Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 May 2008 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on Autonomous Communities financing reform and Catalan Statute compliance during a May 2008 congressional control session in Spain.
Main themes
Autonomous communities financing model, Catalan Statute compliance, financial sufficiency, intergovernmental solidarity, bilateralism between State and Generalitat, LOFCA reform, fiscal federalism, regional public services, political consensus on fiscal reform
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,490
67th percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
31
19th percentile
Grade
16.8
88th percentile
Syntax
3.40
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%43%
  • Economic 36%36%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

75 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President of the Government, just a few days ago you said in the Senate that when addressing the new model of autonomous financing, various principles had to be reconciled, such as the financial sufficiency of the State and the Autonomous Communities, as well as the principle of solidarity. Can you clarify these points?

Secondly, can you clarify whether you will strictly comply with the Catalan Statute regarding its timetable and also concerning the bilateral relationship between the State and the Generalitat?

President.- Mr. Ridao, as you well know, the Government has a firm commitment to comply with the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, the Organic Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities, and, ultimately, all the legal framework that regulates the financing model and the need for a reform of the financing model; a reform for which, as you well know, it is necessary and very desirable to have maximum political consensus and the cooperation of the governments of the Autonomous Communities and, of course, of these Chambers.

The Government does believe that it is possible to meet the objectives of financial sufficiency for the Autonomous Communities and for the State, the principle of solidarity, and to take into account the elements that have changed since the last financing model, especially those affecting the population, taking into account, I insist, the provisions of the Statute of Catalonia and the LOFCA.

Mr. Ridao.- The truth is that you have not been very explicit in addressing some issues because, if we talk, for example, about financial sufficiency, it is not understood that you say that not a single cent more will be saved for the Autonomous Communities and, at the same time, the State reserves 50 percent of the total income without having previously assessed the spending needs of the Autonomous Communities, because the State, as you know, already controls 43 percent of the income, spends only 22 percent, and has a surplus of 23 billion, when that proportion is reversed in the Autonomous Communities. Therefore, we are facing a world turned upside down, when the Autonomous Communities must attend to basic services such as Education, Health, or social services.

You have also not been very explicit regarding the issue of solidarity. I would like you to acknowledge, once again, the irrationality of a system that allows those who contribute the most to have fewer resources per capita. That is prohibited in Germany, for example. Here it should also be impossible for a citizen of Astorga or Aranjuez to receive more resources than one from Cornellá or one from Rubí.

Thirdly, regarding bilateralism, I must tell you that the Statute must be complied with, it should not be negotiated, and that the model will not be decided, I hope, on Ferraz Street. Bilateralism cannot end up being a lukewarm, reheated coffee for everyone. The Statute, and you know this, is a fiscal pact and, as such, is bilateral. The agreement reached with Catalonia can be generalized, and that is what happens, for example, in the European Union with the Cohesion Funds.

Therefore, I want to tell you that the multilateral variables established by the LOFCA for all Autonomous Communities and that are not contained in the Catalan Statute cannot be weighed in the future financing of Catalonia and if, therefore, the State wants to guarantee that solidarity or that multilateralism, it must do so with its own resources. And that is what you and the Government must take very much into account.

President.- As you well know, yesterday a formal process began, with the presence of the Economic Vice President, in the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy with all the Councillors of the Autonomous Communities. This will lead to a number of meetings, surely a high number of multilateral and bilateral meetings.

But I do want to tell you that the State does consider that it needs to have financial sufficiency to fulfill its constitutional obligations: defense, security, major infrastructures, and such important issues, which Your Lordship surely supports, as the fulfillment of the increase in aid for cooperation and development, which is undoubtedly one of the basic needs of Spain's foreign policy. And that is compatible with what represents the financial sufficiency of the Autonomous Communities.

Of course, do not doubt that the citizens of Astorga will have the same levels of services as those of any other Autonomous Community, including, of course, Catalonia; for example, Cornellá.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Xésus Jorquera, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Jorquera.- I take the question as formulated in the terms in which it has been published: What are the Government's criteria regarding electricity tariff policy, considering the impact this will have on consumers and energy-intensive companies, in a context of economic crisis?

President.- Mr. Jorquera, the Government has to make a decision regarding the evolution and increase of the electricity tariff. So far, as established, a certain average increase in the tariff has been proposed by the National Commission on Energy, and at this moment the Government is evaluating that proposal. I can already anticipate that the Government's decision will be a reasonable one; of course, reasoned, and taking into account all aspects, certainly the social aspects and, of course, also the evolution of the economy of our country.

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, I would appreciate it if you could be more precise in your response because, without a doubt, you are aware of the alarm that the proposal made by the National Commission on Energy to raise the comprehensive electricity tariff by 11.3 percent has generated among many consumers, especially since this increase would add to other decisions that have provoked strong opposition. I am referring, specifically, to the disappearance of the so-called "night tariff" starting next July 1; a night tariff that had been incentivized by public authorities to promote energy savings and to change consumption habits, and to which more than a million households in Spain, many of them Galicians, had adhered, who had to make the necessary investments to be able to take advantage of this modality.

Official studies estimate that the replacement of this tariff will mean an increase in costs to consumers of between 25 and 80 percent, depending on the contracted power. Moreover, a report from the Director of the Legal Advisory of the National Commission on Energy warns of possible violations of constitutional principles regarding legal certainty and legitimate trust that this change in model may entail.

It seems evident, Mr. President, that in an economic situation like the current one, with rampant inflation and the growing loss of purchasing power of many workers, it does not seem reasonable to apply an increase like the one proposed by the National Commission on Energy nor to adopt measures such as the elimination of the night tariff, due to the very negative impact it would have on household economies and on the evolution of inflation itself.

I remind you that you yourself, before this Chamber, a year ago, stated that the increases approved by the Government would be in line with the rise in the CPI. Even your Government approved an increase of 3.3 percent last December, well below the proposal of the National Commission on Energy, which at that time was 20 percent, appealing to the sense of responsibility of the Government.

I appeal, Mr. President, to that same sense of responsibility to make decisions that do not punish the purchasing power of workers and that take into account the very negative effects that a measure of this type could have in a context like the one we are discussing, both regarding the disappearance of the night tariff and the increase in the electricity tariff.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Jorquera. I appreciate your interest and sensitivity regarding an issue that undoubtedly has great importance and affects consumers.

I reiterate that what exists so far is a proposal from the National Commission on Energy and there is not yet a decision from the Government, which will be made and which will undoubtedly be evaluated by this Chamber.

I do want to make a clarification regarding the disappearance of the night tariff, which occurs as a result of the application of a European Directive. This disappearance implies the integration of what the night tariff represented into what is known as the time-of-use tariff, which represents a model that expands the possibility of a lower cost and price of electricity and which, according to our calculations, will affect and benefit a larger number of consumers and will have an average reduction of about 2 or 2.5 percent in what this system entails.

We are aware that there have been some problems in the application, especially in some Autonomous Communities. Of course, the Ministry of Industry is trying, with the electricity companies, to clarify what the disappearance of the night tariff really means and the application of this new model or integration into this new model, which should not and cannot imply more costs for the vast majority of consumers.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- With your permission, I would like to congratulate the Civil Guard for the operation they carried out against ETA. I believe it is the right path in the fight against terrorism.

Mr. President of the Government, yesterday you met with the President of the Basque Autonomous Community to discuss his sovereignist plan, today you are going to meet with the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities belonging to your party to talk about autonomous financing, and just a short time ago you rectified and decided on a transfer from the Ebro to Barcelona, which I supported, but you did not respond to other millions of Spanish citizens who are also affected by this problem.

The question I ask you is why you have not met with the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities governed by other parties who also want to talk about autonomous financing, water, or other real problems. I ask you this question because it seems that one must present a sovereignist plan or belong to the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party to be attended to, and that, as is natural, does not seem acceptable to me.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I appreciate, first of all, the congratulations you have given to the Civil Guard for the police operation against ETA that took place last night.

Secondly, I believe that the question Your Lordship asks does not take into account the background, the facts, of how the Government has worked and how I have sought to have a relationship with all the Autonomous Communities.

I want to remind you that in the previous four years I met 64 times with Presidents of all colors and from all Autonomous Communities, and I convened the Conference of Presidents three times. I will not compare with previous data, but I can say that, in the previous four years, I have been the President who has dialogued and tried to reach agreements the most times, sometimes yes; sometimes no, with the Presidents of Autonomous Communities of all political colors.

Of course, I will continue to meet in this Legislature, which has just begun, with the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities. I already have several requests from Presidents of Autonomous Communities of all political colors, and I can inform you that the next will be a President of the Autonomous Community from the Popular Party, as is my obligation… Yes, specifically, the one from Castilla y León; if you want the specific data. And, of course, I will address with them, as I have done on other occasions, the issues of water, the issues of autonomous financing, and all those that wish to raise with the Government of Spain because, certainly, in my political practice, I am convinced that one must govern by listening, dialoguing, and seeking agreements with all the Autonomous Communities.

The times when it was difficult for the President of the Government to have the attitude of being and sharing decisions with Presidents of Autonomous Communities are behind us.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, everything you say is very well, but you have not answered my question. Autonomous financing is a very important issue. We are talking about equality among Spaniards, we are talking about the provision of public services, and we are talking about the rights of citizens.

It is my duty, and I fulfill it, to demand that you meet with everyone, not just those from your party, because those from other parties are not of lesser condition, and the citizens living in those Communities are also Spaniards and are not of lesser condition either. I insist, we are talking about equality among Spaniards, and it seems to me that the decisions you are making in this matter do not bode well for the future.

And the same happens with the water problem. You have not wanted to explain in this Chamber your decisions regarding water. You made the decision to transfer water to Barcelona, I supported you; now your Minister said no, forty-eight hours ago, as if she could bypass the Law; then she said yes and we do not know at this moment what is happening. But neither do the millions of Spaniards affected by such an important problem as water know.

These millions of Spaniards and the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities have the right to an answer, they have the right not to be wronged, they have the right to be treated as equals, they have the right to be heard, and they have the right to proudly claim to be Spaniards and come to discuss with the President of the Government the issues that the President of the Government discusses with others.

It is your obligation to meet with all the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities to address the issue of financing...

President.- Regarding water policy, which we have discussed many times, I will tell you that the Government has sought to guarantee water supply to all Autonomous Communities, even in years when we have suffered from severe drought, and we have succeeded; to all: to the Valencian Community, to the Andalusian Community, and now to Catalonia, to the city of Barcelona.

Of course, I share with you that autonomous financing is a matter of great importance, which requires maximum consensus and dialogue with all the regional Presidents and with all political forces to reach an agreement. But allow me --I am sure you understand and share this philosophy-- to start from within our own ranks to seek that consensus and, from there, achieve an agreement...