Interview with the President of the Government on the program "La mañana," from Cadena COPE.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

5 November 2012 · Interview on the program "La mañana" from Cadena COPE · Palace of La Moncloa, Spain

Context
Rajoy gave a radio interview on Cadena COPE at La Moncloa on the eve of the Popular Party's first anniversary in government, amid rising unemployment and social unrest.
Main themes
Economic recovery, unemployment crisis, labor reform, job creation, austerity measures, social discontent, fiscal consolidation, small and medium enterprises, government budget forecasts, general strike
Duration
~74 min
97th percentile
Words
8,841
97th percentile
Sentences
418
97th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.9
19th percentile
Syntax
3.03
51st percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

418 sentences in 156 paragraphs

President .- Good morning.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- Thank you very much for receiving us here at the Palace of La Moncloa. Thank you for your time.

President .- Thank you very much.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- In a few days, it will be a year since the Popular Party won the elections. There was a lot of hope then; people wanted change and wanted to get out of the crisis. It has been a very tough year, very intense, and it feels like a whole legislative term has passed. What is your feeling about this past year?

President .- The feeling is that things were difficult, as we already knew; but we are making decisions that serve to lay the foundations for economic recovery in the future.

The year was going to be bad, we already knew that. When we presented the budgets, we said: this year economic growth is going to be negative, minus 1.7 percent, and unemployment is going to increase a lot. And those forecasts, unfortunately, are coming true. But we also said: we are going to lay the foundations for economic recovery. And we are making decisions; some are tough, very difficult, and very uncomfortable for people, but they have to be made. And I believe that, from there, the foundations for economic recovery are being laid.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- Today, precisely, in the media, we are all reporting the figure: 128,000 more unemployed in the month of October. You said that your priority, when you arrived at La Moncloa, would be employment. I suppose it will still be your priority, because it is the main concern of Spaniards. And I believe you even said that "we have not yet hit rock bottom and it is possible that we will reach up to six million unemployed before we start to recover."

President .- The government's objective, the capital, as you have very well said, and it is pure common sense, is economic growth and job creation. That is the most important thing, creating jobs, because people want to work, they feel good, and they can carry out a life project. That is the great objective but, in addition, if we create jobs, there will be many more people paying taxes, they will pay personal income tax; they will be able to consume and, therefore, they will pay VAT; businesses will do better; administrations will have more money because they will collect money and, therefore, public services can be improved. That is the great objective.

We said at the beginning of the year, when we came to government: this year the forecast is for six hundred thousand fewer jobs. We said it and it is in the budgets that were approved last March. I believe it will be somewhat less, just as economic growth will be better than we had predicted; but I insist: this was going to be a bad year; next year will be better, 2013; we will not hit bottom yet, but it will be better, especially the second half, and in 2014 the economy in Spain will start to grow.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- The unions presented their official strike proposal yesterday for next week, November 14, and, among other things, they say that the labor reform is what has led us to these unemployment figures, which has been a disaster.

President .- That is not true. The labor reform has worked and we also said at the time, and it is good to remember it to reiterate it now, that the effects of the labor reform, the most important ones, will be seen as soon as economic activity begins. But up to this moment the labor reform is already producing important effects: we created an entrepreneurs' contract and more than sixty thousand permanent contracts have already been made, half for young people; the entrepreneurs' contract was part of the labor reform.

There is also a positive piece of data, within the overall negative data, especially regarding the increase in the figure, which is that throughout this year there are more than one hundred thousand people who work for themselves, self-employed and microenterprises. This is important because, in the end, it is Spanish society and it is the small and medium-sized enterprises that are going to generate real wealth, well-being, and employment.

There is another important effect of the labor reform. Previously, whenever there was an employment regulation file, it ended in dismissal; now, as there is more flexibility, many fewer employment regulation files end in dismissals. Now there may be temporary suspensions, but at least employment is maintained, or there are modifications to working conditions, and that is why employment is also maintained.

I believe, therefore, that there are positive effects in the labor reform and those effects will be much more positive when economic activity begins.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- You are probably aware that there is widespread discontent because, when measures are taken that affect family economics, people say "as long as it doesn't affect me, I think they are fine." Are you aware of that discontent? Social conflict has also increased, protests are happening one after another, and even some voters of the Popular Party have not understood some of your measures. Do you think there are still people, many people, those who do not speak, as you said, who continue to trust your project?

President .- I believe so. I completely understand the discontent of the people. We have had to raise taxes and we had said we would not do that; we have had to reduce spending and that is something we had said we would do, and we have asked a tremendous amount of effort from the people, a tremendous amount. We are absolutely aware of that. There are measures we have taken that we would not have liked to take and there are some that we will reverse later, for example, the increase in personal income tax. We would like to be able to lower the Personal Income Tax in 2014.

Therefore, I completely understand that there are many people who are upset, who are angry, and who cannot applaud these measures; we are aware. But, just as I tell you that, I tell you that if we are taking these measures, it is because they are the measures that Spain needs. I do not raise taxes for pleasure; moreover, I do not believe in tax increases, except in exceptional situations, as is the case here.

We have also had to make many decisions to reduce spending; but I assure you that these measures, along with the reforms or along with the restructuring of our financial system to bring back credit, are what will ultimately produce economic recovery in Spain.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- Mr. President, for those who still trust the project and for those who do not -- I believe everyone has to feel a bit hopeful, because the citizen continues to tighten their belt and can no longer find holes to tighten their belt.-- the question would be: we know we are in a transitional period --you said it-- a tough, difficult period of taking measures; but everyone is asking: yes, but how long are we going to have to endure? When will we be able to breathe a little in our household economy, in our family?

President .- I hope… Well, in 2014 there will be economic growth in Spain. 2012 is the worst year. Well, the worst year…, 2009, 2010, and 2011 were not good; 2009 was the worst. 2012 is bad; 2013, next year, will be better than 2012 and in 2014 there will be economic growth in Spain.

But, I insist, all the measures we are taking are what will allow that economic recovery. It is impossible to create jobs when administrations spend much more than they earn. Look, last year, 2011, the administrations --the sum of autonomous communities, central government, and municipalities-- spent ninety billion euros more than we earned. Of course, that has to be borrowed and now money is very expensive, and there are many administrations that are not lent a dime. That is why we are seeing the things that are happening.

It is also very difficult to create jobs when a lot of money is owed and Spain has a debt outside of Spain of almost one trillion euros. Spain is now in a process, which is inevitable, of deleveraging; that is, families are deleveraging; companies, large, small, and medium, are deleveraging, and so are the administrations. And in a process where one is paying off their debts, it is very difficult to have money to invest and to consume. But that process of paying debts and deleveraging is crucial because, otherwise, no one will finance us and, if not, we cannot grow and create jobs.

Therefore, in this situation it is very difficult, but we are doing what needs to be done, which is to pay our debts; then, we are making reforms that make our economy more flexible and more competitive; and, then, something very important, which is to restructure the banking sector. If there is no credit, it is impossible to have investment and, if there is no investment, it is impossible to have jobs. That is why we are taking tough, difficult, and complicated measures also for the banking sector.

Therefore, there is still some time left but, I tell you, next year will be better and in 2014, economic growth.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- You have mentioned many things and I will stop at some. For example, you talk about the administrations. Have you considered reforming the General Administration, a deep change, to make it more efficient? That thing that is often said "let's avoid duplicities," but it seems we are not making progress and that we have too many administrations for a citizen who is paying so many things, who sometimes does not understand why they have to go to so many windows.

President .- That is the great pending reform of Spanish democracy, because the reform of the administration, and you are a witness to it, a witness to day-to-day, has been talked about for thirty years. Now a reform in the administration is going to be made. However, I want to say one thing: we have not been in office for even a year and we have made a labor reform, which was also a reform pending for thirty years; we have made a reform of the energy sector, where we had a debt of twenty-four billion euros; we are restructuring the banking sector, another pending reform; a reform of regulatory bodies; a Budget Stability Law so that no one spends what they do not have… There are many reforms at the same time.

In the last Council of Ministers, we already agreed, after we agreed on this at the Conference of Autonomous Presidents a few days ago with everyone, to create a Commission that will finish its work by June 30, 2013, because this is a very complicated operation, with four groups: one for administrative simplification, another to eliminate duplicities, another to improve management, and another for institutional administration, to eliminate, which has already been done with many, public companies, autonomous bodies, and bodies that are of no use.

That is a great reform, an important structural reform, which is very laborious and requires time. Tomorrow the Commission will be established; precisely tomorrow the formal constitution of that Commission will take place, which I want to agree upon with the rest of the political groups.

Having said that, a great effort is already being made. In the Public Administrations, the reduction in spending that both the central government and the autonomous communities are making is very important. There is a piece of data that is very unpleasant and very strong, but there was no other choice: public employment is decreasing much more than private employment. If you take the data from the last two quarters of the Active Population Survey, one thousand jobs were lost in the private sector, but more than 150,000 jobs were lost in the public sector this year. That is very hard and very difficult, but within that adjustment that they are making, especially the autonomous communities and municipalities, these are things that need to be done to move forward.

Therefore, it is a very important reform, it is a reform pending for thirty years, and it is a reform that this government has the firm will to carry out.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga .- Every time you speak in public, I hear you always talk about the deficit objective as the great objective of the government. Will you be able to meet the deficit target this year? And next year?

And the next question would be: will there be new fiscal measures to increase state revenues? Because there needs to be adjustments, but without revenues, it is difficult to generate growth in the economy.

President .- This issue of the deficit is something that may be difficult to understand; but I will try to explain it, let’s see if everyone understands.

A family that earns 1,000 a month --let's take an example-- can spend 1,100 or 1,200 a month for one month, two months, or three months; but what it cannot do is always spend more than it earns, because there comes a time when it has to pay what it owes and there comes a time when no one is going to lend to it, precisely because it is very indebted. And that happens to the administration.

I told you that last year we spent ninety billion euros more than we had, that is, fifteen trillion pesetas, which is an astronomical figure, because it is astronomical. That money we had to borrow from abroad, but that money has to be repaid and now, that we are in a financial crisis, a euro crisis, logically those who owe more and have to borrow are the ones who are having the hardest time. If Spain did not have the public deficit it has and, therefore, could meet its expenses only with its income, we would not have a problem, because we would not have to borrow money from anyone.

Therefore, reducing the deficit is the first of the priorities and without that, we are not going anywhere. I have given the example of the family and I think it is understood very well.

This year we have to reduce the deficit significantly. Why? Because last year we did not meet our commitments. Last year, 2011, our commitment to Europe was to reach 6 percent, and in the end, the deficit was 9 percent. This year we have to lower that 9 percent to 6.3 percent, and we have to do it in a phase where there is economic recession, so activity is not increasing, and there is also no financing.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Twenty-seven billion euros.

President.- Of course, that is why the effort is enormous, that is why we have had to raise taxes and that is why we have had to reduce spending so much. Otherwise, we would have reduced spending much less and raised taxes much less.

You ask: will there be more tax increases? I do not plan to make any decision to raise taxes today. In fact, we have already presented the Budgets and we have not made any increases. I insist, I hope it will not be necessary to return to any tax increases. What I want, because I believe in it, is to lower taxes and I hope to be able to do so in 2014.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Nor any type of measures that affect the self-employed, pensioners, civil servants...?

President.- I believe that the fundamental decisions have already been made. There has been another freeze on state salaries, and they have been in that situation for several years; but, of course, I am not going to lower the salaries of civil servants or anyone in 2013.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- And pensions? Will they be updated with this year's CPI?

President.- Pensions, for now, are the only item in the Budgets that will increase. Well, pensions will increase, and unfortunately, the interest on the debt because, of course, the interest on the debt is very high. This year, the first item in the Budgets, excluding pensions, is interest on the debt. It is almost forty billion euros, which is a truly remarkable figure.

Pensions will increase by 1 percent, and we will know at the end of November what the CPI situation is, and then we will make the decision, which has not yet been made, regarding their update.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Much has been said in recent months about the famous bailout of Spain, or the line of credit, or the aid, whatever we want to call it. You, in the last interview you gave on Televisión Española, said that you were studying it, that you had to see if it was necessary and the conditions under which they would give us that loan or that line of credit. Have you thought about it? Have you studied it? Do we have to ask for it? Is it good? Is it bad? Because many businesspeople say that the longer we wait to ask for that help, the less the Spanish economy will grow or the longer it will take to get out of the crisis.

President.- This is also a very complicated issue on which everyone has an opinion, and rightly so, as is natural. Some say we should ask for it, and some say we should not; there are opinions for all tastes. Now I will explain my position.

What does the bailout mean? The bailout means that the European Central Bank would buy Spanish bonds in the secondary market, which would lower the risk premium and make financing cheaper for administrations, for companies, and for everyone. That has already been done. That is to say, last year, 2011, the European Central Bank already bought bonds in the secondary market. Now we are debating a bailout, as such, but the European Central Bank has already done this.

What do I want to say about that? The mere fact that the European Central Bank has announced that possibility is already good, and, in fact, it has lowered the premium and lowered the cost of financing.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Today it is at 435 points.

President.- Yes, it is at 435 points. It was over six hundred at one point.

Now there are several pending issues here because, of course, there are people who say no, yes, we have to ask for it...

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I suppose there will be conditions when they give us the money.

President.- Of course, of course. The problem is not only the conditions but how much the premium will drop because, if this serves to keep the premium at four hundred and something and it does not drop to two hundred, it is evident that it is not the same. We have to see what the conditions are as well, and then we have to ensure the support of all the countries in the European Union. Therefore, those are the three most important issues; but, you see, the most important is what it means for the Bank to buy bonds in the secondary market because, if we stay at the same price as today, the operation we are doing makes little sense.

So, the Government has not made any decision, but I will tell you one thing: the decision we make will be solely and exclusively what is best for Spain; not for anyone in particular within Spain, but what is in the general interest of all Spaniards. It is a path that is open there, and I, of course, do not renounce to use it if it is in Spain's interest. For now, we have not decided to adopt it, but it is a possibility that we have open.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- And when would be the right moment? What conditions do you think would be appropriate to ask for or not ask for this line of credit?

President.- For now, we have covered almost all emissions throughout this year, and, in fact, there are already companies that have financed themselves. If we see that for a long time Spain is financing itself at very high prices, then we would have to ask for it. But it is also very important to know what the specific action of the European Central Bank would be, whether it would maintain the premium at four hundred or at two hundred, and what conditions there would be in return.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Many small and medium-sized businesspeople are listening to us who say: "all this is very well, talking about the big figures, but when will my bank allow me a loan so that I can get out of this situation I am in?"

President.- That is the most important issue in the Spanish economy. The Spanish economy has many problems at this moment, but the most important is the lack of financing because, if there is no financing, there is no investment, nor is there employment, nor is there consumption.

I insist, that is the issue; that question you have asked me is the issue. Because, if in Spain there are people who want to start a business, they usually need a loan; no one has the capital to do it, and in Spain we need people to invest; large businesspeople, too, but especially small and medium-sized ones, who are the ones who employ most people.

We are acting in a dual direction: on the one hand, in the direction we referred to and talked about earlier, trying to lower our financing rate, which is the issue of the European Central Bank and what is called the bailout. That is one direction because, if Spain's financing goes down there, the cost of financing for everyone goes down. And, secondly, we are acting in another direction, which is even more important, which is the restructuring operation of the Spanish financial system and the creation of the "bad bank."

All these operations we are doing with the banks have only one objective, which is to guarantee the creditors of the banks, fundamentally those who have their deposits, the savers and the pensioners who have their money there; and, secondly, to ensure that there is credit.

Look at one thing: in 2008, when the financial crisis hit, all of Europe, the Twenty-Seven, injected one trillion five hundred billion euros into their financial systems, into their banks; that is to say, it is an astronomical amount and it is even difficult to comprehend: one trillion five hundred billion euros. We did not do that at that time and we invented the idea that we had the best financial system in the world. If we had done it then, we would not have the problems we have now, but life is as it is.

We are doing what we should have done four years ago, and this is the restructuring of the financial system. That is what led us to nationalize three banks --we, the Government I preside over, have nationalized three banks-- and the goal is to restore credit and have sound entities. That is the most important issue in the Spanish economy today: credit.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- We will soon continue talking about the banks, but many people say they are afraid and do not consume. What can the Government do to boost consumption?

President.- It is fundamentally a problem of confidence. The economy needs two things to grow, to move, and to create jobs: first, confidence; that is to say, if you want to start a business, you yourself, you and I want to start a business, a business where furniture is sold, for example, then we have to think: this business is going to go well for me. Why? Because houses are going to start being built and I am going to sell furniture or we are going to sell appliances; that is to say, confidence that the business you are going to set up is going to work. That is very important.

And, secondly, credit, which is what we have talked about today, because people do not have money.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- And someone to buy.

President.- Indeed, but that falls under confidence.

Reviving consumption at this moment is not easy, and for a reason I mentioned earlier: we are deleveraging, and in Spain, for many years, we spent a lot. The administrations spent a lot, but many homes were also bought with mortgages, many trips were made, a lot was consumed, and a lot of credit was requested. I have already told you that we have an external debt that is the largest in Europe, and now everyone is deleveraging, and administrations, families, and companies are spending less. At a time when you are dedicating your money to paying off your debts, you cannot dedicate it to consumption, and that is why this is a process that, as I told you at the beginning, takes time.

In any case, we have already implemented some stimulus measures; for example, the aid plan for buying cars. In the car sector, sales had dropped significantly, and you know it is a very important sector for the Spanish economy. We have launched the PIVE Plan, which will mean a reduction: one thousand euros less that the Administration puts in and one thousand euros less that companies put in. That will reactivate car consumption a bit.

Housing. Housing prices are dropping significantly; they are dropping a lot, and now, with the "bad bank," all the banks are putting up for sale the homes that they had to take over because the developers could not sell them and could not repay the loans.

Therefore, those are already more partial measures; but the key is to gradually finish this process of deleveraging the Spanish economy.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I am going to make a statement that many internet users repeat: many do not understand how we are helping the banks, how some banking entities have not been closed, and how in cases that affect us --that help to ethics, to aesthetics, to the heart, when we talk about evictions-- the banks seem to be oblivious to a problem that affects 350 families every day in Spain.

President.- We are helping the banks as all countries in the world do. I told you before that in 2008, one trillion five hundred billion euros were injected into their banks by Europe; but countries like the United Kingdom did it in much greater amounts than Spain; countries that, moreover, were using their own public money. We have requested a loan from European institutions. Germany has done it, France has done it, and, in general, all countries in the European Union have done it.

Why do we help the banks? It is not about helping some gentlemen who are the president of a bank or the CEO of a bank; the bank is somewhat like the circulatory system of... What the circulatory system is to the human body is what the bank is to the economy. If there is no credit, it is impossible to have investment and to have employment. A country without banks could not function, and that is why there is no country in the world without banks. The more powerful a country is economically, the more banks it has.

So, this is about helping the depositors. If a bank goes bankrupt, what happens to the money of the depositors? The Government cannot allow a bank to go bankrupt because it will not let a depositor lose their own money. What happens to the creditors of the banks? What happens to the shareholders of the banks?

Then, above all, the great objective is to ensure that there is credit. There are some banks that were private, and very important, like, for example, Bankia, which was the largest bank in Spain, especially after its merger with Bancaja, which is now state-owned; that is to say, it is nationalized. Just like Novacaixagalicia is state-owned, or just like Cataluña Caixa is state-owned. It is not a problem of helping a specific private company; it is a problem of helping the overall economy of the country and, above all, the people who have their deposits there.

What happens with the issue of evictions...?

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- They say: why don’t the banks help precisely those who are in difficulties, because they do not even have enough to eat?

President.- On the issue of evictions, which is a topic that has been raised, there are people who have indeed taken out a mortgage loan and now cannot pay it. Normally, this does not happen; people pay their loans, and if someone does not pay, at a certain point, action is taken, of course. But we are in a moment of difficulty, right? Because this is not a normal moment; this is a moment in which many people have lost their jobs, many people cannot work, many people have no income, and many people are going through a lot of difficulties...

We did something that had never been done before, which was a Code of Good Practices, which has worked but has not worked as we would like, that is, to resolve the problems, especially the most pressing problems. Now we are in a process of evaluating how that has gone, and I certainly want to say that we will take new measures to resolve the problems that are indeed being raised.

I want to agree on this with the rest of the political forces, especially with the Socialist Party. I have already spoken with Pérez Rubalcaba about this matter, and, in fact, tomorrow there will be a meeting between two people, the Vice President of the Government and one of the top officials of the Socialist Party, to discuss this issue. I hope to make a decision that is equitable and just because, evidently, this is a topic that produces dramas, that hurts a lot, and that is a very graphic face of the crisis we are going through.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- And with immediate application?

President.- Yes, yes. We want to make the decision as quickly as possible and with immediate application, of course.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Let's leave the economy aside for a bit and talk about politics, about Catalonia, for example. Could we summarize everything that has happened in recent days regarding President Artur Mas with his latest statements? I quote verbatim: "neither courts nor constitutions will stop us." Is he perhaps going too far?

President.- I am the President of the Government, and what I have to do is ensure that there is tranquility, calm, and peace, right? I certainly believe that we must face things with serenity and calm. And I will only say one thing: the world today is not for raising walls or borders; in today's world, there are bets on integration and open spaces.

Look, I go to the European Union as the President of the Government of Spain, and there we are... We no longer have a currency, we do not have monetary policy, and we do not have exchange rate policy. Now we have talked about the European Central Bank, and now we are working on banking union, fiscal union, political union, and economic union. We are talking about making more Europe, about pooling all our efforts, about having fewer institutions, and we are even talking about creating a European budget.

The world is going that way, because this is also happening in America: large unions of countries, economic unions that will lead to political unions. And that is happening in Asia.

So, this approach that is being made here goes against history, goes against the tide of the times, and goes against pure common sense. Certainly, in an operation like this, we all lose: the whole of Spain loses, and especially the Catalans lose.

My position is well known, and I will defend that. We have done many things together throughout history; we are the oldest nation in Europe and the people who have been living together the longest. Just look at what we have done in these thirty years: a Constitution, democracy, freedoms, a space for coexistence, and progress has increased, despite the crisis that exists at this moment, and well-being in Spain. That is to say, we have integrated into Europe.

Certainly, my position is very clear, and I believe that leaders should be fair, responsible, sensible, and capable of controlling the situation. Unfortunately, I believe that Mr. Mas is making a big mistake.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I do not know if Mr. Mas has lost control of the situation, and I do not know if dialogue, which you referred to a few days ago, will be enough. Dialogue, I suppose, about the economy. A few days ago, the Vice President of the Government told us that what they want is a new model of relationship with Spain, where they have to return less money to the common solidarity fund, because they say that Catalonia, otherwise, cannot cover its expenses.

But, in any case, if Mr. Mas continues with that independence movement, would you even apply, of course, all the laws at your disposal, including Article 155 of the Constitution, which I remind you suspends the autonomy of Catalonia?

President.- I will tell you what happened in the meeting I had with Mr. Mas. Mr. Mas came here to ask me for something that he knew I could not give him; he was fully aware of it—he knew that I could not give it to him, and I knew that I could not give it to him—which was the Economic Concert. This is a competence of the Cortes; you can take this to the General Courts, and he did not want to.

I offered to talk about regional financing because, in addition, next year it is time to review the model, see how the current one is functioning, and then revise it. And there we could talk, which is what has been done for thirty years. For thirty years, what we have been doing is something as understandable as talking because, of course, when it comes to distributing money among seventeen, either you talk or you tell me how that is done, and financing models have always been approved unanimously.

We have helped Catalonia a lot, and that same day he asked me for more than five billion, a loan to be able to pay current expenses, and, of course, we will continue to help because I will not allow either Catalonia or any Autonomous Community in Spain to go bankrupt.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Spain does not steal, you see.

President.- Exactly. And I told him: let’s talk. He really said no, that it was either this or nothing, and that from then on, he was free to make decisions. I told him that I did not think that was the procedure to function, but I could not say yes to that. From then on, I got to know everything else.

He did not talk to me about calling elections, nor about holding a referendum, nor about a sovereign state; he did not say a word about that in the meeting. He only told me that he was freed because I did not give him the Economic Concert, which I could not give him. Besides, even if I could, I would not have given it to him. And I offered dialogue. From then on, he decided to take those steps.

What am I going to do? I am going to exhaust all possibilities for dialogue, do not doubt that. However, from then on, I only want to say to everyone that I am the President of the Government of Spain, and the President of the Government of Spain can be asked for everything, except for one thing; there is only one thing that cannot be asked of him, which is to violate the law. I do not know anyone in their right mind who could ask the President of the Government, of Spain or any country, to violate the law.

Therefore, I will try to talk, I will try to dialogue, and I will exhaust all possibilities. I believe it is time to act with common sense, but, honestly, I believe that one of the obligations of leaders, of anyone, in this country or any other, is to solve problems and not create problems for people, not to generate divisions in their own territory, because this generates divisions in Catalonia, among the citizens of Catalonia; therefore, solve the problems.

Now Mr. Mas has a huge responsibility to resolve the problem that he has created with his attitude. However, I have always been willing to dialogue; but, of course, not to impositions from anyone, because I will never do that.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- There are still many issues ahead that I would like to raise with you. We will soon talk about the demonstrations in the streets regarding health and education. The PSOE says that you are literally "destroying the rule of law."

But first, I do not want to forget a very recent tragedy, that of the Madrid Arena. You are a father, and your children are still not of age to go to these large parties. I do not know if you are aware that there is a special sensitivity in the streets. I do not know if the Government is going to tighten the regulations and, above all, if it will enforce them from now on, because yesterday the Unified Police Syndicate told us that our young people are not safe at these types of large parties.

President.- I do have two children, indeed, aged seven and thirteen.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- The thirteen-year-old is about to reach that age.

President.- What happened the other day is a tragedy. Just putting yourself in the place of the parents of these girls is enough. That alone suffices for any other type of comment. The most important thing we have as people who have them in this life are our children; therefore, just putting yourself in their place. It is terrible because such young people... It is truly dreadful.

An investigation is open by the regional and municipal administrations; some have the competencies of the ordinances, others of the shows. And there is also a police investigation open. We will wait for their conclusions, and if that investigation shows that it is necessary to adopt any measures that we have not adopted, do not doubt that we will do so.

In any case, you have said one thing that I—take it with caution—I believe is the most important: probably, it is not so much about modifying laws as it is about enforcing those that are already in force. Therefore, perhaps the problem is not so much about regulations, but about compliance with the regulations. But at this moment, an investigation is underway; we will wait, and for anything that needs to be done, we are in contact with the Autonomous Community and the City Council, and we will jointly make decisions.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Let’s talk about that Welfare State, where the Socialist Party says that you are, literally, "destroying it," in a popular expression. They say that the health reform undermines equality, reduces quality, and there are fewer and fewer doctors. In short, what citizens are most concerned about, aside from not having a job, is being healthy, going to a hospital, and being attended to. Really, is healthcare getting worse with the measures the Government is adopting? Are we going to be cared for less? Are we going to have less chance of being attended to by a doctor as well as we were before?

President.- Absolutely not. Public services are not paid for by the Government, nor by any autonomous community, nor by any City Council; public services are paid for by us Spaniards with our taxes. You pay taxes, and part of those taxes is allocated to healthcare. All Spaniards, when we pay our taxes, are paying for public services. The area where we spend the most money is on pensions, where we spend 125 billion euros, that is, a quarter of all public spending in Spain is on pensions, and the second is healthcare, where we spend 63 billion euros.

So, what I want is a Welfare State with three pillars, which I will not renounce, neither I nor the Spaniards, in any way, which are: a public pension system, a public, universal, and free healthcare system; and an educational system. And we will do everything possible to have a good system of care for dependency and a good system of social services.

The measures we are taking at this moment are not taken to annoy, or because we have nothing else to do, or for any prejudice; that is, I do not like to take certain measures, anyone can understand that. We do it because it is the way to preserve the system for the future.

In healthcare, the most important measure that has been adopted is to require the payment of a certain amount, which is an amount—not very exaggerated, but it is an amount—in pharmacies. Pensioners who do not reach a certain level will pay a maximum of eight euros a month, and from there, people—this was already the case before—who are not pensioners pay a certain amount.

There is one thing that we all must be aware of: there was a very large expenditure on pharmaceuticals in Spain. Everyone said: the more or less has a first-aid kit at home.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- You have the pharmacists up in arms too, huh?

President.- Yes, but that is already...

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Because they are not being paid.

President.- ...because the Communities do not pay them, yes.

With the measures we have adopted, we have saved 25 percent of the expenditure on pharmaceuticals, and that is good because the expenditure on pharmaceuticals is more than twelve billion euros a year. We are talking about more than two trillion euros.

Therefore, it is true that a payment is required, as happens in most European countries; but it is the only way to preserve a system that is very good because the professionals in the Spanish healthcare system are very good. You go to a public hospital...

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- They are extraordinary.

President.- They are frankly good. And I know, not in depth, but I know what happens in other countries. So let’s do everything possible to preserve that system and for that system to continue taking care of us in the future.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- And the euro per prescription, President?

President.- Regarding the euro per prescription, I will give you my opinion. I do not like the euro per prescription. I want a healthcare system in which everyone is treated equally. We have made the decision, in agreement with the Autonomous Communities, that everyone pays a small amount at the pharmacy, because that is a saving for the taxpayer; the taxpayer's money is used better and it is a saving for that taxpayer.

So, what cannot be added to that, at least in my opinion, is also a euro per prescription, because then you pay twice.

That said, there are two Autonomous Communities that have made the decision for the euro per prescription: one, Catalonia, and the other, Madrid. Before we resort to the Constitutional Court regarding that decision, we have spoken with the Government of Catalonia and we are negotiating, and we will do so until the deadline, which is in December, and if we reach an agreement, we will not resort to the Constitutional Court. And we will do the same with Madrid. We are going to negotiate. We believe that this is not good, that you cannot pay twice for the same thing and that we already have a system, with the agreement of all, that is applied throughout Spain, by virtue of which a little is already paid, depending on income and the money that each one pays, in the pharmaceutical prescription, in the pharmaceutical product.

Therefore, we are negotiating and I hope that, in the end, we reach an agreement with both Communities.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Let's talk about education, which we have mentioned. He is the only minister who has been reprimanded in Congress, although the reprimand did not go ahead due to the votes of the Popular Party. It all started with that famous phrase from the Minister of Education, Wert: "we must Spanishize the students in Catalonia." From there, all the projects proposed by the Government are outright rejected by the opposition, because they say that you are also undermining the educational model in Spain.

President.- That is absurd. What we are trying to do is improve an educational model that, if you take the PISA report, which is the major report that talks about the educational level in all OECD countries, really places us in a position that I, as a Spaniard, cannot feel proud of: more school dropouts than anyone, more school failure than anyone, and very low grades in fundamental subjects, such as mathematics. There is really a problem of quality in education and we all know it, and the members of all parties and all people, and we have to make an effort to improve it.

Then, there are people who work in education, who dedicate their lives to it. It is a very difficult job, although I believe it is also very rewarding. We put our children in the hands of teachers, which is certainly not a joke what we put in their hands. Therefore, we must support them, help them, and provide them with the means.

We are going to make a reform to improve the quality of education.

Regarding the debate about whether to catalanize or not to catalanize, what I want, and I think is what the majority feels… I am Galician, but I feel Galician and Spanish, and I will not renounce either one or the other. I am Spanish in that I am Galician.

What I want is for everyone to feel, as has always happened, comfortably Catalan and Spanish, to go to school and be able to speak comfortably in Catalan and in Spanish, and that, in the end, they speak both languages perfectly and also speak, if they can, two more, because it will be a wealth for them and a wealth for the whole of their country. I believe that identities are not exclusive, but rather complementary and additive.

In the end, I must say that Minister Wert has all my support as President of the Government.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I have a few questions left and I would ask you to be brief, because we have very little time left. The first is immediate: elections are being held in the United States. Is it better for us if Romney wins, is it better if Obama wins, or is a change of government indifferent to us?

President.- I believe you understand me and will comprehend my answer. The Spanish Government must get along as best as possible with whoever wins. The United States is a great world power, the first; we share with them democracy, freedom, human rights, and many ways of seeing life, and it is the American people who are voting today. It is really exciting, because it seems very close. But we will know, I suppose, tomorrow morning, approximately.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- This afternoon the Constitutional Court is meeting to study the PP's appeal against the Law on Same-Sex Marriage. The report suggests that it leans towards rejecting it. What would the Government do?

President.- We appealed, not because the union between two people of the same sex produced legal effects, we did not care; the only thing we appealed was the name; that is, the name "marriage." That was the reason for the appeal. We will wait to see what the Constitutional Court says and, as we said, then we will make a decision; but first we must wait.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- It is curious that we have hardly talked about the Basque Country. We are no longer talking about terrorism, ETA, and what to do with ETA, but Bildu is in the institutions. After seeing Bolinaga walking through his town, entering a café, and the defense of Bildu's candidate for the detained ETA members, are there reasons to illegalize it or is it politically uninteresting?

President.- This is not a problem of political interest; this is a problem of complying with the Law. The Law is above any other consideration; it is above you, above me, and above everyone. We are all subject to the Law. Therefore, as soon as the Government, the Prosecutor's Office, or the State Attorney believe that there are reasons that advise challenging the candidacy in the Courts, do not doubt that we will do so.

Bildu is there, not because the Government of Spain has said so, but because of what the Constitutional Court has said, and we, and this is how the rule of law works, must respect that decision. What corresponds to the Government, and it will do so, if it believes it is necessary and if it believes that the Law is being violated, is to urge the Courts to illegalize it.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- Let's talk about something entertaining, that does not require thinking about big problems, which is Spanish sports. The truth is that the only thing they give us is satisfaction. But I am going to ask you a question related to the Treasury; Manolo Lama told me to ask you. Why, if we, as citizens, pay taxes, does football not pay?

President.- No, no, excuse me. Football pays… One of the instructions I have given to the Minister of Finance… Look, this year, which has been tough, difficult for everyone, there is a positive piece of data: the collection from tax fraud, and therefore the tax fraud discovered by the State Tax Agency, where there are first-class public officials, in September has already collected much more than was expected to be collected for the whole year. And, of course, football clubs are going to pay their debts to the Treasury and to Social Security; in fact, they are already paying them. Just as everyone will pay. That is to say, that no one should have the slightest doubt.

Many times it is said: the president of the Community, the mayor, do not do, do not give or do not stop giving... We live off the taxes we all pay and there is no greater injustice than a person paying 100 percent of their taxes because they have a salary and another person evading. Therefore, football, football players, and everyone must pay their taxes.

I have frozen Public Employment Offers, except for the Tax Inspection service, and Spain, of the twenty-seven countries of the Union, has the lowest collection from VAT in proportion to its Gross Domestic Product. That cannot be. Therefore, it is an obligation of the citizens, of everyone, to pay their taxes. I insist, it is very unfair that some pay and others evade and do not pay.

Therefore, those gentlemen will pay. In fact, the Ministry of Finance has my instructions, and they are already paying, to do so.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- One last question: voting is taking place these days, the "Ballon d'Or" is going to be voted on. Who would you give it to? Get a little wet, eh!

President.- It is difficult. I would give it to Casillas because, after all, Casillas is a world champion, has been twice European champion in two national teams, has won the Champions League with Madrid, has won the League. It is very difficult for a goalkeeper because, of course, what counts here is scoring goals. It is true that Messi is there and Cristiano is there, and there are good players, very good ones, even Sergio Ramos is there; but if I had to vote, I would vote for Casillas.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I agree with you: I would also vote for Casillas.

President.- We agree on something, you and I.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- I hope in more things.

President.- I hope so.

Mr. Sáenz de Buruaga.- President, thank you very much and good luck, because it is the luck of all.

President.- Thank you very much. A pleasure.