is not the case in other States with European positions. And I remind you that the Autonomous Communities are also a State.

This is the case in Germany, where the participation, as you know, of the "länder" in the formation of the will of the Federation is channeled through the Bundesrat. When matters discussed in the European Union affect the exclusive competencies of the "länder," the position of the Bundesrat is decisive, and often the representation of the Federation falls on a member of a regional government. And it is the case in Belgium where the regions have the possibility to represent and commit the representation of the Belgian State.

The Autonomous Communities, as I said, are also a State, and in the next five years in the European Union, many matters that affect the interests and exclusive competencies of the Autonomous Communities will be addressed. This is the case in Galicia, for example, with the common fisheries policy, a sector for which harsh adjustments continue to be announced; a sector that has marginal importance for the Union but represents almost 10 percent of our GDP in Galicia and employs nearly twenty-five thousand people. And it is the case of the CAP reform and the review of quota policies in the dairy sector.

From our point of view, it is necessary to continue regulating production rights. It is not logical that Galician farmers have had to incur debt to acquire quotas and be in a position to compete only for the rules of the game to change halfway through. But it is also necessary to correct the imbalances. It is not fair that the quota assigned to farmers in the Spanish State is significantly lower than the needs of internal consumption, and this is generating massive imports of milk that are driving the sector to the brink of ruin.

We aspire for the Government to defend these interests in the Union, but it is also necessary for Galicia and the Autonomous Communities to sit more decisively at the negotiating table.

President.- Mr. Jorquera, I appreciate your acknowledgment of the progress that has been made. I do not rule out that new avenues may be explored. You indirectly refer to what may be a reform of the Senate, which we have talked about many times; but, in general, I must remind you that the Government seeks to involve the Autonomous Communities in the formation of the will before the European Union. And, of course, on the issues you refer to, which affect Galicia in a significant way, we will do so...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, I assume you are aware of the deep concern that currently afflicts public opinion regarding the proper management of public funds and, more specifically, regarding the adequate regulation and management of conflicts of interest between elected officials and members of the Government.

This type of conflict, Mr. President, can only be effectively addressed if two things are guaranteed: control and transparency. And we have the impression that your Government is failing in the second, in transparency. Some of the questions that the deputies of my Parliamentary Group have been asking your Government in recent months to inquire about specific situations of some members of your Cabinet have encountered responses that are not just opaque; they revel in opacity.

Mr. President, not only is the information we request denied to us, but they hide behind responses in lapidary, formulaic phrases that serve equally well for a broken situation as for a mended one. The archetypal response is: "the minister or minister X complies, has complied, and will always comply with the Law." These are not ways to respond in the times we are living in, Mr. President.

Public opinion is eager to ensure the transparency of public officials, especially regarding conflicts of interest. The Chamber has asked you to reform this situation, and that is why I am asking you the question.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, as you know, the Law regulating conflicts of interest for high-ranking officials was a law, initiated by the Government, as a commitment to transparency and public dedication that no one had dared to undertake until then.

Through the law and its subsequent regulatory development, we have taken a step forward, guaranteeing to the maximum objectivity, impartiality, and independence in the performance of the functions of the members of the Government. You know that the Law enshrines the principle of exclusive dedication; increases the transparency of the remuneration regimes, eliminating certain perceptions such as attendance at boards of directors, governing bodies, etc., and strengthens control over the patrimonial interests of high-ranking officials. To this end, the Activities Register is public, accessible to any citizen, and the Register of Assets and Rights, while reserved for obvious security reasons, is accessible to the Chambers and the Investigative Commissions created therein, as well as to judicial bodies and the public prosecutor's office.

Furthermore, we have fulfilled the obligations established by the Law by sending the semi-annual reports of the Office of Conflicts to Congress, and in accordance with the recent approval of the regulatory development of the Law, in October, the declarations of assets of the members of the Government will be published in the BOE.

We believe that the assurance of the rights of deputies and senators referred to in the motion is already guaranteed in the Law and that, of course, in compliance with the Resolution, we will study, as you have hinted, the possibilities of reinforcing those rights. I understand that the right of parliamentarians to request the data contained in the Registers of Activities and Assets exists and is recognized at the highest normative level. The publicity regarding the activities of high-ranking officials has a general scope, and while that of their patrimony is more restricted, it is, in any case, accessible to Congress, as explicitly stated in the Law.

That is the right path. In any case, Mr. Erkoreka, I take your suggestion into account, and of course, in those parliamentary questions that may be related to this, although it is not the normal channel, because the channel is established in the Law, the Government will seek to provide all possible information.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, I know the Law perfectly and its development, but that Law that is in force is not preventing these displays of opacity to which I was referring earlier. That is why the Chamber last week urged the Government to carry out the necessary reforms to ensure full transparency, also towards the deputies who have every right to know that information, as public opinion demands.

Hiding data from the Chamber, Mr. President, is not the best way to address the problems related to the conflicts of interest of high-ranking officials of the Government, for two reasons: because, if there is nothing to hide, it is simply absurd to raise unfounded suspicion, and if the intention is to hide something, when irregularities come to light, which sooner or later will, then we will be subject to a double reproach: for the irregularities and for having tried to conceal them.

That is why, Mr. President, there is a parliamentary resolution that must be complied with, and there is a public interest that must be satisfied.

President.- I have reminded you who promoted this Law as a testimony to the progress that is being made, which is the greatest in democracy, in the transparency of the actions of public officials of the Government, in any case. Of course, we will address what the Resolution says and what you have conveyed in this question...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, in the last State of the Nation Debate, the Chamber approved by majority, with the vote against your Group, that you fulfill your commitments, those you assumed in this Chamber, and the decisions that this Chamber made, which is very justified, because you, in the investiture debate, announced a countless number of commitments that you have not fulfilled: reforms, for example, in Social Security, in Justice, in the General Administration of the State, in autonomous financing, in local financing, etc., etc.

You have not fulfilled anything, and that is why there is very little work on Thursdays in this Chamber. Tomorrow, in fact, there is no Plenary. But, in addition, you are governing using the route of Royal Decree Laws. There is no Plenary because no Bills are presented, and furthermore, the route of Royal Decree Laws is being used; you have presented more Royal Decree Laws than laws. Moreover, all the Resolutions that are approved in this Chamber, some with the support, even, of your Group to avoid being defeated, are not fulfilled.

So, Mr. President, I have to ask you if you are going to start governing, if you are going to stop making announcements, and, above all, if you are going to fulfill the announcements. For example, are you going to fulfill the announcement of the Code of Good Governance?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the truth is that the Government does not decide the activity of the Chamber. In any case, I do not know if you are speaking for some deputies; specifically, I can assure you that there are many deputies and Parliamentary Groups who work tirelessly to represent citizens and do a good job before society as a whole.

Secondly, we have had a State of the Nation Debate in which a balance of the Government's work and the fulfillment of commitments is made, and I must tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that the Government maintains its commitments stated in the investiture, which, as you well know, correspond to the Legislature as a whole and are concretized, as we have seen, in various legislative initiatives, some of which have been approved, others have been sent to the Chamber, others have been approved by the Government and sent to the Council of State, and others will occur in the coming months, in a balance that we try to ensure is faithful to our electoral program and the investiture program.

In any case, once again, I must tell you that we are waiting for your participation, your collaboration, and your willingness to join efforts on some important agreements such as those you have referred to: Justice, where we are making progress; autonomous financing, where the agreement of all the Autonomous Communities and your Group is convenient, and local financing, where we have also made progress. And I hope that we can concretize that in the coming months.

Mr. Rajoy.- There are many announcements, but there are few decisions and actions from the Government.

You speak of my participation and my contribution. I will tell you some motions that were approved here at the request of my Group or other Parliamentary Groups that you have not fulfilled: the "roadmap" for the reform of the financial system; the review of the module system for self-employed workers to adapt it to the crisis situation; the necessary measures to prevent SMEs and self-employed workers from paying VAT on unpaid invoices; the electricity pricing system to prevent billing abuses; the procedures to ensure the application of the reduced VAT rate of 7 percent on gas and electricity supplies; the increase in the percentage of VAT compensation for the livestock sector and the elimination of Ministries.

All of this has been approved in this Chamber at the proposal of the Popular Group or other Parliamentary Groups, and you do not comply with it, Mr. President of the Government.

You make announcements like the Code of Good Governance and then use a Falcon from the Armed Forces to go to a Socialist Party rally, which radically contradicts what the Code of Good Governance states. Fulfill your commitments and comply with the decisions of this...

President.- Mr. Rajoy, a good part of the things you have invoked with some urgency I understand have been fulfilled or are in the process of being fulfilled, and some others, frankly, we do not share, as is logical, such as the reduction of a Ministry, which is a power that constitutionally belongs to the President of the Government, as is quite well known.

I can assure you that this Government practices good governance, the Code of Good Governance, and, moreover, is a responsible and serious Government that does not use certain things out of respect for what the institution of the Presidency of the Government represents, former Presidents, and future Presidents. That is why, for the sake of seriousness and responsibility.

Thank you very much.