Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

12 October 2010 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from opposition leaders during a government control session in Spain's Congress on 12 October 2010.
Main themes
Pension reform and Toledo Pact, austerity and social spending cuts, welfare state sustainability, economic crisis response, social protection policies, early childhood education, dependency care system, government accountability, budget priorities, relations with markets and European partners
Duration
~10 min
35th percentile
Words
1,201
35th percentile
Sentences
37
23rd percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
14.6
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%41%
  • Institutional 33%32%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Ceremonial 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

37 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, there is no irreversible design that prevents you from rectifying. In fact, a year ago the only intelligible aspect of your social and economic policy was the maintenance of social protection, and now you have just come to a sudden and abrupt halt that has caused the pieces of our precarious Welfare State to fall apart.

Change, Mr. President, because there is no better message of confidence for your European partners and for the markets than the cessation of the growing social unrest, as was expressed a few days ago in a general strike. Moreover, there are alternatives, Mr. President, because what benefits the general interest is not always what benefits the markets, as the right claims. Why cut social spending and not unproductive spending? Why not slim down the Administration? Why cut productive spending on investment or infrastructure, which is a factor for growth…?

President.- Indeed, we can all make mistakes and we can all rectify, even you, Mr. Ridao, because, objectively, the social spending in this Budget is 58 percent and I believe that is just, because, moreover, you have collaborated greatly in recognizing the progress in social policies and social spending. Even in this very restrictive Budget there are significant social allocations, which you obviously did not mention, such as scholarships, which increase by 2.6 percent, meaning that from 2004 to now they have increased by 8 percent.

It is true that the dependency allocation does not increase, but you cannot fail to recognize that it is in this Legislature where a system of care for dependent persons has been established, with 1.5 billion euros this year from the central Government, which will cover the care for seven hundred thousand people. And, as you will recall, this has also been the period in which we have addressed Early Childhood Education for three to six years and now we are working on Early Childhood Education for zero to three years, as well as doubling the…

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, the Toledo Pact was a very important advance in our country and consisted of all of us agreeing on how our public pension system of Social Security should be. This was great news and the issue is certainly not minor; this has provided security and peace of mind to everyone, to today’s pensioners and to future pensioners; it provided peace of mind at the time of signing and it does so for the future as well, because the spirit of that Toledo Pact was that any substantial modification that occurred would be made with the agreement of all.

All Governments since then have complied with this agreement, all except you who, unilaterally, liquidated the Recommendations of the Pact; specifically Recommendation number 11, which was later embodied in a law stating that pensions would be automatically adjusted according to the cost of living index.

The question I ask you is why you do this and what are the reasons you believe we will trust you for the future, after having so clearly and distinctly breached an agreement that took so much to achieve.

President.- The Government and the Socialist Group defend, because they were founders, the Toledo Pact, which we have permanently respected and that, in an exceptional circumstance due to the serious economic crisis and at a specific point, the Government has been forced to make the decision not to incorporate the revaluation of pensions for the next year, excluding, of course, minimum pensions.

But let me tell you, Mr. Rajoy, something about pensions: since 2004 the average pension has grown by 16 percent, that is, an average of 2.5 percent per year, discounting inflation, while during the Governments of the Popular Party it was only 1.9 percent. And, if we talk about minimum pensions, which is where the greatest effort of solidarity lies, where the greatest needs are, the data is overwhelming, Mr. Rajoy: from 2004 to now the increase has been 27 percent in the purchasing power of minimum pensions and in the eight years of the PP government, it was 3.6 percent; I repeat, we 27 percent and you 3.6 percent. That is authority and legitimacy to talk about solidarity effort and minimum pensions.

As you well know, 35 percent of pensioners, 3.4 million with minimum pensions, will not be affected and, as you well know, Mr. Rajoy, and this is what matters most to everyone and to the future of this country, the Commission of the Toledo Pact in Parliament is working. I hope that a consensus is reached in the Recommendations and with that consensus the Government will draft a Bill, which it wishes to be agreed upon beyond the exceptional circumstance and the specific aspect to which you have referred.

And I hope to count on your collaboration for the future of pensions, which is the key to our Welfare State system and which concerns all groups.

Mr. Rajoy.- Regarding the history you referred to here, I will only remind you that in 1996 the Government of the Popular Party had to request a loan to be able to pay the Christmas bonus to pensioners.

And regarding the Toledo Pact, I will only say two things: that we complied with it and that you do not comply with the Toledo Pact on such an important point as the automatic revaluation of pensions.

You have broken fifteen years of agreement on pensions; you have broken it, Mr. President, and you have repealed by Royal Decree Law a law that took a lot of consensus to achieve among all, and, moreover, there was an alternative because with this freeze you save 1.5 billion euros and you have issued Public Debt in this Legislature amounting to 287 billion euros.

You have not negotiated with any of the political groups; you have not even informed us, at least not ours. You decided unilaterally. You have breached five mandates of this Chamber and, moreover, you have vetoed the debate on this matter in this Chamber.

I will say two things to conclude: we will present an amendment again in the upcoming Budget debate and I demand from you, I demand, that you do not veto the debate on that amendment here, in the Cortes; on the other hand, I ask you to rectify in order to regain credibility so that we can reach some agreement. If not, it will be very difficult.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, you say that we have made this decision unilaterally. It is true that I never expected to count on your support, although it was a difficult decision, precisely because it was a difficult decision. You are not usually the one who makes difficult decisions or accompanies difficult decisions, but necessary for the country.

I have told you, and you have not refuted, that the effort we have made in terms of pensions, and that we will continue to make as a political project, has been a huge effort compared to what you have done. Pensioners know it and they deserve new increases when the economy allows it.