Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

5 October 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish parliament during a parliamentary control session on 5 October 2009, responding to questions about the government's R&D and innovation plans for 2010.
Main themes
R&D and innovation investment, economic competitiveness, budgetary priorities, productive model transformation, science and technology policy, public-private collaboration, Autonomous Communities, researcher funding, CDTI business R&D, sustainable economy
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,271
92nd percentile
Sentences
171
85th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
14.5
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 69%67%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

171 sentences in 72 paragraphs

Mr. President, the Government has repeatedly announced that within the budgetary constraints we are operating under, it will prioritize two policies: policies directly related to training and innovation, and policies aimed at mitigating the effects of the economic crisis on the social sectors that need it most. These are two priorities aimed at improving the competitiveness of our economy while trying, at the same time, to ensure that no one is excluded from global progress. To ensure economic progress, improve our competitiveness, and transform the productive model, it is necessary to invest in education, training, research, and innovation.

It is evident that collaboration from other administrations will be needed, especially from the Autonomous Communities, which is essential due to the distribution of powers that our country currently has. Likewise, it will be necessary to seek the commitment of social agents and the entire society.

For all these reasons, I specifically ask you about the Government's intentions regarding R&D+i in the fiscal year 2010.

President.- Mr. Aleu, thank you for your question. First of all, I must tell you that we share the diagnosis, which has been the subject of debate in this Chamber, also in the Congress of Deputies and in public opinion in general, regarding the felt and objective need for our economic model to advance and change towards a more productive model that incorporates more added value. Ultimately, that means incorporating more science and more innovation.

I think it is good to remember that, unfortunately, our country has been suffering for decades a delay, compared to the European countries around us, in what constitutes a science system, in what constitutes support for research, and in what constitutes the capacity to produce technology, generate patents, and also ensure that this capacity is transferred to companies, turned into innovative products, and makes our economy competitive.

Therefore, I want to point out some data that I find fundamental, because this is a crucial debate for the world of our country's economy and our well-being: since 2004, budgetary resources have tripled for Research, Development, and Innovation: they have increased from 2.9 billion euros to nearly 8 billion for 2010.

If you analyze all the budget items over the last five years, you will conclude that the greatest increase that the Government I lead has prioritized in terms of public resources is Research, Development, and Innovation. What has this allowed us? It has allowed us to be slightly above the average in public spending on R&D+i, it has allowed us to be the ninth scientific power, which corresponds with our economic power, and it should allow us to open a much richer horizon in terms of patents, in terms of high-level technological centers, and in terms of universities that are among the most important in the world.

For this year 2010, the Budget, as I mentioned, is around eight billion euros for R&D+i. It is a budget that maintains commitments and progress in R&D+i, and there will be, and this will be verifiable as a commitment from the President of the Government, no problem in addressing all the commitments of the National Plan for R&D+i, the Ingenio Program for collaboration between the public and private sectors that this Government launched and that is having great success. Furthermore, the increase in scholarships and contracts for researchers and technologists is consolidated, a fundamental element for articulating a good scientific and advanced modern system.

As the Minister of Science and Innovation has just mentioned, the CDTI, the Center for Technological Development, will allocate 1.365 billion euros to business R&D, which is a 30% increase compared to 2009.

Therefore, it guarantees what has been the growth for our science system, for our researchers, and for the work carried out by the OPIs, because, as the Minister has rightly explained, fortunately, they have surpluses to meet their commitments.

But, in addition, in this Budget, innovation, the field in which our technological potential and our creative potential are transferred, has an objective increase due to the establishment of two Funds that go directly to innovation: to the innovation of our companies and to the innovation of our public fabric: one, the Municipal Fund of five billion euros which, except for the 750 million that we will allow municipalities to allocate to education expenses, is aimed at strengthening our technological and innovation system with public investment and, moreover, it means that new actors, such as municipalities, enter the field of innovation to collaborate with companies, with regional governments, and with the State Government; on the other hand, the Fund, contemplated in the Sustainable Economy Law, of twenty billion euros, of which ten billion will be made available by the Official Credit Institute, is aimed at productive business investment in innovative matters, because it will be established for technologically advanced sectors of sustainable economy, renewable energies, energy savings, energy efficiency, and technological advances.

Consequently, we maintain the effort for research, for our science system, and, in addition, we increase, by bringing in new actors, the resources for innovation that, to a large extent, is done by companies and that we also wish municipalities to undertake, which are local economic agents of great potential.

That is the state of the situation of the Budgets for 2010 and that responds to a conviction: that the best path we have to transition to a more sustainable and more competitive economic model must go through supporting researchers, companies that research, that innovate, and, of course, by making a country that continues to gain positions in everything that represents the international context in a system of innovation, technology, and research.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Can the President of the Government guarantee that there will be no further tax increases beyond those recently announced?

President.- I wish to make a nuance and a clarification.

The nuance is that, logically, the tax increase to which you refer is in the Budget Bill. The Budgets must be debated and approved by both Chambers, and, logically, that will be the exact moment to evaluate the tax reforms contained in the Budgets. That is a nuance.

The clarification: I can indeed make a clarification, even a very precise one in this case, and that is that, under any circumstances, with the proposed tax increase that the Government has sent to the Chamber, the tax burden in our country will not exceed the tax burden we found when we came to Government. The resulting tax burden from this tax increase will not exceed, I repeat, the tax burden we found when we came to Government; with an addition: that now there are many more social benefits in our country, such as the Dependency Law, the increase in minimum pensions, the aid to young people for housing, the increase in scholarships, or the aid of 2,500 euros per birth.

That is to say, there is more social policy, more social benefits, and we will not have more tax burden, and we face this situation with the strongest global economic crisis in the last sixty years, as you hopefully know.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have a problem, and that is that the majority of Spaniards already know you. By disguising things so much, your political credit is at a minimum, and your messages, instead of conveying confidence, increasingly convey confusion and, in some cases, weariness, because no one understands the Budget Project that you have just approved; a monumental anthology of nonsense, and I will demonstrate it to you.

You said that it is about not mortgaging the future and that we must comply with the Stability Pact in 2012, but it turns out that today we are spending more than double what we are earning. How do you manage not to mortgage the future? With austerity? By reducing current spending? No; on the contrary, with the largest increase in non-financial spending in history, twenty-seven billion euros, more than a 17% increase, and, with additional spending, a 22% imbalance in 2009. And for the year 2010, in public debt, we will exceed 60% of GDP as set out in the Stability Plan.

Uncontrolled spending, uncontrolled debt, and uncontrolled deficit. Conclusion, the same as always: a new and progressive tax increase, and the stamp of another solidarity effort, the solidarity of the funnel, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero: you and your Government squandering in the wide part and citizens tightening with more taxes.

You intend to convince us that the tax hike is the only possible way out of the crisis, to guarantee social benefits, and to initiate a new productive model; all of this in the same package. Then you ask your Ministers and your party to make a pedagogical effort, and it doesn’t work, because that merchandise is not sellable, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

There is no worse time for a tax increase than now, with the economy slowing down, and what it needs are stimuli to reactivate it, not to slow it down further. I told you the other day: more taxes equal less consumption, equal business closures, equal more unemployment: eighty thousand new unemployed in September. This is not how the crisis is shortened, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero; this is how it is prolonged.

Moreover, the effect you will achieve is that revenue will decrease and that the underground economy and tax fraud will increase, because all experts are warning you about this.

Another inconsistency: the famous new productive model, of which we know very little. "Less cement and more knowledge," is one of your fantastic phrases. Clarify one thing for me, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, because a lot has been said this afternoon and no one has clarified it: is leaving 32% of the budget of the Ministry of Science and Innovation unexecuted this year, is cutting 15% for next year, or is it cutting 10% the funds applicable under the LOE?

You will say: "we always have social policy left." But today I will tell you one thing: stop using the unemployed, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, to cover up your poor management, because that is indeed very bad style. Do not boast, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, about paying unemployment benefits, because that is your obligation, not your merit, and it is the right they have. And think that each new unemployed person is one more proof of the absolute failure of your economic policy.

Reforms. You tell us: "I do not make reforms because I protect workers and the unemployed," confusing everything intentionally. Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, it is not the same to adopt the unavoidable social policies than to adopt the unavoidable measures for job creation, which are the ones you do not adopt, because it gives the impression that you have thrown in the towel in the face of rising unemployment. Because how can you present a Budget that contemplates three hundred thousand new unemployed for next year and not a single measure for job creation? There are those who think that what matters to you is not so much social peace, but that you are left in peace.

Budgets, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. Last year here, in this Chamber, a Budget was vetoed for being unrealistic and ineffective in addressing the crisis and curbing unemployment. Time has proven us right, because you failed in all forecasts: revenues were 18% less than expected and expenses were 22% more, and that is how it has gone for us.

Now you come with another Budget, with the same vices, but seasoned with the largest tax increase in history. Forecast of revenue increase: 21% more than this year; revenue from personal income tax, 7.2% more; revenue from VAT, 26% more. Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, with the background we have, who can believe these figures?

I anticipate that, just like last year, my Group, out of responsibility or, as you call it, shouldering the burden, will also veto this year's Budget in this Chamber, because we understand, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that it is possible to adopt effective reforms without raising taxes; that it is possible to create jobs, which is the best social policy; that it is possible to emerge from the recession at the same time as others and not last, and that it is possible to do things differently and better. And we understand that this is shouldering the burden, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and what you have been doing for some time is shrugging your shoulders.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I do not know if it is a great novelty that you are going to veto the Budgets, that is, that you are not going to provide support on any of the issues that affect the Government's work, even in difficult circumstances, even with an economic crisis. That is to say, that you are almost never even willing to sit down to shoulder the burden is part of your political trajectory before the citizens and in this country.

Any other criticism may be understandable, but the one that we have disguised the tax increase seems to me to be unfair, because the Government has talked about the tax increase permanently, we announced it in the summer, we have specified it... Do not tell me that we have disguised anything or tried to present it in a different way.

We have said that it is necessary to make a collective effort, which the Government understands as moderate, and which it asks the majority of Spanish society for two objectives: first, to guarantee social protection and support the sectors that have the greatest needs, and second, to maintain the pace of investment for that change in the productive model that will get us out of the economic crisis as soon as possible and lead us back to job creation.

We have made it clear, with a sense of responsibility, and what we do not do is play, as other Groups do, with all the circumstances, because you talk about austerity and talk about not raising taxes, but at the same time your Communities and your Town Halls are all day asking for more money from the Government and more public spending, unless you are here to tell us how that can be financed. It is an absolute incoherence.

It will be others, of course; it is neither the Government nor the Socialist Party who use the unemployed. You have said that it is an obligation of the Government to provide protection, of course the one that is in the laws; but this Government has decided to extend, for the first time in history, unemployment benefits for six months to those citizens who have lost assistance or contributory benefits.

It was not an obligation, no; it was not an obligation that those hundreds of thousands of people who were left without any benefit now have the possibility of having a benefit for six months. It has been a political decision, which responds to a political project, of social sensitivity and solidarity. That is why, because you do not have that social sensitivity, you have not proposed a single measure of support for people who have lost their jobs in this harsh economic crisis.

Finally, it is true that, like all European countries and the vast majority of OECD countries, of developed countries, we are having to face this serious economic crisis, which has meant a real slowdown in investment and private activity as a consequence of the financial crisis, with a huge and gigantic effort of fiscal stimulus from the public sector; an effort that, at the outset, has guaranteed that a financial crash did not occur; that, at the outset, has guaranteed the savings of all citizens in the face of the most serious financial crisis we have experienced and that now aims to return to economic growth and create jobs again, as this society has demonstrated on more than one occasion that it knows how to create.

That, when public effort is made, means a deficit because, if we have to support the automobile and the automotive sector to maintain its production, its activity, and its jobs, as we are doing... Today, by the way, a good piece of news has been announced; yes, today a good piece of news has been announced. Are you surprised or not pleased? A good piece of news has occurred: Renault has decided to maintain its activity in Valladolid and an industrial plan of five hundred million euros, thanks to an effort of public resources between the Junta de Castilla y León and the Government of Spain, thanks to an unprecedented effort from both Administrations. But to make that effort, resources must be available. The Junta de Castilla y León must have better financing, as it does now with the financing model, and the Government of Spain must have the political courage to face that situation.

If we did not have access to financing and deficit, many productive sectors that we are supporting in this serious economic crisis would have no future, and many solid jobs, which provide innovation and technology, would have to cease their activity.

With that, I conclude, and I will tell you, since you have invoked, yes, we are going to have a high deficit, which we want to correct next year and reach the Stability Pact and fiscal consolidation; but I remind you that our debt, which is a decisive factor, is and will be twenty points below the average of the European Union in public debt, and therefore, we have a margin in which we must act because, if we did not act with this fiscal stimulus and public spending, what we would do is not be able to maintain social protection and, secondly, make our economy, when recovery arrives, lose growth potential.

If we do not continue investing in infrastructure, technology, and innovation, we will not maintain the growth potential of the Spanish economy, and that is the Government's objective.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jordi Vilajoana, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Vilajoana.- Last December, just nine months ago, the European Commission approved the European Plan for Economic Recovery and Employment. One of the basic measures of the Plan to boost demand, save jobs, and help restore confidence was the commitment to establish a fiscal stimulus equivalent to 1.5 percent of the GDP of the European Union, mainly funded by the budgets of each State. At the time, a statement issued by Moncloa reaffirmed the benefits of the European Plan, saying that it laid the foundations for the recovery of growth and employment in the economies. And at the last G-20 meeting, it was agreed that fiscal stimuli should continue in 2010.

The question, Mr. President, is: if nine months ago in the European Union and a few weeks ago at the G-20 reducing taxes to stimulate growth and employment was the right thing to do, what sense does it make now, Mr. President, to do the opposite? In the General Budgets that we will debate shortly and that have been presented, we are increasing taxes by an amount equivalent to 1.5 percent of GDP. Mr. President, what sense does this increase make?

President.- Mr. Vilajoana, I will make two preliminary considerations. First, Spain, when referring to what the Recovery Plan of the Commission meant, was coming from making a significant tax reduction, which was still coming into effect at that time, of a volume or scope of two percentage points of GDP: I want to remind you: elimination of the Wealth Tax, reduction of the Corporate Tax by five points, and the deduction of four hundred euros in personal income tax, aside from other issues related to VAT.

That is the situation we were coming from, and that is why we celebrated that this was one of the measures that at the beginning of the crisis could make sense, because you will agree with me that the most evident manifestation of the beginning of the crisis was a rise in commodity prices, a rise in oil prices, and, as a consequence, a rise in the Euribor and very strong pressure on family incomes, to which the Government responded by making a fiscal transfer, a tax relief, to support, to the extent of its possibilities, families in the face of that increase.

When the crisis manifests itself in all its intensity as a crisis of the financial system, the response of the European Union is to make a broad fiscal stimulus, that is, to increase public investment. Logically, we were coming from a tax cut, and it seemed that the most logical thing was to face it without modifying taxes at that moment.

The crisis has been acute and deep, as we well know, and it has hit us hard in employment. For this, we have three options: to bet on a path of maintaining social protection, stimulating through productive investment, and not renouncing our fiscal consolidation in 2012, or when the European Commission establishes, to reach the deficit of 3 percent. If we want to do those three things at the same time, and the Government wishes to do so, that tax increase is necessary. Any other approach must give up one of the three objectives, and even so, we will have to make a great effort and a great job to achieve those three objectives, because the magnitude of the crisis has been, as Your Lordship knows well, very serious and very strong.

All this in a horizon that our tax pressure, and we must tell this clearly to citizens, honestly to citizens, is seven points below the average of the European Union, which is at 40 percent of GDP and we are at 33 percent. We are seven points below France, Italy, and Germany, and we are increasingly developing a Welfare State and social policies. Therefore, we understand that this collective effort was necessary.

All citizens know the magnitude of the crisis, and in my opinion, we must tell citizens the truth, even if that truth is uncomfortable, even if it is not popular, even if it is not kind or pleasant. If we want to maintain social protection, reduce our deficit, when it is our turn, according to Europe, and maintain productive investment, we need support in an increase in taxes. That is the analysis that the Government makes and, by the way, an analysis that basically responds to what was raised and to the resolutions of the G-20 from the meeting I had in Pittsburgh.

Mr. Vilajoana.- We supported you when you proposed the reduction of the Corporate Tax, a historical demand of ours, and we think it is good that you eliminated the Wealth Tax; but we clearly disagree with the reduction of the four hundred euros. There were Groups and there were people who said that this was an electoral measure. What we said was that it was a mistake, and Japan had already done it and they had made a mistake, to spend 5.698 billion euros, one trillion of the old pesetas, on making this universal deduction, for sixteen million taxpayers, and we said, and we say, that it would have been reasonable to have done it for lower incomes, of twenty thousand euros or less, and you did not do it.

I believe this was a mistake, and moreover, the most important thing about this is that you, in the economic report when you raised this issue, said that this reduction in the tax burden for personal income tax would mean a substantial improvement in the disposable income of families, which would affect their consumption and savings, and continued, and the report added: "the measure will have a beneficial impact on the economic cycle and could boost job creation."

Mr. President, it has not worked, and now you react and say: "we are removing it." What is the problem, Mr. President? That now money is needed and we have spent six billion euros here, this is our complaint, and here there were six billion euros that at that moment I believe was a mistake, and we told you, to push this issue forward.

Another fact where we clearly disagree. On June 23, in this same Chamber, here in the Senate, came, and it was the first appearance she made, the new Minister of Economy and Finance, Ms. Elena Salgado. And I personally in an interpellation asked her that at that moment economists said that what should be done was to lower Social Security contributions by two or three points and raise VAT by one, two, or three points. I asked the Vice President what they planned to do, and she told me, and this is in the Official Journal of Sessions: we are studying the issue of Social Security contributions; they can be lowered, we are studying it, but in the case of VAT we have studied it and we are not going to raise VAT, because this will really cause a drop in consumption.

So, my question, Mr. President, is why what the Minister told me a few weeks ago, three months ago, was no, why are we raising it.

Mr. President, there are two very clear things on this issue. We believe that at this moment social policy is not questionable, this money must be given; but what happens, and you have said it very well, is that we have more debt available, that is, we can go into more debt, because we are twenty points below Germany and France. Let’s do this. No one, neither the OECD, nor Europe, nor the International Monetary Fund, is saying that we are coming out of the crisis, as you say; but they say a nuance, that Spain will be the one that will come out, along with Iceland and Ireland, last or much later. And what does everyone say? That in situations like the current one we have, it is not advisable to implement a growth tax policy. This is what everyone says, and what we ask the President is to do the same, and we have other relative issues that we are not doing adequately.

What do we say? We believe that there should be a much more significant cut in current spending than we are making. Honestly, yes, Mr. President. Do not smile at me; yes, it must be done. Second, we should not cut investments in infrastructure and we should not cut them in R&D+i, which I fear is what we are doing. And we must do more things, President: we must try to boost this economy with concrete measures that lead to job creation in the short term, even if this leads to an increase in debt.

We must believe more in this country. What do international organizations tell us? We must improve the competitiveness of the country, which has fallen by 30 percent; we must improve exports, which we are not doing; we must innovate, we must improve, and we must believe in the country.

To conclude, Mr. President, on Sunday we were greeted with some surveys that were, for me, no joy at all. In these surveys, what was happening? Fundamentally, that the Spanish, by a large majority, specifically 70 percent of Spaniards, believe that the Government improvises in the economic measures it proposes; 68 percent believe that the tax increase is a harmful measure for economic recovery, and to finish on this topic of the surveys, 86 percent of Spaniards believe that the economic situation is bad or very bad.

Mr. President, and now to truly conclude, we were European in growth, but we do not know or do not want to follow their guidelines to overcome the recession. I believe, Mr. President, sincerely, that it is a great mistake to do what we are doing.

President.- I appreciate the tone of your intervention and I hope that, at least, you recognize an objective fact. You said: why not resort to debt without further ado and not touch taxation? Well, it would have been much more politically comfortable for me and in terms of public opinion; but you know, as I do, that what that represents is that in four or five years we will have a debt of over 100 percent and a situation, for the Government that corresponds, either of a reduction in spending... Reducing spending in our country means either strangling infrastructure or severely cutting social spending. The rest, allow me to say, and we can discuss it item by item, is a bit demagogic.

You know it, you have experience and you are a serious person, because when you talk to me about current spending, what are you talking about? The Government's current spending is fundamentally the public services of the country's security; of defense, which has already undergone cuts, and of the means it uses, and of the Police and the Civil Guard. That is where the large expenditures in current spending policy are, and you know it; the rest is a very small amount where something, but very little, can be done to address the magnitude of the figures we have. That is the reality.

So yes, the Government could have opted to say: we will rely on debt, wherever it leads, and the deficit, and what happens from here to four, five, six, eight, or ten years in Spain and in its public accounts is not our responsibility. Well, I disbelieve in that type of ruler, who only thinks about today and their own interest.

You will not argue with me that announcing a tax increase is not precisely popular, it is not pleasant. No Government can expect citizens to support that measure. Logically, citizens want to pay the least possible taxes and have the best services, that is natural and normal, and it is the ruler's responsibility to explain the situation and, at least, have a certain capacity for explanation and attempt a certain capacity for understanding on the part of the citizens regarding the situation at hand.

Secondly, and to finish, regarding fiscal policy, you spoke about the four hundred euros, and the measures, and invoked the improvisation of the surveys. This is a debate that I must say surprises me, because having to react, adopt new measures, new initiatives, and new policies, as all the Governments of the world have done in the face of the most serious financial and economic crisis in the last sixty years, is what corresponds. It is that, in the face of a turbulence that started as a storm and ended up being a hurricane, there is no GPS, Your Honor; what there is is the attempt by all Governments to steer the ship, taking into account the circumstances of the swell, the tide, and the wind, which has been very harsh.

We have explored new measures, all the Governments, the European Union, and the G-20, trying to respond to a situation. This happens in all serious economic crises. There is no law that says "if you now reduce the four hundred euros, you will stimulate consumption." By the way, we do not know how much it may have prevented consumption from falling further or how much it has stimulated savings, which is not bad for Spanish society and its recovery.

That is what I want to conclude: that we have a serious and responsible debate, and, of course, the Government will do so thinking about the country and the future, not thinking about the short term.

Thank you.