Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at the closing of the 50th Anniversary of the Círculo de Economía.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

30 May 2008 · Closing of the 50th Anniversary of the Círculo de Economía

Context
Zapatero addressed the closing ceremony of the 50th Anniversary of the Círculo de Economía in Catalonia on May 30, 2008, discussing Spain's economic challenges.
Main themes
Spanish economic situation, global financial crisis, Catalonia's economic openness, construction sector adjustment, inflation and oil prices, economic growth differentials, gratitude to Catalonia, Círculo de Economía anniversary, energy dependence, subprime mortgage crisis
Duration
~61 min
96th percentile
Words
7,261
96th percentile
Sentences
219
91st percentile
Readability
33
22nd percentile
Grade
16.6
87th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%47%
  • Institutional 28%26%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

219 sentences in 94 paragraphs

Thank you very much, José Manuel Lara, a notable entrepreneur and always a collaborator of the country, of Catalonia and of Spain, who has certainly given this edition, this fifty years of history of the Circle, a remarkable projection. It has become, at this moment, the most important forum for economic debate and for the transmission of analysis of economic reality, as we have seen these days.

President of the Generalitat, you know that it is always a pleasure for me to be in Catalonia and to be with you. Congratulations on all the rain we have, and it has not all fallen yet; there is still more to come, it seems, which is a notable relief, as you well know. And, of course, thanks also to the foresight of the Generalitat and the President, I believe that we have fortunately overcome this bump, with a May that has brought a very notable amount of rain, and with the works that are being initiated by the Generalitat, in a few months, a year, when they come into operation, we will have cleared the horizon of what was a worrying situation that we had to address and had addressed.

I want to make a first act of gratitude. As José Manuel said, this is my first institutional, official act since the last general elections, since the investiture and the formation of the Government of Spain. No one can ignore that it would be quite unfair on my part not to express a deep gratitude to Catalan society, and I do so here, in the Circle, for the broad support given in the elections of March 9 to the candidacy I led for the Presidency of the Government, which was given to the Socialist Party of Catalonia. And that gratitude extends to all the groups that are willing to govern; I see my friend Sánchez Llibre here during this period.

My gratitude, along with José Manuel Lara, I want it to also extend to Mr. Alemany, to whom I wish the greatest success in his stage.

I want to remember that in these fifty years of history, the Catalan economy has opened up to the world. Its degree of openness of 66 percent is even higher than that of the Spanish economy as a whole, which is 60 percent, and higher than that of the United States or Japan. Consequently, one might ask whether this represents a greater impact from global events, while it is also important to remember that this high degree of openness provides better conditions to take advantage of all the potential of the economy, of the industry, and of the good economic practices of Catalonia.

The current Spanish situation, which is also an economy, fortunately, very open to the world, is not immune to the global economic cycle or to the global situation that, as you know, began to face difficulties from the summer of 2007, fundamentally due to the crisis of the so-called "subprime" mortgages and the entire effect on the international financial system, with liquidity difficulties, which has been joined by an excessive and permanent rise in oil prices, and also a crisis of basic food supplies, a supply crisis, which is causing serious tensions in prices and, therefore, in the real economy.

I want to remind you that Spain grew by 2.7 percent in the first quarter of the year compared to 3.5 percent in the fourth quarter of 2007. The quarter-on-quarter growth has been 0.3 percent, which highlights an intense deceleration, especially in the construction sector, where an adjustment is taking place, an adjustment that the vast majority of those in economic analysis and the business world have been predicting for some time; it has occurred with strong intensity, coinciding, without a doubt, with the pressure of interest rates, which logically restrains demand, restrains consumption, and makes it difficult what could be a continuous expansion of this sector.

Therefore, we are growing less, and we are growing less, especially due to the drastic reduction in the real estate sector, in residential construction. To this has been added, as I mentioned earlier, the price of oil, which has doubled its price in a year, exceeding 130 dollars, and which is responsible for one and a half of the 4.7 points of inflation that we have just learned about from last month. If we eliminated the rise in oil and the rise in basic food prices, today we would have inflation in Spain at 2.5 percent. I think it is good to take into account the external factors that are putting pressure on prices, on inflation, which we currently know.

The first thing to keep in mind is that for the economy in general, perhaps for some companies it is not so, that such a strong rise in crude oil prices represents a lower general wealth as long as we have to pay for it, and, of course, given our energy dependence.

In any case, it is worth remembering that we continue to maintain a positive growth differential with the European Union and that we have very important assets, assets that we did not have in other stages of economic slowdown and adjustment. The objective, therefore, must be to continue growing above the European average, an objective that coincides with the forecasts of the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund.

What are the assets we have to face this strong adjustment period calmly and to have a favorable outlook at the moment when international conditions allow us to return to the path of potential growth of Spanish society?

The first of these is that we have not exhausted the margin to create jobs and, especially, to create jobs by incorporating more women into the labor market. Even in Catalonia, which has exceeded the European objectives of a female employment rate of 60 percent, and which is above the national average; even in Catalonia, there remains a gap of almost eighteen points between male and female employment. The incorporation of women into the labor market is a fundamental objective and, moreover, it is a direct improvement of our human capital, given the higher educational level of younger women, as we know perfectly.

Secondly: the Spanish economy still requires greater investment in capital to accommodate the process of population growth in recent years. We still need more infrastructure that allows us to improve productivity, increasing the capital stock per inhabitant and reducing the differential with Europe. In the last four years, the State has invested 49 billion euros in infrastructure, almost double that of the previous four years. The same is true in Catalonia: in the last four years we have invested more than 7.2 billion euros, compared to 4 billion in the previous period; the pace of 2007 has exceeded for the first time in Catalonia 2.2 billion euros in investment, and thanks to the statutory provisions and their effective compliance, we will maintain a very high investment pace in infrastructure.

Therefore, we have a strength to develop. Fortunately, it can be maintained, because fortunately we have managed to have a surplus, which will allow us to maintain a strong pace of investment in infrastructure that, as you well know, we are accelerating.

Thirdly, our economy has experienced an intense process of internationalization in the last decade, both in trade and in investments. In fact, between 1990 and 2006, our companies have gone from being absent on the international stage to positioning Spain as the third largest investor abroad, which is the ranking we have achieved in 2007, and there the Catalan company has much to say.

Fourthly, the solidity of our financial system, both in terms of profitability and solvency, in part, as has been recognized by the international press, due to the good work of the Bank of Spain, an excellent supervisor and regulator, and also due to the good management of our main financial entities that have not been affected by financial turbulence. I want to remind and emphasize that several of our banking groups are among the top in the European Union and that we have the unique formula of the Savings Banks, which add dynamism and reach to our financial services offering. I am sure that this sector will continue to know how to accompany the necessary investments that the business fabric needs.

Finally, and fifthly, but very importantly and depending on the direct public management of the Government, we have a budgetary situation envied by all the countries around us. More than a decade ago, a progressive process of fiscal consolidation began, and, as you know, last year we had a surplus of 2.5 points of Gross Domestic Product. As the Vice President of the Government reaffirmed yesterday, we maintain our objective of being, despite the economic cycle, in budgetary stability and trying to achieve a certain surplus.

That margin we have achieved allows us to face this period with a fairly reasonable circle when it comes to addressing policies, because the surplus allows us to reduce taxes, as will now materialize with the reduction of personal income tax, allows us to maintain the pace of investment in infrastructure and productive capital, and allows us to maintain, and improve, social benefits, such as in the area of pensions.

Therefore, the question is: how would we be, what margin would we have at this moment, if we had not done our homework well for four years in terms of public account management and having a surplus to face and support the situations we have today and continue preparing the economy for its future?

As you know, that scenario and the scenario of difficulty that has been experienced since August 2007 have led us to take a first package of measures aimed, fundamentally, at supporting families, to reasonably support companies, up to the limit of what we consider reasonable in the problems they may have directly or indirectly with liquidity, and, of course, to allocate a part of those measures to the construction sector.

I want to remind you that with the first measures approved by the first Council of Ministers, we injected 10 billion euros into the economy, and this can be done without any problem of compromising any of the public spending objectives thanks to the surplus.

The first measure, the one with the most impact, which will materialize at the end of this month in the June payroll, is the return of 5 billion euros to families through personal income tax, which will allow them to have an increase in their income that will alleviate, to some extent, the difficulties posed by rising prices, not only of oil but also of interest rates, and the consequence of mortgages, while we inject 5 billion euros that can represent a stimulus for demand and, therefore, have a certain contribution to economic growth. We can do this, I insist, because we have a surplus.

In addition, to help the liquidity of companies, the State guarantee for the use of SME credits has been increased by 2 billion euros, and starting next year, companies will be able to request monthly refunds of the VAT paid. On June 17, we will hold a Sectoral Conference on Housing, which will lay the foundations for a national pact with all the Administrations and involved agents, with the aim of constructing 150,000 protected homes per year during this Legislature. To this end, we have increased the public guarantee for the titling of loans for official protected housing by 2 billion euros, and the tax treatment of building rehabilitation has also been improved.

Furthermore, as you know, we are going to enhance public employment services, in collaboration with the Autonomous Communities, through the hiring of 1,500 people dedicated to what can be the professional and labor guidance of those who are losing their jobs in the construction sector.

These are the short-term measures we have taken in the first Council of Ministers; but the Government has measures for the medium term and to prepare the foundations of the Spanish economy at the time of recovery, with the aim of continuing to gain space for the new model of economic growth that we have been promoting and fostering in favor of innovation and quality employment.

This medium-term strategy has as its fundamental objective to increase productivity, and therefore the competitiveness, of our economy. It requires, on the one hand, to maintain the investment effort in physical capital, which we will do, to continue increasing the effort in human and technological capital, and to break down barriers, of which we still have some left, to guarantee an institutional environment and in the economy in general of the country favorable to the activity of companies, and to their possibilities of growth and expansion.

I want to reiterate that it seems important to me in this Forum that we will maintain that investment effort in infrastructure and that we maintain, and will fulfill, the objective that by 2010 we will be the country in the world with the most kilometers of High Speed. I want to congratulate myself on the result of the High Speed between Madrid and Barcelona, which in three months of operation has surpassed one million people who have used it.

I also want to reiterate that during this period we will continue to invest in the modernization of railways, we will increase the Barcelona commuter network by 42 trains, and that Catalonia, with the development of high-speed rail towards Girona and the border, will become the first region to have all its provincial capitals connected by high-speed rail, witness the renewal process of all the commuter lines, and, of course, the transfer to the Generalitat.

Similarly, as this investment effort in infrastructure continues, in about a year, the works and tests at El Prat will be completed so that Barcelona, Catalonia, and Spain can enjoy one of the best airports in the world, and of course in Europe, which will be the new Prat, with an investment of five billion euros, nearly four billion of which have already been invested. By that date, we must have, of course, the new operational model for airports, with the decisive participation, as I have expressed on some occasions, of the Generalitat and local institutions.

I have used the examples of Catalonia to reiterate that we have the budgetary availability and the political will to maintain commitments in infrastructure.

Second, Education. It is the second challenge we have ahead: the training and education of the Spanish population. It is true that the change our society has undergone is impressive, as the formal education of an adult has increased from five to nine years between 1960 and 2005; but we are still far below the most developed countries: thirteen years in the United States and eleven years in most European Union countries. This is one of the social and economic consequences that limits our growth potential and competitiveness, perhaps the most relevant, one of the most relevant, and that also limits the potential for gaining convergence in per capita income.

There have been advances in the last four years, but there is still much to be done. A notable advance is that we have guaranteed free education for three to six-year-olds, that the dropout rate has been reduced by two percentage points—though it is true that we could say it is only by two points—but the dropout rate has been reduced, and that our university system is increasingly closer to being able to operate in the European Higher Education Area.

Now, as José Manuel rightly said, the effort that remains to be made in education is immense. For this, in a politically decentralized system, the impetus, initiative, or laws of the Government are not enough, because a large part of the determination of what happens is in the hands of the Autonomous Communities, which manage education. But the Government of Spain does not want to look the other way; the Government of Spain takes responsibility for education as one of the key issues for our future, and therefore, I have committed to convening a Conference of Presidents on education, aimed basically at improving quality, extending the period of education for our youth, and, of course, ensuring equality.

Education goes hand in hand with the third determining factor for that future, for that horizon of economic growth in the potential we have, and even improving it, which is innovation, research, development, and everything that entails. You are well aware of the effort that has been made in the last four years, as we have almost tripled spending on R&D&I. At this moment, we are at 7.7 billion euros, and the latest available data, from 2006, placed us at 1.20% of GDP in R&D&I spending, which was the largest increase in a year in fifteen years. You know that this spending has focused on seeking maximum synergy between the public sector and the business sector.

Catalonia is a good example of this, because in the programs we have launched, it has had and has a unique presence: In the CENIT Program, Catalan companies have taken nine projects, mobilizing 250 million euros; in the CONSOLIDER Program, 14 of the 44 consortia in excellent research are Catalan, mobilizing resources of nearly 100 million euros; and in the AVANZA Plan, which is changing our country's relationship with the Information Society, nearly 580 million euros have been mobilized for Catalan society. I say it is changing because, fortunately, the latest figures that Spain provides regarding the Information Society place us at a very competitive average standard.

This effort to increase R&D&I will be maintained thanks to budgetary availability, and in the next phase, we will address the development of the National R&D&I Plan 2008-2011, which, as you know, has priority lines that I want to reiterate, especially in a business context, such as: health, biotechnology, energy, climate change, Information and Communication Technologies, nanotechnology, and new materials. Here we will make a significant investment effort and mobilize what represents the entire flow of research energy that our country and our companies have.

In addition to infrastructure, education, and innovation, we will undertake structural reforms; reforms that will have a timeline and specificity. Before the summer, the Council of Ministers will approve a package of structural reforms that will be incorporated into the National Reform Program that must be presented to the European Commission in October, a package of structural reforms that will focus on the following fundamental aspects, although I will outline the general lines; they are not all, it would be impossible, but so that you can see the orientation:

First, we will reduce administrative burdens on companies by 30%. It is estimated that there are twenty-two thousand regulations in force in Spain and an annual flow of two thousand more between the State and the Autonomous Communities that affect economic activity in one way or another. Perhaps we are one of the OECD countries with the most administrative regulation, and this is a bottleneck and an outdated view of the regulatory effectiveness of economic activity by public authorities. We are convinced that the simplification and reduction of administrative burdens by 30%—and I can assure you that this will be a very serious commitment from the entire Government—will lead to an increase in business productivity that will enhance greater competitiveness. Our GDP level could increase by up to 2%.

We will launch a pilot project that will measure the cost of burdens in an area that you know well, which is the area of environmental regulation, and before the end of the year, we will publish a Royal Decree reducing the administrative burdens imposed on companies across all Ministries.

Likewise, secondly, we will carry out an ambitious transposition of the European Services Directive, which must reduce the differential inflationary behavior in this sector, which is undoubtedly the main sector of economic activity. This Directive represents the opportunity to create a regulatory environment based on transparency, certainty, and efficiency, as well as to eliminate those barriers that unjustifiably hinder the creation of new projects. We need to increase the variety and quality of services available to businesses and citizens, and thus achieve greater dynamism and competitiveness in our economy. The Government will present before the end of the year a "framework law," as experts currently call it, which will incorporate the general principles of the Directive and provide a legal reference framework to reconcile future regulatory developments with those principles.

Therefore, we will undertake new regulations in the field of professional services to eliminate obstacles and modernize professional organizations, in order to better defend the interests of consumers.

In the area of structural reforms, as a third aspect, we will promote competition in freight rail transport so that its share in transportation, currently only 3% of the total, converges with that of the more developed countries and we reduce our emissions of polluting gases. To achieve this, it is necessary to strengthen the independence and functions of the regulatory body of the rail sector.

Similarly, regarding the energy sector, we must address the issue of electricity tariffs, which have not reflected the significant increases in international fuel prices and, therefore, are currently far from real costs. To this end, the Government is working on designing new tariffs; new tariffs in which, to minimize the impact on consumers, a new domestic time-of-use tariff will be created, which will promote savings and energy efficiency, along with a social tariff aimed at minimizing the impact of international increases in energy prices on consumers with less economic capacity.

Likewise, one of the aspects to improve our energy supply is the increase in electrical interconnections with other countries. We are about to reach a historic agreement that will double the interconnection capacity with France and will have a significant impact, in terms of improving supply, in Catalonia and, consequently, in the quality of service provided to citizens.

We maintain our determination to achieve the goal of 12% renewable energies by 2010, through a stable and predictable remuneration framework, but at the same time with a reasonable cost for consumers.

In telecommunications, we will finalize the development of new regulations that will enhance the efficient use of the radio spectrum, we will strengthen measures to ensure quality in broadband services and consumer guarantees when changing suppliers, and finally, we will review the provision of the universal service obligation, expanding its coverage and introducing competitive provision mechanisms.

As you can see, this is an ambitious package, and I do not explain it in all its extent, of reforms that, as I said, we will bring to the Council of Ministers in less than a month and for whose development we will seek the support and collaboration of social agents and the different Parliamentary Groups. These are part of the reforms, not all the reforms; but undoubtedly, these are very important. There will be others that will be some reflections on the public sector and specific plans aimed at sectors of our economic activity.

I told you that we hope to count on the support of social interlocutors because, as you know, for the Government, social dialogue is an essential path to address problems. It was so during the last Legislature, with twenty social agreements, and it will be so in the next; a Legislature in which those twenty agreements achieved social peace, contributed to macroeconomic stability, and resulted in agreements on Social Security and agreements in favor of employment stability, all of which had positive outcomes. I take this opportunity, by the way, to remind you that on July 1, there will be a reduction in the unemployment contribution of 0.25 points as a result of past agreements.

Now we have a new scenario, but the fact that the economic scenario is different does not change the Government's commitment to social dialogue. That is why, in the coming days, I will convene the representatives of workers and unions to draft and sign a new declaration of social dialogue, marking the beginning of a new phase. I am sure I will have their favorable disposition, as has been the case throughout my time at the head of the Government.

I want to emphasize that within those agreements and that new phase of social dialogue, there is one particularly relevant aspect, which is the need to renew the Toledo Pact on Social Security. Immediately after the summer, we must work in that direction. This concerns social interlocutors, but also, and very prominently, parliamentary groups, the Parliament. Both social interlocutors and Parliament must have equal prominence, and we need to form a triangle of dialogue between Parliament, unions-employers, and the Government to renew the Toledo Pact, which, as everyone knows, constitutes an essential foundation for our future in the field of social protection.

Among other things, there we can and must discuss the evolution and future of the Social Security Reserve Fund, which, as you know, currently has almost 52 billion euros, which will be nearly 56 billion before the end of summer, because we will make a new provision of 4.7 billion euros to Social Security, to reach that figure of 56 billion. This is nothing but a reflection of the good evolution of Social Security, despite the fact that we are in a moment of very notable deceleration in affiliations; but the income and health of Social Security continue to show great strength.

What are the objectives of the measures we have already taken, which are currently being implemented, including, among others, the tax reduction of four hundred euros, and the structural measures that we will approve before the summer, which I just mentioned? The objective is the same, the same course we set in the previous Legislature: a more competitive and innovative economy, and a business fabric that allows us to continue maintaining the level of growth.

I believe that the sectors on which we will base this economic future to grow again to our potential and continue gaining competitiveness must be very clear to all Spanish society. They are:

Other sectors include agri-food; automotive components, where we have magnificent competitiveness figures abroad; the textile production sector, supported by a world-renowned fashion sector, and others such as, logically, tourism, where the Government aims to contribute to a process of renewal of our infrastructures and support for the sector so that it continues to maintain its important contribution to Gross Domestic Product.

In short, we are at a moment of adjustment in the economy, but thanks to the surplus and the good management carried out in recent years, we can help families and businesses; we can maintain investment commitments in infrastructure and productive economy so that our country continues to gain competitiveness, and we can maintain and fulfill commitments for social improvements in pensions, scholarships, and housing that have characterized a good part of the political action of our Legislature, along with the development, which is so important in the Welfare State and also in economic activity and employment, as I just mentioned, of the Dependency Law.

These are the basic challenges we aim to face in economic matters. Allow me to make a final reference to what autonomous financing represents as one of the issues with which the Government is committed and will put into practice.

First consideration in this regard. From my point of view, there are conditions to achieve a general agreement on a reform of the autonomous financing model. From the words I could sense from afar yesterday from Rajoy, it seems to me that they favor that consideration.

Second, the Statute of Catalonia will be fulfilled as, by the way, it is being fulfilled. I know that the President and the Catalan political forces would like that development to be faster. The development of the Statute is taking place impeccably in terms of the commitment regarding infrastructures, with investment in infrastructures, just as in those other issues we have pending and that I hope will advance in July.

That is to say, we are moving towards a model of greater fiscal autonomy, of greater fiscal co-responsibility; we are moving towards a model where solidarity has more transparency and is related to basic public services, especially education, health, and social services; we are moving towards a model that takes into account the singularities that exist, as is logical, in some Autonomous Communities, which exist, but where logically the evolution of the population is a fundamental factor, and we are moving towards a model that ultimately is important for financial sufficiency and correction of the results of the current model that, logically, have produced an excessive range between what represents financing for basic services per inhabitant in some territories and others.

The Government's desire is that we meet the deadlines and the Government's commitment is that this new model, of course, represents a clearly positive impact for what the financing needs of Autonomous Communities represent that have seen a very notable population evolution, such as Catalonia, and that we have the capacity to assume that this model needs, regardless of the changes that occur, a permanent attitude of collaboration between the central Government and the Governments of the Autonomous Communities.

Collaboration yields great results. Thanks to good collaboration, we have had positive results in what have been such important issues as the delay in infrastructures for Catalonia, reflected in the Statute; we have had it in what was a problem, which fortunately did not reach its ultimate consequences, such as the potential lack of water supply for the urban area of Barcelona, there has been permanent collaboration; and there will be in the transfer of Cercanías, in the management of the airport, and in the construction of the new model or reform of autonomous financing.

That is the future I envision for our country and for Catalonia in particular. The future is earned if the course is correct and the objectives are shared by the vast majority, knowing that there are moments of greater ease in the evolution of the economy, which are easier, and moments of greater difficulties. Now we have a moment of difficulties, but we are prepared to alleviate them for those who may suffer the most and to maintain the modernizing tension of Spain and its economy. We have resources and projects. If this modernizing tension, the resources we have, and the projects I have just mentioned are joined by a good political climate and a collaborative attitude from the rest of the political groups, it will undoubtedly bring a positive benefit.

To not disappoint José Manuel, I will conclude with a reflection on political dialogue on the horizon of the Legislature. I express from here my willingness to reach agreements with the main opposition party. I do not speak of the other parties, because I believe I have demonstrated the ability to reach agreements with all political forces; on some issues, not all, not always, but a willingness for dialogue and agreement, and I have always expressed my gratitude to the political forces that have been willing to engage in that dialogue. I want to reach agreements with the Popular Party and for me, the previous Legislature weighs nothing. Democracy has a great virtue, and it is that people, citizens, vote every four years, and the coming four years are for the future. They are not to settle what happened in the previous four years; they are for the future. That is the message I want to leave here and leave to the Popular Party.

What are the priorities in the agreements? The fight against terrorism. There is currently an understanding, there is another favorable climate. I am pleased about this, and the only thing that should be remembered is that in the fight against terrorism, all political parties are very important. I would like the Popular Party to also have that conviction that the best thing is to have a reasonable understanding with the entire Chamber, in addition to the two main parties.

Second, and which is fundamental for me, Justice, which I have not referred to in my speech because I will address it in this process, let’s say, of dialogues or agreements. In Spain, Justice needs a profound renewal, a serious reform, an intense modernization. I believe that throughout the entire period of democratic transition to now, it is one of the public services in which we have been least able to achieve results, and for that, and to renew the institutional bodies, political agreements of substance are needed, and also to renew the Constitutional Court where, in my opinion, anyone who can play with a tactical vision is mistaken. They are mistaken for the Constitutional Court itself, which plays a fundamental role in our political system, and they are mistaken because, normally, anyone who wants to have a global project for Spain cannot play with a vision of tacticalism, a short-term vision.

The third objective in this area of dialogue is foreign policy and, especially, the Spanish Presidency of the European Union in 2010, which will be a moment of great importance for our country.

Fourth, I have just mentioned it, the Toledo Pact, the future of Social Security, the future of pensions. I believe it would be very good to renew a climate of agreement as was the Toledo Pact.

And, as I do not want to be utopian, I will not go further in my range of objectives for dialogue and agreement. If we achieve agreements in these four areas, I believe that the Legislature will have a different color, and I also believe that there is an immensely greater desire among the citizens for it to have a different color, in which the tension for the dispute in what is the healthy democratic political contest is maintained, in the field of arguments, in the field of ideas, and in the field of the contemporary; of the contemporary and of what we are playing for in the future.

I hope that in that debate or in that field of healthy political contest, the attempt to return with questions to yesterday's issues, more than today's, and what concerns the future of Spaniards does not prevail. I hope that this Legislature will be a debate on future issues, on Spain, on its economy, on its competitiveness, on its education, on the integration of immigration, and not on issues that have to do with those aspects that, in my opinion, are more of the past and that, moreover, provoke emotional and tension factors that have to do with identity aspects. Let us not try to ask questions and seek answers to yesterday's issues; let us walk with the issues of tomorrow, which is what Spanish society wants and, of course, Catalan society in a very singular way.

José Manuel, congratulations on your management, congratulations to the Circle, and congratulations to Catalan society.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT

------------------------------------------------------------------

José Manuel Lara.- First question, which already came up last year at this table and which we know is a long and complicated issue, is the management of the airport as a basic infrastructure for the development of Barcelona and Catalonia in the economy. Do we have a forecast of a possible calendar or a possible way about what kind of path we could dream of so that one day we can solve it, President?

President.- The first thing I want to say is that the figures that the El Prat airport produced last year are spectacular; that, as I just said, the Government has had a determined will to place El Prat airport among the best in Europe, and when the entire expansion work is completed, we will be able to verify it, and that the Government of Spain has the will to fulfill a desire, an objective, and that is that the management of El Prat includes the institutions; certainly the Generalitat, but also the presence of local institutions.

We have debated a lot about this and even this week I was asked in Parliament. I know there is a certain impatience, I understand it, but we are facing an issue, as everyone can understand, that is nothing more and nothing less than the Spanish airport model and a large airport, a large infrastructure, such as El Prat, where the State and the Government logically have a direct responsibility, I simply ask that we do things well.

As many of those present here may have noticed, despite the sometimes repeated impatience, the objectives and commitments have been fulfilled. I refer, at the time, to the Statute and I refer to the commitments of budgetary investment, up to High Speed, although we had a delay that was very hard for Catalan society and where citizens suffered a lot and behaved extraordinarily well. But there is High Speed, just as it will arrive, in a reasonable time, that the journey between Madrid and Barcelona will be even shorter than it is now, because we will increase the speed, and we are working intensively on that other objective that will also greatly dynamize the economy of Catalonia and Madrid. We will meet the objective.

I have said in my speech that we have an important range of reforms ahead of us. I have expressed some of them, some are structural and have to do with the public sector and public companies. Therefore, we will give ourselves enough time.

I can assure you that we will do everything in full dialogue and agreement with the Generalitat of Catalonia and I hope with the political forces of Catalonia. But of course, that is the horizon, that commitments will be fulfilled, just as the transfer of Cercanías will be fulfilled. It is true that we have a development time and we have to do things well, and we will do them.

J. Manuel Lara.- President, there are many questions regarding energy issues. On one hand, there is one that invokes a predecessor in office, President González, who told us here yesterday that we should stop being hypocritical, according to the question, when we decided to connect to the French electronic system, very much based on nuclear energy, and we are still talking about reducing our own nuclear energy. Can anything be said about what the policy could be? Could it be something not taboo one day to discuss this more clearly? It seems to have become a topic where anyone who speaks of nuclear energy is condemned by environmentalism to hell and no one can talk. This is the impression that exists. Will it be possible one day to talk or will there be a debate on that topic?

President.- There is every possibility of having a debate. I have expressed my position on more than one occasion, which has nothing to do with false environmentalism or a preventive stance. I know that, furthermore, there are certain forums where this position is a minority. My position is a forward-looking one, for the country and economically, because the debate would lead us to economically evaluate what nuclear energy represents and the investment in it at this moment. I refer to what is happening in Finland and let us analyze which countries and under what conditions are betting on increasing their nuclear energy capacity.

I believe that our future position as a country is to bet much more decisively on renewable energies. They will provide us with much more added value as a country and, of course, I am fully convinced that if we were to go in the other direction, we would not make the effort we need to make that will make us great in renewable energies. That is my position.

I am willing to have a monographic debate on this topic and I am aware that, increasingly, my position in certain circles is not a majority one. I think that with this I have said quite enough, but I maintain it and, moreover, I maintain it with more conviction every day.

J. Manuel Lara.- The radial system in communications is still being maintained quite a bit, and it seems that a peripheral system is needed, especially in the Mediterranean Corridor, in freight and railway infrastructures.

President.- Absolutely agree. So much so that the PEIT, the current Transport Infrastructure Plan, above all, seeks to overcome that exclusive radial conception and move towards a network conception of infrastructure in our country. Catalonia will experience this in High Speed, in a very clear way, and, of course, it is absolutely essential and we are giving a boost to everything that the Mediterranean Corridor represents, just as we have given a boost to what the Silver Route represents, which is the communication of all of western Spain and is opening new opportunities. Absolutely agree and, moreover, to be honest, I believe this is one of the issues that President Maragall insisted on the most, who was an absolute defender of what Spain in a network in communications was.

J. Manuel Lara.- Will VAT increase?

President.- No, not at all; no. I reiterate, it is true that we are in a deep economic slowdown and we will see how long it lasts. The Government has to do everything possible to make it last as little as possible, but in this situation, I insist, what we are doing is reducing taxes and fiscal pressure. I have just given the figure and I reiterate it because perhaps, as it was an electoral commitment, it has had excessive partisan debate, but at the end of this month, and from the end of this month until December 31, we are going to put five billion euros into families as a consequence of the deduction of four hundred euros from the personal income tax.

I know it has been criticized by some who have spent their whole lives defending tax cuts and, when it is done effectively and commitments to citizens are strictly fulfilled, they criticize it. It affects, as you know, workers, self-employed individuals, and pensioners. It is going to stimulate consumption to some extent and, of course, it is going to help families, because approximately close to five million families will see their income increased by eight hundred euros by December 31.

J. Manuel Lara.- Last question, the need to take measures for the protection of intellectual property. We are the sixth largest power in piracy.

President.- Statistics in this area are, as in some others, always difficult to accept as entirely accurate; but there is no doubt that we have a serious problem and, of course, within the package of structural reforms I have not mentioned it, because the list would be very extensive that we want to implement, there is the strengthening of the defense of intellectual property.

Those countries that take intellectual property seriously are those countries that value talent, creativity, innovation, the countries, ultimately, where production is best and where the economy functions best. And those countries that lose respect for intellectual property are those countries that do not expect themselves to be capable of creating above others.

Therefore, it is necessary to strengthen the defense of intellectual property. We are going to do it and we are going to pursue, if possible, piracy with more emphasis and more effort. But I absolutely agree with this consideration.

J. Manuel Lara.- President, thank you very much for being with us.

President.- Thank you very much and see you next year. Thank you.