Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

26 April 2010 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on employment policy during a legislative control session in Spain's Congress on April 26, 2010.
Main themes
Unemployment policy, labor market reform, economic crisis, social protection, parliamentary accountability, youth unemployment, government credibility, social dialogue, temporary vs permanent workers, female unemployment, fiscal policy
Duration
~40 min
91st percentile
Words
4,849
91st percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
14.5
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 49%46%
  • Economic 34%32%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

159 sentences in 80 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- What assessment can the President of the Government make of his employment policy during the first half of this Legislature?

President.- As Mr. García-Escudero well knows, he knows the Chamber and he knows Spanish society, we have experienced, as a result of the severe economic crisis, an intense process of job destruction in these last two years, which has meant that our unemployment rate has returned to figures not seen since the 90s. Therefore, the assessment is one of concern and also of responsibility, because we have worked with a fundamental priority objective, which has been to maintain social protection and social cohesion to the maximum, and we can provide the significant data that 80 percent of unemployed people have a degree of protection with some of the benefits recognized by the system, including those we have expanded.

We are also convinced that we are at the moment when our unemployment rate has reached the highest level, very high, excessively high, as we share, and that reasonably we should see a positive trend in the coming months.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, when we talk about employment, what matters are the figures and everything else is smoke screens, and you stated this once: facts and not words.

For two years, when you denied the crisis and promised full employment until today, it turns out that Spain has more than doubled the unemployment rate and it has increased by more than two million unemployed. And this is the true balance of the first half of your Legislature: two years, two million unemployed; an unmitigated failure. And this explains why you have been very careful not to make an assessment, because you have nothing to boast about.

Today Spain has the highest unemployment rate of all developed economies in the world, over 20 percent according to the data from the EPA that we learned today, more than doubling the average of the European Union, Greece included, and with no prospects for improvement in the coming years because, as the International Monetary Fund warns us, we are at the tail end of the global economic recovery.

And given this situation, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, do you think you will continue for a long time without truly addressing, in a decisive manner, a genuine labor market reform? Or is unemployment not your responsibility? Or will you continue to blame the Popular Party for not lending a hand, or the eruption of the Icelandic volcano? Because you continue to face this crisis as if it were a natural disaster, waiting for it to pass or for the wind to carry away the ash cloud. And in the meantime, many plans, drafts, tables, photos, and announcements… All very seasoned, with a lot of improvisation but, in the end, always leading to the same thing: contradictions and rectifications, and much denial.

Because what you are doing is raising taxes, even taxing the aid to young people for rent and the aid and subsidies for the purchase of vehicles.

If not, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, let’s see what is happening with the famous social dialogue.

In July 2008, you signed a very solemn Declaration with the social agents for the Promotion of the Economy, Employment, Competitiveness, and Social Progress. A year later, in July 2009, the only tangible result was this: one million more unemployed.

In February of this year, you unveiled a new draft of Lines of Action in the Labor Market. Just a few weeks ago, you made public another new document and, in the meantime, another half a million more unemployed.

And now, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you announce to us that the dialogue is about to bear fruit, although, of course, you warn us that these will be scarce.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, how many thousands more unemployed are we going to have to wait for in Spain for you and your Government to truly address a labor market reform decisively? As you also stated on another occasion, this is the true measure of your management: almost five million unemployed.

Time passes, the unemployed continue to multiply at the same rate as the new announcements you make, and your credibility, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, continues to diminish here, in Spain, and outside of Spain, in the same proportion, and as of today, your employment policy only admits one definition: loquacious immobility. And this is in the face of a highly serious structural problem: for the first time, we have more than one million unemployed over 45 years old.

There is an unjust duality between permanent workers and temporary workers; the figures for youth unemployment, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, are scandalous and this generation of young people, more than 40 percent of whom are unemployed, will be called the "Zapatero generation"; female unemployment is still growing at a faster rate than male unemployment; the system of hiring bonuses is absolutely ineffective; the rigidities in labor negotiation are not eliminated and our Vocational Training system is glaringly absent.

And all of this, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, which is more than evident, is being reminded to us every day by the European Commission, the International Monetary Fund, the Bank of Spain, all economic research services and, of course, we are also reminding you from the Popular Party through countless parliamentary initiatives here, in the Senate, and also in Congress; initiatives that you systematically vote against and, when any of them is approved, your Government takes care to disregard and not comply with.

A good proof of the confusion you have in this matter, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, is that all the deficiencies I have just enumerated you recognize in your latest document. So, if that is the case, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, why have you been doing nothing for years?

You are obsessed with making a myth of social dialogue, when social dialogue should be a mere instrument, unavoidable, yes, when it comes to facing a reform; but much more important and much more essential to be able to carry out a reform is to have clarity of ideas, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and you, as of today, do not have clarity of ideas.

You are content to satisfy the social agents, taking many photos with them. The other day the Second Vice President of the Government recognized this with absolute impotence: the crisis is only economic, but not social. Social peace, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, is that what you are satisfied with? And what about creating jobs?

Social rights, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero… I have told you many times: there is no more sacred and important social right than the right to work, and there is no more authentic social peace than that everyone is working, that everyone has the right to prosper.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, stop using social dialogue and social peace as excuses for your inaction. The balance of your management, you said one day, is there: almost five million unemployed, 20 percent of unemployed in Spain. Stop wasting time, take the bull by the horns and tackle the reforms we need in this country, which are unavoidable, in the time you have left in this Legislature, because you are leading us to ruin, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I wish to make a clarification. I have not evaded the figures at any time and on some occasions, and I have no objection to repeating it today, nor the responsibility. I have already said that the Government… Personally, I feel responsible, as it cannot be otherwise, for the situation of the people who have lost their jobs as a consequence of the severe economic crisis and the primary responsibility lies with the Government of Spain.

Responsibility means facing what seems to me to be a priority and essential, which is that, while we do not have, due to the conditions of the economy, the capacity to generate employment, and I hope we are not far from that moment, we make the maximum effort -- it has been the Government's commitment, which we have fulfilled -- with social protection for people who lose their jobs. I just gave you the data: the degree of protection is 80 percent, the highest in history.

Beyond that, Your Lordship has raised labor reform as a decisive, determining factor that would explain our labor framework, the high unemployment rate, and that our unemployment rate is double the average of the European Union. By the way, this has been the case throughout the democratic period. We have always had an unemployment rate double the European average. Therefore, precisely… It is not true, indeed. Indeed, in the last Legislature, with the Government I preside over, we reached the average unemployment rate, that is, the lowest unemployment rate of 8 percent. Yes, that is true.

But, generally speaking, our unemployment rate, and in times of crisis, has always doubled above the European average. Those are objective data.

You invoke labor reform and have described some of the circumstances that, in your opinion, hinder and do not favor job creation: ineffective bonus policies, rigidity of collective agreements, collective bargaining, and duality of contracts between permanent and precarious. We agree on some things, but allow me to say that this is the model and labor framework that has been built over the years, not to say decades, in our country. That is to say, the labor framework has not been a labor framework reformed, constructed, or created by the Government I preside over.

But, even so, I agree with you that it is advisable to modernize our labor relations framework and allow me to express my opinion that it is very necessary and extraordinarily convenient that this reform is made with agreement between employers, unions, and the Government. Why? Because, if they make it their own and commit, it will yield much better results.

Labor reform must help create jobs. As Your Lordship well knows, we will create jobs when economic growth picks up; when, indeed, we consolidate what in our opinion has already occurred in the first quarter, which is to emerge from the recession and leave the economic recession behind. And we hope, as I said in my first intervention, and we trust that the unemployment rate will begin to decrease slightly, precisely from this month of April.

I can assure you that the commitment to carry out a labor reform is a serious commitment of the Government, firm and determined, and I am convinced that the responsibility of unions and employers is high to reach an agreement that truly represents a reform of the labor framework. And the most appropriate moment is precisely when the economy begins to show positive signs, as it does at this moment, because it will effectively help create jobs.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ramón Aleu, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Progress

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Aleu.- Mr. President of the Government, if we have a global view of the world, we can agree that one of the most notable characteristics of Europe is the existence in all States of the Welfare State, understood as a set of universal and public benefits provided by the Administration.

The crisis we are experiencing has called into question the financing of these benefits and, moreover, it seems that the exit from the crisis is favoring those economies that do not have the costs of the Welfare State. Europe must respond to this challenge and the European Union must be able to listen to the demands of its citizens and seriously address the exit from the crisis with future perspectives. To a large extent, this is the fundamental legitimization of the European Union and the basis for the modification of the Treaty of Lisbon: to achieve more agile institutions that are capable of responding to the demands of citizens.

At this moment, these demands focus on the response to the economic crisis and, above all, on the adoption of measures to create employment that necessarily must be based on more solid foundations than the current ones, than those we have had so far.

Within the Presidency of the European Union, the adoption of a strategy to address this situation was set as a priority. The European Commission, in its meeting on March 3, made a communication "Europe 2020, a Strategy for Smart, Sustainable, and Inclusive Growth," which has been put to discussion among all European institutions and which is intended to be approved by the European Council in June.

The proposal sets out some fundamental objectives: to achieve an employment rate of over 75 percent for the population aged 20 to 64; to ensure that investment in R&D is at least 3 percent of Gross Domestic Product; to tackle school dropout rates so that they are below 10 percent; to ensure that 40 percent of young people complete higher education; and to lift twenty million Europeans out of poverty. All of this is to be achieved through seven flagship strategies: increasing innovation; improving educational systems and young people's access to the labor market; accelerating digital deployment; reducing carbon emissions and increasing the use of renewable energy with the 20-20-20 criterion: a 20 percent reduction in carbon emissions compared to 1990, 20 percent use of renewable energy, and 20 percent improvement in energy efficiency; improving the business environment and the industrial base; modernizing labor markets and fighting poverty.

The specific question is: Mr. President, do you believe that the Strategy will succeed in guiding and promoting a new, more sustainable productive model for the entire European Union and for Spain?

President.- Indeed, for Spain, during the period of the rotating Presidency that we hold this semester, there has been a great objective, and that objective is to create a European economic government and strengthen economic coordination policies and cooperation, because it is evident that in this historical time, globalization demands far-reaching decisions, especially in an Economic and Monetary Union like the one to which we belong.

To this end, as you know and have recalled here, Europe has launched a new Strategy, the so-called Strategy 2020, which replaces the Lisbon Strategy approved in 2000, which was in effect until 2010.

This Strategy 2020 has three fundamental objectives: the first objective is to strengthen economic coordination among the twenty-seven countries of the European Union and, especially, among the countries belonging to the eurozone in all matters affecting monetary policy and the regulation of the financial system, much more so after what we have experienced; but also other economic policies that can promote that union, such as the development of the internal market, common energy policy, and other areas.

Second, to make the European Union a more competitive economy, with greater capacity to raise productivity levels, so that we can recover the ground we have lost in relation to emerging economies, which have gained weight in the global economy and have also gained weight in international trade during this era of globalization. Gaining competitiveness means gaining innovation, strengthening education, and ultimately making the European area capable of achieving the highest levels and yields of productivity and innovation.

And the third major objective: to preserve our social model; to preserve the long-term social protection system, what we know as the pension system in our country, and to guarantee the rights that have shaped the Welfare State in education, health, and social affairs; that model which is exclusive to Europe, which is a reference model.

The great question for the European Union is that we must be as competitive as those who do not have a social protection model like ours and, therefore, do not dedicate as many resources to that social protection, which logically favors their competitiveness.

That is the option that Strategy 2020 puts into motion and, as you know, it will have a second phase of conclusion at the European Council in June, where we will approve the integrated guidelines and where we will specify each of the areas and objectives that we will set at the level of the entire European Union and at the level of each country for compliance in the next ten years.

Undoubtedly, that Strategy, if we have new mechanisms for its effective implementation, for what is known as its governance, to be put into practice in each country and in each area, will contribute decisively to the change of the productive model, which is the great need of the Spanish economy and, in part, also of the entire European economy.

Response of the President of the Government to Mr. Jordi Vilajoana, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Vilajoana.- Mr. President of the Government, today my question was and is to know your position regarding the interim situation of the Constitutional Court; but I cannot fail to mention a fact that occurred this morning and that seems particularly significant to me. The President of the Government of Catalonia, the very honorable Mr. José Montilla, and the President of Convergència i Unió, the honorable Mr. Artur Mas, have reached a four-point agreement.

In the first point, Mr. President, they reiterate their conviction that the Statute of Catalonia has achieved the maximum possible legitimacy by being ratified by the citizens it is meant to serve and reaffirm their conviction about its full constitutionality.

In the second point, they propose to convey to the Parliamentary Groups of Congress and Senate the urgent and unavoidable need to proceed with the appointment of the magistrate that corresponds to Congress, vacant due to death, and to unblock the procedure for the appointment of four magistrates of the Constitutional Court, pending for more than two years in this Chamber, in the Senate.

In the third point, they state that, after five failed attempts to issue a ruling, the Constitutional Court is not in a position to carry out the tasks that it is constitutionally assigned and, in this sense, they will promote all actions within their reach to ensure that the Constitutional Court declares itself incompetent.

In the fourth, they request a reform of the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court that prevents the prolongation of the mandate of the magistrates of the Constitutional Court in cases of blockage of the processes for renewing its members, a situation that, as you know very well, Mr. President, we are currently suffering.

I would like to know, Mr. President, firstly, your position on these points agreed upon this morning and also to ask you if you will maintain your position of not acting regarding the interim situation of the Constitutional Court.

President.- Mr. Vilajoana, I thank you for the question, because this is a topic of great relevance in the public debate in recent days in our country and, moreover, it is a topic of great depth.

I must say that I respect, of course, as could not be otherwise, the agreement you have just described, which has been reached between two Catalan political forces, between the two political forces with the greatest representation in the Parliament of Catalonia. Logically, as that agreement will have a course of action, we will set our position at each moment in each of the specific initiatives.

But, beyond that, allow me to express my position on this matter. I believe we should have a certain perspective when evaluating the role and responsibility of the Constitutional Court regarding the pending ruling on the Statute of Catalonia in a dual direction: first, the issue raised regarding the Statute of Catalonia is an extraordinary appeal, in the sense that until now no Statute of Catalonia has been challenged on such a high number of articles, which gives it a certain complexity that must be explained and that requires understanding from all actors for the time that the Constitutional Court has been deliberating on the ruling and seeking an agreement for a decision; a time that, on the other hand, is within the average that the Constitutional Court usually needs to resolve appeals of unconstitutionality regarding laws in force, historically averaging four years.

Second, regarding the situation of the Constitutional Court, we must be respectful of the rules of our legal system. To the Constitutional Court, what belongs to the Constitutional Court, and to Parliament, what belongs to Parliament, because the Constitutional Court is not responsible, nor can it be criticized, for the fact that the renewal of the members who have already left or whose term has expired has not occurred in time. It is our responsibility, and this should be institutionally clarified time and again.

I can assure you that, as President of the Government, and I already made this clear during my time as leader of the opposition, I always have the will for the renewal of institutional bodies to occur in a timely manner. As leader of the opposition, I facilitated the renewal of the members of the Constitutional Court and now, in this period, as Your Honor well knows, it has not been possible to reach an agreement to renew the members of the Constitutional Court, which partly corresponds to this Chamber.

You ask me: do I continue with the intention of not acting? And I answer: I will act when the conditions are acceptable to reach an agreement. Surely Your Honor understands me when I say that the worst conditions for reaching an agreement are that this agreement is subjected to public debate day by day and that, as almost always happens in these processes, a certain calm and some discretion are necessary for the renewal of the Constitutional Court to occur, which I wish to take place as soon as possible.

While we do not reach that agreement and renewal, we must be extraordinarily faithful to the spirit and the letter of our constitutional rules. And fidelity to the spirit and the letter of the constitutional rules means maximum respect for what the Constitutional Court, which currently has the responsibilities, may decide, beyond the fact that, logically, the content of that decision may be criticized or not criticized.

But allow me, Your Honor, to say that I do not recall a non-ruling provoking so much debate, and we should have a certain calm. I do not even want to imagine what debate we would have if there had already been a ruling. A non-ruling has produced so much debate and, even, a certain sense of institutional conflict.

Therefore, let us allow the Constitutional Court to work in its responsibility, from which it cannot abdicate, to try to form a majority for a ruling on the appeal of unconstitutionality regarding the Statute, and let the political groups work to seek renewal; each in their role and without mixing what can be messages from one side to another.

I reiterate two things to conclude. The first, and I have expressed it on many occasions, the Government considers the Statute of Catalonia to be constitutional. For a reason we gave our support. In my case, in my capacity as a deputy, I supported it and would support it again. And I am going to give you an argument for why that support, which at the time I voted for, I could not have present: because, after almost four years of validity of the Statute of Catalonia and application of the Statute of Catalonia, things are functioning reasonably well: the self-government of Catalonia has been strengthened and Spain remains united and strong. That is the reality.

Mr. Vilajoana.- Mr. President of the Government, I also thank you for your tone, although I do not share, as you did not share with me, everything you have expressed.

I share with you that the Statute is very important and was a significant, decisive leap, which was ratified by all of Catalonia, and this is a clear difference from other situations. But I do not share with you, firstly, that you continue to shield yourself in the behavior of the Popular Party, which we do not share at all; that we do not share, not only with you, but with the Popular Party. Neither now nor before, we do not share it.

But I also have to tell you one thing: we respect the behavior of the Constitutional Court, but we have a problem: that this debate is being conducted with rules that do not conform to the constitutional mandate. That is to say, you have said at one point that during the game the rules cannot be changed. No, it is that the rules have already been changed in the middle of the game. We have been in the game for four years or three and a half years, and at the moment when Article 159.3 of the Constitution, which calls for renewal, is not applied… not that it requires, but that it proposes renewal and it is not done, the game changes its rules, Mr. President.

This is our opinion and we believe that this is not a good way to conduct such a difficult and complex debate as the one we are raising. And this is a very important problem.

Then, there is another aspect, Mr. President, that I would like to make clear to you today. You know perfectly well that you have a mechanism and you have a sufficient majority to introduce an absolutely constitutional and possible change in the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court that leads to two situations, which we consider very important, and which are very clear in this agreement that you valued earlier.

First, you have an absolute majority in this Chamber and in Congress to introduce something that was already proposed by our Group in Congress, which is, once the deadlines have expired, to give a time extension but, if not, finally, let us say, dismiss those magistrates who have reached this limit. This was a legislative proposal that was put forward, which you did not support, and I would like you to reflect on this issue, because, I repeat, you have an absolute majority to do so and it is absolutely constitutional to do so.

Secondly, also, and there are documents and scholars who support this approach, Article Four of the General Law of the Constitutional Court allows the Constitutional Court to refrain from ruling in certain cases and on certain appeals. We understand that it would be reasonable to introduce this aspect that in the laws where there is a referendum by the people, it should be an element where the Constitutional Court can refrain.

These are the proposals that this agreement presents to you, Mr. President, and I repeat, what seems very significant to me is that, while absolutely respecting legality, something we never want to break, you have, you and this Chamber, an absolute majority sufficient to introduce changes that would unblock the situation.

What we ask from our Group, and in this case no longer just our Group, but what this agreement of the Government of the Generalitat and Convergència i Unió asks of you, is that we make a move and that you make a move in this direction.

I know that you share many of the things we defend. You defended the Statute, it is true, and you voted for it, Mr. President. The Statute is nothing more than a political agreement, to which you committed yourself with great clarity, first, before the people of Catalonia, when six and a half years ago you committed to defend the Statute that would come out of Parliament, and in the very debate of the Statute you personally engaged.

Mr. President, now is a great opportunity for you to exercise, within legality, this possibility of unblocking a situation, because you clearly know that this Statute is being developed, as you have very well said, perfectly, without breaking anything, and that this situation is introducing a complexity into political life that is not at all convenient for anyone.

President.- Your Excellency, I believe I have not hidden behind any squire. I must say that I have not invoked the Popular Party.

But I will tell you that the rules of the game today are what they are. Can they be changed? Yes. And you have raised a question that, without a doubt, is at the core, but which is tantamount to debating or amending the Constituent: what happens when a Statute is ratified by the people and there is a constitutional appeal? I acknowledge that it is a question, a constitutional science, of great scope. But the Constituent made a choice. Let us respect the Constituent, the Constitution, and the rules of the game.

Can we change the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court? We can talk about it, but as of today, let us allow things to function as they are in the legal framework. This way we strengthen democracy, we strengthen the credibility of the Statute, and we strengthen the credibility of what we have done. Any other step would weaken the credibility of what we have done.

Thank you very much.