Statement by President Lula during a meeting with heads of the Powers to address the fires.

Brazil Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · President of Brazil

19 September 2024 · Meeting with heads of the Powers to address the fires

Context
Lula addressed a joint meeting of Brazilian branch heads on September 19, 2024, to discuss emergency measures in response to widespread fires and severe drought.
Main themes
Wildfires and arson, climate crisis, drought in the Amazon and Pantanal, environmental responsibility, government preparedness and civil defense, greenhouse gas emissions, inter-branch cooperation, public health impacts, deforestation and land destruction, legislative and executive response
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,180
78th percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.99
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
14th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 36%35%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

146 sentences in 38 paragraphs

And I would like to start by saying to you that this meeting was conceived because of the pact we signed not long ago, with the presence of President Lira [Arthur Lira, President of the Chamber of Deputies], President Pacheco [Rodrigo Pacheco, President of the Federal Senate], President Barroso [Luís Roberto Barroso, President of the Supreme Federal Court], and other personalities, so that we can begin to address the issue of climate with much more responsibility and determination.

In recent days, we have seen a worsening of the situation in Brazil. We cannot yet say that the number of fires occurring in Brazil is criminal. There are strong indications. Just yesterday, in Rio de Janeiro, 20 people were arrested because, in Rio de Janeiro, there were almost 1,800 fire hotspots yesterday, in a state with a small territorial extension.

I visited the state of Amazonas to see the effects of the drought in the heart of the Amazon. It is something that we, from Brasília or elsewhere in Brazil, cannot believe, that the image of those mighty rivers we see will never run dry. I went to places where the river, which used to be over 15 meters high, now has only half a meter of water, making it impossible for people to use their boats to buy food or sell what they can produce.

And to make matters worse, I arrived on Sunday afternoon and received news that a neighborhood in the National Park was on fire, a neighborhood in Torto, I think it was. I went to pay a visit. I took a helicopter to see how things were, and the impression I had was that it was a line that had been drawn and set on fire, that is, for almost I don’t know how many kilometers, I thought it was about 10, 15 kilometers — very, very, very long and it caused a lot of damage in the National Park.

The concrete fact is that today, in Brazil, we were not 100% prepared to deal with these issues. The cities are not taken care of. Up to 90% of the cities are unprepared to handle this. The states, there are few that are prepared, that have Civil Defense, that have firefighters, that have brigadistas. Almost no one has.

In other words, what we are noticing, after what happened in the Vale do Taquari, in Rio Grande do Sul, is that nature has decided to show its claws. It has decided to give us a lesson and said the following: “look, you take care of me properly, I am not obliged to endure so much irresponsibility, so many wrong and misguided things that humans are doing.” Because, unfortunately, human beings are the only animals capable of destroying their own place to sleep, capable of ruining their own food, capable of killing their fellow beings for no reason, something that in the animal world practically does not exist.

So, this meeting is to review the concept that each one has about the climate issue in Brazil. It is worse than at any other time. Just to give you an idea: the drought in the Pantanal is the worst in 73 years. The drought in the Amazon is the worst in almost 50 years. In other words…

And then, this week, to make us more accountable regarding the climate issue, I thought it only rained in Rio Grande do Sul, and I saw Germany flooding, I saw Romania flooding, I saw Turkey flooding. In other words, there is a movement on the planet and, if what scientists say is true, we have a lot of responsibility.

Hence the need for us to discuss, with a little more depth, new proposals to care for the environment, new behaviors [to be adopted] and, at the same time, we need to start thinking more seriously about reducing greenhouse gas emissions. If we want to live on a better planet, not only from a climatic point of view, but also the effects of this on health, especially for children, the respiratory issue is becoming a very big problem. Older people are also having respiratory problems, and all of this is linked to the climate issue.

So, my companions, Marina [Silva] will present to me a series of proposals that we had already discussed in Manaus. These proposals, we will turn into law, into decree, into provisional measure. As I pass this to the Civil House to build a definitive proposal. And we will want to hear other segments of society because we want to share not only the pains of the problems but we want to share with Brazilian society, with the National Congress, with the Brazilian Judiciary, we want to share a solution that is definitive for this climate issue.

I would like to conclude, before passing the word to Marina, by saying to you that there is a lot of suspicion that many of the fires are criminal. For example, we went to visit three communities in the Amazon and, on the way back, it seems like provocation, but we found several fire hotspots. In other words, giving the impression that it was done for us to see that they were indeed setting fires, they were not trying to hide it from us.

In São Paulo, the number of fires that occurred, an enormous number of cities on the same day, is something unthinkable. In São Paulo, some people were arrested, but we do not know if the investigation has progressed. In Rio de Janeiro, yesterday, 20 people were arrested.

There is a complaint, including from the Civil Police of some states, Minister Barroso and fellow jurists here, there is a complaint that, many times, the Civil Police arrest a citizen under suspicion and, half an hour later, someone releases that citizen and the police cannot even investigate or carry out the normal inquiry. The Federal Police has 52 or more inquiries paralyzed because there is no judicial authorization in the first instance for the Federal Police to conduct investigations.

So, this meeting is for us to take some actions that are not provided for in our day-to-day life until today. Something that the people who are trying, with this criminal action, should be warned that we are not joking, that we will take this very seriously. Because this country cannot…

Possibly, all of this is because of COP30 here in Brazil, perhaps all of this is due to the performance that Brazil has in the environmental discussion worldwide, perhaps part of this is due to political interests. We do not know, we cannot accuse, but there is suspicion, there is. It is important not to fail to mention to you that a very important person, in the call for the act in September on Avenida Paulista, used the words: “let's set fire to Brazil.” Or: “Brazil will catch fire." Something like that. This is on the internet, you can see some things.

The concrete fact is that, to me, it seems very abnormal. Some things are always, routinely, catching fire. The drought is the worst in recent times, the heat is the highest in recent times, and it is happening all over the world, but there is also a smell of opportunism from some sectors trying to create confusion in this country. What we want is also authorization so that we can conduct investigations, fulfill inquiries, investigate, interrogate. Because, honestly, if people are committing this type of crime, the law must be exercised in its fullness.

So, I want to thank you. I know that some of you made sacrifices to be here because you had other commitments. I want to thank you, our president of the Court of Accounts was on a UN mission in the Netherlands, but Vital here represents the Court of Accounts of the Union with great dignity.

So, companion Marina, I pass the word to you or to the professor first, for him to make a presentation. The idea, for those who arrived late, the professor made a presentation yesterday, in a government meeting, here in this room, about the climate issue. He is a physicist, from USP, and I found it very interesting to bring to you the presentation he made for us. He summarized it, it will not take as long as we did yesterday. Then Marina and Nísia will speak. Then Barroso will speak and anyone else who wants to speak from here on. Alright? Let's go then. Professor Paulo Eduardo Artaxo Netto.

[Speeches from ministers and participants]

Just two small pieces of information before passing the word to President Lira [Arthur Lira]. I will be with the negotiator from the European Commission, from the European Union, now in New York, and one of the topics I will discuss with her is to ensure that she does not include this issue in the agreement between Brazil, South America, and the European Union. Because for 30 years they have been saying that it was Brazil or Latin America that did not want to make an agreement. Well. We have decided, we have a proposal, and therefore, now do not invent another argument to say that they will make the agreement difficult. I will go there with one of these missions.

The other important thing for those who will speak after me is the following: I had a very long conversation with Minister José Múcio [Defense] and General Tomás [Ribeiro Paiva, Commander of the Army], and the suggestion I gave him is that from now on, all 70,000 recruits who are called to the Armed Forces every year, and for whom we do not have war. Therefore, we do not need to prepare anyone for war, because we do not want war, that these young people be prepared to face the climate issue. Especially, learning to be brigadistas and to deal with floods, with fire, and with other things. Because when they leave, we will have to work a lot. The municipalities could have specialized people in their cities.

This is a topic I want to discuss with the next march of mayors. Instead of them bringing just a list of demands, we will deliver to them a list of demands that each municipality must have a brigade, each municipality must have specialized people in Civil Defense, because it is not a problem of the Federal Government. In other words, when there is a stomach ache in Roraima, when there is a stomach ache in Acre, it is a problem that there must be a structure there to take care of it, without needing to rely on the Federal Government. So, these things will happen already within the gravity of the climate problem. Now I pass the word to the President of the Chamber, Arthur Lira.

[Speech by the President of the Chamber, Arthur Lira]

All our guests have spoken. I don’t know if you are noticing, but something new is happening in our country: it is making it a habit for us to invite all the constituted Powers in the Federative Republic of Brazil to discuss matters pertinent to the interests of Brazil.

I believe that the presence of the Supreme Court, the presence of the Supreme Court of Justice, the presence of the Court of Accounts, the presence of the Chamber [of Deputies] and the Senate [Federal], and the Attorney General of the Republic, in a meeting demonstrates that we are returning to be a civilized country. And I have a habit and have already told Lewandowski [Ricardo Lewandowski, Minister of Justice and Public Security]: whatever project we send to the National Congress, whether it is a PEC or not, we must discuss it with the governors of the states, discuss it with the leadership of the National Congress, so that we take the attitude that no project of ours arrives more raw in the Legislative House. And then we spend more time explaining the project than if we had explained it at the time we were going to launch the project.

I think it is very important because it has not been long since we held a meeting here with all the Powers to create the Pact for the Ecological Transformation of the Three Powers of the Brazilian States, and we are today strictly fulfilling item eight of paragraph two due to the crisis. It states the following: promote measures of serenity and legal security in administrative procedures and judicial processes in environmental and climatic matters, including cases of deforestation, land disputes, conflicts related to the use of natural resources, environmental infractions, and reparation for environmental and climatic damages. In other words, we are already fulfilling something that we deliberated not long ago.

We have a series of proposals for things to do, we need to create a National Climate Emergency Council, we need to create a National Climate Authority, we need to create a Scientific Institute to take care of these matters. Because it is necessary that we assume responsibility, that if you do not involve society, if you do not involve institutions and even personalities from civil society who are specialists, it becomes much easier for us to build. And it is very important because when we discuss the new budget again, we will have to know that new things have happened and we cannot continue with the same rules that we had established for so many years.

It has changed. The climate has changed, the needs of people have changed, the vision of people has changed. And I am convinced that no serious businessman in agribusiness, none, desires burning. Because they all know the importance they have in exporting Brazilian agricultural products and they know the international demands that are placed in the air for all countries. So, what we can say is that the citizen who decides to provoke burning, whatever his reason for provoking burning, unnecessarily, is committing a crime against Brazilian legislation; he is committing a crime against the Brazilian economy; he is committing a crime against the aspirations of this country, which wants to become a highly sovereign and respected country in the world. And we have been achieving that.

Pacheco and Lira, in one year and nine months we have opened 180 new markets for Brazilian agricultural products. I will repeat: in just one year and nine months we have opened 180 new markets for Brazilian products. This must be respected, because it produces in the field.

So, we have a commitment, I will go to Maranhão on Thursday to legalize a quilombo that has been waiting for 40 years, which is in Alcântara, and an agreement has been made with the Brazilian Air Force, with the Alcântara Base. They will keep 9,000 hectares and we will, the first part, is 62,000 hectares for the quilombolas, recover a part of the sea that they have the right to, which is where the fish are. And all of this at a negotiation table.

So, from now on, it will be like this: everything we do, we will try to establish a discussion, who knows, maybe someone is listening to us, watching us, and maybe we are taking steps every day for the country to become more civilized.

Today, comrades, we spent the morning discussing the issue of pesticides in this country. It is not possible. It is not possible that we do not take action with the increase in the use of pesticides in this country. And I told my comrades today: we will make a proposal, we will call the party leaders, we will call Embrapa, we will call the entrepreneurs and we will discuss. Because it is not possible, it is not possible, that 80% of the pesticides banned in Germany can be sold here in Brazil. Banned in the United States, can be sold here in Brazil. As if we were a banana republic where anything that is not allowed can be thrown here: used tires, you know, everything used can come here. It is not possible.

I even said in the meeting: I am willing to hold a meeting with the so-called ruralist bench. Then we will find out who is serious and who is not serious. Because people know that using bioinputs is much easier. Using things that guarantee healthy productivity is much more interesting for everyone. So this is a discussion that we will also have, and our discussion is to talk to everyone. No one will be caught by surprise with a bill delivered in the Chamber, welcomed by our leader, at nine o'clock at night. No one will be caught like that.

We will sit at a negotiation table and talk to all people. With those who like us, with those who do not; with those who are civilized, with those who are not. And we need to ensure that this country occupies a space, in fact and in law, that we should have occupied a long time ago, but that the inferiority complex of this country does not allow us to grow. It does not allow. And it is not rural producers who are pressuring Congress, no. It is the pesticide entrepreneurs, who can even convince good-hearted people to use something unnecessary. That kills children, that kills animals. So, we will have to rethink many things in this country, a lot of things.

I just wanted to remind now, because I am remembering here, Lewandowski, we made, we will make a weapons decree, which is a controversy there in the Chamber and so on, and I am telling Lewandowski that we will have to make a correction. We will have to separate what is, you know, is CAC [Certificate of Registration for individuals to carry out activities of collecting firearms, sports shooting, and hunting] that it talks about? We have to separate what is people who want to learn to shoot to do harm or to defend themselves, from those who learn to shoot for national and international competition. We will separate the wheat from the chaff so that we do not punish people who should not be punished. And all of this we want to do by talking. Talking with all parties, with all institutions, so that we can build something that is palatable to Brazilian society.

So I want to thank each one of you. To you, Gonet; to you, Benjamin; to you, Vital; to my comrade Lira, to my comrade Pacheco, for your commitment to attend yet another invitation I made for you to participate in something. If we continue like this, you can be sure that when we finish our term, Brazil will be more civilized, more understandable, more humanistic, more supportive, and I would say with fewer problems.

Therefore, thank you very much, Lira. Thank you, Pacheco. Thank you, fellow ministers. And let’s move forward. Let’s move forward, because we need to transform this country into a definitively developed and environmentally developed and just economy, because the environment is part of our growth and quality of life.

Thank you, comrades.